She sings with backing vocals because she's dancing on chairs, squatting, wearing heels, and the mix of this song isn't one that's easy to sing with natural sound. If you notice a lot of the song sounds like there's a filter...because there is. Sunmi killed it
It might sound like she lip synched but if you pay attention you can hear that there is a double voice sound. It is probably a base for her sound and her live voice together. Unfortunately her base was louder than her live vocals, but at least she sang the other songs live...
It's the backtrack. All artists use it to get a fuller and fatter sound when singing live. You can clearly hear she misses one note at one place, so it's live. I just wish they'd use proper mics instead of these broadcasting mics. They seem to be popular in in Korea. I'm a music producer and audio engineer my self and those mics is my biggest nightmares cause they won't make your voice sound the best and isn't for singing so they have a completely different sound range. Sad.
Yeah, it's all about the backtrack, the artists have nothing to do with them. That's what their fans repeat over and over again. Why do they need to sing live when nobody can hear their real voices but the backtrack? I've never seen anything more ridiculous than that. They choose to use that kind of backtrack simply because they want it to cover their weak voices. Next time, when your artists sing with the backtrack which is "too loud", please dont say anything like "they sing live but the backtrack....blabla" again. I've got enough of this.
Okay for all the ones saying she is lip syncing...most solo artists will choose parts to sing, and you can definitely hear her voice in several parts. Just stop saying she is lip syncing, what do you expect to see? A person singing and dancing a whole song by herself?
Y'all can never appreciate anything without arguing about it... the stage was nice, she looked beautiful, the song & dance are good, if you just wanna hate honestly just go away it's so tiring
She definitely needed to catch a breath so she couldn't be dancing this choreo that requires a lot of energy and keep singing throughout the performance!! This is nevertheless one of her beautiful performances!!
guys, are you serious? she doesn't lip sync, the back track is kinda loud, but you can hear that she sings a long. how can you possibly expect her to sing EVERYTHING when she's a solo artist and has an intricate choreo that is all about grace and being sultry? i honestly don't understand why are people suddenly coming for her with such accusations + those "plagiarism" claims, like do y'all know what sampling is in the music industry? those beats are everywhere, sampling exists to make songs catchier, sometimes several super famous people use the same sample and that's okay, it doesn't mean the song is plagiarized. anyway, the point is that sunmi doesn't deserve the hate. update: i was informed that teddy insisted that it wasn't a sample, however, i still don't see that many similarities between heroine and cheryl's song to call it plagiarism, there are just so many catchy similar tunes that producers get inspired by and make them go viral again, everyone is just using similar stuff, pop music can get repetitive but it doesn't mean it's not fun. and it doesn't mean it's plagiarism either.
(www.copynot.org/Pages/Music%20sampling.htm) "If you want to use a sample legally, you must obtain permission from the copyright owner. The copyright owner is usually a publishing company or record label. Remember that you must obtain permission from both the owner of the sound recording and the copyright owner of the underlying musical work." But Teddy said that it was 100% his work and he did not sample.
okay, i didn't know that he made a statement, thank you. but to me, heroine and cheryl's song aren't that similar for it to be considered plagiarism anyway. catchy tunes are all quite similar + that kind of beats is coming back to be trendy again. the same thing happened with radiohead's creep and lana del rey's get free, she just mixed a sultry vibe that has kind of "creep"-y feel if you choose to reach like this, and people started overreacting that radiohead sued her for it, but radiohead actually didn't, it was all people being hateful - and what is the point? i'm just saying, sunmi is clearly a talented artist, people who have been following her career since the wonder girls days especially know that. yeah, the tunes are catchy and everyone kinda does the same thing, but it can get repetitive at times in pop music, so i don't see the reason why everyone is hating on sunmi, she's like the chillest artist out there.
There is MR removed version of this. You can clearly hear her live vocal ( especially in headphones). So, please, don't say rude things, we know she reads comments.
Are y'all actually complaining about her vocals. She wasn't fully lip syncing in fact she was singing along to most of it but obviously this is a hard song to sing and she's a SOLOIST. That means there are a lot of parts and at some point she's going to have to catch her breath. Plus she's never said she was the best vocalist, she's more advertised as a dancer/idol. Her stage presence is something you can't find in many people though
Holy hell. Sunmi gets so much unnecessary hate. I think people are legitimately jealous their faves can't both be as beautiful as her while being talented.
Acting like Black Pink and 2ne1 dont have the same heavy backtrack like Sunmi that make them look like lip-syncing! All TEDDY's work have heavy back tracks, so instead of assuming! YEAH! YYH will never allow lip sync! SUNMI FTW!
She’s definitely singing the pre chorus and chorus part. The others, half of them are lip sync and you can tell those are when her mouth isn’t open and she probably CHOSE to not sing those parts. Other times, she’s not lip synching and the track is just so loud it’s covering her voice, also because the notes are kinda reaaaaaally low at those parts. So it’s hard to belt out super low notes.
tae tae I'm not hating on her or anything, but tbh I would categorize her outfits as quite sexy. Not stripper sexy but still artist/musician sexy. There's nothing wrong with wearing revealing clothes, as long as that's not the main point :)
You guys are funny. Sunmi has always sung live bcs I always hear her struggling to sing. She uses her raw voice which she can’t reach the high notes cleanly. If she lip syncs she won’t be dumb enough to not sing some part so obviously like that. True, she’s not a good singer but not everybody in the world expects good singers. We also want good performers and Sunmi always gives a good performance. I’m not even a Sunmi fan but I can present you these facts. You all are expecting all Korean singers to be some kind of perfection but they’re performers. Art. If Sunmi’s vision of art is a good performance, who are you to judge what she can and what she can’t show to us?
I thought this was the only performance she sang live for Heroine. I mean... she slays both ways, and also it's fine if she lip-syncs because the choreo doesn't look easy to sing with
Acting like Black Pink and 2ne1 dont have the same heavy backtrack like Sunmi that make them look like lip-syncing! All TEDDY's work have heavy back tracks, so instead of assuming! YYH will never allow lip sync!
honestly if it’s a problem for you or if you want to hear her sing, just go back to the hundreds of performances Wonder Girls ALWAYS did live on music shows
ctrljimin you can clearly see than she is singing live but are parts where she don't sing she is a solo artist you can't hope than she sing all her song when she is dancing too
진짜 선미는 연옌의 연옌이다... 라이브 개잘하는데 한국인 왜 없누...
확실히 유스케가 선미 라이브가 잘들려서 좋다 ㅠㅠㅠ 마지막에 자막 뜨면서 무대 끝나는것도 넘 멋져 ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ 🥺🥺🥺
저때 실제로 봤는데 진짜 개쩔었음
뻥치시네
@@월향-o3d ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 개웃겨
뭐가 쩔었다는거야 립싱크하는구만
@@므찐스퇄 뭔 립싱크임 ;
@@므찐스퇄유스케에서 립싱크안함 ㅋㅋㅋ라이브 인증하러 가는 곳이 유스켄데 뭔
She sings with backing vocals because she's dancing on chairs, squatting, wearing heels, and the mix of this song isn't one that's easy to sing with natural sound. If you notice a lot of the song sounds like there's a filter...because there is. Sunmi killed it
선미언냐 멋있다^-^!! 걸크러쉬가 사람이라면 이런언냐일듯♡♡
이 옷들 잘어울린다
장르가 선미다
She’s gorgeous!! This song brings me strength.
Tbh this outfit is much more prettier than most outfits she had wore during music shows. Love ya!
I’m waiting patiently for Sunmi to wear they black outfit from the video!!!
노래 좋아요^^
Hey outfit is everything
ok but have y'all realized how sunmi is literally performing her song day after day, and slaying every time?
It might sound like she lip synched but if you pay attention you can hear that there is a double voice sound. It is probably a base for her sound and her live voice together. Unfortunately her base was louder than her live vocals, but at least she sang the other songs live...
Plus I never saw anyone lip sync in Yu Huiyeol's show
It's the same as Immortal songs
Tasnim Nasoma twice knock knock
It's the backtrack. All artists use it to get a fuller and fatter sound when singing live. You can clearly hear she misses one note at one place, so it's live. I just wish they'd use proper mics instead of these broadcasting mics. They seem to be popular in in Korea. I'm a music producer and audio engineer my self and those mics is my biggest nightmares cause they won't make your voice sound the best and isn't for singing so they have a completely different sound range. Sad.
Yeah, it's all about the backtrack, the artists have nothing to do with them. That's what their fans repeat over and over again. Why do they need to sing live when nobody can hear their real voices but the backtrack? I've never seen anything more ridiculous than that. They choose to use that kind of backtrack simply because they want it to cover their weak voices. Next time, when your artists sing with the backtrack which is "too loud", please dont say anything like "they sing live but the backtrack....blabla" again. I've got enough of this.
Okay for all the ones saying she is lip syncing...most solo artists will choose parts to sing, and you can definitely hear her voice in several parts. Just stop saying she is lip syncing, what do you expect to see? A person singing and dancing a whole song by herself?
agree, she sang clearly and stable
is no one going to talk about how gorgeous she looks?...just me? ok.
Sunmi's performance never disappoint people👍
i like this oufite on her so much
Everyday..I want to see her performance..I love her
SUNMI SLAY THE HATERS! SHES GREAT SINGING LIVE IN EVERY MUSIC SHOW!
Y'all can never appreciate anything without arguing about it... the stage was nice, she looked beautiful, the song & dance are good, if you just wanna hate honestly just go away it's so tiring
She's a queen, she looks so beautiful 💙👑
This is the best outfit😍😍😍
because she is a soloist, the song has some background vocals, she actually sang a lot
一個很愛果果的迷妹 ARMY ikr..most of the soloist has background music too
meithemeow yea, she did very well, and stable
I think she looks better with pants or jeans 😘💜
she sing with backup vocal, hear the mr removed.. she still sing live and i'm so proud:')
MA QUEEEEEENEE SLAY
She definitely needed to catch a breath so she couldn't be dancing this choreo that requires a lot of energy and keep singing throughout the performance!! This is nevertheless one of her beautiful performances!!
perfection!!!!
Another perfect performance
SUNMI💛
I wish her management/whoever is calling the shots had more confidence in her ability and experience to turn down the backing vocals more
Outfit on point vocal on point visual on point queen sunmi
guys, are you serious? she doesn't lip sync, the back track is kinda loud, but you can hear that she sings a long. how can you possibly expect her to sing EVERYTHING when she's a solo artist and has an intricate choreo that is all about grace and being sultry? i honestly don't understand why are people suddenly coming for her with such accusations + those "plagiarism" claims, like do y'all know what sampling is in the music industry? those beats are everywhere, sampling exists to make songs catchier, sometimes several super famous people use the same sample and that's okay, it doesn't mean the song is plagiarized.
anyway, the point is that sunmi doesn't deserve the hate.
update: i was informed that teddy insisted that it wasn't a sample, however, i still don't see that many similarities between heroine and cheryl's song to call it plagiarism, there are just so many catchy similar tunes that producers get inspired by and make them go viral again, everyone is just using similar stuff, pop music can get repetitive but it doesn't mean it's not fun. and it doesn't mean it's plagiarism either.
preach
(www.copynot.org/Pages/Music%20sampling.htm) "If you want to use a sample legally, you must obtain permission from the copyright owner. The copyright owner is usually a publishing company or record label. Remember that you must obtain permission from both the owner of the sound recording and the copyright owner of the underlying musical work." But Teddy said that it was 100% his work and he did not sample.
okay, i didn't know that he made a statement, thank you. but to me, heroine and cheryl's song aren't that similar for it to be considered plagiarism anyway. catchy tunes are all quite similar + that kind of beats is coming back to be trendy again. the same thing happened with radiohead's creep and lana del rey's get free, she just mixed a sultry vibe that has kind of "creep"-y feel if you choose to reach like this, and people started overreacting that radiohead sued her for it, but radiohead actually didn't, it was all people being hateful - and what is the point?
i'm just saying, sunmi is clearly a talented artist, people who have been following her career since the wonder girls days especially know that. yeah, the tunes are catchy and everyone kinda does the same thing, but it can get repetitive at times in pop music, so i don't see the reason why everyone is hating on sunmi, she's like the chillest artist out there.
There is MR removed version of this. You can clearly hear her live vocal ( especially in headphones). So, please, don't say rude things, we know she reads comments.
Perfect dance lovely music 👌🏻🌸
*QUEEN* 💓
SUNMI FIGHTING!!!!
I proud of you❤
LOVE YOU
As always her girl back dancers they are all beautiful
Are y'all actually complaining about her vocals. She wasn't fully lip syncing in fact she was singing along to most of it but obviously this is a hard song to sing and she's a SOLOIST. That means there are a lot of parts and at some point she's going to have to catch her breath. Plus she's never said she was the best vocalist, she's more advertised as a dancer/idol. Her stage presence is something you can't find in many people though
If you listen carefully, you’ll hear her voice.
Holy hell. Sunmi gets so much unnecessary hate. I think people are legitimately jealous their faves can't both be as beautiful as her while being talented.
Wow the dance is cool, she's pretty, the song is nice. THE END. Y'all need to chill
Slayin' my life😍😍😍
看到Sunmi就按讚
Acting like Black Pink and 2ne1 dont have the same heavy backtrack like Sunmi that make them look like lip-syncing! All TEDDY's work have heavy back tracks, so instead of assuming! YEAH! YYH will never allow lip sync!
SUNMI FTW!
Teddy and Sunmi should change the title of the song to "The Show Must Go On", it'd fits their situation better.
everything she wears is so good
Прекрасное Видео Для Вас Смотрим Все И Ставим Класс 👏👏👏👏👏
It's obviously gonna be hard for her to sing a whole entire song all alone while dancing can y'all give her a break
She’s definitely singing the pre chorus and chorus part. The others, half of them are lip sync and you can tell those are when her mouth isn’t open and she probably CHOSE to not sing those parts. Other times, she’s not lip synching and the track is just so loud it’s covering her voice, also because the notes are kinda reaaaaaally low at those parts. So it’s hard to belt out super low notes.
In this era, the stylist deserves an award.
She’s so seductive. I also love that just bc they use the automatic voice she uses her real voice. She’s queen all the way around
اجنن😍💖
sunmi teaches us that without using any seductive outfits or dance moves, u can be sexy
tae tae I'm not hating on her or anything, but tbh I would categorize her outfits as quite sexy. Not stripper sexy but still artist/musician sexy. There's nothing wrong with wearing revealing clothes, as long as that's not the main point :)
You guys are funny. Sunmi has always sung live bcs I always hear her struggling to sing. She uses her raw voice which she can’t reach the high notes cleanly. If she lip syncs she won’t be dumb enough to not sing some part so obviously like that. True, she’s not a good singer but not everybody in the world expects good singers. We also want good performers and Sunmi always gives a good performance. I’m not even a Sunmi fan but I can present you these facts. You all are expecting all Korean singers to be some kind of perfection but they’re performers. Art. If Sunmi’s vision of art is a good performance, who are you to judge what she can and what she can’t show to us?
I thought this was the only performance she sang live for Heroine. I mean... she slays both ways, and also it's fine if she lip-syncs because the choreo doesn't look easy to sing with
I just want her to give me a big hug
QUEEN
Nuna Saranghae 😍😘
😍😍😍😍
Her voice is EVERYTHING I SAY EVERY FRICKING THING
She has like 10 years of training thats why she sounds so good dont say its lip , its back track u
We don't deserved you QUEEN👑😭
YAS slay 💕
YAAAAAASSSSS
عشق 😍😍
I come to see her performances only for that dancer oppa 1:50
❤
Can she open a clothes line for all the outfits she wore for her heroine stages :((
Lucita D'cruz agreed!!! I love all of her outfits for this song
Lip-sync or not, it's not a big deal for me. She sings live? Great. She lip-syncs? It's her voice anyway
Sone2539 i am with u😙
teddy of blackpink produced this masterpiece once again
You mean.. teddy of YG / Black label?
yesss !! the one and only teddy, he did all blackpink's songs
#Queen
i'm expecting less backing vocals but it's so loud here it's almost (maybe not almost) drowning Sunmi's vocals.
she sings some parts of the song and others are backtrack. since gashina she's doing this, i don't get the polemic. lol
Why did KBS World stop subtitling Sketchbook in English?? Please bring Sketchbook back with English subs on KBS World!
DaRunningMan ㅋㅋ 웨 용오 안 써죠 찡찡~ 그렇게 알고 싶으면 한국어를 배우지;
Uhm , i don't get it why you guys saying she is lip-synching?
And it's ok to lip-synch sometimes like every artists does that
Sunmi xi
You are the best
Đoạn end nghe tiếng sunmi thở luôn
props to that dancer stabbing his eye and not reacting at all 2:51
Lol she is definitely tired here. Very clear with the popping moves and when she squats down.
She look like Bae Irene (little) in the tumbnail
장풍날리기춪
😍🙊👏👏
It's not like she didn't sing live but there were parts where she didn't sing but I wish she sang the verses too. The backtrack was so loud
For those who's saying Sunmi can't sing..go watch she sang Georgy Porgy..you'll scream 😀
Cannot blamed her...
I think she is so tired and her sound become very hoarse.....
This is why people can only spot the wrong and not the correct. tsk.
Sorry
Every solo singers do lipsync because they can't sing 100% of the music and dance at the same time
I love this song, but the act was far from what I love to see from a YHS performance. Sad :c
A
Fight For This Love (Korean ver.)
Shouldn't the artist sing live on this show? I wonder why she hasnt really sang live this comeback:(
laurustoyou This is live . Please listen carefully ok ??
영어타이틀이 히로인, 알파벳 하나차이로 헤로인과 비슷한데 노래 가사 일부분도 왠지 헤로인을 복용한 상태를 설명하는것같음
Lip Syncing
Wow I guess sketch book got rid of that no lip syncing rule
Acting like Black Pink and 2ne1 dont have the same heavy backtrack like Sunmi that make them look like lip-syncing! All TEDDY's work have heavy back tracks, so instead of assuming! YYH will never allow lip sync!
But Twice lip-synced in YHY? Sunmi didn't lips-sync but "they" did
Lips Syncing on this show #SHOOK
I think she mostly lip-sycn the low notes and the ' hey yeah yeah ' part. You can hear her voice in other part
K1 Kiu yes I little bit sound her voice... But this show normally live performance like immoral song
I know that too. Maybe the choreo is a bit tiring. Gashina's performance is full live
honestly if it’s a problem for you or if you want to hear her sing, just go back to the hundreds of performances Wonder Girls ALWAYS did live on music shows
Samia elghobar fuck you. Sunmi is singing live.
people usually sing live on this show why is she lip synching :’(
ctrljimin you can clearly see than she is singing live but are parts where she don't sing she is a solo artist you can't hope than she sing all her song when she is dancing too
ctrljimin she sang live ok ??? Please listen carefully
ctrljimin She DID sing live but the background vocals were too loud and you’re not allowed to lip sync in Yoo Heeyeol Sketchbook.
Pay attention please :))
rainie a kpop trash but twice done
Dont come on sketchbook if youre gonna use such loud back vocals...
Triangle what about twice?
Sing like her first, then dance like her, then do it all together while promoting :)
Triangle and shes actually singing so