ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 1 มิ.ย. 2024
- Jakarta is the world's second-largest city and the capital of Indonesia, but it is sinking into the sea. This is the effort to save it.
Key sources and videos quoted:
Anthony Bourdain Parts Unknown bit.ly/3Kmn4oj
Jakarta is Sinking! • Jakarta is sinking! - ...
Jakarta is the World's Fastest Sinking City • Jakarta Is The World's...
Asia's Sinking Cities: Jakarta • Asia's Sinking Cities:...
Jakarta Kota Air (Part 1) • JAKARTA KOTA AIR (Part...
Jakarta Unfair (Full Version) • JAKARTA UNFAIR (full v...
Why Jakarta is sinking • Why Jakarta is sinking
Indonesia Pollution: Jakarta tries to clean world's filthiest river • Indonesia Pollution: J...
Let It Flood: Ciliwung Delta by Bindi Purnama bit.ly/3PKERqB
Subscribe for city profiles:
/ thedailyconversation
All other research links:
Indonesia's new capital • Indonesia’s New Capita...
34 million urban area population demographia.com/db-worldua.pdf
Demographics, economy of Indonesia en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indonesia
Employment shift to services from agriculture bit.ly/3PQMTxZ
World's second-longest coastline bit.ly/2T66SfJ
Jakarta growth from space 1990-2019 go.nasa.gov/3An8994
Capitalism and the Dutch East India Company (Batavia) • Capitalism and the Dut...
Indonesian Independence 1945 • Indonesian Independenc...
Fewer than 1 million have access to piped water bit.ly/3ct5mmy
Sinking 3 times faster than a few years earlier bit.ly/3ALgLYs
Talking trash in Jakarta • Talking Trash in Jakarta
$40 on Great Garuda Sea Wall (Guardian) bit.ly/3TgSocj
Indonesia's giant capital city is sinking (Nat Geo) on.natgeo.com/3pIqF6K
Why Indonesia is moving its capital (Real Life Lore) • Why Indonesia is Movin...
Nusantara construction begins [video] • MUANTEP BOS KU PROGRES...
Indonesia passes law to relocate capital to Borneo • Indonesia passes law t...
Indonesia picks winning design for its new capital • Indonesia picks winnin...
Why do countries move their capital cities? econ.st/3PP9kns
Softbank’s exit from Indonesia’s new capital project bit.ly/3wweBcE
Jokowi is considering extending his term econ.st/3wrQV95
TransJakarta en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TransJa...
Megacity Episodes:
Buenos Aires, Argentina: The World's Southernmost MEGACITY
• Buenos Aires, Argentin...
London, England's MEGACITY: Capital of the British Empire • London: The Empire MEG...
Jakarta, Indonesia's MEGACITY - World's Second Largest City • The Race to Save Jakar...
Los Angeles, California's Megacity:
• Making Modern Los Ange...
AFRICA'S MEGACITY: Kinshasa, DRC (CONGO)
• Kinshasa, DRC: Africa'...
TOKYO: Earth's Model MEGACITY • Earth’s Model MEGACITY...
PARIS: Europe's MEGACITY • Paris, France's MEGACI...
SAO PAULO: South America's MEGACITY • São Paulo, Brazil's ME...
DHAKA: Fastest Growing MEGACITY • DHAKA, Bangladesh's ME...
CAIRO: Middle East • Cairo, Egypt's MEGACIT...
DELHI: India's Capital • Delhi, India's MEGACIT...
SHANGHAI: China's Largest MEGACITY • China's Largest City: ...
MEXICO CITY: Largest MEGACITY in the Americas • MEXICO CITY, Mexico's ...
Obama Makes Baby Stop Crying • Obama Makes Baby Stop ...
President Obama's Anger Translator at White House Correspondent's Dinner • President Obama's Ange...
Greatest Recorded Speeches in American History (1933-2008) • Greatest Recorded Spee...
Bill Nye Destroys Noah's Ark • Bill Nye Destroys Noah...
President Obama Walks The Streets of Washington • President Obama Walks ...
Trump Destroyed by Comedian Hasan Minhaj at 2017 White House Correspondents Dinner • Trump Destroyed by Com...
Seth Rogen Testifies Before Congress • Seth Rogen Testifies B...
President Obama's Anger Translator: Behind The Scenes • President Obama's Ange...
Jakarta, Indonesia's MEGACITY: The World's Second Largest City
Chapters:
0:00 Introduction
1:11 Welcome to Jakarta
2:55 'Urban planning gone horribly wrong'
3:09 History of Jakarta
3:56 Suharto comes to power
4:30 Land subsidence explained
4:56 Sinking 3x faster
5:29 Historic flooding
6:32 Raising their homes
7:15 The problems with channelization
8:34 Floodplain development
9:15 Kampungs resettlement
10:55 The rising sea
11:47 Great Garuda Sea Wall Megaproject
12:48 A New Capital: Nusantara
14:11 Questions surrounding Nusantara
15:19 A City worth saving
16:21 Piped water for all
16:58 Creating more greenspace
17:30 Building an aquatic metropolis
18:07 Floodproof homes
19:12 Tiny homes on stilts
19:44 How Kampung Tongkal was saved
Indonesia new law parliament bali ache criminalize Indonesia bans outside marriage as parliament passes sweeping new criminal code
Jakarta is a prime example of city without urban planning, just by looking at the map you can tell about 80% of the "city" is unregulated urban settlement consisted of improvised buildings.
True, even the suburb
Yess
But can that fix ?
@@arvyno7129 😮💨it'll be very hard i think
@@arvyno7129 gusur, bikinin rusun.
@@rizkyadiyanto7922 langsung didemo sampe longsor kek Ahok
One of the Best countries I have visited. Bekasi, Jakarta and Bandung share the same problem of Horrible traffic jam but the People are so Resilient, Hard Working and Adopting. Hope they will overcome whatever problems they are facing.
Cheers from Pakistan.
Cheers. I saw a lot of similarities between Jakarta and Manila (which I just profiled).
Much better country than Pakistan. While Pakistan tries to forget its Indian and Sanskrit Heritage, trying to be more Arab and Iranian. Indonesia embraces both Islam and Sanskrit Heritage
@@amit4Bihar Why did you Adopt English then ?
This is so far the most comprehensive video about the complexity of Jakarta’s problems yet, thank you!
I appreciate that, Alilolo--that's what I'm going for with these videos.
@@TDC_TheDocumentaryChannel You definitely hit the mark
Before this video, many of the points that you brought are only really talked about by Indonesian media and Indonesians themselves. You earned a subscriber!
Man caught on camera stealing 10-year-old's ...Dad Of The Year !
th-cam.com/video/q4pgSgSritk/w-d-xo.html .
Agreed well done. Appreciated the focus on potential adaptive strategies as well
Agree, very nicely put together.
I love the fact that residents along the river got involved and reduced the space they occupy by 5 meters from the river banks. A win-win for the government, the people and nature.
Hopefully they can replicate this cooperative model throughout the highly populated river system.
Yes
Ducth colonial fault
As a Jakarta resident this is quite depressing tbh because there doesn't seem to be much hope for this city, especially compared to your other videos where cities like Cairo and Lagos are on the rise and have improved significantly with a bright future ahead of them.
Personally, I think Jakarta's problems is way too much that abandoning ship is the way to go. There needs to be significant investment in other cities and open up proper job opportunities there instead of them crowding in the Jabodetabek metropolitan area where most of the jobs are.
Personally, I think moving the capital to Borneo is a good idea. Once the bureacrats and government offices are relocated, that would mean Jakarta can focus on being the financial capital instead of serving two functions which the landmass can't support.
But yeah, despite the overall depressing state that Jakarta is in there is still a lot to be hopeful about like the MRT system, the LRT, as well as planned water treatment facilities so that people won't have to pump their water from underground.
Excellent video regardless :)
Thanks for your thoughts, MA! I hope moving the capital indeed accomplishes those worthy goals :)
Nah bro Lo bener, emang hopeless Jakarta. Sebagus-bagusnya bakalan semana sih? Tetep aja sumpek, berisik, ricuh, sinking pula 🤦🏻♂️
Paling enak emang bangun kota2 baru yg alami di pulau Sumatra Kalimantan Sulawesi irian dll, landscape nya keren2 diluar sana masih alami udara juga seger gak sumpek
@@angcil88 lu kurang ngikutin pembangunan di jakarta kali bro. gubernur sekarang bikin banyak waduk2, tujuannya ya itu biar air bisa kembali ke tanah.
pengguna transportasi umum juga meningkat drastis. kalo terus ditingkatin, lama2 jakarta bukan lagi kota yg paling penuh polusi.
@@rizkyadiyanto7922 tp ttp ga imbang dgn pemukiman dan penggunaan air tanah membuat jkt tanahnya makin turun
@@rizkyadiyanto7922 but still sinking awal mula seperti kata JJ Rizal kanal itu penyakitnya dulu sebelum kanal blom banjir sekarang udah telat pendangkalan udah akut
Jakarta has got a lot greener since the last years. I really like the downtown area, and all the vibes it has. Especially at night it's also very unique :)
Ini video lama
@@ww2753 ini video di upload 1 hari yang lalu
Sadly some of the large ones are privately owned :)
@@dddf27 most of the footage comes from 2020
a lot of those high rises in Central and South Jakarta don't even have piped water. They pump groundwater. That's why the city is sinking. So they build skyscrapers on top of already sinking ground and then pump groundwater, which makes it even worse
Jakarta is the prime and peak example of how corrupt the system & government in Indonesia that they dont care about its people, but their own pocket & wealth instead
Sundapura (Tarumanagara) > Sunda Kalapa (Sunda+Galuh) > Jayakarta (Demak+Cirebon+Banten) > Batavia (Nederlandsch-Indië) > Djakarta Tokubetsu Shi (Japan) > Jakarta (Indonesia)......
Sunda pura ibu kota taruma nagara (bekasi)
Sunda kalapa pelabuhan terbesar kerajaan sunda (Taruma nagara- padjadjaran)
Ibu kota padjadjaran (bogor)+(galuh pakuwan).
@@champurantv Sundapura itu letaknya di Kampung Tugu, Jakarta Utara...... Memang berbatasan dengan Bekasi...... Tapi secara administrasi masih merupakan wilayah DKI Jakarta....... Di sana ada prasasti nya...... Kalau Bekasi itu Chandrabhaga........ Chandrabhaga sendiri memiliki sinonim yaitu Bhagasasi yang menjadi cikal-bakal nama Bekasi saat ini.......
It is actually very eye opening for me as I live in Jakarta and this place might only be as far as 5 to 6 miles from my neighborhood, the more horrifying is the fact that not many of us are aggressively informed about the problem.
We know Jakarta is sitting below the sea level and that it is sinking a few centimetre every year, but nobody really brings the awareness and proofs that not only it's already happening, it happens fast.
Our media is obsessed with politics, religions and how to combine them, when there's a literal place not far from our houses where a man can fish on the street.
Hello, I saw this exact type of comment on many of the videos I watched during my research, and is the main reason why I included so many quotes from locals. I'm glad it helped shed a bit more light on what's going on.
Well you yourself are obsessed with life of celebrity arent you? The media you are talking about is probably just infotainment news hence what you hear is gossip. I don't even live in jakarta but i know this problem since about 7-9 years ago. Many of jakarta citizens should have known this right when the idea of moving the capital to borneo first be announced. It has nothing to do with the mainstream media be discussing other topics beside the sinking of the city. It clearly has nothing to do with religion, politic, and obsession. We have been informed about this sinking issues for years and the local govt also have done their best to solve the problem as we can see in this video. What we as the citizens must do are to cooperate and protect the environment instead of keep on complaining
@@wtfareperfectplaces its so undercover and the author used city Karachi Pakistan foortage and polluted river in Phom penh Cambodia and now one realized .
@@TDC_TheDocumentaryChannel lol
@@NPC2358 author fooled anybody LOL
Canadian expat living in Jakarta here. It's a crazy place. Beautiful but very dirty. The people are welcoming and kind. Every city has it's pros and cons. But I'm not leaving. I'm proud it's my new home!
I think you should choose places like Bangkok instead. Much cleaner compared to Jakarta.
Why'd you choose Jakarta?
@@gmubl also much easier to live. Indonesia makes it very hard to immigrate permanently.
@@gmubl having lived in both, I'd definitely choose Jakarta.
@@Secretlyanothername not really. You just have to give up your citizenship if you want to stay permanently without marrying a local.
Living in Jogja, a city on the south of Java, but will spend a month in Jarkata, so this video is very appreciated!
I'm looking forward to hearing your thoughts on the city after your visit!
@@TDC_TheDocumentaryChannel currently living in jakarta as a uni student here. My thoughts? Expensive
I am an Indonesian living in Jogja
As a person that born & live on Borneo for decades, yes, this part of the area is quite safe. No major disasters. The only problem is smog problem caused by farming's open burning.
We do hope the change of Indonesia capital will means real development on this island, including stimulating development in neighbouring countries (Sabah, Sarawak & Brunei) - which frankly, are quite falling behind compared to other places. Despite the size of Borneo island, there isn't any real modern transit system available, this place is still the largely backwater countryplace... If you're looking for low living cost & quiet place to live, currently Borneo is a nice spot. If you looking for advance modern hightech living, eh...... there aren't really anything interesting going on around here.
Environment is, and SHOULD BE, the top concern.
low living cost??🤣
@@ankokunokayoubi you are absolutely correct! The forests of that island are some of the most important on the planet. Also some of the most threatened.
What about landslide?
@Reza Ardana Makanya belajar
Assalamualaykum. I'm Filipino with Bruneian and Chinese descent. Hope we strive together to be a strong country as SEA neighbors.
To avoid confusion:
Jakarta SCR (also the province of Jakarta SCR) population is only 10.5 million (2020)
Jakarta Metropolitan, consists of Jakarta SCR and satellite cities from two neighboring provinces:
Jakarta SCR (Jakarta SCR province)
Bogor (West Java province)
Depok (West Java province)
Bekasi (West Java province)
Tangerang (Banten province)
South Tangerang (Banten province)
Total population is 33.5 million (2020). Indonesians call this metropolitan as 'Jabodetabek'
The later is the one this video is talking about and call it 'the 2nd largest city'.
Hi Anggita. Yep, this series focuses on the greater metros as continuously built-up urban areas based on rankings by Demographia.
@@TDC_TheDocumentaryChannel Yeah it makes more sense to not confine it to only Jakarta proper since water doesn't follow along administration lines
True ! when you just count the proper city only, Jakarta even not get on the top 10 list the most populated city in the world
mbak anggita jkarta tuh pas jam kerja betul bisa 35 juta orang .kan bnyak pekerja dari area jabotabek kerja si jakarta.
yah kalo udah malam jam kantor bisa menyusut sampe 25 juta juwa
ingat banyak yg kos dari sliruh indinesia dtng merantau
kalo yg ktp jkarta paling 11 juta orang
kan kenyataan nya jkrta penuh padat
@@wahyunux gausah ngarang ,jam kerja jakarta bisa 35 juta ,35 juta tu total penduduk jabodetabek ,lu kira smua org2 dr bogor ,depok ,tangerang,bekasi ,smuanya pada ke jakarta kalo jam kerja ? Lu pikir anak2 ,emak2 dan smua nya dr kota2 satelit itu pindah ke jakarta pas jam kerja ? Statment lu salah besar ,
Ini baru bener how jakarta actually, jangan cma daerah gedung² ny aja yg di sorot apa lagi smpe bilang jakarta udh kayak jepun ohh jauh skali tidak, itu sebabnya perlu IKN
Better and most reality content from some of our modern jakarta building youtubers 😅 .
Good job , 10 thumbs up for you 👍
All Indonesia 🇮🇩 But especially JAKARTA and all Java offers a lot to see there , something that I appreciate there , IS THE PEOPLE , Very friendly , Respectful,Smily , Hard Working , and the most hospitable people you can find around the globe 🌎🙏
Definitely!
Yes
Also very racist, a lot religious issues and average IQ 80. This is a fact of our country
Love the content your channel produces! I would love to see a video of yours on the Brazilian city of Curitiba! It’s one of the mos incredible examples of how to make world leading urbanism projects on a budget! Cheers for the content!
Hi Gregorio, so glad you like what I'm doing here! I discussed Curitiba and Jaime Lerner briefly in my video on Sao Paulo a few years back ;)
This is a solid solid endeavor. I don't think any of these are new for most Jakartan (n to a lesser extent Indonesian) but this is a good summary for non-Jakartan. Not only you give ample space for the locals to talk, you also selected the 'right' pieces*. Again a solid 20 mins window to Jakarta's problem and potential.
Born and raised in Jakarta, decided to leave the city in the early 2000s but even to this day still technically a citizen of Jakarta. I still want my voting right for Jakarta, my voice for a better Jakarta altho I've been moving from town to town of Indonesia for the past 20 years.
*bar a clip of Jogja at 15:30 while discussing about traffic in Jakarta.
PS: I know Yu Sing personally, learned a great deal from him. A great man.
Thanks for this comment Topher!
*and that TV news about eviction, which is in Bandung, not Jakarta
I live in jakarta, and feel jakarta is better now if compare to before 2010...in few area still have flooding but mostly will running out soon...
seperti biasa seketika bnyak orang indo atau jakarta komen di sini wkkwkwkw
ayolah biar orang asing yg menuhin komentar di sini
Seeing how a system of infiltration well located near my house is not working as itended and required a pump to drain the water, I can say that 2020 Great Flood will surely happen again in the future... Brace Yourself
@@pstw4890 Org asing cuma mncari popularitas viewer ttg sisi negatif suatu kota.. Tidak saja Indonesia tpi juga negara brkmbang yg lainnya bro..
@@richlistening5511 ya biarlah... lagian nyatanya gk bgitu klw mereka betulan langsung k sini
@@richlistening5511 mksd ku di sini tolonglah jngn NORAK banget netizen indo itu
Very impressed with your video. Felt thorough yet concise. Even though an American, I felt a connection as I've visited this city and a lot of Java while getting got caught in several flash flooding events. Glad to see the city and it's residents are seeming to be making progress in a challenging situation.
Great job and thanks for covering this incredible complex mega city …. and for offering some possibilities of hope for its future.
Glad you enjoyed it!
Great lol fixed
Alot of footage aren't in Jakarta even in Indonesia
@@TDC_TheDocumentaryChannel LOL sarcasm
Very nicely compiled!
I live in jakarta and the floods are only after very strong rain. Similar to any city around the world after very strong rain.
Yes
I lived in Jakarta for 13 years and loved it. I was caught in that flood in Jan 2020.
I always said the capital relocation won't work because all the male politicians have several girl friends and not sure how that will work out in Kalimnatan
😁😁😁😁
the new capital, Nusantara, will be a hot stinking mess. mark my words!
All girl would be "exported" to there
This guy knows what influences decision making
@@roryasrorri701 Still it doesn't stop immigrants from Sulawesi and Java to come to Kalimantan,and these immigrants keep coming and their number is increasing.Its much easier to found this people in city in kalimantan rather than Dayak people.
gambaran yang bagus tentang jakarta yg bukan sekedar JPO dengan gardu pandang, halte cantik, atau pedestrian yg diperlebar. jakarta lebih kompleks dari sekedar 3 hal itu, yg undevelop.
Undevelop soal urban yang SDMnya tertinggal
Jakarta Utara masih banyak pemukiman padat, kumuh, yg di pinggir sungai, sungai kotor, sampah dll, tapi itu bukan keahlian Anies, Anies kurang tertarik masuk ke sana sebab saya rasa dia takut kehilangan suara dari rakyat kecil😁, jadi Anies fokus mempercantik transportasi, trotoar, JPO dan taman2 kota
jakarta masih kumuh amu gubernurnya anis ke, ahok ke tetap masih kumu krn ya problemnya membludak
datang lah ke Jakarta, lalu komen lagi
banyak infrastruktur dibandingkan
@@denyhams bagus Jakarta daripada KL
I loved Jakarta when I have visited there twice but I did stay around Central Jakarta on both occasions but I was aware of its problems with flooding and polluted water from locals who talked to me about it when I was there
I visited in 2012. I didn't care for the many mosquitoes and crazy amount of traffic. Otherwise the people and culture were amazing. I hope they find a solution to the flooding problem, and the traffic.
Good idea of moving the capital from jakarta to east kalimantan, let jakarta becomes center town of business, crowded houses crowded people must seperate from government area. hopefully jakarta can be better many green areas, change the crowded house become apartments.
kind of like what happened with malaysia. separating the capital city (Kuala Lumpur) and the head of state (Putrajaya)
Well the Dutch actually built a good system, however many of the canals being filled in since the 90s. When I was in jkt for the first time, the population was around 7 million in 89. The new airport was built on farmland in the west of city. Now is surrounded by urbanisation. Consisting traffic was already horrible in the 80s. The crash in 97 was already signs of what to come
Such an amazing Video about an important problem, that will affect so many people! Thanks for creating this awesome video!
Great video!
Wow! Such a great documentary of Jakarta! I learned so much!
Thank you for the amazing video.
I have a question. Would youtube not show more vids of yours in the algoritm if you waited till you finished all videos then released each vid weekly?
Keep up the great work!
Hi R K, thanks! You're right, it would definitely help to publish a video each week ;)
Lol
New capital is not build in remote faraway land like Naypyidaw. East Kalimantan is one of the most richest GDP wise outside of Java. There are several big city like Samarinda, Balikpapan, Bontang, and Tenggarong near the proximity of new capital. Also its build at government own monoculture plantation, not some virgin natural forest.
But funds for building it will be loaned from china
@@namazlur78 data dari mana??
Pembangunan awal IKN masih mengunakan APBN
Dana asli pemerintah bukan utang Blok
Ngk usah kau sebar hoax
@@Tumanggor-sq2xp data apa? Mmg semua org tau yg jokodog ingin 80% dana dari investor jadi tak ada yg mau. Uae & saudi juga lari wkwk
Awesome video!
Just discovered this channel. I love all the video's 👍 so informative keep it up 🙏
Ayook...Yang selalu muji² Jakarta kota modern kayak Singapura.. mana suaranya😆
Gak heran, presidennya aja yg janji2 mau perbaiki ibu kota. Eh malah lari ke hutan borneo. Sekalian aja bawa semua pengikut si sambo 🤭
@@inforingkasolahraga kamu harus mengikut nya lari ke Borneo, menbeli rumah ketika masih murah,rumah di sana di kawasan industri dan penjabat kerajaan akan sangat mahal setelah beberapa tahun.khabar nya Jokowi menberi intensif lumayan pada orang-orang muda yang ingin mengikuti nya,kalau aq dan teman2 aq warga Indonesia,pasti ingin mencuba nasib di pulau Borneo
Jakarta Belongs to Me, although sometimes there are many disappointed and painful feelings in Jakarta but here is always a lot of love, this city is really crazy and amazing 💙
Yes
Love ur channel, thank you
good Editing old video and New video...#Jakarta always improved to change...Problem All city in the worlds watching from #CentralJava Indonesia🇮🇩 2022🌍🌏🌎💪👍
technically what you refer as Jakarta is not city, but province. this special province of Jakarta Capital is most populated and have great economic impact for Indonesia. even with Surabaya, 2nd largets city in Indonesia are beyond compare. most of mid class are not living in Jakarta but in other city such as Bogor, Depok, Tanggerang, Bekasi then we call this megacity as Jabodetabek even this come from 3 different province (Banten, Jakarta, west Java). this also make million of people commute everyday between those city to work at Jakarta.
Not just in Jakarta! Everywhere in Indonesia, we have horrible city planning, you turn to your left you see horrible city planning, you turn to your right you see horrible city planning, you look up and down you see horrible city planning.
Great vid 🌱🌱🌱
Very comprehensive discussion on Jakarta problems. Highly appreciate! 👍
Glad you think so!
we build together we are strong together🇮🇩🇮🇩🇮🇩
Only now did I get to know, that it's the 2nd largest city on the planet.
Lots of things surprise me while researching this series and this fact was definitely one of them.
@@TDC_TheDocumentaryChannel it's the 1st time, being noted by a channel's owner.
Thank you.
Good video thanks
This was an exceptional report. What a shame it is only 20 minutes. I could have watched this for at least 2 hours.
Lately I have become more interested in Indonesia and have to admit I know very little about it. This helped. Thank you.
Wow, thank you. Feel free to watch two hours of my other episodes ;)
A mess, enough said. The fact that people still believe that the government wouldn't abandon them for the new capital is mindblowing.
I'm curious as to what makes the amsterdam canals work while not the jakarta ones since both of them are built on low lying swamps under sea level (other than improper maintenance of course)
Either way i really like the way you uncover this problem. You exposed its many nuances and explained how things became the way they are and why the people haven't done anything to solve it, and the challenges faced in the process to solve it
jakarta lies in a tropic region, high rainfall and surrounded by mountain in the south which act as aboundant source of water, thats why no ancient kingdom capital in java located in the shore... the best way is to naturalize most of its vital part like upstream, riverbanks and planting mangrove as a natural sea walls..
@@Ayrustration so is the amount of rain and water flowing into amsterdam not comparable with jakarta?
Ehm, is that really a question? Amsterdam is not directly at the sea, it sits behind a broad patch of dunes where it also gets its water from. The water level in the city is 40 cm below sea level, and it relies on Dutch water engineering to keep it dry. The city had its origin when a dam was built across the mouth of a river, precisely because the poldering in the area had caused the land to sink. The dam prevented the river from eroding the land further, and the silt building up behind it is the ground on which the city stands. I don't see protective dunes and soil-retaining dams in Jakarta. Perhaps the Dutch cheated a bit when they dug the canals and left away the rest of the system.
@@kimyeonahchannel for a start, Indonesia is along the equator, just slightly south. Equatorial tropics receives heavy rainfall throughout the year. Temperate countries much further north or south like Netherlands do not receive as much rainfall.
Indonesia has much coastline and mountains, cold air from the highlands and moisture-rich warm sea breeze meet constantly to produce rain. Same for places like Brazil.
Indonesia experiences monsoon seasons as well.
Discharging rainfall directly into the sea via straight concrete canals is the perfect recipe for disaster, where groundwater is not able to recover its critical levels. The huge population and unregulated groundwater extraction increases the problem multiple folds. The vacuum hence caused the ground to sink constantly, with increasing concrete high-rise buildings adding to the pressure.
@@kimyeonahchannel yes, even the dutch give up and rebuild the new capital in the middle of west java highland..
Wow... !!! My best friend, Great... Awesome... Full watched. Thanks Have a happy day!
Thank you! You too!
Beautiful place. Happy New year 🎉 From Philippines 😍😘
SIAPA SURUH DATANG JAKARTA...
SIAPA SURUH DATANG JAKARTA...
SIAPA SURUH DATANG JAKARTA...
..in my city, where i live...is called elevated contruction... a elevated house (bangunam panggung), a elevated neigboarhood road (jalan titian)... we are here, live on watersurfaces.... sebuah warisan budaya permukiman sungai dan rawa...salam sehat
No entry to Indonesia without taking the keel shots!
Greetings from Egypt ❤ beautiful documentary ✔️ thank you
The Citarum River does not pass through Jakarta, its downstream is in Bekasi Regency - West Java.
Jakarta is a beautiful city in SE I love it
Beautiful city tour Jakarta! I enjoy it a lot! thanks for sharing my friend! big like4777, new sub from Taiwan!
I like the homeowner who renovate her house to be friend with water ❤️❤️❤️
Me too!
I have been to Jakarta twice, nice city with good people yes Jakarta has flood issues and traffic congestion but with smart engineering ideas with proper planning and project execution can protect the city...
We'll see...
I love java people, they very polite,maybe rarely found in other country
Jawa campur hindu dapat lah flores kan.. hindunesia negara miskin mundur
@@zackpheonix9042 Mal0n mal0n dah nyepong British blum?! 🤣🤣
My beautiful Jakarta. Cantik sekali, miss it soooo much
the aerial shot is soooo good.
Jakarta is merely a slum with office blocks in between.
High time to move out.
The current governor of Jakarta, Anies Baswedan, does not want to take serious action on the water problem in Jakarta. Whether it's clean water, waste water, groundwater, sewers, rivers, lakes and so on. Five years as governor, he built sidewalks and pedestrian bridges. Maybe it's because the current type of governor is a dandy type, so what's taken care of is Jakarta decorations, according to his personal interests.
As live in jakarta, I hope the new capital will be completed quickly for infrastructure alignment in Indonesia 🙏
Do you think the new capital is a good idea?
Thank you
You should learn from the Dutch fight against nature, not run away
@@aha5693 itu urusan negara kami
Bukan urusan kau
Nice sharing 👍
Thank you! Cheers!
THANK YOU
This is fantastic, now you need Indonesian subtitles to increase your audience!
The Indonesian guy complaining about the Dutch way of handling canals and water should seriously start learning from the Dutch on how to manage lands that are below the sea level. While the Dutch never stopped innovating, this guy really enjoys complaining without offering any solutions
People in the tropics are like that, they are too lazy, unlike people in temperate or frigid zones, they need to work hard to survive the winter
love Jakarta from Bangkok, Thailand.
Thank you for sharing my country, hopefully we will be better from now to future.
@Ary zal di negara kau bangla chinese bhsa melayu tak kekal kasihan
@Ary zal konsep alam melayu terkial kial gagal mbentuk negara bangsa, malang sekali masih merasa seperti di jajah
Awesome video, the narrator said it best when he said that the capital doesn't need to move and it will be cheaper if they just fix the problem over time, step by step.. But the problem is that someone will get really big money from relocating. Indonesia's politicians are not allowed to find the better alternative for the people. The Indonesian politicians are prisoners of their international overlords, and guess what... They don't care about the people's well being.
Always someone else's fault eh? Nothing to do with the corruption rife in the Indonesian government or the decades of neglect by the indonesian government? Blame the foreigners instead.
@@wbbartlett No, I think the Indonesian government is to blame for the most. But it is to blame for letting foreign powers meddle in internal Indonesian affairs with unreasonable projects. Is it clearer to you now?
plus, they should destroy Borneo.
Narrow minded
U r narrow minded, capital should in the center of the country. So the people from every parts of country get a equal acces to it.
Wow, Kudos to all the brave Indonesian fighter, you are brave and just know the world is watching!
🇮🇩🙏❤
Thank you 🙏
You’re welcome 😊
I always confuse the largest cities in the Southern Hemisphere between Sao Paulo and Jakarta. Some stats put Sao Paulo above Jakarta and others put Jakarta above.
Some stats only show population in the administrative area, others shown total metropolitan population
Indonesian here.
Jakarta SCR (also the province of Jakarta SCR) population is only 10.5 million (2020)
Jakarta Metropolitan (Consists of satellite cities from two neighboring provinces) population is 33.5 million (2020)
Jakarta Metropolitan consists of:
Jakarta SCR (Jakarta province)
Bogor (West Java province)
Depok (West Java province)
Bekasi (West Java province)
Tangerang (Banten province)
South Tangerang (Banten province)
Indonesians call this metropolitan as 'Jabodetabek'
Terserahlah,media luar sih emang begitu,nyari Vidio lama gua ga tahu,yang jelas dalam masalah banjir di daerah gua tepatnya di Jakarta Selatan sekarang kaga banjir lagi 👍👍walaupun hujan hujan begitu lebat...😁👍👍
Klo banjir emang udah jarang kedengeran sih, cuma gatau dah daerah lain.
Ya kan Jakarta Utara yang di beritakan media luar dan dalam negeri Jakarta Selatan ngak terlalu kena malahan daerah kumuh dan sempit kebanyakan di Jakarta Utara.
Apa hubungannya Jakarta Selatan yang jauh dengan laut.
@@minangaceh5263 hmm.. kebetulan tinggal di jakarta utara, cuma daerah saya udah nggak pernah banjir kaya dulu gitu sih.
now I know how they (foreigners) think about Jakarta.
Greetings from BANTEN INDONESIA 🇮🇩
@TDC how about you do a Video on Istanbul Europes Biggest/Largest City and one of biggest cities in the World.
I live here 6 years. This new city never happand ;) this country its just country of "dreaming peoples". All is only plans and never will happened.
pemindahan ibu kota adalah langkah yg sanggat tepat... semoga pembanggunan IKN bisa berjalan cepat dan lancar...Aminnnnnn!!!!!
"we are sinking!!"
"ok i have a solution. lets move, bye"
"whuat? ur leaving us? what about us? and we are still sinking"
"i said, this is the solution."
Keep clam. Step by step Modern Jakarta. Big Jakarta?
jakarta 🇲🇨=bangladesh🇧🇩
No problem at all, Bangladesh is nice. Indonesians don't have any intention to look down any other countries...
perhaps you come from neighbouring country
Hindunesia is harga mati
@@zackpheonix9042 chinaysia rising
@@Martha.fokker indonsial next sri lanka
@@zackpheonix9042 magaysial will go extinct by 2025 and the chinese will take over it so sad
The problem with water access is way more than how much pipe we should connect. I am growing up in Jakarta pretty much all my life, and for the most part using well pump. I just switched to government water pipe 3 years ago and let's say that only create more problem for me. The water comes from a very polluted river, and need to be treated heavily with chemical to the point that tap water tasted closer to swimming pool than drinkable, thus more investment on filtration system if you plan to not buy gallons of water for daily consumption. Then the flow of water is so weak and not reliable, that for 10 hours a day, I don't have running water access since I live in second floor. I mean, come on, second-biggest city in the world and yet I can't poop peacefully on my own toilet at midnight.
Also, there is this problem with corruption culture that is killing the country as a whole, siphoning fund from such project that could help Jakarta. Like, rather than putting investment for a long term, government officials use the cheapest and shittiest concrete so that they could play with margin and so it will be broken every year. Broken infrastructure annually means funds allocation every year, more budget to play with.
Hi Arby, thanks for your insights as a local. That was my takeaway too, that much more needed to be done to clean up the rivers so they could be a reliable source of potable water. All the best!
This is a great mini documentary
Projek to transportasi water. To Jakarta city 🇮🇩🇮🇩. Wonderful Indonesian 🇮🇩🇮🇩
why videos about Jakarta and Indonesia in western media are always recorded from the past, that was jakarta 10 years ago, look at now jakarta in 2022 has changed a lot modern, many rivers that used to be dirty are now clean, even jakarta in 2021 won the title of city with the best transportation In the world,
why do western media lose to TH-camr Traveling, they always cover Jakarta with the latest updates
Latest update from Tourist, amazing Jakarta th-cam.com/video/unhBwozgxiw/w-d-xo.html
chanel ini krisis view
This is the reality
Jakarta have good side and the bad side you cant discredit the bad side by just hightlighting the good side, Jakarta now is still the same its still sinking.
do you know why Jakarta is sinking? 😁 because 90% of the houses in Jakarta uses Underground Water. because the inability of the Water Company in Jakarta. that couldnt supply or maybe dont care about it or maybe overlooked it.
Wowwww... amazeeee
i've been to north jakarta myself , it was pretty scary , behind of those sea wall the water were higher than the houses seriously scary .
Yg di salahin belanda melulu..
Belanda tidak gagal membangun kota tapi penghuni kota nya yg gagal paham bagaimana hidup dan ber prilaku di kota. Buang sampah sembarAngan aliran sungai buat hunian...dan masih banyak lagi
S7.. Nyalahin Belanda tapi masyarakatnya sendiri masih bodoh.. Di zaman kolonial malah justru penataan kota sangat rapi.. Di kasih rusun malah balik lagi tinggal di bantaran sungai dan rel kereta api
01:35 R.I P. Anthony Bourdain
I love the reporter pronouncing "megacity" as "me-GAH-city" at 0:23.
Videonya mantap🎉
great documentary, in the future #vientiane, #laos will be like #jakarta as well; they are build now and figure out later. vientaine, if the city planners are doing everything now... then everything will be fine, but the rate of what is going on now will soon be flooded and whatnot
fthe fact of jakrta..because jakarta not only sudirman and thamrin road..
I am indonesian born. If you ask why....
this is Indonesia with a huge size, huge in number, huge in religion, huge in culture, huge in ethnicity, and another huge in democracy.
Politically this is very, very hard. their rather low level of education makes them very easy to move politically because of the enormous freedom of speech in this country.
so it's not easy whoever the leader is... even a putin will surely fail to lead Indonesia. and even if ordered by the military in a very hard way though it will surely fail because hardworking Indonesians never give up even in gun wars.
350 years war with Netherland and 3.5 with japanese indonesian people consistent a war...
So... It is HARD WORK... Of indonesian leader
All the best to the people in Indonesia. May you all prosper 👋🏻🇳🇱❤️🇲🇨 born in Holland 100% Javanese ancestry (and proud of it)
Deepest documentary report video about Sunda Kelapa - Batavia - Jakarta 👍
Housing is the biggest problem in terms of city planning. Converting those ilegal squaters and slum is a must, but our current Governor, Anies, is doing nothing on this.