I think that Efie would try to help the tributes but would eventually would get caught up in whatever she was doing. However I think the capital would provide a “mentor” for the tributes if they had no victor
Marciana Perry Yeah i haven’t read the books yet but i know some mentors like Snow who mentored Lucy Gray and then Arachne who sponsored Bradey and also get killed by Bradey and I have to say Bradey is such a savage for killing her mentor
Katniss didn't really need sponsors. The only time she was ever in need for a sponsor was for peeta (blood poisoning). Katniss is very resilent and is able to hunt really well. Finding food in the woods is the least of katniss's problems as she is very good at hunting. Some may say that katniss is better fed when she's in the arena rather than when shes at home (district 12). This is because, although the peacekeepers turn a blind eye about katniss going to the woods, she still has to make sure that she doesn't over stay her welcome in the woods, as she could be caught by the capital as hunting in the woods is illegal and is punishable by being turned into an avox. Katniss is able to live in the woods for years on end without a problem. Remember in catching fire (the book), katniss even thought about running away to the woods with her family, peeta ,gale and haymitch and had stated that she could survive in the woods for years on end as finding food would not be a problem as she is very familar with the woods and can hunt extremely well. As well as this, what i meant by katniss being resilent is that as well as hunting, katniss is very knowledgeable about plants as she would know which ones are poisonouse and which ones are safe to eat. In terms of resilence, the biggest killer a tribute can face in the arena is infection. Katniss having a mum that deals with medical problems on a daily for example, treating wounds and injuries has probably picked up on ways of preventing infection. If katniss was to ever get injured in the arena she would know how to prevent an infection. In conclusion, i think katniss would have still survived even without any sponsors. Like mentioned in the other videos "the odds were in katniss's favour" as the arena was the "woods" something that katniss is more than familar with as she spent most of her life hunting and being around nature. Yes, you could argue that the sponsors did make katniss's life easier in the arena but she would have still survived regardless of sponsors.
It depends on how she won it. If she used the same method of Haymitch the same would have happened to her family. But if she won it the traditional way.. idk
Than for the third quarter quell, Katniss or Maysilee would have to go in, but Peeta would be no exception as he's the only male living district 12 victor. But based off how Katniss and Maysilee had a sibling they'd do anything to protect, both of them probably wouldn't volunteer for the other for very selfish reasons. But that's more directed to Maysilee as now she and her sister are grown women now and Katniss is relatively young and doesn't deserve to endure the harsh reality of the dystopian world they live in.
@@lovelykitty42 what Maysilee could do is use the poison from her darts to taint the blade of the deceased Haymitch's knife with the lethal substance against the district 1 female he originally fought. Because she was a formidable opponent who almost defeated Haymitch if he wasn't smart to weaponize the forcefield against her. Because if anyone read Catching Fire, the dialogue described her as "being bigger than Haymitch, and just as fast". Plus even though Haymitch dealt heavy damage on her with his knife, the district 1 female almost disembowel him as an axe is a superior weapon to a knife. So with the poisoned knife, all Maysilee has to do is be fast enough to dodge the attacks of her larger and more menacing career counterpart, and get one clean cut and let the poison do its work the same way it did when she saved Haymitch from the district 1 or 2 boy who almost killed him. And based off how smart she was to use the resources of a deadly arena to her advantage, Maysilee would've most likely done what I just said.
This theory could also become a several part series if you wanted considering there are many factors as to what could happen. Like the fact that Maysilee was the original owner of the Mockingjay pin so Katniss might not have had it as a token. There’s just a lot that could happen because Maysilee’s death impacted Mrs Everdeen and Mrs Undersee greatly.
I’d like to know what would happen if glimmer never got stung to death. cuz thinking about it, it would change the whole franchise as katniss wouldn’t get her bow, possibly meaning she would die
She could possibly build her own bow as Gale said earlier. Katniss is smart and probably would’ve found another way. Even if she didn’t die, she would still be effected by the venom.
Artsicorn in the hunger games, she was mostly running for her life, but that really is a good question. Maybe, we can ask her to do a video on why Katniss didn’t make her own weapon
I mean they had Haymitch who drank more alcohol then water so not much of a downgrade (I know he gets better later on but still not that great (even though he does get some sponsors for Katniss and Peeta))
@@Darbie911 Yeah, I think that if Katniss had shot Seneca, Snow would have made her pedestal explode. Or if they decide not to do that, then they would definitely torture that tribute in the arena. Either way, they definitely wouldn't win the games...
PhoenixSword24 In the new prequel book it brings up the answer to op question not with a game maker but it gives a good example of what happens to any tribute the hurts a capital citizen or try’s to escape. It’s a good book almost finished it.
She would be made an example of. When the countdown to the games start, her tracker would detonate and kill her. They would say that the capital knows everything or explain slightly what happened
I love that you still do hunger games theories !! Yesterday my sister bought me a birthday present, ‘the ballad of songbirds and snakes’ and I’m so excited reading it!! Love your make up, too! ❤️💙
I have a video idea, what If Wiress had survived the 75th games, honestly having a resurgence of a hunger games phase after reading the newest book and I've been binging these.
I feel like there would be some sort of system in place, so that if the tribute didn’t have a mentor, they could still be sponsored in the arena, and gent sent things. The Capitol citizens love sponsoring tributes, so it’s hard to imagine they’d be denied that because the tribute had no mentor. Just an idea though.
Thanks for another good vid 🙂 I've wondered this as well. Firstly, Effie being a mentor deserves its own spin-off. Secondly, I think that in the games straight after the 10th, where most districts didn't have victors, The Capitol would have appointed (strong/athletic/skilled/wise/mix of these) citizens of The Capitol to act as mentors. Maybe they would get a reward (financial or otherwise) if their tribute won?
That's a film only question. In the books Marvel did not throw any spear. Also Katniss could not embrace Rue before Rue got stabbed, because Marvel stabbed (not throwing) the spear in Rue's stomach seconds before Katniss arrived in the clearing , I think because he heard Katniss coming, thought he had time enough and decided he did not need Rue to be longer alive. Marvel had not even time to pull the spear back before Katniss' arrow pentrated his throat (not his chest is in the film).
I feel if there was a tribute with no mentor they would just be told “it’s your problem, you have to find out for your self how your gonna survive” and then it’d be down to the tributes to decide if they gonna go to the escort, try and make friends with other tributes and try and get tips from them or whatever 😊
I would think that either the Capitol would give them a Mentor. Kind of like in court if a person doesn't have a lawyer, the court will appoint one for them. Or maybe each district has people who are not Victors but will volunteer as a Mentor. It couldn't be anyone with a connection to either tribute though. Maybe a council member or mayor or school headteacher or something. I think that a Mentor would be more likely to be from the Capitol though.
@@StoryDiver Imagine being reaped, but your older brother/sister volunteers for you (most likely dying) only for you to be reaped again a year or two later... That would just suck.
Prim didn’t seem too worried about being reaped for the Quarter Quell so I reckon you can avoid it. But district 1 and 2 would go through the kids pretty quickly because there are so many volunteers.
Well we know that district 12 didnt have a mentor until atleast the 25th I believe since they say the other district victor was dead by the time of the 74th games. So I believe that between when mentors was introduced and the 1st district 12 victor. The district 12 tributes would proboly not have mentors. Also I wont go into spoilers for the new book since I know theres some stuff in there which might contradict what I said. :P
@Sky i know your trying to help but you shouldn't spoil the book. Since not everyone has read it. people like TPWDS havnt read or are currently reading it. Just please dont spoil the new book until it is no longer new.
I feel like for show the capitol would want each district to have at least one mentor, so if there was a district without one, I could see them low key manipulating the games so a tribute from that district wins. Not because they care for the tributes or districts, but because the games are a television show and they want good ratings. It would just be a bad look if a district didn’t have a mentor.
I think Effie would have tried her best to get sponsors for them but since she doesn't know district 12 very well, she probably wouldn't been as effective as Haymitch. She may have gotten some if not any. However she would have been able to train them to present themselves very well for the cameras and may gain more sponsors that way and may out last their competitors. But that isnt enough to have survive their hunger games since what happened in the games towards the end
She cant do a video of it cause all that would of happened was she would die and the Rebellion would not happen. It would be too short plus everyone kinda already knows the answer.
I think a possible solution is they would get a mentor from another district but I think what they would really do is just, don’t care! Like you said The capitole’s mentality would probably be « They never won, well they deal with it! » And here is a video idea: What if Katniss allied with Foxeface instead of Rue? I don’t know if you already did it but if not, well there you go! Btw I LOVE your videos they are really great!
A big part of the mentor´s advice for Katniss and Peeta was outdoor living and avoiding getting tangled up in the first big fight at the beginning of the contest. Effie would not have a personal experience there. Dive safely, and never dive without a buddy.
Yoru vides are amazing I would love a shoutout in your next video and I bought your Kerch it’s so well made and comfortable I love your background and I hope 🤞🏼 you make more Merch soon
Mel Altman I don’t get what you said „he took Finnick‘s death and Finnick survived?“ 😂 and how could the dude that was killed by Peeta survive? You could literally still see his corpse a few minutes later
Jaden Moore same, he’s one of my favs, too! I cried so much when he died, especially because his death was so „fast“. Like you didn’t really get the time to say goodbye :(
WOW Yoo actually made the video! I haven't been on yt for a while so I just saw the vid, Thanks for actually making it and answering my question. That's soo cool. Also very well thought through answer, haven't seen this topic in that light before. And I'm still loving the lipstick!
I’m certain at this point that no one has dived into this series as much as you have. You’ll keep interest in this series alive for a long time. If they ever reboot this series they absolutely need to bring you on as an advisor.
So this is only possible if the district at the very least had 1 victor already, but my idea is that the victors could write a memoire/diary/textbook (something like that) and fill it with tips and tricks, things they learned. Basically a 'how to survive the hunger games (or how to increase the chance of survival)' book. And this would be given to the tributes if the only victor of their district has died/no victor remains.
Thank you!! I just realised that some people could possibly be illiterate/ or just can't read well so instead of writing a book they could also just make a video or record something for future tributes.
Congrats on 16k Jess!! I think if Effie were to be the mentor for Katniss and Peeta, she would help them a lot since she sees an opportunity for herself to be promoted, and with one of the two winning, it would make her more popular in the eyes of the Capitol
Great video! Love these hunger games videos! I have a book series that I thought you might like, the book series is Keeper of The Lost Cities by Shannon Messenger. I think the book series would make some interesting videos too. There are 8 books and have another one coming out next year, they are fantasy. This is just a suggestion I thought you might want to look into. I hope you like them! I love your channel, keep up the great work!❤️
In the first hunger games Katniss and peeta did an act of rebellion by almost eating the berries. Later Haymitch talks to Katniss and tells her that snow didn’t like that. Why didn’t Katniss/peeta’s family get punished like Haymitch’s?
Probably because Snow realised it's more effective to keep the family alive and have that threat hanging over the victor's head. He couldn't force Haymitch or Johanna into anything anymore because they didn't have any loved ones left, which is a waste of a victor for him (especially with Haymitch being a Quarter Quell victor).
😱 oh my ik u might not remember but a few months ago I requested a theory about if a tribute didn’t have a mentor . Wow this is amazing ilysm. Ur channel is amazing I do agree that if the tributes didn’t have a mentor that it would be an escort
We certainly see that Effie can rise to the occasion later when she finds herself in District 13. I believe that if Effie had to fill in the mentor role, it would have been fine as she does demonstrate at least some level of care, even if that care is about getting a victor to get promoted. In fact, being in that mentor role might kickstart her character arc earlier in the story as she would have that extra responsibility and connection as well as the feeling of loss as she would have been the mentor to the tributes before Katniss and Peeta. But maybe that's me having too much faith in the humanity of the Capitolites.
Could you do a video on how sponsoring works? I have some questions. 1. How do they tell the gamemakers that they want to send a gift? 2. Do they choose what to send in? 3. Where did a capitol citizen get a trident, a huge weapon?
*Heres some ideas! -What if Peeta has died with the careers in the first games? -What if there wasn’t a bow and arrow in the arena? -What if Prim had survived? -What if Katniss died in the 75th hunger games before she could’ve been rescued? -What if Peeta had died when he hit the force field, how would it affect katniss? -What if Katniss ended up with Gale instead of Peeta? -What if Peetas hijacking couldn’t be reversed? -What if Maysilee won the 50th Hunger Games instead of Haymitch? -What if Katniss had killed a game maker when shooting for the apple? -What if Katniss and Peeta did fight as the final two when the announcement allowing one victor was made? -Why was Katniss skill with a bow and arrow not questioned when a girl from district 12 shouldn’t have been able to acquire a skill like that? -What if Katniss didn’t have a special skill (Like other district 12 tributes)? Love your videos btw!!* 💞💕
I think they’d use another victor from a different district. Like if Haymitch died, maybe Annie could’ve mentored Katniss and Peeta since Mags and Finnick were mentoring instead..?
I've always been confused (since we get Katniss' POV and 12 only has ONE mentor) if each tribute gets a mentor or if the district pair shares one (like Katniss and Peeta 'shared' Haymitch'). Either way, I always interpreted it as random Victors would be sent to mentor districts that were lacking but they were almost always weaker Victors to begin with. So Victors like Brutus, Enobaria, Cashmere, Finnick, or Gloss would definitely stay in their district. But some lesser-known or less impressive (most Career) Victors would be rotated to districts with no Victors until it finally happened. That way, there's incentive for those mentors (they only get to go home and 'retire' if they succeed), Snow gets to keep hope alive in all districts to stay in power, AND all districts eventually do get a victor (at least one of each sex, no less).
I think the escort would work really hard just so there can be a new victor in the district and so they could be relieved from doing the mentor's job, otherwise they would have to do the same task every year. Also I think if a escort managed to have a victor without a real mentor it would make them pretty famous in the capitol (if Snow allows it).
I don't know if Thresh and Rue got very many sponsors (other than the bread), so if you are smart and strong like they are, you could make it pretty far with allies if you have no mentor. However, I don't think that some of the richer district tributes like Cato wouldn't make it that far, because he's not very smart. Just what I think though, feel free to comment you opinions!
Hey I love your videos!!! And I was wondering, since we only got the games from the POV from Katniss, a non-career, and we see careers from her point of view, do you think you could do a video on the games of a careers point of view? And how they viewed her?
Hey, I also have two topics: What if one of the rebels who helped Katniss escape the arena betrayed them. (What if Johanna killed Katniss for example) I just forgot the other one but if I remember it I’ll comment it on this comment
Ik u talked about how the rig the games so maybe they rig is so that every district will have a mentor. How they can do that is by rigging the other districts so that they have less strong or smart ppl. So then the district they are trying to get to win has more odds to win. Bc they only would have to worry about district 1,2,4. Just a theory but it might be true seeing as every district has at least one mentor.
that theory is very likely, but i think that since the capitol doesn't care about the tributes, they would have capitol citizens who are honor role students or just very good ones, and the tirbutes would have to make the capitol citizens like them.
I iften wondered this on: what would have happened if Peeta had died before Katniss had reached him? Or similar ideas, because then Haymitch would be in the arena and there would be no mentor.
Can u maybe make a video on what happened to the rest of north america after the war? even though most of panem was turned into a district, if u look at a map of panem, a lot of it (especially in Canada, were not in fact turned into a district. I dont know weather they got bombed or maybe there are still people living there or maybe they rounded everyone up from around there and put them districts? Idk, just seems like an interesting subject.
I think that if there was no mentor, maybe another district with over two mentors could chose to help the other tributes without a mentor. Maybe they wouldn't have to or be able to, but I still find that an interesting idea.
I think that Efie would try to help the tributes but would eventually would get caught up in whatever she was doing. However I think the capital would provide a “mentor” for the tributes if they had no victor
Thanks Jess 😉
I think this is most probable- kinda like what they did in the ballad of songbirds and snakes a provide a 'mentor' from the Capitol
I'm writing a fanfiction where this is the case, a new Victor from district 10 is sent to mentor district 11 since they didn't have one of their own
Marciana Perry Yeah i haven’t read the books yet but i know some mentors like Snow who mentored Lucy Gray and then Arachne who sponsored Bradey and also get killed by Bradey and I have to say Bradey is such a savage for killing her mentor
I would like to know “What if a Game maker dies between the Games”. Also, absolutely love your videos!
I'll look into it! Though I'll probably focus on the head gamemaker, as the others would likely just be replaced
@@StoryDiver what if the head game maker dies?
Didn’t this happen between 74 and 75? They just replace them
Slytherin Pride it does
I think they mean if they died right before or while the games are happening
What if katness didn’t have a score of 11 and didn’t get sponsores
I'll look into it!
She would've died lmao💀
Katniss*
Katniss didn't really need sponsors. The only time she was ever in need for a sponsor was for peeta (blood poisoning). Katniss is very resilent and is able to hunt really well. Finding food in the woods is the least of katniss's problems as she is very good at hunting. Some may say that katniss is better fed when she's in the arena rather than when shes at home (district 12). This is because, although the peacekeepers turn a blind eye about katniss going to the woods, she still has to make sure that she doesn't over stay her welcome in the woods, as she could be caught by the capital as hunting in the woods is illegal and is punishable by being turned into an avox. Katniss is able to live in the woods for years on end without a problem. Remember in catching fire (the book), katniss even thought about running away to the woods with her family, peeta ,gale and haymitch and had stated that she could survive in the woods for years on end as finding food would not be a problem as she is very familar with the woods and can hunt extremely well. As well as this, what i meant by katniss being resilent is that as well as hunting, katniss is very knowledgeable about plants as she would know which ones are poisonouse and which ones are safe to eat. In terms of resilence, the biggest killer a tribute can face in the arena is infection. Katniss having a mum that deals with medical problems on a daily for example, treating wounds and injuries has probably picked up on ways of preventing infection. If katniss was to ever get injured in the arena she would know how to prevent an infection.
In conclusion, i think katniss would have still survived even without any sponsors. Like mentioned in the other videos "the odds were in katniss's favour" as the arena was the "woods" something that katniss is more than familar with as she spent most of her life hunting and being around nature. Yes, you could argue that the sponsors did make katniss's life easier in the arena but she would have still survived regardless of sponsors.
shahzeb aslam u do realise no ones gonna read all that right
If you want, here’s a decent idea for a video:
What if Maysilee won the 2nd Quarter Quell and Haymitch was the one to be killed by the mutts?
It depends on how she won it. If she used the same method of Haymitch the same would have happened to her family. But if she won it the traditional way.. idk
Than for the third quarter quell, Katniss or Maysilee would have to go in, but Peeta would be no exception as he's the only male living district 12 victor. But based off how Katniss and Maysilee had a sibling they'd do anything to protect, both of them probably wouldn't volunteer for the other for very selfish reasons. But that's more directed to Maysilee as now she and her sister are grown women now and Katniss is relatively young and doesn't deserve to endure the harsh reality of the dystopian world they live in.
@@lovelykitty42 what Maysilee could do is use the poison from her darts to taint the blade of the deceased Haymitch's knife with the lethal substance against the district 1 female he originally fought. Because she was a formidable opponent who almost defeated Haymitch if he wasn't smart to weaponize the forcefield against her. Because if anyone read Catching Fire, the dialogue described her as "being bigger than Haymitch, and just as fast". Plus even though Haymitch dealt heavy damage on her with his knife, the district 1 female almost disembowel him as an axe is a superior weapon to a knife. So with the poisoned knife, all Maysilee has to do is be fast enough to dodge the attacks of her larger and more menacing career counterpart, and get one clean cut and let the poison do its work the same way it did when she saved Haymitch from the district 1 or 2 boy who almost killed him. And based off how smart she was to use the resources of a deadly arena to her advantage, Maysilee would've most likely done what I just said.
I’d love to see a dive on this!!
This theory could also become a several part series if you wanted considering there are many factors as to what could happen. Like the fact that Maysilee was the original owner of the Mockingjay pin so Katniss might not have had it as a token. There’s just a lot that could happen because Maysilee’s death impacted Mrs Everdeen and Mrs Undersee greatly.
Can you do one for:
What if Katniss and Gale ran away to the woods like they said they would.
And I'm loving your videos lately.
YES PLEASE
Thank you! I'll look into it!
Great idea.
What if Peeta has successfully strangled Katniss?
Prim would go in
I’d like to know what would happen if glimmer never got stung to death. cuz thinking about it, it would change the whole franchise as katniss wouldn’t get her bow, possibly meaning she would die
She could possibly build her own bow as Gale said earlier. Katniss is smart and probably would’ve found another way. Even if she didn’t die, she would still be effected by the venom.
Abby Anime Lover but wouldn’t t she make one earlyer??
Artsicorn in the hunger games, she was mostly running for her life, but that really is a good question. Maybe, we can ask her to do a video on why Katniss didn’t make her own weapon
I love Effie, but imagine having to rely on her as a mentor.
I would've been like "okay. My times come. I'm dead. Make my funeral fabulous, Effie."
All she would say be "May the odds evaa be in your favour!"
Michelle Ng evaa*
@@rayanbari3468 ok I change
I mean they had Haymitch who drank more alcohol then water so not much of a downgrade (I know he gets better later on but still not that great (even though he does get some sponsors for Katniss and Peeta))
Can you do
If Peeta actually strangled Katniss?
Or
If Katniss got captured by the Capitol and Peeta got rescued by 13?
what if a tribute killed a gamemaker? (Katniss Misses her shot of the apple killing Seneca?)
I'll look into it!
I think they would most likely get killed or severely punished for it.
@@Darbie911 Yeah, I think that if Katniss had shot Seneca, Snow would have made her pedestal explode. Or if they decide not to do that, then they would definitely torture that tribute in the arena. Either way, they definitely wouldn't win the games...
PhoenixSword24 In the new prequel book it brings up the answer to op question not with a game maker but it gives a good example of what happens to any tribute the hurts a capital citizen or try’s to escape. It’s a good book almost finished it.
She would be made an example of. When the countdown to the games start, her tracker would detonate and kill her. They would say that the capital knows everything or explain slightly what happened
I love that you still do hunger games theories !! Yesterday my sister bought me a birthday present, ‘the ballad of songbirds and snakes’ and I’m so excited reading it!! Love your make up, too! ❤️💙
Happy birthday!
Story Diver thank you my dear 🥺❤️
What did you think of it? I personally loved seeing a fresh perspective! Also happy late birthday
Lex Quinn yeah Me too, it was so interesting!! Loved it ❤️ and thank you 🤍🖤
I have a video idea, what If Wiress had survived the 75th games, honestly having a resurgence of a hunger games phase after reading the newest book and I've been binging these.
I'll look into it!
*Imagine Effie being their mentor😂😂*
May the odds be evaa in your favor
She would be terrible lmao
That one dislike is president snow
Yes. Yes it is.
ofc it is
And the second one is from President Alma Coin
Wait. President Snow is dead-
@@clem_b00ks it is
I feel like there would be some sort of system in place, so that if the tribute didn’t have a mentor, they could still be sponsored in the arena, and gent sent things. The Capitol citizens love sponsoring tributes, so it’s hard to imagine they’d be denied that because the tribute had no mentor. Just an idea though.
I've been curious about this for a while... You've done a great job explaining this
Thank you!
Me too.
Thanks for another good vid 🙂 I've wondered this as well. Firstly, Effie being a mentor deserves its own spin-off. Secondly, I think that in the games straight after the 10th, where most districts didn't have victors, The Capitol would have appointed (strong/athletic/skilled/wise/mix of these) citizens of The Capitol to act as mentors. Maybe they would get a reward (financial or otherwise) if their tribute won?
Omg it’s u I love your tales of the hunger games videos
Hi Christian
What if no one would get children anymore, just like Katniss who didn’t want to have kids at first?
They would probably reap the adults.
Yeah like a rebellion but they couldnt punish them as it isn't against the law
Forced birth, obviously
Hi! I have a video idea for you,
What if marvel Didn’t miss Katniss when he threw his spear?
I'll look into it!
That would be a great video
Katniss would have died.
River Games we’re dealing with a genius!
That's a film only question. In the books Marvel did not throw any spear.
Also Katniss could not embrace Rue before Rue got stabbed, because Marvel stabbed (not throwing) the spear in Rue's stomach seconds before Katniss arrived in the clearing , I think because he heard Katniss coming, thought he had time enough and decided he did not need Rue to be longer alive.
Marvel had not even time to pull the spear back before Katniss' arrow pentrated his throat (not his chest is in the film).
Hi i have a video idea: (you dont have to do it)
Why did no one volunteer for rue if they all loved her so much in D11?
They didn't love Rue more than any other child. Her death is what moved people
@@StoryDiver It’s sad really, people only valued her life once it was over :(
TPWDS sad reality of life☹️
TPWDS you guys r really asking 14, 15, 16 yrs olds etc, to sacrifice their life for others, when they are all children too
Maybe they felt she had a chance They just hoped she would make it out
I feel if there was a tribute with no mentor they would just be told “it’s your problem, you have to find out for your self how your gonna survive” and then it’d be down to the tributes to decide if they gonna go to the escort, try and make friends with other tributes and try and get tips from them or whatever 😊
It is a very good book
I would think that either the Capitol would give them a Mentor. Kind of like in court if a person doesn't have a lawyer, the court will appoint one for them. Or maybe each district has people who are not Victors but will volunteer as a Mentor. It couldn't be anyone with a connection to either tribute though. Maybe a council member or mayor or school headteacher or something. I think that a Mentor would be more likely to be from the Capitol though.
Likely someone from the Capitol. They did that in Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes. The first Mentors were Capitol citizens after all.
@@josheydubs snow was a mentor
I always thought that they pulled Victors from other districts, because the capital wants the best show and like 1,2 and 4 have excess
I just got the Hunger Games, Catching Fire, and Mockingjay books. I'm so excited
I have a question, when a tribute is volunteered for, can they be reaped next year again or are they out of the bowl?
The only way you are safe from the reaping is bring older than 18, or being a victor
@@StoryDiver Imagine being reaped, but your older brother/sister volunteers for you (most likely dying) only for you to be reaped again a year or two later...
That would just suck.
PhoenixSword24 I agree, but more than likely it’s already happened.
Prim didn’t seem too worried about being reaped for the Quarter Quell so I reckon you can avoid it. But district 1 and 2 would go through the kids pretty quickly because there are so many volunteers.
ES Mockingjay Prim wasn’t worried because she wasn’t eligible for it...
Bro I’ve been looking for your channel for MONTHS... I just kept googling “happy bubbles book review” 😭😭 this is the best day ever!
I'm happy you find it!
I have a question, does anyone know Mrs Everdeens real name?
It’s not canonical, but a lot of fans say her name is Marigold. However, Collins never explicitly states her name so there is no canon name for her.
She isn't named
I think she's just referred to as mother/mom or ms everdeen
Just finished re-reading the hunger games! Loved the video 😀
Thank you!
Greetings and salutations fellow humans
Tysm for doing my idea
YOUR HAIR IS AMAZINGGGGGGGGG !!!!!!!!
Thank you!
I’m rereading the Hunger Games trilogy because every time I watch your videos , I yearn for the books. I love this channel
Well we know that district 12 didnt have a mentor until atleast the 25th I believe since they say the other district victor was dead by the time of the 74th games.
So I believe that between when mentors was introduced and the 1st district 12 victor. The district 12 tributes would proboly not have mentors.
Also I wont go into spoilers for the new book since I know theres some stuff in there which might contradict what I said. :P
@Sky they literally said they wont put spoilers even though they prove a different point, please read the full comment
Sky they literally just said they didn’t want spoilers
@Sky Oh thanks a lot, I’m guessing it’s Lucy Gray? I’ll just chuck the book I’m midway through straight out the window
@Sky i know your trying to help but you shouldn't spoil the book. Since not everyone has read it.
people like TPWDS havnt read or are currently reading it. Just please dont spoil the new book until it is no longer new.
@Sky Maxwell Huh? What new HG book? How could I have not heard of this?
You should do a spotlight on the different districts! Talk about each districts' industry and maybe about the districts victors! Love your videos! ❤
I can’t imagine the hunger games without Haymitch lmao
I feel like for show the capitol would want each district to have at least one mentor, so if there was a district without one, I could see them low key manipulating the games so a tribute from that district wins. Not because they care for the tributes or districts, but because the games are a television show and they want good ratings. It would just be a bad look if a district didn’t have a mentor.
Honestly Effie was almost like a mentor because haymitch was hardly sober
You should do a video of “What if a Pandemic Happened in Panem” thats a lot to ask for but it would be a great vid just like the rest!
She’s done one about district 13’s small pox outbreak.Not sure if that’s “tIcKlEs YoUr fAnCy”
Rayan Bari yes but i feel like she would do a great job with with a vid about Panem going through what we are right now
I think Effie would have tried her best to get sponsors for them but since she doesn't know district 12 very well, she probably wouldn't been as effective as Haymitch. She may have gotten some if not any. However she would have been able to train them to present themselves very well for the cameras and may gain more sponsors that way and may out last their competitors. But that isnt enough to have survive their hunger games since what happened in the games towards the end
You are honestly so underrated. Love your vids! ❤️
Thank you so much!!
It’s great to see that you’re finally getting the attention you deserve! Great video as always. :)
Thank you so much 😀
“Acually be your happy self-“ this is so Effie if it isn’t Effie than Haymitch doesn’t drink.
I love your channel thanks for making these awesome vids I absolutely love your channel and the hunger games!
Thank you!
OMG I REMEMBER MENTIONING THIS IN THE LIVE CHAT ON YOUR LIVE STREAM! I'VE ALWAYS WONDERED ABOUT THIS! THANK YOUUUUUUUUUUUU SOOOOOO MUCH !!!!!!!!!!!!!
I’m not going to say what they would do because it would spoil part of The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes which would be rude
Thank you for being considerate!
Probably just a left over victor from a career district
You should do what if thresh never saved Katniss from clove at the feast
Your vids put everything in hunger games in prospective ❤️❤️
She cant do a video of it cause all that would of happened was she would die and the Rebellion would not happen. It would be too short plus everyone kinda already knows the answer.
I know but who would win and would the rebellion still happen but I get what your saying
I think a possible solution is they would get a mentor from another district but I think what they would really do is just, don’t care! Like you said The capitole’s mentality would probably be « They never won, well they deal with it! » And here is a video idea: What if Katniss allied with Foxeface instead of Rue? I don’t know if you already did it but if not, well there you go! Btw I LOVE your videos they are really great!
Love your hunger games series. You are so well researched and your theories are very interesting
I love your videos. They always make me take a deeper look at all of my favorite books.
Ps I also love your lipstick
Thank you!
A big part of the mentor´s advice for Katniss and Peeta was outdoor living and avoiding getting tangled up in the first big fight at the beginning of the contest. Effie would not have a personal experience there. Dive safely, and never dive without a buddy.
Yoru vides are amazing I would love a shoutout in your next video and I bought your Kerch it’s so well made and comfortable I love your background and I hope 🤞🏼 you make more Merch soon
Love ur unique style Jess u look great!
The capitol would probably just go: you ain't gettin' a mentor. MAY THE ODDS EVAAA BE IN YOUR FAVOUR
Would you ever make a video listing what weapons would be the best/worst in the games !!! Love your content 💕
I'm loving this videos, great job!
Thank you so much!!
Spoiler for book 3:
Could you do a „what if Finnick was still alive“ 😭😭
Mel Altman Whut?
Maggie T wut-
Mel Altman I don’t get what you said „he took Finnick‘s death and Finnick survived?“ 😂 and how could the dude that was killed by Peeta survive? You could literally still see his corpse a few minutes later
Jaden Moore same, he’s one of my favs, too! I cried so much when he died, especially because his death was so „fast“. Like you didn’t really get the time to say goodbye :(
Maggie T no- wait nvm I don’t feel like explaining lol uhm forget what I said ima delete that comment XD
What if the winners didn't go back to the arena in the second book?
ShadowWolf then they couldn’t kill Katniss which makes the Capitol especially President Snow scared.
WOW Yoo actually made the video!
I haven't been on yt for a while so I just saw the vid, Thanks for actually making it and answering my question. That's soo cool. Also very well thought through answer, haven't seen this topic in that light before. And I'm still loving the lipstick!
You are so talented and I love watching your videos ❤️
Thank you so much!!
I’m certain at this point that no one has dived into this series as much as you have. You’ll keep interest in this series alive for a long time. If they ever reboot this series they absolutely need to bring you on as an advisor.
So this is only possible if the district at the very least had 1 victor already, but my idea is that the victors could write a memoire/diary/textbook (something like that) and fill it with tips and tricks, things they learned. Basically a 'how to survive the hunger games (or how to increase the chance of survival)' book. And this would be given to the tributes if the only victor of their district has died/no victor remains.
I really like that idea!
Thank you!! I just realised that some people could possibly be illiterate/ or just can't read well so instead of writing a book they could also just make a video or record something for future tributes.
I got a Present Snow Funko Pop!! I'm happy
Oooh!
Can you do a vid of what if Katniss didn’t run into the cornacopia or if she got the bow at the bloodbath
Congrats on 16k Jess!! I think if Effie were to be the mentor for Katniss and Peeta, she would help them a lot since she sees an opportunity for herself to be promoted, and with one of the two winning, it would make her more popular in the eyes of the Capitol
do what if the morphing from 6 didn't save peeta
Great video! Love these hunger games videos! I have a book series that I thought you might like, the book series is Keeper of The Lost Cities by Shannon Messenger. I think the book series would make some interesting videos too. There are 8 books and have another one coming out next year, they are fantasy. This is just a suggestion I thought you might want to look into. I hope you like them! I love your channel, keep up the great work!❤️
District 12 tributes didn't have a mentor for 40 years! So Haymitch won his games with no help.
In the first hunger games Katniss and peeta did an act of rebellion by almost eating the berries. Later Haymitch talks to Katniss and tells her that snow didn’t like that. Why didn’t Katniss/peeta’s family get punished like Haymitch’s?
Probably because Snow realised it's more effective to keep the family alive and have that threat hanging over the victor's head. He couldn't force Haymitch or Johanna into anything anymore because they didn't have any loved ones left, which is a waste of a victor for him (especially with Haymitch being a Quarter Quell victor).
😱 oh my ik u might not remember but a few months ago I requested a theory about if a tribute didn’t have a mentor . Wow this is amazing ilysm. Ur channel is amazing I do agree that if the tributes didn’t have a mentor that it would be an escort
We certainly see that Effie can rise to the occasion later when she finds herself in District 13. I believe that if Effie had to fill in the mentor role, it would have been fine as she does demonstrate at least some level of care, even if that care is about getting a victor to get promoted. In fact, being in that mentor role might kickstart her character arc earlier in the story as she would have that extra responsibility and connection as well as the feeling of loss as she would have been the mentor to the tributes before Katniss and Peeta. But maybe that's me having too much faith in the humanity of the Capitolites.
Your videos are awesome ❤ from France
Thank you!
Could you do a video on how sponsoring works? I have some questions.
1. How do they tell the gamemakers that they want to send a gift?
2. Do they choose what to send in?
3. Where did a capitol citizen get a trident, a huge weapon?
I love ur videos!!!! Side question, your lipstick always look so fun, whwre do you get them? 😳
Thank you! They're from NYX or Jeffree Star Cosmetics, but I'm always looking for more brands!
Love your videos!
Thank you!
In the 1st movie why the district 4 career a 12 year old? Can you make a video about this
It's very likely he volunteered
@@StoryDiver thank you Hihihihi how stubborn
@@StoryDiver A bit foolish to volunteer at 12...
*Heres some ideas! -What if Peeta has died with the careers in the first games? -What if there wasn’t a bow and arrow in the arena? -What if Prim had survived? -What if Katniss died in the 75th hunger games before she could’ve been rescued? -What if Peeta had died when he hit the force field, how would it affect katniss? -What if Katniss ended up with Gale instead of Peeta? -What if Peetas hijacking couldn’t be reversed? -What if Maysilee won the 50th Hunger Games instead of Haymitch? -What if Katniss had killed a game maker when shooting for the apple? -What if Katniss and Peeta did fight as the final two when the announcement allowing one victor was made? -Why was Katniss skill with a bow and arrow not questioned when a girl from district 12 shouldn’t have been able to acquire a skill like that? -What if Katniss didn’t have a special skill (Like other district 12 tributes)? Love your videos btw!!* 💞💕
I think they’d use another victor from a different district. Like if Haymitch died, maybe Annie could’ve mentored Katniss and Peeta since Mags and Finnick were mentoring instead..?
I've always been confused (since we get Katniss' POV and 12 only has ONE mentor) if each tribute gets a mentor or if the district pair shares one (like Katniss and Peeta 'shared' Haymitch'). Either way, I always interpreted it as random Victors would be sent to mentor districts that were lacking but they were almost always weaker Victors to begin with. So Victors like Brutus, Enobaria, Cashmere, Finnick, or Gloss would definitely stay in their district. But some lesser-known or less impressive (most Career) Victors would be rotated to districts with no Victors until it finally happened. That way, there's incentive for those mentors (they only get to go home and 'retire' if they succeed), Snow gets to keep hope alive in all districts to stay in power, AND all districts eventually do get a victor (at least one of each sex, no less).
Can you do what if katniss was killed during catchig fire. Would there be no rebellion or will they choose anyone else? Etc
I love your hunger games videos
Your amazing
Thank you!
Story Diver thank you so much for making me happy and for saving my life in mutple occasions
I want to know what if Peetah died in the hunger games
Could you do a video on what the other sectors could have been in the 75th games?
It's on the list!
Yes I've been wondering about thisss
I think the escort would work really hard just so there can be a new victor in the district and so they could be relieved from doing the mentor's job, otherwise they would have to do the same task every year. Also I think if a escort managed to have a victor without a real mentor it would make them pretty famous in the capitol (if Snow allows it).
That makes sense!
I don't know if Thresh and Rue got very many sponsors (other than the bread), so if you are smart and strong like they are, you could make it pretty far with allies if you have no mentor. However, I don't think that some of the richer district tributes like Cato wouldn't make it that far, because he's not very smart. Just what I think though, feel free to comment you opinions!
Hi! i have a video idea for you!
What if Peeta had ate the nightlock that foxface gave him?
Foxface didn't give him the nightlock, he found a bush of it. I'll look into your idea!
Omg tysm
Hey I love your videos!!! And I was wondering, since we only got the games from the POV from Katniss, a non-career, and we see careers from her point of view, do you think you could do a video on the games of a careers point of view? And how they viewed her?
Hey, I also have two topics: What if one of the rebels who helped Katniss escape the arena betrayed them. (What if Johanna killed Katniss for example) I just forgot the other one but if I remember it I’ll comment it on this comment
Ik u talked about how the rig the games so maybe they rig is so that every district will have a mentor. How they can do that is by rigging the other districts so that they have less strong or smart ppl. So then the district they are trying to get to win has more odds to win. Bc they only would have to worry about district 1,2,4. Just a theory but it might be true seeing as every district has at least one mentor.
I love your videos ❤️ I have a video idea what if print one the hunger games
Could you do a vid about what every quarter quell might be if the games continued for 27 more quells? Or how did Mags win?
that theory is very likely, but i think that since the capitol doesn't care about the tributes, they would have capitol citizens who are honor role students or just very good ones, and the tirbutes would have to make the capitol citizens like them.
After reading the new book I recon they would make a capital student mentor
I iften wondered this on: what would have happened if Peeta had died before Katniss had reached him? Or similar ideas, because then Haymitch would be in the arena and there would be no mentor.
If i didn't have a mentor i would just give up.
Early!! I love ur vids!!!
Thank you!
Can u maybe make a video on what happened to the rest of north america after the war? even though most of panem was turned into a district, if u look at a map of panem, a lot of it (especially in Canada, were not in fact turned into a district. I dont know weather they got bombed or maybe there are still people living there or maybe they rounded everyone up from around there and put them districts? Idk, just seems like an interesting subject.
I think that if there was no mentor, maybe another district with over two mentors could chose to help the other tributes without a mentor. Maybe they wouldn't have to or be able to, but I still find that an interesting idea.
Hi! Could you do a video on what if Peeta’s name was drawn in catching fire?
I've done a few videos on that reaping, they'll likely answer your questions!
Snow does not care about fairness so he would just not care if tributes don't have a mentor