If you think about it from Mary's perspective, you begin to understand a lot. She's young, she lost her father, and she just wants to have someone there for her. These things though, do not justify her wrongs. She is very violent, has tried to harm Ib many times and has even gone as far as to kill Gary. A lot of the events within the game are orchestrated by Mary to keep Ib inside the gallery with her. Mary is a tragic character, who deserved better. But that doesn't mean she's a good person. I personally love Mary as a character, though as a person I see her as who she is. A violent, clingy, and overall sad girl. If you love her, that's perfectly fine and justified. If you dislike her, that's just as understandable and okay. There is really no need to fight.
this is a horror game after all, there's no everybody happy forever after. the closest one you got is "The puppet room" which is quite f*ck up in it own right
@@card4694 So Rafscrap is a TH-cam cover artist! They cover a wide variety of songs like vocaloid, to disney, to even hidden gems like this game here. I had recently seen them upload a video of a rock version of this song, kind of different lyrics and whatnot, but reading through the comments I had found that they are attempting to remaster Ib ^^
guys, garry isn't related to the painter! she says "why he resembles the one who creates.." garry looks like guertena therefore she thinks HE created her and that's why she sets out for revenge on him, for leaving her although she doesn't know that he is dead
True, it's not even officially confirmed if Mary even thought Gary resembles her Father. The original theory is that she just is jealous about his bond with Ib :)
It takes sacrifice to have a real life and she can not kill Ib because she is young so she thought of killing Garry. If you're right in terms of killing Garry ! (Because i love Garry and Ib) P.S: Sorry for my english ^^'
i remember when i was in maybe 3rd grade I’d walk around alone during recess singing this song, i knew the lyrics by heart. i can’t believe how long it’s been, but the melody is still always with me
To be honest I never dislike Mary.... The whole world has been cruel to her....she just wanted a friend and Garry is just trying to keep Ib away from Mary which I think is the reason that Mary doesn't like Garry
This song perfectly describes and explains Mary and her madness. Gods, this song is making me think of the first ending in the game and all the incident with the blue rose.
has anyone ever thought about WHY she was evil? I mean she is locked up all her live in there and desperate to escape, any of you would ALSO lose your minds after years and years... don't act like you wouldn't, all she wanted is to either die so it would stop or escape, and escape has the higher priority of course, and if 1 life is in her way, than so be it, because you're that desperate... stop hating her, she can't help it that shes gone mad.
"BURN THE PICTURE" NO SHES SO LONELY IM GOING TO SAVE THIS POOR GIRL "JUST BURN IT" OK FINE i want 2 save mary and garry and we can all be happy in the real world and nothing will HURT
+Dr. Frenchfries The Crazy Sadly, all three cannot go to the real world together, as the same amount of people that entered must leave. Since only two entered, only two can leave. There is an ending where Ib stays and Mary and Garry go to the real world, though.
You know, good or bad, Mary was kind of an idiot. I know she's young (At least mentally) and I know that she didn't know him well but it doesn't take a rocket scientist to figure out that Garry's nice, in fact, right after they met, he was telling Ib and Mary to be safe and keep an eye on their roses until she interrupted him, and even before that he clearly showed friendliness. Now, I think it's safe to assume that the "Flowers of Jealousy" painting (The one that separated them) were controlled by Mary, at least to some degree, as we clearly see she holds authority over some works in one of the endings (I believe it was "A Painting's Demise", where she asks the Red Headless Statue blocking her way to her sketchbook to move, and it does). Had she not separated them by force, though, she could have easily stopped Garry from reading the book that told him she was a painting, and let them discover on their own that only two could get out, and had Garry just sacrifice himself, or, maybe not even let them find out that only two could get out. Surely if all three of them got to the "Fabricated World" painting together, she could ask to go through first and neither Ib nor Garry would have a problem with that. After all, she seems quite comfortable making herself seem weak and innocent and scared. Remember, Mary not only knows the ins and outs of the gallery, but she also has some degree of control over it, and has been trying to get out for, presumably a long time. In fact it's likely that she's far older than Ib or even Garry and honestly, mentally young or not, she should have figured all of this out, by that point. That being said, I find this game absolutely beautiful and this is not me criticizing it in any way.
Katoka Karalashvili Why should gary have to sacrifice himself to let a that girl get out. I think it would always have turned into a fight to the death. Mary new this. mary new this I think. Someone wokld have have to be miserable. Death is the only way out, and mary new this, to some degree. She just didn't want to dye. Gary would have never let marn mary get out. I feel like later on, after the game, she would have burnt that place to the ground. It was the creator who was really at fault here. He knew this would cause misery, but he created it anyway.
ok... I write it under this but it's for everyone... did you stay in a madhouse without the sun for years and years without a friend and a person who could teach you what's wrong and what's bad??! (excuse me for mistakes but i'm italian, I'm not very well in english..)
Moge_k0_02 that is also true and I agree that her life was sad and horrible. I am one of the people that feel bad for Mary, others don't. ( But I don't hate on the other group )
Marin Loem Y U LIKE MARY U R HORRIBLE Actually, that's not my opinion. My opinion, instead, is that Mary is one of the most well- developed characters I've ever heard of. And I can explain this with only one sentence: People disagree on whether she's a good person or a bad one. I love Mary as a character for the same reason I believe that Kouri should not add an ending where both Mary and Garry make it out alive: This shows both Kouri's genius and the fan's inner character. Garry, however, I have a VERY dissenting opinion on. That being that while I like him as a PERSON, as a CHARACTER he's unappealing to me. In my opinion, Garry just seems bland, theme songs and all. He's just your ordinary father- type character with a strong weakness to jumpscares. He bores me. Plus, it seems like him being there eventually starts to take away from the atmosphere that the Blue, Green, and Yellow Areas did *_so_* well. Well, either that, or I just don't like the song for the Violet and Brown Areas. I have to admit, though, it was pretty funny seeing him go "KYAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA" because a painting with a wobbly tongue tried to spit on him.
It's so sad! Ib and Garry deserve to escape, that was a case of wrong-place-wrong-time, and imagine being all alone in a gallery in a painting where the only one that looked at you- your creator- left. How lonely would that be? Poor Mary. She didn't deserve what she got either, ut none of the ending are happy XO
Black Licorice she kills Garry in more than one ending. If we're assuming that she DOESN'T control the dolls (which is unlikely, since the other pieces in the gallery seem to respond to her orders, so it isn't a stretch to think that she's responsible for what happens to garry in the doll room and for his death in the endings where he goes permanently mad in there), then she still kills him directly in at least 2/10 endings.
I love Mary. YEAH THATS RIGHT MARY IS ONE OF MY RPG BABIES! She just wants some love! Mary shall forever always be one of mah babies! Now I feel alone cause there is a small percentage of people who like Mary...
damn throwback 🥺i used to listen to this a lot in elementary, and was invested in other series like misao, mad father, etc. omg so much time has passed😣 the nostalgia is giving me whiplash
I know this has been said a million times, but I just finished the game. So yeah. It needs an ending where all three can escape. In my mind, Ib's parents adopt Mary and they become sisters, then Ib meets Garry again years later (when she's an adult) and they get married, with Mary gaining a big brother in the process. Garry is a nice guy and I think Mary really is a sweet girl too, she's just lonely and desperate. None of them should die. Even if it's hard to obtain, that's fine. Just make it exist. ;A; I connect most with Mary because I also lost my father and miss him dearly. Course, I'm not a painting... or am I? *dun dun dun*
that is a very sweet ending! that would be lovely, but there's just one hitch. GARRY IS MAYBE TEN YEARS OLDER THAN IB OR SO, AND I THINK IB'SPARENTS WOULD BE REALLY FREAKED ABOUT HER MARRYING A GUY WAY TOO OLD FOR HER. BY THE TIME SHE CAN MARRY, GARRY WOULD BE AT LEAST 29 OR 30 OR SOMETHING. Maybe they can just live together instead, but no marrying No hard feelings or offence meant
+sophie01 nuevo Mary was a child + she was locked up inside the other world by Guertena, which is why she freaked out when Gary and Ib tried to leave. My theory is that Mary went insane after being locked up for so long. But hey, thats just my theory.
+sophie01 nuevo Mary was a child + she was locked up inside the other world by Guertena, which is why she freaked out when Gary and Ib tried to leave. My theory is that Mary went insane after being locked up for so long. But hey, thats just my theory.
Every time I hear this song, it makes me feel sorry for Mary, but every time I think of Garry giving his rose to her and she slowly plucking away at his life makes me feel sorry for Garry and Ib. Needless to say, I have mixed feelings about this amazing, evil, sad, antagonist. Although we can all agree this song is INCREDIBLE!
TTT~TTT sniff i never once really thought of mary to be all evil rather i felt sad for her she just wanted a friend and experience what i t is like to live as a human oh if only just if only they all could have left together.....that would have been the most happiest ending like how the three friends in Fantasy maidens odd hideout were all together in the end TTnTT if only it happened here...
Why do people hate Mary? She is so awesome, in my opinion she is just missunderstood wanting a family and friends but they left her alone so now she is left alone.
i agree, i never hated her but just misunderstood her for a while, then it makes me really sad looking back on things, i wish everyone could live, but it cant be that way DX
Everytime I'm playing Ib (trying to get all endings) I mention that I'm playing to my friend and right away she tells me to "BURN HER" That happened one time before she even knew what Ib was, and before I told her how you're supposed to burn Mary to get the right ending-- If you ask me, Together Forever is the right ending ;)
As much as I love Mary, I strongly dislike the ending Together Forever, especially when you have to choose between Mary and Garry. It literally makes me cry because Garry has done so much - sacrificed his own life to save Ib's just for her to leave him in the Fabricated World when they both showed lots of care for each other and were so motivated to get out.
And I am here to say thanks to all the RPG MAKER games They really made my life better I found out about them in all the Covid situation and now thats like my safe space And from what I seen a lot of these games have a really interesting story that gets you interested
This song is really good. I honestly don't understand why people hate Mary. I mean if you think about it, she didn't do anything wrong....other than kill Gary.
+PiterGamerGames Since only two entered, the three cannot leave all together. The same amount of people that leave has to be the same amount that came in. They might all be alive, but one person would have to stay behind. There is an ending where Ib and Mary go to the real world, and Garry is left (but in this ending, he's dead). There's another ending where Ib burns Mary, and Garry is dead, and Garry becomes the painting. Then there's an ending where Ib stays, and Mary and Garry go to the real world. And I believe there's an ending where Mary goes to the real world alone, because Garry is dead and I think Ib is too. I'm not too sure about that though.
You know. It would be kinda cool if Mary somehow tricked Garry into escaping through the painting with her. So Ib is left behind. That's just me personally. And they would become like a father/daughter pair.
There is a tweaked version of the game with an ending called sacrifice where Ib pushes the other two into the real world and stays by herself in the painting world.
***** But she wouldn't escape alone. She would have basically stolen Ib's real life and alter reality so that Ib's parents never had her in the first place. If you've seen the ending where Ib and Mary escape then you'd know it's possible for her to exist as long as she escaped with a real person.
I just remembered this song because I was playing the piano and it just came back to me and I was like "WHAT THE HELL IS THIS MEMORY" and I was only 10 when I found iB and now 5 years later im going to find this damn game,
wow it's so hard to get sick of this song...i've just had it on repeat and honestly thinking of mary's story and all it really just makes me vulnerable to all these feels :')
XxLover KittenxX Gaming nu she didn't her father was her painter but he left her in the world "why does he resemble the one who created the gallery and picture that gave me a birth?"
Rosen little girl. In a Fabricated World. Learns what’s real and not. - A solemn young man. In a Fabricated World. Discovers her truth. - Painted little girl. In a Fabricated World. Wants to become real.
This is sad... She misses her father. When she found ib she found a friend. She didn't like Gary because he was a grown man getting in the way of their friend ship.
Alice jgvig Not the lyrics, and the song itself was taken from a website, not created specifically for the game. The same website was used for Mad Father, which is why they share some of the same songs, such as old doll.
OMG HERES A POEM. Ib Burned Mary, Ib left with Gary, I thought Mary was a fairy, I ate a berry ^-^ I dont know why, I like to rhyme, I ate a pie, I wasted your time! :D
...I have some empathy for Mary here. I know what it's like to be in her shoes. Not necessarily perfect grammar, though... but it still portrays a great idea.
Poor Mary. Must be super lonely alone. ;u; I don't hate you Mary. Just don't kill Garry. ;u; If Me, ib and garry would be trapped in the gallery, I'd let the two of them go back and stay with you ;u;
So my dad heard me playing this and was surprised, cuz he heard it at the part "why do you hate me so much" and i had to explain the true ending of Ib...after trying to explain witches house prior, i already knew he couldnt quite see past it being fake, but i nonetheless tried. Result? He called it evil, and assumes i'm consumed by it because i actually understand the story and results and why the actions taken were necessary. I had no idea that being intelligent and being able to understand was such a "sin". -_-#
I thought Mary was off at first, because DANG she was too happy to be someone lost in a creepy gallery. Then, I thought she was better when she smashed the mannequin. AND THEN SHE ATTACKED IB AND I WAS LIKE "NOPE"
You know what would be awesome? If corpse party and Ib could somehow mash up and Sahiko would get stuck in the fabricated world so everyone else could live a happy life! THAT would have been the best Ib/corpse party ending.
Yup. She may or may not be evil, (I didn't quite get the story, even though I played all endings) but either way, I felt sad for her, when you burn her to pieces... R.I.P Mary. ;(
The reason of mary was guertena's last piece. Mary wanted to get out of the world ib went in, mary gets out in only 1 ending I think, which is together forever.
There’s no win win here... you have to kill one of the other, but if there was an ending were Garry and Ib both get out, but Mary is still alive. Maybe she could be transferred to a sketchbook, and stay with Ib forever, while not being in the real world? It’s sad that she still can’t interact with things, but at least Mary could see the world and still have a friendship with Ib.
Welcome to my world, that’s painted with sadness There’s no light of sun, there you can’t hear any sound at all Here I’m waiting silently for you, father Why were you so cruel, to left poor Mary alone? Please take me away, I desperately promise To be a good girl, to be worthy of your love I don’t need the paint books, the dolls and the dresses Just tell me why you’ve left your pictures And gone Who are you, stranger? With a red rose in your hand I’ve liked you from the first sight, I wanna be your friend LET’S PLAY! I never asked for this place that’s called my home, But I hope you will be staying With me until the end Please don’t be scared of me I am a good girl I just want to be with you To forget my sorrow I’m tired of being The puppet of this world Oh tell me, Why do you want to go with this man? Is he your true knight, in the shining armor? He’ll sacrifice himself, just for your sake with no fear BUT THEN!! Why he resembles, the one who created This gallery and picture That gave me a girl My tears are falling, Oh why it’s so painful? I did nothing wrong, So why do you hate me so Much This burning canvas, became your cruel answer And now flames Unsparingly kiss me GOODBYE. ... Welcome to her world, that’s lying in ashes There’s a sea of fire, There is no place to run, at all She only wanted to be with her father, But little Mary’s melting, in her abyss, alone.
Ib is the best game ever, Thank's for the lyrics I really needed them! BTW Gary and Ib are like amazing and den dere's Mary dah evil bish. Gary saved Ib so many times
Well he dont "take place" of her. Its more like she used garry to get out and wanted to stay with ib. The mary is ib's sister thing is that mary probably changed their memories or something.
I'm going through a big time depression and my own best friend left me, every time I listen to this I get very tense and it reminds me of my worst memories, why do I still listen to this song?
I love how they dont all have happy endings. That is what makes the stories so great!!! It is a horror rpg after all. Happy endings just not right for these.... Plus marry has to replace someone in the real world to be able to leave that is why she only wants one rose and not both. She cares for Ib more (due to you being with her longer) and so she would rather kill Garry than Ib.
You guys are all like "She did nothing wrong!? What about when she killed Garry!?!?" This isn't a timeline where she kills Garry, this is a timeline where her only friend BURNS HER ALIVE.
Mary doesn't want to kill Ib and Garry but if she has to leave she has to take someone's place and leave. You will know more when you get the ending A Painting's Demise.
If my answer is correct, Garry is the son of the painter..Which is Mary is Garry's beloved sister! The question is " Why is Garry stuck with Ib at the gallery?"
At first I didn't like Mary, cuz she tried to hurt Garry and Ib. But after hearing this, Mary ;-; I'm so sorry. She's like a female Edward scissorhands >_
By far my favorite character. All some see at first is a psychopath. But what really is there stands a young,desperate girl who wants to escape her prison at any cost.
Mary isn't a bad guy people. She's lonely and scared and this corrupts her. When she sees Ib she's so ready to not be alone anymore that she lies to be with her. She doesn't hate Gary but sees him as a threat to taking away her only friend and that's why she tries to take his place in the real world. I'm not saying that she was good, but she certainly isn't bad.
Ib is a game that is still good when compared to the games that have come out in the following years. ------------------------- Ib Witch's House Mad Father The three classic horror rpg games.
If you think about it from Mary's perspective, you begin to understand a lot. She's young, she lost her father, and she just wants to have someone there for her. These things though, do not justify her wrongs. She is very violent, has tried to harm Ib many times and has even gone as far as to kill Gary. A lot of the events within the game are orchestrated by Mary to keep Ib inside the gallery with her. Mary is a tragic character, who deserved better. But that doesn't mean she's a good person. I personally love Mary as a character, though as a person I see her as who she is. A violent, clingy, and overall sad girl. If you love her, that's perfectly fine and justified. If you dislike her, that's just as understandable and okay. There is really no need to fight.
Mary did nothing wrong, shes just a lonely girl who wants to exit the fabricated world and be a real person
I wish there was a ending where you save all three of them!
I'm very confused, I found this video randomly. Is there a game to this?
Yes. Look up "Ib Game"
+Aero Moyer
yes...
Is old, but...
Is great
this is a horror game after all, there's no everybody happy forever after. the closest one you got is "The puppet room" which is quite f*ck up in it own right
I so agree!!! I love Gary,Mary and obviously Ib!
This quarantine is letting me dig up so many gems.. The nostalgia just hits different
Same here
Do you guys have play with mary? I mean sometimes you guys play with mary you know ok...
hey hey dude i just heard from Rafscraps cover of this song (in the comments) that a remastered version is coming out this year!
I dont know what is Rafscraps...
Is it song?
@@card4694 So Rafscrap is a TH-cam cover artist! They cover a wide variety of songs like vocaloid, to disney, to even hidden gems like this game here. I had recently seen them upload a video of a rock version of this song, kind of different lyrics and whatnot, but reading through the comments I had found that they are attempting to remaster Ib ^^
I kinda feel bad for Mary cause she just wanted to be a Real Girl....
well there is a ending called"forever together"
Samuel Ling Yeah but Garry is dead...
sacrifice ending
only two people can get out
Samuel Ling The sacrifice ending is only in Ib: Green Version, and it is not cannon
PUT UP YOUR HAND IF YOU FEEL THE SLIGHTIST BIT SAD FOR MARY. (Hi this is an update from 5 years later,,, it’s been 5 years go home folks)
✋
✋
✋✋
foxy fan liz ( *puts hand up*)
👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎😤😤😤😤😤😤😤😤😤😤😤😤😤😤😤😤😤😤😤😤😤😤😤😤😤😤😤😤😤😤😤😤😤😤😤😤😤😤😤😤😤😤😠😠😠😠😠😠😠😠😠😠😠😠😠😠😠😠😠😠😠😠😠😠😠😠😠😠😠😠😠😠😠😠😠😠😠😠😠😠😠😠😠😠😑😑😑😑😑😑😑😑😑😑😑😑😑😑😑😑😑😑😑😑😑😑😑😑😑😑😑😑😑😑😑😑😑😑😑😑😑😑😑😑😑😑🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥💣💣💣💣💣💣💣💣💣💣💣💣💣💣💣💣💣💣💣💣💣💣💣💣💣💣💣💣💣💣💣💣💣💣💣💣💣💣💣💣💣💣🔫🔫🔫🔫🔫🔫🔫🔫🔫🔫🔫🔫🔫🔫🔫🔫🔫🔫🔫🔫🔫🔫🔫🔫🔫🔫🔫🔫🔫🔫🔫🔫🔫🔫🔫🔫🔫🔫🔫🔫🔫🔫
Hands down.
Five years later and I’m still humming this.
The lyrics are pretty sad, but the melody is BEAUTIFUL :)
Same, this and afew others lol
guys, garry isn't related to the painter! she says "why he resembles the one who creates.." garry looks like guertena therefore she thinks HE created her and that's why she sets out for revenge on him, for leaving her although she doesn't know that he is dead
True, it's not even officially confirmed if Mary even thought Gary resembles her Father. The original theory is that she just is jealous about his bond with Ib :)
idkk
this doesnt true she said she just want to be with her father
3:02
Dude it said 2 fucking times that she WANTED to BE with her FATHER she did NOT want revenge She WANTED HER FATHER
Mary is not bad ... She just want to have a normal life and be a real girl...
Yea but she killed Gary in one of the endings
I would have liked Mary if she hadn't killed gary
I see but she not a bad person.
I know she is not a bad Pearson but still she killed someone it is wrong
It takes sacrifice to have a real life and she can not kill Ib because she is young so she thought of killing Garry. If you're right in terms of killing Garry ! (Because i love Garry and Ib)
P.S: Sorry for my english ^^'
i remember when i was in maybe 3rd grade I’d walk around alone during recess singing this song, i knew the lyrics by heart. i can’t believe how long it’s been, but the melody is still always with me
"I'm tired of being a puppet to this world" & "I never asked for this place that's called my home." I FELT THAT ON WAY TO MANY LEVELS.
Oh my god this gives me such nostalgia
Me too!
Me fourth
Me fifth :)
Me sixth !!^^
Me eighth !
To be honest I never dislike Mary.... The whole world has been cruel to her....she just wanted a friend and Garry is just trying to keep Ib away from Mary which I think is the reason that Mary doesn't like Garry
+Helen He I think same sometimes is important just have someone for talk
garry just trying to protect ib
Rinato KawaiiAngel but poor mary
+Helen He I like all them there oh so cool & yes poor Mary-chan
Well most stuff that comes from paintings are evil.
Mary's fate is what made Ib so memorable to us. 11 years later and I'm still listening to this. Still lamenting the fact you can't save all three.
9yrs later and this still gives me the chills. Great job, love it.
This song perfectly describes and explains Mary and her madness. Gods, this song is making me think of the first ending in the game and all the incident with the blue rose.
has anyone ever thought about WHY she was evil? I mean she is locked up all her live in there and desperate to escape, any of you would ALSO lose your minds after years and years... don't act like you wouldn't, all she wanted is to either die so it would stop or escape, and escape has the higher priority of course, and if 1 life is in her way, than so be it, because you're that desperate... stop hating her, she can't help it that shes gone mad.
"BURN THE PICTURE" NO SHES SO LONELY IM GOING TO SAVE THIS POOR GIRL
"JUST BURN IT" OK FINE
i want 2 save mary and garry and we can all be happy in the real world and nothing will HURT
you should watch the fan made sacrifice ending then
+Chou Usagi they sacrifice is a real ending in the Green edition of Ib
+Dr. Frenchfries The Crazy Sadly, all three cannot go to the real world together, as the same amount of people that entered must leave. Since only two entered, only two can leave. There is an ending where Ib stays and Mary and Garry go to the real world, though.
+ReallyCoolSami Is there an ending where Mary and Ib go to the real world?
Small Snivy Yes. It's called "Together, Forever", and it was the first ending I ever got.
You know, good or bad, Mary was kind of an idiot.
I know she's young (At least mentally) and I know that she didn't know him well but it doesn't take a rocket scientist to figure out that Garry's nice, in fact, right after they met, he was telling Ib and Mary to be safe and keep an eye on their roses until she interrupted him, and even before that he clearly showed friendliness.
Now, I think it's safe to assume that the "Flowers of Jealousy" painting (The one that separated them) were controlled by Mary, at least to some degree, as we clearly see she holds authority over some works in one of the endings (I believe it was "A Painting's Demise", where she asks the Red Headless Statue blocking her way to her sketchbook to move, and it does).
Had she not separated them by force, though, she could have easily stopped Garry from reading the book that told him she was a painting, and let them discover on their own that only two could get out, and had Garry just sacrifice himself, or, maybe not even let them find out that only two could get out. Surely if all three of them got to the "Fabricated World" painting together, she could ask to go through first and neither Ib nor Garry would have a problem with that. After all, she seems quite comfortable making herself seem weak and innocent and scared.
Remember, Mary not only knows the ins and outs of the gallery, but she also has some degree of control over it, and has been trying to get out for, presumably a long time. In fact it's likely that she's far older than Ib or even Garry and honestly, mentally young or not, she should have figured all of this out, by that point.
That being said, I find this game absolutely beautiful and this is not me criticizing it in any way.
i agree
I agree
Galaxy Gamer6678 your profile pic is my phone lock screen, I'm proud of you.
I agree with you.
Katoka Karalashvili Why should gary have to sacrifice himself to let a that girl get out. I think it would always have turned into a fight to the death. Mary new this. mary new this I think. Someone wokld have have to be miserable. Death is the only way out, and mary new this, to some degree. She just didn't want to dye. Gary would have never let marn mary get out. I feel like later on, after the game, she would have burnt that place to the ground. It was the creator who was really at fault here. He knew this would cause misery, but he created it anyway.
That awkward moment when your song has about 1 000 000 views, while it's reprinted to the other channel... OTL
:P
That IS awkward xD
u created this song wtf this load of bull 400,000 from urs tht mess up
everyone is like poor mary but i think this is the poorest thing ever
I've never played the game or know anything about it, but this music is just so sad and enchanting!
Mary's death is unacceptable
Okay I just finished the game and I hate Mary. SHE KILLED GARRY!
+SailorMorgy28
You can save Garry, though. And you still have to kill Mary... I hate Garry for making me feel bad for Mary, but Garry is so cool /;-;/
Ari Amakawa I love Garry!! I got the ending where Ib and Mary get out and live together
+SailorMorgy28
That one's the best ending /;-;/
I wish they hadn’t changed Mary’s theme in the remastered this song fits perfectly with her character!
"I did nothing wrong, so why do you hate me so much?"
Umm... Because you killed Gary?
Maybe she doesn't think it's wrong
Osama Bin Laundry true, but it was still a harsh thing for Ib to see. She wasn't very happy with Mary for that in one of the endings.
ok... I write it under this but it's for everyone... did you stay in a madhouse without the sun for years and years without a friend and a person who could teach you what's wrong and what's bad??! (excuse me for mistakes but i'm italian, I'm not very well in english..)
Moge_k0_02 that is also true and I agree that her life was sad and horrible. I am one of the people that feel bad for Mary, others don't. ( But I don't hate on the other group )
Marin Loem Y U LIKE MARY U R HORRIBLE
Actually, that's not my opinion. My opinion, instead, is that Mary is one of the most well- developed characters I've ever heard of. And I can explain this with only one sentence: People disagree on whether she's a good person or a bad one. I love Mary as a character for the same reason I believe that Kouri should not add an ending where both Mary and Garry make it out alive: This shows both Kouri's genius and the fan's inner character.
Garry, however, I have a VERY dissenting opinion on. That being that while I like him as a PERSON, as a CHARACTER he's unappealing to me. In my opinion, Garry just seems bland, theme songs and all. He's just your ordinary father- type character with a strong weakness to jumpscares. He bores me. Plus, it seems like him being there eventually starts to take away from the atmosphere that the Blue, Green, and Yellow Areas did *_so_* well. Well, either that, or I just don't like the song for the Violet and Brown Areas.
I have to admit, though, it was pretty funny seeing him go "KYAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA" because a painting with a wobbly tongue tried to spit on him.
It's so sad! Ib and Garry deserve to escape, that was a case of wrong-place-wrong-time, and imagine being all alone in a gallery in a painting where the only one that looked at you- your creator- left. How lonely would that be? Poor Mary. She didn't deserve what she got either, ut none of the ending are happy XO
Alois what are you doing here......?
Dannie Hopkins Imma bored~ Ole~
Dance!! *Plays music*
Ole! ( Gets Alois and starts dancing)
*Dances with Catherine*
I would've pitied Mary...
...If she didn't kill Garry-kun in one ending.
Exactly
Black Licorice YEAH FUCK MARY
#TEAMIBANDGARRY
Sonic Everhate that is why most people love garry he is mysterious
Black Licorice I'm sorry for killing Garry-kun..... I just wanted to leave.....
Black Licorice she kills Garry in more than one ending. If we're assuming that she DOESN'T control the dolls (which is unlikely, since the other pieces in the gallery seem to respond to her orders, so it isn't a stretch to think that she's responsible for what happens to garry in the doll room and for his death in the endings where he goes permanently mad in there), then she still kills him directly in at least 2/10 endings.
I love Mary. YEAH THATS RIGHT MARY IS ONE OF MY RPG BABIES! She just wants some love! Mary shall forever always be one of mah babies! Now I feel alone cause there is a small percentage of people who like Mary...
By the way Ib community don't kill me *hides in a tree*
bb *raises hands*
+Jewell TH
Yay agreements
(。･ω･｡)ﾉ🌹
I love Mary :D
I love Garry :D
I love Ib :D
Mostly like them all :D
+Frisk Determination
Stay determined!
I was obsessed with this game...and now i’m getting all the nostalgiaaa
Oh my god same, it’s so cool to see comments that aren’t from 5 years ago tho
damn throwback 🥺i used to listen to this a lot in elementary, and was invested in other series like misao, mad father, etc. omg so much time has passed😣 the nostalgia is giving me whiplash
i wish i could relive the early 2000s
this isnt early 2000s. It's 2010s. Early 2000s is Yume nikki, ao oni,...
I know this has been said a million times, but I just finished the game. So yeah. It needs an ending where all three can escape. In my mind, Ib's parents adopt Mary and they become sisters, then Ib meets Garry again years later (when she's an adult) and they get married, with Mary gaining a big brother in the process. Garry is a nice guy and I think Mary really is a sweet girl too, she's just lonely and desperate. None of them should die. Even if it's hard to obtain, that's fine. Just make it exist. ;A; I connect most with Mary because I also lost my father and miss him dearly. Course, I'm not a painting... or am I?
*dun dun dun*
how do you get the game
that is a very sweet ending! that would be lovely, but there's just one hitch.
GARRY IS MAYBE TEN YEARS OLDER THAN IB OR SO, AND I THINK IB'SPARENTS WOULD BE REALLY FREAKED ABOUT HER MARRYING A GUY WAY TOO OLD FOR HER. BY THE TIME SHE CAN MARRY, GARRY WOULD BE AT LEAST 29 OR 30 OR SOMETHING.
Maybe they can just live together instead, but no marrying
No hard feelings or offence meant
CandyQueen11
you do realize that is normal in Japanese society right?
IwuzLeft4Dead Well other than the fact that IB had a Western setting, uh...citation needed. Badly.
well thanks
Now I see what my friend was talking about. Yup. Going to the Mary side. *casually sits down in the Mary fan group *
Well, Mary didn't know any better. She's just a little girl.
+sophie01 nuevo Mary was a child + she was locked up inside the other world by Guertena, which is why she freaked out when Gary and Ib tried to leave. My theory is that Mary went insane after being locked up for so long. But hey, thats just my theory.
+sophie01 nuevo Mary was a child + she was locked up inside the other world by Guertena, which is why she freaked out when Gary and Ib tried to leave. My theory is that Mary went insane after being locked up for so long. But hey, thats just my theory.
I love Mary out of all of them my friends don't tho they think she could die in a hole
+Cheshire Cat wow you're friends are mean to poor Mary......just a thought!!!!!
Every time I hear this song, it makes me feel sorry for Mary, but every time I think of Garry giving his rose to her and she slowly plucking away at his life makes me feel sorry for Garry and Ib. Needless to say, I have mixed feelings about this amazing, evil, sad, antagonist.
Although we can all agree this song is INCREDIBLE!
TTT~TTT sniff i never once really thought of mary to be all evil
rather i felt sad for her
she just wanted a friend and experience what i t is like to live as a human
oh if only just if only they all could have left together.....that would have been the most happiest ending
like how the three friends in Fantasy maidens odd hideout were all together in the end
TTnTT if only it happened here...
I've,listened to this countless times .
yah i saw ur comment when i was commenting
Really ??
What it say though ? =w=
Somethign about U saying like U listen to it and saying its sad??
Idk I didn't really payed attention =w=
For some reason I just caught myself wondering how screwed up this painter's brain must have been to create such a bizarre place XD
Why do people hate Mary? She is so awesome, in my opinion she is just missunderstood wanting a family and friends but they left her alone so now she is left alone.
i agree, i never hated her but just misunderstood her for a while, then it makes me really sad looking back on things, i wish everyone could live, but it cant be that way DX
I feel ya *Nod's slowly*
There is an ending where all of them stay in the painting world. Kind of scary.
Yeah I know
Hm?~ What do you mean?
8 years later and I still remember the lyrics
IVE BEEN LOOKING FOR THIS SONG SINCE 2019 AND I FINALLY FOUND IT
A single tear ran down my cheek at the end ;-;
Mary sounds like shes saying Help Help Help. Over and over, pretty scary to be her.
Oh my god, you're right! I never noticed that until now.
Exactly i saw a comment say that before and i replayed it and listened closely. And then im like....WHOA SHES REALLY SOUNDING LIKE THAT
LuckySpiritWolf OnAJ I KNOW RIGHT.
if you sing the song saying help all they way it actually sounds like it and I play aj too XD
I used to my final video on my channel is about my quitting of animal jam.
Poor Mary... She was my favorite character in IB, even after she turned all evil.
Everytime I'm playing Ib (trying to get all endings) I mention that I'm playing to my friend and right away she tells me to "BURN HER"
That happened one time before she even knew what Ib was, and before I told her how you're supposed to burn Mary to get the right ending--
If you ask me, Together Forever is the right ending ;)
+Danielle Lynn I think Forgotten Portrait is the right ending
As much as I love Mary, I strongly dislike the ending Together Forever, especially when you have to choose between Mary and Garry. It literally makes me cry because Garry has done so much - sacrificed his own life to save Ib's just for her to leave him in the Fabricated World when they both showed lots of care for each other and were so motivated to get out.
Yeah because then you get the true end. IF you do several things right of course ;b
And I am here to say thanks to all the RPG MAKER games
They really made my life better I found out about them in all the Covid situation and now thats like my safe space
And from what I seen a lot of these games have a really interesting story that gets you interested
I love this song and I love the RPG!
Bella.
empolgante
I love this song a lot
baket444 me too but do you know the name of the movie from the song
Alessandra M. As much as I know this song comes from the game "ib" that's all I've heard XD
This video was my childhood
This song is really good. I honestly don't understand why people hate Mary. I mean if you think about it, she didn't do anything wrong....other than kill Gary.
Why there isn't an ending where everybody is alive ;-;
I know right?
+PiterGamerGames There is, it's just That at least one person has to stay behind.
+PiterGamerGames Since only two entered, the three cannot leave all together. The same amount of people that leave has to be the same amount that came in. They might all be alive, but one person would have to stay behind. There is an ending where Ib and Mary go to the real world, and Garry is left (but in this ending, he's dead). There's another ending where Ib burns Mary, and Garry is dead, and Garry becomes the painting. Then there's an ending where Ib stays, and Mary and Garry go to the real world. And I believe there's an ending where Mary goes to the real world alone, because Garry is dead and I think Ib is too. I'm not too sure about that though.
+ReallyCoolSami The one where Ib stays is actually fan made
You know. It would be kinda cool if Mary somehow tricked Garry into escaping through the painting with her. So Ib is left behind. That's just me personally. And they would become like a father/daughter pair.
no
Yeah.... Could've been a possible ending ya know!! (._.)?
There is a tweaked version of the game with an ending called sacrifice where Ib pushes the other two into the real world and stays by herself in the painting world.
I agree lol
***** But she wouldn't escape alone. She would have basically stolen Ib's real life and alter reality so that Ib's parents never had her in the first place. If you've seen the ending where Ib and Mary escape then you'd know it's possible for her to exist as long as she escaped with a real person.
Five years since this vid was posted. Still as beautiful as I remember.
I just remembered this song because I was playing the piano and it just came back to me and I was like "WHAT THE HELL IS THIS MEMORY" and I was only 10 when I found iB and now 5 years later im going to find this damn game,
* Mary has a beautiful backround, Literally its yellow roses. Yellow is my favorite color.
i was humming this song at work the other day… i haven’t listened to it since middle school and it’s been almost ten years…. like wtf
wow it's so hard to get sick of this song...i've just had it on repeat and honestly thinking of mary's story and all it really just makes me vulnerable to all these feels :')
"I did nothing wrong"
YOU INVENTED A PAINTING'S DEMISE WHERE GARRY GOES INSANE, GIRL. THAT'S WHAT YOU DID WRONG.
nobody teach what is wrong what is right
...
XxLover KittenxX Gaming she killed him bc she thought it was her father
She killed her father.
WHO WAS ALREADY FRICKING DEAAD.
XxLover KittenxX Gaming nu she didn't her father was her painter but he left her in the world
"why does he resemble the one who created the gallery and picture that gave me a birth?"
This song goes from pretty sad to horribly depressing at around 2:25, to the extent that it's even brought a bit of a tear to my eye.
COMMENTS! COMMENTS EVERYWHERE!!!
Hi.
Hi.
WTF
Slendy!!! Hug? Pwease??
*hugs everyone*
Rosen little girl.
In a Fabricated World.
Learns what’s real and not.
-
A solemn young man.
In a Fabricated World.
Discovers her truth.
-
Painted little girl.
In a Fabricated World.
Wants to become real.
Geez, i remember the lyrics, the rhythm, the insane 20+ endings, this game aged like the finest wine glass
This is sad... She misses her father. When she found ib she found a friend. She didn't like Gary because he was a grown man getting in the way of their friend ship.
Gary and I b were in love and he is not a grown man he is 17
thalia torre ... Its confirmed that Gary is 21.. And IB IS JUST 9 DUDE
Well sorry but he looks like he is 17 he acts like he is 5 though because he always screams more then ib does
-^-
+Mary The Painting he's older than you and me.
The only thing I don't like is the support of the fan theory with no evidence which is that Garry is Guertena or related to him.
He just looks like him
Alice jgvig Considering there has never been an official picture released of Guertena, how do they know?
Amber McLeod
The song was made by the creators, I think.
Alice jgvig Not the lyrics, and the song itself was taken from a website, not created specifically for the game. The same website was used for Mad Father, which is why they share some of the same songs, such as old doll.
So it's legit, then?
I guess so...
It's strange, eh?
OMG HERES A POEM.
Ib Burned Mary,
Ib left with Gary,
I thought Mary was a fairy,
I ate a berry ^-^
I dont know why,
I like to rhyme,
I ate a pie,
I wasted your time! :D
CLEVERNESS RIGHT HERE.
THANK YOU XD
SERIOUSLY THOUGH, BRO. ABSOLUTE GENIUS.
Joey Pacman THANK YOU :D
AND THANK YOU.
FOR THE BEAUTIFUL POEM :D
...I have some empathy for Mary here. I know what it's like to be in her shoes. Not necessarily perfect grammar, though... but it still portrays a great idea.
Poor Mary. Must be super lonely alone. ;u; I don't hate you Mary. Just don't kill Garry. ;u; If Me, ib and garry would be trapped in the gallery, I'd let the two of them go back and stay with you ;u;
This is so sad!
I love Mary and Gary,
But Its Cruel for Poor Ickle Mary ;n;
*The Tears come along*
DAMMIT VAHL.
Ik
xD
;>:
So my dad heard me playing this and was surprised, cuz he heard it at the part "why do you hate me so much" and i had to explain the true ending of Ib...after trying to explain witches house prior, i already knew he couldnt quite see past it being fake, but i nonetheless tried. Result? He called it evil, and assumes i'm consumed by it because i actually understand the story and results and why the actions taken were necessary. I had no idea that being intelligent and being able to understand was such a "sin". -_-#
welp
my gosh. My dad does the same with just about everything I watch or listen to. :T
So does mine lol
Same here -.-
Actually my mom does that to me, my dad just doesn't care lol.
I thought Mary was off at first, because DANG she was too happy to be someone lost in a creepy gallery. Then, I thought she was better when she smashed the mannequin. AND THEN SHE ATTACKED IB AND I WAS LIKE "NOPE"
:(
childhood me loved this so much. sometimes it pops up in my head then i have to search forever to find it again
lyrics just make this song more sad...
Wow...
it really does
You know what would be awesome? If corpse party and Ib could somehow mash up and Sahiko would get stuck in the fabricated world so everyone else could live a happy life! THAT would have been the best Ib/corpse party ending.
I love your username :3 !
RinYukaViolaEllen AyaIbMaryMisaoAki oh and... there was a blonde chick in mad father? o-o i never knew that...
Cursed Cat But her name is Mary, not Coron. And they look totally different! And Coron was dead in the first place...
ohhhh that chick!
wha? now im just confused..
Still love this song so much
i lovr mary she is not evil at all she just want to have friends and ro see her father so yes she is a good girl ,i feel bad for her!
Yup. She may or may not be evil, (I didn't quite get the story, even though I played all endings) but either way, I felt sad for her, when you burn her to pieces... R.I.P Mary. ;(
+Ari Amakawa I agree
I knew you would.
The reason of mary was guertena's last piece. Mary wanted to get out of the world ib went in, mary gets out in only 1 ending I think, which is together forever.
then tell me who on the world is evil？
Why couldn't all three of them gone out of the painting???
it depend how many people came like 5 people came in only 5 people can get out 6th people will need to stay there
Samuel Ling Oh...
Sierra Rinnea :0 Another Sierra appeared.
Because someone needs to take Mary's place as a painting. Be it Gary, ib, or both. Mary can't take her own place. She wants to see the outside
***** how about together forever ending
this song brings back so many memories
Ikr
I want an ending where they are all safe and sound and happy, away from the painting world.
can never exist due to how marys existance is a painting and not a real living being
There’s no win win here... you have to kill one of the other, but if there was an ending were Garry and Ib both get out, but Mary is still alive. Maybe she could be transferred to a sketchbook, and stay with Ib forever, while not being in the real world? It’s sad that she still can’t interact with things, but at least Mary could see the world and still have a friendship with Ib.
the grammer hit me
The pic goes perfect with this comment XD
Well Mary is a young child painting thing I don't think she can English
+Kittypurry64 your grammar hit me
+Kittypurry64 teach me your skills
😂😂
10 years, omg...
ahhh.. where has the time gone
Welcome to my world,
that’s painted with sadness
There’s no light of sun,
there you can’t hear any sound at all
Here I’m waiting silently for you, father
Why were you so cruel, to left poor Mary alone?
Please take me away,
I desperately promise
To be a good girl,
to be worthy of your love
I don’t need the paint books,
the dolls and the dresses
Just tell me why you’ve left your pictures
And gone
Who are you, stranger?
With a red rose in your hand
I’ve liked you from the first sight,
I wanna be your friend
LET’S PLAY!
I never asked for this place
that’s called my home,
But I hope you will be staying
With me until the end
Please don’t be scared of me
I am a good girl
I just want to be with you
To forget my sorrow
I’m tired of being
The puppet of this world
Oh tell me,
Why do you want
to go with this man?
Is he your true knight,
in the shining armor?
He’ll sacrifice himself,
just for your sake
with no fear
BUT THEN!!
Why he resembles,
the one who created
This gallery and picture
That gave me a girl
My tears are falling,
Oh why it’s so painful?
I did nothing wrong,
So why do you hate me so
Much
This burning canvas,
became your cruel answer
And now flames
Unsparingly kiss me
GOODBYE.
...
Welcome to her world,
that’s lying in ashes
There’s a sea of fire,
There is no place to run, at all
She only wanted to
be with her father,
But little Mary’s melting,
in her abyss,
alone.
Ib is the best game ever, Thank's for the lyrics I really needed them! BTW Gary and Ib are like amazing and den dere's Mary dah evil bish.
Gary saved Ib so many times
Makes me cry every time.. ;~; Poor Mary.
Oh No I’m on a nostalgia train for Ib and Mad Father
SAMMMEEE
My friend showed me this song and i instantly fell in love with it 😍 can't stop listening to it!!!
same
Hi Erza!
I’m 19 now. I listened to this when I was like 9-10 😭
I HATE that there wasn't a way to save Mary;-; I DIDN"T WANT TO HAVE TO KILL HER!
Well if you get the ending sacrifice you can sacrifice yourself garry then garry stays or mary then she stays
Oh and on sacrifice if you chose both she sends them both out then takes all of here rose petals of her rose
zebulia01 Thats an fan made ending. The real game dont have that ending.
Well he dont "take place" of her. Its more like she used garry to get out and wanted to stay with ib. The mary is ib's sister thing is that mary probably changed their memories or something.
Fan made other ending. For example. Ib does sacrfiece, or become rulebreaker to escape all togethef
I feel the same way as Mary... T-T
I hate Mary... But this song make me cry. She wasn't bad at all.
I know...Im like You were so good Mary...THEN BECOME A GOD DANG PERSON WITH A PALETTE KNIFE AND GO CRAZY!
I'm going through a big time depression and my own best friend left me, every time I listen to this I get very tense and it reminds me of my worst memories, why do I still listen to this song?
I love how they dont all have happy endings. That is what makes the stories so great!!! It is a horror rpg after all. Happy endings just not right for these.... Plus marry has to replace someone in the real world to be able to leave that is why she only wants one rose and not both. She cares for Ib more (due to you being with her longer) and so she would rather kill Garry than Ib.
You guys are all like "She did nothing wrong!? What about when she killed Garry!?!?" This isn't a timeline where she kills Garry, this is a timeline where her only friend BURNS HER ALIVE.
Mary doesn't want to kill Ib and Garry but if she has to leave she has to take someone's place and leave. You will know more when you get the ending A Painting's Demise.
9年前にこうも私の嫁って言いたいメアリーに素晴らしいリメイクがきていたとは……
If my answer is correct, Garry is the son of the painter..Which is Mary is Garry's beloved sister! The question is " Why is Garry stuck with Ib at the gallery?"
that is something very smart...
At first I didn't like Mary, cuz she tried to hurt Garry and Ib. But after hearing this, Mary ;-; I'm so sorry. She's like a female Edward scissorhands >_
yup
By far my favorite character. All some see at first is a psychopath. But what really is there stands a young,desperate girl who wants to escape her prison at any cost.
B.B. Hood yup
yup
Thank you... At least SOMEONE understands my pain. I was a pile of ashes. Now the lady in blue is eating it...
Mary is a good girl......mary is a good girl.....mary is a good girl
Yes😭😭😭
It's been so long sense this game came out; and this song still breaks my heart as much as the game every time.
Who just looked this up because you remember like 4 years ago you were obsessed with ib
Yeah, I’m in the same boat. Decided to look up the Ib OST on a nostalgic whim. Now I’m replaying the game. Fuck.
Mary isn't a bad guy people. She's lonely and scared and this corrupts her. When she sees Ib she's so ready to not be alone anymore that she lies to be with her. She doesn't hate Gary but sees him as a threat to taking away her only friend and that's why she tries to take his place in the real world. I'm not saying that she was good, but she certainly isn't bad.
I feel so sad for Marry :( She just want some compagny D:
thank you
Mary Guertena I want to be your friend
reaally you said that to mary but you almost prevent yuki to have friends
And so?
So? that's unfair and don't make sense
1:18 LOL LOOK AT GARRY'S FACE XD I DIED LAUGHING!!!
Ib is a game that is still good when compared to the games that have come out in the following years.
-------------------------
Ib
Witch's House
Mad Father
The three classic horror rpg games.
2021 and this is still so sad (but such a bop)😭
1:24 and 2:18 are the only times mary sings la but all the other times it's the sound of her sobbing.
Omg I love this so much. I've been listening to this for almost 40 minutes now. XD
I've love this song too, can't stop replaying it!