sir...a lower middle class family student like me would feel more comfortable if u make here a separate voluntary contribution option which started from minimum ₹100.We want to contribute but because of the minimum embargo,we find ourselves unable to do so.😊
I do Hope that this *_"MASTERSTROKE"_* of Modi doesn't meet the same Fate as it was with DEMONETIZATION & G.S.T. The intention was Good but the Implementation and its Execution wasn't up to the Mark which brought the Indian Economy to its lowest position accompanied by a 4 decades high Unemployment rate in India. Not to forget, The Negative impact it made on the small-scale industries in rural areas due to the Faulty implementation and execution which resulted in its terrible CLOSURE making it tougher for the people to make their both ends meet. 🤲🏼🙏🏼🤲🏼🙏🏼
The worst thing in our education system? Some teachers demanding that your answers in exams should be the exact copy of how it is written in your textbook. That's where you kill all the creativity and promote rote learning. Allow the student to express the same answer in his own words and not the words of the author(in fact encourage it)
Exactly, it's like that 3 idiots movie scene where the teacher asked what a machine is and reprimanded him ( Aamir) to give the exact textbook definition. I hate it when teacher does that.
I was an average student and got really low marks because I always wrote what I understood. I could never learn the exact lines. Later I moved to school in Canada, and with my same understanding skills, I got the highest marks in my first year at university. I hope India can give away the rote learning system.
I don't share your point of view. When I gave my CBSE boards of 10th standard, I referred a book called Oswaal. The book had toppers' answers, and there I observed that none of the toppers had actually rote learned. I think it's just an excuse we perpetrate to make us feel good about ourselves.
@@influencer_22 It is and then it is not. While it isn't a great trait, it is good have this as a part of soft skill. If it gets you what you want, use that.
@@karannainwal1990 incorrect history, dude you might need a time machine to write the correct one, the historians were peeasses now karan will do it better
@@nick-sw3in 370 i didn't read much about and caa was highly criticised. But this one actually seems good. A new education policy was the need of the hour as our education system is pretty bad.
@Purnendu Das are you a TMC cadre? I am also from Bengal and i know that in TMC era, the education system is fully politicised. The SSC and TET stopped by this Gov.
YOU r right but one question i have that is in this crisis how government will spend 6% of GDP in education ?At present our GDP growth rate is 3.2% .Also for covid growth rate of GDP will slump down more and it will have more negative impact on us. Its a matter of concern to all of us.
While making laws we have to be specific. Regional language means any Indian language spoken in that region. Many small but significant languages will benefit like Tulu, Gondi or Bhil.
@@islandsunset Tulu, Gondi or Bhil are all Indian languages in my book. For arguments sake, what would you call Hindi or Malayalam? And what language in India is a 'not-regional' language?
@@nrusimha11 I said that while making laws the rules have to be specific. Like if a school has to be opened on Mangalore which is a Tulu majority region and if state govt mandates that Kannada is going to be medium of instruction then it could lead to a problem. So to remove such an issue, the law say regional language for tribal and minority languages.
If I look back on my school life, it is so flawed. I wanted to learn Commerce but I did not get it because not good enough marks. So I was forced to learn science because I was "eligible" do so.
can't we atleast copy the education system of USA South Korea Taiwan Singapore Europe? why it took 35yrs to copy unless we want to well educate select few and feel superior
Lol instead of watching video here if you had watch the conference video where they declared the new policy than you would not be saying this. In that video the lady clearly said that its not going to be a raatta maro policy anymore.
@@ArreSidu the education system as a whole has fucked so many lives, so I feel u bro. Uk if this gets implemented well, the next gen will take all this for granted and we will tell the stories of our struggle.
An automobile Engineer should be able to dissemble and assemble a car, before getting his degree. Similarly an Agriculture degree should be given to a parson who can cultivate one acre competing with the farmers.
Assembling and dismantling is not an automobile engineering. Those can be learnt with in a week or month. Engineering is an art form of science. We should teach fundamental science very well. Then only we can get good engineers. Technicians can do assembling.
@@HariKrishnan-pe3ft have you even read NEP ? Now rather than other subjects the focus will be more on your stream and not only theory but practicality .
I built my own wall-bed here in Bangalore, well designed, fully functional, still standing and working after 5 years. Some of my neighbors who saw the wall-bed joked demeaningly that, he has two jobs one of a Software engineer and another of a Carpenter. Some said why did you spend all that time learning engineering when you had to do Carpentry. Some of my relatives whom I showed it to, said why did you do it, didn't you have money to get it done by a carpenter. Some still think I am a miser for doing things myself. They don't understand the joy of creating things with your own hands or fixing things that are broken. The first thing you need to do anything or achieve anything in life is to stop caring what others say. Sorry 'Super'...long rant.
Is Education really a Noble Profession? And is it OK to exclude it from being governed under Free Market rules? Watch my latest Video on National Education Policy 2020 tryin to answer these question th-cam.com/video/bcI5Zjq3zqE/w-d-xo.html
@Seeker that's probably true... but we have no way of substantiating it... cuz neither our parents' nor our grandparents' generations went through gurukula... they and us were subject to the same clerk-education that today's young are receiving... But the big difference was that... by some stroke of luck they learnt their mother tongue n Sanskrit and even Hindi(despite being south indians)... Which the recent generations have completely missed... all they know is a peculiar "indlish"... a bit of regional lingo heavily influenced by their regional cinema and unprintable words borrowed from the west... So yes in a way we have become puppets with strings being pulled by unknown devious powers...
@@arahul4045 so does that mean that this year's 10th std have to adhere to the new policy or is the upcoming board exams going to follow the previous education system?
Frankly, even most western education systems don't teach basic working with hands. *However, the students are loaded less and have more time.* So, they learn these things by helping out their parents or similar things. And even take up small jobs, once they are of legal age. This allows them to learn more basic skills, earn some money and have a first taste of how economy works🤷♂️
@@rudramahadev22 Yes, but there are enough cases of child labour in hard jobs as well. So I think we need them. However, govt. can specify job types/definitions where a teen above 14 or 16 can be allowed to work.
i think our education should teach these things like decent reading, writing/journaling and then self education, practical and scientific methods for studying and it also should teach more practical skills like communication, social, entrepreneurship, personal finance, personal health, basic problem solving (on personal and local level), quality/smart hard work (and how to get into flow state), basic systems thinking, how to create habits and destroy them, how to tackle procrastination. Does the reader have more things to add or subtract from my list??
I watched your presentation on the New Education Policy with keen interest. I am Indonesian but educated at the Jawaharlal Nehru University (JNU). Before studying at JNU, I spent one year at Delhi University. It was a shocking experience studying for a Master's Degree in the university where we had the only exam once in a year, no mid-semester, no paper presentation, and no discussion in the class. It was exactly like what you said, Russian roulette system. I failed one paper and I had to appear again next year for the exam. I decided to move to JNU. Thank you so much for your presentation.
i think our education should teach these things like decent reading, writing/journaling and then self education, practical and scientific methods for studying and it also should teach more practical skills like communication, social, entrepreneurship, personal finance, personal health, basic problem solving (on personal and local level), quality/smart hard work (and how to get into flow state), basic systems thinking, how to create habits and destroy them, how to tackle procrastination. Does the reader have more things to add or subtract from my list???
There was NCF nothing happened. By the time we started to understand NCF they changed NEP. Many of the things they mentioned in the change are done by experienced highly qualified educators. Our government only make documents not enough budget or manpowers. If they merge everything under one umbrella organization, quality will suffer. But positions of jobs will come down. There are many such issues with this new policy.
@@deeptobhattacharyya3249 gst is a slight disaster as they don't have proper planning but this will will be a success it's planned for 5 years just like UPI
I don't understand why Segar Guptha refuses to talk about the EIA 2020, though. @Ankit Jaiman He's the editor-in-chief of ThePrint. I'm 'commenting repeatedly' because I want to know his thoughts on the matter.
Basically, people who are primarily science/commerce graduates lean on the internet to understand society beyond their real life experiences. The internet can give them very polarising opinions regarding the same, however, had they studied these things in detail, they would have understood it in a nuanced manner.
@Sam Aj Not dumb heads. We are given for what we deserve. Now a days even an average student is getting best score. Change didn't come in mind but on paper.
When I started out in America (don't worry, I'm back now, so dont label me a deshdrohi lol.), I started by making money by doing odd jobs, wherein I learnt how to fix pipes, change the filter of an air conditioner and change the spark plug of my bike. That's how kids learn or rather should learn. Nowadays though that system of hardwork has gone in the US... Only kids from poor families do summer jobs, while most middle class and rich kids lack any basic life skill. The opposite is true in India, where alot of kids go out and work during their vacations to make money and learn something.
@@ashutoshsharmash where in India do kids work in summers? Does it really happen? Which companies offer summer jobs? I hope you are not referring to 3rd year internship, engg students do ..
My dear Indian brothers and sisters th-cam.com/video/pV4vongkWI4/w-d-xo.html I have started my new channel Various big changes A complete guide of New Education Policy 2020 Please do like, subscribe and share 😊😊
My whole education life I never got any mentionable merit, neither in my Standard / Grade nor in my class until my CA Final exams. I secured 13th rank in whole of India in my CA Final Exams, stood first in Gujarat, stood first in my city Surat, and get three gold medals. I perfectly relate to what Shekhar is saying. The way others rate your academic intelligence is directly related the you being lucky in those 3 hours in the examination hall.
Sir people like u are real motivation for so called average or below average students like me . I am also an average student but preparing for civil services . Hope things also work out for me
@@Ashishkumar-ui8rp thanks a lot for your kind words. Wishing you all the very best. Best wishes for you passing with flying colors. Keep the hard work on, it always pays.
I have a son who is 18 months and he will be starting school soon. My wife asked me today about the education changes govt brought today and I replied please wait for Mr. SG to explain. Now I can go and show off my knowledge :) thanks print!
I don't understand why Segar Guptha refuses to talk about the EIA 2020, though. @Dead pool Yet, there are people in this very same comments section saying he's a leftist and that he's against the EIA 2020, but is too scared to voice his opinions on it.
@@imayavarambannedunjezhiyan5222 shekhar is capitalist he is huge advocate of capitalism & capitalist won't give fuck about environment and also his capitalist mentality bring him much closer to bjp's ideology but politically I believe he is still neutral.
I am a faculty at Emory University Atlanta - and I believe that day, when we see international universities opening in india is not too far. Definitely a long way to go though
Wonder why Segar Guptha refuses to talk about the EIA 2020, though. @Rituraj Mitra So, which habit do you think Segar Guptha is suffering from? @Rituraj Mitra Are you aware of the fact that a hashtag 'TN rejects EIA 2020' is trending? @Sreekanth Yerram I don't think he 'missed' it, though. If it was indeed 'missed', I believe it was 'missed' on purpose. P.S.: You know the disclaimer. It goes something like 'The edit was necessitated by...'
The first 12 minutes of this CTC are real gem to understand what is that ails our education system currently and I can bet no other journalist can do it better. The simple real life examples including through movie lyrics and Stephen Cohen’s mending the plug, do explain the current troubles with our education system bag on. The next 17-18 are the explanation of new NEP and as always help you to declutter the issue. Great Job Shekhar ji. Hats off to Shekhar ji and team Print.
This will go down as one of the best reforms of this government 👏, I have seen engineers who got in for peer pressure, they may have passion for arts ,dance, sculpture or culinary sciences , acting, sports etc , they can take this subject as optional subject along with usual , and can continue their passion along with regular subjects , it may also be their full time career, vocational courses from 8 th class will help the kids set up small businesses by 20 years , due to any reason if a person wouldn't be able to complete a degree can get a certificate ,and continue later , if you have passion for research or depth you can go to PhD directly after the 4 th year , lot of prospects
There will be a lot of opposition if government tries to bring private sector in education. But it will bring better research opportunities. So sooner or later India must do it.
As long as private sector is honest and transparent,don't do the usual 'indian jugaad' I wud very much welcome the decision Lyk Shekhar sir said,govt. interference shud be low but at same tym fees shud be maintained
Living abroad, I find that one of the most lacking parts of our education system is the lack of focus on trades. We need many more plumbers, electricians and carpenters than we do engineers. Our plumbing and electricity work is not half as good or safe as in the developed world. We should stop making unemployable engineers and work at the basics first. There shouldn't be shame in being an electrician compared to an electrical engineer. In fact, electricians often make as much money if not more.
Wonder why Segar Guptha refuses to talk about the EIA 2020, though. @yellow dots Some people in the comments section seem to think he's pro EIA 2020, too. So, I think it'd be better to hear that from himself. Do you know that a hashtag 'TN rejects EIA 2020' is trending, btw? P.S.: The edit was necessitated by Segar Guptha and his piraameen paarppanaals who hide, delete and block my comments.
@@tejasmohite2651 Not everyone should do coding for a career and at grade 6 one should definitely not specialise into coding that quickly. Atleast until 8th they should be exposed to different disciplines to see where their interests lie.
@@ankitgupta8945 coz there are movis and serials regarding that.. it's in books even..there are many sources..nd quraan is not easily available in our language..even as a Muslim have read Ramayana Mahabharata..seen serials coz they are available..bt for quraan translation u have to join madrasa..which can take 2 or 3 years..u may not be able to complete yr education of certain degree..and wrong sources are easily available on internet..so people have access to that..which is unfortunate..and this religion is massively misunderstood..
I work in IT industry and even if they say that IT jobs are stressful and make you sad deep inside. I still believe that my school days were even worst. I feel that my life in so called stressful IT job is much much better that my school days life.
One name that comes as a journalist is Shekhar Gupta. Whenever I want to have a simplest ways of gathering knowledge, I fall back to to Shekhar Gupta's videos. Thank you for making your videos so lucid.
Good presentation sir. Hats off to Modi govt for bringing such Wonderful changes in our educational system The interdisciplinary approach in senior levels of education is exemplary. Sir, I too studied science with botany, chemistry and zoology but my urge to study economics still a dream. The architects behind this policy shold be applauded for their wonderful vision. But the implementation of these ideas which is more important should be done with utmost care. Being a school teacher in science, let me tell you, when these great visions reach the classroom it's misinterpreted and will be done in such a manner that everything done for the sake of doing as the govt has developed a policy. Recently I attended a workshop on art integration to various subjects a major point in our new policy. The workshops were done by school heads and academic experts but made me think a lot how their techniques are going to help the children and if it is going to be implemented likewise then the ideas and agendas of the policy remains as ideas in paper alone. Therefore well developed script for each topic to be done and circulated among teachers.
When I asked about these problems at my school I was scolded and told just mug up and pass the exams this year they brought in the new policy the sad thing is this year only I have passed out my school wanna study in the new system :(
dont worry nothing will change cause change is internal.....the teachers are same and the people are same...the marking scheme is same and importance of marks over knowledge still resides
@@unpopularopinion5022 Well I believe Mark Twain made a very witty comparison between the two, "I will never let my schooling interfere with my education."
My dear Indian brothers and sisters th-cam.com/video/pV4vongkWI4/w-d-xo.html I have started my new channel Various big changes A complete guide of New Education Policy 2020 Please do like, subscribe and share 😊😊
Osama got his training from CIA. CIA was pretty involved with the Taliban during the cold war. They were helping Taliban to push out the USSR from Afganistan. Now the Taliban has turned against them.
Genuine Non-Profit Education like I went to works! When I was in school ( SSC ), I remember having a class for electrical, knitting, & stitching. We were a co-ed school. We learnt to fix a fuse, open and reassemble a pressing iron ( mica and all), plus knitting a hair band or something, as well as stitching patterns like hemming, back-stitch, etc which I use today in my daily life. Our school did with whatever little we had. Although, I see my colleagues who seem to not know much. Go Mumbai schools! It was not a public school but fees were like Rs5 for fifth std, Rs 6 for sixth standard. Being low income, fortunately my fathers work place allowed use to get scholarships subsidy until I was in college and my father had a blue collar job. I am thankful that they went an extra mile and sacrifices to get us in a paid school although most of my neighbors did not. I lived in low income housing provided by Mumbai’s lottery system. I feel my school was affordable. Bus fare for public bus was 5-10 paise and we walked although way to school. We had others from middle income who used private school bus service. It was a great experience and I did struggle a lot in my early years of education. Oh and let me add. My parents had just elementary education up to 4th grade. My mom helped us study and I guess learnt along the way. I am a big proponent of Education!! I see it is being neglected by governments that have all the powers to change that. Private or government-run, it the government wants go give a good education it can do so. It has the money and the power needed, unless our politicians want us to remain uneducated to seek votes from a less informed, and innocently ignorant population.
Why does Segar Guptha refuse to talk about the EIA 2020, though? @B Prithiraj So, you think I asked you? Lol. P.S.: The edit was necessitated by Segar Guptha and his piraameen paarppanaals who hide, delete and block my comments.
We need good teachers too who loves teaching without pushing for rote learning and makes money in private tuition. Edit: Grey areas in this bill: - Instruction in local language in Class I-V will not work. My kids school has around 30% non-Bengalies. We live in a plural society, at least in all major cities. People who can afford will flock to pure English medium school and kids there would always have an edge over others. - It makes your K-12 education irrelevant. It's a direct copy paste of US education system. In US if you fail to score above 1000 out of 1600 in SAT you may not get chance in good colleges. In Indian context that number of unsuccessful UG entrants could be high even if you get A++ grade in XII and you education career is pretty much over if you fail to crack a SAT like exam. NTA NET Paper 1 is another example. Phd aspirants with non-math background struggles there as scoring 40% is difficult and scoring above cut off marks is herculean task. You have to appear at least 5 times to crack NET. *And then there will be Quota & reservation.* - I don't think text materials & syllabus of Rajasthan, Manipur and Kerala/WB/MH/TN and UP/BH can be identical. There are huge gaps in infrastructure and you can't address it immediately. - Teacher student ratio is absurdly high in India compare to US/EU. This bill doesn't talk about how this will be handled. - 6% of GDP towards education looks good on paper, but this govt have actually reduced education budget allocation last year. Most of the non-tech colleges hardly have any infrastructure and quality teachers. Our economy is mismanaged. It was growing 4% pre-Covid days and now we are in recession. Let's not live in Utopian ideology.
There are many good teachers. Thing is that the heavy and hectic syllabus is not allowing to give holistic learning. Children with different backgrounds come to school and each one must be treated according to his mind and ability. Teachers are busy in completing syllabus. They don't even have time to revise the lessons.
@@kundrapuharitha5187 Not only that, Teacher student ratio is absurdly high, which this bill has failed to address. We don't have resources and this bill looks like just another jhumla. I think NET 2020 isn't feasible in Indian context in the medium term.
Education allocation has not been reduced. Please give your source for your claim. www.google.com/amp/s/www.moneycontrol.com/news/business/economy/budget-2020-education-sector-allocation-up-5-4892771.html/amp says 5% increase
@@architrungta120 Hi, I'm not talking about FY 20-21. You need to check data from 2014 onwards. Between 2014-’15 and 2019-’20, the share of education expenditure in the total Union budget fell from 4.1% to 3.4%. Check pg 19 of this PDF www.cbgaindia.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/07/Promises-and-Priorities-An-Analysis-of-Union-Budget-2019-20-2.pdf
@@tamal thanks for the article. Anyway, you said last year and you didnt mention share. I thought you were talking about total amount which has increased YoY.
Best and most relatable video Shekhar sir! Holistic approach to knowledge and manual work and creativity is very very important rather than just scoring high marks with rote learning!
My dear Indian brothers and sisters th-cam.com/video/pV4vongkWI4/w-d-xo.html I have started my new channel Various big changes A complete guide of New Education Policy 2020 Please do like, subscribe and share 😊😊
There is nothing arrogant about Steve. Other than focusing on marks, our education system never focuses on life skills. We hardly gain any knowledge in our education system. India produces largest number of engineer in the world but limited or no useful innovation, patents etc., We hardly won any noble prize in last 70 years.
Our educational system is in the grip of education mafia. Take for example entrance to say medical or undergraduate courses. For a medical education you have Rs 50lakhs and above as fees for an undergraduate course likewise around Rs20lakhs or so for an engineering course.From, where can student's parents of an average middle class afford that much fees. Seats in government colleges are meager. Nothing addresses that issue. Our politicians are the biggest education mafia or to say the other way around these mafias have entered the political system. They are to be found both in ruling parties and in the opposition. Where are the jobs? Where will the educated youths go after finishing his studies? No one has an answer to this . Even children in most of the government schools studying in class 5 cannot add or subtract let alone write an application form.Instead of burdening them by teaching English, hindi , sanskrit or their mother tongue ,they should be taught one language only in High school.
This is important. Since 2014, India has been trying hard to reach a level of education that most OECD countries have and infact has been trying to do better.... This might just tip the scales in India's favor. This is a very progressive policy. The 4 year undergraduate program was a good touch.
Parents in small cities are dumb headed, whole day they can watch landing of 5 Rafael jets at the end of the day they don't even know 2 were trainer jets
Very unbiased and sussinct synopses of our brand new education policy. Shekhar Gupta has the capacity to find humour in drabbest possible subject. And to show his own marksheet to prove his point was ,to say the least---bold!!
I don't understand why Segar Guptha refuses to talk about the EIA 2020, though. @puntertakeson Thanks for the link. Appreciate it. Would like to know Segar Guptha's take on the issue nonetheless. @puntertakeson And I do know Tamil, btw. It would be a great sin to have the title of Nedunjeralaadhan and the name of Aariya Padai Kadandha Pandiyan and Thalaiaalanganaththu Seru Vendra Pandiayan for my name, if I didn't. 😉
I love the way how he humorously highlighted the problems in our education system in the starting of the video. 😄 Thank you for sharing your views on this topic sir.
Parents/ Students should be able to choose the medium of instruction....if they want it to be english, it must remain english. I hope they don't make it mandatory to get education in mother tongue...English speaking is one of the biggest assets of indian youth. It would be difficult to get a grip over a language if you start in later years.
I think the best among all this is the mix-and-match thing. No hard differentiation between Arts and Science or Commerce and Science or the worse between Arts and Science streams. People can study Physics and History together if they want.
English medium since LKG. In class 8, I remember 2 friends from Kannada Medium who kicked out asses in Mathematics. I personally feel many of us struggled to understand English when we were kids. Also we were bombarded with Languages in our beginning years English Kannada Hindi Instead of teaching us in Kannada, Also languages can be learnt but concepts cannot be learnt.. China, Germany, France, South Korea, etc many countries have excelled in every sector without English as Medium of instruction
Why does Segar Guptha refuse to talk about the EIA 2020, though? @Amit Thanks for expressing your opinion, Mr. Amit. Would appreciate it if you'd ask Segar Guptha to express his opinion on EIA 2020, too. P.S.: The edit was necessitated by Segar Guptha and his piraameen paarppanaals who hide, delete and block my comments.
I don't understand why Segar Guptha refuses to talk about the EIA 2020, though. @sarath krishna They say there are a couple, yes. And I want to hear what Segar Guptha's take on the matter is.
AS A NEPALI I WAS ALSO BOUGHT UP INTO 10+2 SYSTEM BUT I WAS VERY LUCKY TO GET LAST 4 YEARS OF SCHOOL IN UK EDUCATION SYSTEM WHICH IS FAR BETTER WITH MORE CHOICES. NOW I'M ARCHEOLOGIST
@@imayavarambannedunjezhiyan5222 there can be many reasons, but one that I know that he is also pro-market, certain minister in erstwhile govt has done some serious damage to many ambitious infrastructure projects
@@RahulKumar-ng2gh Still, I'd like to hear what he thinks about it himself, though. You do know that a hashtag 'TN rejects EIA 2020' is trending, don't you? @Fart knocker Thank you for expressing your opinion, Mr. Fart shooter. Ciao!
Shekhar Gupta why don't you talk about bureaucratic reforms?? we always blame the politicians for everything but the bureaucracy is the one who is implementing things
There is a supreme court decision not allowing profit in educational institutions of 9 judges.That is where GOI IS STUCK. S.C HAS TO REVIEW ITS OWN DECISION.I TOTALLY AGREE WITH GUPTA ji
I was told this story by a very senior scientist who retired from a major government research agency: he had gone to France for postdoctoral research and was assigned an office that was dusty from lack of use. His advisor came to check on him after a couple of days, and wondered why the office was still dusty. My friend replied that he was waiting for the cleaning person to come by. The advisor wordlessly took him to the broom closet and nicely asked him to grab a broom and get busy cleaning. Hopefully this new policy will instill dignity of labor from school age.
Shekhar sir was so annoyed with his childhood subjects that first time he made really an apolitical video... Shekhar sir : Var mein jaye politics, Nishank ji today I am with you... 👍
11:53 I have heard this too many times - learnt something and employed in some other field. People don’t understand that employers are looking for really smart people. Unfortunately most smart people land up doing engineering or become doctors because of peer pressure. there are very little talented people who know what they want to do and are given freedom to do it. 80% of americans here are cross trained. I have worked with a programmer who was a truck driver.
Propaganda. ALWAYS against the government - it's not about criticism anymore. If tomorrow Modi takes a bullet for him he will report it as a conspiracy to become a martyr and how Modi will reincarnate as eega to take revenge against him for his "courageous" journalism.
I don't understand why Segar Guptha refuses to talk about the EIA 2020, though. @ahs pm Yeah, I know it was brought about by Rajiv Gandhi after the Bhopal gas tragedy. But, I want to hear his views on EIA 2020, though. P.S.: The edit was necessitated by Segar Guptha and his piraameen paarppanaals who hide, delete and block my comments.
I got in to IIT with general rank but at the same time had 60% in boards. I never understood the education system. I assumed I was always made for objective tests. Turns out I am not. It's just the fixed criteria I had to go through were different.
@@neerajkumar-ts6om I studied in a famous private school..over 150 yrs old...the fact is I was not good in pressure environment..I always excelled in school but floundered in competetive type exams
I was topper many years but failed in many engineering exams. Now i m a businessman. My studies didn't teach that, my family taught this lesson. Let everyone learn a skill for livelihood.
Good journalism needs support from smart people like you. Subscribe to ThePrint here: theprint.in/subscribe/
Sir, you are one of the best journalists I have come across
Very true
SIR WE RALLY SUPPORT YOUR EFFORT AND DEDICATION ...
sir...a lower middle class family student like me would feel more comfortable if u make here a separate voluntary contribution option which started from minimum ₹100.We want to contribute but because of the minimum embargo,we find ourselves unable to do so.😊
I do Hope that this *_"MASTERSTROKE"_* of Modi doesn't meet the same Fate as it was with DEMONETIZATION & G.S.T.
The intention was Good but the Implementation and its Execution wasn't up to the Mark which brought the Indian Economy to its lowest position accompanied by a 4 decades high Unemployment rate in India.
Not to forget,
The Negative impact it made on the small-scale industries in rural areas due to the Faulty implementation and execution which resulted in its terrible CLOSURE making it tougher for the people to make their both ends meet.
🤲🏼🙏🏼🤲🏼🙏🏼
The worst thing in our education system?
Some teachers demanding that your answers in exams should be the exact copy of how it is written in your textbook. That's where you kill all the creativity and promote rote learning. Allow the student to express the same answer in his own words and not the words of the author(in fact encourage it)
Exactly, it's like that 3 idiots movie scene where the teacher asked what a machine is and reprimanded him ( Aamir) to give the exact textbook definition. I hate it when teacher does that.
I completely agree with your assessment. Some professors also keep grudge on students who fight against such systems. It is pathetic.
National education policy 2020 🇮🇳
key features in 3 mins 🙏❤️
th-cam.com/video/KHvJBsZhRhg/w-d-xo.html
I was an average student and got really low marks because I always wrote what I understood. I could never learn the exact lines. Later I moved to school in Canada, and with my same understanding skills, I got the highest marks in my first year at university. I hope India can give away the rote learning system.
I don't share your point of view. When I gave my CBSE boards of 10th standard, I referred a book called Oswaal. The book had toppers' answers, and there I observed that none of the toppers had actually rote learned. I think it's just an excuse we perpetrate to make us feel good about ourselves.
Unfortunately, ICSE and CBSE has already lost its credibility. In fact, internal assessment marks are based on buttering up the teachers!
Haa na..Sab Teachers ke chatu log ko marks milta hai..
Buttering up the right people is also a skill.
@@influencer_22 It is and then it is not. While it isn't a great trait, it is good have this as a part of soft skill. If it gets you what you want, use that.
And it is reserved for the toppers
I guess, buttering works everywhere 😅
11:29 My professor at Delhi University said "These days learning carpentry is better than doing Master's in History"
These proffesors also teach how important it is to join the maoists
@@sivachandan7089 de mara chakka.. Lol salam
Anyway it's incorrect history written by left leaning historians !!
We need to correct it too
@@karannainwal1990 History is written by victors.
Now we getting sanghi as VCs and HODs
It's never too late.
@@karannainwal1990 incorrect history, dude you might need a time machine to write the correct one, the historians were peeasses now karan will do it better
6% of GDP will now go to education. Finally, a step by BJP that i can appreciate.
Education is a state subject. so state governments have to pitch in
@@nick-sw3in 370 i didn't read much about and caa was highly criticised. But this one actually seems good. A new education policy was the need of the hour as our education system is pretty bad.
@Purnendu Das it still is. Wb board is one of the toughest in india. People just don't talk about it.
@Purnendu Das are you a TMC cadre? I am also from Bengal and i know that in TMC era, the education system is fully politicised. The SSC and TET stopped by this Gov.
YOU r right but one question i have that is in this crisis how government will spend 6% of GDP in education ?At present our GDP growth rate is 3.2% .Also for covid growth rate of GDP will slump down more and it will have more negative impact on us. Its a matter of concern to all of us.
At some point, we should stop using pejorative terms like 'vernacular' or 'regional languages' and just call them what they are - Indian languages.
While making laws we have to be specific.
Regional language means any Indian language spoken in that region. Many small but significant languages will benefit like Tulu, Gondi or Bhil.
@@islandsunset Tulu, Gondi or Bhil are all Indian languages in my book. For arguments sake, what would you call Hindi or Malayalam? And what language in India is a 'not-regional' language?
@@nrusimha11 I said that while making laws the rules have to be specific. Like if a school has to be opened on Mangalore which is a Tulu majority region and if state govt mandates that Kannada is going to be medium of instruction then it could lead to a problem. So to remove such an issue, the law say regional language for tribal and minority languages.
Respect🙌🏻
Sach bola toh kadwa laga?
India's Educational System will progress only if we get rid of "rote learning system" [ memorize and vomit in exam].
If I look back on my school life, it is so flawed. I wanted to learn Commerce but I did not get it because not good enough marks. So I was forced to learn science because I was "eligible" do so.
can't we atleast copy the education system of USA South Korea Taiwan Singapore Europe? why it took 35yrs to copy unless we want to well educate select few and feel superior
Harshdeep Singh : sorry I didn't realize that that applies to education too where job market is global
Lol instead of watching video here if you had watch the conference video where they declared the new policy than you would not be saying this. In that video the lady clearly said that its not going to be a raatta maro policy anymore.
@@ArreSidu the education system as a whole has fucked so many lives, so I feel u bro. Uk if this gets implemented well, the next gen will take all this for granted and we will tell the stories of our struggle.
I wish to be a school kid now. I could have learned what I enjoy the most. And hopefully, I won't be judged by marks alone.
Wonder why Segar Guptha refuses to talk about the EIA 2020, though.
You can still learn what you enjoy best.... It is never too late to learn something new
Yes... I think learning these basics again can b started for adults also..... N it wud b a great startup as well... Y dnt b start.
same here.
An automobile Engineer should be able to dissemble and assemble a car, before getting his degree. Similarly an Agriculture degree should be given to a parson who can cultivate one acre competing with the farmers.
It's TRUE our current education system is more of theory than practical experience. This should change.
Assembling and dismantling is not an automobile engineering. Those can be learnt with in a week or month. Engineering is an art form of science. We should teach fundamental science very well. Then only we can get good engineers. Technicians can do assembling.
@@HariKrishnan-pe3ft have you even read NEP ?
Now rather than other subjects the focus will be more on your stream and not only theory but practicality .
Practical knowledge+ Theoretical knowledge
What's the use of knowledge if we can't use in outer world.
Bro... These are automobile engineers you are talking about. Not mechanics🤣🤣
That is so true. I learned to paint walls, make furniture, install tiles all by on my own after I moved to US.
Shit man, good for you making some bucks, God bless you.
Vaku Zaku this is for my own place. Not for sale!
I built my own wall-bed here in Bangalore, well designed, fully functional, still standing and working after 5 years. Some of my neighbors who saw the wall-bed joked demeaningly that, he has two jobs one of a Software engineer and another of a Carpenter. Some said why did you spend all that time learning engineering when you had to do Carpentry. Some of my relatives whom I showed it to, said why did you do it, didn't you have money to get it done by a carpenter. Some still think I am a miser for doing things myself. They don't understand the joy of creating things with your own hands or fixing things that are broken. The first thing you need to do anything or achieve anything in life is to stop caring what others say. Sorry 'Super'...long rant.
Rajesh Doyijode yeah don’t get bothered. These people probably won’t do anything interesting in their life.
That's great, bro!
NEP sounds really interesting.
Wasted 17 years of life with "Parrot Learning". I can't recollect a single term I studied in those years. 🙄🙄
Then I believe the issue is the way u have been taught.... I worry now why my child has to learn 3 languages... That's useless
Is Education really a Noble Profession?
And is it OK to exclude it from being governed under Free Market rules?
Watch my latest Video on National Education Policy 2020 tryin to answer these question
th-cam.com/video/bcI5Zjq3zqE/w-d-xo.html
it is all about the teachers who taught you... we had great teachers at school... i wont exchange my schooling for anything in the world...
@Seeker that's probably true... but we have no way of substantiating it... cuz neither our parents' nor our grandparents' generations went through gurukula... they and us were subject to the same clerk-education that today's young are receiving...
But the big difference was that... by some stroke of luck they learnt their mother tongue n Sanskrit and even Hindi(despite being south indians)...
Which the recent generations have completely missed... all they know is a peculiar "indlish"... a bit of regional lingo heavily influenced by their regional cinema and unprintable words borrowed from the west...
So yes in a way we have become puppets with strings being pulled by unknown devious powers...
@Seeker perhaps we can understand that by knowing what was so special about gurukuls that modern schools do not provide.
I want to go back to school days and restart my life.
This kind of system would've been more helpful than the 10+2.
Do you know when this system is going to be implemented? Is it going to start from 2020-2021?
@@CherryMxTx 2021-22
@@arahul4045 so does that mean that this year's 10th std have to adhere to the new policy or is the upcoming board exams going to follow the previous education system?
@Abhijit Sanyal Same story bro
Wonder why Segar Guptha refuses to talk about the EIA 2020, though.
"Our education system doesn't teach you how to work with hands "classic. Sums up all short comings of our education system
Frankly, even most western education systems don't teach basic working with hands.
*However, the students are loaded less and have more time.*
So, they learn these things by helping out their parents or similar things.
And even take up small jobs, once they are of legal age. This allows them to learn more basic skills, earn some money and have a first taste of how economy works🤷♂️
@@rudramahadev22 Yes, but there are enough cases of child labour in hard jobs as well. So I think we need them. However, govt. can specify job types/definitions where a teen above 14 or 16 can be allowed to work.
We are expert masturbaters ...what are u talking about????
@@light_reason3577 definitely not about that
MARK TWAIN must have been thinking about India when he said: I never let my schooling interfere with my education
i think our education should teach these things like decent reading, writing/journaling and then self education, practical and scientific methods for studying and it also should teach more practical skills like communication, social, entrepreneurship, personal finance, personal health, basic problem solving (on personal and local level), quality/smart hard work (and how to get into flow state), basic systems thinking, how to create habits and destroy them, how to tackle procrastination. Does the reader have more things to add or subtract from my list??
😂😂
I took physics in school and switched to economics in college. I am happy with my decision
I watched your presentation on the New Education Policy with keen interest. I am Indonesian but educated at the Jawaharlal Nehru University (JNU). Before studying at JNU, I spent one year at Delhi University. It was a shocking experience studying for a Master's Degree in the university where we had the only exam once in a year, no mid-semester, no paper presentation, and no discussion in the class. It was exactly like what you said, Russian roulette system. I failed one paper and I had to appear again next year for the exam. I decided to move to JNU. Thank you so much for your presentation.
Haha!
"Your Mom hasn't prayed hard enough or your competitor mom had prayed harder"
Best line from today's episode.
i think our education should teach these things like decent reading, writing/journaling and then self education, practical and scientific methods for studying and it also should teach more practical skills like communication, social, entrepreneurship, personal finance, personal health, basic problem solving (on personal and local level), quality/smart hard work (and how to get into flow state), basic systems thinking, how to create habits and destroy them, how to tackle procrastination. Does the reader have more things to add or subtract from my list???
Wonder why Segar Guptha refuses to talk about the EIA 2020, though.
@Ashley D Can you see my reply, Ashley?
This NEP must be welcomed! Great decision by the government to make education liberal! Thanks, SG for your analysis! :)
Nope, it's implementation should be.
I see a "liberal" in the comment, just kidding it's a good step forward, hope the implementation isn't like GST
There was NCF nothing happened. By the time we started to understand NCF they changed NEP.
Many of the things they mentioned in the change are done by experienced highly qualified educators. Our government only make documents not enough budget or manpowers. If they merge everything under one umbrella organization, quality will suffer. But positions of jobs will come down.
There are many such issues with this new policy.
pradhan chutiye
@@deeptobhattacharyya3249 gst is a slight disaster as they don't have proper planning but this will will be a success it's planned for 5 years just like UPI
Great step by Modi govt. India can finally move towards a more practical and meaningful education
Even though I dont agree with the BJP in most of the things.....I can say now....WOW!!!...the New Education Policy 2020 is really good!!!!!👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
@@justinthomasjacob595 yeah you dont agree that's why your the fucking ' print '
I don't understand why Segar Guptha refuses to talk about the EIA 2020, though.
@Ankit Jaiman He's the editor-in-chief of ThePrint. I'm 'commenting repeatedly' because I want to know his thoughts on the matter.
@@priyaljoshi470 why being so intolerant with people who dont share ur ideas and thoughts???😄
@Kaushal Batavia 😂😂😂😂
his jihad story doesn't make any sense.
mulla logic
Cause it was narrated by owaISI that's why.
@Sachin kashmir ka
What else be expected form extremist razakrs buthers of Hyderabad.
Extremists owasi brothers
Basically, people who are primarily science/commerce graduates lean on the internet to understand society beyond their real life experiences. The internet can give them very polarising opinions regarding the same, however, had they studied these things in detail, they would have understood it in a nuanced manner.
I get shivers when i hear scores achieved by kids now a days...
in our days, marks were the body temperature in Celsius , 36.5-37 C. ; now the marks are like body temperature in Fahrenheit. 97°F - 99.5 degree F
@@MrPolunnel 😂 great observation
@Sam Aj fuck off troll...
@Sam Aj
Not dumb heads. We are given for what we deserve. Now a days even an average student is getting best score. Change didn't come in mind but on paper.
Vicky sir don't get shiver. Just you test them you'll find yourself far better than them. Change didn't come in minds but on papers.
This action "Feels soo good". Much better than any Surgical Strike or Ram Mandir. Thank U GOI
Why does Segar Guptha refuse to talk about the EIA 2020, though?
@Abhishek Tyagi thats a bot. 🤣✌️
This bike story was mentioned in an older cut the clutter🤓 and it's so true that our generation lack life skills than our previous generation.
When I started out in America (don't worry, I'm back now, so dont label me a deshdrohi lol.), I started by making money by doing odd jobs, wherein I learnt how to fix pipes, change the filter of an air conditioner and change the spark plug of my bike.
That's how kids learn or rather should learn.
Nowadays though that system of hardwork has gone in the US... Only kids from poor families do summer jobs, while most middle class and rich kids lack any basic life skill.
The opposite is true in India, where alot of kids go out and work during their vacations to make money and learn something.
@@ashutoshsharmash where in India do kids work in summers? Does it really happen? Which companies offer summer jobs? I hope you are not referring to 3rd year internship, engg students do ..
Wonder why Segar Guptha refuses to talk about the EIA 2020, though.
If we learn all life skills than what is the use of expertise???
Even he didn't know it then...so not much difference 😀😀
I'm unlucky, i wanted to learn history with Science 🤧
I think u can😃
Prathamesh Kale But she’s probably done with her schooling
Me too
Toh book kharid ke chaat le.
Mee too
"The Print" is the best thing to happen in Indian journalism in recent times.
Thanks for making the things so easy to understand, sir.
They are pretty biased but they do great work many times.
"IITians get MBAs and then sell toothpaste" lol.
As well as iitans dropouts... And build unicorns
Jabardast
Unicorns which never make money.
My dear Indian brothers and sisters
th-cam.com/video/pV4vongkWI4/w-d-xo.html
I have started my new channel
Various big changes
A complete guide of New Education Policy 2020
Please do like, subscribe and share
😊😊
Check ur facts, how many iitians go for mba n how many go for higher studies IAS, and other jobs
My whole education life I never got any mentionable merit, neither in my Standard / Grade nor in my class until my CA Final exams. I secured 13th rank in whole of India in my CA Final Exams, stood first in Gujarat, stood first in my city Surat, and get three gold medals. I perfectly relate to what Shekhar is saying. The way others rate your academic intelligence is directly related the you being lucky in those 3 hours in the examination hall.
Sir people like u are real motivation for so called average or below average students like me . I am also an average student but preparing for civil services . Hope things also work out for me
@@Ashishkumar-ui8rp thanks a lot for your kind words. Wishing you all the very best. Best wishes for you passing with flying colors. Keep the hard work on, it always pays.
@@NiravJoshi omg u replied thankyou sir . Thank you for your blessings
Hi sir
I have a son who is 18 months and he will be starting school soon. My wife asked me today about the education changes govt brought today and I replied please wait for Mr. SG to explain. Now I can go and show off my knowledge :) thanks print!
Don't trust him so much. Happy for your kid.
Just teach your kid how to learn with good discipline and never spoon feed.
I don't understand why Segar Guptha refuses to talk about the EIA 2020, though.
@Dead pool Yet, there are people in this very same comments section saying he's a leftist and that he's against the EIA 2020, but is too scared to voice his opinions on it.
@@imayavarambannedunjezhiyan5222 shekhar is capitalist he is huge advocate of capitalism & capitalist won't give fuck about environment and also his capitalist mentality bring him much closer to bjp's ideology but politically I believe he is still neutral.
if you are general category, dont have children.(unless u plan to move abroad shortly) there is no future in India for general category kids..
One thing the journo missed: opening of international universities in india...
I believe, it is intentional. Opening international institute and 'not for profit' mindset doesn't rhyme..
No,I think he genuinely forgot as he talked about private sector towards the end and he's generally a neoliberal man atleast regarding economy
I am a faculty at Emory University Atlanta - and I believe that day, when we see international universities opening in india is not too far. Definitely a long way to go though
Will have to be merit based tho. Warna bangladeshi and other rival nations ke log ayenge fueling the separatist propaganda in india.
Wonder why Segar Guptha refuses to talk about the EIA 2020, though.
@Rituraj Mitra So, which habit do you think Segar Guptha is suffering from?
@Rituraj Mitra Are you aware of the fact that a hashtag 'TN rejects EIA 2020' is trending?
@Sreekanth Yerram I don't think he 'missed' it, though. If it was indeed 'missed', I believe it was 'missed' on purpose.
P.S.: You know the disclaimer. It goes something like 'The edit was necessitated by...'
The first 12 minutes of this CTC are real gem to understand what is that ails our education system currently and I can bet no other journalist can do it better. The simple real life examples including through movie lyrics and Stephen Cohen’s mending the plug, do explain the current troubles with our education system bag on. The next 17-18 are the explanation of new NEP and as always help you to declutter the issue. Great Job Shekhar ji. Hats off to Shekhar ji and team Print.
This will go down as one of the best reforms of this government 👏, I have seen engineers who got in for peer pressure, they may have passion for arts ,dance, sculpture or culinary sciences , acting, sports etc , they can take this subject as optional subject along with usual , and can continue their passion along with regular subjects , it may also be their full time career, vocational courses from 8 th class will help the kids set up small businesses by 20 years , due to any reason if a person wouldn't be able to complete a degree can get a certificate ,and continue later , if you have passion for research or depth you can go to PhD directly after the 4 th year , lot of prospects
I feel like I wasted 17 years of my life and now I wanted all those years back.
Same here
i feel the same 😪
@prijesh rajan biggest scam engineering
Shame on u.
@prijesh rajan explain why u feel cheated?.
There will be a lot of opposition if government tries to bring private sector in education. But it will bring better research opportunities. So sooner or later India must do it.
private sector is already in education.
The private sector is already in education. Has been there for decades.
@@sreekr Not so much in pure science research.
As long as private sector is honest and transparent,don't do the usual 'indian jugaad' I wud very much welcome the decision
Lyk Shekhar sir said,govt. interference shud be low but at same tym fees shud be maintained
@@sagarvijayendra8683 Yeah, we don't want the same situation of private institution fees as in the US.
A person who can share their first year marksheet, need serious applause. 😂😂
Great episode.
Wonder why Segar Guptha refuses to talk about the EIA 2020, though.
Fu fu
@@imayavarambannedunjezhiyan5222 I ko y
Very true. I have similar pattern and no repent. 🙂🙂
Living abroad, I find that one of the most lacking parts of our education system is the lack of focus on trades. We need many more plumbers, electricians and carpenters than we do engineers. Our plumbing and electricity work is not half as good or safe as in the developed world. We should stop making unemployable engineers and work at the basics first. There shouldn't be shame in being an electrician compared to an electrical engineer. In fact, electricians often make as much money if not more.
i liked the idea of dropping out and completing the degree after some time
We get compartmentalised too early in life- IIT Coaching from 6th standard...
Wonder why Segar Guptha refuses to talk about the EIA 2020, though.
@yellow dots Some people in the comments section seem to think he's pro EIA 2020, too. So, I think it'd be better to hear that from himself. Do you know that a hashtag 'TN rejects EIA 2020' is trending, btw?
P.S.: The edit was necessitated by Segar Guptha and his piraameen paarppanaals who hide, delete and block my comments.
Coding isnt IIT coaching lmao....its the future
@@imayavarambannedunjezhiyan5222 he's kinda against regulation
@@tejasmohite2651 Not everyone should do coding for a career and at grade 6 one should definitely not specialise into coding that quickly. Atleast until 8th they should be exposed to different disciplines to see where their interests lie.
@@RMatt2016 i think coding will be included in the computer syallabus ,not a seperate subject...so just basic overview
Video starts from 12:00👍
Why does Segar Guptha refuse to talk about the EIA 2020, though?
Thanks
Its India. internal assesment will ultimately lead to corruption.
Wonder why Segar Guptha refuses to talk about the EIA 2020, though.
In every country there is curruption but in this procedure people who have & want to learn they will get better opportunity than previous system.
Absolutely
200% agreed.
it will not because students are given rights to choose thier teacher.. if they are bad they can complaint
“Study IIT & MBA and sell toothpaste” - Best quote 😂
Agali baar #500 par modiji
Great work..
Rip to all liberandu jihadi secular hypocrites...
Wish i could 5 year back. What was stopping the gov't to bring this in his first tenure
Need a lot of study and implement
Buerocracy and pressure groups bro
You Can Only Expect These Questions On Channels Like The Print , The Wire, The Quint, Scroll.in, NDTV, etc.
@@vardaansharmaa why??
@@vardaansharmaa aaj tak and group busy in welcoming Rafael 😄
What is relation between physics, chemistry, maths with jihad. It's a rediculous reason for defending terrorist.
Lol what do you expect from Asaduddin OwaISI.😂😂😂
Even we after graduation learn about Ramayana and Mahabharata. We dont go out for battle or burn the goddamn city.
that's not defending.. that's the explaination or analysis..
@@ankitgupta8945 coz there are movis and serials regarding that.. it's in books even..there are many sources..nd quraan is not easily available in our language..even as a Muslim have read Ramayana Mahabharata..seen serials coz they are available..bt for quraan translation u have to join madrasa..which can take 2 or 3 years..u may not be able to complete yr education of certain degree..and wrong sources are easily available on internet..so people have access to that..which is unfortunate..and this religion is massively misunderstood..
Shaker say Mumbai not Bombay.
Respect local sentiments.
I work in IT industry and even if they say that IT jobs are stressful and make you sad deep inside. I still believe that my school days were even worst. I feel that my life in so called stressful IT job is much much better that my school days life.
One name that comes as a journalist is Shekhar Gupta. Whenever I want to have a simplest ways of gathering knowledge, I fall back to to Shekhar Gupta's videos. Thank you for making your videos so lucid.
Good presentation sir.
Hats off to Modi govt for bringing such
Wonderful changes in our educational system
The interdisciplinary approach in senior levels of education is exemplary. Sir, I too studied science with botany, chemistry and zoology but my urge to study economics still a dream.
The architects behind this policy shold be applauded for their wonderful vision.
But the implementation of these ideas which is more important should be done with utmost care.
Being a school teacher in science, let me tell you, when these great visions reach the classroom it's misinterpreted and will be done in such a manner that everything done for the sake of doing as the govt has developed a policy.
Recently I attended a workshop on art integration to various subjects a major point in our new policy. The workshops were done by school heads and academic experts but made me think a lot how their techniques are going to help the children and if it is going to be implemented likewise then the ideas and agendas of the policy remains as ideas in paper alone.
Therefore well developed script for each topic to be done and circulated among teachers.
When I asked about these problems at my school I was scolded and told just mug up and pass the exams this year they brought in the new policy the sad thing is this year only I have passed out my school wanna study in the new system :(
dont worry nothing will change cause change is internal.....the teachers are same and the people are same...the marking scheme is same and importance of marks over knowledge still resides
Well, education is life long. And the changes arent just limited to school, they're in higher education too.
@@ashutoshsharmash schooling and education are different bhai....so yess education is lifelong
@@unpopularopinion5022 Well I believe Mark Twain made a very witty comparison between the two,
"I will never let my schooling interfere with my education."
I don't understand why Segar Guptha refuses to talk about the EIA 2020, though.
I fell in love wit ur ''boring journalism'' why did u make me like news.
Then you need to watch Study IQ and The Lallantop
Wonder why Segar Guptha refuses to talk about the EIA 2020, though.
My dear Indian brothers and sisters
th-cam.com/video/pV4vongkWI4/w-d-xo.html
I have started my new channel
Various big changes
A complete guide of New Education Policy 2020
Please do like, subscribe and share
😊😊
US soldiers: where did you learn terrrorism.
Osama: Google.
Osama got his training from CIA. CIA was pretty involved with the Taliban during the cold war. They were helping Taliban to push out the USSR from Afganistan. Now the Taliban has turned against them.
@Avinash Kashyap 😂 😂 great iq.
@@sunkillersharkny quran
*where he searched for Quran* 🤣🤣
@Avinash Kashyap Internship in Jaish-e-Morgan(Not JP Morgan) and placement in LeT(Not L&T)..
"Your mom may not have prayed enough" , burst out laughing at this.
What about a Voucher System ?
National education policy 2020 🇮🇳❤️
key features 🙏
th-cam.com/video/KHvJBsZhRhg/w-d-xo.html
Being tested in Odisha under a world bank program - read it in Business Standard
Woah that's awesome didn't know that
Here is a wise man who had the good fortune to meet a lot of people and it is my pleasure to gain knowledge from him. Thank you Shekar sir
Genuine Non-Profit Education like I went to works! When I was in school ( SSC ), I remember having a class for electrical, knitting, & stitching. We were a co-ed school. We learnt to fix a fuse, open and reassemble a pressing iron ( mica and all), plus knitting a hair band or something, as well as stitching patterns like hemming, back-stitch, etc which I use today in my daily life. Our school did with whatever little we had. Although, I see my colleagues who seem to not know much. Go Mumbai schools! It was not a public school but fees were like Rs5 for fifth std, Rs 6 for sixth standard. Being low income, fortunately my fathers work place allowed use to get scholarships subsidy until I was in college and my father had a blue collar job. I am thankful that they went an extra mile and sacrifices to get us in a paid school although most of my neighbors did not. I lived in low income housing provided by Mumbai’s lottery system. I feel my school was affordable. Bus fare for public bus was 5-10 paise and we walked although way to school. We had others from middle income who used private school bus service. It was a great experience and I did struggle a lot in my early years of education.
Oh and let me add. My parents had just elementary education up to 4th grade. My mom helped us study and I guess learnt along the way. I am a big proponent of Education!! I see it is being neglected by governments that have all the powers to change that. Private or government-run, it the government wants go give a good education it can do so. It has the money and the power needed, unless our politicians want us to remain uneducated to seek votes from a less informed, and innocently ignorant population.
Why does Segar Guptha refuse to talk about the EIA 2020, though?
@B Prithiraj So, you think I asked you? Lol.
P.S.: The edit was necessitated by Segar Guptha and his piraameen paarppanaals who hide, delete and block my comments.
How much old u are sir ?
This is 2020
@@imayavarambannedunjezhiyan5222 ask sekar not us.
We seemed to have gone to same/similar school!
How are people commenting in just 9 minutes, when video is of 29 minutes?
Haha.... Right.
Internet has fucked up ppl's attention span. Vivek Bindra talked about all this a lot
@@harshjain3122 No he never said that he said social platforms like tik tok and instagram reduce the attention span.
Why does Segar Guptha refuse to talk about the EIA 2020, though?
I wish everyone watches this. I've shared in at least 10 groups
Wow thanks Deepak! Very humbled to know that. Do keep following ThePrint.
@@ThePrintIndia 😞👎🏻
@@rrrajsrivastava ?
The Print is bais
We need good teachers too who loves teaching without pushing for rote learning and makes money in private tuition.
Edit: Grey areas in this bill:
- Instruction in local language in Class I-V will not work. My kids school has around 30% non-Bengalies. We live in a plural society, at least in all major cities. People who can afford will flock to pure English medium school and kids there would always have an edge over others.
- It makes your K-12 education irrelevant. It's a direct copy paste of US education system. In US if you fail to score above 1000 out of 1600 in SAT you may not get chance in good colleges. In Indian context that number of unsuccessful UG entrants could be high even if you get A++ grade in XII and you education career is pretty much over if you fail to crack a SAT like exam.
NTA NET Paper 1 is another example. Phd aspirants with non-math background struggles there as scoring 40% is difficult and scoring above cut off marks is herculean task. You have to appear at least 5 times to crack NET.
*And then there will be Quota & reservation.*
- I don't think text materials & syllabus of Rajasthan, Manipur and Kerala/WB/MH/TN and UP/BH can be identical. There are huge gaps in infrastructure and you can't address it immediately.
- Teacher student ratio is absurdly high in India compare to US/EU. This bill doesn't talk about how this will be handled.
- 6% of GDP towards education looks good on paper, but this govt have actually reduced education budget allocation last year. Most of the non-tech colleges hardly have any infrastructure and quality teachers. Our economy is mismanaged. It was growing 4% pre-Covid days and now we are in recession.
Let's not live in Utopian ideology.
There are many good teachers. Thing is that the heavy and hectic syllabus is not allowing to give holistic learning. Children with different backgrounds come to school and each one must be treated according to his mind and ability. Teachers are busy in completing syllabus. They don't even have time to revise the lessons.
@@kundrapuharitha5187 Not only that, Teacher student ratio is absurdly high, which this bill has failed to address. We don't have resources and this bill looks like just another jhumla. I think NET 2020 isn't feasible in Indian context in the medium term.
Education allocation has not been reduced. Please give your source for your claim. www.google.com/amp/s/www.moneycontrol.com/news/business/economy/budget-2020-education-sector-allocation-up-5-4892771.html/amp says 5% increase
@@architrungta120 Hi, I'm not talking about FY 20-21. You need to check data from 2014 onwards. Between 2014-’15 and 2019-’20, the share of education expenditure in the total Union budget fell from 4.1% to 3.4%.
Check pg 19 of this PDF www.cbgaindia.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/07/Promises-and-Priorities-An-Analysis-of-Union-Budget-2019-20-2.pdf
@@tamal thanks for the article. Anyway, you said last year and you didnt mention share. I thought you were talking about total amount which has increased YoY.
Best and most relatable video Shekhar sir! Holistic approach to knowledge and manual work and creativity is very very important rather than just scoring high marks with rote learning!
I don’t know whether BJP doing good or not .But every minister is trying new ways .Its good .New India
Search "string"
Blows the spark plug..
SG :- steve u r an engineer
Steve :- i am an american
SG :- typical uncle sam..! 😅😅
I don't understand why Segar Guptha refuses to talk about the EIA 2020, though.
Hahahaha
My dear Indian brothers and sisters
th-cam.com/video/pV4vongkWI4/w-d-xo.html
I have started my new channel
Various big changes
A complete guide of New Education Policy 2020
Please do like, subscribe and share
😊😊
There is nothing arrogant about Steve. Other than focusing on marks, our education system never focuses on life skills. We hardly gain any knowledge in our education system. India produces largest number of engineer in the world but limited or no useful innovation, patents etc., We hardly won any noble prize in last 70 years.
New National Education Policy is welcome. More work to be done.
Our educational system is in the grip of education mafia. Take for example entrance to say medical or undergraduate courses. For a medical education you have Rs 50lakhs and above as fees for an undergraduate course likewise around Rs20lakhs or so for an engineering course.From, where can student's parents of an average middle class afford that much fees. Seats in government colleges are meager. Nothing addresses that issue. Our politicians are the biggest education mafia or to say the other way around these mafias have entered the political system. They are to be found both in ruling parties and in the opposition. Where are the jobs? Where will the educated youths go after finishing his studies? No one has an answer to this .
Even children in most of the government schools studying in class 5 cannot add or subtract let alone write an application form.Instead of burdening them by teaching English, hindi , sanskrit or their mother tongue ,they should be taught one language only in High school.
"It is English that makes us equal" by shekar Gupta .... I'vl remember this for years to come...😎
Not sure if there is a relation between math and terrorism but surely there is one with the skullcap
This is important. Since 2014, India has been trying hard to reach a level of education that most OECD countries have and infact has been trying to do better.... This might just tip the scales in India's favor.
This is a very progressive policy. The 4 year undergraduate program was a good touch.
I hope this will be available in hindi too so that parents in small cities could get this.
@Avinash Kashyap you seem to belong here really well.. would that make you an elite too? ;)
Parents in small cities are dumb headed, whole day they can watch landing of 5 Rafael jets
at the end of the day they don't even know 2 were trainer jets
Never seen Guptaji so passionate rightly so. Best degree is one where student gets patents without worrying about exams.
Very unbiased and sussinct synopses of our brand new education policy. Shekhar Gupta has the capacity to find humour in drabbest possible subject. And to show his own marksheet to prove his point was ,to say the least---bold!!
Start watching at 12 minutes and upto 23 mins. You can thank me for saving your time
I bought some flowers for our terrace inspired by your backgrounds.
Wonder why Segar Guptha refuses to talk about the EIA 2020, though.
Marks system is totally flaued , more interdisciplinary studies & research should be focused.
I don't understand why Segar Guptha refuses to talk about the EIA 2020, though.
@puntertakeson Thanks for the link. Appreciate it. Would like to know Segar Guptha's take on the issue nonetheless.
@puntertakeson And I do know Tamil, btw. It would be a great sin to have the title of Nedunjeralaadhan and the name of Aariya Padai Kadandha Pandiyan and Thalaiaalanganaththu Seru Vendra Pandiayan for my name, if I didn't. 😉
@@imayavarambannedunjezhiyan5222 You can watch about EIA 2020 if you know tamil.
th-cam.com/video/IhNGqMKYHLc/w-d-xo.html
@Siddhartha Choudhury Why do you think Gender studies is useless? Explain.
This is the best thing brought by a government in a long time.
I love the way how he humorously highlighted the problems in our education system in the starting of the video. 😄
Thank you for sharing your views on this topic sir.
Parents/ Students should be able to choose the medium of instruction....if they want it to be english, it must remain english. I hope they don't make it mandatory to get education in mother tongue...English speaking is one of the biggest assets of indian youth.
It would be difficult to get a grip over a language if you start in later years.
"The sheer suddenness of the move, the unexpected nature of the move, the unpredictability of the move''
Why does Segar Guptha refuse to talk about the EIA 2020?
They Google "JIHAD". A TH-cam link opens up to speeches by Owaisi Bros. The rest is "MISSION KASHMIR"
Wonder why Segar Guptha refuses to talk about the EIA 2020, though.
Kashmir has got nothing to do with owaisi.
They are paid bjp tools.kashmir is a legitimate concern.
So are most states of india
I think the best among all this is the mix-and-match thing. No hard differentiation between Arts and Science or Commerce and Science or the worse between Arts and Science streams. People can study Physics and History together if they want.
English medium since LKG.
In class 8, I remember 2 friends from Kannada Medium who kicked out asses in Mathematics.
I personally feel many of us struggled to understand English when we were kids.
Also we were bombarded with Languages in our beginning years
English
Kannada
Hindi
Instead of teaching us in Kannada,
Also languages can be learnt but concepts cannot be learnt..
China, Germany, France, South Korea, etc many countries have excelled in every sector without English as Medium of instruction
Calcutta University is still living in 19th century. They have age old syllabus and worst kind of egoistic teacher
Absolutely..
Same in UP
Why does Segar Guptha refuse to talk about the EIA 2020, though?
@Amit Thanks for expressing your opinion, Mr. Amit. Would appreciate it if you'd ask Segar Guptha to express his opinion on EIA 2020, too.
P.S.: The edit was necessitated by Segar Guptha and his piraameen paarppanaals who hide, delete and block my comments.
I am a victim of it. All of my MSC physics class is in line for bank jobs
@@imayavarambannedunjezhiyan5222 don't spam
this education policy is atleast 10 years late . better late than never
Becoz BJP came late in power
I don't understand why Segar Guptha refuses to talk about the EIA 2020, though.
@sarath krishna They say there are a couple, yes. And I want to hear what Segar Guptha's take on the matter is.
@@imayavarambannedunjezhiyan5222 Is there a problem with it ??
Life of an Indian Student
Born
10th
12th
JEE/NEET
Dies🤣🤣
*science student
bhai Ca and ias add kardo complete ho jayega
@@Techion sorry bhai bhul gaya science student hun na🤣🤣
@@allenpradhan2063 mai bhi BIO student hu but mereko CA easy lagra hai mbbs se
Why does Segar Guptha refuse to talk about the EIA 2020, though?
AS A NEPALI I WAS ALSO BOUGHT UP INTO 10+2 SYSTEM BUT I WAS VERY LUCKY TO GET LAST 4 YEARS OF SCHOOL IN UK EDUCATION SYSTEM WHICH IS FAR BETTER WITH MORE CHOICES. NOW I'M ARCHEOLOGIST
I’m in UK, UK system is not good either
I am happy, you mentioned Pratham/ASER. I work with Pratham since last 10 years!!!! :):)
let me re-do my 12th and engineering, I want to study biology, computer science, economics and politics
Why does Segar Guptha refuse to talk about the EIA 2020, though?
@@imayavarambannedunjezhiyan5222 there can be many reasons, but one that I know that he is also pro-market, certain minister in erstwhile govt has done some serious damage to many ambitious infrastructure projects
@@RahulKumar-ng2gh Still, I'd like to hear what he thinks about it himself, though. You do know that a hashtag 'TN rejects EIA 2020' is trending, don't you?
@Fart knocker Thank you for expressing your opinion, Mr. Fart shooter. Ciao!
You will need Aladdin's lamp for that.
Play at 1.25x speed...... Welcome you all.
Shekhar Gupta why don't you talk about bureaucratic reforms?? we always blame the politicians for everything but the bureaucracy is the one who is implementing things
There is a supreme court decision not allowing profit in educational institutions of 9 judges.That is where GOI IS STUCK. S.C HAS TO REVIEW ITS OWN DECISION.I TOTALLY AGREE WITH GUPTA ji
I was told this story by a very senior scientist who retired from a major government research agency: he had gone to France for postdoctoral research and was assigned an office that was dusty from lack of use. His advisor came to check on him after a couple of days, and wondered why the office was still dusty. My friend replied that he was waiting for the cleaning person to come by. The advisor wordlessly took him to the broom closet and nicely asked him to grab a broom and get busy cleaning. Hopefully this new policy will instill dignity of labor from school age.
The big joke: Jihad & Maths, physics and chemistry; Reality: Jihad & Religion.
Don't encourage crook like AO
AO stands for Asaduddin Owaisi
Shekhar sir was so annoyed with his childhood subjects that first time he made really an apolitical video...
Shekhar sir : Var mein jaye politics, Nishank ji today I am with you... 👍
Why does Segar Guptha refuse to talk about the EIA 2020, though?
11:53 I have heard this too many times - learnt something and employed in some other field. People don’t understand that employers are looking for really smart people. Unfortunately most smart people land up doing engineering or become doctors because of peer pressure. there are very little talented people who know what they want to do and are given freedom to do it.
80% of americans here are cross trained. I have worked with a programmer who was a truck driver.
Education and Health in India should never be compromised or commercialized.
Reading arts and music are leisure activities. We have been too underprivileged to appreciate this. Vocational education is necessary for us.
How come NDTV is talking all "ill" of this new Policy
@ 😂😂😂💪🏿💪🏿
Propaganda. ALWAYS against the government - it's not about criticism anymore. If tomorrow Modi takes a bullet for him he will report it as a conspiracy to become a martyr and how Modi will reincarnate as eega to take revenge against him for his "courageous" journalism.
@@Priya-cm3tr Hilarious 😂
A fun not-so-fun fact: this insular marks based system exists to a huge extent even in NITs.
I don't understand why Segar Guptha refuses to talk about the EIA 2020, though.
@ahs pm Yeah, I know it was brought about by Rajiv Gandhi after the Bhopal gas tragedy. But, I want to hear his views on EIA 2020, though.
P.S.: The edit was necessitated by Segar Guptha and his piraameen paarppanaals who hide, delete and block my comments.
@ahs pm EIA is not the problem, the new draft of EIA is the problem.
I got in to IIT with general rank but at the same time had 60% in boards. I never understood the education system. I assumed I was always made for objective tests. Turns out I am not. It's just the fixed criteria I had to go through were different.
I failed in iits but scored 93 percent in boards...I preferred boards type of education
I got 71% and study B.Tech in NIT Trichy. 😁
@@neerajkumar-ts6om see how bad the system is..I got 93 percent in boards..studying in unknown college
@@nishant1877 Did you studied in a gov't school because there passing percent are usually high but childrens are dumb. I said most not all.
@@neerajkumar-ts6om I studied in a famous private school..over 150 yrs old...the fact is I was not good in pressure environment..I always excelled in school but floundered in competetive type exams
I was topper many years but failed in many engineering exams.
Now i m a businessman.
My studies didn't teach that, my family taught this lesson.
Let everyone learn a skill for livelihood.
A good point addressed by Shekar ji on hypocrisy of Education been a non-profit business!
why do engineers need to learn what is jihad in 1st place, why don't they become curious to know more about quantum physics??
by then they must have gotten more curious and knowledgeable about their idea of "heaven"... pardon my french :-)
Now MP Government had made compulsory of Ramayana , mahabharat, is there any link with engineering 😆😆😆😆, wow
10:32 SG :- Steve you are an engineer !
Steve :- No man, I'm just American
The Print team, please tie Gupta Ji's hands! :-)
Gupta ji: We learned to do little with our own hands.
Single: We took that personally.