I am a soft-side luggage user and assume everyone else who is, too, uses the trick of inserting a large plastic garbage bag in their luggage first…then pack your stuff INSIDE the bag. It acts as sort of a skin against theft - you’ll know right away if someone messed with your sealed bag - and adds some level of waterproofing to the contents. Works for me!! Thanks for another great vid!💕
We've used this tip for quite a while. On a recent trip I was really happy that we did! We got to the hotel and dropped the luggage in our room and went out. When we got back there was an unpleasant odour in the room. We narrowed it down to the luggage. It smelled like dog urine! We took the luggage outside on the balcony and pulled the clothes out of the plastic bag inside. The clothes were fine but we ended up tossing the luggage and buying new (hard shell replacement) I am guessing that there were animal travelling with us on a flight.
Great idea!! 1. I once saw a young woman crying at the airport at 10pm -- her suitcase broke- stuff all over. She would have given anything for a garbage bag .... 2. Packing clothes etc into a Garbage bag first would have helped my kids. Their flight delayed bcuz of weather, they looked out to see all the luggage trolleys standing outside in a downpour for an hour in NOLA. 🌧️😟
It helps to use 3M Scotch Guard or NikWax type coating for added water resistance for soft shell suitcases (just do this a few days ahead). Weirdly, when locks are on my bags, they were more likely to be opened/searched. Now I use tiny zip ties and then a bright ribbon over it to secure (& identify) my bag and I've somehow been lucky and have not had any bags opened when just a ribbon is visible. 😅 (Knocking on wood!)
Sofe side. 1. I never check bag. Carry on and personal only 2. I spray my luggage down with Permethrin. Kills bedbugs, fleas, etc on contact for 30 days 3. Soft luggage will most likely fit in the luggage check if over stuffed. Stomped my bag down in the bag check to make it fit. Saved $100
I recently saw a review of a hard shell with a top lid and one large compartment. It was too expensive for me but I really hope the style of it catches on because you are absolutely right - the main advantage of soft is the ease-of-use. If a top loading hard shell becomes the norm then it will easily win over soft shell, for me.
Recently, I've had two hardshell suitcases broken by baggage handlers. Expensive, well-built luggage, and the wheels were crushed back into the suitcase shell. Two flights in a row! Found a soft-sided with much sturdier wheel attachments, and it flexes when treated roughly (instead of breaking).
The same happened to me. Had an expensive, hard sided bag that I took to Israel. Obviously, it was dropped from a high distance and the wheels were broken off and the bag would not close. It was a zipperless bag and had two heavy duty locks. One still worked, which is why my garments didn't fly out. But I trashed the bag and asked for a refund from United.
As a frequent flyer, my choice is NEITHER of what was presented in this video. I have a top zipper bag with a side and a bottom waterproof pocket. It is a tennis player's bag that I bought in 1984 and have carried onto at least 500 flights. Both hard and soft-sided luggage have to be laid flat to open with that long zipper. I can reach into the overhead compartment, unzip my bag a few inches and reach my hand inside to find anything I need inflight. My laptop goes n the side pocket and my passport/cash etc goes in the bottom 'secret" compartment. As for durability, my bag has never been washed and is now 40 years old.
Some good points, but for a carry-on I choose to use a 2 wheel soft case. The most vulnerable points on any suitcase are the wheels. Recessed wheels on soft carries gives far greater protection as well as more capacity in the interior. Some European budget airlines have strict restrictions on weight and size and soft cases are usually much lighter. My Samsonite soft carry-on only weighs 1.7KG (half the weight to all the options shown in this video!) and I suspect I can fit more in it than all the options given as well. Most hard shells have clamshell interiors as well which is not an efficient design for packing. Good soft cases will already have some water resistance, but if you are really worried about the rain, you can always get a light waterproof suitcase cover.
Another consideration is two wheels or four. Nearly all hard shell luggage will have four wheels. Soft sided luggage will often give the option of two wheels. Four wheels will allow 18 inches of storage in a 20 inch bag where a two wheel bag will give you the full 20 inches, minus the corners where the wheels are located. So you get 10% more room in a two wheel bag.
I have a very ‘past it’s use by date’ soft shell suitcase which has two wheels. All the new ones that I’ve seen have four and I constantly watch suitcases rolling away from the owner when they let go of it. Mine doesn’t do that and I love it for that. Wish I could buy one with just two wheels!
Megan, thank you for another excellent comparison video. Personally, I use a TravelPro softshell, which has come in handy with an expandable zipper that gives you a little bit of extra space when you need to squeeze a few more items in it. Weight-wise, it's never been much of an issue for me, but I have yet to test the softshell in the rain. Moving forward, I'll carry a plastic bag in case I ever get caught in the rain. 😁Luggage for many will always come down to price. As long as we can all get out, see the world, and share new experiences, that's all that really matters.
I've traveled with the same TravelPro soft-sided suitcase since the early 90s. TravelPro has replaced both wheels for me and also repaired some wear on the edges. It's flown a few million miles and has covered several miles over the cobblestone streets of Vienna and other cities. Unfortunately the handle detent won't keep it extended any more, so I'll have to replace this bag after only 30 years.
I've had hardshell for over a decade but grew aggravated by the clamshell and how inconvenient it is at destination. I've migrated to soft sided luggage entirely for this reason.
I’ve been using a Rimowa polycarbonate cabin bag for the past decade plus and recently moved to soft sided luggage for the same reason. Clam shell design is so awkward. So far very happy with switching.
Most thieves know about the pen trick to defeat zippers, so most hard-sided luggage are NOT more secure than soft-sided luggage. I would only consider the higher-end hard-sided luggage that use latches instead of zippers as being more secure.
I laughed a lot when you modeled the pulling of the hardshell versus the softshell suitcases. 🤣🤣🤣 Thanks for the info, I had just bought a new hard shell and can’t wait to use it on my next trip😉
I am used to travel in Europe and mostly just carry on only. So it's really important for me to have light weight luggage, because of weight limits of most of airlines. After long searching I found the best for me. It's AeroStep from American tourister 🎉Volume 36-40l and weight only 2,3kg❤
You can pack more stuff into soft luggage because it expands unlike hard sided luggage. Also, a lot of hard sided luggage isn't as secure as you'd think because a sharp cutting tool can slice right through them. Also they can be crushed in instances were soft sided luggage will bend and give to pressure. Another superior feature of soft sides luggage is that they're more user friendly because they have outside pockets that are easily accessible as opposed to having to open the entire hard sided case to access the contents. Soft sided luggage is easier to pack as well. Lastly, soft sided luggage is much easier to fit into an overhead. I use hard sided luggage when I have to check a larger suitcase and it's at the mercy of baggage handlers but always use soft sided with carry-ons and I've had my soft sided case for years, if you purchase a good one they last just fine.
To say that a soft-sided suitcase is better because you can over stuff it and stretch it, and that you can compress it to fit into the sizers are diametrically opposed statements. If you can over stuff it and stretch it then it's not going to fit into the sizer or no matter how much you compress it. I was hoping with the title saying new airline rules that you would finally cover suitcases that actually fit the airline regulations for size. When are all of the carry-on manufacturers going to come out with a carry-on case that actually meets the regulations???? I'm so tired of reading through hundreds of items on Amazon to try to find one that meets the regulations. It's very frustrating!! I especially love it when in the description of the item it's specifically states that it meets the size restrictions for airlines and it actually gives the names of the airlines but then when you read the dimensions of the bag it does not. Please Megan, use your influence with these companies to try to get them to make bags that meet the requirements!!! I like the quality of the level eight bags but right now I am in the process of ripping off the front laptop compartment door of mine to trim it down, and glue it back on to the front covering the opening, so that it meets the requirements! Seems strange but it's better than tossing 180 bucks away.
@@JD-zt3nr Well, all I can say is that I do it all the time without issue and I travel a lot. The only time it's been questioned was at the airport in Barcelona a few years back but it fit into the overhead there as it always has. It's an American Tourister nylon carry-on that I've had for years. So maybe it's a tad smaller than newer ones; it does appear just a hair smaller than my wife's which is new but the difference really is negligible.
I have to add this to your equations. We were on a sailboat that sunk. They were able to get our luggage off a few days later. I had just bought at TJ Maxx the Samsonyte hard sided luggage. That was in 2015 I am still using the suitcases today, even though they were in the bottom of the ocean for a while.🤷♀️🏝️
Our sweet spot is our Osprey soft-side carry-on size rollerboards AND we only do air-based travel a few times a year (often to Europe from Canada) and we utilize "Zone 2" boarding, so we can avoid checked bags. Our Ospreys have built in compression flaps that are brilliant and I use a high-end waterproof spray on the exterior.
@clyster3000 If that was for me ..... 2 wheels. You get more capacity with only 2 wheels, it's lighter, and I prefer it. I don't like my suitcase to roll downhill on its own. Some very high end suitcases have a break, but I've never had one of those.
It doesn't matter. Ramp workers will break both hard and soft sides. We just switched to Amazon Basics Ripstop Wheeled Duffel Bag for Travel, Travel Bag. Ramp workers will also break the pullout handles.
9:41 I had already two flights with UAL, where a gate agent made me check in my bag at the gate. Everything with a battery in my bag had to get out. So do not forget to pack a cotton bag into your carryon.
I have used Rick Steves' Rolling Carry-On for 13+ years. It has a molded frame, making the back hard but the front soft-sided. It's 6.5 pounds and $180.
You beat me to it. I was going to mention this one. Thinking of buying one. The dimensions(53.5 x 35 x 23 cm) also make it compatible with most airlines in the world.
Your comparison towards the end, too cute. I don’t travel much, but when my t. handle broke on my soft while on a trip, I had to immediately buy a new case. I found a hard at a local store. My last trip, I had one of each, so could enjoy the benefits of both. You nailed it perfectly in all of your categories. For me, needing more space to open the hard is the only aspect that I find annoying.
Very helpful episode today. I am considering new luggage after 22 years of reliable service from what I currently have. It is hardside. Thought about soft, but decided for hard instead. Thank you for the vlog enjoyed.
Rolling duffle is my way to go, I have a Samsonite and the web handles are a little long which allows for slinging the bag on a shoulder which was great when in London and using the tube and not looking so dorky pulling luggage through the tube.
I use the Ebags TLS Motherlode Wheeled Duffel. 29 inch. It’s part hard shell and part soft. It has lots of space on both sides. The protection is great because I put my clothes in the soft side and anything else in the hard side. I can also access the soft side via a front zipper without opening the whole thing. I always check a bag and use my backpack for under seat.
I am a big fan of Hard-sided suitcases & and have been for awhile. I find them lighter (in general) and more durable. In fact I just bought a Mixi carry on (hard shell) that opens at the top! Love it and it’s so much better than a clamshell opening for a carry on!
A lot of small group tour companies like OAT tell you NOT to bring hard shell luggage because of difficulty getting into the smaller vehicles you will be using. So evaluate your travel before buying.
Thanks Megan. I picked up a hard sided Verage set last year and am very happy with it. Four flights so far, one international and they came through beautifully. Really like their construction and features.
I love my 19 inch Delsey hard shell after years of loyalty to my soft side. The hard shell fits the US carryon size restriction. Whereas when I have used soft side in the same size configuration I have had a few airlines that have pulled it to check on without bothering to check the sizing bin. Having multiple airline employees in the family, I have been told that airline employees know people can overstuff the soft sides, so they go for them first when pulling luggage at the gate for carryon.
So the one thing I found with most of the hardshelled cases is that they have the lock built-in and it's TSA certified (meaning anyone can get a key). As far as baggage handlers are concerned I"m not that concerned about when it's being checked by TSA but more so when it's at my destination, as I tend to lock my laptop and any camera stuff I'm not going to carry with me, in my bag luggage bag as I feel this can be more secure than carrying around expensive items I am not gonig to use while out and about especially in foreign countries, but also in general. And I'm aware that a no bag is completely immune to being broken into, and the locks only buy you time from someone getting in. So the ballpoint trick has me concerned. I've been trying to find an affordable hardshelled case that doesn't have the built in locks but rather just clasps that accomodate a lock so I can then use my own non-TSA lock with when I get to my destination (I stopped locking my luggage for TSA to be honest since it seems they would cut of the locks even if it was TSA certified). So I now bring non-TSA locks to use when I get to my destination. (I don't necessarily see the built-in TSA lock as a security feature though. I wish they didn't build these into the bags.) All I'm looking for is a bag that preferrably is hardshelled, doesn't have a zipper (maybe a hard seam with a rubber gasket to keep water out) and most importanly, no built in lock. I guess a Pelican case may be the only option that i can see (or some other similar hard-shelled case that is not necessarily meant for clothing). I will say that Samsonite bags can be decent from a durabltility standpoint. I know the more expensive versions do last longer, but for example, I managged to pick up a small roller carry-on bag for about $80 on sale (normally it was something like $150) about 10 years ago, and that bag lasted me well over 10 years (just retired it this year and found another one ,as the wheels became damaged and are hard to replace on some models, so Idecided to just get another one, but for $8 a year, that wasn't a bad buy). It had probably 200k miles of use on it and possibly more as I stopped keeping track after a while, but it lasted a long time, so there can be some good deals out there (but I also don't overpack my bags either). I've found that the airlines that include free carry-on do not weigh them in 95% of cases, but budget airlines like Spirit and Frontier are well known for this since their baggage fees are higher and it's pure profit for them (and they're planes tend to be smaller since they only fly narrow-body jets anyway). But for example on a Delta flight 6 years ago I had roughly 45 lbs in my carry-on and nobody cared (had to wiggle it into the bin but it fit; thus saving me a $50 checked bag fee). I also overloaded a backpack that barely fit under the seat (Same flight) with about 15 lbs.
I Thought you Were Saying Your Name was “Rick Steves”,but After I Saw Another person comment “Rick Steves” I Looked it Up. It’s an Interesting prospect.
Love the soft shell for ease of access and able to fit easily. Also has handy external pockets for documents. What I don’t love is the chance that you are forced to gate check your luggage because flight is packed. This leads to chance that it is exposed to external weather such as rain or snow which then mean your soft shell luggage acts more like a sponge. If you are not sure what I am talking about simply take the water hose and put some heavy object on your luggage and water it. The pressure is like when other luggage’s sitting on top of yours like the typical luggage cart. Really cheap hardshell luggage isn’t any better in that they tend to crack or open very easily after 1-2 flights. It because not only luggage handlers but also the luggage sorter. There is TH-cam videos of these sorters in action and even I was surprise how much force they use to sort luggage.
I've only ever had softsided luggage mostly because I prefer the two wheel configuration to the four wheel on rolling luggage and I do like the expansion zipper on my softsided items also. I can have a packed full carryon on the way to my destination, then add space for some souvenirs and check the bag on the way home where it matters less if my bag is lost/delayed.
Great comparison review. I have an 'Away' brand hard shell carry on, but I avoid placing my MacBook or anything of value inside, because of the remote chance the flight runs low on overhead space and requires me to check my carry on at the jetway. I also carry a very small backpack that qualifies as a personal item for my laptop, phone, snacks, etc. So, in my case, I could actually use either a soft sided or a hard sided carry on.
I work in a cruise line & saw how they throw luggages when they deliver it to the rooms. Most of the time it's the hard luggage that gets broken or loose wheels. So I always use the soft one & it can expand more. Breakable items can be wrap & place in hard plastic containers inside the luggage. While hard case is very limited to expand. Not a fan of hard case since I've done 50 int'l flights.
A hardsize suitcase wheel was damaged and jammed into the shell after last cruise. Cruise luggage handlers have been vocal complainers about size and weight of bags when taking it at drop off or pick up.
I travel internationally and I've been soft shell for decades. Due to some growing dissatisfaction, I recently switched to hard shell and I'm happy I switched. The hard shell is more challenging to pack, but it's better for everything else. I don't plan on switching back.
I spent several decades as a road warrior (consulting). My go-to has always been a hard-sided, two wheel carry-on from Delsey. I always avoid zippers, opting for a metal ring design at the joint with proper locking latches (metal to metal closure) - I'm surprised none of the hard-siders shown were zipper-free. The only soft-side I'd even consider would be the TravelPro top line models, but I'll stick with my hard-side till I can no longer get it.
My bag is a combination hard side and soft side. The bottom area below the zipper and around the wheels is hard, but the top is soft sided, so it expands if needed and is easy to pull items out if needed without opening the whole bag. If I'm not sure if my bag is overweight, I will put things that I can pull out easily to meet the weight limit within easy reach. I've had the bags for over 15 years and love them!
My suitcase got left out in the rain during a trip to Florida Disney World. Everything got wet. That would not happened if I had a hard shell. I’ve been traveling with a hard shell now for a long time and I love it. I have an Away suitcase. I have had it for years now and it held up great. I learned how to pack really light. It actually makes things easier. used to pack a lot when I used soft suitcases and I ended up not using the half the stuff 😊
Soft sided 2 wheel for me, but I do carry on so abuse by baggage handlers not so much an issue. As my ancient but still very practical Atlantic carry on still does the job I will keep it till it can't. Then probably a Travelpro Maxlite 5 as a replacement. Lots of great info to help make a choice in your video.
If you dont travel much like me you lean to price but the most important thing is the durability of the wheels and handle extension because nothing else matters if that breaks, also the bigger the wheels the easier it is to drag over rough flooring like tile with deep grouting..BTW I am leg man and your outfit in heels is quite stunning
I've been looking for a soft sided carry on due to being able to select one's with expanders unlike the hard shells. However, the mention of bedbugs has really made it me rethink it! Thank you for mentioning this as it was never something I had considered before.
I use the Topo Design Global Travel Bag Roller (meets the KLM / Air France / British Air maximun size for carry on) which is not cheap… but incredible - combining the advantages of both soft & hard shells, while adding the versatility of a backpack option. Easily the best bag I ever travelled with!
Delsey (black) spinny wheel 22" soft! It's light and has pockets so I don't have to open the bag for a passport or to stash my phone for a TSA screening, and I can jam it into something , like the overhead or that luggage cage they have at the gate to measure your bag
@@PortableProfessional I find that some bags, both hard and soft don't fall within the TSA measurement guidelines. An inch here, or don't take into account the "expandable" feature or the measurement "don't count the wheels".
I would certainly recommend avoiding hard surface cases for both checked-in AND carry-on luggage. Very difficult to pull both at the same time. Whereas a soft bag can be sat on top of the larger hard hold case.
the 2 trips i have done with friends i have used only hard shell and thats just carry on. For West Jet, they have a pretty small overhead bin space. Soft shell suitcases are almost better for westjet.
Hardshell for: - super packers that stuff a lot - people that’s going to stay in the same hotel room more than 3 nights - stays in decent hotel - access to car to / from airport / train station - vacationers Softshell for: - light packers - people that moves on quickly so no time to unpack - stays in backpackers hostel - have to rely on foot / public transit to / from airport - professional working on the move What you get depends on what kind of travelers you are. Another thing, I’ve noticed a new kind of hybrid carry-on luggage is getting popular in Asia, I think Japan’s LOJEL started the design. Essentially a hardshell trunk with front opening and expansion. I got a Thai “UPRISE” branded luggage of this design and it’s superior to my Level8 and Monos “pro” luggages
Personally I prefer a good carry-on sized backpack like the Osprey Fairview 40 or the Aer Travel Pack 3 (Regular 35L or Small 28L) I have all three and find them just way more convenient than lugging around a suitcase!
Great advice with lots of options. I also think it depends on how often you have to check a bag either by choice or at the gate. The way the handle luggage is criminal. Just look at the video of how they handled a college golf teams clubs.
I bought a Mixi hard shell carry on that is top-opening, like a softshell. It’s great. I also find hard shells are slimmer, without those extra pockets on the outside, so they can be easier to fit in tight spaces even though the don’t compress.
I’m on the fence about hard or soft shell luggage, Meagan. I personally like suitcases that only have two wheels that are recessed in the body. I’m Andrew. I have a Travelpro maxlite 4 suitcase. But it’s soft shell. I’d put my valuables (meds, headphones, cellphone, laptop, etc) in my backpack (personal item) anyway.
I’ve selected the Antler Brixham soft sided Carry-On at 1.9kg. 4 sets of dual wheels and TSA lock. I’m planning to put a cover over it to keep it nice looking and security.
Really great video, well produced and concise. I have spent hours on TH-cam and the Internet on the issue of hard shell versus soft sided. Ultimately came down to soft sided for me. As you point out this is a matter of personal preference. For me the two big issues were the clamshell opening (don’t like that) and the flexibility of the soft sided.
I have a hard side carry on from Samsonite and a 24 inch soft sided when I know I'm going to be checking a bag. I'm checking less often now and have had better success getting around with the carry on due to the 360 wheels. I tend to take the larger suitcase if I am cruising, as I will only unpack once. The 24" does stow neatly under the bed, which helps as the cabins are usually on the cozy side.
I’ve flown a couple million miles and finally converted to a hard side after yet another incident where some hideous liquid in someone else’s bag burst and ruined my (expensive) soft sided bag. Gate check is the devil and not in my control. Hard side bags keep my things (and my bag) safer.
I use my North Face base camp duffle bag with wheels (2 wheels) and love it. I also own North Face duffle bag/backpack for more mobility. It's easier for me to store in the overhead bin. For personal items, I use my Fjallraven Classic kanken. It is just the right size for my toiletries and some change of clothes.
My soft sided luggage has metal zippers which prevent the opening of the zippers with a pen. Any nylon zipper can be breached and then “repaired” by running the zipper back and forth. I cannot find a hard sided suitcase with a metal zipper, so I’ll keep using my soft sided ones instead, thank you very much. I just don’t put anything in my checked bags front pockets unless I can lock them too.
I like this comparison. My soft luggage is a two-in-one. Basically a large rolling backpack with a smaller personal item backpack that can zip to it when needed. I’ve used it since 2017 and it’s such a great hybrid.
I personally think it’s a personal choice. For me I have a small 20 litre backpack that I take on the plane,I have the paperwork segregated into coloured carrier bags. Blue for the airport, Orange for itinerary so I can show my details if needed. I have clear plastic bag with my phone charger and small USB charger too, I keep the international travel plug in there too so I don’t get caught out. My hold-all I have for travelling is a soft sided one by Eastpack and has a retractable handle and wheels built into the bottom. It also has a security ring to lock the zipper to. I always work on the basis of being able to travel single handed. I can wear the backpack while pulling the hold-all along with minimal effort, I can use one hand to pull the hold-all and the other to help me through the airport gates. I only take with me what I need and nothing else. If you plan things properly you can travel very easily with little delays. One thing to consider is that most luggage is very similar and on the luggage belt it might not be so easy to find. If you get a permanent marker and put your name on the bag in about 6 different places it’s very unlikely it will come off. I also put an envelope inside with my details and mark it up as details of bag owner, that way the person in the lost property office can see who it belongs to, I put my travel dates and email address with it so they can contact me. If you watch folk at the airport you sometimes be surprised, there’s always someone with too much luggage. You don’t need the entire Samsonite collection for going away on a holiday. Travel light and travel far. I try to save any hassle by not taking liquids with me, the tiny bottles and bags are an inconvenience I can easily do without. I buy what I need at the other end in a local store and that is usually enough. Don’t feel compelled into having to buy anything at the airport, you can save money by having things to do while waiting. A few podcasts for travel are always worth having. If you can try to eat before you arrive at the airport, that way you won’t want a burger or something else. Most flights give you something so make sure you eat and drink on the plane, what you get given on the plane you leave on the plane as you could get a fine for stuff like fruit . Some places are strict about the rules too. If you are nice to the airline staff they might give you an extra pack of biscuits or something else. Eat them and know you are not going to be the one who gets a penalty for trying to bring stuff through the airport. It’s best to keep it simple and keep safe.
I'm switching to hardshell from softshell just because of how strict airlines are getting over carry-on sizing - I want to know when I walk out the door at home that I haven't put a little too much in the bag. The "not one more thing" nature of the hardshell really appeals to me.
First of all your videos are so pleasing to look at and so are you ! I have all hard shell suitcases consisiting of Beatles theme and London theme ones. I did have an issue with the wheels in one of my hard shell case as it cracked after baggage handling at the airlines. I used some duct tape and now it is good to go. The only soft sided case I have is my new Samsonite under seat bag used for my Pocket 3 video/ case and medicines and other things needed for the flight itself. Love your videos and you win for explaining your subjects so well for us too. Take care and see you again next time.
Be careful with the combination lock included on a suitcase, I once had one reset itself during travel and it wouldn't open with the combination I had set. Thankfully I had to sit with the suitcase while my travel partner waited in a long line at the hotel to check in, so I had time to try all the combinations until I found the one the suitcase had set itself. I started at 000 and went from there. Thank goodness it was in the 2s and not the 9s!
I prefer soft, using the Red Oxx Air Boss for US cities and the Mini Boss or C-Ruck for trips to Europe. I find that not having wheels enables me to move faster through the airport, and I appreciate the ability to squish into overhead bins.
Thank you Megan for another info filled video from you . for years i have always been wondering which one is better.. and i have used both hard and soft baggage.. unfortunately my hard shell suitcases got cracked a couple of times.. i think due to the porters handling them roughly . Your points are a eye opener and very good guide. for people to decide what to buy . keep up the good work with best wishes.from Toronto❤💚
@@dawncrossland3028 It was a couple of hundred dollars cheaper. It is holding up well, but it is the carryon size, so it has been checked only once. It did get a slight ding due to that but so far it has been good.
I've traveled with both and want to get a hard sided expandable luggage with a laptop external compartment! Can you provide any information on these in comparison to softshell luggage with the same capabilities?
After years of only soft side, I got a hard shell when my beloved soft side was in the rain on a tarmac and I arrived at my destination with all wet clothes. Then I discovered that the 20” quince hard sided I just bought weighs less and holds more than my 22” travel pro soft. I’m a convert.
I’ve also noticed that travel pro soft sided bags I got last year aren’t near the quality of ones I got a decade ago. After 2-3 trips, it was discolored and the handle kept sticking. Last ones were like new a decade later. Other brands may vary
Okay, I’ve always scratched my head about the obsession around the kislux book totes and their practicality, but this one is adorable!! Congratulations
I have seen some hard shell cases now that top open have you tried any of those yet? Hard to find any 9 inches or less all seem too big for carry on even though they say they are.the level 8 grace carry on is over 9inches so can not be used as a carry on on many airlines
Love your videos- great information. have a good quality 9.5 lbs. soft sided carry-on but it's heavy & doesn't have spinner wheels. So I bought a Delsey hard case weighing 6.6 lbs with spinner wheels which feels much lighter but I hate the clamshell style. I don't like the space I need to have it open and I struggle with closing the zipper. Both do have 8 wheels which I understand is better than 4. I took the 9 lb one to Italy and found it heavy when moving from place to place. The 6 lb I took to San Fran and it was so light but a pain to open & close. What to do if I am going to Thailand?
I've just ordered a hard, clam shell design opting for no interior or exterior pockets for maximum storage inside. It also has a wide handle so I have the full capacity vs the interference of the handle rising up the middle of the floor of the bag
*My carry-on bag* (Megan15 for discount + free shipping: bit.ly/PP-level8-textured
*Best check-in suitcase* (Megan15 for discount + free shipping): bit.ly/PP-level8-voyageurC
*Best budget hardshell* amzn.to/3zzs2wI
*Best budget soft-sided* amzn.to/4cYsZNx
I am a soft-side luggage user and assume everyone else who is, too, uses the trick of inserting a large plastic garbage bag in their luggage first…then pack your stuff INSIDE the bag. It acts as sort of a skin against theft - you’ll know right away if someone messed with your sealed bag - and adds some level of waterproofing to the contents. Works for me!! Thanks for another great vid!💕
This is a great idea! I’m a soft case user too. Might use this tip! Cheers!
We've used this tip for quite a while. On a recent trip I was really happy that we did! We got to the hotel and dropped the luggage in our room and went out. When we got back there was an unpleasant odour in the room. We narrowed it down to the luggage. It smelled like dog urine! We took the luggage outside on the balcony and pulled the clothes out of the plastic bag inside. The clothes were fine but we ended up tossing the luggage and buying new (hard shell replacement)
I am guessing that there were animal travelling with us on a flight.
Yes
Great idea!! 1. I once saw a young woman crying at the airport at 10pm -- her suitcase broke- stuff all over. She would have given anything for a garbage bag .... 2. Packing clothes etc into a Garbage bag first would have helped my kids. Their flight delayed bcuz of weather, they looked out to see all the luggage trolleys standing outside in a downpour for an hour in NOLA. 🌧️😟
Soft, just works for me. More flexible w packing, having more ease in putting things overhead.
Two great reasons! Thanks for watching!
It helps to use 3M Scotch Guard or NikWax type coating for added water resistance for soft shell suitcases (just do this a few days ahead). Weirdly, when locks are on my bags, they were more likely to be opened/searched. Now I use tiny zip ties and then a bright ribbon over it to secure (& identify) my bag and I've somehow been lucky and have not had any bags opened when just a ribbon is visible. 😅 (Knocking on wood!)
Sofe side.
1. I never check bag. Carry on and personal only
2. I spray my luggage down with Permethrin. Kills bedbugs, fleas, etc on contact for 30 days
3. Soft luggage will most likely fit in the luggage check if over stuffed. Stomped my bag down in the bag check to make it fit. Saved $100
I recently saw a review of a hard shell with a top lid and one large compartment. It was too expensive for me but I really hope the style of it catches on because you are absolutely right - the main advantage of soft is the ease-of-use. If a top loading hard shell becomes the norm then it will easily win over soft shell, for me.
Recently, I've had two hardshell suitcases broken by baggage handlers. Expensive, well-built luggage, and the wheels were crushed back into the suitcase shell. Two flights in a row! Found a soft-sided with much sturdier wheel attachments, and it flexes when treated roughly (instead of breaking).
The same happened to me. Had an expensive, hard sided bag that I took to Israel. Obviously, it was dropped from a high distance and the wheels were broken off and the bag would not close. It was a zipperless bag and had two heavy duty locks. One still worked, which is why my garments didn't fly out. But I trashed the bag and asked for a refund from United.
As a frequent flyer, my choice is NEITHER of what was presented in this video. I have a top zipper bag with a side and a bottom waterproof pocket. It is a tennis player's bag that I bought in 1984 and have carried onto at least 500 flights. Both hard and soft-sided luggage have to be laid flat to open with that long zipper. I can reach into the overhead compartment, unzip my bag a few inches and reach my hand inside to find anything I need inflight. My laptop goes n the side pocket and my passport/cash etc goes in the bottom 'secret" compartment. As for durability, my bag has never been washed and is now 40 years old.
Smart choice.
Some good points, but for a carry-on I choose to use a 2 wheel soft case. The most vulnerable points on any suitcase are the wheels. Recessed wheels on soft carries gives far greater protection as well as more capacity in the interior. Some European budget airlines have strict restrictions on weight and size and soft cases are usually much lighter. My Samsonite soft carry-on only weighs 1.7KG (half the weight to all the options shown in this video!) and I suspect I can fit more in it than all the options given as well. Most hard shells have clamshell interiors as well which is not an efficient design for packing.
Good soft cases will already have some water resistance, but if you are really worried about the rain, you can always get a light waterproof suitcase cover.
Helps against theft as well
Another consideration is two wheels or four. Nearly all hard shell luggage will have four wheels. Soft sided luggage will often give the option of two wheels. Four wheels will allow 18 inches of storage in a 20 inch bag where a two wheel bag will give you the full 20 inches, minus the corners where the wheels are located. So you get 10% more room in a two wheel bag.
I have a very ‘past it’s use by date’ soft shell suitcase which has two wheels. All the new ones that I’ve seen have four and I constantly watch suitcases rolling away from the owner when they let go of it. Mine doesn’t do that and I love it for that. Wish I could buy one with just two wheels!
Megan, thank you for another excellent comparison video. Personally, I use a TravelPro softshell, which has come in handy with an expandable zipper that gives you a little bit of extra space when you need to squeeze a few more items in it. Weight-wise, it's never been much of an issue for me, but I have yet to test the softshell in the rain. Moving forward, I'll carry a plastic bag in case I ever get caught in the rain. 😁Luggage for many will always come down to price. As long as we can all get out, see the world, and share new experiences, that's all that really matters.
I've traveled with the same TravelPro soft-sided suitcase since the early 90s. TravelPro has replaced both wheels for me and also repaired some wear on the edges. It's flown a few million miles and has covered several miles over the cobblestone streets of Vienna and other cities. Unfortunately the handle detent won't keep it extended any more, so I'll have to replace this bag after only 30 years.
Agree with the Travelpro choice.
LOVE My TravelPro!
I've had hardshell for over a decade but grew aggravated by the clamshell and how inconvenient it is at destination. I've migrated to soft sided luggage entirely for this reason.
I’ve been using a Rimowa polycarbonate cabin bag for the past decade plus and recently moved to soft sided luggage for the same reason. Clam shell design is so awkward. So far very happy with switching.
Most thieves know about the pen trick to defeat zippers, so most hard-sided luggage are NOT more secure than soft-sided luggage. I would only consider the higher-end hard-sided luggage that use latches instead of zippers as being more secure.
I laughed a lot when you modeled the pulling of the hardshell versus the softshell suitcases. 🤣🤣🤣 Thanks for the info, I had just bought a new hard shell and can’t wait to use it on my next trip😉
I am used to travel in Europe and mostly just carry on only. So it's really important for me to have light weight luggage, because of weight limits of most of airlines. After long searching I found the best for me. It's AeroStep from American tourister 🎉Volume 36-40l and weight only 2,3kg❤
You can pack more stuff into soft luggage because it expands unlike hard sided luggage. Also, a lot of hard sided luggage isn't as secure as you'd think because a sharp cutting tool can slice right through them. Also they can be crushed in instances were soft sided luggage will bend and give to pressure. Another superior feature of soft sides luggage is that they're more user friendly because they have outside pockets that are easily accessible as opposed to having to open the entire hard sided case to access the contents. Soft sided luggage is easier to pack as well. Lastly, soft sided luggage is much easier to fit into an overhead. I use hard sided luggage when I have to check a larger suitcase and it's at the mercy of baggage handlers but always use soft sided with carry-ons and I've had my soft sided case for years, if you purchase a good one they last just fine.
You make some great points. Thanks for sharing!
To say that a soft-sided suitcase is better because you can over stuff it and stretch it, and that you can compress it to fit into the sizers are diametrically opposed statements. If you can over stuff it and stretch it then it's not going to fit into the sizer or no matter how much you compress it. I was hoping with the title saying new airline rules that you would finally cover suitcases that actually fit the airline regulations for size. When are all of the carry-on manufacturers going to come out with a carry-on case that actually meets the regulations???? I'm so tired of reading through hundreds of items on Amazon to try to find one that meets the regulations. It's very frustrating!! I especially love it when in the description of the item it's specifically states that it meets the size restrictions for airlines and it actually gives the names of the airlines but then when you read the dimensions of the bag it does not. Please Megan, use your influence with these companies to try to get them to make bags that meet the requirements!!! I like the quality of the level eight bags but right now I am in the process of ripping off the front laptop compartment door of mine to trim it down, and glue it back on to the front covering the opening, so that it meets the requirements! Seems strange but it's better than tossing 180 bucks away.
@@JD-zt3nr Well, all I can say is that I do it all the time without issue and I travel a lot. The only time it's been questioned was at the airport in Barcelona a few years back but it fit into the overhead there as it always has. It's an American Tourister nylon carry-on that I've had for years. So maybe it's a tad smaller than newer ones; it does appear just a hair smaller than my wife's which is new but the difference really is negligible.
I have to add this to your equations. We were on a sailboat that sunk. They were able to get our luggage off a few days later. I had just bought at TJ Maxx the Samsonyte hard sided luggage. That was in 2015 I am still using the suitcases today, even though they were in the bottom of the ocean for a while.🤷♀️🏝️
Our sweet spot is our Osprey soft-side carry-on size rollerboards AND we only do air-based travel a few times a year (often to Europe from Canada) and we utilize "Zone 2" boarding, so we can avoid checked bags. Our Ospreys have built in compression flaps that are brilliant and I use a high-end waterproof spray on the exterior.
I love Travelpro Maxlite 5 as it allows me to pack it light enough to actually put it in the overhead bin. I am 79.
That’s great! Happy travels, Lynn!
I bought this same suitcase after my last international trip, specifically because it is so lightweight. A clamshell suitcase is a hard NO for me.
2 or 4 wheels!?
@clyster3000 If that was for me ..... 2 wheels. You get more capacity with only 2 wheels, it's lighter, and I prefer it. I don't like my suitcase to roll downhill on its own. Some very high end suitcases have a break, but I've never had one of those.
@@DC-pr2bq i was looking at a travel pro carry on and they seem to have 2 or 4 wheel option. I can’t afford high end either
It doesn't matter. Ramp workers will break both hard and soft sides. We just switched to Amazon Basics Ripstop Wheeled Duffel Bag for Travel, Travel Bag. Ramp workers will also break the pullout handles.
9:41 I had already two flights with UAL, where a gate agent made me check in my bag at the gate. Everything with a battery in my bag had to get out. So do not forget to pack a cotton bag into your carryon.
I have used Rick Steves' Rolling Carry-On for 13+ years. It has a molded frame, making the back hard but the front soft-sided. It's 6.5 pounds and $180.
That is an interesting sounding case and must be sturdy to last so long! I like that it is only 6.5lbs!
You beat me to it. I was going to mention this one. Thinking of buying one. The dimensions(53.5 x 35 x 23 cm) also make it compatible with most airlines in the world.
Your comparison towards the end, too cute. I don’t travel much, but when my t. handle broke on my soft while on a trip, I had to immediately buy a new case. I found a hard at a local store. My last trip, I had one of each, so could enjoy the benefits of both. You nailed it perfectly in all of your categories. For me, needing more space to open the hard is the only aspect that I find annoying.
Very helpful episode today. I am considering new luggage after 22 years of reliable service from what I currently have. It is hardside. Thought about soft, but decided for hard instead. Thank you for the vlog enjoyed.
Glad it was helpful!
Rolling duffle is my way to go, I have a Samsonite and the web handles are a little long which allows for slinging the bag on a shoulder which was great when in London and using the tube and not looking so dorky pulling luggage through the tube.
I use the Ebags TLS Motherlode Wheeled Duffel. 29 inch. It’s part hard shell and part soft. It has lots of space on both sides. The protection is great because I put my clothes in the soft side and anything else in the hard side. I can also access the soft side via a front zipper without opening the whole thing. I always check a bag and use my backpack for under seat.
I am a big fan of Hard-sided suitcases & and have been for awhile. I find them lighter (in general) and more durable. In fact I just bought a Mixi carry on (hard shell) that opens at the top! Love it and it’s so much better than a clamshell opening for a carry on!
A lot of small group tour companies like OAT tell you NOT to bring hard shell luggage because of difficulty getting into the smaller vehicles you will be using. So evaluate your travel before buying.
Thanks Megan. I picked up a hard sided Verage set last year and am very happy with it. Four flights so far, one international and they came through beautifully. Really like their construction and features.
I love all the features of my soft sided luggage and the deep compartment for packing and it is so much easier when you have to open it up.
I love my 19 inch Delsey hard shell after years of loyalty to my soft side. The hard shell fits the US carryon size restriction. Whereas when I have used soft side in the same size configuration I have had a few airlines that have pulled it to check on without bothering to check the sizing bin. Having multiple airline employees in the family, I have been told that airline employees know people can overstuff the soft sides, so they go for them first when pulling luggage at the gate for carryon.
I love traveling with my Level8 carry-on bag. I have a pale blue bag in the 20" and last year bought the 24" checked bag. Couldn't be more thrilled!
So the one thing I found with most of the hardshelled cases is that they have the lock built-in and it's TSA certified (meaning anyone can get a key). As far as baggage handlers are concerned I"m not that concerned about when it's being checked by TSA but more so when it's at my destination, as I tend to lock my laptop and any camera stuff I'm not going to carry with me, in my bag luggage bag as I feel this can be more secure than carrying around expensive items I am not gonig to use while out and about especially in foreign countries, but also in general. And I'm aware that a no bag is completely immune to being broken into, and the locks only buy you time from someone getting in. So the ballpoint trick has me concerned. I've been trying to find an affordable hardshelled case that doesn't have the built in locks but rather just clasps that accomodate a lock so I can then use my own non-TSA lock with when I get to my destination (I stopped locking my luggage for TSA to be honest since it seems they would cut of the locks even if it was TSA certified). So I now bring non-TSA locks to use when I get to my destination.
(I don't necessarily see the built-in TSA lock as a security feature though. I wish they didn't build these into the bags.) All I'm looking for is a bag that preferrably is hardshelled, doesn't have a zipper (maybe a hard seam with a rubber gasket to keep water out) and most importanly, no built in lock. I guess a Pelican case may be the only option that i can see (or some other similar hard-shelled case that is not necessarily meant for clothing).
I will say that Samsonite bags can be decent from a durabltility standpoint. I know the more expensive versions do last longer, but for example, I managged to pick up a small roller carry-on bag for about $80 on sale (normally it was something like $150) about 10 years ago, and that bag lasted me well over 10 years (just retired it this year and found another one ,as the wheels became damaged and are hard to replace on some models, so Idecided to just get another one, but for $8 a year, that wasn't a bad buy). It had probably 200k miles of use on it and possibly more as I stopped keeping track after a while, but it lasted a long time, so there can be some good deals out there (but I also don't overpack my bags either).
I've found that the airlines that include free carry-on do not weigh them in 95% of cases, but budget airlines like Spirit and Frontier are well known for this since their baggage fees are higher and it's pure profit for them (and they're planes tend to be smaller since they only fly narrow-body jets anyway). But for example on a Delta flight 6 years ago I had roughly 45 lbs in my carry-on and nobody cared (had to wiggle it into the bin but it fit; thus saving me a $50 checked bag fee). I also overloaded a backpack that barely fit under the seat (Same flight) with about 15 lbs.
GREAT STUFF! Was considering hard shell but this definitely changed my mind!
For my wife and me “Rick Steves “ Ravenna Rolling case” it weighs 7lbs , 21”x14”x9” have used one for years… it is a great carry on case.👍👍
I Thought you Were Saying Your Name was “Rick Steves”,but After I Saw Another person comment “Rick Steves” I Looked it Up.
It’s an Interesting prospect.
Last time i watched a Rick Steves video he was ragging on how bad wheeled luggage was. That was a long time ago. I guess he changed his mind.
Love the soft shell for ease of access and able to fit easily. Also has handy external pockets for documents. What I don’t love is the chance that you are forced to gate check your luggage because flight is packed. This leads to chance that it is exposed to external weather such as rain or snow which then mean your soft shell luggage acts more like a sponge. If you are not sure what I am talking about simply take the water hose and put some heavy object on your luggage and water it. The pressure is like when other luggage’s sitting on top of yours like the typical luggage cart. Really cheap hardshell luggage isn’t any better in that they tend to crack or open very easily after 1-2 flights. It because not only luggage handlers but also the luggage sorter. There is TH-cam videos of these sorters in action and even I was surprise how much force they use to sort luggage.
I've only ever had softsided luggage mostly because I prefer the two wheel configuration to the four wheel on rolling luggage and I do like the expansion zipper on my softsided items also. I can have a packed full carryon on the way to my destination, then add space for some souvenirs and check the bag on the way home where it matters less if my bag is lost/delayed.
Nice to have that option of adding more! Happy travels!
Great comparison review. I have an 'Away' brand hard shell carry on, but I avoid placing my MacBook or anything of value inside, because of the remote chance the flight runs low on overhead space and requires me to check my carry on at the jetway. I also carry a very small backpack that qualifies as a personal item for my laptop, phone, snacks, etc. So, in my case, I could actually use either a soft sided or a hard sided carry on.
Thanks! Wise to keep those more valuable items with you!
I work in a cruise line & saw how they throw luggages when they deliver it to the rooms. Most of the time it's the hard luggage that gets broken or loose wheels. So I always use the soft one & it can expand more. Breakable items can be wrap & place in hard plastic containers inside the luggage. While hard case is very limited to expand. Not a fan of hard case since I've done 50 int'l flights.
soft sided luggage with 2 wheels?
A hardsize suitcase wheel was damaged and jammed into the shell after last cruise. Cruise luggage handlers have been vocal complainers about size and weight of bags when taking it at drop off or pick up.
Last year, based on your recommendation, we got Level 8 carry-on bags to use in Europe and are very happy with them.
I travel internationally and I've been soft shell for decades. Due to some growing dissatisfaction, I recently switched to hard shell and I'm happy I switched. The hard shell is more challenging to pack, but it's better for everything else. I don't plan on switching back.
Sounds like you have found the right fit for you!
I spent several decades as a road warrior (consulting). My go-to has always been a hard-sided, two wheel carry-on from Delsey. I always avoid zippers, opting for a metal ring design at the joint with proper locking latches (metal to metal closure) - I'm surprised none of the hard-siders shown were zipper-free. The only soft-side I'd even consider would be the TravelPro top line models, but I'll stick with my hard-side till I can no longer get it.
My bag is a combination hard side and soft side. The bottom area below the zipper and around the wheels is hard, but the top is soft sided, so it expands if needed and is easy to pull items out if needed without opening the whole bag. If I'm not sure if my bag is overweight, I will put things that I can pull out easily to meet the weight limit within easy reach. I've had the bags for over 15 years and love them!
Hi Megan! My soft-shell carry-on is perfect for my CPAP, medication, jewelry and tablet!
My suitcase got left out in the rain during a trip to Florida Disney World. Everything got wet. That would not happened if I had a hard shell. I’ve been traveling with a hard shell now for a long time and I love it. I have an Away suitcase.
I have had it for years now and it held up great.
I learned how to pack really light. It actually makes things easier. used to pack a lot when I used soft suitcases and I ended up not using the half the stuff 😊
Perfect timing for upload, this is my next research item of something I'm buying for my trip to SEA in September.
Hope I’ve been able to help in your research and choice! Safe travels!
Soft sided 2 wheel for me, but I do carry on so abuse by baggage handlers not so much an issue. As my ancient but still very practical Atlantic carry on still does the job I will keep it till it can't. Then probably a Travelpro Maxlite 5 as a replacement. Lots of great info to help make a choice in your video.
If you dont travel much like me you lean to price but the most important thing is the durability of the wheels and handle extension because nothing else matters if that breaks, also the bigger the wheels the easier it is to drag over rough flooring like tile with deep grouting..BTW I am leg man and your outfit in heels is quite stunning
I've been looking for a soft sided carry on due to being able to select one's with expanders unlike the hard shells. However, the mention of bedbugs has really made it me rethink it! Thank you for mentioning this as it was never something I had considered before.
I use the Topo Design Global Travel Bag Roller (meets the KLM / Air France / British Air maximun size for carry on) which is not cheap… but incredible - combining the advantages of both soft & hard shells, while adding the versatility of a backpack option. Easily the best bag I ever travelled with!
Delsey (black) spinny wheel 22" soft!
It's light and has pockets so I don't have to open the bag for a passport or to stash my phone for a TSA screening, and I can jam it into something , like the overhead or that luggage cage they have at the gate to measure your bag
A great advantage of the soft luggage!
@@PortableProfessional
I find that some bags, both hard and soft don't fall within the TSA measurement guidelines. An inch here, or don't take into account the "expandable" feature or the measurement "don't count the wheels".
I would certainly recommend avoiding hard surface cases for both checked-in AND carry-on luggage. Very difficult to pull both at the same time. Whereas a soft bag can be sat on top of the larger hard hold case.
Great video, although I do still prefer soft sided for carry-on. I use hard sided for checked luggage.
the 2 trips i have done with friends i have used only hard shell and thats just carry on. For West Jet, they have a pretty small overhead bin space. Soft shell suitcases are almost better for westjet.
The variety of textures in the kislux pack is impressive. From smooth leather to textured suede, there's something for everyone.
Solgaard. Hard side without the vulnerable zipper. And their integral closet makes unpacking a snap!
Nice! I will have to take a look at them!
I prefer hard shell. I feel it's sturdier. I don't have to worry about my luggage getting wet or ripped.
Hardshell for:
- super packers that stuff a lot
- people that’s going to stay in the same hotel room more than 3 nights
- stays in decent hotel
- access to car to / from airport / train station
- vacationers
Softshell for:
- light packers
- people that moves on quickly so no time to unpack
- stays in backpackers hostel
- have to rely on foot / public transit to / from airport
- professional working on the move
What you get depends on what kind of travelers you are.
Another thing, I’ve noticed a new kind of hybrid carry-on luggage is getting popular in Asia, I think Japan’s LOJEL started the design. Essentially a hardshell trunk with front opening and expansion. I got a Thai “UPRISE” branded luggage of this design and it’s superior to my Level8 and Monos “pro” luggages
The variety of textures in the kislux pack is impressive. From smooth leather to textured suede, there's something for everyone.
I take a medium soft duffel for domestic and international travel. Carry on only. This has saved me many headaches
Good choice! Happy travels, Alexandra!
Personally I prefer a good carry-on sized backpack like the Osprey Fairview 40 or the Aer Travel Pack 3 (Regular 35L or Small 28L) I have all three and find them just way more convenient than lugging around a suitcase!
Great advice with lots of options. I also think it depends on how often you have to check a bag either by choice or at the gate. The way the handle luggage is criminal. Just look at the video of how they handled a college golf teams clubs.
I bought a Mixi hard shell carry on that is top-opening, like a softshell. It’s great. I also find hard shells are slimmer, without those extra pockets on the outside, so they can be easier to fit in tight spaces even though the don’t compress.
I’m on the fence about hard or soft shell luggage, Meagan. I personally like suitcases that only have two wheels that are recessed in the body. I’m Andrew. I have a Travelpro maxlite 4 suitcase. But it’s soft shell. I’d put my valuables (meds, headphones, cellphone, laptop, etc) in my backpack (personal item) anyway.
I’ve selected the Antler Brixham soft sided Carry-On at 1.9kg. 4 sets of dual wheels and TSA lock.
I’m planning to put a cover over it to keep it nice looking and security.
Good choice! Happy travels!
I love my TravelPro Crew Expert carry-on.
Really enjoy your videos. I actually took advantage of Prime days last week and got myself a carry on. Thanks Megan!🙂
Really great video, well produced and concise. I have spent hours on TH-cam and the Internet on the issue of hard shell versus soft sided. Ultimately came down to soft sided for me. As you point out this is a matter of personal preference. For me the two big issues were the clamshell opening (don’t like that) and the flexibility of the soft sided.
I have a hard side carry on from Samsonite and a 24 inch soft sided when I know I'm going to be checking a bag. I'm checking less often now and have had better success getting around with the carry on due to the 360 wheels. I tend to take the larger suitcase if I am cruising, as I will only unpack once. The 24" does stow neatly under the bed, which helps as the cabins are usually on the cozy side.
I’ve flown a couple million miles and finally converted to a hard side after yet another incident where some hideous liquid in someone else’s bag burst and ruined my (expensive) soft sided bag. Gate check is the devil and not in my control. Hard side bags keep my things (and my bag) safer.
Is hard shell best for checked bags and soft bags for carry on?
I have always used a hardshell. Always thought the soft seemed too flimsy to last! Another good video to give me lots to think about!
Hard for sure. I only say that due to the rain, sometimes luggage will be left out and if it's raining it'll soak through the soft one!
I use my North Face base camp duffle bag with wheels (2 wheels) and love it. I also own North Face duffle bag/backpack for more mobility. It's easier for me to store in the overhead bin. For personal items, I use my Fjallraven Classic kanken. It is just the right size for my toiletries and some change of clothes.
My soft sided luggage has metal zippers which prevent the opening of the zippers with a pen. Any nylon zipper can be breached and then “repaired” by running the zipper back and forth. I cannot find a hard sided suitcase with a metal zipper, so I’ll keep using my soft sided ones instead, thank you very much. I just don’t put anything in my checked bags front pockets unless I can lock them too.
Which Name Brand Please?
I like this comparison. My soft luggage is a two-in-one. Basically a large rolling backpack with a smaller personal item backpack that can zip to it when needed. I’ve used it since 2017 and it’s such a great hybrid.
Brand Name?
@@dawncrossland3028 Hypath 8-in-1
I personally think it’s a personal choice. For me I have a small 20 litre backpack that I take on the plane,I have the paperwork segregated into coloured carrier bags. Blue for the airport, Orange for itinerary so I can show my details if needed. I have clear plastic bag with my phone charger and small USB charger too, I keep the international travel plug in there too so I don’t get caught out. My hold-all I have for travelling is a soft sided one by Eastpack and has a retractable handle and wheels built into the bottom. It also has a security ring to lock the zipper to. I always work on the basis of being able to travel single handed. I can wear the backpack while pulling the hold-all along with minimal effort, I can use one hand to pull the hold-all and the other to help me through the airport gates. I only take with me what I need and nothing else. If you plan things properly you can travel very easily with little delays. One thing to consider is that most luggage is very similar and on the luggage belt it might not be so easy to find. If you get a permanent marker and put your name on the bag in about 6 different places it’s very unlikely it will come off. I also put an envelope inside with my details and mark it up as details of bag owner, that way the person in the lost property office can see who it belongs to, I put my travel dates and email address with it so they can contact me. If you watch folk at the airport you sometimes be surprised, there’s always someone with too much luggage. You don’t need the entire Samsonite collection for going away on a holiday. Travel light and travel far. I try to save any hassle by not taking liquids with me, the tiny bottles and bags are an inconvenience I can easily do without. I buy what I need at the other end in a local store and that is usually enough. Don’t feel compelled into having to buy anything at the airport, you can save money by having things to do while waiting. A few podcasts for travel are always worth having. If you can try to eat before you arrive at the airport, that way you won’t want a burger or something else. Most flights give you something so make sure you eat and drink on the plane, what you get given on the plane you leave on the plane as you could get a fine for stuff like fruit . Some places are strict about the rules too. If you are nice to the airline staff they might give you an extra pack of biscuits or something else. Eat them and know you are not going to be the one who gets a penalty for trying to bring stuff through the airport. It’s best to keep it simple and keep safe.
Hiya, Magen. Good info. I have a couple TravelPro bags. Rather pleased with them. Carry-on & next size larger. What's your opinion?
No Travelpro Maxlite 5 Softside Expandable Luggage with 4 Spinner Wheels, Lightweight?
I'm switching to hardshell from softshell just because of how strict airlines are getting over carry-on sizing - I want to know when I walk out the door at home that I haven't put a little too much in the bag. The "not one more thing" nature of the hardshell really appeals to me.
One less thing to worry about! Happy travels!
Great video Megan, I use a hard sided suitcase for checked bags, and soft for carry on.
Thank you, Patrick!
Same
My mom bought one kislux and she loves it. It had been there for over 10 years when she went out with it.
First of all your videos are so pleasing to look at and so are you ! I have all hard shell suitcases consisiting of Beatles theme and London theme ones. I did have an issue with the wheels in one of my hard shell case as it cracked after baggage handling at the airlines. I used some duct tape and now it is good to go. The only soft sided case I have is my new Samsonite under seat bag used for my Pocket 3 video/ case and medicines and other things needed for the flight itself. Love your videos and you win for explaining your subjects so well for us too. Take care and see you again next time.
Be careful with the combination lock included on a suitcase, I once had one reset itself during travel and it wouldn't open with the combination I had set. Thankfully I had to sit with the suitcase while my travel partner waited in a long line at the hotel to check in, so I had time to try all the combinations until I found the one the suitcase had set itself. I started at 000 and went from there. Thank goodness it was in the 2s and not the 9s!
I don’t use carry on any more as I can’t lift it overhead to put in the bin. I have soft side and hard shell and absolutely prefer hardshell.
I prefer soft, using the Red Oxx Air Boss for US cities and the Mini Boss or C-Ruck for trips to Europe. I find that not having wheels enables me to move faster through the airport, and I appreciate the ability to squish into overhead bins.
Thank you Megan for another info filled video from you . for years i have always been wondering which one is better.. and i have used both hard and soft baggage.. unfortunately my hard shell suitcases got cracked a couple of times.. i think due to the porters handling them roughly . Your points are a eye opener and very good guide. for people to decide what to buy . keep up the good work with best wishes.from Toronto❤💚
Thanks so much! Glad you enjoyed watching!
I like hardshell. I got a Rimowa when I was in Germany last year.
I’ve Bought one as well,
but have Not used it yet.
Was it cheaper in Germany?
How is it holding Up?
& What Size Did You Get?
@@dawncrossland3028 It was a couple of hundred dollars cheaper. It is holding up well, but it is the carryon size, so it has been checked only once. It did get a slight ding due to that but so far it has been good.
I've traveled with both and want to get a hard sided expandable luggage with a laptop external compartment! Can you provide any information on these in comparison to softshell luggage with the same capabilities?
My preference is hard sided without zippers.
Nice choice! Safe travels.
Hi Megan! Is there any solution to the zipper attacks in the offing?
After years of only soft side, I got a hard shell when my beloved soft side was in the rain on a tarmac and I arrived at my destination with all wet clothes. Then I discovered that the 20” quince hard sided I just bought weighs less and holds more than my 22” travel pro soft. I’m a convert.
I’ve also noticed that travel pro soft sided bags I got last year aren’t near the quality of ones I got a decade ago. After 2-3 trips, it was discolored and the handle kept sticking. Last ones were like new a decade later. Other brands may vary
Okay, I’ve always scratched my head about the obsession around the kislux book totes and their practicality, but this one is adorable!! Congratulations
you’re literally my comfort person i love you kislux !
Thank you for this! A lot to weigh out, no pun, between carry on, checked bags & backpacks.
I have seen some hard shell cases now that top open have you tried any of those yet? Hard to find any 9 inches or less all seem too big for carry on even though they say they are.the level 8 grace carry on is over 9inches so can not be used as a carry on on many airlines
Love your videos- great information. have a good quality 9.5 lbs. soft sided carry-on but it's heavy & doesn't have spinner wheels. So I bought a Delsey hard case weighing 6.6 lbs with spinner wheels which feels much lighter but I hate the clamshell style. I don't like the space I need to have it open and I struggle with closing the zipper. Both do have 8 wheels which I understand is better than 4. I took the 9 lb one to Italy and found it heavy when moving from place to place. The 6 lb I took to San Fran and it was so light but a pain to open & close. What to do if I am going to Thailand?
You have made the case for the hard shell carry on. I will have to try it. Thank you.
Cute examples of how you feel when you travel with the different types. But very helpful.
Glad you liked that! Really enjoyed doing this video and good to know you found it helpful!
I've just ordered a hard, clam shell design opting for no interior or exterior pockets for maximum storage inside. It also has a wide handle so I have the full capacity vs the interference of the handle rising up the middle of the floor of the bag
Sounds great! Hope it works well for you! Happy travels, Leslie!