There are many reasons as to why I will always stan Amber the way I do. 1. She's not afraid to be herself 2. She's inspired me to feel strong as a tomboy 3. Her voice is breathtaking 4. Her songs are so inspiring There are many more, but these 4 are the most important to me at the moment. I will always have a deep love for Amber and anything she does.
@Lewa Alayna so like for example playing football or something like this. Then i guess i'm a half tomboy, because i like wearing oversize and i have a few things that my brother wore befor
@@tofu4784 Tomboys are typically women/girls who identify as female but don't really like feminine things like wearing makeup, dresses, skirts, etc. And prefer things that are more typically "male".
Even though I knew Amber wasn't the best singer in fx, her voice was always my favorite. There's something so honest and calming in her voice and it's beautiful.
yesss exactly! yeah Lunas voice is stronger but to be honest i would listen to 2 songs of her no more. Amber i could listen to for dayssss, there for i say she has the best voice in fx
Isn't this song about how she feels toward SM? She asks where is sm to help her build her career, but then she feels like she's on her own. And the part "But still I hold on,this mask is running thin" could mean she still keeps her smile on her face, but the sadness is too big for her to kepp holding the smile in her face ("I'll lie and say it's okay"). And she says "So far I've gone to get to you" could mean she went all the way from States to korea to get to sm. Well, there's a lot more thing to say about this song, but I think this song is deeper than what it actually looks like
Renan Yuji I thought this too. I always have this song on repeat, trying to decipher the lyrics and enjoy it at the same time. Oddly enough I can relate to this song. But recently I discovered that it could also be directed to MeU. Like the lines "I want you here to stay, for you complete me. But I'm here alone. Where are you?" Mainly for "U" complete "Me". "MeU". It's like she's saying she needs our help. MeU's complete f(x). Like MeU's could demand comebacks and proper promotions from SM for f(x) and all the members. Popular demand can do wonders. Either way, SM needs to step it up. MeU's, Amber, and all of f(x) have had enough.
I think what she is trying saying by "my mask is running thin" is, usually when people suffer from deppression (idk if amber does suffer from deppression) they feel that they have to "put on a mask" so people will think everything is fine but deep down nothing is fine. And by saying that its "running thin" she could be saying that she feels like she cant act like everything is fine anymore. That's just my opinion though.
This is so short but so meaningful. I mean, she didn't need a bunch of special light/sound effects or a huge studio with 1000 dancers in order to show her feelings. Is just Amber being Amber, no make up, no fashion trends or random stuff. This is simply beautiful and YOU can't deny it lol.
I'm not a kpop girl group fan neither do i have any other favorite girl kpop artist apart from Amber, she is just the best. Always cheering for you Amber
I love how Amber is so true to herself. She doesn't need surgery or loads of makeup or really sexy outfits to be beautiful. She is trying to spread the message that people are who they are and who they want to be and we are all beautiful the way we are. Amber, you're my inspiration and I seriously think we need so many more people like you in this world. You are beautiful the way you are and no one and nothing can change who you are. Hwaiting and stay awesome and unique!!!
It’s okay it’s okay I’ll lie and say It’s okay So far I’ve gone to get to you It’s okay it’s okay You see through my hardened face Trying to see the light through the rain Hoping that nothings gone But still I hold on this mask is running thin I know I’m losing my senses I pray each and every day For me to stay awake ‘Cause I’m on my own where are you It’s too late It’s too late Won’t believe I came too late The bells rung me out I’ve been knocked down I’m done for good I’m done for good Though there’s no way But still I hold on this mask is running thin I know I’m losing my senses I pray each and every day For me to stay awake ‘Cause I’m on my own But still I hold on my breath now is running thin I don’t care that I’m losing I want you here to stay For you complete me But I’m here alone where are you Where are you No more things left to say I just wanted you to stay Hold on this mask is running thin I know I’m losing my senses Pray each and every day For me to stay awake Cause I’m on my own where are you
Amber is growing up. Little by little she's showing us her personally story and I'm scared of what this means for F(x). Out of all of them she would probably be better off solo when you think about it.
Same feeling. I'm happy that she's growing and creating her own music color. But we have to face it, its far from f(x)'s style. I'm just going to hold on and embrace what lies in for the future. For now, let's support Amber and help her attain more llama lovers.
+Shell Ross I think any idol that starts out in an idol group should only leave if their company is restricting them. In Amber's case SM seems to be letting her do her own thing and I don't think there's much reason for her to leave f(x)
+Shell Ross I love (F)x too but it looks like they are already parting ways. Sulli left awhile ago, Victoria has been doing lots of work in her country China, Krystal was unhappy and apparently followed her sister and doing her own thing. Only Luna & Amber have shown any interest in singing and they can actually sing very good they have proved it. Lets encourage Amber and Luna to do their thing.
Wow... I don't actually know how to feel about this. As a #MeU since their debut, I'll always support f(x), OT5, wherever and whenever. But I get the feeling that Amber has a lot to say and many personal decisions to make, and if I want to be selfish, yeah that scares me a lot... I'm terrified the f(x) I know won't be the same anymore. At the same time, part of their musical journey is self-discovery, and while it might be hard as a fan to accept that - especially since it feels like we've stuck through thick and thin with them - I really hope they all do what makes them happy. I'm glad Amber is finally releasing solos and willing to share them with us, I'm happy Victoria stays our ever-positive leader (with a million promotions in China
The truth is they don't rely on being f(x) anymore. They are building their own careers. Yet they never forget about us and that's all I need to be assured that no matter what happens f(x) will always love MeUs.
from different perspective, i've never been a fan of f(x). i just simply didn't like their music, maybe except for the latest '4 walls'. but i love amber's solo so much! i love that she produces her own music and writes songs, because i feel like THIS is a part of her. this is her style, her words. so, my opinion is: if members of f(x) are not interested anymore in being in a girl group, they shouldnt force herselves. if it makes them happy, then they can be f(x) how long they want to.
Man, I don't listen to that much kpop anymore, but I decided to go listen to this since she wrote it herself, and I really like it! The production, the lyrics, the vocals and the music video are all beautiful. Good job Amber!
Oh why? I wanted to quit kpop once before, because I felt so trapped amongst all the groups which are practically the same with their music. But then I realised I just didn't see far enough and here I am, back again, this time supporting groups that I genuinely like :) But if you really decide to stop being a kpop fan then I guess that's a good choice for you
+VIPANDA I don't know, I don't hate kpop at all, I just don't like the fact the members of groups don't often contribute creatively. Isn't the point of music to express yourself?
+Kelly sorry to butt in. but i dont think music is only to express yourself. some singers are great as messenger. they spread the message from the song writers. i dont believe that music is so rigid as in to expresd yourself only when it is so flexible as enjoyment
Dear Amber, I love everything about you from your style to your personnality, you're amazing and such an inspiring person. I wish you're happy because "borders", "on my own" and "beautiful" are songs that show the harships you had to go through. I find myself in your words and I want to thank you for singing things I can't tell to myself. You have an awesome voice, take good care of yourself, don't worry about haters, I'm not even a huge fan of yours but I can tell you're a kindhearted person. I hope one day I'll get the chance to see you and remind you that you've worked so hard to achieve your dreams and you've succeded :) From the bottom of my heart.
Hana ELF SJ She didn't mean that Amber's English is bad. It's just that we listen to too much kpop to realize that Amber was singing in English. We are too used to listening to Korean.
among all of these girlband soloists, i think amber is the most unique and creative one. im not really a kpop fans so i really didnt know what sm do did and done but i just honestly proud of her, her songs are very different but easy to listen and i just in love with her:")
THIS is the Amber I've been waiting for, this is the Amber we've been praying for, THIS is her being in her natural element and showing us her truest light! Oh my god, I'm ready for this and this song is perfect in English and Korean. Her and Gen Neo, I can't speak enough on this perfection. Thank you Amber for always putting your best foot forward and never compromising who you are despite the nay-sayers. I can't imagine anything that you must have gone through this business and all of the highs and lows but I'm telling you now, I and thousands of people are here to support you and I pray to the heavens that you are happy regardless. FIGHTING!
Today he was having hard time again because he's sick, so I let him listen to it (and also borders by amber) again and he calmed down immediately 😻😻😻💕💕 Amber thank you so much touching all of us young and old. He loves al your meaningfull songs like beautiful, borders and on my own💕💕
Hey Amber. I don't know if you will ever read this but I just wanna thank you for everything you had done and everything you're doing. People like me probably listen to your songs more. People like me as in people who are more emotional than most. And I don't know but it's just probably you yourself and your music that gives me a warm feeling and it soothes my soul. Thankyou so much. Thankyou for existing. You're definitely one of my role models. I love you so much.
She's so real honestly and so inspiring one of the only kpop idols who I can say I look up to and is a role model. I hope she knows that she inspires a lot of people to just be themselves to accept that we all have struggles and life will never be perfect but still we"ll get through it some how. she deserves all the success in the world.
my heart is melting...she is such and genuine, real and such and inspirational person. the fact that she is always being herself and always there for others...i just love her. i only wish you the best for everything you do and your future. I love you Amber. Thank You for being you.
Why this mv isn't getting enough views ? it should have reached 1M But no matter what amber is still a miracle maker she always save me in my worst situation thank you for your great and amazing songs amber you are such an insperation
We don't deserve amber , look at this amazing production and this is all for her fans , for us llamas like .. she needs to know how much she means to us
no matter how many times i listen to it, it touches my heart a lot every single time....like it goes straight to ur heart.loves everything abt thiS SONG..its message, music,lyrics and emotions and of course amber calming and soothing voice. I miss u a lot Amber T-T
It's so hard to find female artists that put so much emotion into their voices... you can find all of the soulful voices in the world but I would prefer the quiet melancholy I feel from Amber's voice in this song...
That angelic voice! WHERE HAVE YOU BEEN HIDING IT FOR SO LONG??? I'm so happy she finally gets to do a solo and I sincerely hope the Korean fans supports her because I don't see many views and this makes me sad. I love this girl so much she's my only girl crush and my dream is to see her in person one day. Amber is the most unique female korean idol there to make a change and I pray to god she succeeds. On another note I really really wish there is a collab with Jonghyun because I love my little dino family lol no seriously tho their voices together would sound magical! LOVE AMBER!!!! ♥♥♥♥
At first I didn't think that I'd like Amber because I don't listen to f(x) but she is now one of my favorite solo artists and i don't even like female singers/bands but Amber is special
"I'll lie and say it's okay." This song is so beautiful and very emotional. In addition to that, the MV is so pure and beautiful too. This is the type of music I live for. Amber can go from Shake That Brass to On My Own in like .3 seconds
Amber release things for the most perfect time for me. Borders was released when I wanted to give up. Now this, is released when I'm falling apart... Every time, the songs gives me power and reminds me of my promises with myself and how I should/would always stay strong no matter how tough and hard times gets... Thank you so much Amber for giving me more hope and power. ❤
+Rhea Lapez It's so amazing how the song just really goes with what I have been thinking. like before borders were released I was thinking about "Fight" and like how I should keep on fighting and then the song has "Fight your way" and now for months I have been thinking about "Hold on" and I had been doing so. And now the song has "but still I hold on" like AMBER DO YOU READ MY STUFF? 😂😂😂❤
Oh my god, I love Amber so much. This song is so good, (both the English and Korean versions) I can't express how much I appreciate Amber's existence. Thank you *sobs and makes wild hand gestures*
yes!! Im so glad you have your own channel, I hope you get tons of support and gain even more popularity and recognition for your amazing talents, vocal, and music writing/production skills!! :D THANK YOU SM FOR LETTING HER OUT OF THE DUNGEON
amber please keep going we are here for you you're not on you're own we are always here for you we love you from the bottem of our hearts you're my inspiration so please go on AMBER FIGHTING!!!!!!!!!!!!
We all have different sides to ourselves: happy, sad, angry and etc. You are always so cheerful and happy, always seems to be having fun, having a good time. But behind all those, you are suffering from all these negative feelings: loneliness, emptiness, helplessness. What I admire you the most is that you use the most positive way to release all these negativities, and that is through your music. You express your feelings to it and hope to encourage others with it. That is it just so admirable! You are a true inspiration Amber and I love you for it
Amber stay stong you beautiful soul. We the fans are with you till the end you sweet angel. You always give us hope so its time for us to give back the love and hope you gave to us. Stay strong Llama 😭💪🙏💖
Amber. I cried! Will always support you. I can't do much but i'll always purchase your music and give you as much support as I can! Don't lie to yourself... It's so not okay to hear you said it's okay 😭
Oh baby, you have so much more to come. I'm so proud of you, whichever path you take from here on out. I've loved you since f(x)'s debut, and I'll love you wherever you are, with anyone by your side, or with no one at all. Keep it going, kiddo!
OMG I just can't..... I'm Sooooooooooo in love with her...... there's something wonderful about Amber....... I hope she comes to NJ...i wanna meet her soooooooo bad
amber you should debut in US too~~ love your beautiful voice, it's a gem, really ;) n.b. lol i just realize the manager oppa was in the video :'))) hope you guys still in touch huhu i miss seeing the super cute interaction between amber and manager oppa... T_T
This song is so good. Hauntingly beautiful. Especially around 2 minutes where Gen Neo's voice just mixes smoothly with her voice. When I close my eyes, I feel like im outside in a field just like in the mv where she walks around some road.and all alone. Something about this song resonates deeply in me. This and "beautiful" simply magical.
Crossing. Borders. On my own.
+Charleigh John how about need to feel needed
+ikAEmmA i need to feel needed but here i am crossing the borders on my own
+Yasmin Trammell i need to feel needed and beautiful but here i am on my own crossing the borders
+Amber Ayra I love you omg
+idk lmao i love ur name..haha
GOSH AMBER, STOP MAKING ME CRYING WITH ALL YOUR SONGS. YOU SAID IT'S OKAY, BUT DAMN I ALMOST DROWN ON MY OWN TEARS .
Me too, the song is so beautiful
Pia Aguilar ikr T-T
SAME OMG /lies in puddle of own tears
Gingerbunnyyy **cries for more**
Cried a Han river
There are many reasons as to why I will always stan Amber the way I do.
1. She's not afraid to be herself
2. She's inspired me to feel strong as a tomboy
3. Her voice is breathtaking
4. Her songs are so inspiring
There are many more, but these 4 are the most important to me at the moment. I will always have a deep love for Amber and anything she does.
Firstly: i totally agree
Second: can you explain what a tomboy is?(sorry for asking)
@Lewa Alayna so like for example playing football or something like this. Then i guess i'm a half tomboy, because i like wearing oversize and i have a few things that my brother wore befor
@@tofu4784 Tomboys are typically women/girls who identify as female but don't really like feminine things like wearing makeup, dresses, skirts, etc. And prefer things that are more typically "male".
Even though I knew Amber wasn't the best singer in fx, her voice was always my favorite. There's something so honest and calming in her voice and it's beautiful.
YASSSSSS
Yes!
Yazzz
yesss exactly! yeah Lunas voice is stronger but to be honest i would listen to 2 songs of her no more. Amber i could listen to for dayssss, there for i say she has the best voice in fx
الو
Isn't this song about how she feels toward SM? She asks where is sm to help her build her career, but then she feels like she's on her own. And the part "But still I hold on,this mask is running thin" could mean she still keeps her smile on her face, but the sadness is too big for her to kepp holding the smile in her face ("I'll lie and say it's okay"). And she says "So far I've gone to get to you" could mean she went all the way from States to korea to get to sm. Well, there's a lot more thing to say about this song, but I think this song is deeper than what it actually looks like
Renan Yuji I thought this too. I always have this song on repeat, trying to decipher the lyrics and enjoy it at the same time. Oddly enough I can relate to this song. But recently I discovered that it could also be directed to MeU. Like the lines "I want you here to stay, for you complete me. But I'm here alone. Where are you?" Mainly for "U" complete "Me". "MeU". It's like she's saying she needs our help. MeU's complete f(x). Like MeU's could demand comebacks and proper promotions from SM for f(x) and all the members. Popular demand can do wonders. Either way, SM needs to step it up. MeU's, Amber, and all of f(x) have had enough.
I think what she is trying saying by "my mask is running thin" is, usually when people suffer from deppression (idk if amber does suffer from deppression) they feel that they have to "put on a mask" so people will think everything is fine but deep down nothing is fine. And by saying that its "running thin" she could be saying that she feels like she cant act like everything is fine anymore. That's just my opinion though.
OMG Amber has her own Channel this is amazing! This is rare for SM isn't it?
Somewhat. Jonghyun has his own channel if I'm not mistaken.
+Kaitlin A. Blagg that's his own personal chanel, though, not for any official releases like this one.
+Kaitlin A. Blagg really what is it
+ginny7000 it's still his though ^^ just like amber has this one and what the pineapple!
+G 바네사 i don't remember off the top of my head but i can find it for you! its somewhere in my subscriptions.
AHHHHHHHHHHH IM HERE
hahahha hi
This is so short but so meaningful. I mean, she didn't need a bunch of special light/sound effects or a huge studio with 1000 dancers in order to show her feelings. Is just Amber being Amber, no make up, no fashion trends or random stuff. This is simply beautiful and YOU can't deny it lol.
You are right, I really love Amber because of that! *---*
THIS ♡
+Nathalia Carolina (Applepie13) ikr it is so meaningful , i wanna cry on how good this is !
true
Certainly!
Resting my tired eyes on my beautiful Amber....and my ears to her wonderful voice.
I'm not a kpop girl group fan neither do i have any other favorite girl kpop artist apart from Amber, she is just the best. Always cheering for you Amber
Immaculate ExoFan I thought it was just me, I'm not way into girl groups/artists but Amber is too extra to not like
Maybe because she is different from other girls.
i hope in the past year y'all have seen the light that is girl groups lmao
I love how Amber is so true to herself. She doesn't need surgery or loads of makeup or really sexy outfits to be beautiful. She is trying to spread the message that people are who they are and who they want to be and we are all beautiful the way we are.
Amber, you're my inspiration and I seriously think we need so many more people like you in this world. You are beautiful the way you are and no one and nothing can change who you are. Hwaiting and stay awesome and unique!!!
Glad we agree.
YeolDaFire wait she?
"she"? i dont really understand this comment..can someone explain it to me?😟
Rasyika Efriyet it's a dam girl for fuck sake
yep, Amber is a girl.
I love how she always give credit to God in her songs that she writes.
same
Yesss!
True !!
Luke Borden when did she do that? Lol
You can hear it defiantly in her song Borders when she says "Oh fear not ‘cause
I know I’m in His hands Though I can’t see I know there’s a plan"
that moment when you listen to too much K-Pop it takes you a minute to realize it's in English
haha
same 😂
+Bunnii Yeah, I was listening the Korean version and then I switched to the English version accidently and I was like, oh I just put it on repeat.
same haha
omg yass
It’s okay it’s okay
I’ll lie and say It’s okay
So far I’ve gone to get to you
It’s okay it’s okay
You see through my hardened face
Trying to see the light
through the rain
Hoping that nothings gone
But still I hold on
this mask is running thin
I know I’m losing my senses
I pray each and every day
For me to stay awake
‘Cause I’m on my own
where are you
It’s too late It’s too late
Won’t believe I came too late
The bells rung me out
I’ve been knocked down
I’m done for good
I’m done for good
Though there’s no way
But still I hold on
this mask is running thin
I know I’m losing my senses
I pray each and every day
For me to stay awake
‘Cause I’m on my own
But still I hold on
my breath now is running thin
I don’t care that I’m losing
I want you here to stay
For you complete me
But I’m here alone where are you
Where are you
No more things left to say
I just wanted you to stay
Hold on this mask is running thin
I know I’m losing my senses
Pray each and every day
For me to stay awake
Cause I’m on my own
where are you
V. Louiz thanks..... 😍
Its so wierd because I wrote a poem that just goes so well with these lyrics and back when I wrote it I didn't even know that this song existed
Wow... Beautiful... I love it
She deserves this so much I'm glad we can finally see the real Amber too
Haha I've found another leafy and kpop lover!!
+SNSD EXO Yass
YAS
Amber is growing up. Little by little she's showing us her personally story and I'm scared of what this means for F(x). Out of all of them she would probably be better off solo when you think about it.
Same feeling. I'm happy that she's growing and creating her own music color. But we have to face it, its far from f(x)'s style. I'm just going to hold on and embrace what lies in for the future. For now, let's support Amber and help her attain more llama lovers.
+Shell Ross I think any idol that starts out in an idol group should only leave if their company is restricting them. In Amber's case SM seems to be letting her do her own thing and I don't think there's much reason for her to leave f(x)
I think she provides a nice touch to f(x). They can't all have the same direction in music, but I believe they still like what they're doing.
+Shell Ross I love (F)x too but it looks like they are already parting ways. Sulli left awhile ago, Victoria has been doing lots of work in her country China, Krystal was unhappy and apparently followed her sister and doing her own thing. Only Luna & Amber have shown any interest in singing and they can actually sing very good they have proved it. Lets encourage Amber and Luna to do their thing.
+MYHelen143 how did u know krystal unhappy? lol their bond still strong :))
Wow... I don't actually know how to feel about this. As a #MeU since their debut, I'll always support f(x), OT5, wherever and whenever. But I get the feeling that Amber has a lot to say and many personal decisions to make, and if I want to be selfish, yeah that scares me a lot... I'm terrified the f(x) I know won't be the same anymore. At the same time, part of their musical journey is self-discovery, and while it might be hard as a fan to accept that - especially since it feels like we've stuck through thick and thin with them - I really hope they all do what makes them happy. I'm glad Amber is finally releasing solos and willing to share them with us, I'm happy Victoria stays our ever-positive leader (with a million promotions in China
The truth is they don't rely on being f(x) anymore. They are building their own careers. Yet they never forget about us and that's all I need to be assured that no matter what happens f(x) will always love MeUs.
+Evan Montero i feel the same :(
from different perspective, i've never been a fan of f(x). i just simply didn't like their music, maybe except for the latest '4 walls'. but i love amber's solo so much! i love that she produces her own music and writes songs, because i feel like THIS is a part of her. this is her style, her words.
so, my opinion is: if members of f(x) are not interested anymore in being in a girl group, they shouldnt force herselves. if it makes them happy, then they can be f(x) how long they want to.
+Lighten Shadow *themselves
+Lighten Shadow Amber has her own color in the industry far from f(x)'s style. It's darker and purer. But I love both ♡
Man, I don't listen to that much kpop anymore, but I decided to go listen to this since she wrote it herself, and I really like it! The production, the lyrics, the vocals and the music video are all beautiful. Good job Amber!
Oh why? I wanted to quit kpop once before, because I felt so trapped amongst all the groups which are practically the same with their music. But then I realised I just didn't see far enough and here I am, back again, this time supporting groups that I genuinely like :) But if you really decide to stop being a kpop fan then I guess that's a good choice for you
I quit from Kpop long time ago but I only came here for her music. she seems genuine.
Agreed
+VIPANDA I don't know, I don't hate kpop at all, I just don't like the fact the members of groups don't often contribute creatively. Isn't the point of music to express yourself?
+Kelly sorry to butt in. but i dont think music is only to express yourself. some singers are great as messenger. they spread the message from the song writers. i dont believe that music is so rigid as in to expresd yourself only when it is so flexible as enjoyment
Love her sensitivity, her musical talent, and her heart that's as big and deep as the ocean.
The most beautiful person on the world
I know right😍
I hope JRE makes a reaction to this. Damn my screen is wet.(the tears doe).
omgggg I thought the same but I guess he does not react to English song :/
Should I cry or should I cry???
CRY
Let's just cry as a fandom *virtual hugs*
Baby, don't cry, tonight ~Exo
Cry
+MissPsychobabbler i think you should cry
God Amber is such a beautiful person on both the inside and outside. Already got both the english and korean versions downloaded!
I'm on an Amber marathon. Watching all her songs and so far I haven't come across a bad one. Love them all. ♥
My bestfriend passed recently, this song speaks so hard to me right now. I really don't know who I am with out her.
❤❤❤💔 I'm so sorry for your loss ❤
Daniel Olchowoj you evil
I love Amber so much for making English songs. It's very refreshing to here things I can understand every once in awhile.
Amber, you are not alone. We fan's are always with you.
Dear Amber,
I love everything about you from your style to your personnality, you're amazing and such an inspiring person.
I wish you're happy because "borders", "on my own" and "beautiful" are songs that show the harships you had to go through. I find myself in your words and I want to thank you for singing things I can't tell to myself.
You have an awesome voice, take good care of yourself, don't worry about haters, I'm not even a huge fan of yours but I can tell you're a kindhearted person. I hope one day I'll get the chance to see you and remind you that you've worked so hard to achieve your dreams and you've succeded :)
From the bottom of my heart.
I listen this twice to realize that this is in English lmao. kpop influence hits me so hard.
Anna Wang So me!
Anna Wang omg me too I realize it because of ur comment !!! this is insane 😂😂
I guess you're the one who's bad in English cause she's korean American and she lived in Los Angeles :) her English is really fluent you don't know
Hana ELF SJ She didn't mean that Amber's English is bad. It's just that we listen to too much kpop to realize that Amber was singing in English. We are too used to listening to Korean.
Hana ELF MeU Amber is taiwanese american, not korean american.
Amber's voice is amazing! She really show us herself piece by piece, she is just great
I need to start shopping at the shop Amber get's her clothes from
Face full of tears 5 seconds into the video! 😢 Amber outdid herself with this one, feature is bomb too
You're not on your own Amber ... WE'RE HERE FOR YOU!!!
From uni to work, this is my going to home with a heavy heart song, it bring me comfort
among all of these girlband soloists, i think amber is the most unique and creative one. im not really a kpop fans so i really didnt know what sm do did and done but i just honestly proud of her, her songs are very different but easy to listen and i just in love with her:")
I LOVE OUR LLAMA T^T ALL THE FEELS, GUYS. ALL THE FEELS FROM THIS MV.
THIS is the Amber I've been waiting for, this is the Amber we've been praying for, THIS is her being in her natural element and showing us her truest light! Oh my god, I'm ready for this and this song is perfect in English and Korean.
Her and Gen Neo, I can't speak enough on this perfection. Thank you Amber for always putting your best foot forward and never compromising who you are despite the nay-sayers. I can't imagine anything that you must have gone through this business and all of the highs and lows but I'm telling you now, I and thousands of people are here to support you and I pray to the heavens that you are happy regardless.
FIGHTING!
The heartbreak in this song is tangible. This is a beautifully haunting song and it is going in my playlist!
we're always by your side amber.. you are not on your own
Her voice is addicting. I can't stop listening.
Amber's voice is so so gentle, yet strong. TT3TT
My baby brother struggles to sleep but this song makes him calm down. Something special about this song even babies feel it.
Aww Amber touching even the littlest hearts
+Min Young Ah 민 영아 awwwwww that is so cute!
Today he was having hard time again because he's sick, so I let him listen to it (and also borders by amber) again and he calmed down immediately 😻😻😻💕💕 Amber thank you so much touching all of us young and old. He loves al your meaningfull songs like beautiful, borders and on my own💕💕
I always listen to this song when I'm returning home from university
like a routine👧
Hey Amber. I don't know if you will ever read this but I just wanna thank you for everything you had done and everything you're doing. People like me probably listen to your songs more. People like me as in people who are more emotional than most. And I don't know but it's just probably you yourself and your music that gives me a warm feeling and it soothes my soul. Thankyou so much. Thankyou for existing. You're definitely one of my role models. I love you so much.
I really hope things will get better for Amber...she deserves so much better honestly.
Her voice is veeery beautiful and I'm really happy that she got a TH-cam channel
She's so real honestly and so inspiring one of the only kpop idols who I can say I look up to and is a role model. I hope she knows that she inspires a lot of people to just be themselves to accept that we all have struggles and life will never be perfect but still we"ll get through it some how. she deserves all the success in the world.
I'm singing this song everyday before I go to sleep, actually all of her songs
Jack Jack just completes this video x3
SHANNON 💜 IS RIGHT THERE
Amber and her, best friends forever. 💜
I'm in love with her voice
I'm in love with her style
I'm in love with her lyrics
WHY I DIDN'T KNOW HER BEFORE WT-
amber 😭 you are freakin' good singer
YOUR VOICE. TOO BEAUTIFUL AMBER.
Her voice is so beautiful and lovely. I, honestly, could listen to it all day.
Sm is doing nothing but treating f(x) and MeU like they never exist.. I love this song so much, please produce more ❤️❤️
THANK YOU AMBER FOR ALWAYS BEING YOUR BEAUTIFUL SELF. YOU'RE AN INSPIRATION TO US ALL
my heart is melting...she is such and genuine, real and such and inspirational person. the fact that she is always being herself and always there for others...i just love her. i only wish you the best for everything you do and your future. I love you Amber. Thank You for being you.
She's so underrated. People need to see and appreciate what a talent she is. SM included.
Amber stop. My heart can't take it.
tell me about it
ysewrantz lubin I giggled so hard when I first saw it and then realized I was in class at the time.
lol. that sounds just like something i would do
ysewrantz lubin I spazz too often over new songs.
GO CHECK OUT HER LATEST VIDEO need to feel needed
I find myself relating to most of Ambers songs....
Why this mv isn't getting enough views ? it should have reached 1M But no matter what amber is still a miracle maker she always save me in my worst situation thank you for your great and amazing songs amber you are such an insperation
I think SM should promote her more
We are now at 1M.
TAKE ME AMBER, I LOVE YOU, THIS IS SO BEAUTIFUL
So proud of you amber! We're with you! You go girl!!
...i'm watching this again and I'm crying. manager oppa is gone and im going to cry. how is amber dealing with sm taking away her family?
Jack jack out there getting fans. This song is so beautiful amber💞
This girl is amazing! SM thank you for allowing Amber to shine like this. Just a beautiful song
Crossing/Borders/On My Own I love u Amber
We don't deserve amber , look at this amazing production and this is all for her fans , for us llamas like .. she needs to know how much she means to us
I can already imagine amber's solo fan meeting and that she sings all these beautiful songs:D
no matter how many times i listen to it, it touches my heart a lot every single time....like it goes straight to ur heart.loves everything abt thiS SONG..its message, music,lyrics and emotions and of course amber calming and soothing voice. I miss u a lot Amber T-T
It's so hard to find female artists that put so much emotion into their voices... you can find all of the soulful voices in the world but I would prefer the quiet melancholy I feel from Amber's voice in this song...
That angelic voice! WHERE HAVE YOU BEEN HIDING IT FOR SO LONG??? I'm so happy she finally gets to do a solo and I sincerely hope the Korean fans supports her because I don't see many views and this makes me sad. I love this girl so much she's my only girl crush and my dream is to see her in person one day. Amber is the most unique female korean idol there to make a change and I pray to god she succeeds. On another note I really really wish there is a collab with Jonghyun because I love my little dino family lol no seriously tho their voices together would sound magical! LOVE AMBER!!!! ♥♥♥♥
The lyrics to this song continues to dig deep in my heart. Thank you Amber, thank you.
Amber....you need to stop....you are hurting my heart with your beauty and beautiful voice. Gosh, thumbs up to the MAX Xo
At first I didn't think that I'd like Amber because I don't listen to f(x) but she is now one of my favorite solo artists and i don't even like female singers/bands but Amber is special
"I'll lie and say it's okay."
This song is so beautiful and very emotional. In addition to that, the MV is so pure and beautiful too. This is the type of music I live for. Amber can go from Shake That Brass to On My Own in like .3 seconds
Amber release things for the most perfect time for me. Borders was released when I wanted to give up. Now this, is released when I'm falling apart...
Every time, the songs gives me power and reminds me of my promises with myself and how I should/would always stay strong no matter how tough and hard times gets...
Thank you so much Amber for giving me more hope and power. ❤
i feel you too. same! just like she can understands what happen with her fans :') Thank God for good timing :)
+Rhea Lapez It's so amazing how the song just really goes with what I have been thinking.
like before borders were released I was thinking about "Fight" and like how I should keep on fighting and then the song has "Fight your way"
and now for months I have been thinking about "Hold on" and I had been doing so. And now the song has "but still I hold on"
like AMBER DO YOU READ MY STUFF? 😂😂😂❤
+Euangelia Evelia yes she does understand which is so amazing!
Im glad it helps you. Stay strong.
+Alma G. G. Thank you! ^^ :)
Oh my god, I love Amber so much. This song is so good, (both the English and Korean versions) I can't express how much I appreciate Amber's existence. Thank you *sobs and makes wild hand gestures*
yes!! Im so glad you have your own channel, I hope you get tons of support and gain even more popularity and recognition for your amazing talents, vocal, and music writing/production skills!! :D THANK YOU SM FOR LETTING HER OUT OF THE DUNGEON
2023 im still here from start… i miss you amber
Me too!
HAPPY 10th YEAR ANNIVERSARY f(x) AMBER LIU 💜💜💜
Is this JackJack's MV debut?? ;}
Lol thought so too :>>
the world may ever know
KOooopu
amber please keep going we are here for you you're not on you're own we are always here for you we love you from the bottem of our hearts you're my inspiration so please go on AMBER FIGHTING!!!!!!!!!!!!
# Amber J. Liu for life you will always have support no matter what ♡♡♡
she must believe more in her self she is such a hero she helps me in my hardest times
We all have different sides to ourselves: happy, sad, angry and etc. You are always so cheerful and happy, always seems to be having fun, having a good time. But behind all those, you are suffering from all these negative feelings: loneliness, emptiness, helplessness. What I admire you the most is that you use the most positive way to release all these negativities, and that is through your music. You express your feelings to it and hope to encourage others with it. That is it just so admirable! You are a true inspiration Amber and I love you for it
I came here again after watching that buzzfeed video. Anyone else? This song is just too good.
Haha thank you for checking out Amber's music.
omg thank you amber just thank you. thank god i made my way to watch this! ❤
even if everything is hard, it's okay amber!!! hang in there, everything will be better alrighty, you always got us!!
Her voice is absolutely beyond any recognition she's ever gotten for it
Wow. After watching this video, boy, was I not expecting my face to be this moisturized.
Wait, those are my tears.
Dammit.
this song deserves more recognition....Amber your the best LOVE THE SONG
Amber stay stong you beautiful soul. We the fans are with you till the end you sweet angel. You always give us hope so its time for us to give back the love and hope you gave to us. Stay strong Llama 😭💪🙏💖
Amber. I cried! Will always support you. I can't do much but i'll always purchase your music and give you as much support as I can! Don't lie to yourself... It's so not okay to hear you said it's okay 😭
Amber has two TH-cam channel wow
this one is run by sm but wtp is completely her own
+Luis Enrique Figueroa She also has one for her music. :)
Amber is such a beautiful artist, if only all stars could express themselves this freely
She should have debuted as a American singer. Her music makes me feel relaxed.
QUEEN OF MY LIFE, QUEEN OF MY HEART 💖💖 LOVE YOU SO MUCH
Oh baby, you have so much more to come. I'm so proud of you, whichever path you take from here on out. I've loved you since f(x)'s debut, and I'll love you wherever you are, with anyone by your side, or with no one at all. Keep it going, kiddo!
OMG I just can't..... I'm Sooooooooooo in love with her...... there's something wonderful about Amber....... I hope she comes to NJ...i wanna meet her soooooooo bad
amber you should debut in US too~~ love your beautiful voice, it's a gem, really ;)
n.b. lol i just realize the manager oppa was in the video :')))
hope you guys still in touch huhu i miss seeing the super cute interaction between amber and manager oppa... T_T
Amber is such a great singer. I hope she can continue to have solo development in 2017.
Love her
This song is so good. Hauntingly beautiful. Especially around 2 minutes where Gen Neo's voice just mixes smoothly with her voice. When I close my eyes, I feel like im outside in a field just like in the mv where she walks around some road.and all alone. Something about this song resonates deeply in me. This and "beautiful" simply magical.