Walberg Stunned By Columbia Pres's Response To Professor Who Made 'Perverse' Statement After Oct. 7
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 17 เม.ย. 2024
- At today's House Education Committee hearing, Rep. Tim Walberg (R-MI) grilled Columbia University President Minouche Shafik about a professor who celebrated the Oct. 7 attack on Israel by Hamas.
Fuel your success with Forbes. Gain unlimited access to premium journalism, including breaking news, groundbreaking in-depth reported stories, daily digests and more. Plus, members get a front-row seat at members-only events with leading thinkers and doers, access to premium video that can help you get ahead, an ad-light experience, early access to select products including NFT drops and more:
account.forbes.com/membership...
Stay Connected
Forbes on Facebook: forbes
Forbes Video on Twitter: / forbes
Forbes Video on Instagram: / forbes
More From Forbes: forbes.com
Fire her. This woman is totally unsuitable.
It's a phenomena. Not a persona.
This woman is a huge disgrace.
Fire DC. The whole world is getting disgusted wth US Hypocrisy.
Agree!!!
YOUR tenured professor. What punishment has he received.
This is absolutely unacceptable. This guys been here for 20 years pounding this propaganda into peoples heads.
You mean the AIPAC lobby?
Professor Massad should meet the Mossad.
Great reply!!!
This!!!
That's a good one Marv.
They make great alarm clocks.
😂🤣👍
Just like UPenn and Harvard, this woman MUST GO!!!
👍👍👍👍
Agree 100%!
Yes
Walberg is an APAC Zombie, he wants to nuke Gaza, Shameless
Agree but the same board of trustees that hired her will only hire another person just like her.
The entire faculty is just like Prof Massad…
What exactly is happening in the US ??? How is this shit allowed ??
Democrats
The underlying philosophy responsible for this insanity is post-modernism. It is anti-Enlightenment. Objective truth, a belief in a Real world, Reason, Logic, evidence, science, capitalism, private ownership of property, Big-L Liberalism (not to be confused with the political party), all the freedoms and Rights we enjoy in the West, etc., are all Enlightenment values. There are some good videos on Post-Modernism by Stephen Hicks. Please educate yourselves so that we can bring back Enlightenment values to our schools.
This called people start to wake up, and realize that Zion control their country, and their government. They realized that Americans are brainwashed
@@rafeone9808 Constitution.
LOL...do you really believe this is just a US problem?
Have we learned nothing from 9/11/01 WAKE UP AMERICA!!!!!!
I don't think the western world has learnt anything from the terrorist attacks that have been brought upon us because we are still importing the people who hate our countries and want to kill us.
That’s shit was faked by the government
I've learned not to believe a damn thing America's Zionists and Neocons say. What are you saying, exactly? That this ongoing religious war has been legit all along? For 40 years or so?
That is the most confusing thing here. It's like it was completely forgotten
Staged by the government!!!!!
Shame on Colombia university
Not only to Colombia but all universities doing this protest is shame
Shame on Americans for tolerating
This president either have no idea what is going on at her university or she is lying
Probably lies!!!!
Or you have no clue
They lie
She is not just lying she is of the same mind.
Her last name gives her away period
They ALL need to be sacked.
Agreed, the politicians need to go.
@@matthewlueder2656 you need treatment, counseling treatment
Here Columbia is wrong to promote any biased prejudiced environment against anyone is wrong
If you were talking about congress, I'd agree.
including pro israeli donors
Also deported!!
The senetor is absolutely right. The Columbia Professor who commented such should be deported and the Columbia University representative should be sacked.
So....what happened to his first amendment right? Yall are such hypocrites!
“He has been spoken to.” Now, there’s a real slap on the wrist!
😂
lol
Slap on the wrist ? More a tap on the wrist !
Prof Masad needs to removed from Columbia U and the Columbia U President needs to follow him out the door.
I would like to see hundreds of parents show up with UHauls!!! Bye Bye $$$$$$$$
Better to prove him wrong than to fire him. If he is wrong, prove it, and if he is correct, learn from him. That's really the only effective way to confront objectionable speech. Being objectionable does not make the speech wrong, being wrong makes the speech wrong. So prove the speech tobe wrong and vanquish it once and for all. And if the speech is correct, then why silence it? It is then objectionable because it points out peoples' flaws. Fix the flaws if the speech is correct, don't silence the speech.
She is scared to remove the professor
@@atsusa The last time Columbia used tyranical tactics to break up student protests was when they called in New York City police to quell campus protests was in 1968, when students had taken over the campus and some buildings as part of the anti-war protests that raged on college campuses in that election year. The result was that something like half of Columbia's faculty departed soon thereafter for other schools in large part due to the university's violation of the principle of academic freedom. Its how UCal Berkley became known as the "Columbia University of the West".
Shafik is trying to avoid a similar outcome this time.
Amen!
We have lost our country if the people don't wake and stop these traitors.
The real traitors are the AIPAC sell out politicians.
Vote for Trump, sleepy Joe will destroy América
She is scared to remove that professor. I am so disappointed and feels so sorry for Jewish students. This is new America.
How about the genocide in Gaza they are civilians too
@@AhlamSoliman-jw2dq Sorry you support people who are losing the war they started....and has NOTHING to do with this hearing
@@vladt876 75 years of occupation let them go back from the where come from
@@AhlamSoliman-jw2dq There was no "occupation" in Gaza since 2005, the Palestinians can blame Hamas who uses them as human shield after they committed murderous massacre against the Israeli people on October 7th.
@@AhlamSoliman-jw2dq
1.civilians to hamas terrorist kill rate is near 1:1 or 1:2, what genocide are you talking about ? lowest civilians death rate in modern history. You simply distribute hamas propoganda.
2. 2005 Israel left Gaza completely - what occupation are you talking about ? perhaps from the river to the see type ? Then you simply call for genocide in Israel .. aren't you ?
This woman must GO!!!
Prof Masad needs to be stripped off of his U.S. citizen and send him to Gaza.
Now wait, you mean the president of Colombia uni is masad from gaza and sadfik is a professional proffessor from Egypt both of them Muslims 😮😮😮😮, is something pulling my leg, you mean you gave up your children to those kinds of leaders to teach them, now you're reaping the fruits of their labour, how could you 😮😮😮😢😢😢
Exactly
Yeah cos that's how we deal with 'free speech' in good old USA.
@@yvonnemccalla7282Well if he just had his opinion and that was it, sure. He's free to have it to himself. He's free to talk to others about it, so long as it is in a personal or public setting.
The instant he is in a position of power and I fluence over others and their careers, and he essentially stifles any opinion other then his own? Nope. That's when you get a warning, and if you can't calm down, maybe you should get the boot.
US IS THE LAND OF IMMIGRANTS. EVERYONE IS EQUAL
Congressman, I spoke to him... What a joke. She must be fired.
Get shafik out of there. Have her resign and get her on a one way trip to gaza
not one day but forever
Why you all pro isreali ???!!!
@@ALIKN1-1 we're on the truth side!
@@mariesy7130 if killing innocents is truth the devil is what you follow
@@ALIKN1-1 you're out of the topic we're talking about Shafik. She's lying
SPOKEN TO? WTF?
Did she ever get to finish?
She didn’t have to finish. Even when she “elaborated” she had nothing to say that of any importance
Word salad
Yeah, they had a good laugh about it. She's part of the problem, not part of
the solution.
She spoke to him, with encouragement to continue.
I can not believe how anybody would want to graduate on Columbia State University
Every parent should pull their students from this morally corrupt school.
I seriously doubt you're one to speak on "morals."
he’s been spoken to.. holy cow..
Stop making fun of Hindis.
@@mrbaab5932 how is that even a mockery? stop behaving like those hooligans who find everything blasphemous.
Thank you Rep.Walberg. Your questioning was powerful and demonstrated the institutional anti-semitism at Columbia.
'spoken to' - wow, that is a very severe punishment. What comes next?
A stern letter next
@@alfavulcan4518 With the proper pronouns I hope.
@@guymandudely324😂😂😂
Next, he would be sent to the naughty corner
I wonder what exactly was said to him?
She proves a point you can't educate out stupid from anybody
The most terrifying is that he is still teaching in the classroom. What kind of university allows praising genocidal acts and stays as if nothing has happened?
One where the head is called ‘Shafiq’!!
9.11
These people have to go! They have NOTHING to teach kids.
How to be terrorists
YOU CALL Terrorism Humanity! SMH. @AshrafKhan-sd7sf
@AshrafKhan-sd7sf That's not what they're teaching ,,AT ALL .
@AshrafKhan-sd7sf You wouldn't know what humanity was if your life depended on it.
If Americans stood up against this that professor would be fired. Is all they will do is complain on social media while their country is being destroyed. It is sad
Who employs these women at US Universities . Shocking
Affirmative Action
exactly DEI
The Woke Community, it's not about how able you are to do the job, it's about how woke you are!!!! Hammas and Woke, a toxic cocktail!!!!
AIPAC did
I am a woman. But I completely agree with you.
Sickening
The sniveling cowardice in academia is nauseating.
uffff that is just terrible, sad, and low., she says "spoken to" like he is a 3 years old
IF YOUR PAYING FOR THIS COLLEGE PROFESSOR TO TEACH MY KIDS I WOULD SUE❗🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
Defund these colleges which is Citizen's Taxpayers monies. They have plenty of monies and donors!!!
We can fix this do not hire anyone graduating from Columbia University.
That's the American way with free speech. Total hypocrites.
The student can leave?
They are the ones who paid to be there
I doubt they would get their money back. Also, that would teach that it's ok for someone to terrorize someone else and the victim just "needs to leave"
No the American people pay isn't biden trying to wipe out all student debt ?
To what end? Should universities become Jewish free?
The president of the University stated that the Jewish students don't need to attend class if they don't feel safe.
But, they paid to be there.
@@Melissa-xz8ss Obvs not knowing what orgs/jobs you are involved with, what would be your opinion if your gym, or place of work, or community pool club or whatever started to preach that women were “xyz bad thing”, and just told you that you can leave those places? Simply put: is it reasonable for a community to engage in aggressive/violent rhetoric against members of that community with the expectation that they could just leave and go find another? How about if your entire neighborhood starts to shame you for being a progressive woman and working a job until you either quit your job to comply with their beliefs or move to a new town? If you’re cool with those things, then kudos, but most people do not think thats the kind of place we want to build as a nation.
Get your school under control woman
some people are simply not capable of doing what is necessary and what is right in leadership positions. She is one of them
What's out of control?
From her point of view all is just as it should be.
Amusing comment - where are the gop get your act together calls ?
No not her someone else, let her be history together with illhan
Unbelievable! Fire him now
If this ding dong President can't stand up to hate, then step down and let someone on board who can.
These are the same people that won't let conservatives speak on campus because someone might get offended
Bye bye professor Massad , you won't be missed😃
How can he be missed? He is a rotten apple.
😂 that guy should probably be under psychiatric watch 24/7, not teaching at colombia. 😂😂
Rep. Walberg, you are awesome Sir.
Respect for Rep. Walberg for speaking up on this absolutely terrible example of how students are being brainwashed today, not just in the US, but in many European Universities as well. Hamas committed an act of unprecedented and vile terrorism and must be held to account.
Better late than never 😅
She is Arabic born in Egypt in 1962
So??!!
@@maghrebi_wa_bidalaelso she should know the history of the MB and minorities in her home country.
@@MsBhappy what's MB?
@@msinbalonyMuslim Brotherhood
Which is why she isn't doing anything
That professor needs fired today now and deported if possible and why hasn’t the FBI gotten a file on him
Remove him now not one more day shall he remain on this campus
America did not wake up. It WOKE up.
what a snake pit!
Don’t insult snakes 😂
@@hol5593😂😂
@@hol5593feel same for cows🥲
Talking to??? A talking to???? He needs to be fired immediately and sent packing, to NEVER teach in another school at ANY level!!! Shameful!!! And shame on you madam president!!
she is no better, just look at her face....it is said all , most of the liberal professors should be fired , but this university got most of the money from all those countries who hate America..
Why can't all of these women university presidents answer simple questions or condemn vile conduct?
Because their ideology supports rad1calism. Its a mistake to think this lot can ever become democratic.
because they support it and have been bought by quatary iranian money
Colombia University is a recruiting arm of hamas
All you have to do is look at who sends money to the schools.
Qatar...
@@charlesayache6801Qatar give $ and house Hamas leaders.
End the funding!
And parents are paying for this kind of garbage.
We made sure that he did timeout for 30 minutes and we spoke to him that no you didn’t let me finish. Yeah, we spoke to him.
Hence, the muslim question
All I can say is I’m SO PROUD of my daughter for saying NO to Columbia, and every other Ivy League school when she was accepted ! She is now a TOP orthopaedic Surgeon, specializing in sports medicine without a degree from any of these indoctrination schools!!! Question is do you want a doctor that cares about humanity or NOT????? University should be teaching talents, education, NOT INDOCTRINATION of other Countries AGENDAS!!!!!!!
💯💯💯👋👋👋👋
Bravo to you as well! You raised her well🙏🏽
Very well done.🎉💯💪👏
She should resign.
I am glad that this is being brought to light rather than brushed under the carpet.
wow she really went out on a limb and said i condemn his statements and he's been given a talking too 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Deport
He should be out of the country
Fire that professor!!!
Such callous intolerance and blatant hypocrisy! Where is the outrage by this president and these trustees?
Imagine if these deplorable words and actions were directed at black students?
Why would any parents pay money to send their kids there? Amazing!
The professor must be sent to Iran
Fired expelled and in jail for hate speech !!
That Professor and the many others like him at Columbia should be stripped of tenure and booted off campus. Perhaps even out of America
for holding a different opinion .. wait till they come for you for your opinion then don’t cry when your silenced
@@nirmalsandhu5256Yes a opinion that is completely intolerable to coexist peacefully with other differing opinions should be eradicated and silenced. Big difference of having an opinion and peacefully disagreeing with another and still being able to coexist. Versus downright having an opinion with the hopes the it enacts violence on anyone with a different opinion.
@@nirmalsandhu5256Plenty of documented Palestinians that work and peacefully coexist within Israel.
God this woman should be sacked immediately what a disgrace!!
"He's been spoken to". I like his style after that, how he successfully and constantly interrupts her anytime she starts an attempt at gaslighting, until he forces her to answer his questions. Her answers demonstrate she's not up to the task.
Tenure is the protection of terrible people in important positions
I learned something i ever won't forget probably, thankyou!
Shafiq is a disgrace. Sack her & punish her for what the Jewish students have had to go through under her Presidency
Why can this be happening in America???
This woman and the racist Prof. MUST GO!!
He has been spoken to ,that's savage ,he'll not sleep at nights.!!!!
Why does he still have a job in America
Professor Massad should be fired and not allowed to teach students hate and intolerance. Hell with his tenure . He shouldn't be teaching anyone!!!!.
It's like watching a movie about the events leading up to Germany ww2!
Yes Germany began to occupy Europe and committed atrocities and genocide. The Israelis occupied Palestine in 1948 and slowly occupy more land till this day and commiting atrocities and genocide.
We can imagine what kind of nonsense he is teaching over several years
Anti Semitic dialogue should be condemned and the perpetrators of these outrageous statements should be brought before a court.
aren't the rights of these students being violated by the so-called professors? it seems to me that the best way is for the students and their parents to file civil suits against them fore each and every case. (in addition to having the US DOJ investigate them for civil rights violations)
Traitor
Traitor, if he is a citizen of Israel and not USA.
@mrbaab5932 I dont know. Haven't though about that. I'm 68 Veteran Christian I've been taught to love God's children.
Also a patriot that loves America.
With what I see , if we the people allow the people don't put Trump in office we're screwed.
@@howtolivewithapacemakerWhat are you talking? You still make a counterargument about what did it say the person up there
@jostinbastias3449 only thing I've figured out we can't talk.
Haven't watched the video over again . We have so many traitors weak sheep. Straight out communist.
I can see why war is coming. God bless you.
"He's been Spoken to..." 😂😂 She whispered sweet nothings into his ears? Disgraceful!
What's he doing? Why is this brought up now. If he's been doing this for sometime why has anybody condemn him then. This is bullshit. Congress should also be held accountable.
I think they're smarter than you and me, i will leave it at that
Terrible
We pray these professors who support hate speech, be given their notices, never to come back to Columbia's university
Well said Congressman Walberg. Excellent! This panel is disgraceful.
free speech in colombia: "you are free to speak as long as its my opinion you are parroting"
thank you professor masaad for showing us the true face of this establishment :)
Weren’t they already celebrating 9/11?? Really?? Wake up
it truly is insane that these monsters teach kids in the city of 9/11
Shame on her. Congress should make sure she is gone
I love when the caption a couple of times referred to this "professor" last name as "MAD." HE IS indeed MAD. shame on you Columbia U.
Shafik is a strict muslim and under her watch anti semetism, American hate and promoting hamas has thrived. Which American company would employ Columbia students?
7th century troglodytes should be in 7th century TroglodyteStan teaching other troglodytes.
I have never been more proud of congress than I am today!!! It is emotional
As a Jew finally seeing our elected leaders doing what is necessary to expose this double standard and hypocrisy.
Aaaaaand She Still won’t answer the question forthrightly.
The fact that he has been saying this for many years, not only. Shafiq all other presidents should be questioned as well.
Does free speech include criticizing the flaws in Quran and Hadiths ? Why was Salman Rushdie attacked for his book "The Satanic Verses"? Why do only people from one faith allowed to ridicule other religions, how is this freedom ? This is just one group bullying the whole world just because we dont agree with the teachings of their prophet. Secular Talk can you criticize the verses in Quran which specifically states that a husband can legally beat his wife even if he has a doubt that she is being unfaithful, or any person who does not belong to their faith either needs to be converted or has to pay a tax for not being of their religion or killed if he does not pay tax. For the LGBTQ community think twice before supporting Hamas, you will brutally murdered, there is no forgiveness just death penalty. I agree with freedom of speech but it should both ways. Don't you think if Hamas releases the hostages then this war would be over. Isn't it Israel's right to protect their people ? Hamas attack on Oct 7th, ruthlessly killing infants, men women, rap*ing , stripping them naked beating them. In fact people of Palestine were celebrating rejoicing the attacks. People of Palestine are supporting a terrorist organization and now when Israel is retaliating it's still Israel fault.
If all Americans or Europeans saw what Hamas did on October 7th, they would join the IDF.
Unfortunately a lot of them have seen what they did, and they support it.
@@michal131187 How do you know?
@@user-sp1md5xu8j how do I know that they support Hamas? Listen to what they say.
If Americans or Europeans see what the Israelis did before and after Oct 7 on the Palestinians , they would condemn the IDF , unless they are a supporter of racist apartheid israeli state.
If they saw what the IDF does on a daily basis, they would join Hamas.
File a court case and revoke her license to teach. Look what she did.
It is very painful to observe the un-esteemed President's waffle with each answer that should be straightforward. I guess she is constrained by the oil money countries donations to Columbia and other US universities.
I don't understand why people are so upset. I mean he got SPOKEN TO people!