If you notice, from the stationary camera angle at 0:43 and again at 1:54 the car is not in the same exact position relative to the yellow lines. They did a car swap (probably brought the dude into the office for a minute).
well spotted have you see : DYNAMO PHONE IN BOTTLE 'TELL ME WHATS WRONG WITH THAT 1 SO MANY FLAWS YOU HAVE TO SEE THE FULL SEANCE YT CUTS DONT SHOW IT LOLZZZZZZZZZZZZZ
Well, what I did weenermeat, is I stopped the video, then I print out a screengrab and I separate the pixels by cutting them out and I weigh the different colored ones. And in the second screen grab the weight of the yellow pixels was less.
there's a cut in between where they told the guy to do something or go to their office to fill up some paperworks or something and then someone switches the car for a new one. at the end of the day it all boils down to their editing and how they present their whole magic stint in a video like this, and they do it so well. Very entertaining, 10/10
@@polichic Not what this show is about. They want the TV viewers to have the same idea that the person in front of Michael has. If you wanna see how tricks work on the public, Just For Laughs is what you want.. this show wants the viewer to see the trick how it would be there and then
You can see the tip of the yellow line @0:43 then you can’t @1:54 because the car is up a bit with the door still open and Michael now standing there. So they probably did indeed call the guy into the office to sign paperwork for returning the car and switched the vehicle out during that time 😆 I know they do this on every episode but I wished they showed it. Michael is good but not that darn good. 😝 they always cut a scene where the person has left then come back, but they never say like “hey, we only left for a second now this happens” 🤔 maybe they cut that too 😩🤣
Even the setup doesnt make sense on this one: "Oh I didn't think this one had a moon roof... let me take this charge off because we charged you for a moon roof" .. no you didn't you just said you thought it didnt have a moon roof.
They switched cars while customer was distracted. Check 0:05 the tires are parked right on the yellow tape, at 1:07 shows the tires parked in front of the yellow tape.
All they did was take the customer away and switch the car. You can make out shapes of the letters in the license plate even though its blurred and the replacement car had a different plate. Also, the 2nd car is not parked in the same exact spot, its about 10 inches further forward. And you can see a jump cut at 0:47 that does not match the action of the customer (strange head jerk) so that is where they picked up from when they brought the customer back out to the car. You can also see Michael's chin movement does not match what he is supposed to be saying in that cut even though we see him from behind and the customer's eye line is off when we see Michael now in front of the driver side door even though he had just previously stepped out behind it.
What's funny is that when someone doesn't know how the trick is done they call it staged. But when they can figure it out, they call Michael untalented. …. learn some magic and you'll appreciate the show so much more.
@@prostynick But it's all a lie for us, it doesn't show how they took the participant elsewhere while changing the car, which make it be more of a trick thing to us, to which the program should be honest, than the participant.
How else are you going to know if a window works? I've got a window in my basement that I can't tell if it's working because I've never stuck my arm through it.
Yep, if you compare 0:18 and 1:53 you can clearly see they swapped cars. Lots of editing in this show but hey, the wedding cake toppers is the best EVER!
He’s talking about a couple of the same cars. Michael said, “I didn’t think this one had a moonroof,” and the guy replied, “Yeah, there might have been a couple of them.” As in a couple of different versions of the same car lol
Some people in the comments say this is not a real magic trick and always is calling fake this magician, he do magic tricks in interviews too. Why people not say chriss angel is fake too, some people feel envy of this magician because he look so awesome doing magic with this incredible concept of trying to pretend is not magic and just something like a new tecnonolgy or something like that.
“LoOkIn aT tHe LiGhT rEfLeCtIoNs, aNd BaSeD oN mY cAlCuLaTiOnS” stfu lol you can just open your eyes and tell they did a car swap. You dont need to gauge light reflections and do mathematical equations lol it doesn’t take a genius to know they probably just walk him inside for a second, swapped the cars, and then just cut that part out.
so nobody has been observant enough to realize that it’s a different car, clearly evident by the different rims before and after the moonroof removal. First they’re silver alloy then black!
Yeah. I'm really annoyed by people's lack of imagination. I mean, I'm a little biased since I know some magic. But it's not as impossible or staged as they think. It's quite simple if you give it enough thought. (no car swap)
They swapped cars. Period. Nothing to wrap my mind around. I understand slight of hand and the amount of time spent practicing it. But it insults my intelligence when you try to get me to believe that it is physically possible. When he performs blatant fake skits it takes away from his other tricks.
Grayson Sheridan - you know about sleight of hand, but do you know about stage illusions? Because the trick is centered around an effect used on stage.
@@winterhaydn5640 Can you just save us the agony and tell us how it is done? Is the roof a rigged sliding roof? Is it a hologram? did someone switch the roof when his back was turned? What?
The top ten sing reflexion on the cars roof is in the cieling of the car. At 43 sec of vid the at 156 its on the back window signs dat they switched cars he that's probably the reason why he told him to keep the car on and I'm guessing he took the man to go do paperwork and left door open exactly how he left it still tricking him to thinking it was the same car when they came back from doing paperwork
Last night I commented on another video that I stated my opinion that it's basically acting. Although this show is funny if I don't think about this fact. Today I need one of you guys that knows how to edit videos, you can use scratches if you not allowed to use the actual video, to prove that in this video one of two things happened here; The car was replaced or the video camera's location were changed. Watch for example the location of the car before and after. Look at the yellow lines as references or the backgrounds. Anyway I personally think most are great acting.
1) Watchers of the show always complain of actors, and it's a very lame cop out. These tricks don't need actors to do what they show. They might require extra takes with different people, but there's really no reason to believe the participants are stooges. …. 2) It's not a car swap. Know why? The car door stays between Michael and the other guy during the crucial moment. It's quite implausible that the rest of the car moved during that time. Especially in the 5 second time span that we see. …. 3) The secret is much simpler than you think. Magic tricks are designed to give the illusion that something "impossible" occurred. But if you think about it logically, there's an easier answer.
To people saying it was a running car. No the car didn’t move at all the reflections at 0:43 and at 1:54 are at the same position. They are really hard to mimic. Also at the beginning of the you can Michael saying stop and the cars stops just ahead of the yellow line and its position is maintained throughout , it is easy to compare. He has multiple hidden camera at the same positions on top of each other and the best footage is selected from them. It is just a change in camera perspective.
@@suyashsngh250 I am guessing the car was rigged to have some type of roof that slides that covers up the whole. Switching the cars just seems not likely.
@@Acujeremy No it was a running car now that I look. OMG I am sorry. I was just seeing the tubelight on above the car when you look at 0:43 see the light on the rear left corner of car how it is between glass and metal but in 1:54 you can see the light is completely in the glass section. Sorry for wasting your time.
I think after he checks the moonroof and says “ok, we got…” they took the guy to sign some paper or whatever, swapped the cars, entered again in the car and suddenly “wait this one didn’t have a moonroof”
different car. first car is nearly parked on the yellow line, they distracted the guy somehow, switched cars, trick car is more forward in front of the yellow line, and had darker colored tires. the magic is, how they distracted the guy long enough to switch cars, then have that guy really believe what he just saw
0:43 and 2:16 They probably cut out the part where they distracted the guy in the office or something and switched cars. Would this be considered “magic trick” or a prank? I use to move my neighbours cars in the winter when they were warming them up just for a laugh to see their confused faces when they came out of their house. Same difference...
I was thinking he used a roll up flat TV to create an illusion that the window is opening and closing, but he stuck his arm through the hole of the window.
There has to have been some camera manipulation with this one... like they went off to an office or something and came back, but that part was edited out.
I love all their initial thinking faces. lol lol lol wait wait wait... let me try to process this through every knowledge I have in my brain on this subject.
When I first saw this show on youtube I thought he was a great sleight of hand magician. But now, after seeing this video I realize they cut portions out of the videos and he may not be what I thought. there is no way this played out as they show it. To quote some old politician...Fake News..lol
Michael sort of uses the excuse that the focus is more about audience reaction than anything else. He does plenty of sleights, but there is some of this stuff, too. I'm good with it. I know that he knows that we at home know. It's fine.
0:04 Notice the dude stopped the car front tires almost on top of yellow line. Now look here 1:06 see how far the front tires from the yellow line. What you dont know is, they took the dude away. switched cars and cameback. But they cut out so many parts of the video. You know what this called? The Carbonaro Effect LMAO its all video edited to make each video super short and trick the audience. If victim reaction sucks, they dont show it on TV. Many cases victims bust them easily.
![NISAMANEE - TADA (ท้าดา) [ OFFICIAL MV ]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/hcQHEPMmJpU/mqdefault.jpg)
If you notice, from the stationary camera angle at 0:43 and again at 1:54 the car is not in the same exact position relative to the yellow lines. They did a car swap (probably brought the dude into the office for a minute).
They shouldn't cut that now it looks fake
well spotted have you see : DYNAMO PHONE IN BOTTLE 'TELL ME WHATS WRONG WITH THAT 1 SO MANY FLAWS YOU HAVE TO SEE THE FULL SEANCE YT CUTS DONT SHOW IT LOLZZZZZZZZZZZZZ
It actually looks exactly the same. Did you pause the vid and break out your ruler?
Well, what I did weenermeat, is I stopped the video, then I print out a screengrab and I separate the pixels by cutting them out and I weigh the different colored ones. And in the second screen grab the weight of the yellow pixels was less.
onjoFilms no you didn't
there's a cut in between where they told the guy to do something or go to their office to fill up some paperworks or something and then someone switches the car for a new one. at the end of the day it all boils down to their editing and how they present their whole magic stint in a video like this, and they do it so well. Very entertaining, 10/10
The scene is cut though and it would be better to show all the action
@@polichic Not what this show is about. They want the TV viewers to have the same idea that the person in front of Michael has. If you wanna see how tricks work on the public, Just For Laughs is what you want.. this show wants the viewer to see the trick how it would be there and then
@@breakingaustin
Exactly.
-JFL: Shows you how it’s done
-Scare Tactics: Horror/Thriller
-JKX: Comedy
-Carbonaro Effect: Magic
They blend the in between cut scene so well..i was like "okay, this is different trick..or is it?"
Of course you think it s magic
I sometimes wonder if the joke is on the viewer?!
Bro it definitely is!!!! Lmao
it's all edited. Indeed we are
Yup
ya think?
Facts
Yes, we know they swapped the car...but the guys face when he removed it was priceless.
The roadrunner had those too. The coyote would paint a fake tunnel on the side of a mountain but the road runner was always able to go through it.
You can see the tip of the yellow line @0:43 then you can’t @1:54 because the car is up a bit with the door still open and Michael now standing there. So they probably did indeed call the guy into the office to sign paperwork for returning the car and switched the vehicle out during that time 😆 I know they do this on every episode but I wished they showed it. Michael is good but not that darn good. 😝 they always cut a scene where the person has left then come back, but they never say like “hey, we only left for a second now this happens” 🤔 maybe they cut that too 😩🤣
Even the setup doesnt make sense on this one: "Oh I didn't think this one had a moon roof... let me take this charge off because we charged you for a moon roof" .. no you didn't you just said you thought it didnt have a moon roof.
They switched cars while customer was distracted. Check 0:05 the tires are parked right on the yellow tape, at 1:07 shows the tires parked in front of the yellow tape.
Later that day, the same man tells someone that he has the high ground...
The moustache gets me everyime. Makes everything look alil extra😂😂
Automatic acceptance of something completely unbelievable.
How religion started....
@@ChrisDied only a dipshit like you could bring religion into a non religion discussion. GFY.
the acting makes it semi acceptable. besides, he didnt accept it -- he was still checking.
All they did was take the customer away and switch the car. You can make out shapes of the letters in the license plate even though its blurred and the replacement car had a different plate. Also, the 2nd car is not parked in the same exact spot, its about 10 inches further forward. And you can see a jump cut at 0:47 that does not match the action of the customer (strange head jerk) so that is where they picked up from when they brought the customer back out to the car. You can also see Michael's chin movement does not match what he is supposed to be saying in that cut even though we see him from behind and the customer's eye line is off when we see Michael now in front of the driver side door even though he had just previously stepped out behind it.
1:13 Haha his vest jacket gets stuck on the car door :D
lol must have been the carbonaro effect, have you heard of it? the carbonaro effect?
What's funny is that when someone doesn't know how the trick is done they call it staged. But when they can figure it out, they call Michael untalented. …. learn some magic and you'll appreciate the show so much more.
If the show was focused more on tricking the participant and not about tricking the viewer, then neither of those criticisms would be applicable.
@@NOWABOmusic The participant looks pretty tricked to me.
@@prostynick But it's all a lie for us, it doesn't show how they took the participant elsewhere while changing the car, which make it be more of a trick thing to us, to which the program should be honest, than the participant.
His BIG TALENT is just to think of the prank idea, not so its realization.
@@prostynick it's because in the actual show they distracted the client while they switched the cars lol
The guys expression at 1:30 is HILARIOUS! 🤣
Why can't sit back and just enjoy?!!!! 😷💯🤔🖤😇
What if he never told anyone at the end that it was a joke .? There would be so many lunatics everywhere...
Hahah there absolutely would be 😂 and a lot more conspiracy theorists 😆
You believe in paranormal ??
@@davidbiga7285You believe in believing?
“Just wanna make sure that’s functioning...”
*puts his arm through the open window*
“Yep, that works....”
How else are you going to know if a window works? I've got a window in my basement that I can't tell if it's working because I've never stuck my arm through it.
1:56 "These cars are working with NASA." 🤣🤣
Different car/different position: right tyre on yellow line at 0:05 and past the line at 1:08
Plus wheel rims seem darker
Yep, if you compare 0:18 and 1:53 you can clearly see they swapped cars. Lots of editing in this show but hey, the wedding cake toppers is the best EVER!
I dont see "clearly" swapped cars.
The look on his face has me rolling...😂
This is crazy enough to watch it on screen , I can’t imagine how the dude was feeling on live !
I’m done 😂😂😂😂with this😂😂😂
The guy should be questioning his sanity 😂😂😂😂😂😂
The real trick is on the people watching this video!
No, we all know this is fake. There’s no trick.
@@Kentrantran Not everyone does.
@@wartortle577 because not everyone is stupid enough to think it's fake
Everything is fake. Nothing ever happens. I am very smart.
With cut-scenes, I can make ANYTHING disappear and I can't even do a simple card trick.
Michael: Oh a moonroof!
Guy: Yeah, there might have been a couple of em.
Wtf?
In It To Spin It I think he may have thought that moon roof was another name for sun roof.
He said that the rental company might of had a couple of the same vehicle make as his that had a moon roof aka sun roof.
He’s talking about a couple of the same cars. Michael said, “I didn’t think this one had a moonroof,” and the guy replied, “Yeah, there might have been a couple of them.” As in a couple of different versions of the same car lol
He say he doesn’t know how they make it happen but then gives an explanation lmao
This Michael cannot be limited to the expectations of his actions ..!!
To those looking for tips, notice how the first car/session is with the front passengers headrest is up, then at 1:48 its down, interesting...
1:32 the dudes face is in utter disbelief xd
Some people in the comments say this is not a real magic trick and always is calling fake this magician, he do magic tricks in interviews too. Why people not say chriss angel is fake too, some people feel envy of this magician because he look so awesome doing magic with this incredible concept of trying to pretend is not magic and just something like a new tecnonolgy or something like that.
He’s so confused 😂😂😂😂😂
0:47 transition of the video but audio is being retained from the second cut.
Looking at the background and light reflections off of the roof, I can see the car has been moved about six inches. They changed cars.
“LoOkIn aT tHe LiGhT rEfLeCtIoNs, aNd BaSeD oN mY cAlCuLaTiOnS” stfu lol you can just open your eyes and tell they did a car swap. You dont need to gauge light reflections and do mathematical equations lol it doesn’t take a genius to know they probably just walk him inside for a second, swapped the cars, and then just cut that part out.
@@PtylerBeats You're the reason aliens won't visit us because they don't want to deal with assholes like you.
Who cares how he did it, he keeps us entertained.
True. I like his shows
so nobody has been observant enough to realize that it’s a different car, clearly evident by the different rims before and after the moonroof removal. First they’re silver alloy then black!
No that's magic.
That was a sick illusion!!!Mr Carbonara strikes again!!!! One of the best!!
I think Michael Carbonaro is also a hypnotist. That's the only way he would've been able to swap cars without this dude knowing
Your comment gave me the answer to how he did it, it seems so obvious now; he gave him Roofies :p Moonroofies... ok ok, I'm going...
@@SeeOurWrecks ha ha
Now that one really woulda confused the hell outta me
This show is trying to play a trick on the audience, not the "participant"
or is it ..???
Exactly
I hate people who say the people are paid actors lmao.
He is either an actor or they took him to a different area when they swapped out the car.
What a handsome man! Couldn't even pay attention to the trick lol
it's like he was having a fever dream.
Cars working with NASA! LOL. Got em'
This man looking like what the hell just happened 🤣
second car was at a slightly different (more forward) position than the first :)
So the guy is returning the car to a car rental company that doesn't exist. I wonder how that works.
Obviously the car has changed position a little bit
Bro is still confused till date
Its intereating seeing how everyone inspects for themselves and talk to themsleves when left alone
Bro great illusion got so many haters that can't wrap there head around it😂
Yeah. I'm really annoyed by people's lack of imagination. I mean, I'm a little biased since I know some magic. But it's not as impossible or staged as they think. It's quite simple if you give it enough thought. (no car swap)
They swapped cars. Period. Nothing to wrap my mind around. I understand slight of hand and the amount of time spent practicing it. But it insults my intelligence when you try to get me to believe that it is physically possible. When he performs blatant fake skits it takes away from his other tricks.
Grayson Sheridan - you know about sleight of hand, but do you know about stage illusions? Because the trick is centered around an effect used on stage.
It's fake mate if u don't know that 🤣🤣👍
@@winterhaydn5640 Can you just save us the agony and tell us how it is done? Is the roof a rigged sliding roof? Is it a hologram? did someone switch the roof when his back was turned? What?
I can't figure out how he does those tricks.... giving me sleepless nights
If this was my show I'd never tell them it was all joke or magic
The top ten sing reflexion on the cars roof is in the cieling of the car. At 43 sec of vid the at 156 its on the back window signs dat they switched cars he that's probably the reason why he told him to keep the car on and I'm guessing he took the man to go do paperwork and left door open exactly how he left it still tricking him to thinking it was the same car when they came back from doing paperwork
dat???
Last night I commented on another video that I stated my opinion that it's basically acting. Although this show is funny if I don't think about this fact. Today I need one of you guys that knows how to edit videos, you can use scratches if you not allowed to use the actual video, to prove that in this video one of two things happened here; The car was replaced or the video camera's location were changed. Watch for example the location of the car before and after. Look at the yellow lines as references or the backgrounds. Anyway I personally think most are great acting.
1) Watchers of the show always complain of actors, and it's a very lame cop out. These tricks don't need actors to do what they show. They might require extra takes with different people, but there's really no reason to believe the participants are stooges. …. 2) It's not a car swap. Know why? The car door stays between Michael and the other guy during the crucial moment. It's quite implausible that the rest of the car moved during that time. Especially in the 5 second time span that we see. …. 3) The secret is much simpler than you think. Magic tricks are designed to give the illusion that something "impossible" occurred. But if you think about it logically, there's an easier answer.
He just did a Looney tunes gag in real life
It’s the old cartoon hole gag! 🥸
why didn't they show us that they swaped the car?. it felt like the trick was played on us.
2:06 How to scratch your paint 101.
Who cares bruh, itll just be a micro clearcoat scratch if anything
To people saying it was a running car.
No the car didn’t move at all the reflections at 0:43 and at 1:54 are at the same position. They are really hard to mimic. Also at the beginning of the you can Michael saying stop and the cars stops just ahead of the yellow line and its position is maintained throughout , it is easy to compare.
He has multiple hidden camera at the same positions on top of each other and the best footage is selected from them. It is just a change in camera perspective.
So how was this trick done?
@@Acujeremy Don't ask me. I am not a magician.
@@suyashsngh250 I am guessing the car was rigged to have some type of roof that slides that covers up the whole. Switching the cars just seems not likely.
@@Acujeremy No it was a running car now that I look. OMG I am sorry. I was just seeing the tubelight on above the car when you look at 0:43 see the light on the rear left corner of car how it is between glass and metal but in 1:54 you can see the light is completely in the glass section. Sorry for wasting your time.
@@suyashsngh250 I still can't figure out how this trick is done. This is one of the greatest Carbonaro mysteries.
@ 1:27 he started towards the twilight zone.
now, this show is obviously made for you to discover how the tricks are done more than to laugh at them.
0:05
Top Ten Rent a Car? 🤣 Nice try Dave Chappelle Magic Hour!
I think after he checks the moonroof and says “ok, we got…” they took the guy to sign some paper or whatever, swapped the cars, entered again in the car and suddenly “wait this one didn’t have a moonroof”
I bet he drove the car in a 'circle' And swapped cars when out of sight
different car. first car is nearly parked on the yellow line, they distracted the guy somehow, switched cars, trick car is more forward in front of the yellow line, and had darker colored tires. the magic is, how they distracted the guy long enough to switch cars, then have that guy really believe what he just saw
Another one of those fakes cameraclip cutting tricks
Guy: "Come again?"
0:43 and 2:16 They probably cut out the part where they distracted the guy in the office or something and switched cars. Would this be considered “magic trick” or a prank? I use to move my neighbours cars in the winter when they were warming them up just for a laugh to see their confused faces when they came out of their house. Same difference...
The real Carbonaro Effect is played on us.
Comments crack me up! Its fake it's fake lmao... No sh*t.. Nooooo he actually just removed a moon roof..
friend what good videos do you have I congratulate you
I was thinking he used a roll up flat TV to create an illusion that the window is opening and closing, but he stuck his arm through the hole of the window.
This was not a continuous shot. Too bad they air this. I love his real tricks though
if the trick is swapping the car and you present it to us like it isnt then this is just lame
It's called magic. The goal of the show is to fool the victims not you.
There has to have been some camera manipulation with this one... like they went off to an office or something and came back, but that part was edited out.
Please look for the episode of store credit with doll. GENIUS....
I thought Carbonaro Effect is not about illusions created from video editing.
this is a clip from an episode they can’t post the whole thing so that’s why a lot of things are cut out in this so you don’t see everything
I love all their initial thinking faces. lol lol lol
wait wait wait... let me try to process this through every knowledge I have in my brain on this subject.
Leave the car running. So that when we wana swap the cars u dont hear a new car starting. While u are in the office for a few seconds. 😅
Wait for camera switch
That guy has a great beard.
When I first saw this show on youtube I thought he was a great sleight of hand magician. But now, after seeing this video I realize they cut portions out of the videos and he may not be what I thought. there is no way this played out as they show it. To quote some old politician...Fake News..lol
Michael sort of uses the excuse that the focus is more about audience reaction than anything else. He does plenty of sleights, but there is some of this stuff, too. I'm good with it. I know that he knows that we at home know. It's fine.
So creazy Michael You Awesome 😀😁😂
Cant believe they got a hold on the same people from the chevy adds
High quality actors i must say
I was kinda shocked, but then he said NASA and that cleared it up.
One second let me come back till then u can stay confused
I love this feature on my Honda
0:04 Notice the dude stopped the car front tires almost on top of yellow line.
Now look here 1:06 see how far the front tires from the yellow line.
What you dont know is, they took the dude away. switched cars and cameback. But they cut out so many parts of the video. You know what this called?
The Carbonaro Effect
LMAO its all video edited to make each video super short and trick the audience. If victim reaction sucks, they dont show it on TV. Many cases victims bust them easily.
He should tell people it is possible because of a controlled glitch in the matrix 😅
The editors are awesome!
This one kinda killed it for me... Obvi the dude was in on it.
Fake or not, this guy is hilarious...
How does he do this stuff
That chap could not give a toss all he wanted was money back
I watch this video again and again just to see this bearded cutie😁
Proof some of these are staged if not all.
I want the extended 😁 😁 😁