Ranking Fatui Harbingers as ROOMMATES?!
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 3 มิ.ย. 2024
- ⌂ Download AFK Journey on both PC and mobile for FREE! bit.ly/Koomaxx Get over 40 heroes for free! Use my CDKey: AFKJourney88 to get 100 diamonds & 18,888 golden coins!
⌂ Follow Koomaxx on Twitter: / koomaxx
⌂ Become a member and support the channel: / @koomaxx
⌂ For business inquiries and PR opportunities only: koomaxx@moreyellow.com
⌂ CHANNEL CREDITS: ⌂
⌂ Video Editor: @trinitok
⌂ Koomaxx Character Art (thumbnail and in-video): Victoria Putinski
/ incaseyouart
⌂ MY EQUIPMENT: ⌂
⌂ Capture Card: amzn.to/2WBbXRS
⌂ Microphone: amzn.to/3h9QuZU
⌂ Audio Interface: amzn.to/3xepcr0
⌂ Recording Software: OBS + Audacity
⌂ Editing Software: Premiere Pro
--------------
Brandenburg Concerto No4-1 BWV1049 - Classical Whimsical by Kevin MacLeod is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution license (creativecommons.org/licenses/...) Source: incompetech.com/music/royalty-... Artist: incompetech.com/
--------------
Some of the above links are affiliate links, meaning I earn a small percentage of sales made via those links, but it doesn’t cost you anything extra!
#genshinimpact #hoyocreators #arlecchino #ad - เกม
Download AFK Journey on both PC and mobile for FREE! bit.ly/Koomaxx Get over 40 heroes for free! Use my CDKey: AFKJourney88 to get 100 diamonds & 18,888 golden coins!
You should do a hsr ship tier list
can you do Genshin characters as Tiktok Rizz Party People pls
Yess AFK Journey is nice
While Childe is very energetic and chaotic we've seen him be very responsible many times. He loves cooking, he takes care of his home. He's definitely the type to make breakfast and leave u a note about where he is even if u don't care. A pillow fight with him could escalate tho
About to lose a tooth AND an eye in that pillow fight
@@Koomaxx with the fact that his highest arrow damage was the one he threw, i'd say you would lost more than that
If Arlecchino is scary emo Eula, Childe is scary rich-boy Thoma.
Childe is also unreasonably hot
@@laurie1183 U see, i wanted to say that I'd lose more than just a tooth and an eye during that pillow fight but i held back
Scara would eat your leftovers right in front of you just to taunt you.
"Too bad these nutritions are going to waste"
Bullying is not girlboss,f'k that.
doll can eat food?!?!???????
@@Idknlandwh123 3:10
Good thing that I don't even put leftovers.
Scara doesn't need food. He hasn't the need of eating. "I have no need for food." Said him once.
Columbina is definitely the friend who brings someones ashes to the party.
It's Signora
"I got this cute box on sale for it. Aren't the butterfly patterns on it pretty? 😊"
@@likethecolour “Hey what’s in the box?”
“Oh don’t worry it’s just Signora”
#relatable
Imagine your exhausted from dealing with dotore all day and he finally goes to sleep when another one walks in.
I've heard theories that he has 24 segments + his real self. Because the one we got introduced to in Sumeru was the "Omega Build". Omega is the last letter of the Greek alphabet and that consists of 24 in total. So there might've been 25 different Dottores in Teyvat at one point. Also, imagine having to get your keys duplicated so many times. He'd better pay for that himself. 😂
oh god
Imagine Arlecchino goes and makes an orphanage of you guys’ place. You’d come home and see a bunch of children and be like: “Where did all these kids come from??”
There was a flood, so arguably.
@@Areullekino 😯
Dottore is taking your kidneys.
Good
#relatable I quite enjoy stealing kidneys.
And selling them on the Internet
Objection to the Scaramouche-leftovers conclusion, even tho he doesn't need to eat, I wouldn't put it above him to eat them out of pure spite.
That is an excellent point lmaoo
Imagining him hacking up the stolen food like a cat with a furball. Ofc, doing it in front of you 😧
put it on top of the fridge and he can’t reach it, no leftovers eaten
@@cool.kid.ig- I now have the mental image of Scarameow trying to reach the leftovers and crying cause he can't reach it to bully us all. Thank you. It is lovely.
@@cool.kid.ig- lmaooooo true
Shortest Genshin Teir List to EVER exist-
Honestly this was so relaxing to make as a change of pace LOL
@@Koomaxx true- 🤣
imagine living w Sandrone and opening ur fridge just to see it fall apart because she dismantled it and couldn't put it back together XD
I'd expect it to work with 30% more efficiency...and also be able to bench press a mack truck.
One thing with Childe is that you're likely not just getting him, but his siblings as well. I imagine he'd be really fun, responsible, but also like to mess around and wrestle ya while the kids cheer on one of you. Could be fun, but could also be really draining lol.
Ughhh so true, I don’t think I could handle that personally 🥲
But hey he'd always do his chores
:0 Him AND his little siblings?!
Oh my god, I'd be on board. Just because it'd be so fun to play with Teucer and Tonia! Plus? Man knows how to wife and beat the crap out of potential intruders. So it'd be top tier.
and he might shove his siblings onto you when hes busy like he did during his story quest. i love kids and i could maybe handle living with them as long as childe was taking care of them, but idk if i could handle spontaneous babysitting sessions :’)
I think Arlecchino could fluctuate from SS to Hiding In Room depending where on her radar you are: either she’s cooking and cleaning her share, she’s cordial and polite OR she’s bugging the home, being passive aggressive, watching you sleep.
Honestly the BIGGEST downside(maybe upside?) no matter what is that she might bring home an abused and abandoned child some random day to take care of.
Yeah, sounds about right. It think it would be more of a “I don’t mess with you, you don’t mess with me” kinda vibe
@MoonlitBookworm73, that has been a very reappearing theme for Fontaine characters "You scratch my back, I scratch yours"
@MoonlitBookworm73 and Arlecchino, despite doing things for her own gain it generally tends to be beneficial to both sides so far.
@@Areullekino mhm!
Me: (to the children) “PLEASE ask first you want to play with my games! And kids, STOP messing with my books and toy collection!”
Captain sounds like the type of guy who will wake me up at 4 am for training 😂
Harbinger tier list ideas:
-most rizz
-would take you on the best date
-would be a good babysitter
The funny thing is, a good chunk of these could completely shift when we meet the other harbingers and learn more about them.
Tbf, If we're ranking Pantalone lower for working closely with Dottore, I feel like we have to rank Scaramouche lower as well - imagine ur chilling at home, and Dottore comes in, looking for his ✨favourite✨ test subject
Time for Dottore-proof doors! 😂
Machine guns usually do the trick
😂
@@Em.or.something no i tried those, and I regret my desicion
@@MyNvtsTasteGreat whoops
I don't know why but I could definitely see Capitano getting a mani-pedi with Signora after hours 😂
I feel like if Dottore was your roommate you would randomly hear weird noises from the basement and when going to check it out se him dissecting a body or something-
Sandrone as a roommmate would be my Goob from Meet the Robinsons origin story
I imagine you are chilling with capitano and segnora and Dotore just looks at you three from a window while laughing crazy quietly to himself
I can’t get this picture out of my head now and i can’t stop giggling 😭
STOP THIS IS GREAT
Idk why, but I feel like Columbina would be the roommate you could just ramble to over tea. The pure therapy bestie. And we’d both fall asleep the during a horror movie. Columbina is bestie.
The hate for Venti is uncalled fooooor😭😭😭
Fr 😢
Columbina and me making sick beats in the dorm fr
Personally I don't trust Columbina she seems like she's up to something nefarious 😭😭
Well, we know that the members of the House of the Hearth seem to genuinely love Arlecchino. She is an expert at maintaining her house, and she throws a decent tea party too. Only thing is I imagine she'd be very judgy and controlling.
That Fatui Mask suites you ngl🤣
Scaramouche and Signora would bully me 💀
Capitano would be part of the girl boss friend group with Signora & Arlecchino, they all be talking bad about the other harbingers behind their backs
Nah Capitano’s too righteous for that
Childe is a perfect roommate. Even the fatui was shocked at how skilled Childe is with housework
Arlecchino, I'm not exactly important enough for her to try and use me, and she doesn't seem to be the kind of person to kill others for the sake of it, I think since we'd share the rent she'd be a pleasant roommate who you only see once a week (it's like 2am and she's just drinking scolding hot tea in the living room with all the lights off)
(5 seconds into the video) Annie you forgot the most important category: “Always eats my food in the fridge.” Come on how haven’t you ever had a roommate who tore through your ice cream sandwiches you’ve been looking forward to all week?! 😭
EDIT: 3:30 nvm she knows
Something funny about a content creator making knee-jerk reactions prematurely in the comments section. =p
Even as a harbinger you wouldn’t be safe from dottore, just think about what he did with scara
Arlecchino would just act like a cool mom the whole time won’t she?
While everyone is normal, only Dottore is "abnormal" because imagine when you go home and witness his experiments, then 100% sure you will chase him away immediately :)
I think I'd be next then, because no way would he let anyone tell him what to do. And I can proudly say I've never had to lie on an operating table in my 20 years of life and I'd like to keep it that way. 😅
Also i Sandrone is off transforming people into robots and cutting their tongue and stuff... I feel like I'd hear her evil laughing at 3AM. 10/10 roommate
Haven't watched the video yet, but I feel like I need to give my personal opinion beforehand: Scara can move in with me any day, I'm not even demanding that we split the rent, his presence alone is payment enough (don't judge me. He reminded me of myself the very first time I saw him, so I got a soft spot for him). But Dottore on the other hand... I think it's obvious that I'm gonna put up a mechanism at the doors (and windows. You never know.) that automatically recognizes and shoots him. That man gives me chills just from having him randomly mentioned in conversation. 😐
I died at the Signora comment “she’s dead” 😭😂
people are underestimating Sandrone and Columbina for sure 😭😭 Sandrone cut a man's tongue out and left a note in his mouth for traveller to find. Even Tartaglia doesn't wanna fight Columbina. That alone says a lot about her.
Where does it say that in lore?
@@Hellothere99929 It's world quest called "Questions and Answers". You can accept it by going The Steambird. The lady in the end tells you how she found the guy missing his tongue inside Opera Epiclese waiting to be judged.
They're both adorifying and that's why I want both of them, but also at a safe distance away, which could very well mean the next continent over.
While La Signora punting Venti is iconic, she gives off "Do you know who I am?!" vibes. I honestly think she would just be really passive aggressive/condescending all the time (Unlike The Balladeer who would just be aggressive). I don't trust The Knave either but I agree with her and Childe being in the same tier. They'd both be fine roommates if you ignore what goes on when you're not around. Childe leans more toward the "fun" roommate/friend while The Knave is more the responsible, cordial, occasional chat over tea type.
I feel like the headcanon of Sandrone being messy is 100% justified because my dad's a hobbyist and let me tell you, there are planes EVERYWHERE! Our basement is like 80% RC planes and the ones that don't fit down there because there so many are stuck somewhere upstairs. Most of them he doesn't even fly, like half of them probably wouldn't even start. The house is utter chaos.
I've literally at two computer skeletons sitting in front of my TV for the past few months. One of them was supposed to use the parts I recently replaced for my own computer and then go to my nephew, but neither my dad nor I have gotten around to it so they're just sitting there with their guts exposed and lying on the floor.
Oh, and when dealing with people like us, _do not clean up our mess._ We _will_ be completely incapable of finding something when we need it if you do. (Whether or not we'll ever need it is another matter and only time can tell.)
I think Capitano will play Mario Cart with us :D
YESSSS
That sounds really fun.
I absolutely could not live with Columbina. Could you imagine hearing her singing that horrifying funeral melody from the harbinger video while you're just... chilling in your room?! Horrifying. I'd never sleep again after waking up to "laaaaaaaaaa laaaa laaa laaaaaaaa la!" at 3am.
6:29 well that bridge is pulling up cause we’re headed to Natlan pretty soon well after we snag Arlecchino that is lol
pierro i feel like would be a good roommate who's willing to hang out sometimes like even if its just to watch a movie and still keep his end as well with the bills and laundry etc.
pulcienna (the rooster) is kind of a hard one to place because yes he does have that strict grandpa vibe but hed be willing to help with things like bills since he runs the bank and was willing to shut down the northland bank for half a day so they could mourn the loss of signora so placing him is hard really
Childe will indeed be a good roommate, because he is not only funny but also very good at many different things, he will bring laughter to us.
6:35 She feels like "Klee but gone WRONG"
oh my god my two hyper-fixation harbingers in the bottom tiers, I am sobbing. I do completely understand why Dottore and Pantalone would be the shittiest of roommates. However! I do have a reason why I feel they would be good roommates, at least Pantalone. I feel that Pantalone is a very proper man, and if you were roommates with him, I feel you wouldn't have to worry about cleaning up anything, because with the amount of money he has, he would just hire a maid to clean up everything. He would be pretty quiet, and would honestly keep to himself most of the time. You'd get along with him if you were being peaceful, but you'd be in for it if you made him made, because you know he would drag you to Dottore and have him deal with you. Basically don't piss him off and stay on Pantalone's good side, or your in for a bad time.
Thank you for listening to my TEDTalk
ANOTHER PANTALONE STAN I have found my people yes I agree with this 100%
im crying i never thought id see that scaramouche reddit post in a video 😭
im a chaotic, messy artist, so Sandrome and i would be perfect for each other, we'd be able to go to each other and be like "hey, you got this for a project?" and i just think we'd have fun crafting/tinkering sessions together
I WILL DIE ONE THIS HILL: AJAX IS S TIER ROOMMATE! He cooks, cleans and he takes care of his siblings! He also is amazing at finance (I mean he works at the bank and has money) SSS TIER PEAK 👌🏻
Not necessarily for harbingers (but also for harbingers) I’d love to see an updated Anime Convention tier list cause of all the new characters and also our better understanding of Cyno and how he is like second to fischl in commitment
If I’m being honest, I would live with Arlecchino mainly. Like she’s responsible, she can pay the bills on time. Plus she’s good with kids so if like you have to watch your little sibling or cousin, she can help with that totally
Finally, someone that shows appreciation to Signora instead of hating her, THANK YOU 😭✋🏽
Agreed! Signora is amazing.
I already know that childe and scara will be unhinged
I’m so glad you agree with my exact thought process for Signora.
R.i.p the baddest queen girlboss of all Genshin. 😩
I like Il Dottore because of how unrepentantly evil he is. A lot of Genshin antagonists are either brainwashed, misunderstood, repentant, or pitiful. Il Dottore is legit just an evil dude who won't be caught dead doing stupid things that foils his plans. He'd be a nightmare to have as a roommate indeed, especially if you ever got on his bad side even briefly...
I like him as an antagonist too. Like, I think his character and lore were really well designed. He feels like a true villain at least. He creeps me out so much and I think the fact that I say I don't like him as a character is proving how good of an antagonist he is. Most antagonistic characters, not only in Genshin, are still on a level where you could argue that they aren't evil or could even feel sympathetic towards them (Scaramouche in my case. I love his character so much but he doesn't feel like a true villain. More like someone who was hurt too much in his life and struggles with some serious mental health problems.). But then there's this full on deranged lunatic amongst the ranks of the Fatui who isn't only scary in theory (he's nightmare fuel for me. But I easily get scared.) but also implied to be super powerful since he's got such a high rank. So, while I hate him as a character, I love him as an antagonist that would, in real life, definitely make me run for my life. And I agree, having him as a roommate would be horrible. I'd just stay in my room or out of the house for the most time, and when I'd have to interact with him, I'd put on even more false confidence than Furina during the Fontaine Archon Quest (still crying whenever I think about her backstory). Never show your fear to your predator, you know.
I’d love to live with Signora!
Also Sandrone and Columbina sound quite fun too.
I'd most want to room with Arlecchino. She is just so pretty, and I think she would be fairly friendly to me since i wouldn't have anything that she would have to fight me over
She only fights if it's necessary she did avoid that with Neuvillette because to her war isn't an answer
9:20 IS THAT JOSEPH JOESTAR?? ZOO WEE MAMA😍‼️
Just so you know, Sandrone cut out a guys tongue and mind broke him. So, you might wanna keep an eye on her as a roomate. She might just turn you into a doll.😅
Does she know that dottore experimented on scaramouche as well?-
If you wanna know what it feels like to live with Dottore for just a single day, you should try the Dottore "Dating Sim" (Not really a Dating sim, thats more so an inside joke. Think its called something like Dottore and the Spy)
That exists??? 😶 What in Rex Lapis' name is going on in this fandom?
Bro childe is such a good character to be honest if he was a roommate I would be best friends with him every time or even better husband and husband
Honestly, I would rank them the same, except for Pulcinella. Stay OUT OF MY HOUSE, he gives me the CREEPS, and he don’t respect workers rights, like, c’mon. And would absolutely live with Columbina. Besides she being my absolutely favorite character, I feel like she’s completely crazy, and you can expect weird recipes being made each week, and the weirdest yet exciting plans for the weekend. We could end in a fancy hotel without paying a penny, or end up at prison. It’s a roulette, and almost every option is a wreck. Love that
Seeing Signora in S makes me happy
ARE YOU A SIGNORA FAN TOO I LOVE HER AND I CANT FIND ANY OTHE RFANS PLS TELL ME YOU LIKE HER AS MUCH AS I DO PLSPLSPLS
Childe would be a good roomate, loud but good.
Dottore definitely has experiments in his room and it reeks of bodies.
Pantalone is the perfect roommate.
Sandrone is creepy yet meh at best, though the robot is annoying.
Capitano is okay, but he’s never around bc yk busy man.
Arlecchino is a clean freak and reserved.
Columbina is fcking creepy and definitely has more than one body but she cleans so its meh-
(All current harbingers)
EDIT: HELP I FORGOT THE ROOSTER DUDE- eh he’s annoying and a weirdo but like meh in general-
Capitano is the type to go to the girls night out just to make sure no one messes with his pals.
✨️ Vid Idea ✨️
How likely Genshin characters (or jusf harbingers) would survive the backrooms
Katherine is the window to Sandrone. And the fact she is so meticulous with keeping order in Sumeru Quest (Katherine is instantly replaced once she was bopped). I think she would keep everything chill in the house. Also, I dont want to get on her bad side because she probably knows everything because of the Katherine network. She probably knows a way of dampening sounds because Katherine makes no robot sounds at all, and most robotic things are loud af in genshin.
Loved the video @Koomaxx! Can't wait for the next video Girl! Loved the fact that you kept the Harbinger Mask on you at the end of the video with your supporters scrolling past LMAO!
As for the List, it seems to fit pretty well, although for me Roommate would just be a Cover for me having La Signora over since I'd gladly take her as my "Lovely Lady" to say the least. Arlecchino and I would be fighting over who takes the lead, but I'd still somehow manage to win.... Although I think if she were to come into my room to try and wake me up, she might tease me about having a certain item that makes up a Skeleton.
Tartaglia I can definitely see him Covering for me if a Payment is late or something and just tell me not to worry about paying him back. Then again, in my own Head Cannon, I'm a Big Time Upstart playing the Stock Market and using the Money I get from it to Rebuild various Industries like the Shipbuilding Industry and even Invest in Gaming Companies who support their Player Base. "Why would I be late on a Payment to start off with?" you might ask, Uh.... Maybe caught up in a few things that Tartaglia's still pretty chill about. Then again, He can't complain much because of the Two of You all being together. You always meet up with him Dressed to the Nines, 6 inch Platform Stiletto Heels with a 2 inch Platform, Open-toed, T-Straps with a Bow Detail over the Toe, and you always say "Hi Handsome!" as soon as you two get close enough to talk; like Less than Arms length close. Yeah, Tartaglia and I usually have the occasional Boy's Night Out at the Taverns.... When I'm not Checking over the Progress of some Ships from the Second World War *AHEM* What? I didn't say that!
Anyway, let me know what you think about this and I'll catch you in your next video Girl! Koomaxx × Tartaglia, A bit more Tame than Yor and Loid but still cute together!
Me as a Fatui member: “Hey guys, here’s a better idea: How about if we team up with these?”
(Shows them footage of various villain groups from different video game universes, as well as Galeem and Dharkon from Super Smash Bros.)
Singora would talk every evening about her dead boyfriend, like eating ice cream and crying and you will be made the therapist wheter you like it or not
I think that Arlecchino would be a perfect roommate if you … weren’t a harbinger yourself because as I heard about here she is only on their side in order to protect children from House of Hearts and still be able to give them roof and protection in exchange for their information gathering skills
I agree with you about dottore (kinda) but not when you said we don't like that or we stan collie or something like that but anyways sorry but I don't care about her or what happened to her in the past honestly(imo) I would just put him in the hide myself in my room one! 🫶
Video idea,you could totally rank genshin characters to decide which one should get a skin😮,btw love your videos❤
Rank the harbingers as: babysitters, school members, or the kids you babysit?
Based on how everyone talks about Capitano,I would guess he’d be a good choice for a roommate.
I'd be too scared to live with Sandrone because of the giant robot protector situation. Kinda like with Klara and Svarog, I feel like the tiniest wrong move would be misinterpreted by the robot and I would just get instantly clapped. Columbina is also way too sus there is no way she's not up to something utterly devious.
Insane take but I feel like Columbina would be a great roommate actually, but that is purely based on the fact that you have no clue what the hell she even does. Like you come home after a hard and she’s chilling on the couch with a cup of tea and gives you a smile to say the kettle is still hot and then silently puts on your favourite show.
It’s a quiet vibe but it entirely hinges on the fact that you (as a roommate) are completely oblivious. Kinda like your her version of playing house - she’ll dispose of you if you break the illusion sure, but if you’re just chill I can guarantee you’ll be just fine lmao
Captain will be the death of me once we see him in game! I love him
I’d personally take any of the girls. But I feel Arleccino is the most responsible of the women here on this list. I’d say a girl or Childe cause I’m a real P.O.S. (Piece of sh*t) on my period and I feel like the girls will understand, but Childe wouldn’t understand as well but he’d try his best lmao.
So yeah. Likely Signora, Arlecchino, or Childe for me on roomies.
Bro i wish I could learn to 3d animate faster so I can animate all these scenarios 😭
Harbinger tier lists, hmm...looking at the old ones, who you'd babysit sounds funny. By their crimes seems very on the nose. I'd DARE you to punch any one of them. School popularity has potential. In a horror movie seems appropriate. House party or sleepover is...maybe. Rizz might actually see you put Dottore somewhere other than the bottom -- he's scary, but it's a charming scary.
If scara was in the same country as me... There would be a nuclear explosion and not from him.
On one hand, Ajax is a family man and seems responsible enough if he wants to be... But he also kinda low-key gives off middle school popular boy vibes and like he'd purposely try to get a rise out of me... But I like him far too much for that to stop me
I feel lile Scara would leave YOUR house because he finds it unworthy
I think I’d be too busy simping for Columbina to notice anything wrong bc I’m also a messy person 😅
Plot twist Sandrone is the robot ( *cough* - Alain - *cough* ) and the girl he's holding is the puppet ( *cough* - Marry-Ann - *cough* )
This has been my headcanon since they were revealed just because the alternative wouldn't be strange enough for a Harbinger.
I'd be happy to have Ajax as my roomate, S tier roomate even in my opinion. Even if he's not fully trustworthy, i've read his lore so many times to the point you really need to get to know him more and fully side with him, besides, MANS got a responsibility of being a family guy to his sisters, brothers, mom and dad (even if his father was the reason why he's in the Fatui) and he'd treat us just like family too, since in his serenitea pot dialogues he's so open to us when talking about his relatives
How I see dottor: IM ON MY KNEES, PLS GIVE ME SOMETHING TO ME TO JRINK
I think Childe is perfect. But overall, the tier list is so good 😂
colombina is the type of girl to leave the dishes in the sink for so long that they grow a new strain of mold lmao
You should do a hsr ships tier list
You know you should do a tier list with all the Genshin Impact characters when they see a play
I will not be surprised if columbina is the pyro archon......nahida once told traveler the top 3 harbingers r capable to fight with the archons, but there yet hasnt been a battle between any harbingers and archons, so how nahida knows that...cuz columbina, the 3rd overall, is herself an archon
enough of the 1-on-1 stuff, I challenge you
BUILD-A-FAMILY!
1 spous/parents (you can be one, but I just realized it might be more fun to ship 2 characters in a fam)
2 kids minimum
at least 1 grand-parent and at least 1 uncle/aunt (they have to be invited to all major birthdays/holidays)
who is going to help the kids with their homework the most, what gift is the grandparent bringing for the birthdays
I have no idea if it would make a good video, but I'm in the deep character-wikis right now, trying to find a full set of 4 grandparents for Collei, Gaming and Klee that wont get drunk at christmas
Imagine best parents with the harbingers I'd die to see that😂
ngl I do agree with most of comments pointing Childe would be the best option out of all of them lmao
Tartags would absolutely be SSS Tier for me. A bit high energy, but... Heck, I like weapons, they're cool. And he'd probably be willing to teach some self-defense combat tactics... even if he goes overboard sometimes.
Arlecchino... I agree with you on her. Great and amicable, as long as you aren't on her bad side... but you'd always have to be vigilant, which could get tiring.
Even though I don't have meet most of the Harbringers yet, I should definitely stay away from Scaramouche, but I don't want to! I love him so much! He's my main, and one of my two favorite characters overall (along side Venti)!
I'd say I agree with your choice of ranking, except for Signora, as I faintly recall an anecdotal account from a Fatui soldier that he'd rather serve under The Captain than Roslyn.
Also, Columbina is such an enigma to me (despite everything we know) and I have no clue were she'd be on this tier list.