Personally, I would do “Survivor: Renegades, Rebels & Rogues.” The lines have been so blurred between heroes and villains since Season 20, to the point that I think it would be more interesting to see characters play that don’t ascribe to the hero/villain mentality, because the game has shifted so radically that morality is no longer such a huge sticking point with players, to the point that someone like Sarah Lacina could win the game so thoroughly despite playing a diabolical game behind the scenes, or that someone who promotes honor and integrity could lose like Woo did (regardless of any “Weasel Woo” remarks). Renegades (players who are not afraid to shake the game up, whether it be forcing rock-draws or snitching votes at tribal, etc.) Rebels (players who have flipped or been behind the biggest betrayals of the show) Rogues (players who have and will cut the throats of anyone standing in their way)
Charles Warren Anyway, Spencer has that character development. His last game was purely focused on using cold strategy, and he got 4th place. Then he tried incorporating a social game and got to the end
@@nick.s.2005 that stupid redemption island twist where the entire island then becomes the jury is dumb. you'd almost be better off losing and hanging out with the jury and winning your way back into the game.
Haha I'm here after TONY won. Natalie didnt even deserve any votes in my opinion. Well maybe 2...she bought Tyson an idol and his vote and Jeremy was her best friend. Anyone else is trash for voting for her lol. Voted off first. Adios.
Honestly I can TOTALLY see Natalie Anderson being the second two time winner. She reminds me of Sandra A LOT. That would be one wild way to see Heroes vs Villains 2 play out.
Natalie was a better player than Sandra... also she was smart and didn't have any attachments because her sister left so early in the game. She was playing the game in the right way while all the other players were trying to protect their love ones and making mistakes all over the place.
Great list. I always thought of Natalie Anderson as a badass Hero, though, just considering how such a significant part of her gameplay was about avenging the betrayal of her best friend. Kind of Game of Thrones-level badassery. But a great pick either way.
I agree with that. It's sort of like when they put Sandra on the villains. Having an attitude against people that have wronged you does not make you a villain.
I have to agree with what Jeff says. I would love an all winners season. But, that would a) have to be the series finale and b) we need 20 GREAT winners. I love a lot of these winners, but not all of them scale evenly.
@@iandean1112 I love all these winners and your cast is spot-on. There's very few alterations I'd make if any at all, but that's where Jeff Probst stands with the theme. If we ever get one and this is the cast, I'd be more than satisfied. But, some of these winners won't come back because they might prefer leaving Survivor as a champion and we've heard this from Jeff himself. Once some of them decline this offer, the casting crew would have problems recruiting people who weren't initially considered and so much to the extent that winners who aren't perceived in as positive of light as others are on a season they only ended up getting in because other people refused to return. There'll always be different casts and different desired outcomes or expectations for these casts and that'll mean that even if everyone here earned the title of Sole Survivor, some worked harder or has been given more praise than others. Some resorted to solely exerting themselves physically because if they didn't have immunity, they would go home because of their social status. Some have made many mistakes in their game and might even win as a result of a jury that has strong resentment towards a certain player. That's my problem with the all winners season. If we could get them, perfect, but I don't think there's likely chances.
asumdiver51013 the problem with Christian was that he was very likeable, which is why people kept him around for so long until they figured out that someone who’s likeable is not who you want to take to the FTC. The entire season I went “why is he still in the game?! What’s going on? Don’t you guys want to win?”
@@ariellee2329 I mean, it's not that some people weren't trying to get rid of him. He had 18 votes cast against him during the season, which is one less than the record of most votes cast against one player in one season.
If you propose bringing back Jay as a villain, you HAVE to bring back Adam from MvGX as a hero. Their friendly rivalry was one of the most compelling aspects of that season, and I would be thrilled to see them play together as allies this go around in a post-merge scenario.
I completely agree -- but only because everyone would expect them to work together, and I don't believe they would. I believe their unique relationship -- where they're fast friends who are bitter rivals -- makes incredibly compelling TV.
It was so cool for them to really dislike each other in the beginning but then grow to really respect each other. That's one of my top 5 seasons. So many great characters even some of the early boots.
Jay was a hero, for sure, I thought David and Hannah were the villians. Well not so much David as much as I just didn't like him, but he worked with the most weasel villian in hannah.
Aubry and Kelley are already confirmed for season 38, if they were on season 40 it would be kinda exhausting. Jessica and Jackline would be terrible choices for heroes vs villains, if it were second chance I would not mind seeing them again
I think the same could be said for Danielle and Candice before the season aired, but I'm glad both were on the season after the fact. I think both could be of a similar situation, and like I said, I think they'd bring more to the table than meets the eye.
I love Jaclyn for HvV. Jessica I would love to see again but I'm not sure she's a villain. The only person I would add to this list is Andrea somewhere.
Here is my list, no winners are included so it could be about revenge vs redemption. This also only includes seasons 21-41. Heroes: Malcom - Phillipines Elaine - Island of the Idols David - Millennials vs Gen X Wentworth - San Juan Del Sur Michael - Ghost Island Janet - Island of the Idols Christian - David vs Goliath Aubrey - Koah Rong Xander - 41 Tasha - Cagayan Villains: Jason - Koah Rong Abi Marie - Phillipines Dominic - Ghost Island Chrissy - Heroes vs Healers vs Hustlers Jay - Millennials vs Gen X Cass - Cagayan Devens - Edge of Extinction Shan - 41 Albert - South Pacific Angelina - David vs Goliath
My honourable mentions are: Male heroes: leif from one world and devon from hvhvh Female heroes: kim from one world and brenda from nicaragua Male villains: troyzan from one world and devons from edge of extinction Female villains: michaela from mvgx and sarah from Cagayan
My only real critique is Denise being the only winner on the Heroes tribe I feel like if you are gonna have winners, you need at least 2 on any given tribe, so the 1 winner doesn't stand out like a sore thumb as an easy out
Denise and Mike Holloway. Would be surprise if that season happen and I see those two as Hero Winners. Natalie Anderson and Tony Vlachos would be my choices for Villain Winners. I want Kim to return, but it will be to soon. She litterly had three kids, all under 5. After she won, she basically had a kid every year for 3 years. Mabye someone could take care of them and she could come back
@@carter4616 Naa not really. If Sarah won fire Natalie would lose to Sarah instead of Tony. She came back into the game with an idol at F6 and then found another straight after, she was guaranteed F4 but (let's be real) had 0 chance of ever winning unless she could get people to turn on Sarah/Tony at that F6 tribal, which she didn't. She could then vote out either Sarah or Tony again (whichever wasn't eliminated at F6), she wins F4 immunity, she sends home Denise. In a Michelle / Natalie / Ben F3, Natalie wins Winners at War with Michelle in 2nd. Anyway, none of that came even close to happening.
Also known as "Survivor:Another Crappy Twist, So They Can Stay Relevant, Despite the fact that they have been #1 in there Time Slot For Years, And There Titles Keep Getting Longer" or "A.C.T.S.T.C.S.R.D.T.F.T.T.H.B.I.T.T.S.F.Y.A.T.T.K.G.L"
@@deepadilla9920 and? My comment still stands. Considering how many times Natalie b has been an alternative on past seasons with returning contestants. She was robbed once again in this fantasy line up by excluding her season
Dalton ross shared a tweet of Natalie Bolton filming a cast photo before S20 started, she was an alternative for Danielle, she was so unlucky and she was also not in the S31 ballot. Kinda disappointing. I would have chosen her over Monica
I honestly want another season of MvGx. or that type of format! it was in my opinion the best season from the s30-s39 era with Cambodia a close second. I loved Adam and Jay's "I love you but I'm not gonna vote with you" storyline!
I simulated this on BrantSteele Survivor simulator and the votes are all included here (abi and Wentworth find idols) 1st vote: 6 votes Denise, 4 votes Jacyln, meanwhile Abi, Kass and Rodney are in an alliance on the Villains tribe: iconic 2nd vote: 4 votes Keith, 4 votes Malcolm, 1 vote Jaclyn, Revote: 4 votes Keith, 3 votes Malcolm 3rd vote: 8 votes Jessica, 2 votes Natalie 4th vote: 5 votes Aubry, 3 votes Jacyln 5th vote: 4 votes Malcolm, 3 votes Jaclyn (Heroes and Villains both go to tribal separately as 6th and 7th vote) 6th vote: 2 votes Tai, 2 votes Michael, 2 votes Jaclyn, revote: 2 votes Tai, 1 vote Jaclyn 7th vote: 5 votes Natalie, 4 votes Jay 8th vote: 4 votes Jaclyn, 1 vote Mike 9th vote and 1st member of the jury: 4 votes Abi, 4 votes Jay, Revote: 4 votes Jay, 2 votes Abi 10th vote and 2nd member of the jury: Abi plays the idol on Rodney, 1 vote Rodney, 3 votes Domenick, 3 votes Abi, Revote: 3 votes abi, 2 votes Domenick Merge Merge vote: 6 votes Michael, 4 votes Rodney 4th member of the jury: 5 votes Rodney, 4 votes Kass Wentworth finds another idol 5th member of the jury: 7 votes Kass, 1 vote Tony (lmao) 6th member of the jury: 3 votes Tony, 3 votes Chrissy, 1 vote Jason, Revote: 3 votes Tony, 2 votes Chrissy 7th member of the jury: 4 votes Chrissy, 2 votes Mike 8th member of the jury: 4 votes Domenick, 1 vote Jason 9th and final member of the jury: 2 votes Jason, 2 votes Sabrina: Revote: 1 vote each, Firemaking: Jason wins Final three: Wentworth, Doctor Mike and Jason Juror votes: 8 votes Wentworth, 1 vote Doctor Mike, which was Tony Chrissy was the fan favourite Immunities: Wentworth: 3 Dom: 2 Kyle: 2 Chrissy: 1 Dr Mike: 1 I definitely believe this season based on the votes would be pretty iconic, Abi doing a Russell except going home off it, Wentworth having two idols and not having to play them and getting no votes. I laughed so hard when I saw 7 votes Kass 1 vote Tony. Then, from the merge vote on, 5 villains go in a row. It was just funny to see this simulation go down.
If only they did this sooner because every dream cast I’ve seen for HvV2 has Tony on the villains tribe but after WaW I don’t know if he really much of a villain anymore
For me the cast would’ve been: *Heroes:* Malcolm (Philippines, Caramoan, Game Changers) Ozzy (Cook Islands, Micronesia, South Pacific, Game Changers) Reed (San Juan Del Sur) Tai (Kaōh Rong, Game Changers) Bobby Jon (Palau, Guatemala) Denise (Philippines, Winners At War) Andrea (Redemption Island, Caramoan) Brenda (Nicaragua, Caramoan) Sophie (South Pacific, Winners At War) Tina (Australia, All Stars, Blood Vs. Water) *Villains:* Kass (Cagayan, Cambodia) Abi Maria (Philippines, Cambodia) Natalie (San Juan Del Sur, Winners At War) Baylor (San Juan Del Sur) Dawn (South Pacific, Caramoan) Tony (Cagayan, Game Changers, Winners At War) Richard (Borneo, All Stars) Jonny "FairPlay" (Pearl Islands, Micronesia) Penner (Cook Islands, Micronesia, Philippines) Spencer (Cagayan, Cambodia)
I had almost the same cast. Just dont want to see Abi and Kass back so I didn't pick them, also I put Jay in the heroes tribe. Also put two winners per tribe : vilains: jo 35 jason 32 domenick 36 tony 28 rodney 30 nathalie 29 Stephanie 22 crissy 35 brenda 21 alicia 24 heroes: michael 36 jay 33 hayden 27 Ben 35 Malcom 25 aubry 32 chelsea 24 kelley 29 denise 25 holly 21
This would've been my cast after s39 Male heroes Spencer: cagayan Malcom: Philippines Devans: eoe Christian: d v g Devon: hhh Female heroes Kelley: san juan del sur Aubrey: koah rong Janet: ioi Denise: Philippines Tasha: cagayan Male villains Tommy: ioi Dominick: Ghost island Tony: cagayan Jay: m v g Brad: san juan del sur Female villains Victoria: eoe Natalie: san juan del sur Lauren: hhh Kass: cagayan Abi: Philippines
My list: Hero Men 1. Michael 2. Spencer 3. Adam 4. Keith 5. Tai Hero Women 1. Michaela 2. Kelly Wentworth 3. Denise 4. Allison 5. Laurel Villain Men 1. Dominic 2. Tony 3. Rodney 4. Jay 5. Jason Villain Women 1. Kass 2. Natalie 3. Debbie 4. Ciera 5. Chrissy
Great list! Here is mine (my villains tribe was similar to yours): Heroes: Malcolm, Hayden Moss, Mike Holloway, David Wright, Michael Yerger Kim Spradlin, Wentworth, Cydney, Aubry, Lauren Villains: Tony, Domenick, Jay, Kyle Jason, Chris Noble Abi, Kass, Chrissy, Natalie A, Carolyn
My cast if 40 was HvV2 Heroes 1. Malcolm 2. Jeremy 3. Tai 4. Christian 5. Rick Devins 6. Sabrina 7. Denise 8. Sydney 9. Kelly Wentworth 10. Kellee Kim Villains 1. Phillip 2. Tony 3. Rodney 4. Kyle Jason 5. Domenick 6. Abi 7. Kass 8. Natalie 9. Chrissy 10. Angelina
Lily Frederiksen honestly. I think she would have a greater chance of getting voted out early than other players just because she is there to play and shes a bit unpredictable. she’s proved that both in blood v water and camodia
My h vs v picks are Heroes: Dawn, Adam, Zeke, Tasha, woo, Fabio, Keith, Tai, Janet, and Wendell. Villains: Rick devons, Kelley Wentworth, Brandon Hantz, Sarah, Kass, Spencer, Tony, Natalie, Ben, And Tommy
Heroes: -men: Malcolm (Philippines) Spencer (Cagayan) Eddy (Fans vs Favorites 2) Fabio (Nicaragua) Yau Man (Fiji) *YES I KNOW THIS WAS BEFORE 20 SO IT'S AN EXCEPTION* -women: Brenda (Nicaragua) Chelsea (One World) Kat (One World) Jeffra (Cagayan) Denise (Philippines) Villains: -men: Cochran (South Pacific) Phillip (Redemption Island) Colton (One World) Tony (Cagayan) Stephen (Tocantins) *YES I KNOW THIS WAS BEFORE 20 SO IT'S AN EXCEPTION* -women: Abi-Marie (Philippines) NaOnka (Nicaragua) Andrea (Redemption Island) Sherri (Fans vs Favorites 2) Sarah (Cagayan) Tell me your thoughts on my list!
MY DREAM CAST Heroes: 1. Keith (Blood Vs. Water 2/Second Chances) 2. Malcolm (Philippines/Caramoan/Game Changers) 3. Wendell (Ghost Island) 4. Michael (Ghost Island) 5. Christian (David Vs. Goliath) 6. Gabby (David Vs. Goliath) 7. Michaela (Millennials Vs. Gen X/Game Changers) 8. Jaclyn (Blood Vs Water 2) 9. Aubrey (Koah Rong/Game Changers) 10. Shirin (Worlds Apart/Second Chances) Villains 1. Tony (Cagayan/Game Changers) 2. Dom (Ghost Island) 3. Phillip Sheppard (Redemption Island/Caramoan) 4. Rodney (Worlds Apart) 5. Jay (Millenials Vs. Gen X) 6. Abi Maria (Philippines/Second Chances) 7. Chrissy (Heroes Vs. Healers Vs. Hustlers) 8. Natalie (Blood Vs. Water 2) 9. Missy (Blood Vs. Water 2) 10. Angelina (David Vs. Goliath) HONORABLE MENTIONS: Heroes: 1. Adam (Millennials Vs. Gen X) 2. Jeremy (Blood Vs. Water 2/Second Chances) 3. Zeke (Millennials Vs. Gen X) 4. Kelley Wentworth (Blood Vs. Water 2/Second Chances) 5. Hannah (Millennials Vs. Gen X) 6. Denise (Philippines) 7. Reynold (Caramoan) 8. Keith (Blood Vs. Water 2/Second Chances) 9. Jenn (Worlds Apart) 10. Tai (Kaoh Rong/Game Changers) Villains: 1. Joe (Heroes Vs. Healers Vs. Hustlers) 2. Shamar (Caramoan) 3. Figgy (Millennials Vs. Gen X) 4. Francesca (Redemption Island/Caramoan) 5. Peter (Brains Vs. Brain Vs. Beauty 2) 6. Dan (Worlds Apart) 7. Natalie (David Vs. Goliath) 8. Kass (Cagayan/Second Chances)
@@owennicholson8914 I actually put Gabby on the list before she became annoying on this current season. I was rooting for her and Christian very early on and thought she'd be an interesting person to see on a cutthroat theme like Heroes Vs. Villains. I still stand with keeping her on the list because despite her being annoying, to see her around BIG personalities like Tony & Dom will be interesting especially since she was barley able to handle Carl imagine her being around this cast.
The shot at 9:48 was filmed on the Edge of Extinction. I know that this challenge (family visit in HHH) and the pole immunity challenge in GC that Tai won were both filmed there pre-EOE. It's really interesting to see how they use the same beaches for challenges, twists, and camps across seasons.
Malcolm(Philippines) - 4th Place Malcolm(Caramoan) - 4th Juror Malcolm(Game Changers) - 4th Voted Out Abi-Maria(Philippines) - 7th Juror Abi-Maria(Cambodia) - 7th Juror Michaela(MvG) - 7th Voted Out Michaela(Game Changers) - 7th Juror Idk who had the same number of Place,Juror and Voted Out. So that is all Thank you
Heroes Michael 36, Terry 12, 31, Malcolm 25, 26, 34, Tai 32, 34, Mike 30, Laurel 36, Natalie 29, Jessica 33, Andrea 21, 26, 34 Villains Jason 32, Tony 28, 34, Phillip 22, 26, Domenick 36, Rodney 30, Abi-Maria 25, 31, Sarah 28, 34, Debbie 32, 34, Chrissy 35, Eliza 9, 16 4 winners, 1 male hero, 1 female hero, 1 male villain, 1 female villain. Original HvV had winners and this would spread it out with 4 winners instead of just 1 or 2 where they could maybe be easy targets. Spread out the seasons somewhat. No original HvV players. Mostly newer players as that's most likely more realistic as to what CBS would do. But a couple of older seasons players. Eliza is still young enough and Terry did play a 2nd time in 2nd chances. Had Aubrey, Wentworth, Joe and David in my older list, but since they're back in 38, I took them out. There's usually a pretty thin line between a hero and villain, so you could argue a few could be either tribe, but you could do that with some on the original HvV as well.
Hey peridiam, if Russell Hantz was on a season and the other people on his tribe got a 15 minute head start for each idol, how many do you think he would find
He would still find a lot because most of the cast would get tired and thirsty and then stop after 30 min. Russel and Tony found so many idols because they looked for them all of the time. It looks easy on tv but they usually spend all day looking for 1 idol.
David and Mike Holloway I feel have a better pull than Michael and Mike Z. Maybe replace Jessica with Sophie. Otherwise, I love this list and I'm glad you remember Rodney and Jay.
Might need to revise this with a number of DvG members. Christian, Davie, John, and Nick I could see being on the Heroes, and definitely Angelina and possibly Mike on the Villains.
Little did we know....we’d be getting all winners instead.
Personally, I would do “Survivor: Renegades, Rebels & Rogues.” The lines have been so blurred between heroes and villains since Season 20, to the point that I think it would be more interesting to see characters play that don’t ascribe to the hero/villain mentality, because the game has shifted so radically that morality is no longer such a huge sticking point with players, to the point that someone like Sarah Lacina could win the game so thoroughly despite playing a diabolical game behind the scenes, or that someone who promotes honor and integrity could lose like Woo did (regardless of any “Weasel Woo” remarks).
Renegades (players who are not afraid to shake the game up, whether it be forcing rock-draws or snitching votes at tribal, etc.)
Rebels (players who have flipped or been behind the biggest betrayals of the show)
Rogues (players who have and will cut the throats of anyone standing in their way)
That's so interesting!!
I nominate Mike Holloway for Rebels tribe.
I actually like him a lot.
I can ses Brenda Lowe as a Renegade
I can see charli damelio in renegade
Kas would be a Rebel (I could see her as a renegade, but I thought Rebel was more fitting)
Spencer is underrated. He deserves a shoutout.
When Tony wins WaW you probably think you predicted it.
Ethan Tinklenberg I didn't predict it I just wanted him to win
Yes Spencer was so good
Spencer is overrated. He never knows what's going on in the game.
Charles Warren Didn't old school survivor teach you badongus?! You don't have to have perfect strategy to be a fan favorite
Charles Warren Anyway, Spencer has that character development. His last game was purely focused on using cold strategy, and he got 4th place. Then he tried incorporating a social game and got to the end
Who’s here after tony had the greates performance in the history of survivor
I am xD
not me. anyways Natalie winner of Winners at War
Nicholas Stella you have a kpop profile picture, your opinion doesn’t matter
@@nick.s.2005 that stupid redemption island twist where the entire island then becomes the jury is dumb. you'd almost be better off losing and hanging out with the jury and winning your way back into the game.
Haha I'm here after TONY won. Natalie didnt even deserve any votes in my opinion. Well maybe 2...she bought Tyson an idol and his vote and Jeremy was her best friend. Anyone else is trash for voting for her lol. Voted off first. Adios.
I need this to happen, so that we can see Tony and Chaos Kass on the same tribe 😂
Lmaooooo or trish and Lindsey would have be laughing the entire time
@Kelly touch grass
Honestly I can TOTALLY see Natalie Anderson being the second two time winner. She reminds me of Sandra A LOT. That would be one wild way to see Heroes vs Villains 2 play out.
natalie got lucky with the twist or she would have gone home.Sandra should have never won once but hater jury's made it happen!
Natalie was a better player than Sandra... also she was smart and didn't have any attachments because her sister left so early in the game. She was playing the game in the right way while all the other players were trying to protect their love ones and making mistakes all over the place.
No she got voted out today lol
We are talking about Natalie the winner not the Natalie that was a Cirie + Philip The Specialist
@@hoseman88 what twist
The funny thing is that I've always seen Natalie Anderson as a hero.
I feel like she could be put in either tribe and it would work
Rip Keith. Sadly we can’t see him on our screens ever again.
Great list. I always thought of Natalie Anderson as a badass Hero, though, just considering how such a significant part of her gameplay was about avenging the betrayal of her best friend. Kind of Game of Thrones-level badassery. But a great pick either way.
I agree - I'd place Natalie firmly in the Heroes camp, definitely not a villain.
I agree with that. It's sort of like when they put Sandra on the villains. Having an attitude against people that have wronged you does not make you a villain.
I feel like Michaela Bradshaw would be a great fit for the Villains team , love her !
Asher started tripn
Ya she’s on my dream tribe of heroes. Idk how you get villain from her.
@@robertperry766 I think it is because of her really aggressive personality durring challenges
She's dumb
Moore, OK Tornado Sirens
You’re pretty dumb.. michaela was a very good strategist and a funny personality
Can we get an all winners season though? That would be great.
Maybe not all winners but at least make Top 3 be a requirement
I have to agree with what Jeff says. I would love an all winners season. But, that would a) have to be the series finale and b) we need 20 GREAT winners. I love a lot of these winners, but not all of them scale evenly.
@@JacobCT25 Denise, Natalie Anderson, Sandra, Parvati, Sophie, Kim, Dani, Sarah, Michelle, Jenna Morasca (Girls)
@@JacobCT25 Tony, Cochran, Earl, Jeremy, JT, Aras, Yul, Ben, Adam, Todd.
@@iandean1112 I love all these winners and your cast is spot-on. There's very few alterations I'd make if any at all, but that's where Jeff Probst stands with the theme. If we ever get one and this is the cast, I'd be more than satisfied. But, some of these winners won't come back because they might prefer leaving Survivor as a champion and we've heard this from Jeff himself. Once some of them decline this offer, the casting crew would have problems recruiting people who weren't initially considered and so much to the extent that winners who aren't perceived in as positive of light as others are on a season they only ended up getting in because other people refused to return. There'll always be different casts and different desired outcomes or expectations for these casts and that'll mean that even if everyone here earned the title of Sole Survivor, some worked harder or has been given more praise than others. Some resorted to solely exerting themselves physically because if they didn't have immunity, they would go home because of their social status. Some have made many mistakes in their game and might even win as a result of a jury that has strong resentment towards a certain player. That's my problem with the all winners season. If we could get them, perfect, but I don't think there's likely chances.
I'm so happy you included Jay. I want to see him on my TV screen again so much, he was so fun!! :)
Jay was only good when he wasnt hanging around Taylor, Figgy or Michelle that season.
He’s on The Challenge now
Wow I've never been this early for any TH-cam video! Clearly my love for Peridiam is bigger than I thought
What about Christian from David vs Goliath?
this video was made mid season so idk
asumdiver51013 the problem with Christian was that he was very likeable, which is why people kept him around for so long until they figured out that someone who’s likeable is not who you want to take to the FTC. The entire season I went “why is he still in the game?! What’s going on? Don’t you guys want to win?”
@@ariellee2329 I mean, it's not that some people weren't trying to get rid of him. He had 18 votes cast against him during the season, which is one less than the record of most votes cast against one player in one season.
@@JosiahVarenkamp Really? I don't remember that. Good to know the people weren't as oblivious as I remember them being, haha. ;)
Seriously!! I need to see Christian again
2020 here. I need to see rick devins again. one of my favourite players of all time.
agreed he’s my favorite non-winner
Second chance 2
Yes
I want him play with Russell Hantz
IKR I was sooooo mad when he wasn’t included
What about Christian??? I feel like he will for sure be back at some point!
This was made before S38 I think
this video was made before the release of S37. i asked the same question and Peridiam told me why Christian wasnt mentioned.
Christian said in an interview that he has to prioritise his career but will probably still consider returning
I would prefer to see Brenda over Jessica but good list anyway
But Brenda after Caramoan would be considered as a heroe
Would love to see Brenda back as a hero
and Matt from Redemption island
Brenda would be one of my favorite villians
Andrea over brenda
Keith is like Rupert 2.0.
Really love him, hoping he'll comeback on Season 40.
nah Rupert thinks he's hot shit, Keith is pretty damn humble
Rip Keith
I'd love to see this video be updated now that David v. Goliath, Island of the Idols, and Winner at War have come out.
I would like to see it now after 41, 42, and 43 and now 44
Everyone always talked about how crazy it was that Candace was on the hero tribe.. I think it's way crazier that Sugar was lmao
i think sugar was deamed a hero for Saving bob at the final 4 in her 1st season
If you propose bringing back Jay as a villain, you HAVE to bring back Adam from MvGX as a hero. Their friendly rivalry was one of the most compelling aspects of that season, and I would be thrilled to see them play together as allies this go around in a post-merge scenario.
I completely agree -- but only because everyone would expect them to work together, and I don't believe they would. I believe their unique relationship -- where they're fast friends who are bitter rivals -- makes incredibly compelling TV.
Troublemaker Baker I would agree it’s like Amanda and parvati with jay being parvati obviously and Adam as Amanda
It was so cool for them to really dislike each other in the beginning but then grow to really respect each other. That's one of my top 5 seasons. So many great characters even some of the early boots.
Jay was a hero, for sure, I thought David and Hannah were the villians. Well not so much David as much as I just didn't like him, but he worked with the most weasel villian in hannah.
I want to see Fabio from Survivor Nicaragua on the Heroes Tribe.
i
I would want Marty Piombo from nicaragua fro the villains tribe he was the only one playing
ew why
He’s literally a golden retriever as a person it’s amazing
I wanted to see naonka on the villains tribe
dude. i loved michael. he played so well. i was sad in ghost island when i saw him go. it was great.
To be honest, you should do a game changer 2 cast same with second chance 2
This needs to happen. We need to see the Denise and Malcolm alliance again
If this gets 1 like, Peridiam does a face reveal
JP Murphy follow him on Instagram lmfao
Benjamin Lau billy giese
Aubry and Kelley are already confirmed for season 38, if they were on season 40 it would be kinda exhausting. Jessica and Jackline would be terrible choices for heroes vs villains, if it were second chance I would not mind seeing them again
I think the same could be said for Danielle and Candice before the season aired, but I'm glad both were on the season after the fact. I think both could be of a similar situation, and like I said, I think they'd bring more to the table than meets the eye.
I think this list is without taking the fact that they are on 38 into account
Super Ego OMG AUBREY AND KELLEY?!?!?!? ❤️❤️❤️❤️
I love Jaclyn for HvV. Jessica I would love to see again but I'm not sure she's a villain. The only person I would add to this list is Andrea somewhere.
@@alejandroreyes9566 Yes. And Joe Anglim and David Wright as well.
Here's an idea
Top 5:
Castaways who deserve a 2nd chance.
Castaways who deserve a 3rd chance.
Castaways who deserve a 4th chance.
The 4 timers tribe:Malcolm, Malcolm, Malcolm, Malcolm, aannnnddd Malcolm
What about castaways who deserve an 8th chance?
why always Malcolm he already got so many chances. I don't want them to help him like they did for Rob Mariano and Tyson Apostol. LOL
@@darrylflinch5274 he didnt get a real 3rd season cause of the J.T. bullshit
Treeko137, but that's only one person?
Here is my list, no winners are included so it could be about revenge vs redemption. This also only includes seasons 21-41.
Heroes:
Malcom - Phillipines
Elaine - Island of the Idols
David - Millennials vs Gen X
Wentworth - San Juan Del Sur
Michael - Ghost Island
Janet - Island of the Idols
Christian - David vs Goliath
Aubrey - Koah Rong
Xander - 41
Tasha - Cagayan
Villains:
Jason - Koah Rong
Abi Marie - Phillipines
Dominic - Ghost Island
Chrissy - Heroes vs Healers vs Hustlers
Jay - Millennials vs Gen X
Cass - Cagayan
Devens - Edge of Extinction
Shan - 41
Albert - South Pacific
Angelina - David vs Goliath
My honourable mentions are:
Male heroes: leif from one world and devon from hvhvh
Female heroes: kim from one world and brenda from nicaragua
Male villains: troyzan from one world and devons from edge of extinction
Female villains: michaela from mvgx and sarah from Cagayan
Robert Maher why leif???
I wouldn’t consider Troyzan a villain even though he was the best in that season
Kim was not ahero
Leif? i cant remember what he did in S24. he was just... there
Why are there so many people from One World?
My only real critique is Denise being the only winner on the Heroes tribe
I feel like if you are gonna have winners, you need at least 2 on any given tribe, so the 1 winner doesn't stand out like a sore thumb as an easy out
Denise and Mike Holloway. Would be surprise if that season happen and I see those two as Hero Winners. Natalie Anderson and Tony Vlachos would be my choices for Villain Winners. I want Kim to return, but it will be to soon. She litterly had three kids, all under 5. After she won, she basically had a kid every year for 3 years. Mabye someone could take care of them and she could come back
Denise isn't coming back she has a psychological background they realized that was a mistake.
Ernie Mike from Worlds apart
@@Slothpdx
Dude season 40 cast was leaked in may
@@Slothpdx Oh really?
IM SO HAPPY YOU SAID KYLE JASON OMG, he's one of my favorite complex anti-heroes
also very surprised at no David (MvGx) for Heroes tribe
Natalie is one of my all-time favorite winners, and I would LOVE to see her win a second season
Seanzie P same
She was so close in season 40
@@carter4616 Naa not really. If Sarah won fire Natalie would lose to Sarah instead of Tony. She came back into the game with an idol at F6 and then found another straight after, she was guaranteed F4 but (let's be real) had 0 chance of ever winning unless she could get people to turn on Sarah/Tony at that F6 tribal, which she didn't. She could then vote out either Sarah or Tony again (whichever wasn't eliminated at F6), she wins F4 immunity, she sends home Denise. In a Michelle / Natalie / Ben F3, Natalie wins Winners at War with Michelle in 2nd. Anyway, none of that came even close to happening.
TrueGuardify ok yes but she was still very close being the runner up 😂
She played a great game in SJDS. It was interesting to see her loved one leave first and that drive her to win.
I thought for sure we’d have Ciara from Blood vs Water and Cambodia back as a villain. That would be cool
Did you know that she voted off her mom!! /s
love ciera.
And Michael recently said on insta he would defiantly come back if he’s asked!!
*definitely
You're in luck. Both Aubrey and Kelly Wentworth will be back next February for 'Survivor: Isle of Extinction'.
Also known as "Survivor:Another Crappy Twist, So They Can Stay Relevant, Despite the fact that they have been #1 in there Time Slot For Years, And There Titles Keep Getting Longer" or "A.C.T.S.T.C.S.R.D.T.F.T.T.H.B.I.T.T.S.F.Y.A.T.T.K.G.L"
Seth Arrons That season makes me want to die.
I like to pretend that this season isnt happening
See i like returning players but 4 of them with newbees
Um wtf
I just want Aubry to win finally 😂
Not too bad so far
Natalie Bolton getting robbed once again. :S
Tell that to Shane!
yes! and Tracey!
Well he already said that he only included players from post Heroes vs. Villains seasons (Nicaragua to Ghost Island)
@@deepadilla9920 and? My comment still stands. Considering how many times Natalie b has been an alternative on past seasons with returning contestants. She was robbed once again in this fantasy line up by excluding her season
Dalton ross shared a tweet of Natalie Bolton filming a cast photo before S20 started, she was an alternative for Danielle, she was so unlucky and she was also not in the S31 ballot. Kinda disappointing. I would have chosen her over Monica
I WANT HAYDEN MOSS AND JAY STARRETT BACK SO MUCH!
XxTheAnimetrixxX same
same
The two people in survivor that desperately need to return!
R.I.P. Keith
I honestly want another season of MvGx. or that type of format! it was in my opinion the best season from the s30-s39 era with Cambodia a close second.
I loved Adam and Jay's "I love you but I'm not gonna vote with you" storyline!
Happy anniversary Peridiam ! I've watched all your videos and i love literally all of them
Yes keith is my favorite survivor player of all time
Dawson Craig Russell Hans is mine
Keith's an idiot. He couldn't play the game if someone gave him an instruction manual.
narutosbelievin But he was funny as heck
I simulated this on BrantSteele Survivor simulator and the votes are all included here
(abi and Wentworth find idols)
1st vote: 6 votes Denise, 4 votes Jacyln, meanwhile Abi, Kass and Rodney are in an alliance on the Villains tribe: iconic
2nd vote: 4 votes Keith, 4 votes Malcolm, 1 vote Jaclyn, Revote: 4 votes Keith, 3 votes Malcolm
3rd vote: 8 votes Jessica, 2 votes Natalie
4th vote: 5 votes Aubry, 3 votes Jacyln
5th vote: 4 votes Malcolm, 3 votes Jaclyn
(Heroes and Villains both go to tribal separately as 6th and 7th vote)
6th vote: 2 votes Tai, 2 votes Michael, 2 votes Jaclyn, revote: 2 votes Tai, 1 vote Jaclyn
7th vote: 5 votes Natalie, 4 votes Jay
8th vote: 4 votes Jaclyn, 1 vote Mike
9th vote and 1st member of the jury: 4 votes Abi, 4 votes Jay, Revote: 4 votes Jay, 2 votes Abi
10th vote and 2nd member of the jury: Abi plays the idol on Rodney, 1 vote Rodney, 3 votes Domenick, 3 votes Abi, Revote: 3 votes abi, 2 votes Domenick
Merge
Merge vote: 6 votes Michael, 4 votes Rodney
4th member of the jury: 5 votes Rodney, 4 votes Kass
Wentworth finds another idol
5th member of the jury: 7 votes Kass, 1 vote Tony (lmao)
6th member of the jury: 3 votes Tony, 3 votes Chrissy, 1 vote Jason, Revote: 3 votes Tony, 2 votes Chrissy
7th member of the jury: 4 votes Chrissy, 2 votes Mike
8th member of the jury: 4 votes Domenick, 1 vote Jason
9th and final member of the jury: 2 votes Jason, 2 votes Sabrina: Revote: 1 vote each, Firemaking: Jason wins
Final three: Wentworth, Doctor Mike and Jason
Juror votes: 8 votes Wentworth, 1 vote Doctor Mike, which was Tony
Chrissy was the fan favourite
Immunities:
Wentworth: 3
Dom: 2
Kyle: 2
Chrissy: 1
Dr Mike: 1
I definitely believe this season based on the votes would be pretty iconic, Abi doing a Russell except going home off it, Wentworth having two idols and not having to play them and getting no votes. I laughed so hard when I saw 7 votes Kass 1 vote Tony. Then, from the merge vote on, 5 villains go in a row. It was just funny to see this simulation go down.
It’s sad to know that Keith died this year
If only they did this sooner because every dream cast I’ve seen for HvV2 has Tony on the villains tribe but after WaW I don’t know if he really much of a villain anymore
I really want to see Natalie Bolton from Micronesia play again though!! She’s such a proud villain.
She was apparently an alternate for the original HvV!
@@Spongeboymebob5 Natalie was found taking photos near the place HvV was filmed but they decided with Courtney instead.
For me the cast would’ve been:
*Heroes:*
Malcolm (Philippines, Caramoan, Game Changers)
Ozzy (Cook Islands, Micronesia, South Pacific, Game Changers)
Reed (San Juan Del Sur)
Tai (Kaōh Rong, Game Changers)
Bobby Jon (Palau, Guatemala)
Denise (Philippines, Winners At War)
Andrea (Redemption Island, Caramoan)
Brenda (Nicaragua, Caramoan)
Sophie (South Pacific, Winners At War)
Tina (Australia, All Stars, Blood Vs. Water)
*Villains:*
Kass (Cagayan, Cambodia)
Abi Maria (Philippines, Cambodia)
Natalie (San Juan Del Sur, Winners At War)
Baylor (San Juan Del Sur)
Dawn (South Pacific, Caramoan)
Tony (Cagayan, Game Changers, Winners At War)
Richard (Borneo, All Stars)
Jonny "FairPlay" (Pearl Islands, Micronesia)
Penner (Cook Islands, Micronesia, Philippines)
Spencer (Cagayan, Cambodia)
Tai could be considered a villian
@@jaimebaase3012 ya but than I would have to get rid of one of the male villains
Ehhh flip him and spender was sort of a villain in second chance but heroe in Cagayan so I’d consider him a hero
Ew
I had almost the same cast. Just dont want to see Abi and Kass back so I didn't pick them, also I put Jay in the heroes tribe. Also put two winners per tribe :
vilains:
jo 35
jason 32
domenick 36
tony 28
rodney 30
nathalie 29
Stephanie 22
crissy 35
brenda 21
alicia 24
heroes:
michael 36
jay 33
hayden 27
Ben 35
Malcom 25
aubry 32
chelsea 24
kelley 29
denise 25
holly 21
lp mande why Ben tho?
This would've been my cast after s39
Male heroes
Spencer: cagayan
Malcom: Philippines
Devans: eoe
Christian: d v g
Devon: hhh
Female heroes
Kelley: san juan del sur
Aubrey: koah rong
Janet: ioi
Denise: Philippines
Tasha: cagayan
Male villains
Tommy: ioi
Dominick: Ghost island
Tony: cagayan
Jay: m v g
Brad: san juan del sur
Female villains
Victoria: eoe
Natalie: san juan del sur
Lauren: hhh
Kass: cagayan
Abi: Philippines
Cosmic 1806 I agree
@@rainigumbo9339 thanks
My list:
Hero Men
1. Michael
2. Spencer
3. Adam
4. Keith
5. Tai
Hero Women
1. Michaela
2. Kelly Wentworth
3. Denise
4. Allison
5. Laurel
Villain Men
1. Dominic
2. Tony
3. Rodney
4. Jay
5. Jason
Villain Women
1. Kass
2. Natalie
3. Debbie
4. Ciera
5. Chrissy
JD Randall replace spencer with Malcolm, Spencer wasn’t necessarily a hero in cambodia
Great list! Here is mine (my villains tribe was similar to yours):
Heroes:
Malcolm, Hayden Moss, Mike Holloway, David Wright, Michael Yerger
Kim Spradlin, Wentworth, Cydney, Aubry, Lauren
Villains:
Tony, Domenick, Jay, Kyle Jason, Chris Noble
Abi, Kass, Chrissy, Natalie A, Carolyn
Jack A. Russo?
Russel?
The destructive duo! !!!! No, he was on HvV
Kim is definitely be a villain
Jack A. Your villains list is amazing
RIP Kieth
My idea is that there is a whole season of contestants who got eliminated first
CletusDaYeetus Mr.Deletus that’s gonna be a season full of annoying people/ people bad at challenges😂
Kevinn what about Mari? She was good at challenges
@@alexmundy3034 she was not out first there was rachel, but So would be good i think (worlds apart)
Kevinn but what about the greatest survivor player of all time Zayne Knight
Francesqua- the queen stays queen adios
My cast if 40 was HvV2
Heroes
1. Malcolm
2. Jeremy
3. Tai
4. Christian
5. Rick Devins
6. Sabrina
7. Denise
8. Sydney
9. Kelly Wentworth
10. Kellee Kim
Villains
1. Phillip
2. Tony
3. Rodney
4. Kyle Jason
5. Domenick
6. Abi
7. Kass
8. Natalie
9. Chrissy
10. Angelina
Rest In peace Keith😢
I think Jessica Lewis from Millennials vs Gen X should be the random brought back
Cece D yes, or for the next second chance season. There is such a story to be told in her second chance when she gets it.
THE WITCHES COVEN NEED TO COME BACK!
But if ciera would play again I feel like she would be a vytas and go out early
Editsssyt do you think she would be voted out first twice?
Lily Frederiksen honestly. I think she would have a greater chance of getting voted out early than other players just because she is there to play and shes a bit unpredictable. she’s proved that both in blood v water and camodia
pretty sure wentworth is already coming back, but abi and kass back too would be good
2nd best women allaiance after the black widow brigade
You want me to speak llama to you? Tony’s a beast
My h vs v picks are Heroes: Dawn, Adam, Zeke, Tasha, woo, Fabio, Keith, Tai, Janet, and Wendell. Villains: Rick devons, Kelley Wentworth, Brandon Hantz, Sarah, Kass, Spencer, Tony, Natalie, Ben, And Tommy
Malcolm is the best, I hope he comes back.
I would love to see this video remade after WaW!
Still waiting for any excuse to bring back Russell! He changed the game forever...
Wouldn’t it be cool if it was 4 tribes of 5 the hero men, the hero women, the villain men, villain women
CGP travels that would be a bit too much to keep up with, and also to fit in the episode
CGP travels no one would expect that it would be a shocking twist
Preston Oliver yes but a shitty twist
They have done 4 tribes before and it was honestly an amazing season. #racewars
Dominic Deluca don’t forget about Panama that was a pretty decent season too
Heroes:
-men:
Malcolm (Philippines)
Spencer (Cagayan)
Eddy (Fans vs Favorites 2)
Fabio (Nicaragua)
Yau Man (Fiji) *YES I KNOW THIS WAS BEFORE 20 SO IT'S AN EXCEPTION*
-women:
Brenda (Nicaragua)
Chelsea (One World)
Kat (One World)
Jeffra (Cagayan)
Denise (Philippines)
Villains:
-men:
Cochran (South Pacific)
Phillip (Redemption Island)
Colton (One World)
Tony (Cagayan)
Stephen (Tocantins) *YES I KNOW THIS WAS BEFORE 20 SO IT'S AN EXCEPTION*
-women:
Abi-Marie (Philippines)
NaOnka (Nicaragua)
Andrea (Redemption Island)
Sherri (Fans vs Favorites 2)
Sarah (Cagayan)
Tell me your thoughts on my list!
A little confused as to why Brenda and Kat are on the heroes tribe
@@temporal4652 well Brenda is very much a hero but Kat is a wild card like Peridiam mentioned
Man, hopefully Malcolm will comeback and win it or atleast make it to the final 3.
MY DREAM CAST
Heroes:
1. Keith (Blood Vs. Water 2/Second Chances)
2. Malcolm (Philippines/Caramoan/Game Changers)
3. Wendell (Ghost Island)
4. Michael (Ghost Island)
5. Christian (David Vs. Goliath)
6. Gabby (David Vs. Goliath)
7. Michaela (Millennials Vs. Gen X/Game Changers)
8. Jaclyn (Blood Vs Water 2)
9. Aubrey (Koah Rong/Game Changers)
10. Shirin (Worlds Apart/Second Chances)
Villains
1. Tony (Cagayan/Game Changers)
2. Dom (Ghost Island)
3. Phillip Sheppard (Redemption Island/Caramoan)
4. Rodney (Worlds Apart)
5. Jay (Millenials Vs. Gen X)
6. Abi Maria (Philippines/Second Chances)
7. Chrissy (Heroes Vs. Healers Vs. Hustlers)
8. Natalie (Blood Vs. Water 2)
9. Missy (Blood Vs. Water 2)
10. Angelina (David Vs. Goliath)
HONORABLE MENTIONS:
Heroes:
1. Adam (Millennials Vs. Gen X)
2. Jeremy (Blood Vs. Water 2/Second Chances)
3. Zeke (Millennials Vs. Gen X)
4. Kelley Wentworth (Blood Vs. Water 2/Second Chances)
5. Hannah (Millennials Vs. Gen X)
6. Denise (Philippines)
7. Reynold (Caramoan)
8. Keith (Blood Vs. Water 2/Second Chances)
9. Jenn (Worlds Apart)
10. Tai (Kaoh Rong/Game Changers)
Villains:
1. Joe (Heroes Vs. Healers Vs. Hustlers)
2. Shamar (Caramoan)
3. Figgy (Millennials Vs. Gen X)
4. Francesca (Redemption Island/Caramoan)
5. Peter (Brains Vs. Brain Vs. Beauty 2)
6. Dan (Worlds Apart)
7. Natalie (David Vs. Goliath)
8. Kass (Cagayan/Second Chances)
How's figgy a villain?
stevenrobinsonmovies I saw Gabby I threw this list in the trash can
@@owennicholson8914 I actually put Gabby on the list before she became annoying on this current season. I was rooting for her and Christian very early on and thought she'd be an interesting person to see on a cutthroat theme like Heroes Vs. Villains. I still stand with keeping her on the list because despite her being annoying, to see her around BIG personalities like Tony & Dom will be interesting especially since she was barley able to handle Carl imagine her being around this cast.
If that was an actual season I would refuse to watch it.
How is mikayla a hero and dom a villain
I'm so damn happy you said Keith Nale. I would love to see him again on Survivor.
My list:
Heroes:
Adam Klein (33) (1/20)
David Wright (33, 38) (4/20, TBA/20)
Denise Stapley (25) (1/18)
Hali Ford (30, 34) (11/18, 13/20)
Holly Hoffman (21) (4/20)
Joe Anglim (30, 31, 38) (10/18, 8/20, TBA/20)
Kelley Wentworth (29, 31, 38) (14/18, 4/20, TBA/20)
Lauren Rimmer (35) (7/18)
Malcolm Freberg (25, 26, 34) (4/18, 9/20, 17/20)
Michael Yerger (36) (9/20)
Villains:
Chris Noble (36) (13/20)
Debbie Wanner (32, 34) (9/18, 11/20)
Domenick Abbate (36) (2/20)
Kass McQuillen (28, 31) (3/18, 13/20)
Marty Piombo (21) (11/20)
Morgan McLeod (28) (10/18)
Natalie Anderson (29) (1/18)
Natalie Cole (27) (TBA/20)
Tai Trang (32, 34) (3/18, 4/20)
Tony Vlachos (28, 34) (1/18) (19/20)
re: "(TBA/20)", word on the street is that Season 38 is actually going to be 18 people rather than 20.
Tai isn’t a villain
Captain Wesley Remember Scot? Remember Caleb? He’s made a lot of gutsy and kind of mischievous moves, I personally consider him a villain
Who is Natalie Cole?
Morgan yesssss
The shot at 9:48 was filmed on the Edge of Extinction. I know that this challenge (family visit in HHH) and the pole immunity challenge in GC that Tai won were both filmed there pre-EOE. It's really interesting to see how they use the same beaches for challenges, twists, and camps across seasons.
Malcolm(Philippines) - 4th Place
Malcolm(Caramoan) - 4th Juror
Malcolm(Game Changers) - 4th Voted Out
Abi-Maria(Philippines) - 7th Juror
Abi-Maria(Cambodia) - 7th Juror
Michaela(MvG) - 7th Voted Out
Michaela(Game Changers) - 7th Juror
Idk who had the same number of Place,Juror and Voted Out.
So that is all
Thank you
Who’s your favorite on David vs Goliath so far
Christian!
Nick
After 3 episodes: Christian
Gabby, Elizabeth and Lyrsa for me
Definitely Christan it's super rare to find someone nerdier then me but I found one
Heroes
Michael 36, Terry 12, 31, Malcolm 25, 26, 34, Tai 32, 34, Mike 30, Laurel 36, Natalie 29, Jessica 33, Andrea 21, 26, 34
Villains
Jason 32, Tony 28, 34, Phillip 22, 26, Domenick 36, Rodney 30, Abi-Maria 25, 31, Sarah 28, 34, Debbie 32, 34, Chrissy 35, Eliza 9, 16
4 winners, 1 male hero, 1 female hero, 1 male villain, 1 female villain. Original HvV had winners and this would spread it out with 4 winners instead of just 1 or 2 where they could maybe be easy targets.
Spread out the seasons somewhat. No original HvV players. Mostly newer players as that's most likely more realistic as to what CBS would do. But a couple of older seasons players. Eliza is still young enough and Terry did play a 2nd time in 2nd chances.
Had Aubrey, Wentworth, Joe and David in my older list, but since they're back in 38, I took them out.
There's usually a pretty thin line between a hero and villain, so you could argue a few could be either tribe, but you could do that with some on the original HvV as well.
No one from Ghost Island deserves to play again.
@@camilamancilla7143 Well Wendell already did and um...Domenick, clearly he deserves to.
@@spfan68 Domenick sucked. Very unlikeable just like the entire Ghost Island cast.
@@camilamancilla7143 Incorrect. Domenick is gonna play again 100%
2019: Rick Devens. Period.
On 1000
yeah as a villain maybe lol
rick devons and Christian oh my..
Wow peridiam predicting three out of four returnees from edge of extinction
My boot order-
20th- Jaclyn
19th- Jessica
18th- Rodney
17th- Denise
16th- Kyle
15th- Abi-Maria
14th- Mike
13th- Chrissy Hofbeck
Merge
12th- Sabrina
11th- Domenick
10th- Jay
9th- Kass
8th- Aubry
7th- Keith
6th- Kelley
5th- Tai
4th- Tony
3rd- Natalie - 2 votes
2nd- Malcom - 3 votes
1st- Michael- 4 votes
rip Keith
Peridium: Malcom, Tai, Keith, Michael,
Me: I swear if its not joe....
Peridium: Mike
Me: Hold my torch ;(
Ok I was waiting for him to say joe not kieth
Honestly, Reed from SJDS would be a cool villain as well.
Watching this in 2020 is awesome and hilarious knowing that most of these players have been back in the last three seasons
My ideal cast:
Heroes:
Wendall (Ghost Island)
Michael (Ghost Island)
Keith (Game Changers)
Malcolm (Philippines)
Dr. Mike (HvHvH)
Trish (Cagayan)
Kelly Wentworth (Cambodia)
Denise (Philippines)
Aubrey (Cambodia)
(Wild Card Slot) Roark (HvHvH)
Villains:
Dom (Ghost Island)
Tony (Cagayan)
Devon (HvHvH)
Joe (HvHvH)
(Wild Card Slot) Bradley (Ghost Island)
Kass (Cagayan)
Christie (HvHvH)
Abi-Maria (Philippines)
Natalie (Ghost Island)
Jessica (HvHvH)
Dr. Mike Zahalsky and Alison!
Hey peridiam, if Russell Hantz was on a season and the other people on his tribe got a 15 minute head start for each idol, how many do you think he would find
He would still find a lot because most of the cast would get tired and thirsty and then stop after 30 min. Russel and Tony found so many idols because they looked for them all of the time. It looks easy on tv but they usually spend all day looking for 1 idol.
David and Mike Holloway I feel have a better pull than Michael and Mike Z. Maybe replace Jessica with Sophie. Otherwise, I love this list and I'm glad you remember Rodney and Jay.
I think Holloway definitely does but since David is going to be on season 38 that seems less likely.
If David has a similar performance then I think he'd be even more likely
There's also too many HvHvH people in his season. Mike, Michael, Jessica, and Chrissy? They aren't all gonna make it
@@frostyaces4103 Michael's from ghost island
Abi Maria is a villain, for sure, but not one you want to watch. She’s literally the worst
Yes
PREACH
I personally enjoy watching Abi
this is what brantsteele did with this cast
Episode 1:
Reward: Heroes Tribe
Immunity: Heroes Tribe
Voted Out: Chrissy (6-4 vote)
Episode 2:
Immunity: Villains Tribe
Voted Out: Michael (6-3*-1 vote)
Episode 3:
Immunity: Heroes Tribe
Voted Out: Tony (5-4 vote)
Episode 4:
Reward: Heroes Tribe
Immunity: Heroes Tribe
Voted Out: Domenick (5-3 vote)
Episode 5:
Reward: Villains Tribe
Immunity: Villains Tribe
Voted Out: Sabrina (4-3-2* vote)
Episode 6:
Immunity: Jaclyn and Abi
Reward: Villains Tribe
Voted Out: Natalie (5-2 vote)
Voted Out: Tai (4-4 vote), (4-2 revote)
Episode 7:
Reward: Villains Tribe
Immunity: Villains Tribe
Voted Out: Malcolm (4-3 vote)
Episode 8:
Reward: Heroes Tribe
Immunity: Villains Tribe
Voted Out: Keith (3-3 vote), (3-1 revote)
Episode 9:
Reward: Heroes Tribe
Immunity: Villains Tribe
Voted Out: Jessica (3-3 vote), (3-1 revote)
Episode 10:
Tribes Merge
Immunity: Jay
Voted Out: Abi (5*-5 vote)
Episode 11:
Reward: Jaclyn, Rodney, Mike
Immunity: Jason
Voted Out: Kass (5-4 vote)
Episode 12, Part 1:
Immunity: Denise
Voted Out: Jaclyn (6-2 vote)
Episode 12, Part 2:
Immunity: Mike
Voted Out: Denise (3-2*-2 vote)
Episode 13:
Reward: Aubry
Immunity: Rodney
Voted Out: Aubry (4-2 vote)
Finale, Part 1:
Immunity: Jay
Voted Out: Kelley (3*-1-1 vote), (2-1 revote)
Finale, Part 2:
Immunity: Mike
Voted Out: Jason (2-2 vote), (1-1 revote)
, (Tie Challenge)
Reunion:
Finalists: Jay, Mike, and Rodney
Winner: Mike (5-3-1)
Favorite: Aubry
That clip of jay and michaela gives me chills every time. So risky and so boldly said. Jay is my all time favorite
YES KEITH! He is my favorite player of all time! (2nd is woo)
If they don’t just do post HvV I would hope to see Kelly Goldsmith or T-bird return
T-bird NEEDS a return!!
Fucking Yes to T-Bird. My god she’s been gone way way way to long.
NATALIE BOLTON
My favorite castaways of all time are Malcom, Wu, and Jeremy
Cydney from kaoh rong would be amazing for the heroes
A lot of duels between contestants of both tribes
Aubry vs Jason
Jaclyn vs Natalie
Michael vs Domenick
Denise vs Abi-Maria
I feel like DvG means this list has to shift completely
Eden Dorra agreed. Bring back Alison as a hero and Angelina as a villain or Natalie Cole!
only to include Christian
How about a cast for bb all stars 2 though
How about heroes vs villains 2 instead
I think He might do bball-star next year, but not now, sense were in the survivor season, probably in june or july
He might do it when Celebrity big brother 2 starts
We need a top 5 saltiest votes
cookie
All stars lol
All stars and Samoa
This villains tribe is absolutely stacked even if you replace Tony with someone else now
Chrissie, Kass, Abi, Natalie and Jessica.... MAN, I LOVE YOU. CBS MAKE IT HAPPEN
Kelly wentworth is a villain way way more then a hero
Now she is.
Wentworth is my hero. It’s all perspective really. Boston rob is a hero to Amber and agent shepherd.
Yup she was the leader of the witches coven
she's a hero because she played a very underdog game and a lot people were rooting for her to win
Maddy Dimakos that doesn’t make her a hero. that just means the fans like her
When you started on the male Heroes list, i was all like woo, the next one will be woo and it never happended
so sad :((
Few seasons since this. Might need an update, christian, devens. Hard to have Tony a villian now. Kind of turned it around after WoW
Might need to revise this with a number of DvG members. Christian, Davie, John, and Nick I could see being on the Heroes, and definitely Angelina and possibly Mike on the Villains.
If this is the cast, I would definitely rooting for Aubry, Natalie and Michael!!! Tasha would be a great addition too.