VS | Obi-Wan Kenobi vs Anakin Skywalker vs Ahsoka Tano
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 19 มิ.ย. 2016
- Obi-Wan Kenobi vs Anakin Skywalker vs Ahsoka Tano: The Path to Knighthood. If they were ever set in conflict and faced each other, who would win?
Watch more Star Wars Versus Videos!
• Antoine Bandele's Star...
Support this channel through Patreon!
www.patreon.com/antoinebandel...
Get e-mail updates for my channel!
eepurl.com/bTW8C9
Get e-mail updates for just my Versus Series!
eepurl.com/bTW6W9
Like me on Facebook!
/ youtubeantoinebandele
Follow me on Twitter!
/ antoinebandele
#starwars #versusseries #obiwankenobi #anakinskywalker #ahsokatano #theclonewars #rebels
ART USED
Obi-Wan Kenobi by TereseNielsen
www.deviantart.com/art/Obi-Wan...
Ahsoka Tano by aeryvae
www.deviantart.com/art/Ahsoka-...
SOURCES
MOVIES
Star Wars Episode 1
www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00...
Star Wars Episode 2
www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00...
TELEVISION
The Clone Wars Season 1-5
www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00...
NOVELS
Jedi Apprentice series
www.amazon.com/gp/product/059...
Jedi Quest series
www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00...
COMIC BOOKS
Clone Wars Vol 2: Enemy on All Sides
www.amazon.com/gp/product/159...
Rise of the Sith Vol. 1
www.amazon.com/gp/product/078...
Obi-Wan & Anakin
www.amazon.com/gp/product/078...
SOURCEBOOKS
The Clone Wars Character Encyclopedia
www.amazon.com/gp/product/075...
Ultimate Star Wars
www.amazon.com/gp/product/146...
Everything You Need to Know
www.amazon.com/gp/product/146...
Jedi vs Sith: The Essential Guide to the Force
www.amazon.com/gp/product/034...
The Jedi Path
www.amazon.com/gp/product/145... - บันเทิง
Ahsoka is a Ninja
Obi Wan is a Samurai
Anakin is a European Knight or a Gladiator
:D
i never thought of it like that
Personally, I'd call Ashoka more a dervish than an ninja
Persoon56
Most the world does not even know what that is.
Fair, sorry, I guess I lost my head for a second
+Persoon56 A Rogue
Obi Wan was a late bloomer. He became one of the best Jedi to ever be, but after he achieved knighthood. Not fair for Obi.
Are you implying that Obi-Wan was weaker as a Knight? If so, that just isn't true.
+Steven Zissimos he is saying that obi wan achieved his prime as a knight, and as a padawan just wasnt that good, but started seeing more improvement as a knight than as a padawan. Or that is what i understand
I think I understand what you mean. Kenobi was a late-bloomer, in the context that the full magnitude and range of his skills did not emerge until later in his life: as a Jedi Knight and as Jedi Master. He was not a prodigy like Anakin or Ashoka, since he was initially rejected from Padawan-level training because he did not garden enough to stand out and cause other Knights or masters to take interest in him. But his commitment and dedicated, particularly as Anakin's teacher and in wake of Qui-Gon's death result in him emerging as a legendary Jedi. He was more like Bruce Lee rather than Wolgang Mozart.
David Jones well, I don't like Obi Wan, but I like Anakin! Yay :D
He was alright.
Not bright with the force but good at light saber combat with a good clutch game.
Dooku was a L
GG was a W *clutch*
Maul was a W *clutch*
Anny was a W *high ground*
I hope you can make Obi-Wan Kenobi (ROTS) vs Anakin Skywalker (ROTS) vs Ahsoka Tano (Rebels)
Yep. Gonna make a vote whether or not folks want to see Vader or Anakin.
good,gooooood...
kenobi would win because of the high ground
no , what if kenobi never have high ground would be fair
cheuk hang Yu TRAITOR
Obi-Wan is the clear third wheel here, in terms of fighting at least.
I feel like obi wan would win and take out both of them...
+Teemo4Life not padawan obi wan.
And if we're going by their adult abilities, I suspect that Darth Vader's suit would give him a bit of an advantage.
It might just be fanon causing me to reply, but I think that Vader's suit subtly weakens him so that he would be unable to defeat his master. If that is true, that could cross over with Obi-wan and Ahsoka
Uhhh, The suit made him slower, and depending on what time, he wasn't really accustommed to it.
Ahsoka is SO worthy of a film appearance. I so hope we get a reference of her in the form of her light sabers appearing or perhaps a statue of her.
Mandalorian Season2
@@Nicox-cw6zu yep
Obi-Wan is hampered here by his lack of the form that defines him as a duelist when he becomes a Jedi Master: Soresu.
To be fair Ahsoka is younger than both of them
Age doesn't really matter. This can apply to real life sports.
TheNuisanceBird for her age she has more battle experience than them both
+Luke Woods This is a match up of a direct fight not a battlefield engagement.
TheNuisanceBird I know, what I meant was she's had far more experience against lightsaber foes
Luke Woods Neither Ventress or Grievous were legitimately trying to kill Ahaoka and both Kenobi and Skywalker as Padawans are the two people she'd have trouble with.
I distinctly remember Ahsoka having premonitions about a Padme assassination attempt, so yes. Ahsoka has displayed foresight
All Jedi has precognition, so Ahsoka's advantage in foresight doesn't do her much here
"But [Obi-Wan] was certainly more bouncy than his master," has got to be my favorite Antoine Bandele quote.
Obi wan : hey puberty hit hard man
6:46 are we just gonna ignore the fact that Ahsoka force choked him lol
Arisa Discord exactly
she was kidnapped and forced into some hunger games like thing with other padawan learners after having all their lightsabers & communicators taken. still odd for a jedi, especially a young one but was probably a fight or flight type response🤷♂️
She took that from me😇
@@DarthVader-6637 that’s a first I’ve seen you happy
Obi-Wan had the extremely powerful High Ground ability, but only after achieving knighthood.
I think a far more interesting fight would be pitting these three against each other in their primes. Obi-Wan as a Master of the Council, Anakin in Vader's hayday before A New Hope, and Ahsoka as Fulcrum. Both Obi-Wan and Ahsoka have easily held their own against Vader, and while we all know that Obi-Wan's victory over him was quite certain, we still don't know whether or not Ahsoka defeated him or not (though she clearly left her mark).
It's coming but each character at their light-side peak (so no Vader).
By far _one the best_ Star Wars VS I’ve seen. This is why you are the most subscribed of the forcecast group (though I really, really like GreyJedi91).
Even though this video is longer than most of your others, your points were short and relevant (you could have cut down on the dueling parts, imo), you had tangents but none went on too long. You gave each character their due credit, without embellishing or overstating their abilities to make a point, or underselling their abilities to make a counter point. You tied it up with a nice little thesis of Knighthood, and I know I’ve mentioned this before, but whenever you reference a source it makes giddy. You always have the best, most well-rounded researched material in your videos. You don’t pull from just one or two sources but just about everything, and if something conflicts or doesn’t make sense to you you make a point of it before stating your reasoning. You cross reference and treat these videos more like a MLA essay than an editorial writer.
Bravo. Truly. Bravo. I agree with the verdict. In fact I would even say Anakin is superior to AOTC Obi-Wan considering how they both faired against Dooku.
Now get on those animations! This channel definitely deserves the upgrade!
Well hot damn, thanks. I better see your support on Patreon! I would be so stoked to get animated battles done.
Couldn't agree more with this comment!
He's like the Obi Wan of the forcecast, he has a tight, fluid, and minimalist style of explaining things. The information is not over exaggerated or downplayed, he stays consistent and simple. He also has a unique cinematic style and brandishes variety in his videos. A flair that the other members don't put into their videos not nearly enough as he does. The only criticism I give him is that sometimes his speculations and given primes aren't always correct. But all in all I agree with you, there is a reason why he's the most subscribed.
Real talk
Since they are very similar, I would like to see Ahsoka Tano VS Sara Keto
Ooo
I know this comment is old, but Ahsoka VS Serra Keto is a very interesting matchup. The pupil of Anakin Skywalker versus the pupil of Cin Drallig, both Jar'Kai specialists.
But then an unexpected addition came to aid anakin.......
It was sand!!!
Demolitioexpert and the highground
I agree with Anakin being the victor in this scenario. He seems like kid of an underrated character, and I think he often isn't given enough credit for his abilities.
Barbossa's undead pirates vs Davy Jones' fishmen pirates (without the krakken)
unless the curse is broken, i'd say Barbossa's pirates would win. Davy Jones' crew can be killed or at the very least stopped while Barbossa's cant. but the video would be hilarious lol
yas
Barbossa and his crew all the way.
Davies crew can not be killed because they are already dead and their body parts can be removed with the ability that they become sentient when that happens these limbs can also be reattached if removed. Barbossas crew under the curse can not be killed in the conventional means of the word but in the novelization nor in the Movie do I remember any instances of Barbossa's crew being able to put them selves back together of their own accord like Davies crew can add that with the weakness of being turned into weaker more fragile skellington's under moon light. So it would come down to Davies crew dismembering all of Barbossa's crew how long that takes is no factor in this fight because they are immortal although both of them are capable of recruiting in a long term war like situation Davies crew has an ace up their sleeves. They have BOOT STRAP BILL, if dismembering Barbossa's crew does not work they can take away their immortality.
You're right. As Padawans, Ahsoka was 17, Anakin was 20 and Obi-Wan was 25.
" a ballerina of the force" that... Actually makes sense...
Heh indeed.
You should do this again but with them all as knights, anakin as Vader or revenge of the sith anakin
That's the next step. Going to put it to a vote though ... on whether folks want to see Anakin as a Jedi Knight or as a Sith Lord
Come on bro, that's not even fair. Rots Anakin vs Jedi knight Ashoka and obiwan? It's a stomp for Anakin, what do you think he did in the temple?
@@mannyman1012
Yeah, Jedi Knight Anakin would easily beat Knight Obi-Wan, and would beat Rebels Ahsoka. As Vader...Neither would stand a chance.
Revenge of the sith anakin is op
Obi-Wan Kenobi vs Anakin Skywalker vs Ahsoka Tano: The Path to Knighthood. If they were ever set in conflict and faced each other, who would win?
Watch more Star Wars Versus Videos!
th-cam.com/play/PLDFq63aBi3_x_hhCNeHiT0xbfWUGpXl0J.html
Awesome video, I like that you didn't take them in there prime but as apprentices!
Perhaps one day I will update the video to their primes ;-)
I've been waiting for this one ever since your Q and A and Editing live stream
AWESOME VIDEO you woke my up it is 1:29 AM in Florida thx because i was about to be knocked out.
Gr8 vid man yor channel is amazing
I believe that the fight would play out to the climatic duel in episode 1 with Kenobi being knocked out of the duel early on but taking on and possibly defeating the victor of the duel between Ashoka and Anakin
I really love your in-depth analysis of each Padawan. Had no doubt on who the winner would be, but it was worth seeing a close fight.
Plus, it was about time that someone got into detail about Anakin's creative use of Force powers. They might be useful for a future Versus video. What do you say to that?
Nice preview for the summer videos. Can't wait to see Kanan go up against Komari Vosa!
Yeah. I must admit, I oversimplified Anakin. He's not just talent, he's practiced skill as well. Can't wait to see Komari and Kanan as well! Will be a fun and new analysis!
Antoine Bandele
Agreed.
Waiting 4 a new Ahsoka versus series for like forever~~
You'll get sick of her by year's end. She shall return in her adult form by the year's end.
Actually she might now show up this year. Her novel comes out in November so the turn around would be too quick.
Guess I'm not sleeping for a while. Thanks, Antoine.
Heh! No sleep! The video is going nowhere!
+Antoine Bandele could you do a versus series with darth kracyt( if that's how you spell his name) darth sidious again or even kota?
Kota is coming on Jensaarai1's channel. Sidious isn't really that interesting to me in terms of a VS set up (but never say never).
Antoine Bandele ah alright thanks I'm really am enjoying this content
I don't get why sidious isn't interesting if the opponent can match his powers, and that whole its only speed thing is false, because sidious fought mace and he matched his speed exactly, so sidious fought with pure skill
Btw, just wondering but how's your watch time and retention time on these longer videos?
Not great. That's why I try to keep these as short as possible. But my retention is above average for length.
Hmm, at least retention time was good, I was thinking it might've also been that these characters aren't all that popular in a versus match but given Obiwan and Anakin are in the title, it doesn't seem that way..,,
I've not watched it yet but here's my guess: 1st is Obi-Wan, 2nd is Ahsoka and 3rd is Anakin --- 40 minutes later --- I'm just gonna stop talking now... I clearly forgot about Anakin's duel with Ventress and I also forgot that Obi_-Wan was amped by rage. I think I kinda just over-estimated Ahsoka from the start. This was one o the best quality of VS series videos I've seen and I just can't wait for next season! Great job Antoine
Spoiler Alert
Obi-Wan goes down first, than Ahsoka, leaving Anakin the victor.
Ahsoka's often overrated anyways.
TheNuisanceBird Not really. Have you seen the last 3 seasons of TCW? Ahsoka showed a combination of skill, courage, and intelligence that nobody else showed.
+Furious Sherman Yes, I'm aware of all of that. But then we have to consider people like Ezra on her level in some areas.
Many of her fears are inconsistent and overinflated fanservice. Many of the other characters in TCW are vastly underpowered. Going by the show only, Ahsoka should have more tactical ingenuity than Kenobi which would seem ridiculous.
Antoine personally thinks TPM Kenobi > TCW Ahsoka in a 1v1.
+redwarrior There is 6 seasons, so the two other last three would count...
11:36 While some of it was due to her force sensitivity some of it was her natural biology. Part of the reason it didn't work in her fight with Offee was because of the fact she used force Cloak on Ahsoka, the other is because she was still in adolescence (though she was near the point of adult she wasn't fully grown). the final part was because she was focused on anger and blocked everything else out. So I think her biology played a bigger part but my opinion though I loved this video it is my favorite one so far keep it up Antoine
hm can you make a Luke Skywalker vs Obi Wan Kenobi?
Obi Wan Stomps
+josiah jenks NOOOOO
Hit Mightiest of Men If we're talking about RoTJ Luke, he has no chance.
Would be cool to see!
Actually ROTS Obi and ROTJ are about equal, although I think Obi would win. But GM Luke slams Obi
Most of you comment on who's gonna win and how, with out thinking of the fact that this is when they were padawans😑
Yep
no name exactly.
She would school them as padwans, and even hold well against a Knight Obi-Wan.
well done Antoine. I have watched all of your versus videos and this is definitely my FAVOURITE one so far. Keep up the good work :)
Thanks. I liked this one too.
This is one of the best so far!!! So much fun to watch
Thanks Zand!
Damn, Antoine--another great video! I agree with all points made, including the verdict. Now that you've done a 3-way with these as Padawans, why don't you do a 3-way with these in their primes when you reach 200,000?
Tis the plan.
my bet is on Kenobi for this rematch
I think Kenobi will edge out as a duelist (though barely), but Anakin takes the physical and Force edge, which will give him the victory, in my opinion.
Obi-Wan beat Anakin in RotS even with the physical and Force edges. The question is how throwing Ahsoka into the mix will affect things if she is a third party
Aye, though Anakin's ability to draw upon the Force to enhance his abilities during the Mustafar duel was limited, due to the emotional state Analin was in. If Anakin was in his normal state, I'd say he'd get a 7/10 advantage due to his Force ability being much more powerful than Kenobi's.
Personally, I don't see Ahsoka being on the level of Kenobi or Skywalker's level, but the concept of the battle is interesting.
I have a few ideas for the versus series:
1. Galen Marek vs Obi Wan Kenobi
2. Darth Malgus vs Anakin Skywalker
3. Anakin Skywalker vs Darth Bane
4. Revan vs Darth Vader.
5.*Maul and Dooku and Vader vs Sidious
6. Satele Shan vs Starkiller (TFS2)
What do you think?
Number 5 sounds interesting each apprentice of sidious representing the prequels movie
Rosani Rodrigues Thank you
+Max Kogan well it is an interesting fight what do you think will happen who will be left standing sidious or one of the apprentice or two one will die eventually.
Rosani Rodrigues Well, it would be an intense fight, neither side would be holding back nor could they afford to. They could maybe synchronize a force blast and generate enough power to overpower Sidious. Lightning would be casted from both sides. Sidious would be at his absolute limit, knowing that this is perhaps the greatest challenge he's ever faced or ever will face. They would all unleash a flurry of strikes, one that Sidious would be struggling to keep at bay. Perhaps Sidious's lightning would short out Vader's respirator, but Vader would draw on his rage to keep himself alive until the end of the fight (as he has done before). Eventually, after a long fought battle of the Darkside, Sidious, exhausted and desperate, would extend both of his hands, one pointing at Dooku the other pointing Vader, a burst of violent waves of purple lightning would come forth. Vader would catch it with his lightsaber and Dooku with his hands, using tutaminis to block it, as he knows that he would be quickly overpowered if he used just one, but he could at least keep it at bay. Vader and Dooku would be struggling against their master's power. Sidious smiles as he believes that the battle is won, feeling that he's overpowering them, but then something feels wrong. He feels pain, a burning in his chest. He looks down and sees half of a crimson blade pushing out of his chest. He feels his power slowly leaving him, his lightning dissipates. He looks behind him and he sees Maul, gasping for air, a small smile forming across his face. Sidious looks in disbelief as his vision blackens and looks back at Vader and Dooku and then back to Maul. When the light fades from his eyes Maul would remove his blade from Sidious and he would fall just as Maul would fall to his knees from exhaustion, just as Dooku would collapse, desperately trying to catch his breath, and just as Vader would fall finally being free of his master, the master that took everything from him, who manipulated him, and who lied to him for years. Now he could finally die in peace. The land scarred by the battle of the Sith. But that's just one scenario.
+Max Kogan you mention respirator so you're talking about cybernetic Vader from the original trilogy I was thinking each apprentice representing the prequel movies darth maul-phantom menace darth tyranus-attack of the clones darth Vader-revenge of the sith before the duel on mustafar you get what I'm saying still cool description
I live for this series man, keep up the amazing work! And may the force be with you my friend.
Thanks James. And may it be with you.
this video was great, like all of your VS!
Thanks Darkra!
Reven and Sidious vs Yoda and Luke.
Money's on Regan and Sidious
*Revan
Sounds interesting!
thats not even fair Revan and Sidious take that one
Actually, if it's EU Grandmaster Luke? Luke and Yoda will pwn those n00bs.
DARTH NIHILUS VS. DARTH MALGUS PLEASE!
Suck vs smash. Could nihilus suck malgus life? If he cant, game over.
Dang. What a great versus video. Already, my mind is forming dozens of other possible outcomes. Thanks for the inspirations, Antoine.
Thanks Nathaniel!
+Antoine Bandele great video try Ventress vs xanatos or count duku vs darth malgus and kylo Ren vs savage opress
Antoine, masterful. Words are, quite obviously, your forte. They are not mine. I can feel things that I cannot express. My reaction to this presentation is one of those things. A simple "this was truly great" seems inadequate. In concept, in presentation, and in execution, "most notable discharged". Thank-you for this effort, it is truly appreciated. Dante.
Thanks Dante, much appreciated.
I think Yoda vs General Grevious would be awesome, since both of them had insane offensive skills, overwhelming some of the best duelists of the Clone Wars.
If it would really happen in the temple Yoda would rage out and use UNLIMITED POWER.
UNLIMITED POWER = Stop the fight by a force ability.
I love this one! Thanks for uploading this, keep up the good work
Thanks Shyam!
Wow, this was REALLY good! You gave each fighter the respect they deserve and was one of the most well researched Star Wars fight on TH-cam as a whole. My hat is off to you... If I was wearing a hat, that is...
Oh snap! Thanks! Thank you for pointing out the respect given. That's really something I try to achieve.
Antoine Bandele No problem. Although some of the crossover stuff could improve (For example, I thought Sora vs Aang was so obvious that it shouldn't have been done), your Star Wars matches make me come to this channel.
Truly impressed by this vid. Havent seen you do much in the way of multiple opponents, was worried you wouldnt quite get it right given how complex it could be. My worrying was for nought though, excellent job, especially as you didnt view it as a multiple set of 1 on 1 fights, just stuffed into 1 video.
Only disagreement is that I think Ahsoka would have 1 less victory in the mid fight, and Anakin 1 more in the late fight. But thats hardly something to really complain over, more personal preference.
Thanks Mufasa.
ahsoka used far sight to scene padme's attack by Aura sing
this is a truly awesome vid Antoine this vid shows why u r my fav of all the versus council u r very fair,u give every character credit where credit is due and overall ur analysis is very awesome. I can't wait for summer versus ^^
Thank Hyuga! You and Jeff's comments are very similar in nature.
+Antoine Bandele really?
This guy makes the best Star Wars versus videos.
Thanks frost.
Much welcome. Also if i might ask, how do you find all this information to do your research? The comics you used are not exactly easily found. Is there a website you get them from? Thanks
Here is the thing. I have a love/hate relationship with Wookiepedia. I *LOVE* Wookiepeida but I *HATE* how people use it. It's a great _re_source but a terrible places for sources. Many people online use Wookiepedia as a source when it's not. It's simply a resource to other sources. I feel like I'm one of the few that uses Wookiepedia as it should. I go there to references to text. If you look at one of the articles you'll always see a footnote. What I do is go to that footnote, see what that line was referencing to, find that novel/comic/books/video game and verify that source. Hence, the reason you see me referring to so many different things.
Thanks Antoine. keep up the good work!
I see a lot of comments on here that has me thinking, 'Did y'all even watch the video?' like Wtf lol
Honestly, me too. It seems only in the first month people actually were making arguments that directly correlated to points made in my video. More recently I feel it's folks who didn't even watch or listen to the points being made.
"Ahsoka does not have the power to PENETRATE Anakin". Yeah, she can't penetrate him @@
Nguyễn Bảo Anh Anakin do tho ;))
I was so hyped for this
And now you are disappointed . . . ;-)
Your videos are so well made, i love them so much, I definitely agree with your results, they are so well thought out. Thanks 😊
Thanks Anakin.
Anakin wins. He would overpower Ahsoka. Then he will wear down Obi-Wan Kenobi because Obi is older and Anakin has better strength. This is partly why Obi-Wan jumped to the higher ground on Mustafar, it is because Anakin's attacks are starting to cut into his energy.
In this scenario, Obi-Wan is the same age ... are people really not understanding the context of the video? Or skipping to the end? I wonder ...
Antoine Bandele people just don't understand the contextual conditions of the match... At least you tried hahahah thanks man keep at it
No obi wan has the high ground...
Save us Jedi Master Obi Wan Kenobi, you’re our only hope.
This was pretty cool. I saw in one your comments that you're planning a part 2 with them more in their primes later. Definitely looking forward to that :D
For sure. I would LOVE to have that one animated.
I just got into Star Wars and I’ve been binging your versus vids*
Obi Wan falls of first
Me: What about the high ground tho?
If I had to guess I'd say #1 is Anakin #2 is Ahsoka and #3 is Obi-wan.
Thank you! im so tired of all the obi-wan d*ck s*ckers who mumble on about how he'd outlast ahsoka and the use his "mastery" of ataru to finish her off. fact is Ahsoka held her own against rebels vader, who is known to be more powerful then the ROTS anakin obi-wan fought, as anakin then was unbalanced and an emotional mess. anyone with eyes could see obi-wan struggling to keep up until he changed the paradigm. fact is he only wins cause of tactics and cocky opponents, never throught his own skill. against someone in control and not arrogant like dooku, he got stomped everytime. so i think if Ahsoka focused on him, she;d quickly overwhelm him with her speed, then disarm him. the fight between her and anakin would be long with both parties being wounded, until finally anakin would use his strength and land a blow that would knock her off balance. in all reality however, the ROTS anakin would lose to ahsoka, it's only vader who might beat her and only because he's like 6'7 and has enhanced strength due to his cybernetics.
Only as padawans at there peaks
1. Anakin 2. Obi wan kenobi 3. Ahsoka
Sick video man as usual!!
Thanks M.
I think this is one of the best videos you've made
I quite like it as well.
yeah same kenobi would go down first, then Ahsoka, the Anakin would win
Powerful jedi was he, powerful jedi.
I really like how Ahsoka is the balance between Anakin and Obi wan, and because of that I think she would beat kenobi but not Anakin because he’s the chosen one.
Keep up the good work
Great vid
Thanks Allan.
Great Work!
Thanks Horst!
Kenobi is my favorite star wars character :(
He's rather dope.
Mines Anakin (don’t hate me)
Obi Wan wins this hands down.
Based on him hanging from an endless pit? Anakin and Ahsoka as padawans have much better feats, especially Anakin contending with Dooku.
Like ahsoka contending with ventress very briefly that's more impressive than maul. And Anakin has dooku for a short while. obi wan is screwed.
this is when they're padawans
Vincent Escolano I don't agree with Ahsoka hanging with Asajj though. Once Asajj got serious she sat Tano down.
Nice work love it 😃.
Thanks Phil.
Fantastic job as always, Antoine. Looking forward to the Summer season
Thanks Sheldon.
I think If we looked at Obi wan during revenge if the Sith, Anakin Skywalker also during revenge of the Sith and Ahsoka Tano during clone wars then Ahsoka would probably get taken out quickly and then the fight between Anakin and Obi wan would be similar to the fight they had in revenge of the Sith and Obi Wan Kenobi would also win.So if we look at the 3 characters at this point then Ahsoka would be taken out first then Anakin would be taken out and Obi Wan Kenobi would win.
SPOILERS
I kinda hate to admit it, but you are completely right with your arguments.
But I see following outcome at least as logical as yours:
Obi-Wan would struggle, because he is only average after all, as padawan as well as a master. Anakin on the other hand was a skilled fighter, but as you mentioned, he was often to overconfident. Also, Ahsoka was a bright girl, which she displayed in many fights.
I would say the Early Fight is with a *1-1-1* perfectly described, but the Mid Fight would be crucial.
You said she would probably take Obi-Wan out of the fight, but I would consider, that she doesn't do that, because of good reasons. First of all, during the Early Fight she would come to the conclusion, that she could not match either of them one on one, so she would probably let them fight. However, if she decides to take crucial actions, she would probably focus on Anakin, due to his offensive pressure on Obi-Wan. Anakin would most likely get overconfident in the battle, thus become wide open for a surprising blow by Ahsoka. While she can't take him out, Obi-Wan would be able to get on the offensive and finish Anakin with Ahsokas help. Right after, she could surprise the remainer and overwhelm him with her quick movements to end the fight without giving her enemy a chance to adjust to the new opponent. I would say: *Ahsoka: 3 ; Anakin: 1; Obi-Wan: 1* (depends on whoever Ahsoka decides to 'help', most likely Obi-Wan, though, because she would see the overaggression of Anakin)
In the Late Battle, if Ahsoka decided not to take out one of her opponents during the Mid Fight, Ahsoka would be the least exhausted, so she would either wait till Obi-Wan and Anakin are taking out one another and just sweep the remaining one.
If she helped Obi-Wan taking out Anakin in the Mid Fight, she would have a one on one with Obi-Wan, which is difficult to imagine. While Asoka was debatably the more skilled padawan due to her time in the clone wars, Obi-Wan was a more balanced fighter. Therefore, it would depend which happens first: Ahsoka penetrating Obi-Wans defense or Obi-Wan finding a flaw in Ahsokas tactic. Therefore, I would rate the Late Game: *Ahsoka: 1 ; Obi-Wan 1 ; Anakin: 0*
Which would conclude this dispersal:
*Ahoska: 5*
*Obi-Wan: 3*
*Anakin: 2*
This analysis entirely draws on the fact that Ahsoka and Obiwan team up, which may or may not be the case (sounds feasible). However Anakins noticeably higher skill level is not to be underestimated. And we shouldnt just take the teamup for granted.
Anakin doesnt just get overconfident, he actually has very good reasons for being so, but dueling on par with Dooku isnt something to scoff at and is something that neither other combatant probably would be capable of doing.
And dont forget, once one of the fighters is out, the other 2 still have to actually fight each over ie if Ahsoka takes out Anakin, she still has to take on Obiwan, the only problem is, Anakin isnt gonna be easy to take down
I didn't mean "teaming up" in that kind of fashion. In my thoughts, Anakin would be the one attacking Obi-Wan, which would Ahsoka naturally give a better chance to surprise the attacker than the defender. Once Ahsoka would interfere with the battle of the other two, she would therefore attack the attacker, Anakin, so that Obi-Wan would be thankful for the oppertunity to take Anakin on while he is distracted and his focus is spread.
I just meant to say, that I would think, that in the Mid Fight Ahsoka would take out Anakin rather than Obi-Wan (like Antoine said).
DodoRebirth The problem is, Obiwan is offensive as well, and what you said is how Ahsoka is getting most of her victories, the problem is, Obiwan just isnt as viable in this contest and Anakin can fight both to some degree far better than the others could if a committed assault was against him.
Anakin isnt just going to blindly let them attack him though, he will try to sidestep or else get to focus on one person, and his actual defences are pretty solid, Obiwan id say has the greatest shot of having his defences broken, its just Anakin, like you said, is more likely to draw attention
I'm sorry Obi-wan wasn't an 'average' Jedi at this or any point of his career he was far better then the Average Jedi (Jedi High Council member later, as well as one of the best duelist of the Jedi Order). Darth Maul had killed Anoon Bondara (the current Jedi Battlemaster, or if not a Battle Master a well known Lightsaber instructor) and Anoon Bondara's apprentice Darsha Assant. While Obi-wan wasn't able to land a blow against Darth Maul he survived and even managed to push him back after seeing Darth Maul strike down Qui-Gon.
Crazyscotsman I only think hes average right about now.
Dont bother using him as a member of the jedi council, thats very much far ahead in the future and at that point, he is certainly exceptional as both a swordsmen and what a jedi should strive to be, but as a padawan, he doesnt exactly have as much to boast about. He would of course rectify this in the future though, I really do enjoy Obiwans character and dont for a secod think he should be underestimated, but when putting up what hes capable of doing for this context of a 3-way with his skills as a padawan, he is poorly equipped for the task
His victory agaisnt Darth Maul was at best circumstantial, and was more a result of Mauls own arrogance than Obiwans own skill, though him contending with Maul is indeed a skillful feat.
I dont know much about Bondara, and Im not going to look at wookieepedia to find out, it would just prove that Im unqualified to judge the contest, but more importantly I dont know the circumstances of the fight or where it took place
Amazing job my friend
Thanks Lego
WOW!! beautiful... just beautiful!! lol great job on this antoine
Thanks Snow.
I admit I am sceptical as ashoka seemed just fine against vader who had the same advantages. ashoka in my opinion is the best character of all because of her mindset and natural skill, I believe she would shout to kenobi or focus solely on skywalker and take him out first having a knowledge of his skillset and a respect for obi wan. leaving just the two of them left. she would then unbalance him and win. what do you think?
This is Ahsoka from TCW, not Rebels, who Vader took pretty handily.
Ahsoka would have trouble surviving the duel with Anakin and Obi-Wan. She's the weakest duelist of the three.
you are correct on the first point yes, but I was simply referencing the fight as a showing that she can overcome that type of foe. my main point was she would gang up on Anakin basically sandwiching him between herself and obi wan. because she knows anakins style inside out as he is her master who she is learning from. she would gang up against him and then defeat obi wan soon after Anakin bites the dust.
+Lunar Legion, dude listen to what you're saying. In this duel, they are ALL PADAWANS. No one has any prior knowledge on each other. Ahsoka is the weakest duelist of the 3 and only her agility and force usage would keep her from losing outright.
+Lunar Legion, dude listen to what you're saying. In this duel, they are ALL PADAWANS. No one has any prior knowledge on each other. Ahsoka is the weakest duelist of the 3 and only her agility and force usage would keep her from losing outright.
I can picture that happening.
Every Ashoka v Grievous duel left a bad taste in my mouth. If she didn't have so much plot armor she wouldn't have survived. Grievous was reduced from his master-slaying 2003 form to... This
only 2 duels and Ahsoka was very fast for Grevious. And she was never on the offensive, she was just running for her life
Too true. If she didn't have plot armor Grievous would've crushed her head
So what you’re saying is that a young padawan couldn’t stand up to a Jedi master killing freak? Weird... besides she wasn’t trying to take him out in the second fight she was covering the retreat of others while he had heavy reinforcements coming. Rebels Ashoka would have tooled on grievous I think
Bob Bobson Ashoka beat Maul during ROTS. She almost beat Darth Fucking Vader.
Don’t underestimate Ashoka.
Kira The Renegade Ahsoka is good, but she’s no Grevious.
Love your videos man! keep up the great work!
Thanks Geroy.
this video is fantastic man. thank you :D
Thanks Beau, much appreciated.
i feel like ahsoka will be out matched badly by anakin and obi wan
No this is their padwan stage. We're seeing Ashoka at (until Rebels) is her prime.
Obi would later on win though easy
No
I disagree, Obi Wan is a far superior Jedi than the other two
Anakin and ashoka are just lucky they had his teachings
Define "superior Jedi." Remember we are analyzing each character's combative prowess, now their personalities. I think there is a case for Master Kenobi being very combatively viable against these two, but not Padawan Kenobi in this 3-way fight. I have made several points of this in the video. Did you have a more specific rebuttal?
You know these ar ejust there padawan years in which Obi is surley the weakest of the three.
I feel as an adult yes, obi wan was a greater Jedi, but because of the clone wars, Anakin and Ashoka were forced to adapt and be stronger padawans than obi wan was at the time, both benefitting from his training
interesting video Antoine I really like it. And, your Star Wars vs series & The Council Forecast. I really enjoyed.
Thanks Zach!
Antoine Bandele Your Welcome. And think you for watched for my old video of lightsaber guys vs series of EvanNova95 vs Antoine Bandele & left a comment too. ShadowFox77, that's me.
You put soo much work in your videos
Thank you. Welcome to our dysfunctional community of misfits! Check out some of my other videos!
th-cam.com/play/PLDFq63aBi3_x9Yv0zGF_S-XhRug0g6qKW.html
th-cam.com/play/PLDFq63aBi3_yGAJNwozcKYs0OfmgMiqu-.html
You should have compared them all at their peaks as that shows how powerful each Jedi really was. In that case obi wan and anakin would be tied with Ashoka being last as she never became a Jedi Knight in the first place
obi is stronger than this
Rewatch Round 1. Or the entire video. The premise of examination is pretty clear throughout.
I just think that taking out darth maul is more than everything ahsoka did,only my opinon.
Anakin is totaly stronger, in that i agree.
:)
Taking out Darth Maul by way of circumstance and through a Hollywood ending does not work with me. I favor when someone shows superior skill, not superior luck.
hollywood ending? mmm well in the end i agree to disagree.
but this is great video men! love it
I agree with you. But I don't think that Anakin was stronger than Kenobi in AoTC. Anakin was just a Padawan, and Kenobi was almost a Master. Also, Kenobi did press Dooku, according to the novelization. Amd ApTC Kenobi stood with Jango Fett with ease.
NO. I NEED TO SLEEP. WHY ANTOINE. I MUST RESIST AND SAVE THIS TO LISTEN ON MY MORNING RUN
lol
Save it until tomorrow! I'm so sorry I uploaded it so late. It was supposed to be done this morning!
Thanks for the reply :) Love all your stuff man. Keep up all the good, hard work!
Thanks Zach.
Congratulations! 100,000 subscribers! Keep up the fantastic work! I love your videos man! Good job!
Thanks Shadow.
i think obi-wan would win
Based on?
Antoine Bandele experience?
Ronald Calinawan
of the 3 padawan's it was Ahsoka who had the most experience in dueling
Anakin and obiwan had roughly the same level of experience as padawan's
Hey Antoine, excellent video as always :) keep up the good work
I have a request for a future vs series: Jaina solo fel vs Shakk tii
Not a bad thought.
Great video! The verdict was as it should be. The end reference is from a Kevin Hart stand-up where he was talking about his son touching the stove or oven.
YES! YOU GOT THE REFERENCE! YOU GET ALL THE COOKIES! ALL THE COOKIES!
This is going to be amazing
Ah!
Loving this series! Can't wait to see more!
Thanks RZ.
I think this vs is one of my favorite thank you
Thanks Cali.
What if you did a versus video different than normal? Like a squad of commando droids vs. magnaguards. Or Clone troopers vs. Stormtroopers vs. First Order Troopers.
your videos are awesome
Great video keep up the versing videos
Fo sho Toxic.
Another AMAZING video. Antoine = IMO best TH-camr.
I definitely have a long way to go before I'm on par with these bigger channels.
Antoine Bandele Maybe popularity-wise but personally I get more enjoyment out of your videos than literally anyone else on TH-cam. Well it's between you and TFS I guess haha. Keep up the good work man.
Wow. Just wow.
This video gives you a completely different perspective about these three. Especially Obi-Wan, who's now pretty much known for being more on the calm and defensive side.
I really liked this video, simply because of how they would all work in a three way dynamic, and combining all their different techniques.
Though in my personal opinion, Ahsoka's getting a bit of an advantage because she had more growth in her 5 season series, and I think Obi-Wan can put up a bit more of a fight. But I enjoyed it either way.
I am very happy with your script, especially since you seem to have stopped overusing certain phrases like you've done in some of your previous videos.
Sorry if this seems really analytical of me, but I can definitely see how much you have improved in your work.
Really good job, and may the force be with you.
(Also, you're in a Star Wars fan film? AWESOME!)
Thanks Andrea! I try to take the feedback and apply it to each and every video. I think that's why you've seen such a change from my first VS to the ones we have now.
Well, I can say I'm impressed. Keep doing what you do, and I think you'll be just fine.
👍
I still get creeped out with that weird looking Bane from Batman in that picture of you training blind folded lol. Also, love the new layout for these vs videos!
Thanks! Also . . . if you want more insight about that screenshot!
th-cam.com/video/3sh0FaINh_A/w-d-xo.html
Excellent matchup. I know I sound like a broken record, but I truly think you have gotten better and better with each Versus matchup. The research for this one was spot on. I love how you focused on how in spite of being Padawans, their experiences in their respective eras shaped them differently. And that's one of things I love about Star Wars; seeing how the various eras impact the characters and how they cope. This being the peaceful times of Obi-wan or the hectic timeframe of the Clone Wars via Ashoka and Anakin.
If you permit me to go off topic, some major news has hit Rogue One. I know you aren't a fan of spoilers, but a character from TCW will be a major character in Rogue One. I won't spoil his name for you. What's your take on this? Personally, I'm glad. LucasFilm has continually preached about connecting the new canon with the films. TFA was a horribly missed opportunity and it very much seems like the company is following through on its promise.
Hey Antoine do u know why executor class drednaugts have weird square like shapes all over its top
Can you try out a Rule of Two battle between the starters (Bane and Zannah) versus their heirs (Sidious and Dooku)? I'd love to see this from your perspective, great video as always.
You should check out the very end of the video 😉