Jim Duquette EXPLAINS: What Would It Take For Tigers To TRADE Tarik Skubal

แชร์
ฝัง
  • เผยแพร่เมื่อ 6 ก.ย. 2024
  • Former Mets GM Jim Duquette lays out what he believes it would take for the Orioles to acquire Tigers ace Tarik Skubal.

ความคิดเห็น • 89

  • @BrutallyOrange
    @BrutallyOrange หลายเดือนก่อน +12

    Not only is Kjerstad back in the lineup, but I think Hyde is sending us a message that he’s done playing games with this lineup he made tonight. This is Thee lineup, except I think Holliday, norby or Mayo should come up and replace Urias’ spot.

    • @jeremybear573
      @jeremybear573 หลายเดือนก่อน +2

      Mounty doesn't have a spot in the current lineup?

    • @BrutallyOrange
      @BrutallyOrange หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      @@jeremybear573 you don’t think he’s been struggling to a point where he should be in the lineup against LHP at best right now? You think O’Hearn and Kjerstad haven’t earned the shot? Mullins is the guy that technically has his lineup spot. Who you want against a RHP? Especially an elite one?

    • @jeremybear573
      @jeremybear573 หลายเดือนก่อน

      @@BrutallyOrange I hear ya regarding against LHP and he should be rotated in against RHP replacing the one who isn't hitting RHP well. I don't know who that is at this time. I'd say Norby for Mateo & Mayo for Mullins. That's out future lineup. I don't know how Jackson fits when he's ready except to take Norby out

    • @BrutallyOrange
      @BrutallyOrange หลายเดือนก่อน

      @@jeremybear573 Mateo and Urias are out
      Of options so if they send them down they’d have to DFA them.

    • @jeremybear573
      @jeremybear573 หลายเดือนก่อน

      @@BrutallyOrange I know. I'm projecting a future lineup.

  • @itinerantpatriot1196
    @itinerantpatriot1196 หลายเดือนก่อน +14

    Tiger fan here, just a bit curious to see how O's fans feel about making a deal. Seems like there are more than a few who would be against it, so the fanbases might be pretty close in alignment. I'd say the Tigers have done a sh*tty job of getting any return for the stars like Verlander and Martinez they have traded away but that would be insulting to things that are sh*tty. If they trade Skubal they risk alienating a fanbase that is just now returning in any real numbers. Stretching this eight-year rebuild out another decade as we wait on more players at AA and AAA to become anything will be a killer.
    Personally I'd like to see Illitch sell the team. Outside of that mini-burst in the early 2000s when the old man started giving a damn because he realized he might die and never see his team win it all (which is what happened anyway) the family's track record as owners is lower than whale crap. The only reason the media gives them any kind of break is because the Wings won some Cups under their ownership and they draw a lot of water in a own where water is scarce. Billy Ford never got cut the same slack when he ran the Lions into the septic tank.
    I will say this, if you get Tarik, you're getting a helluva pitcher, the best left hander Detroit has developed since Mickey Lolich. I for one am pulling for ya. Yeah, you guys used to beat the snot out of us back when you had Boog, Brooks, Palmer, and that bunch in the 70s, but you're not the Red Sox or the Yankees. So whether you get our guy or not, I hope you finish ahead of both of those clubs. There was a time when I was okay with Boston but that time has passed and my grandpa would rise from the dead and haunt me if I ever rooted for the Yankees, for anything, ever. And I'm good with that. Anyway, best of luck and I really hope you can do it without taking our guy. We only have a few on the team worth a damn and I'm too old to wait for that 2032 championship team to come to fruition. Oh yeah, I made my kid watch the game where Cal broke Gehrig's record. Cal was the last of the old-school giants. Mad respect there.

    • @user-dj7lx9ec8j
      @user-dj7lx9ec8j หลายเดือนก่อน

      Tigers fan here-I agree. If Tigers deal Skubal, the front office have no faith in what the Tigers can do in the next couple of seasons, and we have rebuild 3.0 which is just plain depressing.

  • @florida1289
    @florida1289 หลายเดือนก่อน +2

    Skubal is the best pitcher in baseball and hes just getting started. Yes, you can point to other pitchers that have accomplished more in their past but thats what makes Skubal so enticing his HOF career is still in front of him.

  • @seanhenderson2498
    @seanhenderson2498 หลายเดือนก่อน +3

    I’m not as MLB expert when it comes to trades and what not and l’m an Orioles fan but we definitely need some pitching if we want to win a championship. We have so many good prospects in the farm system that we don’t even have the room for all of them to play as full-time starters on the field anyways. So, l will say just trade some of them prospects to fix our weaknesses so we could get what we need to go and get someone that is not a rental as well.

    • @xcc9162
      @xcc9162 หลายเดือนก่อน +2

      Absolutely, Skubal fits this mold perfectly, this is the best opportunity to utilize our prospect capital to massively improve our roster

  • @americanadreaming
    @americanadreaming หลายเดือนก่อน +6

    If Baltimore won't offer up 3 of their top 5 prospects, Detroit won't consider. Trading a power lefty in the middle of a Cy Young season and pennant race is a hard sell to the fans and owner.
    Plus, the Tigers were great when they kept trading their farm for actual players. None of what they traded for Miguel Cabrera, David Price, or other big gets turned into stars.
    Remember that Boston and NY will be window shopping in Detroit, too.

    • @rugbyslug
      @rugbyslug หลายเดือนก่อน +3

      Well, then I say: enjoy your non-playoff season and ace pitcher, guys.

    • @jpalmer9286
      @jpalmer9286 หลายเดือนก่อน

      ​@@rugbyslugExactly

    • @DennisK-q9g
      @DennisK-q9g หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      ⁠​⁠​⁠@@rugbyslug I’m a Tigers fan, and let me say first, I don’t think a Skubal trade happens to any team. 1) The Tigers must get a good return for Skubal because he is a top five pitcher with controllable years. Detroit is under no time pressure to trade Skubal, so the price is going to be high. 2) Only Baltimore has the high end prospects to get a deal done, but historically hang on to their top prospects. Myself, I think Tigers fans are crazy to think they are getting two of the top three prospects. But, Os fans are equally crazy to think the can get Skubal without offering one of Holliday or Mayo ( they are exactly what Detroit needs). This is the deal, I think happens, if it happens, Skubal for Holliday or Mayo, Norby, and a good (not great) AA pitching prospect.

    • @americanadreaming
      @americanadreaming หลายเดือนก่อน +3

      @@rugbyslug Tigers fans said the same thing when we traded the farm to get guys like Miguel Cabrera and others. Enjoy your magic beans, we will keep the Cy Young pitcher.

    • @americanadreaming
      @americanadreaming หลายเดือนก่อน +2

      @@jpalmer9286 How many power lefty, price controlled, guys under 27 that are leading the Cy Young race have ever been traded? Do you see what you are asking for? This isn't some veteran rental.
      You need to pay to get players like this.

  • @fall7991
    @fall7991 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    Guy knows his stuff

  • @larrydanadavid2435
    @larrydanadavid2435 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    The Orioles would be better off trading for Flaherty. They wouldn’t have to give up as much. I see the Tigers signing Skubal.

  • @winnguyen443
    @winnguyen443 หลายเดือนก่อน +4

    Trade won’t happen, both teams have leverage. Move on , nothing to see here.

  • @BrutallyOrange
    @BrutallyOrange หลายเดือนก่อน

    Dang. I was close!

  • @mainetain15
    @mainetain15 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Ryan, I think Stowers is about to be the odd man out and traded for pitching.
    Outfield is tougher to crack than infield rn. Mullins is not going anywhere anytime soon, Satander, Kjerstad and Cowser will get the majority of the at bats. Thats not including Austin Hays. Plus Ohearn can play corner OF when needed.
    Hyde said when Stowers went back down he did nothing wrong and he is a MLB player whether here or somewhere else. Idk that was weird to say about a young guy thats actually here and getting sent back with .300+ avg in limited playing time.

  • @rugbyslug
    @rugbyslug หลายเดือนก่อน +4

    I say forget trading the farm for Skubal or Crochet. Go get a solid 2/3 starter and focus on stud bullpen pieces. The O's need bullpen help for the playoff push.

    • @cmartin834
      @cmartin834 หลายเดือนก่อน

      Yes, been saying this. May be cool to have one of these guys but we absolutely do not need them and should not give up the farm for them. This isn’t MLB The Show lol. Go get Fedde and some bullpen arms and we will be straight.

    • @xcc9162
      @xcc9162 หลายเดือนก่อน

      This trade wouldn’t just affect this season, sure you would get Skubal for this Playoff push, which would be invaluable, but you get him for at least 2 more. If Corbin leaves we will absolutely need a 1 starter, which is not Grayson. Adding Skubal also doesn’t preclude you from trading for a solid rental bullpen price like Brebbia, Yates, Robertson, or whoever else.

    • @zackmclef1911
      @zackmclef1911 หลายเดือนก่อน

      That’s the route I’d like to see them go also

    • @DennisK-q9g
      @DennisK-q9g หลายเดือนก่อน

      Even a #2 is going to cost more than you think.

  • @pnantais1111
    @pnantais1111 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    Tigers are absolute fools if they trade Skubal to Orioles for anyone not named Holliday as the centerpiece and Orioles are absolute fools if they include him so this = stalemate and as a Tigers fan, I am thrilled with that. Extend Skubal now and build around him! Orioles fans should be equally thrilled if they don't lose Holliday.

  • @romemvp
    @romemvp หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    Holiday, Kjerstad and Either Stowers, Fabian, Norby or Bradfield

    • @esasoftware1900
      @esasoftware1900 หลายเดือนก่อน +2

      No chance

    • @User-b9q2z
      @User-b9q2z หลายเดือนก่อน

      No chance you get him with any less​@@esasoftware1900

    • @jpalmer9286
      @jpalmer9286 หลายเดือนก่อน

      ​@@esasoftware1900Right

    • @johnbaber9660
      @johnbaber9660 หลายเดือนก่อน +2

      Forget detroit

    • @jamesrawlings6694
      @jamesrawlings6694 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      You’re insane. Thankfully not the GM

  • @jonathonbloomfield9912
    @jonathonbloomfield9912 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    He's probably the only untouchable for the tigers

    • @robertfrost9934
      @robertfrost9934 หลายเดือนก่อน

      Riley Greene, Colt Keith also

  • @sundaygolfer79
    @sundaygolfer79 หลายเดือนก่อน

    No mayo, jackson, and heston

  • @soarinskies1105
    @soarinskies1105 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    The fact you wouldn’t even be willing to trade Mayo is insulting
    Also btw Bassallo as a primary asset in a potential deal would be a terrible trade for the tigers
    Bassallo can’t receive the ball and work on developing pitchers by calling games
    Who cares if he can hit, defense, game calling and pitcher development are infinitely more important at that position
    With his bat or his arm he’d be a first basemen, which we don’t need.
    If you can’t even at minimum say Mayo would be the primary asset in a potential trade then I’m sorry but we are just too far apart then.
    Stop trying to pitch Bassalo to us, 1st base is like the easiest position to replace on the Diamond so why would we waste a hot commodity trading for a catcher who is likely to become a first basemen, when I can just move colt Keith to 1st and then call up Jace jung at second base, and thus solve my first base and 2nd base problem in 1 move.
    Mayo Norby Beaver/McDermott and you have our attention

    • @jpalmer9286
      @jpalmer9286 หลายเดือนก่อน

      Tigers not getting Mayo

    • @DennisK-q9g
      @DennisK-q9g หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      @@jpalmer9286Tiger fan here, I don’t want Mayo for the same reason, we don’t want Basallo, he is looking like a 1B or LF. They are both great hitting prospects, but their gloves make them 1B. If there is a trade, it’s going to come down to Holliday being the major piece from the Os. Detroit’s best prospect who is likely to stay at SS, was just drafted this year. I’d like Holliday, Norby and a AA pitcher for Skubal. If Baltimore says no to that, then I don’t see it getting done.

    • @jpalmer9286
      @jpalmer9286 หลายเดือนก่อน

      @DennisK-q9g I would love to get Skubal I think he can put Baltimore over the top so hopefully the 2 teams can make a deal

    • @soarinskies1105
      @soarinskies1105 หลายเดือนก่อน

      @@jpalmer9286if you would love to get Skubal you gotta give us a real 3rd basemen who can help us. You don’t want to give up Mayo that’s ok we can take Westburg instead, but if you really love Skubal and want this trade to happen you aren’t keeping both. I gotta have 1, Westburg or Mayo and we can go from there, take your pick.

  • @mrcstravels
    @mrcstravels หลายเดือนก่อน

    Detroit will only trade Skubal if they are blow away with 2.5 years of team control if there is a trade yes Holiday must be part of it and Mayo then maybe an arm to add in. Its alot but you are getting alot and frankly the Tigers would almost be just as happy not making a trade so it would need to be a trade package that rich to get it done

  • @BrutallyOrange
    @BrutallyOrange หลายเดือนก่อน

    Calling it, OHearn pinch hits for Mountcastle and hits a 3 run game tying homer.

  • @AB-jr9ny
    @AB-jr9ny หลายเดือนก่อน

    Skubal for Orioles top 2 prospects + Kjerstad.

  • @VoxVeritas1776
    @VoxVeritas1776 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Any deal with the Orioles must include Jackson Holiday

    • @nicklove3963
      @nicklove3963 หลายเดือนก่อน

      Bullshit

    • @DennisK-q9g
      @DennisK-q9g หลายเดือนก่อน

      @@nicklove3963tigers fans feel the same way about trading Skubal without getting Holliday. If both fan bases are correct, there will be no trade at all.

  • @Bubbsttv19
    @Bubbsttv19 หลายเดือนก่อน

    If I’m the orioles, I do this trade in a heartbeat. Even with Holliday as the centerpiece. The whole point of accumulating top prospects is to eventually get enough to win a World Series. If you get skubal, you expedite your chances and propel yourself to the top of the A.L overnight giving yourself the best chances to win now. You gotta do this trade. Skubal is under team control on an amazing contract so you can spend and compound free agents to this enticing club, but ONLY if you get skubal now. In my opinion, if you get Skubal you win the World Series this year. You only get so many chances.

  • @rstaples5426
    @rstaples5426 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Bring up Basallis and dfa McCann

  • @paulvonauth7254
    @paulvonauth7254 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    this is stupid. Without pitching in today's MLB you have nothing, the Tigers have a "Lamborghini" in Skubal. You wait till the final day, the final 12 hours and accept offers. Sorry folks, no "Fords or Chevy's", maybe a Ferrari, Porsche, and Audi in exchange being it is the "motor city"!!!

  • @The_Gunner9
    @The_Gunner9 หลายเดือนก่อน

    I would take Reece Olsen

  • @davids9520
    @davids9520 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    The Tiger "doormats" finished in 2nd place last season. The Tigers have lost all three of their opening day outfielders. Their opening day 1st baseman is in AAA. They've lost three starting pitchers to injuries. Plus last years closer. Do that to the Yankees, and lets see them compete for 1st place in the East. These are just more baseball pundits, who never watch the Tigers. Time to go.

  • @GreatBlueMako
    @GreatBlueMako หลายเดือนก่อน +2

    Orioles are gonna shit the bed this trade season like every trade season

    • @jayseaborg3895
      @jayseaborg3895 หลายเดือนก่อน +2

      You mean like the Mancini trade that yielded Seth Johnson and McDemott and the Lopez trade that brought Cano and Povich? LOL.

    • @GreatBlueMako
      @GreatBlueMako หลายเดือนก่อน

      @@jayseaborg3895 Told ya

    • @jayseaborg3895
      @jayseaborg3895 หลายเดือนก่อน

      @@GreatBlueMako WTF does this mean? Told me what? Their trades were fine, and most of the analyst agree.

    • @GreatBlueMako
      @GreatBlueMako หลายเดือนก่อน

      @@jayseaborg3895 Those trades are working out impeccably

  • @davewhite113
    @davewhite113 หลายเดือนก่อน

    They should go after Mitch Keller.

  • @jeremybear573
    @jeremybear573 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    I would trade Bassaio as he may not be up until 2 years later.

  • @Truthtella
    @Truthtella หลายเดือนก่อน +2

    Detroit better not trade Skubal unless they are getting Jackson Holiday back. There is no other prospect that's worth a left handed power pitcher whose about to win the Cy young. Holiday is where it starts and ends if I'm Detroit.

    • @jpalmer9286
      @jpalmer9286 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      Lol

    • @Truthtella
      @Truthtella หลายเดือนก่อน +3

      @@jpalmer9286 You can laugh but what is a potential World Series in the next 2 years worth as oppose to having Holiday.

    • @DennisK-q9g
      @DennisK-q9g หลายเดือนก่อน

      @@jpalmer9286You can laugh, but what did you think the Tigers would take for Skubal? If the names Holliday or Mayo are not part of the trade, then you’re dreaming my friend. And good luck getting Miller or Crochet with one of those guys leaving. Any top pitcher with years of control left is going to cost a top prospect. Teams are not trading their best player for 4-5 “lottery ticket” prospects. You guys have a really good farm system, but it is very top heavy, I think once you get past the top three players, many teams could outbid you. Not that I think the Tigers will accept any trade offer that doesn’t include a top 15-20 overall prospect. So that leaves Boston and Baltimore as the only teams with a realistic chance to convince Detroit to let Skubal go. I understand it’s hard to give up great prospects, but if you think you’re getting a pennant changing pitcher without that sacrifice, I can only say good luck to you.

    • @Bubbsttv19
      @Bubbsttv19 หลายเดือนก่อน

      @@Truthtellathis right here. The whole point of accumulating top prospects is to win one. Skubal would turn the orioles into a juggernaut the next few years.

    • @howardsun
      @howardsun หลายเดือนก่อน +2

      Holiday + Mayo for Skubal sounds a reasonable trade, O's fan wont like it now but when playoff time comes a solid ace pitcher could help the team wins the big one

  • @Methoes123
    @Methoes123 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Why can't Santander be at front of trade? Santander, Cowser, Norby, Fabian, and Povich should get a trade done!

    • @Methoes123
      @Methoes123 หลายเดือนก่อน

      I'd offer same trade to Seattle for Gilbert !

    • @romemvp
      @romemvp หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      Santander is a Free Agent after this season

    • @kosanmr2
      @kosanmr2 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      Santander has very little value to Detroit. Santander is a FA, and Detroit is not in contention for the playoffs.

  • @User-b9q2z
    @User-b9q2z หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    How bout Fabian and Norby for Skubal? Still an overpay probably by most peoples standards lol

    • @DennisK-q9g
      @DennisK-q9g หลายเดือนก่อน

      Is Fabian still considered good Prospect? His K numbers are and always have been just horrible. The Tigers certainly would have no interest, as they claim the new system philosophy is strike zone control. Fabian is as far away from that as it possible.

    • @howardsun
      @howardsun หลายเดือนก่อน

      Tigers GM would hang up right away , Holiday Mayo and Bassalo two out three have to headline for Skubal plus some draft picks

  • @chrisfranco6603
    @chrisfranco6603 หลายเดือนก่อน

    DO NOT trade any of the top hitter prospects unless you are getting a superstar HITTER in his prime back. Pitchers today are continually falling apart. I’m ok with our pitching prospects for a stud pitcher. But other than that, forget it! If we trade hitting prospects for a guy that’s got great pitching stats now, but that guy is way over his normal usage, I’m telling you it’s a bad deal, because that pitcher we get back is going to get hurt!

  • @TrewlPatrol
    @TrewlPatrol หลายเดือนก่อน

    Blue Jays should trade Vlady and Gausman to the O’s for Holliday and a top pitching prospect

  • @user-hg8ot4nc5v
    @user-hg8ot4nc5v หลายเดือนก่อน

    The Tigers’ skin Flint, trust fund owner would NEVER pay Skubal when the time comes. Trade him now.