Transgender Rights: Last Week Tonight with John Oliver (HBO)
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 28 ธ.ค. 2024
- This week’s gay rights victory was historic, but the transgender community still faces staggering challenges. John Oliver focuses on the “T” in “LGBT."
Connect with Last Week Tonight online...
Subscribe to the Last Week Tonight TH-cam channel for more almost news as it almost happens: / lastweektonight
Find Last Week Tonight on Facebook like your mom would:
/ lastweektonight
Follow us on Twitter for news about jokes and jokes about news:
/ lastweektonight
Visit our official site for all that other stuff at once:
www.hbo.com/las...
“Isn’t that just a woman? I can’t even keep up anymore!”
He’s a little confused but he’s got the spirit
I thought the same thing. Him saying: „Isn‘t that just a woman?“ was actually really progressive and J.O. should have pointed it out.
He's trying his best and I'm glad for it
If I had to guess John Oliver may have been responding more to the tone of the question, but idk. But I agree his statement was actually kind of enlightened
Well yeah it isn't a hard concept to grasp. A gender changed to another gender, therefore they are now that gender.
I speak only for myself, but as a transgender person, I want to give that weatherman a hug.
10:50 It's really frightening that every time republicans discuss gender/sexual minorities they make it about how they would sexually harass or assault women openly if they were able to be protected by the law
The P in GOP stands for projection.
Sara Grace women can assault women. Men can assault men. I think that the only way to solve this problem is to knock down all public loos. Replace hem with porta potties
Also statistically trans folk are more likely to experience assault than cis folk
jeez, nothing politically partisan about THAT generalization..... professional victimhood makes it so easy
That's because it's a easy way to sexually assault somebody. Look we're trying to minimise the amount of sexual assaults and you fuckers are here leaving the fucking door open.
i’m a trans guy, and watching this cis male (john oliver) defend, protect and understand us is so empowering. i’m tearing up writing this, it’s genuinely so refreshing and gives me some hope
Charming Person Emotions DONT define gender. That’s the furthest from it. Men can be emotional and Women don’t have to be very emotional. Not all Trans Women are aggressive, in fact little of them are, and same can go for Trans Men.
@@charmingperson5280 I think you may want to choose a different username, yours isn't very accurately descriptive.
Charming Person i honestly do not care if you view me as a woman because i know what i am. it’s sad that you feel such hate and are so ignorant to something so harmless and has extensive scientific research backing it up. i also have a question for you! if you’re so transphobic when why are you watching this video? sounds a bit counter productive to me :)
@@blu2759 Nonbinary trans man here to say I'm proud of you and wish you so much happiness :)
@@charmingperson5280 I was born whit a penis in my pants, yet little things can make me cry for hours. How do you explain that?
"He's a teenage boy trying to take a shit in the men's room" was pretty funny but also possibly one of the most humanizing things he could have said.
She's a woman that wants access to men's only facilities it's wrong
Yup. And now he's gone. Bullied out of existence for wanting basic human things like that
“Just say woman” that weather man is an ally and he doesn’t even know it.
He may not understand but he got the right spirit.
Yeah, but I think the headline was actually about them being transgender (I think).
To be completly fair, i actually mixed it up in the past to (so i thought trangender woman means, born as a woman but feel like a man)
not true though
Because if we started to just call them women that would lead to confusion about Transgender women in women's sport
@@idenree8606 wtf, call them trans women when talking about sports then. Where is the logic
As a trans female I actually love how the news anchor said "just call them women then". Because holy hot hell he just got it right there!
@SpongeBob SquarePants Cool story
@SpongeBob SquarePants Maybe, especially if we stick to a low energy guy like Biden.
@SpongeBob SquarePants Cool story.
@SpongeBob SquarePants I mean you can google the difference between sex and gender but whatever.
@SpongeBob SquarePants Lol your mom doesn’t produce eggs because she went through menopause.
Your. Mom. Is. A. Man.
It’s that easy.
"When I was in Vietnam
I got a medal for killing two men
And a discharge for loving one."
Epitaph of Leonard Matlovich.
Made about as much sense as the military trans ban now.
I am all for it. Lets turn fearsome and mighty US army into snowflake freakshow.
@@SirCap15 please tell me ur joking
@@SirCap15 I have one question are you a Soviet spy
NaiveCynic that’s insane hope we keep moving forward on this issue
Being gay is so different from being trans
R.I.P. Henry Bruce, the teenager who gave that speech. Took his own life two days ago because of "difficulty finding acceptance"
NOOO
It’s absolutely heartbreaking. I remember seeing him on the show, but didn’t connect the dots that this was the same Henry until today.
Man that's horrible, we need less discrimination against trans people in our society:(
This is so heartbreaking and inexcusable. Some people are so afraid of things they don't understand and don't want to understand. Instead they'd rather just pass their own ignorance and fear to the Children in their lives 😡
:(
A trans girl at my school was physically attacked by other students. She was given a week’s suspension alongside her attackers and she spoke about the incident so nonchalantly, as if it were a normal thing, as if it’s happened to everyone at some point. It’s heartbreaking.
Am snek 616 it sort of has happened to everyone at some point.
Unfortunately our schools are just garbage at handling bullying in general and that sort of experience is in no way unique to trans people.
That's upsetting
@Tsar Nicholas II No, actually, they either suspend the attacked person to cause less drama in school for a bit or they do it because they want them to be safe at home, mentally resting. There's an underlying reason as to why they are suspended and it is usually because they want to make safe choices and most of the times it is to suspend everyone regardless to shut up both sides and all the discussions related to them.
The anti bullying system in schools are terrible
I have been in the bathroom with a trans woman. Do you want to know what she did? Well i dont know because she was in her own stall and i was minding my own damn business! She did wash her hand by the way.
thats a lie. Because transgender people have to use the bathroom designated to their birth. you shoulda called the cops
Maslax Ali Not everywhere, you have no idea where OP lives or where this interaction took place.
Robin Moreau That's surprising. I hardly ever see anyone washing their hands. 😁
@Maslax Ali No they don't. They use the bathroom of whatever they identify/pass as.
She's better than me because I'm a cis woman and sometimes i forget
"Isn't that just a woman" damn hes confused but hes also got the right spirit
yeah. It kind of shows how you need to be indoctrinated INTO being transphobic, not the other way round. People default to being accepting generally because it is literally no water off of a cis persons back that trans people exist.
Way to steal someone's comment.
@@bajablast2271 oh shit this comment is stolen?
Hang on lemme retract my like for the time being
@@bajablast2271 almost like there is was an obvious opportunity multiple people took because it was so obvious and if you're that insecure to scan through comments just to make snide remarks maybe that reflects something about you
@@sirpentss744 oof. You really shouldn't project so hard. It's a bad look.
Rest In Peace Henry, I’m so sorry that such hateful people in this world caused what happened. Fly high angel.
You can't blame other people for his suicide. This kind of propaganda has to end. I've been close to a lot of transgender people in my life, and work with transgender kids, and the mental illness they face is not because of a lack of acceptance but because they're on this track to supposedly get some whole new identity and body which never arrives. Transitioning is basically a lie there is no way to medically give someone a different body. Period. Supporting people with genders for you needs to be re-examined so that they aren't sold this golden end result which never arrives.
@@theonlyjamiebourgeois9703 you aren't close to transgender people, fuck you. miss me with your faux sealion
I'm angered that Henry is no longer with us. I was watching another video that mentioned the death of a transman named Henry, and as soon as I saw that person's face, I recognized him. And I came back here to confirm it, and my heart sank. I am so angry that this country has embraced so easily a movement to harm some of its most vulnerable citizens. I am angry that Henry had been fighting for so long to get his rights and Identity protected. I am angry that there are so few options for trans people in red states, that the ghouls in charge are causing all this. But most of all, I am angry that a young man with so much potential is gone because of all this.
@@cherrycardoza405the death was a suicide???
@@cherrycardoza405 henry is burning in hell. That bitchass genuinely thought that kids should get surgery for a mental disease.
I don’t even know if he realizes how much this meant to the trans community, especially at the time this was aired. Even now it still holds up, he a cis man did an entire segment on why we, some one he didn’t need to care about deserved to be respected. And he articulated things in a manner that were respectful and understanding of the issues we face while still being witty and funny as always. And he was able to create one of the best quotes for the trans community that I still personally love today. He did an amazing job all around.
@@khanofkhans5750 Fucking *WHAT*
@@whawhawhawhaaaa I’m talking about bathrooms
@@khanofkhans5750 U know where the door is, get tf out
@@sunnydasheep Wow I can’t believe someone disagrees with you
@@khanofkhans5750 Odds are you have been in the w.c. at the same time as a trans person, and you never knew.
Yea, we have gender-neutral bathrooms all over the place in San Francisco. And here is a list of problems it's caused: none.
Only issue it's caused me is that for some reason places use this as an excuse to only have one bathroom! Like seriously no, just still have 2 bathrooms but make them both gender neutral how hard is that
Opinunate ted usually in England If you don’t feel comfortable in genders bathrooms you have to use he disabled bathrooms
@2manynegativewaves you can check out their crimes on transcrimeuk.com there are quite a few bathroom assaults actually (one near me involved a transwoman trying to get a 10 year old girl to take her pants off in a supermarket toilet, luckily the girl managed to fight him off). It is causing issues for women and girls, many girls are now staying away from school because they don't want to use mixed sex toilets whilst on their period and that's just not fair.
@@nelliewright5832 Did you think I would not click the link? It was some trashy UK tabloid, and the headline was "inmate guilty of two rapes changes genders between trials." That is not remotly related to anything you said, so I call BS. Posting multiple copies of the same headline does not make it any truer, either.
@@legendofFranktheTank Agreed.
Actually, possibly unpopular opinion, I don't think that weatherman faux paux was that bad. His mentality behind the question was exactly what transgender people are striving for, "...why don't we just call her a woman?" I don't know the rest of the convo (if there was more) but he wasn't asking to try and put her down, he was asking because in his mind it didn't make sense to single her out as being transgender, if she's a woman call her a woman. I actually have to respect that. Granted, shouldn't have been a conversation during a news broadcast, but still the thought was there.
well he even said like even when the responses are positive they can read wrongly but i agree i think he was just confused like wait but if you have transitioned and your not in transit now wouldn't that just ..... make you a woman ? like why do you even need to have the trans label is what i think he was confused about
@Pez oh boy seriously ? ya know a woman if it looks thinks feels and acts like one it is one make sense ???? its not a hard concept to grasp
@Pez just like you know when it looks like a duck and acts like a duck its a duck
@Pez i m sorry but if your a grown adult and you have to ask a stranger online what a woman is then we have bigger issues lol and maybe you need to go back to first grade
@Pez you know boobs vagina likes chocolate lol i dont know anyone who defines themselves feminine or what could be categorized as such
The weather guy saying "shouldn't you just say woman?!" With such exhaust and confusion was accidentally super affirming.
you know that boy is serious about being transgender when hes willing to fight to use a highschool boys bathroom, a place of horror.
you haven’t seen a girls bathroom, have you?
vovasenko I am now scared of American bathrooms
I don’t really get that. Did they think that Henry was actually a cis boy trying to get into the girls bathroom? Why give him a pep talk just to force him to use the girls?
Katie Greenhalgh-Higham it’s the other way round, Henry was a trans boy trying to use the boys bathroom
lachlan Bastin , correct. I’m asking if the legislators understood this, seeing as how a lot of clueless people don’t realize that trans men exist.
My cousin is trans, those statistics really do scare me. I love him to death and have looked up to him since I was little, and I can't even think about him getting hurt or hurting himself.
What was it like to fight in the emu war of Australia?
Aw
FWIW, based on my anecdotal experience as a trans person and on statistics on the matter, acceptance from family makes someone a lot less likely to have those negative experiences. Your support of your cousin is probably doing a lot to help him.
If you and your family accept him, then he'll do well. The main reason for those statistics is because of a lack of acceptance from wider society and the people around them.
And the suicide rate is high as hell for us because of bullying
"Isn't that just a woman" is accidentally the most progressive take.
Based
@@axcruz987 true
I noticed that 😂
I ruined ruined 420 likes
He got the spirit
Weird how people will never ask other cis people about their genitals unless they are in a relationship, but the second they talk to us trans people they just HAVE to know.
Testicle or testis (plural testes) is the male reproductive gland or gonad in all animals, including humans. It is homologous to the female ovary. Gender is the human mating dance and those who are not reproducing the next generation have no right to interfere with the future we are building for our children.
I would not care about your genitals. Unless I was going to date you. Which I won’t if you are a trans man. I wish you the best, respect, love and happiness.
You'd think it'd be common courtesy not to inquire about someone's junk during your first sit-down with them. Especially with an audience. I don't even ask about my close friends' genitals (unless we're just goofing around and even then, that's only if it's appropriate for their sense of humor).
Great vid, except for what Oliver did not address, which is women's hard-fought right to protection from male violence. We exclude ALL men from female spaces. When we exclude "trans women" (men) from female spaces its not because they are trans, it is because they are male.
That's because trans people constantly crap on about their sexuality or gender, no wonder people ask personal questions of people that announce their sexuality and gender to the world as though it was their defining quality. The rest of us are more than our gender or sexuality, we are people with varied interests, jobs, beliefs, hobbies and relationships, the trans community are just shallow people who define themselves by their sexual proclivities or gender dysphoria.
To quote a tweet, "if you can call Brendon Urie Panic! at the Disco, when we all know it's just him, you can use people's preferred name and pronouns"
🤣🤣🤣
People have pseudonyms all the time I don’t see why so many cis people have a problem calling trans people by their names lol
Northern Downpour intensifies
Very good point. and I certainly don't say this because I love his music.
Yeah, he is pretty much using the name to keep his fame.
Weatherman: "Aren't you just saying a woman, then?"
*YES.*
Ronnie Januszki That erases the excuses of alt right dickwads of “mental gymnastics” or whatever. The first time this guy ever heard of the concept, and he acknowledges that trans women are women.
That deer in the headlights look on his face while he's trying to figure it out... but yeah, he does seem to arrive at the best possible conclusion in the end. A transgender woman is a woman. She would never go through all the very considerable tribulations of transitioning physically if she had not *always,* on the most fundamental level (personal and emotional) been a woman.^^
The problem is that, honestly, "transgender woman" could mean two things. To me, that could mean "a man that became a transgender woman", or "a woman that became a transgender man". The wording is slightly confusing.
SeaBear Transgender woman means a women who was assigned male at birth who identifies as female.
Ah
Some people don't even realise that they have ALREADY been in the bathroom with a trans person and didn't even realise it.
I haven't because I don't live in a big liberal city.
@@KHDecoder trans people live in rural areas too.
I don’t it safe for kids though
FBI, that’s where you’re wrong. Trans people are much more likely to be the victims of crimes than the perpetrators. In fact, in some states they have what’s known as “lgbt panic laws” which make it legal to assault or even kill a cis person of the same sex or a trans person of the opposite sex, if you accuse them of making unwanted advances.
@@xanderb2377 Bull fucking shit, there is no fucking way ‘I killed him because he said I had a nice ass’ would hold up in court under even basic scrutiny. I can say with fucking certainly that anytime something like that has happened there are factors outside of just “unwanted advances”.
LGBT people have the same human rights as everyone else including not getting murdered for no reason (I know shocker right), well at least in the west that is. Don’t peddle some vaguely defined legal theory as if I was some state enforced law.
No state in the god damn country can legally disallow any gender, race, religious follower or nascar fan of drinking tea without the federal government getting involved, let alone make laws allowing citizens to stab people because they called you hot.
Stop making shit up or believing everything you hear on reddit, which ever comes first.
I'm a trans man, and I can't even imagine coming out at my school. I would probably be so bullied, not only by students, but also by teachers. I'm also fairly popular, so it would be horrible for my social life. I wish for more people like him in the world, so that trans people can finally feel free and themselves in the environments that they daily inhibit.
It's creeps and perverts pretending to be trans that are making it harder for you. Morons are seeing and hearing about the actions of these creatures, and taking it out on all of you unfairly.
Only 0.003% of all humans have gender dysphoria. 5% of young people identify as trans. Entire classrooms are coming out as trans. Something has gone badly wrong.
rooting for you man.
Trans woman here. Full time transgender since a year and it took me around 30 years to come out. I'm happy I haven't come out when I was in school, that would have been a disaster, but now on my 30s I feel it was a bit too late. Try balance out when it's neither too early nor too late :)
-Cass
stop watching gay porn you stupid woman
You’re a woman
"Are you circumcised?" is my standard answer for questions like that.
That's awesome
@Bo Jangles It’s really not. In fact, it’s not much of a comeback. If you asked a male that, they would probably just look at you weird and say yes or no.
Edit: Sorry, it appears I have r/wooshed myself.
other replies include: "why, you gonna suck it?" "So how big is yours?"
@@davidpaul6290 I knew a cis male who got really defensive about it, m8
@@davidpaul6290 The edit made me laugh out loud, thanks for that
My best friend was depressed for so long. He kept going in and out of hospitals for depression and being bi polar. And I would try so hard to understand. I was depressed too. But something was different with him.
It turns how he was trans. He was a man living in a woman's body. And ever since he has started living as a man he has gotten straight As, is going to law school, and no longer has any emotional issues.
So that is the difference that people seem to not understand.
Geek Remix I'm glad to see he's doing better.
i'm glad he found out who he really is
Am I a man
sarmica8 nope. It also happens in india
I'm glad transgender surgery worked for her, but sadly that hardly ever is the case, since both the depression and the suicide rate for transgenders is exactly the same before and after surgery.
This comments section is really depressing. People wonder why trans people kill themselves. Read what you're writing before you send it, and imagine that being sent to you, and everywhere you go people saying the same things, all the time every day. Imagine that following you and never going away. School, work, family, people who you thought were friends, the public, and people online. By the thousands. It's constant, and you're all contributing to it.
Thank you for your sweet encouraging words... Keep speaking truth please
***** I really don't know who you are talking to, but I didn't say ANYTHING about LGBT I was talking about the comments. I didn't say ANYTHING about oppression (because people have no freaking idea what that word means). I didn't say ANYTHING about raising awareness.
I have seen the kind of bile and nastiness which this comments section broadcasts (What I was actually talking about thank you very much) EVERYWHERE. Facebook, news websites, all over youtube, real life, everywhere. And if you're denying that it exists, you're definitely helping! Thanks!
Also you don't understand how percentages work do you? Because even if a community has less of a percentage of existence than the "main community" (such as trans and non trans people) there is still an ABSOLUTE possibility that there are more trans people (percentage wise) who commit suicide than there are non trans people. And did the news story in the video not count as "something not written by a *blah blah blah apparently people don't need to cite their papers anymore*? If not, here's this website (which covers ALL suicide): www.suicidology.org/resources/facts-statistics. And if you're still having trouble with reading comprehension here's the link to the actual PDF from the website: suicidology.org/Portals/14/docs/Resources/FactSheets/2011/LGBT2014.pdf.
Here's a website which talks about transgender people specifically (With virtually the same graphs as the news article what a surprise!!!) www.vocativ.com/culture/lgbt/transgender-suicide/
But no, what I was talking about (which you really didn't seem to understand, did you?) was the tendency of people to just press enter without reading what they've written and thinking about how it may affect other people. Full grown adults may be able to handle seeing stuff like that, and eventually they just tune it out anyways, but children, and teenagers (the group in all statistics which is most vulnerable REGARDLESS of whether they're LGBT or not) can't. And if you're really going to fault children for being unable to handle the vile nastiness that these people who have no regard for or capacity to understand another person's life spew out positively everywhere, then I don't really want to hold much more of a conversation with you.
Also you've just used the word 'retarded', so actually, I don't want to have any more of a conversation with you. I hope you were able to understand what I wrote, if not I really couldn't care less.
Ashley Lewis I think its the whole internet anonymity that causes people to become total asshats online.
HugzByDeath I absolutely agree. I think if people would just realise that they're talking to actual people maybe they'd stop being total asshats. Or at least more would stop being total asshats. I'm well aware that this world is simply filled with nasty people who are looking for an excuse to be nasty and that the internet is that excuse.
Ashley Lewis Ahh it wasn't worth it anyway, SJWs tend to not want to change their opinions regardless of what people say anyway. Have fun, honestly all I wanted you to do was lighten up a little, life has a lot less weight if you do so.
I had never heard of John Oliver, so when I saw that someone was discussing transgender issues (7 years ago), I was expecting the worst. I found instead a great ally and I'm happy now!
And from before Trump was President, no less.
I always get called “it” in my class, like “oh is *it* a boy” and “is *it* mentally stable?”
I'm sorry you have to go through that... That can push into isolation, please know that you're not alone ! Take care of yourself, you deserve it. A lot of us have been through the same thing or similar ones. We understand, you're not alone !
Chin up, remember that they don't get to choose you. You are what you already are. they only wish they could change that but they know they never will be able to. If you do what they want you'll never be happy. I feel sad for those without inner peace that strike others with hate.
My only question is, how old are you?
Take it from me, people in high school will always be mean no matter who you are. Once you graduate, you are free to pick your own friends and you never have to deal with a bully’s intolerance ever again. You can just ignore them and walk away with your true friends that love you for you :)
@@xxXthekevXxx
Well if you are going to go that route I'd say drop out of highschool and get a GED instead (it'll take a couple months but that's better than 3+ years right) then get a Job
Things that are okay:
Accidentally dead naming someone, then apologizing and correcting yourself.
Accidentally using the wrong pronouns, then apologizing and correcting yourself.
Taking a while to get used to a friend or family member's new name and gender.
Things that are not okay:
Purposefully and/or repeatedly dead naming someone or referring to someone's previous gender without apologizing or correcting yourself.
Cutting someone off because "they're turning away their true selves" or for any other reason connected to their new identity.
Refusing to accept someone's new name and preferred pronoun(s).
It's also not ok to make a big deal when you dead name someone.
For example:
"Hey [deadname] how- oh my god I am soooo sorry it's just taking me a long time to get used to I'm so sorry I'll never do it again!!!"
Just say:
"Hey [deadname] how- sorry, [correct name] how was your weekend?"
It makes us feel like we're burdening you by asking you to use our correct name and pronouns.
Preach 👏👏
There's a line though. I can only listen to my parents deadname me so many times a day. Especially when they shout it across a room or a building, and then after I correct them or glare long enough they mumble the correct name under their breath. I am tired of it. Far too tired.
@@vik.2560 "Correct" what are dem chromosomes buddy? Its not a matter of correct, its a matter of not using the name and pronouns you tell others to use.
@@AvNotasian
Oh, you're right. Next time someone tells me to call them Emily and use she/her I'll just call them Ethan and use he/him. Tf are you tryna say?
As a transgender woman I love to see that my favourite comidian cares about our issues. Thank you all for reading this.
Just gonna add a little note here becuase why not, my chosen name is Alex and I'm 16
AND this was in 2015! Like woah 😳
@@nia.r5988 Not all “progressives” are equal. 🤷
@@alyxandrawells4560 .........GET EM
Grundy Fundy that's when Kaitlyn Jenner KILLED A PERSON TOO
I'm a Transman. And, yes, Folk do seem to have a certain fascination when it comes to a Trans Person's junk. Even when they're not asking you, you can tell that every fibre in their body wants to. The 'have you had THE surgery' or 'are you having THE surgery' are common ones. And, bathrooms are always an issue. It's one of my biggest sources of anxiety. I use the Gents, but regardless of how Male I look, I'm still not super confident using them. I much prefer to use a Gender Neutral / Disabled Loo. Far less stressful. Transitioning is not for the faint of heart. It's a lifelong process and it can be a bumpy ride, so the idea that a person would fake being Trans to abuse Women or Children in the Ladies loo, is just so preposterous that it makes my eyes bleed!!!!. I mean, seriously, Sex Offenders do not have to identify as a Woman to Sexually abuse Women and Children. They can do that just fine as they are! It's damaging, hateful and so disrespectful to even suggest it, let alone to pass laws based on that belief. Now I'm getting side tracked, lol! I came here via a link that was posted on a Trans Support Group that I belong to, because I said I didn't know who John Oliver was. Now I do and I couldn't love him more for this video. Anyone who has a negative opinion of a Trans Person, should be encouraged to watch this. Maybe then they'd come to think differently.
This comment needs a LOT more love and attention. This should be a lot further up on the comment feed
@@MuscleCarLover No his comment is actually
pure 🐃💩
Plenty of news articles reporting children/women being assaulted in the bathroom by trans folk
Its the trans people that have the fascination and constantly talking about their junk not the other way around! Take a look at all those groomer teachers talking about their sex life to pre-pubescent children! its sickening.
@@1BuFo Ahhhh, I didn't realise you were Transgender, and so had a personal, lived experience of what it's like to be Trans, and the recipient of the said fascination regards one's 'junk' .
>Sex Offenders do not have to identify as a Woman to Sexually abuse Women and Children
Yet that happened in the past.
>Maybe then they'd come to think differently.
He didn't even address any controversial demands made by trans activists or why people disagree. He just framed anyone being against any sort of demand by trans activists as against "civil rights".
The guy who was confused about trans women and was like "A woman who used to be a man? Isn't that just a woman? I'm so confused." Is an accidental ally and I'm here for it.
That ally would be entirely deluded to believe that, though. An ally in ignorance.
@@cosmofox you're right, they were never a man :)
@@justanotheraltaccount7821 You're nuts.
@@cosmofox says the dumbass who went on their way to reply to a 2yo comment just to spread transphobia
@@justanotheraltaccount7821 your wrong, im sorry but if you are born male you grow to t be a man no matter what happens.
Look, I'll be honest. I wouldn't know how to react if someone told me he/she was transgender. I know how I should respond of course, but how I'd really feel about it; idk. Because its not natural to me, I can't fully understand it. Attempting to deny this is in my view hypocritical.
BUT I would go through any length to ensure that this person has the same rights as me and is not discriminated against. Especially in legal matters. My personal feelings should not have any impact on this persons life and I'd still treat them with the same respect I treat any other person.
Its disgusting that the US allows shit like this in the law. I'm not sure how it is here but I believe transgender people have the same legal rights as anyone else, as they should.
+NiekGAE I'm transgender. How did that make you react?
Max Austin Don't care. You're a name on the internet. I meant someone I've known for a while in person.
NiekGAE Well here's a tip. If someone you've known for a while in person tells you they're trans, get over it
Max Austin O piss off. I don't think they're abominations or anything, I was just being honest that I wouldn't know how to react. I'm pro-LGBT. I wouldn't shun a friend if he/she told me he/she was transgender. But acting like I'm 110% comfortable with it and that I fully understand it would be hypocritical.
But I guess thats not enough for you. You'd rather have me act all PC. Well too bad.
NiekGAE if you want to be pro-LGBT the first thing you should do it stop saying "he/she"
My favourite thing about the bathroom bills is that if a guy wanted to go in and sexually assault a woman in the women's bathroom that's possible. Like, regardless of the bill. BATHROOMS AREN'T LOCKED
This is why we need single stalled gender neutral bathrooms. Just put everything needed in there; toilet, sink, bin, etc. and put a door in front.
@@theviewer6889 That's literally the only type of bathroom we have at my school, far superior
In NYC they are locked.
@@MrEvodio65 wild.
That and it's already illegal to assault someone in a bathroom regardless of which bathroom you are in
Watching this in 2022 is still so depressing, especially while seeing things like the Texas Governor asking courts to investigate transgender healthcare in adolescents for child abuse. The german law governing transgender issues is widely critizized here, becous it contains quite a bit of medical gatekeeping and sometimes dehumanizing examinations, but at least once you've gone through with the process mandated by the law you're done with it and you get EVERYTHING matching your gender identitiy, passport, birth certificate, driver's license... I feel very lucky to live here and to be past that point.
i have to say the weather guy at the beginning had one great statement "so why dont we just call her a woman"
As a transgender woman, this comment section really warmed my heart.
Thank you ^-^
Are you sorting by new or by top
Because oh boy I think you are sorting by top
@@ilmu011 yeah by top
Pixel Bytes Don’t sort by new
Pixel Bytes your welcome you deserve it
Tamahina Pierrot
I can’t tell if you’re saying I deserve the comments sorted by new or the comments sorted by top. Because either you’re being really sweet or being an asshat
"Some transgender people do undergo hormone therapy or sex assignment surgeries as part of their transition, and some do not, and interestingly their decision on this matter is medically speaking ,
NONE OF YOUR FUCKING BUSINESS!"
best thing I've heard today.
exactly this 👏
I don't wanna hear any specifics about anybody's sexuality or gender because I can't help but think about what's in their pants.
So what I'm human. An animal. Screw off with your business
Translation: there is no medical basis for these decisions.
Rest in Power Henry. You deserved far more than this shitty world gave you. 🏳️⚧️
Transgenderism can be treated, you know that right
@vaibhavdeshpande3129 No it can’t. Unfortunately for you, your stupidity can’t be treated, either.
@@vaibhav.dvd55 Do you have a source or is the cure just some old book?
@@mofka26 Yes. It's called 'Growing Up'.
@@vaibhav.dvd55 If someone has an anxiety disorder do you just tell them to “grow up” or do you get medication for them?
It’s the same thing with gender dysphoria if you know the solution to something that is causing distress in a persons life then get that solution
I really don't understand what everybody's problem is with bathrooms. "Oh no! Think of the children!" When there's a mother with a little son and the son has to pee, she will go into the women's bathroom with him. Same situation, but it's a dad with a daughter and they will use the men's bathroom. Does this traumatize the child? No, it doesn't. You wanna know why? Because in a bathroom people are minding their fucking business.
ok not gonna lie the men's restroom KIND of traumatized me but i'm still trans! (nonbinary)
exactly! it's not like you're waving your genitals around in the bathroom publicly.. the only difference is urinals (and not even that's in every men's bathroom)
@Tsar Nicholas II because they use the bathrooms that correspond with their gender, not their 'birth gender' which you would actually refer to as 'biological'. They use the bathroom of their gender, the one which they identify with. Because that's what they are. Period.
I'd say a TERF pulling the pants of a 9-year-old Trans girl in a public bathroom is exponentially more likely to traumatise a kid than any of what you've just described. (This was a true story, for anyone that didn't heard about it)
@@blueheartsystem1502 speak for yourself
I'm a woman and never in my life have I felt uncomfortable meeting a transwoman in the girl's bathroom. Children don't even take notice of things like this and molesting someone in a restroom is a crime and entirely the fault of the criminal and not to be used against transpeople.
Shushu Chan Tbh, as a trans girl I only even go in public bathrooms if I'm basically about to have my bladder explode anyway.. I can't imagine easily getting over that anxiety if you're nowhere near passing tbh.
Oatmeal I understand why this is a cause of anxiety for any transperson and I'm sorry that you have to go through this, just want to let you know you're welcome in the women's restrooms ♡
Oatmeal I have been in the ladies room and seen trans women who are not exactly passing but are trying their best. No one batted an eye. I do live somewhere that is known for being very accepting of everyone though. Hope you get over your anxiety soon.
@@laviniafitzgerald5136 you could have seen e.g. ciswomen with a bad case of PCOS, and not transwomen. Without talking to them there's no good way of knowing if their obvious anxiety and discomfort is because they're terrified of being bullied for their transness, or if because they're terrified of that someone will mock them for "being such a disgusting excuse for a woman" that they even have a more masculine bone structure and male pattern body hair distribution because of their fucked up hormones. There are even butch ciswomen who don't have hormone disorders but dress androgynous, have an androgynous face, and carry themself in a butch manner so they just aren't obviously female, despite being very cisgendered. Point is, you think you saw transgender women, but you have no way of knowing if you actually did instead of e.g. a ciswoman with bad PCOS.
Shushu Chan it’s the bathroom there’s stalls it’s not like you see people going pee or poo
As a trans guy, I can confirm that I’ve gotten a ton more weird looks when I was still in the closet but already looking masc using the women’s bathroom than when I came out and started using the men’s bathroom. In fact, I haven’t gotten a single weird look in the men’s room ever, opposed to when women would give me weird glares and whisper about how there’s a little boy in their bathroom. I’m pretty confident in saying that I make more people uncomfortable by going into the bathroom assigned to my biological sex opposed to the one assigned to what I actually look like and identify as.
Same!!
That's because they think all trans men and women just wear bad drag costumes.
I've never understood getting upset about who uses the bathroom. I had a transitioning peer in school, Mac now MacKenzie, used the women's bathroom. Never once had an issue. 1. Because it's not my fucking business, and 2. It's not my fucking business. The only problem I had was that she was infinitely better at makeup than I. Bitch looked absolutely stellar at prom.
I kept getting asked if I knew that I was in the women’s bathroom lol, kinda makes me feel good
Feel that, I am female, I idetify as such. But I also find I don't give a shit if someone calls me male. My friend tells me that I might just be Gender Fluid, and possibly They Them pronouns would fit me.
Though, I find I don't care if I am called male or female. Due to my short hair and flat chest with my love of boy jeans because damn well they are comfortable. (Like seriously, why do women jeans have to hug the area that heats up easy?) I get mistaken for a male alot, but I laugh it off because I know if you don't look at me in front and up close I look like a guy. But someone mistaking my gender is the least of my worries in life between school, finding work, getting a car, and among other things.
I don't have time to worry about it, and I don't get upset by it. I guess that also because my name gives way for many nicknames, so I got used to this fact. At a young age I never understood why calling someone a different gender was seen as an insult, at least in the sense of little kids teasing or name calling. I was called mockingly a male once or twice, and just gave a confused look at the kid as if to as if that was the best they could do.
(I also get called 14 when I am actually in my 20's, due to have a younger looking face and being short lol)
Crazy shit, when this first aired I was firmly down the alt right pipeline and was very transphobic, but now I'm trans! Time makes fools of us all
same, i was the worst of the worst. all the phobics and ists you can think of. now i realize how stupid and misinformed i was. being trans has probably been the nest thing to happen to me tbh
This is an oddly common experience... It wasn't Oliver who firmly kicked me off the pipeline, it was someone else. My drama teacher. I was one of those Ben Shapiro debate bro asshats who loved to own the libs with facts and logic (talking really fast until my opponent gets confused, frustrated, or gives up)
My drama teacher noticed this kind of stuff and basically told me "Debating is fun, but this isn't how you do it. You need to learn your interlocutor's points before engaging with them" and since I respected him, I took that to heart.
Eventually I realized I related a bit too much with the trans people I was ragging on not even 6 months before, and subsequently concluded that something was up. Then just like that, my egg cracked.
A good 5-6 years later and I'm out to my friends, gathering the courage to come out at school, and still wondering if I should come out to my family before securing a place to stay during the fallout. Overall, a much happier person.
Same for me. Went from being horribly hateful at 13 to a trans guy now.
Congratulations :), I know that feeling too. I wonder if its something we did to try and fit in
Imma get a “its a boy!” Card to come out to my mom
Edit:I came out and my name is sam.
Edit: Guys i’m getting a binder!
lol that'd be amazing, and if u haven't come out already (take your time) then good luck my man
let's hope she doesn't think you're pregnant °~°
Good luck!
Good luck, I'm sure it'll take lots of talking and maybe some arguing but hope you're able to get on the other side and maintain your relationship (which shouldn't be hard because you are you no matter your gender) :)
My mom would panic thinking I got pregnant :D But good luck.
To be fair, that weather man did say "Aren't you just saying a woman then?"
Whether he meant it or not, that was a very forward thinking statement.
@Kaladin Stormblessed What is your goal with this? Why is your mind so important that you spam this at every comment thread here?
@@spsproos I appreciate Kaladin's informative comment. Also, truth is omportant.
Diego Brando 「ТӤЄ шӨЯLD」 Nobody was saying it *was* a biological change, and fyi people who get sex-change surgery know they've just sterilized themselves. They just wanna make their bodies look the way they think they should. It's not much different from piercing your ears or getting a tattoo. People who are perfectly ok with their natural bodies also sterilize themselves with vasectomies/hysterectomies, and I've seen some fat dudes with far bigger tits than mine.
As for suicides? Lots of natural-bodied people off themselves for a million different reasons.
As for kids? Yeah, maybe some of them get hormone replacements, but that's the parent's call. Kind of like if they needed a liver transplant or chemotherapy. It's not your kid, and it's not illegal.
So really, why do you care? It really has nothing to do with you. Don't worry so much about it, none of it is about you o directly affects your life in any conceivable way. I'm not into dating or fucking a trans person, so I don't. But I also really don't give a damn how they choose to live their lives, either.
I think I get where you're coming from, but you need to chill, man. You're clutching those pearls far too tight.
@@Errenium
Ah, I see you are a triple-headed hyperdimensional god-being of culture as well.
@Diego Brando 「ТӤЄ шӨЯLD」 It's biologically impossible to change sexes. Gender isn't even biological. You did, albeit incidentally, make a good point. It perhaps IS impossible to change genders, but it IS definitely possible to come to the realization that your sex organs don't match your gender. You can then opt to surgically alter your genitals to match the genitals of the genitals of the sex that best matches your gender if you wish. As I said, this doesn't change your sex, or really change your gender either, however it seems to provide some transgender people with a more acceptable sense of identity. I honestly don't see why people like yourself would choose to make petty criticisms that are almost always inaccurate to a degree just to make others feel bad about a personal decision. You need to reflect a bit.
They always make it sound like it's about children, while it's about them being undereducated utterly scared knobs
iop erty 🙌🏼🙌🏼🙌🏼
it's about them being utterly scared bi miseducating knobs a(s)s childreN
@Do what you must, I have already won Say that again in a less cognitively-dissonant way
WON'T SOMEBODY PLEASE THINK OF THE CHILDREN UWWAAAA
Do what you must, I have already won that doesnt happen outside of twitter. not even a real problem
Rest in power Henry. You deserved so much fucking better.
I'm so mad. I can't believe the amount of pain he was in for years. Furious doesn't begin to describe how I'm feeling.
I was coming here to say exactly this. Rest in power Henry, I hope you found peace. I'll remember you this November 20th.
She deserved to get actual help instead of a double mastectomy and being used to further her mother's political ambitions
@@MsBrendalina jesus christ a kid commited fucking suicide put your bigotry on hold and realize you're the problem
Do you think if "Henrys" parents had been stricter and guided her to live a more normal life she'd be alive. Do you think that mental problems were the main factor here, 1. thinking she was male 2. being depressed enough to commit suicide, and why should everyone else bend over backwards for people who don't try to live normal lives but basically punish everyone else for their delusions and are still not happy when they get what they want?
Sex: What you physically are
Gender: What you mentally are.
Orientation: What you like to snuggle with.
Suppose that is true, but if sex and gender don't match, why always change the sex and not the gender?
The mind is stranger then the body, there are people who are born that are mentally wired to view themselves as the opposite gender of their sex.
GreatBigRanz Sex: medical information that should be protected under HIPAA. Gender: A facet of your personality. Orientation: A facet of your personality.
Pizza Pie Because you only see the sex change. You never consider that maybe some of these people are in constant conflict with themselves over their gender identity and some do go back and forth. It's not exactly a hot conversation starter.
Pizza Pie Outcomes. Changing the body is easier, less risky and far more effective. Changing the mind has been shown time and time again to fail.
Why are people so obsessed with each other's genitals? Like, chill out; it's none of your business.
It's not just that. People with the most interest in other people's sex lives do so because they don't have one of their own.
So I don't end up in the situation where I think I'mma about to smash a girl but I find a dick instead cause that would be disappointing
This could be one of many reason's why being friend's with a asexual is a good idea
@@therealist158 give it a shot sometime, a good suck, fuck, and swallow can change a "straight" man's life ;)
You dont get it
i lost it at "medically speaking, its none of your f$@&#ng business" because its so true.
+MidnightmoonRR I have to disagree partially. I think it should be allright to ask those questions if they are talked about in preparation of a show and if they are on topic. We have refused to talk about LGBT people in the media that I can understand the public being curious now that we open up to talking about it. Just prep on them.
+Freddy Meyer While I understand where you're coming from, talking about what is below someone's clothing can be VERY uncomfortable. Even if prepped, I don't think many people would want to talk about this reassignment. Speaking from experience, those questions are weird and unpleasant.
+Rogerandi Noire problem?
+Rogerandi Noire that escalated quickly.
+Rogerandi Noire Said the one whose picture is Shadow the Edgehog...
As a cis ally, this is the greatest thing I’ve seen in a while. Not only does he tell you trans rights, he tells you WHY trans rights. Bravo.
You know the term 'cis' was created by a German sexologist, Volkmar Sigusch who was a eugenicist who pushed laws to legalize pedophelia? Good thing it's being labeled a hate slur nowadays.
His predecessors were all eugenicists leading back Irwin gDorbrant, a sex change surgeon who did freezing experiments on Nazi concentration camp prisoners.
You a fucking idiot you let these people give you the term Cis lol! You've never called yourself Cis as child, teenager or an adult but now you are a "cis ally" . You can't be an ally to someone's identity you idiot. That's a personal issue. All you can do is respect their privacy but live your own reality. I will never ever care about someone delusional thoughts. I will mind my own business and live my life only. Wtf I look like being an ally for a mental disorder.
Bruhh this shit was up like 8 years ago now😅
Where were you 8 years ago?
@@sashmcflash1The genetic fallacy, judging something purely by where it comes from. Hell, that might not even be true, but let's assume it is. Doesn't automatically mean trans people don't deserve rights. That's like saying dogs are assholes because Hitler had a dog. He did, by the way.
Now I understand why so many people don't like John Oliver...
He makes way too much sense.
He calls out people for being cunts, but know one likes being called a cunt, so they get defensive.
James Finley try talking to a real doctor
AgeOfSuperboredom This comment would make so much more sense on any other video.
He literally just verbaly chastized a guy for not knowing what transgender means immediately after verbally attacking people for asking questions. This is literally the least amount of sense he has ever made lol
I'm 100% fine with people wanting to be the other gender but there's a line you shouldn't fucking cross because I'm going to call u whatever da fuq I want
WiseSageBum but you think if a guy feels like a girl he should go to the women’s toilet? if the person is trans and now a woman they should be free to go to a womens toilet but if it is a guy with a penis that just feels like a woman they really shouldn’t go to the women’s bathroom.
the idea that people look at each others junk in the bathroom is fucked up. i dont even make eye contact with anyone while i wash my hands at the sink.
+heyysimone I know right. I don't mean to insult men, but I actually think that's all they do that in restroom is look at each other dicks. Then, some of them assume women do the same thing, even though we have no urinals or open space toilets, at least not in the States.
+pluto545 Uhhhh, I have used men's restrooms all my life and have never seen another man's junk. This is one of the main reasons why I believe transpeople should be able to use the restrooms that correspond to their gender presentation. Regardless of which restroom you use, you pretty much have to go out of your way to see some genitals.
+pluto545 LOL if you ever look at a male bathroom with those community urinals or simply don't have dividers, you'll see a lot more men waiting at a wall uncomfortably staring at the ceiling or shoving their junk so deep into the urinal that they risk getting pee all over their pants. I mean, there are men out there vastly more comfortable than most but my own experiences, people hate the guy that takes the urinal (even if its covered) 1 away from the wall which means someone is gonna have to get close to a stranger. xD
But I've personally yet to see anyone go on their tippy toes to see someone's junk over the urinal cover and if that were to happen, its not the end of the world. Probably wont go to that same bathroom ever again, but its not the end.
+heyysimone The rule with urinals is stand one apart from the other person
Kratoctavio ....head facing down, up, or forward. No eye contact. Now, if you're looking for some..uhhh...*action*, proceed at your own risk.
as a member of the military I personally don't care if someone is gay trans bi or all the above somehow. as long as they can watch my back when we go overseas were good. what you have between your legs or decide to put there in your free time is none of my business
you know how ADHD works, right?
how?
It's not
rd0676 amen
rd0676 My dad agrees and the only reason he is alive today is because of a trans man. Just think about transphobic's. The only reason a military solider is alive today is because of another military trans soldier.
I’m here to remember Henry…. I’m sorry the world made you feel so alone. RIP Henry I’m sorry America failed you. You died too young.
I came here expecting TERFy shit. Got an actual ally vibe instead
John oliver is really awesome about using his privilege to help minorities. He also doesn't speak over them and invites advocates onto his show.
69th like
He's a good dude
John Oliver is very good. I don't think I've ever seen him use bias as an argument, which is more than you can say about a lot of people.
vibe check
To be fair to the weather guy, he did say "Isn't that just a woman then?", which is actually correct.
Indeed, it might be that is was more astonished by the others. but i fear he wasn't.
TheBizzle1984 Tell that to a straight man when he hits on it. NOT a woman and can't bear a child. No
TheBizzle1984 no it’s not
well, yes, but so is a black or white or asian woman. Just because there's an adjective in front doesn't make someone not the noun
ok so you know that some biological women can't have children right? So what you your saying is that women who can't bear children aren't real women. and if that is the case wow your ignorant
At least that weather guy said something like "wouldn't you just say woman" give credit where credit is do.
That's kind of the problem I have with this segment it just comes across as preachy. He's basically asking for progress without people who have questions, no matter how private in nature, just want to understand how it all works.
This kind of thing only recently became a big public issue, and most have never knowingly interacted with a transgender individual. So yeah there are going to be questions.
You might as well go and take a top of the line PC to Victorian England with some sort of magic wifi connection to our present, and tell them with this box the sex deprived individuals could get porn. Then proceed to get mad at them when they don't understand how use a plug and they ask you how to.
It's something understandable if you are a private individual, but if you are a public individual like the women at the beginning who are trans, there are going to be questions and the sooner they are answered the sooner we can all go back to not giving a fuck about what someone does in their personal life. Which I wish the world would let me do.
It can never just be simple as accept and understand and move on. No we have to spend the next few decades listening to the bitching and moan of two self-righteous groups of asshole.
Also on a side note, Oliver's definition of trans is wrong, that is gender identity in which all of us fall on a spectrum. Trans is someone who suffers from gender identification disorder in which they can't accept their gender identity being so far away from their sex they think that they are freaks.
Because of this they feel the need to have gender reassignment surgery in order to accept themselves.
thelinedrive Another comment about: *He's basically asking for progress without people who have questions, no matter how private in nature, just want to understand how it all works.* It's called the internet - google and educate yourself, why encroach someones privacy when the tools and info are already out there? Plus your analogy about taking a computer back to the past is dog shit.
thelinedrive It was a joke and afterwards he even said himself that people might just need some time to wrap their head around it.
thelinedrive He's doing us the favor of answering the most common and uncomfortable questions that transppl face on a daily basis from otherwise well-meaning people. Look. We know most of you aren't trying to offend or be rude. We understand that until recently a lot of people had no idea what a transgender person was or why it mattered that you give a shit. We know all of this. But, it's all of the time. It never ends. All Oliver is doing is giving you the rundown and saying what most transgender people wish someone like him would say so we can stop dealing with this.
Part of being transgender means you usually have to also become an expert in gender identity and exhibit supernatural levels of patience for this constant barrage of incredibly personal and inappropriate questions. And like I said, that's from people who aren't even trying to be assholes. Combine that with everyone else who are either asswipes to us, outright violent towards us, with only a very few who are cool and just treat us how we present and maybe you can begin to see why so many transppl just can't deal with it anymore and commit suicide.
Nobody chooses this life and when a transperson says "I've always felt this way inside" they aren't just making that up. There really is such a thing as Gender Identity and all of the peer-reviewed research is heavily suggestive of it being the result of a non-plastic structure in the brain that forms in fetal development in response to whatever hormones are present. Conversely, there is a ton of evidence that rules out gender identity as "learned," socially constructed, or otherwise programmable. The John-Jane-John case was what finally caused the medical community to come around and put serious effort into figuring this out so there has been some pretty compelling research done in the past 15-20 years. Like I said before, I've had to become an expert on gender because I field a never ending line of the same questions, so I've had to actually look at the science. Unfortunately, the implications of this research haven't really diffused into the mainstream culture yet and we still have this "you get assigned a team at birth and that's it" attitude with gender. Doctors have stopped assigning gender to intersex babies as a direct result of John-Jane-John. But, it's up to the parents mostly with transgender babies and while things are a lot better off for transkids now with all the new awareness and focus on dealing with it early-on, there are still a ton that don't know/care/reject the whole idea that a kid could be transgender.
Which means a lot of transppl don't have the luxury of transitioning before puberty and just living their lives with minimal turbulence. Different people have different bodies, and sadly it is your outward appearance that most people will judge you on when trying to place your gender. Behavior/speech/mannerisms are all part of it and sometimes more than compensate, but hey I'll be real and say some transbrother/sisters got a shit hand genetically and/or transitioned later on and didn't get the most ideal results. Personally, I lucked out here and now you'd never know IRL unless I told you. Which is good and bad.
It's good because I'm free from a lot of the day to day looks, questions, reactions, etc. It's bad because the number one killers of transwomen is trans-rage from straight men. I don't even like dudes and I have been with my GF for almost a decade, so it's not like I'm even going out on dates with men or anything. Just walking to the train stop on a friday/saturday night and being cat-called by drunk dudes has led to life-threatening situations when they realize I'm trans.
Look, I hate all these labels and definitions for transppl. I generally agree with that Weather-guy "Isn't that just a woman?" Because that's what I am. (the same can be said for Transmen. Isn't that just a man?) But, we also have a unique set of challenges that non-trans people do not. It's one thing if you are trying to add to that and just a piece of shit. If so none of this matters to you and you're still gonna try to harass/rape/murder me or other transppl so whatever. But, most people are not. Unfortunately, it's the confusion or curiosity from these well-meaning people that drain us emotionally on a daily basis. Oliver is trying to lift that burden by giving you the same talk we would otherwise have to give to several people everyday or go to some great lengths to avoid having. It's doing us a favor, and it's doing you a favor as you won't be unintentionally throwing additional weight to our burden.
Mike Mac I agree, I thought that would be better. Why did the headline have to read "Transgender Woman", instead of just woman. I can only imagine that transgender people would rather just be called a man or woman.
13:33 just heard that Henry Brousseau featured on the show way back when took his own life over the weekend. So so sad. My deepest condolences. This episode and his follow up 7 years later are more relevant than ever.
Is there a news story about this?? I keep seeing these comments but never heard about it in real life.
@@soccerguy325 I'd love to imagine this is a hoax, but it's not a good idea to bring our hopes up.
@@soccerguy325 just look up his name? its one of the first things that comes up
Years ago I was in Japan and they had some very reasonable public restrooms... it was simply the restroom (non-gendered, multi use). There was a wall of urinals and a wall of stalls - use whatever worked for you. There was no problem. Some of the other Americans I was with got freaked out while we were peeing, there were women walking to the stalls. As an American I think many Americans have some weird hangups about people's plumbing. Looking at the arrests, I think we are all safer sharing a bathroom with a trans person than a GOP congressman! 😀🍹🇵🇭
Tito Tim's Videos Hahaha, great ending. I'm conservative, but still, damn.
Oatmeal Hey, that's great! I say, as long as you're a good person, it doesn't matter, left, right, center, African American, Caucasian, Gay, Straight, you're good by me.
Great comment, I agree
Archie Handler Talking about me?
Stop Hating On Aqua, yup
"But that dynamic of praising a transgender person's 'courage' and then NOT actually supporting them speaks to the fact that we're all weirdly comfortable celebrating transgender people while simultaneously dehumanizing them..." ... we have a bad habit of doing this with a number of groups. The homeless, the disabled, immigrants, etc. Seems like too many people like to feel good about themselves, "I'm a good person!" but have no interest in actually taking the effort to BE a good person. I have a transgender friend who doesn't like people to know she's transgender. I always thought it was because she was embarrassed or ashamed for people to know, but eventually came to find out it was because she was sick of being a "token" for people to claim how "welcoming" they were to the transgender community simply because they were friends with her, while simultaneously doing absolutely nothing to help her overcome barriers she faced daily. She can handle the people who openly hate her better than she can handle the betrayal and apathy of friends.
That is so incredibly sad and so incredibly true.
lol, thats like the classic white "liberals" that patronizes minorities... this is exactly why i think democrats are way more racists than republicans... republicans just treat you as a human, democrats treat you as an animal that need to be saved.
America is not a civilized country.
All transgender people are humans. All transgender people have gender dysphoria.
@@fuckamericanidiot Actually, that's not true. Gender dysphoria is a discomfort or an unease felt by someone whose biological sex doesn't match their gender identity. Many transgender people are fine with their biological sex while also being fine expressing their gender identity.
It's disgusting that we don't treat this with the same seriousness as racism, sexism, and homophobia. There are laws being passed that specifically target transgender CHILDREN, requiring SCHOOL STAFF to out them, and I haven't heard a single news outlet talking about it. Regardless of how old this video is, it's extremely refreshing to see someone actually bringing attention to our issues.
You think those other three are treated well? I'd love to live in that world.
@@theviewer6889 That's not what I said, I said that if laws specifically targeting them came about, there would be public outcry.
@@eksel20 those numbers are kind of confusing, and please elaborate if I'm reading it wrong, but the final (Most recent) study finds that only 9.4% ceased transitioning? Also, it isn't "experimenting on children" when said children (Who just in case you forgot, do have minds of their own and are capable of decisions) and their legal guardians are seeking out that treatment, and can cease it at any time. In my opinion, the number of people going back to identifying as their biological gender stems from the number of people who claim the transgender identity, while not experiencing any dysphoria, which unfortunately has become WAY too common These people seek out HRT, not fully understanding its permanent affects, and realize that it isn't truly what they wanted. Instead of a complete ban on HRT or any other medical transitions, there should be a more standardized way of diagnosing gender dysphoria, and only people with this diagnosis should be medically transitioning.
@@eksel20 Honestly, I see no point in continuing the conversation at this point, and just so you know I will be looking into all the things you've mentioned and I appreciate the information. I also just want to thank you for being civil about it and actually backing up all of your claims, and even pointing out potential flaws in the evidence you provided, it's very mature and unfortunately you don't see much of that anymore. Also, thanks for clearing up that statistic, honestly I figured I was reading it wrong I just couldn't really figure it out.
@@sagehogan1001
I know this is kinda old but these are some good videos regarding "studies" on trans children. Alot of them arnt as scientificly sound as they present themselves.
th-cam.com/video/WNjdTNYzWbc/w-d-xo.html
th-cam.com/video/9oEyqY5yM4I/w-d-xo.html
th-cam.com/video/oW_Wwle0ie0/w-d-xo.html
I almost cried when they said 41% had attempted suicide. People are awful. Some are okay, but in general- people are awful. Why do we treat each other like garbage? I'm embarrassed to be a human.
it's a you problem
@@english3082 No; it's a human problem.
@@23pounceown it
That weather man said "wouldn't you just say a woman now?" I agree actually. Who cares if she used to be a man.
I like your spirit! But just to clarify, (trans) women were never men. They’ve known they were woman their entire lives
@@palabritas3980 wait so trand women were not born with a penis? It has been 2 month but I am pretty sure I was referring to who cares what is going on down there
@@nicolereadstarot born with penis, usually yes
Were men though, no
@@TurnipCart Nope
Turnip
Sir there is tons of Beautiful trans woman out there but that doesn’t matter wether or not they pass doesn’t correlate to if there valid or not
Also the Bible says nothing about being trans
If god knows all he probably knew there was guna be trans people in the future and yet he still didn’t say anything that prohibited it so ya he seems cool with it
"Look, this is a civil rights issue. If you are not willing to support transgender people for their sake, at least do it for your own. Because we've been through this before; We know how this thing ends. If you take the anti-civil rights side, and deny people access to something they're entitled to, history is not going to be kind to you."
Probably my favourite John Oliver quote.
@1 Love There's so much wrong with that, I don't even know where to start. But in short, you're wrong. And you don't matter. And nothing you say is going to stop trans people from living their lives and getting their rights. You can shout into the void of the internet forever (and please do), until the day you die. Almost nobody will see it, and absolutely nobody will care.
1 Love Not at all. I mean you, personally, and your opinions don’t matter. There are plenty of wonderful, kind biological women who I am proud to know. Biological woman who don’t find it necessary to attack people who don’t hurt them in any way. You’re nothing like them, I’m sad to say.
This is the single best quote that has ever existed. I believe it will win us the rights we absolutely deserve. I will repost, trans girl here. i am chloe 🤗
Mr1flapjack1 Nowadays for a lot of people including myself, I have nothing against trans people, but I do get upset at the concept of being punished if I mistake a trans person for the wrong gender. Because it can be confusing
@@RaceNcars you wouldnt be punished for making an honest mistake, to err is to be human. but when you attack that person, harrass them, abuse them, when you are kindly corrected, then you are in the wrong and punishment is justified
edit: i want to clairify that the majority of transgender people will not attack a person for misgendering. we tend to either correct if we feel safe or shut down and stay quiet. so if you are corrected, take it with ease, and let them be, there is nothing wrong with making mistakes, its how you choose to correct it, if you correct it, that tells people the type of person you are.
-Are transgender people people?
Yes.
-Should they have the rights of people?
Yes.
-Then why is there a problem?
People.
-Like all of the other problems in the world?
Yes.
Good. Love it.
someone if they are not causing harm to you personally, it doesn’t matter how anyone in the world choses to live their life. Stop worrying about other people, take care of yourself and your own.
Healthcare, let alone mental healthcare, in America is so fucking atrocious that I'm really not surprised by the attitudes I see around here.
@@someone-wi4xl - Are you kind of a dick?
apparently
Here after learning of Henry's death. Fuck this system.
Rest in Peace, friend :(
John is my second favorite ally. My first is the weatherman.
“That’s just a woman” is the attitude everyone should have.
@@the_polish_prince8966 *y e s*
Yee
Tras people can be anyone. If I looked at some of those people, I couldn't tell they were trans. Treat them with respect.
Until they want to reshape society to fit the needs of the few(mentally ill few) and not mass majority.
A this has nothing to do with being disrespectful I never said I would deny their humanity. Also I am aware that society and societal culture changes all the time and throughout history. I never said I didn't want change, however I don't want the wrong change. I'm confident that you know their is such things that are degressive changes within society. This is one of them. What they want are rights and laws that are exclusive to them and punish the vast majority for not agreeing with their views/beliefs. I am fully capable of tolerating something or someone even if I don't accept it or them. The problem with trans people advocating for trans rights in society today is how they do it and what its based on. They want everybody to accept them and their beliefs even though people don't have to and lash out against those who don't agree calling them bigots and at the extreme modern day nazis. Which is very degressive because that puts a lot of peoples' rights of freedom of speech, expression, and religion in strife. Another thing is when you want to claim that gender/sex(sometimes I use them interchangeably) is not a product of science and basic biology, but how one feels or thinks is when I have a problem. You don't get to subvert centuries of scientific research,evidence, and facts because you it doesn't agree with how you "feel". Another thing is they don't have any solid scientific agreeable facts that can represent their group. The closet thing they use is the "gender spectrum"(which has been disproved so many times by real scientists and their studies). They also like to use "intersex" which doesn't really apply to them since that's a REAL medical problem which orchestrated by the mind or how you feel, but caused by a genealogical disorder. Also "trans" people do have a mental illness which has a real name called Gender Dysphoria. HOWEVER, they like to claim this is evidence that they were born in the wrong body and try to fix that by going through a crap ton of therapy and surgeries to be happy in their right body. YET, end up committing suicide, cause guess what.... THEY'RE STILL UNHAPPY!!! Then they want to educate to young impressionable children that they can be whatever they want to be and science can't tell you're wrong. Which is very fricking degresive cause it encourages children to not trust in science which has proven this for millennia and enables them to live the lives they are currently living. So to recap, I don't have a problem with trans people on a basic humanitarian and basic respect aspect. I DO have a problem with they're ideologies and how they want to disregard centuries of scientific facts, because it doesn't agree with their "feelings" or beliefs. You can't just reconstruct society to suit the needs of the minority and bullying the majority to agree with or be labeled as bigot or enemy of freedom. Their is a word for that its called fascism.
The Rookie ugh, you make me sad for liking Monhun
"this has nothing to do with being disrespectful"
You literally just called an entire group of people "mentally ill" lmfao. You don't get to then try and pretend that didn't happen and say you're not being intentionally disrespectful.
" What they want are rights and laws that are exclusive to them and punish the vast majority for not agreeing with their views/beliefs"
No, what they want is to hold the same rights the both of us currently hold, which is to *not be discriminated against for our fucking genitalia* and nothing else.
""(which has been disproved so many times by real scientists and their studies)."
This is patently bullshit, but do try and prove it with a "study" and "real scientists", by all means.
" They also like to use "intersex" "
No, they don't. Transgender people aren't as ignorant as people like you and actively know the difference and important distinctions between gender and sex.
" YET, end up committing suicide, cause guess what.... THEY'RE STILL UNHAPPY!!! "
Right, because *people like you* are discriminatory pieces of shit, not simply because they're transgender. I love when idiots like you try and use that as a mark against transgender issues and people rather than the bigots that *actively* drive them into depression with bills that *actively* restrict their rights as a human.
"You can't just reconstruct society to suit the needs of the minority and bullying the majority to agree with or be labeled as bigot or enemy of freedom."
I wonder how many racist pieces of shit used this exact argument, verbatim, when discussing slavery. I'd say *a fuck load* because it literally applies to every minority group, and history shows that you're not only a bigot and piece of shit, but actively will be shown you're wrong in a matter of 'when' rather than 'if'.
You're so misinformed and ass-backwards on this issue that you actually think what you're saying *isn't* discriminatory, despite the fact that you're *actively* making the same argument racists make against minority races in the U.S.A., you know that, right? Go back to watching Shaprio or some other "educated" moron. You've done nothing but spout bullshit this entire time.
@@godlikejr.3683 but society is already shaped by the majority
Things I don't want to discuss with strangers:
1. My plans for the future
2. Sports
3. My genitalia
The X chromosome is one of the two sex-determining chromosomes (allosomes) in many organisms, including mammals (the other is the Y chromosome), and is found in both males and females. *It is a part of the XY sex-determination system* and X0 sex-determination system. The X chromosome was named for its unique properties by early researchers, which resulted in the naming of its counterpart Y chromosome, for the next letter in the alphabet, following its subsequent discovery.
@@Dichtsau That entire paragraph has no relevance in this conversation.
But the point of sports is to be able to talk to strangers about it.....
Then don’t shove it in people’s faces
4. Drag Races
5. Pride Parades
It brings me no joy to learn that Henry, the boy who was advocating for his own rights in front of legislators in this video, died by suicide on December 21st. These are the consequences of transphobia.
Nope mental illness. I'm black and I've been discriminated against. Do you think I'm going to off myself? Fuck no. He wanted to die because he was insane. I have zero respect or care for any individual that take their own life.
those people have blood on their hands, this shit is unacceptable. he deserved to live.
I think that weatherman didn't understand why they said transgender woman instead of just woman
Yeah, I think he was genuinely confused lol. Throwing his arms around didn't help though..
I agree
Exactly, I think he should be applauded for that, he thought using the term "Transgendered woman" instead of just calling her a "Woman" was dumb.
well transgender things can be confusing for people who don't have much information. when I was just discovering the lgbtq community, it confused me as well, and took me a while to figure out that "transgender woman" meant a person assigned male but became female, rather than a woman who transitioned to male. assuming the weather man knew as much about the issue as I did back then, it's easy to see how it couldve been a bit confusing
I agree. It seems like he was actually being the opposite of "ignorant." Like "Why say transgender? She's just a woman, or am I wrong?"
I really hate that those politicians can stand up and say he changed their minds... and then still vote against him. And lets be clear here, the whole bathroom thing comes down to people being frightened of men and thinking they are all sleeper rapists, so this is prejudiced from literally every angle.
Some females don't want to get naked in a dick farm.
Do you see a lot of naked women surrounded by penises in the lady's room?
+OptimisticCynic715 women don't get undressed in public bathrooms, no more than men do. And it wouldn't be a problem if we have nice private stalls that extend to all walls and floor with a sturdy lock and no gaps. Nice stalls with a reasonable amount of privacy= no unwanted genitals
+K.C. Sealey
Plus, those "unwanted genitals" are honestly an invasion of privacy on the part of the person seeing them, not the person who owns them. Not unless the person owning said genitals is outside the stall. The person peeping through the cracks in the stalls is invading the privacy of the person on the toilet, regardless of that person's genitals.
Yeah, but that costs /money/. We like our cheap, raggedy stalls that are easy to install, have just enough of a crack for everyone to see your goods, and have locks that break after 2 uses.
"The noun or the verb" that took me a second but goddamn that was funny
JOHN OLIVER YOU DROPPED THIS: 👑👑👑
Sexual orientation is who you go to bed with, gender identity is who you go to bed as.
Island Insanity sad
Trying to delegitimize a serious issue by mocking them is sad. Cat isn't a gender. You can't identify as a cat anymore than you can identify as a train, an age, or potato. You're sad, so please, don't be a bigot
Island Insanity I mean, it kinda is, except it's honestly mainly over my primary and secondary genital characteristics. Gender dysphoria isn't always physical too - it's pretty much the feeling that one was born in the wrong body. Like, being called 'sir' or 'mister' or my old, male deadname is quite distressing. Working towards presenting more as my gender identity (female) can help reduce the discomfort I feel over myself and the fact that I was born with the wrong genitalia.
+Island Insanity (Islandinsanity) it's totally okay to ask me :) Yeah, I don't associate my gender identity with my genitals - I essentially feel I was born with the wrong genital characteristics (sausage and no pancakes, as I've heard it jokingly put). My sexuality and attraction hasn't changed, really. I've always been romantically and sexually attracted to women, which means I've gone from technically straight to a lesbian. However, I struggle to feel sexual attraction to a person if I lack a strong emotional bond to them, so my sexuality and gender identity can be described as a Demisexual Lesbian Transwoman.
Things can get really complex though.
What if you're a person with xy chromosomes without male genitals who likes male genitals on people with xx chromosomes who are attracted to people with xx chromosomes and female genitalia?
The weather guy had a point, why say transgender woman? Just say woman. Not hard
Eclipse The Gambling Ocelot nah just call it Man and female
He's a little confused, but he has the spirit.
It's because he a ugly dude in a dress...not a beautiful REAL woman
Christian Gut SHE is a woman
Ugly dude in a dress living in a bubble
I remember when my friend came out to me as trans, and according to her I had the best response; “Hey, I’m trans.” “Cool, wanna play CSGO later?”
I love you
I love you
I love
Now that is pretty epic
you
Cis dude-bro here. Came in not being a fan of John Oliver, worrying about his (possibly archaic) opinions on Trans people. Left with a lot more respect for the guy.
7 Years ago these concepts were way~ more new to the majority of people and many I knew personally were much less aware of trans issues.
I hate that Transgender people still face discrimination in the ways that John O pointed out, but I'm glad he did such a researched segment to bring awareness when there wasn't much.
You can't actually change your gender.
@@troyterry6919 wittle baby needs booba 🍼
@@troyterry6919Genuine question: How does it impact you? What other people are doing with their genders, I mean. I don't care if you think it's "weird" or "gross" or whatever, I'm curious to know why you actually care.
@@milomassacre it is contrary to a free society. You can't force someone to call you what you want to be called. People are being arrested in California for misgendering people. That is fascism.
@@milomassacre transgender people can do what they want but the moment the insist I believe what they are saying is when I say no
I really was not expecting this. I- I can't express how happy I am as a trans man to see you supporting us.
I work directly with the public and see about a thousand people a day. If someone is on the line in their appearance, and I have to communicate something about them, I say "the/this individual". Is this acceptable?
@@tobiasreaper3650 I'm pretty sure that if you say for example *they need to use the bathroom* if you are talking about a non-binary person.
@@tobiasreaper3650 but for Fran's people who are of the two binary genders, male/female, go by the pronoun that they would like.
@@plixenbro5083 That's why I'm trying to make a habit of using "individual" for everyone. Based on the behavior of a good number of the people I interact with, in my brain "specimen" is the word I'm using.
@@tobiasreaper3650 I feel like that's reasonable. All I have to say more is that if the person expressed to you that they dont like to be perfered to be called individual but they would like to be called "he/she, bro, dude, sis, ect" you should call them by that. Thank you. 👍
The alarmingly large number of dislikes on this video indicates that we as a society have a long way to go.
R Yokoe Or lot's of people believe that all this gender nonsense is stupid and hate the way people are treating it as the next great civil rights movement. Personally, my beef is with the science of transgenderism. Many of the studies themselves will tell you that their research is inconclusive. Are people different because their brains are different (i.e more/less white matter) or are peoples brains different because they are different? Also, gender isn't an identity.
Gurren Zero I'm sure you've read so many studies, person who used the term "transgenderism."
Gurren Zero What studies? What is inconclusive? It's not very clear what you're trying to get across.
Gender is an identity, as is sexuality, race, and so on.
Sam Rickim Way to refute what I said and thanks for not being petty and by choosing to focus in on one irrelevant detail.
R Yokoe
The Claim: Gender is a biological construction of the brain and can experience itself as either male or female regardless of whatever character traits a person may have. The science has not demonstrated this to be true.
If you're basing your identity on things you haven't chosen for yourself, you're going to have a bad time. I'm black. What does that say about me? I'm a woman. What can you infer about my character? I'm bi. What does that mean to you?
I'll tell you what these things mean to me. They mean literally nothing. I'm egalitarian, sex positive, more liberal minded, have a passion for engineering, etc. These things that I have decided are my identity.
R Yokoe The fact that someone who had a penis is on the Vanity Fair cover showing off his/her female body indicates that there's something fundamentally wrong with changing genders. Do these people marry other people? That would be very messed up.
As a trans male, i had to use the female bathrooms in my local library, when i went inside; all of the toilets were labeled "Out of Order; Please use male or disabled toilets"
I had been blessed.
*ITS A SIGN* I’m so happy for u I wish you correct pronouns and a nice day
chargestone96 it was a joke
Angie Beattie
say that again when your daughter get traumatised by a devient in the toilets or leered at in a change room'
or beaten unfairly in a sport or has to endure a rape test perfomred by a male - I hope that NEVER happens to ANYONE - but that is the consequence of allowing these devients their so called rights over women and children
IF they'd just minded their own business and not affected the rest of us and just played in the gay olympics or trans only events it wouldnt be an issue - but with all i've stated it damn well is
Stone Artisen my daughter is a wrestler she could beat your ass any day but one gender/sex has no advantage or disadvantage in sports if they are all trying really hard and working their asses off which obviously you know nothing about
HucklePeel thank you I'm bad at explaining what I believe but you are amazing at it
I’ve attempted suicide 3 fucking times and I’ve been raped SEVERAL TIMES because I was seen as a fetish. I’ve had to limit my contact with family to text only and I have so much mental trauma from all the shit I’ve been through that I almost have a panic attack whenever I’m in public surrounded by strangers. I’m stuck as a stay at home mom because my chances of getting and KEEPING a job are so low that I have a meltdown whenever I apply to a job. Thank you John Oliver for defending trans people.
Love, I pray you find what you need.
These ignorant fools think they understand complex medical issues without ever opening a book or asking a single question. Instead they use (un)common (non)sense.
Stay strong!
you live in a third world country
@@aguy481 maybe but maybe not.
i hope you can get help
@@aguy481 I’m glad I’m not the only one who considers the USA to be a 3rd world country.
He needs to do another episode on trans rights, a lot has happened since this video
he did, I'm watching that next
@@mellymel6543 LINK THIS VIDEO PLEASE!!!
yes, like Trump's team trying to have UN human rights legislation altered to exclude transgender people. A move that won't just affect Americans but the entire world.
@@mellymel6543 please link it
I think this is it
th-cam.com/video/5d667Bb_iYA/w-d-xo.html
Friendly reminder that if you're worried about men using gender identification to sneak into female bathrooms, your problem is not with transgender women, but with cis men.
@@opiumbrella3351 they arent gunna understand if these lady says problem with cis men does that mean even us men who have no wrong intention can go to women toilets whenever we want such a deluded asshole
I disagree. There’s no real reason why the problem would be with cis men. If you ask me, the problem isn’t with transgender women, it’s with you.
@@dhmkkk
Us men? Who are you talking about, Stacey?
Solution: single stall, unisex bathroom.
@@haddinsalo8343 cis men. cis is short for cisgender which is when your gender identity matches with you biological sex
sup
if you're trans and don't present like a cis person of your gender typically would
(you're still trans)
if you keep your birth name or pick a name that isn't usually associated with the gender you identify with
(you're still trans)
if you can't/don't wanna take hormones or get surgery
(you're still trans)
if someone looked at you and couldn't "tell you were trans"
(you're still trans)
dunno if anyone needed to hear that but I sure do tell it to myself all the time lol
let's uh respect people yeah?
I very much like you
💖
Oh my God thank you ♥️🤧
if youre a trans femboy, youre still trans. if youre a trans tomboy, youre still trans.
So you’ve just said sex and biology are completely independent of gender. Bathrooms and male and female sport divisions are based on sex (urinals are made for a specific biology). Cops describe suspects based on the sex they look, not gender. The CDC collects information based on sex, not gender. Non-trans people identify sexual preference based on sex, not gender. Neither gay or straight people almost EVER want to date a man or woman that merely identify as your preferred sex, so why such attempts for transgenders to trick people into thinking they are something others don’t want. Don’t you think this would understandingly invite the deceived into acts of extreme violence against transgenders? Weren’t the fights for female rights and suffrage based entirely on sex and not gender ?Isn’t it incredibly insulting to real biological women to have trans women make such movements also about them? Isn’t sexual harassment a problem for the female sex, and not gender (especially since almost no man would ever come onto a trans woman)? So why not just keep everything the same? I have never had anyone ever tell me what a female gender constitutes. I don’t even know if I am a female gender because I don’t know the definition. So, again, just keep everything the same.
RIP Henry Berg-Brousseau
I said this to someone the other day when they said that thing about bathrooms. I said to them, "lets say a transgender man wants to go into the men's restroom, but he's not allowed to, so he has to go into the women's restroom. You know what you got now? You got a man in the women's restroom. You didn't 'solve' it, you took it for a bit of a loop.
@G G Him. Transmen (female to male) have beards, most have deep voices and body hair as well if they've undergone hormone therapy. Testosterone makes them go through another puberty and changes their bone and muscle mass. You would be surprised how much hormones change a human body. One mistake in the womb relating to hormones could well be the cause of many intersexed conditions such as transsexuality
@G G Sex is what someone is assigned at birth. Gender is, well, who someone is, how they feel, and how they feel they should be. This is america goddammit. If someone wants to be called she if they were assigned male at birth or vice versa, they should fucking be allowed to! FUCK!(i'm not yelling at you, I'm yelling at society)
Yep. I'm a trans guy and I only use women's bathrooms. There was a little girl in the bathroom at a library once who freaked out because I was looking especially masculine (I don't always pass as male) and there was a boy in the girl's bathroom!
@@cricocadazzle4439 No. Sex is a recognition of the person's chromosomes. It is not something that is assigned, like being red or blue on the gym teams. Gender is a stereotype of how a person should behave and present based on their sex. Personality is how they feel. I have no problem calling someone by whatever pronouns they want me to, but I don't want anyone with a penis in a female only space. Masculine looking women, whatever, it can surprise you, but they aren't a danger, and they have a right to look anyway they please.
Jennifer, you don't ask someone for their chromosomes to make the call to refer to someone as he or her. Don't be dishonest.
"Trans people can't go to the bathroom because I'd commit a felony if i did"
Logic 100
edit: lol this comment created a mini shitshow, so @ all my trans and nb siblings: don't read the replies
I will just have to poop on the lawn then thats only a misdemeanor, and you cant recreate the smell of fresh cut senate or legislature grass as a bathroom air freshener. XD
@@foyazzrushdie673 why don't you take a few more english lessons and then write a coherent response cause all I'm reading is gibberish.
@@johnsanuy what he's trying to say is that you don't get to decide what is male or female, what is right or wrong, only God and his work (biology, anatomy). Your not God you can't decide that, it's not a choice, like your birthday , your stuck with it until your last breath.
@@jkjkk5819 I appreciate your explanation of foyazz rushdie's comments but i'd respectfully call bullshit to the fact that his initial statement "transgender is sick" doesn't translate into anything you suggested he meant. I like your style though, of throwing your opinion in there dressed up as just trying to clarify for the guy....hahahaaa.
to the asshole responding to this: i'm trans and i am sick. i'm fucking dope as shit thanks
I love it when people complain that being transgender is a recent thing. Brotherboys and Sistergirls have been part of Australian Indigenous culture for what's believed to be tens of thousands of years, and it recognises trans people, which kinda goes against the assumption that gender dysphoria is only a recent concept from developed nations.
It's just not.
It seems like in most cultures there have been trans and third gender people, and it's sad that people don't realize that we've always existed and always will.
@@DigitalDaydreams same with some groups of Pacific Islanders and in Malaysia
600 approx AD a trans woman was killed for being trans and called a witch
Go look at ancient mythology from "classical" civilizations. Egypt and Greece had deities that clearly didn't fit the gender binary. In the Sumerian creation myth, their chief deity specifically requests another category of beings be created to handle the diversity of peoples created by Ninhursag including women unable to bear children, one with no male or female organ, and child stealing demons (that last one probably isn't a popular gender identity today).
Heck, Mesopotamia even had a specific type of priest that was said to change sex when possessed by their goddess Ishtar and the effect could be so profound that some would castrate themselves to be more like that time they were possessed by a goddess. Now, I don't actually believe that that literally happened but it is an example of mythology providing an explanation for a phenomenon common enough that the scholarly/religious caste had to explain why some people transitioned later in life instead of earlier. They wouldn't need to explain it or make generalizations if it wasn't happening enough that people asked about it.
James Endicott I think it’s Babylonian where there is a god who’s non binary technically, Asushunamir the god of the underworld fell in love with them and they have healing powers or something like that
Wow, seven years later and it’s gotten a lot worse for the trans community
It's almost as if trans women aren't women or something and being a total bigot to everyone who disagrees with you (90% of mankind) is bad public relations :D
@@trevorchester4439 90% of man mind? For a stat for that cuz 20% of Gen z ARE trans or gay. That’s at least 80%
@@avacadomangobanana2588 Gay people don't view transgenders as the gender they claim to be
Still not as bad as the starving children in Yemen and Burundi
@@trevorchester4439 sources or its not real facts. you can pull numbers all you like, without scientific backup and data no one in there right mind would believe you
This guy is a good man.
He's a Englishman of course he is
@@anndeedrich911 Jesus christ, do you hate vaccinations as well?
Ann deedrich you sound delightful at parties. I'm sure you have many friends and love ones and a fulfilling sex life.
@@anndeedrich911 You need to grow up.
@Blaire A. Because not everybody passes well, or even is gender conforming to what you think of as 'that gender.'
I'm sure they would prefer to be otherwise, but they are who they are. So deal, yeah?
There's no doubt in my mind that with time and persistence, transgender people will gain full equality in the U.S. If LGB people can come as far as we have, so can T people.
***** I've honestly never understood how the gay and lesbian community sometimes has trouble wrapping their heads around bisexuality and pansexuality. Just...you're already personally aware that liking the same gender is a thing for you, and the larger public likes the opposite gender, can it not be at all conceived in your head that someone could like both? Have you not heard of the Kinsey scale?
***** I'm aware plenty haven't. I'm not bi or pan myself, but I hear *loads* of what my friends that are have to put up with. I just don't get why that small leap is so hard for many already IN the lgbt+ community.
As for some of the less-than-savory comments, I will at least say it's far less than I was expecting. Seeing vitriol in the comments of a youtube video is, sadly, par for the course, and one on transgenderism magnifies it, so all in all this is just mild so far.
Fuck yes!
talesin- god of the internet Take a few steps back son, you're arguing pedophilia should be legal. Don't.
Gimpy i don't get this country. we say FREEDOM, EQUALITY, JUSTICE...LIFE, LIBERTY, AND THE PURSUIT OF HAPPINESS. when really it's a bunch of faux outrage and phony christian morals. as the great wrestler, The Iron Sheik would say: "FAAAKEN BULLSHIT, MAN!"
Why are people so obsessed with other people's gender and sexual preference? As long as it's not harming anyone (like paedophilia or bestiality because this can't be consentual) it's none of your business. Just imagine the screaming when a transman goes into the women's bathroom. That's exactly what supporters of the bathroom bills try to scare you with, a man being in the women's bathroom.
I mean, if you have a penis, you should just go to the one with urinals. Anything else is just asking for inconvenience.
I'm a trans woman, but even in the men's bathroom I use stalls anyway. I'd personally rather have the privacy of a stall rather than just peeing right out in the open, because those little flaps around urinals don't exactly block much
Oh my "peeing out in the open" you really are a male males have penises ! Stop lying to others and lying to yourself, no wonder people are regressive with the amount of lies around "trans' there is , You are male , better start getting use to it ,
So imagine then that a male gets into an accident and ends up losing their penis. By your logic, because they do not have a penis, they are not male. But they don't have a vagina either, so they are not female. What are they? Are they anything? Besides, I don't see how my being female negatively affects your life at all, there's no need to insist my existence is invalid just because you don't like it. There's not even any reason to dislike it, I'm not doing you any harm by existing as a female.
ahahahhahahahahaaha males are a sex class with or without a dick. You will never be female , because you say so , this is you being a liar ... you cannot change your sex through any surgery or hormones, dresses make up heels nothing , you are being a stereotype of femininity lots of women do not do femininity lot's of women don't wear dresses or heels or wear make up. What Some, not many, but the rare few males are doing is mutilating a healthy body cutting their dicks off Most won't because they love their dicks and masturbating, and fucking ! They'r obsessed with their dicks , I didn't say you didn't existat all Stop putting words where there wasn't any like that from me ! ! You are male you exist your mental issues are a problem. get some help.
You *ARE* doing harm, you are a male , and lying about it , Gaslighting is psychological abuse. Period. Females as a sex class produces ova males produce sperm,women /females are the only ones that give birth, if they chose to. You will not, can not ever do that , you are Male Not Female . Saying anything else is you deluding yourself. and *LYING* to others. Get it ,Got it , Good . That will be all. Oh And Stop Lying and Gaslighting !
I don't care to discuss this any further , as you will just try and be mental about it.
7:42 imagine... IMAGINE... Imagine having to go to bloody war just to live an authentic life as yourself. I've never heard something worse! Ideally, this man should be able to live an authentic life at home, and not in a bloody warzone.
To any trans person who has been disowned by their parents due to coming out; I am your mother now. I love you, will always support you, and will defend your right to be yourself.
Now go tidy your room. I love you
Thanks mom, you are amazing, if I could I would hug you
Roly is the Best You’re awesome, keep being yourself and virtual hugs are all I can offer ❤️
@@shrutis that’s my virtual adopted offspring 💙🤍💖
You're not my real mom! You can't tell me to tidy my room! I'm 35 *eats candy and watches cartoons* But no, that's cool that you're wanting to support and love those who don't get it from people they SHOULD be getting it from.
@@sammisabbie I may be 26 but I am your mother now, everyone deserves the love of a family and being trans doesn’t change that. Now finish your candy 💙🤍💖
Holy hell, guys, don't read the comments. Stay up here with John where it's safe.
spiritmint I'm in a fortunate position to be able to delve into the comments and hope to pull a few souls out. I can't do much as a person, but I've found I have a decent way of talking to people on youtube. I enjoy it. I like finding the people willing to talk, and maybe pulling them farther along the line of logic that seems so clear to those who are already on the civil side of history.
spiritmint Humanity depresses me...
spiritmint Good advice. Also upvoted.
Demian Haki agreed. Not sure which half is worse, the hate mongers or the ones that are hate mongers towards the other hate mongers. Both sides constantly claiming to represent morality and good judgement...
TheSlaight I actually get most angry about the people that are actually on the same side of the issue as me, but completely overdue it or ruin its reputation.
It's like a tennis doubles: You are on the same team with a partner, but if your partner screws up you may have to confront them, which sucks, because you may turn your back towards the net, thus potentially giving the opponent AND your partner the false impression like you are on the other side. In other words, unreasonable people of both sides basically force reasonable, less radical people in between to opposing sites. Annoying as hell...
The thing about it is, if you were planning on committing sexual assault on someone while they were in the bathroom, odds are you're not the kind of person to wait until it is legal to use that bathroom by claiming to be the opposite gender.
Brian Nieves whaaaaaaaaaaaaat you wanna say Guy who commit a crime dont Listen to the law ? Mindblowing!
Dominik Ffdfgg The guy who tries to sass an argument without adressing the point being made has worse grammar than the german idiot (who learned a lot of his English by watching Doctor Who) replying to said guy.
Mind. Blown.
;)
Mhh i think im offened by it. But hey atleast im German and watched Dr Who.
Dominik Ffdfgg With the german idiot I meant myself. I was trying to say that even I seemed to have a better grip on English grammar than you (with a wink though, 'cus it was a joke). To be fair, I wrote that comment as a confusing mess. Hm.
Hab es nicht ernst genommen :D fand ich nur lustig hat nämlich auch gut mich beschrieben.
i'm so tired of dealing with transphobia that im watching this video in 2021 just to hear _someone_ talk about trans issues rationally 🥺
You should watch "Ponderful". She's cis but she's a great ally, and she's extremely rational. She totally eviscerates the TERFs.
and 7 years ago at that!
Trans issues rationally??
All you listened to was LIES🤣🤣🤣🤣