This is why it will always be a problem. And there will never be a solution. My kids legally started working at 14 in the US but not in dangerous jobs.
@@Doggiehoomanmomда, но нет никакой гарантии, что ваши внуки или правнуки не начнут работать в США с 12 лет и уже на опасных работах. Это произвол больших корпораций и больших денег. Этот произвол может остановить только сплочённая борьба трудящихся за свои права. Борьба, в короткой американскому рабочему ближе будет китайский рабочий, а не американская корпорация.
Вы же понимаете, что Китай тоже большой. Возможно в экономически развитых провинциях на восточном побережье ситуация сейчас улучшилась, но в том же Китае есть депрессивные западные регионы, где ситуация и сейчас ничуть не лучше, даже хуже, потому что на Востоке много производств, а в западных провинциях их очень мало. Такое впечатление, что вы воспринимаете фильм, как критику Китая, но это не так. Это критика безумной системы эксплуатации, где одни производят телефоны за миску риса в день на вредном производстве, а другие продают эти телефоны в СОТНИ РАЗ дороже себестоимости. Если это будут не китайские рабочие, а рабочие Бирмы или Вьетнама, ситуацию в целом это не меняет.
Just like anywhere , and it is not just these Chinese factories breaking labor laws and being corrupt . Don’t you know ? Are you not aware ? It is all about the MONEY - NOT if it is illegal / against labor law 😒
The only thing worse is what has happened to a generation of adults now who will never know how much better the world was without smartphones.its not good.
If you accept local laws (age, hours, environment, safety) to be broken elsewhere by having products made elsewhere your government facilitates just that yet not in your own country. This exactly on how manufacture is dissapearing in the USA and EU.
The governments of these factories take no responsibility to enforce the laws. They allow the factories to self govern. They aren’t randomly inspected. And if they are inspected they are notified in advance so they can hide any violations. I blame the governments for allowing this to occur and quite frankly they know it’s happening but don’t care enough to disrupt the flow of money into their countries.
j'en suis conscients depuis + de 15 ans, j'ai jamais eux de téléphone connecter a internet, j'ai tjs mon 3310 qui a 20ans, et je me rend compte, que de ne pas être connecté en dehors de chez soi, apporte bcps de bienêtre meme si je passe souvent pour un homme préhistorique a 38ans , je le prend avec le sourire
Child labor is a lot more complex. In Africa it's a survival issue. If you you lock the kids out of the mines, they will simply join criminal gangs or warlords as foot soldiers.
Если тратить деньги не на войны, не на вторжение во Вьетнам, Югославию, Сирию, Ливию, Ирак, Афганистан, не на спонсирование войны на ближнем Востоке между Израилем и арабскими странами, как это делают США всю свою историю. А например тратит деньги и ресурсы на образование, инфраструктурные проекты в той же Африке, на развитие производства или скажем местных силиконовых долин, может быть у этих детей появятся другие перспективы в жизни? Но чёрт возьми, корпорациям это не выгодно! Выгодны чёрные рабы в шахтах и рабы глупости с пластиковым гамбургером в зубах 🤮🤦♂️
А что если тратить деньги не на войну? Как это делают США всю свою историю, начиная от захвата Техаса, да что там, начиная от варварского геноцида коренных американцев, заканчивая Афганистаном. А тратит например на образование, инфраструктуру, сельское хозяйство и организацию производства в Африке. Как думаете, у этих детей появятся другие перспективы? Или вы не привыкли думать? А у меня есть такая дурная привычка - думать! И я уверяю вас - да, другие перспективы у детей появятся. Посмотрите на Бангалор, это силиконовая долина в нищей Индии. Но корпорациям это не выгодно! Им нужны рабы, одни добывающие руду в Африке, другие рабы глупости с пластмассовым бургером в зубах и Instagram в голове 🤮🤦♂️
Ancien... Mais toujours d'actualité. A savoir aussi qu'en Chine, la société s'est énormément endurcie niveau surveillance et crédit social, sans parler de l'expulsion des non-Chinois, tout cela rendant toute enquête impossible de nos jours.
Eu imagino que algumas famílias chinesas simplesmente não tem muita escolha, então seus adolescentes vão começar a trabalhar cedo para ajudar na renda familiar. A questão e ?que tipo de acoes podem forzar o governo a subsidiar programas de treinamento de jovens em que suas jornadas de trabalho não passem de 4 horas diárias para que possam estudar também no turno oposto?
je ne suis pas dans le coup! Je ne l'emporte jamais lorsque je sors et chez moi je ne le prends que quelques mn par jour pour me connecter sur X; je ne reste pas plus de 20mn en lecture. En fait je me suis toujours dis que ce n'est pas un téléphone qui va gérer mon temps et ma vie. Il est à mon service et non l'inverse.
Merci pour tout ça, les pays on un système qui abuse des faibles, il doivent bien payer les employés qui travaillent dans c'est entreprise, les enfants qui viennent travailler dans c'est entreprise doivent être suivie pour effectuer des petits tâches dans de bonnes conditions de travail, le monde de l'être humain s'éteind petit a petit, je souhaite le changement positif
Children are literally exploited, people are buried alive for amounts of money that couldn’t even pay for a meal a day where I live, and people are dying from cancer due to pollution. But sure, let’s focus on how illegal it is to film these atrocities from the violator’s perspective... It’s quite sad when that’s what someone chooses to focus on when they see this. To give you an actual answer, legalities vary across the world when it comes to journalism. Instead, you should ask why reporting the truth should be illegal in the first place. Should they schedule an appointment and film with consent, giving the factory enough time to hide what the rest of the world considers human rights violations-just so certain companies in some countries look better to the rest of the world? Journalism should be about reporting the truth. Imagine that the woman in the hospital is your mother, your aunt, or your daughter-dying from cancer because they were forced to drink polluted water for years. Now tell me you wouldn’t want everyone to know who is indirectly responsible because they are contributing to this kind of exploitation. I own a Samsung phone, an LG TV, and plenty of other electronics. I never even considered that these technologies and products are made possible through the suffering of others. After watching this, I feel ashamed that my purchases support these practices, while all you seem to feel is indignation that someone reported it to let others know where their money is going-or isn’t.
i hav reach to 3/4th of the video, and this is my comments, "its not the fault if the restaurant that cooks the meat and didnt know how the animal was slaughtered, or where it was farmed, its the name of the game, my question is,, shall we stop going high tech? we need to stop using smart fon to kill their bizniz, is that what this video about?😂😂😂 just asking😂😂😂
I really appreciate your efforts! Just a quick off-topic question: My OKX wallet holds some USDT, and I have the seed phrase. (alarm fetch churn bridge exercise tape speak race clerk couch crater letter). How should I go about transferring them to Binance?
I don't see what people get so carried away with this stupid technology. Little. kids look at my shape of powerful computer in my pocket. A bunch of toys
The governments of these factories take no responsibility to enforce the laws. They allow the factories to self govern. They aren’t randomly inspected. And if they are inspected they are notified in advance so they can hide any violations. I blame the governments for allowing this to occur and quite frankly they know it’s happening but don’t care enough to disrupt the flow of money into their countries.
This docu is from 2014. 10 years later nothing has changed except some of the phone assembly has moved from china to vietnam.
我来自中国，也在工厂工作过，这个纪录片至少是10年以前拍摄的。当年在中国有很多农村的孩子，初中没上完就辍学了，他们大多数都是选择去工厂打工赚钱。这也是很多人自愿的选择。确实也有很多企业违反法律偷偷的使用未成年人，但是不存在强迫。这种事虽然不好，但是这些孩子也从工厂赚到钱了，他们用这些钱也帮助了家人。在外国人看来这种事简直不可思议，但是在早些年这都是平常事。我自己十六七岁也在工地搬过砖去赚钱为自己去高中攒学费。
This is why it will always be a problem. And there will never be a solution. My kids legally started working at 14 in the US but not in dangerous jobs.
@@Doggiehoomanmomда, но нет никакой гарантии, что ваши внуки или правнуки не начнут работать в США с 12 лет и уже на опасных работах. Это произвол больших корпораций и больших денег. Этот произвол может остановить только сплочённая борьба трудящихся за свои права. Борьба, в короткой американскому рабочему ближе будет китайский рабочий, а не американская корпорация.
Вы же понимаете, что Китай тоже большой. Возможно в экономически развитых провинциях на восточном побережье ситуация сейчас улучшилась, но в том же Китае есть депрессивные западные регионы, где ситуация и сейчас ничуть не лучше, даже хуже, потому что на Востоке много производств, а в западных провинциях их очень мало. Такое впечатление, что вы воспринимаете фильм, как критику Китая, но это не так. Это критика безумной системы эксплуатации, где одни производят телефоны за миску риса в день на вредном производстве, а другие продают эти телефоны в СОТНИ РАЗ дороже себестоимости. Если это будут не китайские рабочие, а рабочие Бирмы или Вьетнама, ситуацию в целом это не меняет.
You're in a communist-type state are you not?
I'm wondering why you have to pay for your high-school education?
@@karengarrison3666 我不了解其他国家，你们那里上高中不需要交学费吗？
damn. props for this documentary. this, in my humble opinion, is real journalism!
This is old from 2013 . The Iphone 5S was released in 2013
Thank you very much for your hard work. I really appreciate your work. Salute
Now imagine the impact of EVs, which have thousands of such battery cells.
Just like anywhere , and it is not just these Chinese factories breaking labor laws and being corrupt . Don’t you know ? Are you not aware ? It is all about the MONEY - NOT if it is illegal / against labor law 😒
True, the same is everywhere, in the west as well, just more covered and not as harsh.
The only thing worse is what has happened to a generation of adults now who will never know how much better the world was without smartphones.its not good.
If you accept local laws (age, hours, environment, safety) to be broken elsewhere by having products made elsewhere your government facilitates just that yet not in your own country.
This exactly on how manufacture is dissapearing in the USA and EU.
Vielen Dank für diese wertvollen Informationen!
Best Doku,
This channel’s great
This poor people should live in luxury. The companies have to build machines to get the stuff. The Region must be well paid.
What year was this video documented?
Unglaublich in dieser Doku wurde das Galaxy S5 Handy präsentiert das erste Handy der Welt was eine sehr gute videoqualität hatte
The governments of these factories take no responsibility to enforce the laws. They allow the factories to self govern. They aren’t randomly inspected. And if they are inspected they are notified in advance so they can hide any violations. I blame the governments for allowing this to occur and quite frankly they know it’s happening but don’t care enough to disrupt the flow of money into their countries.
I love you all of ‘BEST DOCUMENTARY’ team.
j'en suis conscients depuis + de 15 ans, j'ai jamais eux de téléphone connecter a internet, j'ai tjs mon 3310 qui a 20ans, et je me rend compte, que de ne pas être connecté en dehors de chez soi, apporte bcps de bienêtre meme si je passe souvent pour un homme préhistorique a 38ans , je le prend avec le sourire
alors comment peut tu écrire se commentaire ici sur youtube ?
@valentin829 depuis un pc fixe
@valentin829 de mon pc
Well done here.
My fbi agent needs a raise🤜🤛 👀
😂
Bill only does medicines testing on these countries
27:23 Der Arzt fragt den Grubenarbeiter warum er in die Stollen geht ,
aber ein Handy in der Kittelbrusttasche .👍
History of cell phone
when did this air. this feel like 2012 ish?
2014
Child labor is a lot more complex. In Africa it's a survival issue. If you you lock the kids out of the mines, they will simply join criminal gangs or warlords as foot soldiers.
Thank you for pointing this out. This kind of sensationalist journalism makes me sick.
Если тратить деньги не на войны, не на вторжение во Вьетнам, Югославию, Сирию, Ливию, Ирак, Афганистан, не на спонсирование войны на ближнем Востоке между Израилем и арабскими странами, как это делают США всю свою историю. А например тратит деньги и ресурсы на образование, инфраструктурные проекты в той же Африке, на развитие производства или скажем местных силиконовых долин, может быть у этих детей появятся другие перспективы в жизни? Но чёрт возьми, корпорациям это не выгодно! Выгодны чёрные рабы в шахтах и рабы глупости с пластиковым гамбургером в зубах 🤮🤦♂️
А что если тратить деньги не на войну? Как это делают США всю свою историю, начиная от захвата Техаса, да что там, начиная от варварского геноцида коренных американцев, заканчивая Афганистаном. А тратит например на образование, инфраструктуру, сельское хозяйство и организацию производства в Африке. Как думаете, у этих детей появятся другие перспективы? Или вы не привыкли думать? А у меня есть такая дурная привычка - думать! И я уверяю вас - да, другие перспективы у детей появятся. Посмотрите на Бангалор, это силиконовая долина в нищей Индии. Но корпорациям это не выгодно! Им нужны рабы, одни добывающие руду в Африке, другие рабы глупости с пластмассовым бургером в зубах и Instagram в голове 🤮🤦♂️
Bravo! Brilliant research, love the substitute card coverage. Lives for profit, this is legal slavery, in disregard of us humans. Thank you.
iPhone 5? How old is this?
See whenever the iPhone 5 came out.. That's the year this came out.
Poor detective work.
The video recording is very graphic.
Ancien... Mais toujours d'actualité. A savoir aussi qu'en Chine, la société s'est énormément endurcie niveau surveillance et crédit social, sans parler de l'expulsion des non-Chinois, tout cela rendant toute enquête impossible de nos jours.
what about Apple? they were never mentioned in he documentary.
Did you watch?
@ they were mentioned once during the very end. But I’m curious as to whether my iPhone is made my child laborers overseas making close to nothing.
Eu imagino que algumas famílias chinesas simplesmente não tem muita escolha, então seus adolescentes vão começar a trabalhar cedo para ajudar na renda familiar. A questão e ?que tipo de acoes podem forzar o governo a subsidiar programas de treinamento de jovens em que suas jornadas de trabalho não passem de 4 horas diárias para que possam estudar também no turno oposto?
Which is why making better matters
Blocking the chinese and french translations with the last english words spoken, translated into english. Why?
You are pronouncing Huawei incorrectly
Thanks for sharing your very helpful review of the phone. Wish you good health and good luck.
Talking about iPhone 5? Time stamp on this video is 3 days ago! For me today December 28 2024
I apologize to the person who has to translate my data!
:)
This is what modern slavery and the poverty of workers looks like...Masters make billions in profits😢
Everyone was worried about a chip being installed in us humans well you are holding yours in your hands
Porque no esta en español?
Moi je regarde plus que ça. Toutes les secondes 😂
je ne suis pas dans le coup! Je ne l'emporte jamais lorsque je sors et chez moi je ne le prends que quelques mn par jour pour me connecter sur X; je ne reste pas plus de 20mn en lecture. En fait je me suis toujours dis que ce n'est pas un téléphone qui va gérer mon temps et ma vie. Il est à mon service et non l'inverse.
Wow I feel guilty bec I always have my phone. It’s like an addiction.
24:09
sir excellent investigative report .kudos to you
Merci pour tout ça, les pays on un système qui abuse des faibles, il doivent bien payer les employés qui travaillent dans c'est entreprise, les enfants qui viennent travailler dans c'est entreprise doivent être suivie pour effectuer des petits tâches dans de bonnes conditions de travail, le monde de l'être humain s'éteind petit a petit, je souhaite le changement positif
그리고 불법 불법 하면서 채널에서는 왜 공장 불법 촬영을 했을까? 니가 촬영 하면 합법 타인이 하면 불법 이니??
Children are literally exploited, people are buried alive for amounts of money that couldn’t even pay for a meal a day where I live, and people are dying from cancer due to pollution. But sure, let’s focus on how illegal it is to film these atrocities from the violator’s perspective... It’s quite sad when that’s what someone chooses to focus on when they see this.
To give you an actual answer, legalities vary across the world when it comes to journalism. Instead, you should ask why reporting the truth should be illegal in the first place. Should they schedule an appointment and film with consent, giving the factory enough time to hide what the rest of the world considers human rights violations-just so certain companies in some countries look better to the rest of the world? Journalism should be about reporting the truth.
Imagine that the woman in the hospital is your mother, your aunt, or your daughter-dying from cancer because they were forced to drink polluted water for years. Now tell me you wouldn’t want everyone to know who is indirectly responsible because they are contributing to this kind of exploitation.
I own a Samsung phone, an LG TV, and plenty of other electronics. I never even considered that these technologies and products are made possible through the suffering of others. After watching this, I feel ashamed that my purchases support these practices, while all you seem to feel is indignation that someone reported it to let others know where their money is going-or isn’t.
THAT EXACTLY WHY I HAVE A DUMBPHONE. IT HAS ONLY CLEAN SECRETS.
Capitalism in its truest colors
J AI HONTE DE MOI ET DE MA FRANCE ( QUI M INONDE DE CES M... ) D AVOIR ACHETER CES WIKO ET TEENO QUI MARCHENT MEME PAS VLA L ARNAQUE
Bill Gates :(
i hav reach to 3/4th of the video, and this is my comments,
"its not the fault if the restaurant that cooks the meat and didnt know how the animal was slaughtered, or where it was farmed, its the name of the game,
my question is,, shall we stop going high tech?
we need to stop using smart fon to kill their bizniz, is that what this video about?😂😂😂 just asking😂😂😂
I really appreciate your efforts! Just a quick off-topic question: My OKX wallet holds some USDT, and I have the seed phrase. (alarm fetch churn bridge exercise tape speak race clerk couch crater letter). How should I go about transferring them to Binance?
Capitalism!🥲
I’m from Russia
Je ne vois pas où est le problème moi j'ai bien commencé le travail à 13 ans et pourtant je travaillais en France
Слава России 🇷🇺
S
L
A
V
E
S
I don't see what people get so carried away with this stupid technology. Little. kids look at my shape of powerful computer in my pocket. A bunch of toys
wow
Its pronounced wa way
Is this what came to mind for you? Nothing else?
@nt9389 👍👍
The governments of these factories take no responsibility to enforce the laws. They allow the factories to self govern. They aren’t randomly inspected. And if they are inspected they are notified in advance so they can hide any violations. I blame the governments for allowing this to occur and quite frankly they know it’s happening but don’t care enough to disrupt the flow of money into their countries.