"She went from 60kg to 45kg good good for her" actually with her height she's underweight, can this industry just stop being so damn toxic towards artists body image ffs
Yeah, I think they are also saving them from hate from fans since when they gain weight they actually get So many hate but overdieting is not necessery -_-
Why is everyone acting chill to Wheein saying she collapsed from taking diet pills??? They say "aw that's harmful" and then laugh it off and do things like body shame Solar. There is nothing funny about the way the South Korea views dieting, especially for kpop idols. None of these girls need to diet to the point where they feel tired or weak. A healthy diet should not leave you with no energy! They are all at a fine weight, leave them be!!!
the thing that i as a foreigner think korea really has a way to go is how they view weight gain, girls growing up with that mentality can't be good for them
Hecc, they even said it was good that Byul went from 60kg to 45kg. And when the members said they used to starve themselves, the MCs didn't even bat an eye. These things shouldn't be normal, but they sadly are in this industry where visuals are a priority...
I honestly hope they realize that they don't need to be skinny af, gaining and losing that much weight is crazy, insane, and can make so much damage to their bodies😔 that part of their culture is one I really hate
it could be also for their health so that they can perform better... I mean aya is a tough dance and they were already injured from it so I see it as health issue rather than and looking thin. (it could be both?)
I guess, they are on a diet because they need it for their comeback, like shooting, etc., they have to wear all kinds of costumes and dance, having a slim body makes it easier
@@watermelon_6419 they already say that in interview they go to the diet 1 week before they're comeback after that they eat what they want and at least they eat they don't starve herself
@@Arrow9708 honestly for me that's the make up fault, sometimes her make up make her look bad instead, but with lighter make up like this she truly looks pretty, more make up doesn't always make people prettier Only my opinion ✌️😬
i feel like this show was pretty disrespectful to Solar. they put her in so many uncomfortable situations that weren't even necessary. she's already healthy. the picture they pointed at was her at a healthy weight. she has nothing to be shamed about. i couldn't even tell whether she gained weight in the photo, it's just that the dress made it look like that.
They think they're funny smh🙄 I know is a cultural thing and they don't realize how bad those comments can affect people (cause idols are people too), but they should start to change that mentality
Also I love hwasa but, this show was for solar & for some reason hwasa is always mentioned & televised. (I love hwasa BTW) i feel like I was watching hwasa more than solar
yes my exact thoughts when i saw the comparison of the pictures... she’s a 30 year old woman and she looks excellent at that, she takes good care of herself and they have no right to comment on her body...
@@anntonettet6833 thank you! It's tough to find neutral fans like you. Like yes we're glad that Hwasa's at the peak of her career but the show was about Solar? These Korean shows are always trying to leech on the popular members smh
@@afrinsayed5902 yeah, it takes the shine of the member that's there. & that's how separate fandoms in a group is made & then fan wars etc. If you're going to invite a guest on a show to televise them then stick to televising them, not the other members.
the real question here is: when will they stop shaming mamamoo and start apologizing for their unfair treatment to our goddesses when will they stop painting hwasa as though she's lazy and unmotivated when will they stop evil editing yongsun as though she's a forceful leader when will hyunmoo stop his type of humor of finding faults in a person to make fun of it
Did you watch the full episode? They non stop praise mamamoo for how hard they work and how cool they are. Yes they tease and make fun but that’s a small part. If they don’t do that the show becomes boring. Hyunmoo can be over the top sometimes I agree but that’s the role he plays in this show.
Evil editing? Please watch boss in the mirror from the start, you will find the jokes toward yong/mmm are very tame, why idol fans keep thinking their idols are fragile baby who can't take a joke?
I love how knetz criticized the show after this episode was aired, i mean how can you paint one of the most hardworking woman that works even to the point of collapsing as though she's lazy? Hwasa couldn't even take a break, she's still on the road even after the sun rises. Really dumb editing. And solar was smiling through those uncomfortable comments from the hosts but you can see her forced laughter. The audacity to evil edit Solar's pics to fit their narrative. Have you seen Solar's abs?! She's got one of the best bodies in ent industry her body is literally goals. The producers invited them as the first idol group in this show to showcase the leadership behind the success of a group who came from nothing to one of the biggest and impactful acts in kpop but compared to how you edit theirs' to other bosses (aka MEN) is greatly different and not the good different, it's full of unnecessary and underlying mysoginistic comments 😐. You should be thankful to solar and mamamoo for giving you your best ratings to date!!! The ratings has skyrocketed form the first episode of solar so better give us something worth watching!
Its insane to me that the network hasn't apologised for this. Not only is it disrespectful to Mamamoo, but it is SO dangerous. Think of all the impressionable people who watched this episode and saw the beautiful members being mocked for eating normally after they promote. How would that make you feel? Maybe its something I dont fully understand as a non-Korean, but i cant see how this sort of conversation is in good taste for a national broadcast... I feel very strongly about this as I am in recovery from an ED and if I had seen this sort of thing when I was at my worst it would have been so damaging to my self esteem and my thoughts around eating. Shocking.
Not really they call one male boss a beggar, another is called a bragger, and one is called lazy and fat. They call Dongeun a Robot even though on boss yang chanel you can she she is nice.
@@Wot0-0 The stomach thing was BS as that's just a tight dress it shows nothing. But Hwasa does always lay down, even in I live alone (which Hyunmoo was a part of so that's why he said that) it doesn't mean she's lazy. And it's a comedy show they have to give commentary on something. (if Solar was uncomfortable she wouldn't have gone back to join with Boss Yang)
i'm honestly just glad yongsun just laughed it off when they showed that unnecessary before and after pics which aren't even a before and after because that "after" pic was taken 1 day BEFORE the "before" pic -_-''
I was also shook but I believe its the fact that she accomplished such a big milestone. Losing that amount of weight takes so much effort and is prob one of the hardest things to do. So i think theyre just praising her for working hard
I like how RBW doesn’t force them to diet. However I hate that the hosts keep commenting on their weight when they are healthy. That’s what I hate about Kpop some entertainment companies except the females to be so skinny that they look like skeletons. Also the male idols, although they have a lot more freedom in terms of weight some of them still look unhealthy. I want the hosts to read these comment and become respectful and not joke about people’s figures and beauty. This is just my opinion.
One thing that REALLY does not sit with me well is the fact that mostly people who comment on female idols bodies are either themselves overweight or older males
@@rulialee9802 I think that's what agencies do (at least for RBW and SM). They will tell the trainees to diet and conform to a certain style (hair, clothes) but once they debut they have the freedom to choose.
not only in korea. I live in Indonesia, and all the same in here. Beauty is number #1. 😌 We always joking about the motto of our country, which was originally "Social justice for all Indonesian people" to "Social justice for all good looking people".
Actually all the young girls literally look the same, they always wear the same type of makeup in korea, always the most trendy one. Although their facial shapes are diff, the girls makeup style is totally the same, plus most girls diet even though they are not celebs or even need to. I only dieted once in my life, I was 13 at 150cm and 60kg, and lost to 45 kg, then I became average, but lots of other girls do what I said before
@Joanna Ng celebrity are also ordinary people tho, they just have fame, and a reason they are famous. So if celebs can live up to it so can ordinary ppl. The only thing ordinary ppl lack is the money, fame, and motivation (celebs have ppl to push them forward in the industry while “ordinary ppl” just have themselves) I think Im fine, no one straight up mentioned my weight except for my family and other close adults around me with actual concern, but because of my insecurity about myself I ended up losing it, not towards the celeb standard. I sadly cannot answer ur question about the other girls who diet when it isn’t needed etc because I personally have very few friends, and the ones I do are not that type. I don’t know why but I used to avoid girls like that, afraid they would internally shame my body etc.(although Ik they wouldn’t, but I read too many books and watched too many movies)
@Joanna Ng I never went to school in America except for college, so that’s cool. It’s not like having a celeb face and body is a thing that people think you should have, it’s more like the people want to be that. People seem to want to have a good body over an average/ bad one and people want to look “pretty” with makeup. It’s not like people expect each other to be a celeb, but they all want to, especially the teens you know??
Same, I felt so sad watching this :'( And that other idols go through this too. They really shouldn't be encouraged or heck, celebrated for yo-yo dieting
I rarely leave comments under videos on TH-cam but this one just hit me on another level. This video reeks of double standards and it promotes unhealthy habits. Applauding Moonbyul for ending up underweight (15kg lose) was really painful to watch. I wish I hadn't watched this video. To whoever reading this comment, please eat well and stay healthy. Diets like that leads to a lot of side effects that goes unnoticed when you're young but as you grow older it'll start effecting your metabolism and therefore will lead to a plethora of issues. You're beautiful when you're healthy. Stay safe and take care ❤
even though i really hate that they pulled up those "comparison" photos (solar is literally one of the fittest female idols i've seen), i'm kinda glad that it's solar who's dealing with it on this show. she's shown time and time again that she's a strong and confident person, which allowed her to laugh everything off even though it was disrespectful to her and her members. we never know what's going on behind the scenes, but solar seems to be genuinely comfortable with how she looks and just focuses on maintaining her body/looks/health.
I really hate how they talk about Hwasa « As excepted » (she goes straight into Solar food) While Wheein exactly does the same. « What does she always lie down » Hey ! You didn’t made 3 comebacks and several collaborations this year.
Yes I hate this show. And nowadays they are putting Solar on an extremely unhealthy diet, can we all give dislike to this video to express our discontent? I don't want the girls bad treatment to be so normalized!
the way this show triggered every bad memory i have, the level of disrespect, i weight more than solar so i probably could be obese for them even though i'm healthy, someone tell them to shut up
its ok to loose weight for your health if you are overweight, or if you are unsatisfied with your body. thats totally alright. but its unreasonable to drop down your bodyweight to almost a 9 year olds weight just for some stupid beauty standards...
imagine collapsing several times due to severe diet, that's really cruel :< your body shape does not affect your talent, why should it be a big factor, right?
WE STAN THEM FOR THEIR TALENT AND CHARISMA NOT THEIR WEIGHTS! WE'LL STILL BE SHOWERING THEM WITH CRAZY LOVE EVEN IF THEY CHOOSE TO MUKBANG ALL THE TIME AND GAIN WEIGHT ❤ They are GEM🔥
lmfao they trynna level with mn** with their editing, bruh, the belly wasnt even her real belly, it was part of the dress. Solar is seriously one of many idols who really takes good care of her body, she exercises regularly, and as you can see shes not thin but lean. the disrespect is really out of this world.
Even though they say this light heartedly it's honestly so sad that the industry requires them to look a certain way. And doing it in a way that's so harmful to their bodies.
This is really eye opening! Kpop idols need not to starve themselves! Find alternatives and still be able to enjoy what you eat while in a caloric deficit! Love this!
I never understood why idols go on crazy diets or starve to lose weight. With their hectic schedule and constant practicing/training that I'm sure is already limiting their meal times itself, shouldn't they naturally be losing weight?
"she went from 60kg to 45kg" "good for her" no,WHERE is it good? i mean if she's happy okay but its sad how idols are so pressured they say things like " i was almost 60kg i had to diet"
That's a very healthy weight. Depending on the height and age of the idols this 45 kg ideal puts most idols either close to being underweight (barely normal healthy weight) or means they are seriously underweight. Considering the amount of fainting bc of diets and this unhealthy fixation on weight, I would not want anyone to compare themselves to sth. like this.
This is the Power of mamamoo in this show. Only mamamoo clips has more views than other bosses in this show. It shows how influential and powerful they are. KBS should treat them better.
Not to be that person but i don't think they should have shown this on tv especially them talking about how they ate nothing for 3 days and even collapsed this is not normal and it might look like they are glorifying it when in reality this should be condemned i understand some people might think this is their job and they just spoke about how or what they eat and things but this isn't healthy at all not for any idol and certainly not for others, women especially since we are told how to look and what to eat i feel like this just encourages that anyways i Love mmo tho they are really strong girls and stream aya
One of the reasons i like this group is that whenever i see them theyre looking healthy and fresh.... and i hope they wont be scared for a few calorie... cutting calorie too much is not also good... just eat whatever u want and stay active for fast metabolism and strength is very important it doesnt mean ur bulk ur ugly... tbh kpop artists that are very skinny made me insecure to the point that I can't eat cuz I thought having petite body was great and i had eating disorder i suffered mentally and physically like my mind keeps saying that whatever i do with my body it was not good enough even if i achieved being skinny... and then i had weak muscles and bones so I'm fragile Igot injured easily then I realized how important to eat and build muscles it is very important to help your body have those nutritious food... lifting weights and eating with proper diet helped me and now idc about body image as long as I'm strong...btw guys eat with healthy diet not just diet like cutting your food intake and starving yourself.. have a nice day...
MOONBYUL WAS PERFECT, SHES PERFECT, why did they made her to lose weigth? It was unnecesary, her metabolism changed and now she cannot gain weigth, and she want to gain weigth, and worst, they say "She went from 60kg to 45kg, go0d for hEr", what kind of desease they have? Is their mind good? 60kg for someone who is 1.63m its perfect, what the hell they say?
*From what i gathered over the years, it seems like most idols either had or have an eating disorder. That one dude from Super Junior literally doesn’t eat and they’re a veteran group...*
If I'm a host on some good for long variety show, i should make jokes that would not make the guest hurt even though for you it's a joke but for the person receiving the joke is kinda offended. That's some shit worth of professionalism they have being an idol though.
the hypocrisy "omg poor girl she fainted at the train station" but at the same time they celebrate when someone say she dieted bcs "omg i was nearly 60kg" ?????
This was all kinds of messed up. Moonbyul saying she went from 60kg (~133lbs) to 45kg (~99lbs) and them saying "good for her" is mind boggling. That's not...that's not right. Now, I know this is a very touchy subject and I truly believe that that you shouldn't change your body due to other people's views (change for the health reasons), but they're promoting that unhealthy idea. If Moonbyul is truly happy and HEALTHY then that's different, but she basically had to starve herself to get there. What bothered me too is that the hosts are like "oh they have no energy because they're dieting". THAT IS NOT NORMAL! You should not have to STARVE yourself during a diet. You can have 3 full meals and even snacks while on a diet and still lose weight or build muscle (keep in mind muscle weighs more than fat). You just have to pick healthy choices. Like, eating Eggs, some type of meat, and a carb will do waaaaaay more for you than a bowl of cereal. AND muscle helps you burn more calories even when you're not moving. But you need energy to work out and good fuel to recover your body. So, these healthier foods will aid in that. It just really upsets me when people feel the need to starve themselves for some type of fulfillment and other's encouraging it
I just love everything about them. Also solar's food looks delicious. They are really unique. I just hope normal body is normalized so that no one restricts themselves of basic necessities. :) Also i hope camera doesn't add a few pounds so idols don't have to go to extreme diets. ❤️ Go mamamoo! Inspire mo people!
Maybe the real problem is the fact that even thought they are not forced to diet , they still have to do it BCS THE MENTALITY OF MOST PPL IS BASH IDOL THAT IS NOT FIT. One way or another they have pressure to diet bcs they put a standard where idol HAVE TO BE FIT. Maybe as a fans the first thing we should learn to do is not put a world when idol are not "Sexy" Every idol in kpop is so unnatural beauty visual, and we stan them for that, but we forget most of the time that they are human too. Let's respect every one ❤️ stan mamamoo
so no one is really talking about how solar went to the hospital bc of the colon cleansers, wheein collapsed bc of the suppressors in a train station? damn
I think they need to realise that certain dresses make you look or water weight is a thing, they only know how to talk shit about other people but this woman right here does fucking pole dancing and she picked it up for a fucking music video... she is probably one of the leanest and muscled up female idols, learn what they do instead of commenting what you see from one fucking picture
@@vfb_143 Yes. Moonbyul never gained weight again. She definitely was traumatized since she was supposed to debut in another group under another company but last minute the CEO kicked her out for "being too fat". WTF?! So she lost 30lbs in one month... that's insane! She says her metabolism changed, I doubt that. Usually your BMR LOWERS when you get thinner. I believe her stomach just shrank from eating too little and so eating anything more will make her full easier/not eat more and the subconscious fear of gaining it back.
To maintain a weight of 100lbs at 5'4" is being very strict on yourself for moonstar. Appetite suppressants and Colon cleansers causing hospital trips is so dangerous. Hearing that broke my heart. Happy to see their doing things in a healthy manner now. Idol's/rapper's etc have such a huge affect our youth now a days. I already have a young patient who said she wants to be smaller than lisa from black pink and then she will feel better, she's only 12 years old. I told her that lisa does not lead an unhealthy lifestyle, she eats healthy and does pilates besides dancing everyday. And she admitted to not eating for days and then binge eating. The industries everywhere need to take owner ship and stop this. Then it will flow out to families and cultures to be healthy and fit. Gotta start somewhere.
I really love how Mamamoo dedication and self-control. I love you Mamamoo! Entertaining and funny. But I hope the editor would not be that mean in editing. I don't think it funny how they criticize one's belly. It's actually amazing how they do that l.
People need to stop portraying people's personalities in a bad way when it is not true. Buylie and Solar are both very athletic, whereas Wheein and Hwasa are more chill. This does not mean they are lazy or that they don't pay attention to their health. Screw anybody who shifts the weight/beauty paradigm in SK and shames ANY gg trying to say they should be slimmer that only leads to unhealthy body expectations to young girls who look up the these artists. STOP IT!
![[SUB] Reuniting with SOLAR💛 for a Delicious Dinner! #PARKNARAE #MAMAMOO #SOLAR](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/MG7P72liOrA/mqdefault.jpg)
![[MY LITTLE OLD BOY] looked in the mirror like this... and kissed it? (ENGSUB)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/AHijwBNjNNw/mqdefault.jpg)
![BOWKYLION - วิงวอน (ex-change) [Official MV]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/cLdnZWDaO-w/mqdefault.jpg)
"She went from 60kg to 45kg good good for her"
actually with her height she's underweight, can this industry just stop being so damn toxic towards artists body image ffs
Yeah Byulie has been underweight for years.
Depends in muscle. Bmi aint accurate
@@mightyobserver12 true my bmi says i'm underweight but i'm healthy and strong af
Yeah, I think they are also saving them from hate from fans since when they gain weight they actually get So many hate but overdieting is not necessery -_-
@Raifahyo She was underweight for many years after debut, only the recent years she's been at a healthy weight consistently.
Why is everyone acting chill to Wheein saying she collapsed from taking diet pills??? They say "aw that's harmful" and then laugh it off and do things like body shame Solar. There is nothing funny about the way the South Korea views dieting, especially for kpop idols. None of these girls need to diet to the point where they feel tired or weak. A healthy diet should not leave you with no energy! They are all at a fine weight, leave them be!!!
the thing that i as a foreigner think korea really has a way to go is how they view weight gain, girls growing up with that mentality can't be good for them
Hecc, they even said it was good that Byul went from 60kg to 45kg. And when the members said they used to starve themselves, the MCs didn't even bat an eye. These things shouldn't be normal, but they sadly are in this industry where visuals are a priority...
I honestly hope they realize that they don't need to be skinny af, gaining and losing that much weight is crazy, insane, and can make so much damage to their bodies😔 that part of their culture is one I really hate
it could be also for their health so that they can perform better... I mean aya is a tough dance and they were already injured from it so I see it as health issue rather than and looking thin. (it could be both?)
korean standard beauty for celebs is very cruel right. but their netizen doesnt look that beauty. the double standard
I know, right 😞
I guess, they are on a diet because they need it for their comeback, like shooting, etc., they have to wear all kinds of costumes and dance, having a slim body makes it easier
@@watermelon_6419 they already say that in interview they go to the diet 1 week before they're comeback after that they eat what they want and at least they eat they don't starve herself
I reaally like hwasa in this kind of make up, she looks so pretty
But others are saying that she is the ugliest kpop idol 😭😭😭😭 she is really beautiful 😘😘😘😘😘😘
@@Arrow9708 honestly for me that's the make up fault, sometimes her make up make her look bad instead, but with lighter make up like this she truly looks pretty, more make up doesn't always make people prettier
Only my opinion ✌️😬
@@Arrow9708 she's the it girl in korea at the moment from what I learned from korean variety shows.
I think she looks great with or with out makeup. She kills both looks ❤️
@@zeeh2883 yep we all should appreciate true beauty no matter who they r 🤗
i feel like this show was pretty disrespectful to Solar. they put her in so many uncomfortable situations that weren't even necessary. she's already healthy. the picture they pointed at was her at a healthy weight. she has nothing to be shamed about. i couldn't even tell whether she gained weight in the photo, it's just that the dress made it look like that.
They think they're funny smh🙄 I know is a cultural thing and they don't realize how bad those comments can affect people (cause idols are people too), but they should start to change that mentality
Also I love hwasa but, this show was for solar & for some reason hwasa is always mentioned & televised. (I love hwasa BTW) i feel like I was watching hwasa more than solar
yes my exact thoughts when i saw the comparison of the pictures... she’s a 30 year old woman and she looks excellent at that, she takes good care of herself and they have no right to comment on her body...
@@anntonettet6833 thank you! It's tough to find neutral fans like you. Like yes we're glad that Hwasa's at the peak of her career but the show was about Solar? These Korean shows are always trying to leech on the popular members smh
@@afrinsayed5902 yeah, it takes the shine of the member that's there. & that's how separate fandoms in a group is made & then fan wars etc. If you're going to invite a guest on a show to televise them then stick to televising them, not the other members.
the real question here is:
when will they stop shaming mamamoo and start apologizing for their unfair treatment to our goddesses
when will they stop painting hwasa as though she's lazy and unmotivated
when will they stop evil editing yongsun as though she's a forceful leader
when will hyunmoo stop his type of humor of finding faults in a person to make fun of it
And I'm glad the members give explanation about why Solar is like that and not like what it seems, and understand her
@@mangakuota122 it's as though they knew that this is how the show will portray solar and the group
Did you watch the full episode? They non stop praise mamamoo for how hard they work and how cool they are. Yes they tease and make fun but that’s a small part. If they don’t do that the show becomes boring. Hyunmoo can be over the top sometimes I agree but that’s the role he plays in this show.
That why I want them to change Hyunmo...f****ing hate him
Evil editing? Please watch boss in the mirror from the start, you will find the jokes toward yong/mmm are very tame, why idol fans keep thinking their idols are fragile baby who can't take a joke?
Belly??? The pictures are 1 day a part. The dress made her look like that. She's already skinny, quite your disgusting comments
Ikr? And the “after” photo is fcking one day *before* the “before” pic
It's a joke...
@@lollipopcrazed but a joke is supposed to be funny
@@diana-mw3uk if its not funny, then why is solar dying? Yall are too sensitive lol
Also, that dress makes you look like that so, it is a healthy belly and they think making fun of it is okay, in NATIONAL TV like what???
my heart hurts when wheein said she collapsed twice while trying to lose her weight,
just eat, keep healthy and happy,
moos will support you!
I love how knetz criticized the show after this episode was aired, i mean how can you paint one of the most hardworking woman that works even to the point of collapsing as though she's lazy? Hwasa couldn't even take a break, she's still on the road even after the sun rises. Really dumb editing. And solar was smiling through those uncomfortable comments from the hosts but you can see her forced laughter. The audacity to evil edit Solar's pics to fit their narrative. Have you seen Solar's abs?! She's got one of the best bodies in ent industry her body is literally goals.
The producers invited them as the first idol group in this show to showcase the leadership behind the success of a group who came from nothing to one of the biggest and impactful acts in kpop but compared to how you edit theirs' to other bosses (aka MEN) is greatly different and not the good different, it's full of unnecessary and underlying mysoginistic comments 😐. You should be thankful to solar and mamamoo for giving you your best ratings to date!!! The ratings has skyrocketed form the first episode of solar so better give us something worth watching!
@@ashleyking1146 oh so it's boring if they don't comment on women's bodies, weight ? what a beautiful world
PERIOD!
Its insane to me that the network hasn't apologised for this. Not only is it disrespectful to Mamamoo, but it is SO dangerous. Think of all the impressionable people who watched this episode and saw the beautiful members being mocked for eating normally after they promote. How would that make you feel?
Maybe its something I dont fully understand as a non-Korean, but i cant see how this sort of conversation is in good taste for a national broadcast...
I feel very strongly about this as I am in recovery from an ED and if I had seen this sort of thing when I was at my worst it would have been so damaging to my self esteem and my thoughts around eating. Shocking.
Not really they call one male boss a beggar, another is called a bragger, and one is called lazy and fat. They call Dongeun a Robot even though on boss yang chanel you can she she is nice.
@@Wot0-0 The stomach thing was BS as that's just a tight dress it shows nothing. But Hwasa does always lay down, even in I live alone (which Hyunmoo was a part of so that's why he said that) it doesn't mean she's lazy. And it's a comedy show they have to give commentary on something. (if Solar was uncomfortable she wouldn't have gone back to join with Boss Yang)
i'm honestly just glad yongsun just laughed it off when they showed that unnecessary before and after pics which aren't even a before and after because that "after" pic was taken 1 day BEFORE the "before" pic -_-''
What do you mean "good for her" ??? How is going from healthy to underweight z good thing ?????
I thought i was the only one who was irked by that line. It's just so ridiculous. It shows how much they value outer beauty over health.
fr tho she literally said it changed her metabolism and the said "good for her" like ???
I was also shook but I believe its the fact that she accomplished such a big milestone. Losing that amount of weight takes so much effort and is prob one of the hardest things to do. So i think theyre just praising her for working hard
I like how RBW doesn’t force them to diet. However I hate that the hosts keep commenting on their weight when they are healthy. That’s what I hate about Kpop some entertainment companies except the females to be so skinny that they look like skeletons. Also the male idols, although they have a lot more freedom in terms of weight some of them still look unhealthy. I want the hosts to read these comment and become respectful and not joke about people’s figures and beauty.
This is just my opinion.
Wow, never knew RBW treats their artists like people.
One thing that REALLY does not sit with me well is the fact that mostly people who comment on female idols bodies are either themselves overweight or older males
Their companies did force them to diet... Hwasa specifically. They just stopped when her body started gaining popularity.
@@rulialee9802 I think that's what agencies do (at least for RBW and SM). They will tell the trainees to diet and conform to a certain style (hair, clothes) but once they debut they have the freedom to choose.
The hosts ALWAYS want to be funny but talking nonesense about health stuff is not funny. God...
They really did not need to dig up a photo of yongsun’s barely visible belly 🙄
I would be so happy if I had Solar's belly... Next to her I look like a 3 month pregnant women 😂😂😂
Those types of comments in an open tv program omg??
I don’t see any belly tbh
Ikr, it’s disrespectful, the editor should put into Solar’s shoes and imagine if they (the editor) want to be edited like that... just curious
@@sinthiafs i cant stop laughing omg hahahahaha
....I cannot even .....the editing....
Solar s comparison...like tf how thin do y'all want her to be ...also the damn evil editing..y'all needa stop
The editing is so stupid and disrespectful
korean standard beauty for celebs is very cruel while their netizen doesnt look that beauty. the double standard
not only in korea. I live in Indonesia, and all the same in here. Beauty is number #1. 😌
We always joking about the motto of our country, which was originally "Social justice for all Indonesian people" to "Social justice for all good looking people".
@@babatiti45 yeah ikr. my country also like that, kinda sad but true. not like in western. talent first, not even look at their looks.
Actually all the young girls literally look the same, they always wear the same type of makeup in korea, always the most trendy one. Although their facial shapes are diff, the girls makeup style is totally the same, plus most girls diet even though they are not celebs or even need to. I only dieted once in my life, I was 13 at 150cm and 60kg, and lost to 45 kg, then I became average, but lots of other girls do what I said before
@Joanna Ng celebrity are also ordinary people tho, they just have fame, and a reason they are famous. So if celebs can live up to it so can ordinary ppl. The only thing ordinary ppl lack is the money, fame, and motivation (celebs have ppl to push them forward in the industry while “ordinary ppl” just have themselves) I think Im fine, no one straight up mentioned my weight except for my family and other close adults around me with actual concern, but because of my insecurity about myself I ended up losing it, not towards the celeb standard. I sadly cannot answer ur question about the other girls who diet when it isn’t needed etc because I personally have very few friends, and the ones I do are not that type. I don’t know why but I used to avoid girls like that, afraid they would internally shame my body etc.(although Ik they wouldn’t, but I read too many books and watched too many movies)
@Joanna Ng I never went to school in America except for college, so that’s cool. It’s not like having a celeb face and body is a thing that people think you should have, it’s more like the people want to be that. People seem to want to have a good body over an average/ bad one and people want to look “pretty” with makeup. It’s not like people expect each other to be a celeb, but they all want to, especially the teens you know??
I love them and having the mentality that being 45kg is more important than eating normally and feeling healthy is outrageous.
when they talked about dieting, it made me want to cry. my girls shouldn't have to suffer like that
Same, I felt so sad watching this :'( And that other idols go through this too. They really shouldn't be encouraged or heck, celebrated for yo-yo dieting
I rarely leave comments under videos on TH-cam but this one just hit me on another level. This video reeks of double standards and it promotes unhealthy habits. Applauding Moonbyul for ending up underweight (15kg lose) was really painful to watch. I wish I hadn't watched this video.
To whoever reading this comment, please eat well and stay healthy. Diets like that leads to a lot of side effects that goes unnoticed when you're young but as you grow older it'll start effecting your metabolism and therefore will lead to a plethora of issues. You're beautiful when you're healthy. Stay safe and take care ❤
even though i really hate that they pulled up those "comparison" photos (solar is literally one of the fittest female idols i've seen), i'm kinda glad that it's solar who's dealing with it on this show. she's shown time and time again that she's a strong and confident person, which allowed her to laugh everything off even though it was disrespectful to her and her members. we never know what's going on behind the scenes, but solar seems to be genuinely comfortable with how she looks and just focuses on maintaining her body/looks/health.
I really hate how they talk about Hwasa
« As excepted » (she goes straight into Solar food) While Wheein exactly does the same.
« What does she always lie down » Hey ! You didn’t made 3 comebacks and several collaborations this year.
Um Hwasa has said herself that she likes to lay down and relax a lot,everyone knows this.
Yes I hate this show. And nowadays they are putting Solar on an extremely unhealthy diet, can we all give dislike to this video to express our discontent? I don't want the girls bad treatment to be so normalized!
They said belly return for solar ? Seriously what belly ? It's the type of dress she wore , during that time she was in one of her best shapes.
the way this show triggered every bad memory i have, the level of disrespect, i weight more than solar so i probably could be obese for them even though i'm healthy, someone tell them to shut up
Ikr? Please give dislike. I hate this show so much, they are harming the girls and the viewers.
MB: 1:57 "To the other members, I look happy"
Who else was felt so bad for her at that part?
You guys are PERFECT, don't need to loose weight just be healthy.
its ok to loose weight for your health if you are overweight, or if you are unsatisfied with your body. thats totally alright. but its unreasonable to drop down your bodyweight to almost a 9 year olds weight just for some stupid beauty standards...
imagine collapsing several times due to severe diet, that's really cruel :< your body shape does not affect your talent, why should it be a big factor, right?
WE STAN THEM FOR THEIR TALENT AND CHARISMA NOT THEIR WEIGHTS! WE'LL STILL BE SHOWERING THEM WITH CRAZY LOVE EVEN IF THEY CHOOSE TO MUKBANG ALL THE TIME AND GAIN WEIGHT ❤ They are GEM🔥
this made me so sad, the “before and after” of solar was really out of line.
lmfao they trynna level with mn** with their editing, bruh, the belly wasnt even her real belly, it was part of the dress. Solar is seriously one of many idols who really takes good care of her body, she exercises regularly, and as you can see shes not thin but lean. the disrespect is really out of this world.
Even though they say this light heartedly it's honestly so sad that the industry requires them to look a certain way. And doing it in a way that's so harmful to their bodies.
This is really eye opening! Kpop idols need not to starve themselves! Find alternatives and still be able to enjoy what you eat while in a caloric deficit! Love this!
I never understood why idols go on crazy diets or starve to lose weight. With their hectic schedule and constant practicing/training that I'm sure is already limiting their meal times itself, shouldn't they naturally be losing weight?
Wow I hate how they kept comparing and over-analyzing their bodies/weight
I LOVE THEM...
bear face hwasa is blessed
"she went from 60kg to 45kg" "good for her" no,WHERE is it good? i mean if she's happy okay but its sad how idols are so pressured they say things like " i was almost 60kg i had to diet"
I watch solar in camping show, she eating so well, I love her 👍
1:48 "i was nearly at 60kg"
Me a 22 yo gal who weights 60kg and is 165cm tall: 👁👄👁
That's a very healthy weight. Depending on the height and age of the idols this 45 kg ideal puts most idols either close to being underweight (barely normal healthy weight) or means they are seriously underweight. Considering the amount of fainting bc of diets and this unhealthy fixation on weight, I would not want anyone to compare themselves to sth. like this.
@@kristin1947 you're good. Be healthy and eat well.
This is the Power of mamamoo in this show. Only mamamoo clips has more views than other bosses in this show. It shows how influential and powerful they are. KBS should treat them better.
Not only shaming Solar but the whole mamamoo...They don't need to diet all the time
pointing out yongsun's belly really wasnt it
*The girls in Mamamoo are all talented and beautiful!!! They don't need dieting, surgery, nothing!!! STOP SHAMING FEMALE IDOLS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!*
They are all so pretty with or without make up. In addition the most talented GG for me
The picture comparison was really uncalled for.😒🙄
I'm happy that they are not forced to diet but I hope they do take care of their health well.
Solar is beautiful how dare they say such words to her.
YONGSUN IS THE KINDEST NO MATTER WHAT PPL VIEW HER
Whoever showed those comparison photos are evil and going straight to hell. Our girls are so beautiful no matter what they weigh.
Not to be that person but i don't think they should have shown this on tv especially them talking about how they ate nothing for 3 days and even collapsed this is not normal and it might look like they are glorifying it when in reality this should be condemned i understand some people might think this is their job and they just spoke about how or what they eat and things but this isn't healthy at all not for any idol and certainly not for others, women especially since we are told how to look and what to eat i feel like this just encourages that anyways i
Love mmo tho they are really strong girls and stream aya
Damn...starving, abusing laxatives, collapsing. I hate that they had to go through that.
Hwasa's outfit is mood literally I would wear it everyday if my country is not hot lol
They swiftly and smoothly exposing the reality they are really great
One of the reasons i like this group is that whenever i see them theyre looking healthy and fresh.... and i hope they wont be scared for a few calorie... cutting calorie too much is not also good... just eat whatever u want and stay active for fast metabolism and strength is very important it doesnt mean ur bulk ur ugly... tbh kpop artists that are very skinny made me insecure to the point that I can't eat cuz I thought having petite body was great and i had eating disorder i suffered mentally and physically like my mind keeps saying that whatever i do with my body it was not good enough even if i achieved being skinny... and then i had weak muscles and bones so I'm fragile Igot injured easily then I realized how important to eat and build muscles it is very important to help your body have those nutritious food... lifting weights and eating with proper diet helped me and now idc about body image as long as I'm strong...btw guys eat with healthy diet not just diet like cutting your food intake and starving yourself.. have a nice day...
I like thier agency d ganun ka strict sa pagkain...saludo po ako dun kaya siguro ganyan sila kagaling kasi more energy sila...❤❤❤❤
Hwasa is such a mood and so relatable lol I feel like I'm depleted of energy all the time lol
Seeing byulyi eating well gives me serotonin knowing how she suffered in the past
The editing of this program is really trash, evil, it's not funny at all...kbs you really lost your touch
I wish them healthy metabolisms and glad they eat whatever they want but are also aware of their health and what they need to happy and healthy.
mamamoo really showed how k-pop industry works im proud that they didn't pretend for the sake of the show
Hwasa always looks so chill and comfortable
Mamamoo please stay together forever
MOONBYUL WAS PERFECT, SHES PERFECT, why did they made her to lose weigth? It was unnecesary, her metabolism changed and now she cannot gain weigth, and she want to gain weigth, and worst, they say "She went from 60kg to 45kg, go0d for hEr", what kind of desease they have? Is their mind good? 60kg for someone who is 1.63m its perfect, what the hell they say?
Ofcourse but they want every girl to below 50 kgs "such a stupid thing"
Ikr, I wanted to cry when i saw this
*From what i gathered over the years, it seems like most idols either had or have an eating disorder. That one dude from Super Junior literally doesn’t eat and they’re a veteran group...*
I understand the dieters team. :')
It's so hard and sad when there are delicious food around and you can only eat bland food in small portions. :')
I like that they talk about what they went through and how they change what they do now. Eating wise.
I just came to see all of them eat happily 🤗🤗 especially Hyejin 🥺🥺❤️❤️❤️
Let's be honest, it's not your first time here
If I'm a host on some good for long variety show, i should make jokes that would not make the guest hurt even though for you it's a joke but for the person receiving the joke is kinda offended. That's some shit worth of professionalism they have being an idol though.
the hypocrisy "omg poor girl she fainted at the train station" but at the same time they celebrate when someone say she dieted bcs "omg i was nearly 60kg" ?????
This was all kinds of messed up. Moonbyul saying she went from 60kg (~133lbs) to 45kg (~99lbs) and them saying "good for her" is mind boggling. That's not...that's not right. Now, I know this is a very touchy subject and I truly believe that that you shouldn't change your body due to other people's views (change for the health reasons), but they're promoting that unhealthy idea. If Moonbyul is truly happy and HEALTHY then that's different, but she basically had to starve herself to get there. What bothered me too is that the hosts are like "oh they have no energy because they're dieting". THAT IS NOT NORMAL! You should not have to STARVE yourself during a diet. You can have 3 full meals and even snacks while on a diet and still lose weight or build muscle (keep in mind muscle weighs more than fat). You just have to pick healthy choices. Like, eating Eggs, some type of meat, and a carb will do waaaaaay more for you than a bowl of cereal. AND muscle helps you burn more calories even when you're not moving. But you need energy to work out and good fuel to recover your body. So, these healthier foods will aid in that.
It just really upsets me when people feel the need to starve themselves for some type of fulfillment and other's encouraging it
I just love everything about them.
Also solar's food looks delicious.
They are really unique.
I just hope normal body is normalized so that no one restricts themselves of basic necessities. :) Also i hope camera doesn't add a few pounds so idols don't have to go to extreme diets. ❤️
Go mamamoo! Inspire mo people!
It's kinda sad to see our idols starving themselves and practising hard at the same time. I feel you girls :(
Glad to see so many people calling out the bullshit body shaming happening.
SEEING WHEEIN MUNCHING IS SAD BUT CUTE AT THE SAME TIME
Can we appreciate Bada for calling Solar cute and adorable XD.
Gosh their diets literally made them collapse and get sent to the ER, ohmyGod
Maybe the real problem is the fact that even thought they are not forced to diet , they still have to do it BCS THE MENTALITY OF MOST PPL IS BASH IDOL THAT IS NOT FIT.
One way or another they have pressure to diet bcs they put a standard where idol HAVE TO BE FIT. Maybe as a fans the first thing we should learn to do is not put a world when idol are not "Sexy"
Every idol in kpop is so unnatural beauty visual, and we stan them for that, but we forget most of the time that they are human too. Let's respect every one ❤️ stan mamamoo
The hosts need a weighing machine for themselves before commenting.. 😂😂😂
언니들 녹음하고 맛있는거 많이먹어,,,
진짜 복스럽게 먹는다 다들 ❤️
our baby hyejin
They deserve best
so no one is really talking about how solar went to the hospital bc of the colon cleansers, wheein collapsed bc of the suppressors in a train station? damn
Brother sister our leader is coming with great song again, be ready to enjoy the new debut ROCKSTAR!
just imagine this is just Mamamoo a 4 members group diet experience
emergency,collapse
uhhh it's scary
treat them with respect
I like how they over exaggerated everything even though all of them are just having a meal together like wth 🤢
In the bit talking about their weight they were acting like it was a drastic change and they were huge like huh
I think they need to realise that certain dresses make you look or water weight is a thing, they only know how to talk shit about other people but this woman right here does fucking pole dancing and she picked it up for a fucking music video... she is probably one of the leanest and muscled up female idols, learn what they do instead of commenting what you see from one fucking picture
Didn’t Like how They showed those pictures of solar.. also these idols wouldn’t need to diet at all.. we need to normalize that
When Byul being at 60kg was at her right and healthy weight and she lost 15kg... 😞 That's what I hate about kpop
She was traumatized by her old company. They kicked her out one week before she supposed to debut with other group.
He's 162cm right? I think 60kg is curvy because I'm 164cm and 50kg and I feel the need to lose some weight
@@vfb_143 Yes. Moonbyul never gained weight again. She definitely was traumatized since she was supposed to debut in another group under another company but last minute the CEO kicked her out for "being too fat". WTF?! So she lost 30lbs in one month... that's insane!
She says her metabolism changed, I doubt that. Usually your BMR LOWERS when you get thinner.
I believe her stomach just shrank from eating too little and so eating anything more will make her full easier/not eat more and the subconscious fear of gaining it back.
@@anneanne2509 you don't need to lose any weight.
@@carrie.m I already lost some weight now I'm 46kg as I have fast metabolism and stressed out too much 😅
I would seriously watch Hwasa's mukbang show if there's one. NO DOUBT.
I love hwasa so muchh😭😭🤣🤣💖💖
That's life stay strong
Mamamoo: "No Diet Club 2021"
Solji's willpower is what i need in life 😍🥰
To maintain a weight of 100lbs at 5'4" is being very strict on yourself for moonstar. Appetite suppressants and Colon cleansers causing hospital trips is so dangerous. Hearing that broke my heart. Happy to see their doing things in a healthy manner now. Idol's/rapper's etc have such a huge affect our youth now a days. I already have a young patient who said she wants to be smaller than lisa from black pink and then she will feel better, she's only 12 years old. I told her that lisa does not lead an unhealthy lifestyle, she eats healthy and does pilates besides dancing everyday. And she admitted to not eating for days and then binge eating. The industries everywhere need to take owner ship and stop this. Then it will flow out to families and cultures to be healthy and fit. Gotta start somewhere.
I really love how Mamamoo dedication and self-control. I love you Mamamoo! Entertaining and funny. But I hope the editor would not be that mean in editing. I don't think it funny how they criticize one's belly. It's actually amazing how they do that l.
It's horrible how they laugh, ignore, and criticise them for fainting, weakness, and starving themselves
They are just amazing 😂
they were born to be an idol with that strong mindset. i envy them they can have strong determination
People need to stop portraying people's personalities in a bad way when it is not true. Buylie and Solar are both very athletic, whereas Wheein and Hwasa are more chill. This does not mean they are lazy or that they don't pay attention to their health. Screw anybody who shifts the weight/beauty paradigm in SK and shames ANY gg trying to say they should be slimmer that only leads to unhealthy body expectations to young girls who look up the these artists. STOP IT!
Solar really lives up to her name, she’s so energetic and affects others in a way that reminds you of the sun XD