It's so awesome to see how much Caleb changed his style his appearance, his vocals, and just his overall writing. Attack Attack changed so much but they are still that amazing band. It's good to see that both AA and Johnny have good things going for them.
And yes, Austin Charlile was a very good singer, but Caleb is still doing a very good job. I don't really miss "The old Attack Attack". I just listen to their stuff, and enjoy it. I don't listen to the songs that I don't like. And only because Attack Attack got a new singer, it doesn't mean it's a shitty band.
the phrasing of Caleb's vocals reminds me a lot of how Abandon All Ships' screamer phrases his vocals. I'm so glad Caleb landed at the style he did. haha
you guys ahve to remember that Austin and Caleb have two very different screaming styles, Austin did a lot of highs and vocal frys were as Caleb does a lot of lows and growls they have to different styles. listen to some of their newer stuff live and Caleb doesnt sound that bad
@superslayerguy they probably didnt mic the crowd. cuz the sound isnt from the camera, im pretty sure the sound is direct through the soundboard so u wouldnt be able to hear the crowd unless they put mics in front of the crowd
@thirdtalent723 Yeah, he is WAY better now. I was going to get a new full set but they cancelled their show here on their last tour, so who knows when they'll be back now. =/
i Saw them last night at the extreme thing Festival in las vegas They Were FUCKING AMAZING im Glad They Wernt like this the Crowd Was Going insane Was the best Show Of the night
To all the people saying he can't scream try playing an entire set for about 3 months. You voice will get and you body will start to give. You can't give it 100% every night. Get off his nuts.
@SummerGameProject let me give you the timeline : Austin Carlile was in the recorded first album, Someday Came Suddenly, he left the band, they found Nick Bonham, made the video "Stick Stickly", he also left the band, now Caleb Shomo is the screamer now, the former synth guy, what you hear here is not what is on the recorded version .
everybody please calm your shit this is when Caleb first started and i just saw them a little bit ago and he is beast now so stop hating and go see a live concert
too all those who thinks the screamer sucks ITS CALEB SHOMO IT WAS HIS FIRST TIME HIGH PITCHED SCREAMS HES THE FORMER KEYBOARDIST AND BEST DEAT GROWLER THEY HAVE EVER HAD AND HIS NEW SCREAMS ARE BETTER
@ak99superstar if you're talking about the "This is a Family Tour" then yeah, that tour failed miserably. They came to Denver and it was just.. Bad. Emmure cancelled, the screamer in the band In Fear and Faith was "sick" or gone or something. Also this was the time Attack Attack! had a replacement for the singer.
I hope everyone takes into account that this is like 3 years ago and Caleb was like 16, 17. So could everybody please give Caleb a break, everyone gets better over time.
You do realize that a 20 second HIGH that gets HIGHER with Austin screams. As someone who's in a Nu-Metal/Industrial Metal/Rapcore band, a 20 second prog high scream like Austin's is rare(unless its based from let's say Black Metal or something)
NO OFENSE WHAT SO EVER, but in the official music video I tought their voices were like auto-tuned, THEY FUCKING TREATED MY LIFE.! they are fucking bad ass live.! this band is really cool. (:
@XRyanRevengeX that new "screamer" (if thats what you want to call him) is there original keys player, and he started screaming after AA kicked out austin
I read a comment earlier that said something like "GIve him a break. This was at the end of a set. Blah Blah Blah." If you scream correctly, your voice shouldn't suck this bad.
everyone.....caleb did the low screams on the Someday Came Suddenly album. excuse him for not being able to copy austin carlile. not many people can. plus, he is amazing live now. sooo go listen to some of AA!'s new stuff. caleb is amazing :D
@Dielawn0man Yeah dude, he definitely has. I met him on Wednesday night when I saw Pierce the Veil in Columbus, Ohio. He just turned 18 not too long ago.
Bro, this was in 2009. The singer/guitarist left in 2010, the screamer just recently left the band as well as the bassist. Caleb's screaming usually sounds much better than this although it still needs work as he runs out of breath to easily, but in this video it sounds like he's about to gag the whole time lol
everyones saying how shitty caleb is at screaming, and when i watched this a little while back i didnt realise it was caleb, and i also thought he was shit but hes actually gotten better, i like them with caleb better now
@xxJonLp i dont at all. in fact i think its very hard. however, he's in a band where screaming is the main element. If he was in all time low we wouldn't expect screaming
this is bad, but consider that this is at the end of a set and their voices are completely worn out at this point. it's incredibly hard to keep yourself going onstage. they're definitely 1000x better live now
How is this video clearer then 95% of videos in 2024?!?!
Todo este canal es una joya, lamentablemente ya no hay escena como la de antes :(
Attack Attack wya !?
It's absolutely incredible how much Caleb has improved since this video was taken.
Agreed. A lot different these days. He got so much shit when he first joined, but just needed some time.
It's so awesome to see how much Caleb changed his style his appearance, his vocals, and just his overall writing. Attack Attack changed so much but they are still that amazing band. It's good to see that both AA and Johnny have good things going for them.
I miss this band :(
They are backkkkk lol
Yeah but it all kinda sucks lol
HOW COULD ANYBODY DISLIKE THIS?
Yeah it's so freaking dope even 15 years later I don't care it's a certified banger
Caleb has improved so much, I've seen them in April this year and he sounded really good, so proud of him
And yes, Austin Charlile was a very good singer, but Caleb is still doing a very good job. I don't really miss "The old Attack Attack". I just listen to their stuff, and enjoy it. I don't listen to the songs that I don't like. And only because Attack Attack got a new singer, it doesn't mean it's a shitty band.
I straight up assume I'm listening to Brokencyde when I hear the intro..... Gets me Everytime. Miss Attack! Attack!@
dude you listen to Attack Attack, DUN DUN DUN DUN DIGGA DIGGA CHUG CHUG CHUGGA, you have no right to say anyone is generic
the phrasing of Caleb's vocals reminds me a lot of how Abandon All Ships' screamer phrases his vocals. I'm so glad Caleb landed at the style he did. haha
you guys ahve to remember that Austin and Caleb have two very different screaming styles, Austin did a lot of highs and vocal frys were as Caleb does a lot of lows and growls they have to different styles. listen to some of their newer stuff live and Caleb doesnt sound that bad
If you guys watch live videos now, Caleb has inproved so much.
He's 100x better since this.
i love that "i see stars" shirt hes wearing!!
caleb is SO much fucking better now... seriously i was blown away and gained so much respect for him
i love how the crowd is cheering right up until he says "You want one more?" then it goes silent.
i love that this was a year ago
hes so much better now
oh my God , i loved that intro
Caleb dropped a ton of weight and his voice has gotten way better since his first tour as frontman. Progress ftw!
just realized! damn calebs good too but austins voice was perfect for this album(someday came suddenly) no one could do better
this is a shining example that rap and metal should never be mixed.
Is he repping I See Stars? It looks like his shirt says "SHE SCREAMS MY NAME."
Yea, I had that shit around that time, I think my sister has it now lol
@@yungwoodyharrelson nice
@superslayerguy they probably didnt mic the crowd. cuz the sound isnt from the camera, im pretty sure the sound is direct through the soundboard so u wouldnt be able to hear the crowd unless they put mics in front of the crowd
screamer sounds shit, clean vocals sounds absolutely amazing!
@thirdtalent723 Yeah, he is WAY better now. I was going to get a new full set but they cancelled their show here on their last tour, so who knows when they'll be back now. =/
David visbal en los coros jajajaajaj
Duude I Went to The This Is A Family Tour... They Were FUCKKEN AWESOME.!!!
@butters226 this is caleb, he's still in the band. the guy that left was nick their old screamer
i Saw them last night at the extreme thing Festival in las vegas They Were FUCKING AMAZING im Glad They Wernt like this the Crowd Was Going insane Was the best Show Of the night
y does everyone think this sucked? It actually sounded pretty good, and apparently the audience was having a good time, who else liked it?
Hey that's Bilmuri lol
ugh, please PLEASE get a full set...theyre like a million times better now...
how is the sound so fucking good in this video...
To all the people saying he can't scream try playing an entire set for about 3 months. You voice will get and you body will start to give. You can't give it 100% every night. Get off his nuts.
@SummerGameProject let me give you the timeline : Austin Carlile was in the recorded first album, Someday Came Suddenly, he left the band, they found Nick Bonham, made the video "Stick Stickly", he also left the band, now Caleb Shomo is the screamer now, the former synth guy, what you hear here is not what is on the recorded version .
*coughs* CANT SCREAM *coughs harder*
xP
Bad thing about being a screamo band, when you perform live and start doing all of your screamo songs your voice starts to give out. :c
1:16 "THAT THIS WOULD BE" sounds like hes eating a cheeseburger and sayin that lol
Caleb: Let me hear you!
Crowd: ......
Wetzle: ch ch ch ding!
Caleb: oh.
Dayyyuummm, need to see these. -_-
best 46 seconds of my life
I can scream this shyt better wtf! Bring back Austin! Hate him or not- he's the man.
Give him a break. His throat was wrecked, he told me that night that he was uber sick. Check any other video, they kill it.
im so glad kaleb didnt sound like this when i saw them live :D
Jesus Caleb has come such a long way. This compared to beartooth, just wow it is credible. His vocals were awful here and now they’re great
everybody please calm your shit this is when Caleb first started and i just saw them a little bit ago and he is beast now so stop hating and go see a live concert
best band on earth. thumbs up if you caught on to my sarcastic tone.
too all those who thinks the screamer sucks ITS CALEB SHOMO IT WAS HIS FIRST TIME HIGH PITCHED SCREAMS HES THE FORMER KEYBOARDIST AND BEST DEAT GROWLER THEY HAVE EVER HAD AND HIS NEW SCREAMS ARE BETTER
@ak99superstar if you're talking about the "This is a Family Tour" then yeah, that tour failed miserably. They came to Denver and it was just.. Bad. Emmure cancelled, the screamer in the band In Fear and Faith was "sick" or gone or something. Also this was the time Attack Attack! had a replacement for the singer.
I hope everyone takes into account that this is like 3 years ago and Caleb was like 16, 17. So could everybody please give Caleb a break, everyone gets better over time.
You do realize that a 20 second HIGH that gets HIGHER with Austin screams. As someone who's in a Nu-Metal/Industrial Metal/Rapcore band, a 20 second prog high scream like Austin's is rare(unless its based from let's say Black Metal or something)
A band to listen to is Emmure, The vocalist can scream live way better than any band you could probably think of.
NO OFENSE WHAT SO EVER, but in the official music video I tought their voices were like auto-tuned, THEY FUCKING TREATED MY LIFE.! they are fucking bad ass live.! this band is really cool. (:
AN ASTONISHING END ALBUM OUT NOW ON ITUNES! CATCH US ON TECHNICAL CHAOS TOUR!!!!CHECK OUR MYSPACE NOW!!!
this song is fucking sick as shit!! I loved when I saw these guys live.
ive just have always loved the intro to this song
1: The mormons need to stop advertising on youtube.
2: Attack Attack is amazing and i'm shocked that there are more dislikes than likes.
@XRyanRevengeX that new "screamer" (if thats what you want to call him) is there original keys player, and he started screaming after AA kicked out austin
I cant believe i bought their cd...
@99999999greyson Actually no this is their current singer Caleb Shomo, the former keyboardist for the band.
its caleb as of 2012. this video was posted in 09 dude, check your facts
I read a comment earlier that said something like "GIve him a break. This was at the end of a set. Blah Blah Blah." If you scream correctly, your voice shouldn't suck this bad.
To drummers: hear the cymbals? didnt think so, this kids is why we use overhead, lesson learned.
He's way better now and lost a ton of weight this was his first live
everyone.....caleb did the low screams on the Someday Came Suddenly album. excuse him for not being able to copy austin carlile. not many people can. plus, he is amazing live now. sooo go listen to some of AA!'s new stuff. caleb is amazing :D
Where did caleb get that shirt?!?!?!
2020
@Dielawn0man Yeah dude, he definitely has. I met him on Wednesday night when I saw Pierce the Veil in Columbus, Ohio. He just turned 18 not too long ago.
@Drumrunner117 Agreed, they've gotten sooo much better.
I find it funny that it's Austin screaming on the backing track but then they suck once the track is up haha
Anyone else wonder why this tour was called "Shred Til Your Dead" when none of the bands could actually shred?
this is awesome
@DanielRinerMusic we're haters. everyone has the right to judge even if we dont have the ability to actually do it.
you guys realize this was his first live performance as vocalist right?
Caleb doesnt sound good doing Austins vocals but he sounds good when he does his songs.
Was that Jeremy from ADTR that came on stage during the bridge?
Cannot stop laughing!
Their guitarist is some sick love child between carrot top and Dio.
Bro, this was in 2009. The singer/guitarist left in 2010, the screamer just recently left the band as well as the bassist. Caleb's screaming usually sounds much better than this although it still needs work as he runs out of breath to easily, but in this video it sounds like he's about to gag the whole time lol
THANK YOU!
everyones saying how shitty caleb is at screaming, and when i watched this a little while back i didnt realise it was caleb, and i also thought he was shit but hes actually gotten better, i like them with caleb better now
this is the first music video i've seen where there are more dislikes than likes 0_o
@shibbyska lol was i saying it wasnt? im saying for live shows, not recorded!
@footballkidooooooooo That's Nick. Caleb is on the left playing keys/synths.
I'll miss the old attack attack
this was back in 2009....Caleb's so much more better now.
@cmkelly257 recorded sound using a live feed from the mixer probably, should really have added the camera sound too.
@xxJonLp i dont at all. in fact i think its very hard. however, he's in a band where screaming is the main element. If he was in all time low we wouldn't expect screaming
they seriously got another dude at the end to scream for him
This Is Great!! Why many haters?!
this is bad, but consider that this is at the end of a set and their voices are completely worn out at this point. it's incredibly hard to keep yourself going onstage. they're definitely 1000x better live now
But that was when caleb just took over. He has gotten so much better. I saw them twice with him and they are fucking epic.
@wenisrus1 Yeah, they did. Their old one sings for Of Mice & Men now ;)
@MrAndroidDev first times are rough but do you hear how good he is now!?
the video for this song is funny as hell
on the plus side, johnnys sounding fucking amazing . thats a nice change
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAH I CAN'T BREATH I LAUGH SO HARD TO THE SCREAMER!!
they have got so much better
i love the synth in this. if anyone knows what the exact synth is,please tell me (x
Before the song even came? Wow.
this isnt austin this is nick the guy who took over for austin