Putin's 'rotten' Russia needs to change - Evgenia Kara-Murza on the fight for Russian freedom
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 29 มิ.ย. 2023
- When Evgenia Kara-Murza and her husband Vladimir parted ways in April 2022, she had no idea that would be the last time they’d see each other.
Subscribe: bit.ly/C4_News_Subscribe
Vladimir, a long-time Russian opposition activist, was arrested in Moscow later that month and is now serving 25 years in prison for his public criticism of President Vladimir Putin and Russia's war on Ukraine. Since then, Evgenia has taken up the mantle of his activism, travelling around the world to speak out against his detention and the crimes of Putin’s authoritarian regime.
Today on Ways to Change the World, Evgenia Kara-Murza joins Krishnan Guru-Murthy to talk about her fight to free Russia’s political prisoners, the toll Vladimir’s detention has taken on their family and whether she can envisage a future in a free, democratic Russia.
Produced by Silvia Maresca
-------
Watch more of our explainer series here - • Coronavirus Explained
Get more news at our site - www.channel4.com/news/
Follow us:
Facebook - / channel4news
Twitter - / channel4news
TikTok - / c4news
Instagram - / channel4news
Evgenia..you are a superb politician.
a salute to this iron willed lady,i am from sudan and share her love of democracy,rule of law,freedom and bringng the magnetski law against all kltptocrats worldwide
Bot.
@@tastypymp1287 wth!!!
@@MosmMAli 👈bots do this
@@tastypymp1287 People are risking their lives, and then like some "moron" you come out with "Bot."
Don't you think that is 'pathetic...' behaviour?
@@sebastianwrites 👈 Oh look, they've deployed the sanctimonious bot.
Pipe down.
Very impressive lady,who is talking very bravely and very knowldgable❤❤❤.
What a powerful woman. Watch out for the Russian bots swarming the comments.
Thanks for posting.
I admire you…a woman of strength and your love and supporrt for your husband I pray for you and Valdimir and your children. I watched news and saw the your picture of you and your husband…such a lovely expression and relationship …I pray for Navanly too Pray that time will come one day that Putin, this murderer will be trail one day at Hague.. One of my friend said if there were such a day, she will spit on him and make sure put him in a cage …. You are not lonely….many people around the world is watching and stand behind you.
What a very brave family. God bless.
I admire this family’s courage and commitment to a worthy cause.
Wonderful courageous woman I wish her the best.
They sound like they have a wonderful relationship!
Extraordinary people. I wish them the victory they so deserve: they are resolute and willing to pay the price of self sacrifice against heinous odds and offer themselves up to the Russian maw in support of their argument. Very humbling.
It’s a classic story of self-sacrifice in Russia. Millions of Russians have sacrificed themselves to the regime and then there are those who sacrifice themselves to an ideal that the regime be changed.
wow what an amazing woman, thank you Krishnan, channel 4 for letting her speak her truth
*the truth.
@@HaggardPillockHD'letting her'....
I loved hearing a longer form conversation with Evgenia after seeing her speaking on Channel 4 News and other outlets - what a remarkably strong and brave woman! 💪🏻 I’ve long admired and respected her husband Vladimir when I’ve seen him speak, and the outrageously disproportionate incarceration and treatment of him, Navalny, and basically every political prisoner of an authoritarian regime, leaves me feeling sickened and frustrated that there isn’t more being done to safeguard their basic human rights. And that’s just me speaking as a progressive and a human with empathy, let alone imagining how someone with personal involvement would be feeling.
Thank you... well said.
Brave wife. 😢
Is really sad , separated for thinking and speaking for the right.
God bless you and your inspiring husband Evgenia. The sun is going to rise over Russia again soon and your shared vision will become a reality. There’s always hope 💪🏽😘
How is Vladimir Kara-Murza being treated by his fellow-prisoners? I've heard a few things about Russia prison culture.
Such courage and integrity
Wonderful woman, her husband a real hero.
Russia has always been "rotten" and stood on a delicate power-balance. It's naive to assume that a "free and democratic" Russia can remain as one entity. Internal socio-economic and regional disparities are so huge, Russia needs to split into multiple countries for that to happen. No single person or regime can manage Russia without an iron fist.
Without a strong and powerful regime, Russia can easily disintegrate, which is not a bad thing for the quality of life of ordinary Russian citizens in the long-run. But for the sake of nuclear safety, we need Russia to be united and stable.
It will never be united and stable under a despotic regime for long.
Remarkable woman
❤ Wow ! what a brave lady , brilliant interview.
Evgenia Kara-Murza represents the future of Russia. Great interview. Thank you! - And yes, Mr. Krishnan Guru-Murthy, even oppressed people living in autocratic states are ready for freedom and democracy.
"freedom and democracy" = US domination
A wonderful person -..how can we ordinary people with just laptop or similar, miles away from Russia? Who should we lobby. The British government (mine) seems to have acted disgracefully.
What's going on with Nigel Farage?
With all due respect miss Evgenia, the UK doesn't leave her subjects to be killed/traded to terrorists. Remember SAS? I am trying to understand your frustration, but you know noting. Just like Jon Snow.
You say it so well, this is a fight for the whole world, thank you!
Ok. After 15 seconds i realize what she say is capital pinpoint correct. Like in correct.
С днём рождения, Володя! И долгих лет НА СВОБОДЕ и вместе с семьёй, друзьями и соратниками! Женя, низкий Вам поклон за Вашу борьбу!!!🙏🙏🙏
Why campaign for ONE unfair long term incarcerated person. Why not a class action against all of them? Is this campaign only for those with time, money, access to media and are good communicators?
The Kara-Murza family will save the world! Free Russia!
Strong woman and hero husband
Благослови вас бог семья Кара-Мурзы
My latest messages мои последние послания Я ПОСЫЛАЮ СНОВА ПОТОМУ ЧТО НЕ ЗНАЮ КОТОРЫЕ БЫЛИ УДАЛЕНЫ
Millions of black people was rape torture and murdered on rail road and people live in sells under rail road RIGHT NOW
YANDLE WOTHER SPOON ON A RUSH To HIDE REMAINS OF millions of DEAD BODIES in Cement and everywhere they only can ! Because people began to understand about human TRAFICKING and compline
How comes communism safe planet from japans radical army from MASLEM radical and from Nazi regime 1901-1945
Brezhnev kremlin changed direction of Lenin’s Stalins communism FROm UNCONTROLLABLE POWER
Stalin became dictator after second war becouse uncontrollable power
Славяне могут жить прекрасно без демократии ТОЛЬКО ЕСЛИ НАША ЦЕРКОВЬ БУДЕТ ХРИСТИАНСКАЯ И ПРАВИТЕЛЬСТВО ПЕРЕСТАНЕТ ВОРОВАТЬ И УБИВАТЬ что легко в общем то создать в России ЕСЛИ МЫ СОЗДАДИМ ПРАВИТЕЛЬСТВО СЛАВЯНСКОЕ НЕ ЕВРОПЕЙСКОЕ
все беды на российской святой земле от католичествам или аристократия или просто фашизм what is our cross BARBARIANS DYNASTY 2000 years old
Решение проблемы свободные выборы и контроль чиновников и правительства
All governments in a world are criminal now and they all need 3 rd war what keep them TOGETHER
КГБ KGB IS THE SAME MASS MURDERING MADHINE IN RUSSIA AS RAIL ROAD IN USA which never belongs to USA
ВЕСЬ МИР ПОМНИТ СОМПАНИЮ КОГДА СПАИВАЛИ ЕЛЬЦИНА И ПРОДАВАЛИ РОССИЮ В АРИСТОКРАТИЮ как и было давным давно запланировано 1000 лет назад когда католическая церковь начала свой подъем к вершинам ада
Ещё одна запретная тема CLT Clinton’s foundation or 9/11 and Hurricane Katrina in New Orleans or IRAQ WAR what is pure conspiracy of Europe MIDLE east and USA governments
Few things have to be told ASAP slavory and religion as first reason for all wars
Psychological weapon and devises in many regular things as helmet kids toys cameras
3 rd war was planed to be psychological and it begins 2019 when USA order ghost Churchill became USA president and RELISE long time waiting covid virus
Micro chips in every body and brain world wide
Selling people from country to country so called migration
Если правительство Украины было что называется БАНДЕРЫ то кремль должен был что то сделать чтоб не дать Украине стать слугой Европы и рабой НАТО
НО ТОЛЬКО НЕ ВОЙНОЙ А МИРОМ освободить правительство Украины от бандеровцев т е людей которые верят что возможно отсоединить Украину от России в пользу Европы
СВОБОДНЫЕ ВЫБОРЫ НА УКРАИНЕ !!!
Брежневские коммунисты не целовали задницы западу и умерли в своей смертью
Nothing is free on our planet CERTAINLY NOT ARISTOCRACY
Сергей Доренко скорее всего погиб от micro chip beeing activated for a second
Can’t wait when people will begin talk about micro chips in everybody and brain
Army af doctors working hundreds of years 24/7 to invent this staff in tom6 billions of man kind AND IN TO ALL OUR PETS
DMV ГАИ mass murdering machine SOON SOMEBODY NEED TO GET RID OF SOMEBODY DOCTORS AND DMV ALWAYS TOGETHER all they need activate one or another micro chip in brain and driver losing control
Где результаты експертиз DNA и обещанные факты об участии путина в преступном отношении к человеку или доказательства убийства ПОКА ЧТО РОССИЯ НАЧАЛА ПРОЩАТЬ КРЕМЛЬ И ЕВРОППУ СНОВА И НЕ ТРЕБУЕТ СУДА И НАКАЗАНИЯ
убийство за убийством и все ещё нет суда
Что делают все оппозиции ? Почему они то молчат ? ! Радуются победе диктатуры и коррупции или собираются провести первые свободные выборы ?
👍👍❤
Wow, what a couple 💑 , heroes of the modern era , we constantly see Putin in the media looking like some sort a strong man and we don't really know what this Vladimir looks like . Democracies are not perfect it takes time . Felt like the interviewer kept veering from the important fight these people are literally going through to debate democracies around the world?????
👊💪 to these people in Russia and Ukraine that are fighting the good fight, have to keep reminding myself of how aloof I am just based on my geographical location.
#UkraineRussiaWar
Свободу людям кто за мир
This lady doesn't know that here in Brazil there's a mensurable amount of people who want a dictatorship instead of democracy.
Brasil is full of dummies, sadly.
they are either fools or being bribed by corrupt politicians
Human rights then silence Christian like Britain and US.
Do mean you the Atheist rules of law on round table in England that cause the two wars to destabilise Germany.
Brava!!! Tutti gli italiani amanti della libertà e GENUINAMENTE di sinistra sono con te ❤!
Evgenia Kara-Murza is a very brave lady like her husband speaking out against putin and his sick regime. It shows the brutality, violence, cruelty and bullying that still drives the Russian political system. All the very best wishes on her campaign to free her husband and to free Russia from putin`s toxic and rotten grip
🙄
😮
🥺
The former President fight by Zelensky's side... he's been seen all over the TV?
Also many oppositions appear regularly on TV!
The only parties which were removed were those with links to Russia!
You know people are risking th
Seethe more
Russian bot farms are working overtime lately, they must be saving up for a flight to Dubai!
They obviously feel threatened by this woman because they've employed their best to try and obfuscate this woman's testimony.
23:23 👏🙏🙌👍
Our World 🌎 and US 🇺🇸 Hearts 💕 Are With Courageous You, Vladimir, and All Putin Regime Opposition!!!
🙏 💙 🇷🇺 💙 🙏
God's Loving Peaceful Oneness Light Dissolves and Transmutes Evil 😈 Fascist Furor Darkness!!!
🙏 💖 🕊 🌄✨🌅 🕊 💖 🙏
Please "DO NOT GIVE UP HOPE!!!
it's worth remembering how many families have been deestroyed due to people being jailed for zero charges. Truly dispicable
I am sick of these political protesters who knowingly walked into obvious incarceration,( or death) and then they and their supporters go around seeking support and resources to get them out, or seek compensation and justice. Ironically their ability to protest becomes zero, and are therefore totally ineffective.
“What did you expect to happen when you left him in April 2022” . She did not answer that Q. Why ? because, an honest answer has little integrity or sense. The West need to support people who help themselves, and others, not seeking martyrdom.
What exactly is Russian freedom? Anything like Assange's freedom?
ask snowden its way better
Assange was accused of rape and instead of fighting in court in jumped bail.
Besides it's not Channel 4 who put him in jail.
At least i can criticize my government without worry of being poisoned or arrested.
It's the freedom to criticise govt. To a free press. To fair elections. Assange has been extradited legally and will have a fair trial.
to good to be true
You know cynicism is a form of cowardice?
Russia is not rotten. Nato is rotten. World peace ❤
th-cam.com/video/PhLYP9gO5MQ/w-d-xo.htmlsi=mSN3ZqST9CkytnSo
"...saveing all the people is right, although finland is wrong, finns force soviet union to kneel, although they began westcountries gunsbringing after sinner boris johnsson
Julian Assange also deserves to be free.
He may mean well but unfortunately he's an idiot by potentially putting innocent people's lives at risk and a high security risk
@@strangemagic5502
Reminder;
Most wanted idiot war criminals:
Bush,Blair and Netanyahu.
What did he expect would happen leaking highly sensitive confidential US and UK documents 🤦♂️
There are good means of making changes in this world and that is not one of them.
She deserves freedom aswell:
th-cam.com/video/PhLYP9gO5MQ/w-d-xo.htmlsi=H4a9uMLlW8VK-2_q
Haha
some people think they are greater than most and take it upon themself to voice their greatness as if they were God sent, they would turn a country into ruins for their own benefit and show., without clear objectives or polices.., they deserve what they get.
Your description of Putin absolutely nails it 👌
Find an opposition voice, and justify the action of overthrowing a government.
What are you talking about... do you even know?
I think you should consider your comments please when people are risking so much?
@@sebastianwrites My comment is offensive to you. But I think it offers a different perspective worth of a reflection on what you have believed in so much.
I am a Chinese. I often find the media's biases when reporting China. It is true that they always find a few defiant voices, call them activists or freedom fighters, and make a story to defame and represent China. That is disgusting, indeed.
This lady has a lot of information about security matters in Russia…..as well as America. Two Questions 1. Who is funding her 2. What is that which is greater than her husband’s life?….is it to bring down Putin?…..or to Desecrate Russia into tiny bits…. What NATO wants. 3. calling her own country ROTTEN RUSSIA SPEAKS VOLUMES OF HER N HER HUSBAND. HerHUSBAND IS INDEED A DANGER TO THE INTEGRITY OF RUSSIA
FURTHER ALL COUNTRIES IN THE WORLD PROTESTS. America is the ONLY country where people are not protesting excepts the coloured ones.
And "you" are behaving like an "ignorant" fool!
If you care about something, you criticise and fight for it!
Judging by your comment I doubt you've fought for much of any value and with 'courage...' at any point in your life?
Russia mother of pease
eugenia blowing it out the exhaust
Itll never change, just like Afghanistan will never change, or China, its cultural.
Cultures change and adapt, slowly.
Taliban were a US creation. Afghanistan had a modern socialist government that the US overthrow with the help of the backwards mujahideen. Zbigniew Brzezinski admits it and is unapologetic about it. So much for "cultural"! It's as unfair as saying the Banderaism/Nazism in Ukraine is cultural! They're the Taliban/ISIS of Europe.
And just ridiculous... and ignorant comment.
Afghanistan was a democracy for 20 years!
28% of their parliament were women.
And Germany 80/90 years ago was very much like Russia is now.
Go Ukraine 🇺🇦
Funny thing is they say the same about you.
She would be arrested in America
Nah. But bots like you should be arrested. ^_^
No, she wouldn't be....
And I would think the "dumbest" person in America... are those who vote for a President in Trump who gave $1.8 trillion in tax cuts to millionaires and billionaires, and again and again worked to enrich the rich?
How do Russian nuclear weapons compare to the rest of the world?
Russia - 6,257
America 5,550
UK - 225
France - 290
China - 350
Israel - 90
Pakistan - 165
India - 156
North Korea - 40
A message to the future generations never make russia feel threatened
the difference between "looking dangerous" and "being dangerous".Russia
describes military doctrine as defensive military doctrine. With regard
to nuclear weapons specifically, Russia reserves the right to use
nuclear weapons: in response to the use of nuclear and other types of
weapons of mass destruction against it or its allies,in case of
aggression against Russia with the use of conventional weapons when the
very existence of the state is threatened
Maybe but "future generations" may ask "what was Russia?"
@@paulmaguire2737 if there is no russia there is no world
@@knowledge3563 And Russia can't use those weapons without guaranteeing their own destruction too so...
@@django3422
Russia has only..11 time zones;much easier to destroy other countries rapidly.
@@user1qaz2wsx3edc I'm not sure you know how nuclear weapons work. They don't care about time zones.
This women is driven by guilt, nor reason or practicality. . @ 19 mins. “ I haven’t been able to work out what I’m doing” ??
Ukraine has jailed all of its opposition and has made it law that the next elections will be held when the conflict is over, however long that may be.
Ukraine has been routing out pro-Russian traitors and/or corrupt elements within its political infrastructure for very good reason. I would imagine some are not even in opposition. The country is at war (not of its own volition) and therefore naturally is under martial law, under which fair and democratic elections are impossible and so must be paused. Normal service will be resumed as soon as possible...
No, they have not!!!
Just a disgracefully ill-informed comment!
Seriously do you practice making such daft comments?
The former President fight by Zelensky's side... he's been seen all over the TV?
Also many oppositions appear regularly on TV!
The only parties which were removed were those with links to Russia!
You know people are risking their lives, and losing these everyday... and you can't even be bothered learning your facts?
What conflict? Or do you mean the russian invasion due to which Ukraine finds herself in a war now for over a year?
Did you know, that countrys regulate the processing of mandatory election in times of war by law? And that it is absolutely common sense, that proper elections are likely to be successfully organised in peace-times and not, while you are fighting and invading foreign army that occupies parts of your country and bombs your population constantly?
Where did you get this "information", Ukraine government has jailed it's opposition?
This makes no sense in a parlamentary democracy - is this difficult for you to imagine?
Please share the source/link of your "information" on this for transparency and fact-checking.
Thank you.
@@anjafark You're right. It makes no sense in a democracy. That's because Ukraine is not a democracy. I suggest you turn off your TV and do some of your own research. You can easily find this information anywhere on the internet that is not MSM and probably even on the Verkhovna Rada website but I'm certainly not about to do your homework for you. It turns out that most people asking for links/proof are not really looking for links, proof or truth but to discredit the information. Do you own fact checking or you are free not to believe me.
Yes… yes… we get it
Russia are the baddies
Show some respect for those who demonstrate such courage?
Boris Nemtsov, a Russian dissident politician highly critical of President Vladimir Putin often sounded like an agent of Washington. He was shot and killed today on a street near Red Square.
If Nemtsov wasn’t assassinated by the CIA in order to blame Putin, most likely Nemtsov was killed by Russian nationalists who saw him as Washington’s agent.
Remembering the Magnitsky affair that resulted in sanctions imposed on Russians as a result of the US Congress over-reacting to a jail death in Russia, Nemtsov’s death will likely be blamed on Putin. The Western media will repeat endlessly, with no evidence, that Putin had his critic killed.
I can tell you one thing, and that is that Putin is much too smart to play into Washington’s hands in this way. Moreover, Nemtsov, although a loud mouth, had no impact on Putin’s 85% approval rating. Nemtsov’s support resided in the Washington-funded NGOs in Russia. If the CIA assassinated Nemtsov, they killed their own asset.
It remains to be seen if the propaganda gains justify the CIA’s loss of a Putin critic. Boris was this woman's hero and involved in CIA backed NGO's in Russia.
Reported for propaganda.
@@scotmark Clueless people like you who have been fed MSNBC, CNN, VOA, BBC, CBS, etc fake news your entire life always call opposing views propaganda. Meanwhile, you are from "Democratic countries" with so called "western values" where tolerating the views of others is said to be important. Do you think you have a better view on a Russian issue than a probable Russian? Come on!
@@scotmark Report Channel 4 too.
The Kremlin must really feel threatened by this woman's voice as they've obviously enlisted their best propagandist to try and obfuscate this woman's powerful testimony.
The ever changing story of Russian propaganda has twisted itself into a pretzel.
I'm not buying your latest propaganda and want to let you know that you're on the losing side if you haven't figured it out already.
@@scotmarkYou watch propaganda everyday with a belly full of McDonald’s
Take a look at the UK before you chritasize Russia.
@@peoplesrepublicofninj3418You obviously haven't heard of Graham Phillips, who has been sanctioned and had his property seized by the UK government, simply because he reports a different, on the ground prospective of the events in Ukraine.
When emptying the litter tray, it's not "what about this turd", it's goodbye to bad rubbish. Bye!
@@LegendOfKat The list of UK traitorous Turd politicians is overflowing.
How's the weather in St Petersburg?
What's that word you've just used, Ivan?
from some reason she have some fine coprophagic vibe
Russia itself is a stable humble country what on earth is she talking about
I do hope this is some sort of joke your comment, because I struggle to understand how anyone can be that ignorant?
And if it is a joke, it isn't appropriate!
What part of Russia is a "dictatorship" do too many people not understand? 'Dictatorships...' don't even allow their own people to speak out, or know the truth... so why on earth would think for a moment they would tell "you" the truth?
If a Russian person even calls this a 'war...' they can face upwards of "10 years" or more in jail, or worse be murdered by the regime. Putin has said this 'war...' has to be called a "special military operation."
Russian soldiers are brutalised, lied to and tortured by their own government. The families how lose loved ones, few get the death payments promised them, and soldiers themselves are left often with no pay or weapons with substandard equipment, which left many to freeze to death in winter.
There are no free fair elections in Russia under Putin - all free media and political opposition has been shut down, journalists, politicians and ordinary people - imprisoned or murdered!
Many have been taken in by Russian disinformation: by the way it was Russia under Stalin and the KGB in 1923 which arrived at the concept and coined the word 'disinformation!' They even gave it a Western sounding name, so we would more easily adopt it... so that worked?
Putin has murdered "100 000s" of people in Chechnya, Georgia, Syria, Moldova, Belarus and Ukraine and elsewhere in the world.
Syria, was a people's uprising as a result of the Arab Spring, which began in Tunisia in 2010, as a result Assad slaughtered peaceful protesters with gunships. The people fought bravely for years, but when Damascus was about to fall, Assad called in Putin. Assad and Putin then murdered "100 000s" of people, dropping bombs on children in their schools, burning them alive!
In Russia itself, if people even call the Ukraine Russia War, a "war..." they can face up to "10 years" in jail, or if someone is a high profile politician or public figure, then can be imprisoned or even murdered.
A recent UN stated the in a terror campaign orchestrated by Putin... "children" as young as '4' years old are being tortured and raped.
We must act to stop this, and support the people of Ukraine to ensure this ends... in defeating the Putin Regime this could be a turning corner for humanity, in our search to end war, and all injustice?
She is a agent of UsA
You used the indefinite article. Comrade is learning. But next time try "an".
It's rotten EU needs to change and their policies
How and why?
Fake news
No, it's the "truth..." the problem is with 'your' attitude which lacks character and integrity.
I like the way Russia is now, it's anti woke and respects tradition. We could learn from them, the way our country is going.
If you want to be like russia, you should soon be poisoned for criticising your country.
The Kremlin must really feel threatened by this woman's powerful testimony because they've got you guys over here attempting damage control.
It's not working and all you're really accomplishing is monetizing the creator of this video so they can produce more content. Every little bit helps thank you.
What British traditions do you think we don't respect?
Oh here we are... how did I know you'd make some "idiot" remark with Union - Brexit supporting -Jack on your profile?
You people are so predictably, and then you speak of 'freedom.'
You don't even "think" for yourself... you just peddle the lies of those who pushed Brexit who made £millions, and murderous tyrants like Putin!
Just utter cowardice!
No. Russia could have learned from Europe, from german history - and from it's own past. (Well, it DOES seam to actualy take lesson from german history - mostly Goebbels, unfortunately).
Evgenia's an inspiration to people all over the world in the fight for freedom and democracy.
Lol
@@kaykay865 Cope.
Russia and China determined to end western greedom and kleptocracy.
who cares
People who are conscience, have morals and integrity care...!
You've unfortunately just answered your own question.
Great answer! Thanks !!!
Very impressive lady,who is talking very bravely and very knowldgable❤❤❤.