@@l_ifeefi_l1998The difference betwwen mysejahtera and padu is the sheer amount of personal data concentrated within one database. When there's a leak in mysejahtera, you lose vaccination and some check-in record, bad as that may be. When there's a leak in padu, all your financial data is exposed. If you can't even see the difference between the two, then please don't vote, because your vote would be highly uninformed.
Saya mahu awak tanya bos awak yg awak kata bakal jadi ketua menteri swak kan datang bila kenyalang gold card holder dapat free medical check up di private hospital .Abg jo cakap siapa 2 yg ada kenyalang gold card free medical check up di private hospital atau private clinic semua di kos di tanggung olih kerjaan GPS .
Saya mahu awak tanya yb karim dan Abg Jo kenapa rakyat sarawak berumur 60 ke atas mohon kenyalang gold card sampai 6 bulan atau lebih .maknya GPS tak dapat urus atau laksana kenyalang gold card dgan baik ..
@@akiburung746 SAYA MAHU AWAK PERGI JABATAN KEBAJIKAN SARAWAK, NUAN PERGI SANA, TANYA GOLD CARD HOLDER DAN MOHON ENTI BULIH! ANANG KAMU CAKAP DISII, KAMU SUDAH BESAR, UTUH PUN UDAH BEBULU, ANANG KAMU KOMEN SINI SAJA, TAPI TIDAK BUAT APA2 😂😂😂😂😂😂
@@akiburung746 JANGAN KAMU TANYA SAYA SAYA UKAI SAPIT KEPALA MENTERI SARAWAK, KAMU MAU TANYA, PERGI PAGE OFFICAL KERAJAAN NEGERI SARAWAK, INI KAMU CAKAP DALAM KOMEN SURUH SAYA TANYA BUAT APA? 😂 SAYA UKAI SAPIT KEPALA MENTERI, SAYA CUMA RAKYAT BIASA KOMEN PEMIMPIN KITAI SARAWAK MANAH ARI ORG MALAYA, TAPI KAMU ENDA SETUJU, MAU KOMEN SINI.. AKAI 😂
@@ShahrulJohan let's not simply accuse his son or any parties yet. We can still hear the gentleman/lady above's comments without jumping to negative conclusions. You might be stressing people out for no reason.
Find out first why so much reluctance to fill PADU data before making assumptions. Get feed back. This Sarawakian Ministers podcast tells the real story. He has spoken with an open mind and we voters share his views 100%
Every info that we all key in will be used against us. If you are B40, Padu will reject your application as you may owned a million ringgit property which is inherited. The reason we need to provide all private info is to used against us in future.
The reason is like this minister. The govt will always introduce a new system or new initiative so that there will be crony 3rd party contractor or service provider that will get the multimillion ringgit project. If just maintain the current system how to award new million2 project to the cronies meh? 😊
Given Rafizi's background as the founder of Invoke Malaysia, it's wise to bear some degree of suspicions on that data pooling system. There is definitely something fishy with PADU considering Invoke Malaysia is his political tool in stategizing for electoral advantage. Also, bear in mind that Invoke Malaysia is assisted occasionally by Andrew Caster, an analytics officer from former US President Barack Obama's 2012 reelection campaign. Just hope that the CIA isn't involved in this fiasco.
CIA expect returns on their investments through NED funding PKR, Anwar and his "boys" for 20 plus years. Where do you think a convicted sodomite get money to run a political opposition?
Rafizi the Minister wants PADU, why? Rafizi has the Big Data company Invoke. How can we ever be sure that Rakyat's sensitive datas are being manipulated by Invoke for political aims, as he did before for PKR? Let LHDN do their Job as before. It is LHDN inherent Job to get accurate datas pf Rakyat because our Taxes, government income also depends on LHDN. And secure these Rakyat datas at all cost.
They shd extend the deadline to register for PADU so that the concerns of citizens can be addressed first. They shd tell us what sort of subsidies will be affected if we do not register for PADU.
Its silly and redundant to have a 'padu'. Where the personal data are already with income tax dept and other government agencies. This only make it harder for the common folk, who really needed help and assistance. Dumb idea as it is, and wasting resources. Is malaysia being a police state.
Look like this is one of the ways to force the people to declare their assets in order to assess their qualification for govt financial assistance eg BR1M, STR, subsidy etc
this is true, but the problem is, guarantee is that your data secure or not. I hve group, someone told me his bank acount missing some money after rgster padu about 2 days later. another group share, someone hack PADU server and show people ID, the ID information price sell about 140K USD to someone.
Data peribadi dah ada di pangkalan data kenapa nak lagi buat pangkalan data yg lain, bukankah ini akan membuka ruang untuk kecurian data peribadi berlaku. Klu mahu bantu rakyat data dah isi. Gunakan data yg sedia ada.
Dengan PADU ni baru subsidi bersasar boleh dilancarkan. Aim nya, hanya pemilik mykad yg dapat benefit. Macam sekarang, warga asing, pati, unchr semua dapat manfaat dari hasil tax pemilik my kad dan pemilik syarikat... bayangkan, suatu hari nanti sistem ni dah "padu" semua pemilik mykad telah diperuntukkan mengikut kelayakkan masing2, dan pada ketika itu semua subsidi ditarik balik, apa jadi? -pati , unchr atau bukan target subsidi bersasar akan auto balik, sebab malaysia MAHAL -tiada lagi isu sorok barang subsidi atau seludup, sebab harga SAMA 😂 -peluang pekerjaan bertambah(ramai dah balik) -link kan dengan mykad, dan jabatan2 lain(macam pdrm) supaya jika individu buat jenayah, masuk dalam rekod sekali. sistem PADU ada potensi yg besar utk jadi intelligent system. JIKA ia berlaku sebegini, bukankah ia menguntungkan rakyat malaysia juga? ini yg saya nampak, bukankah ini yg kita mahukan?
Dulu, kita diugut kalau tak amik baksin (walhal, baksin tu sukarela). Sekarang, kita diugut kalau tak daftar PADU (walhal, PADU itu sukarela). Itu padahnya kita pilih pembohong2 sebagai YB2 kita.
@@norsilakhalid5923 Siapa yg sebenarnya rompak harta rakyat? Hampir semua YB2 kita (dulu dan sekarang)!!! Mrk buat undang2 halalkan rompak duit rakyat melalui politikal fund, politikal appt dan peruntukan YB rm 3.5 juta setiap tahun, kononnya utk 'pembangunan'.
sy tak nampak lagi apa yg awak nampak boss, kos sara hidup rakyat yg semakin pedih dan menyakitkan pada hari ini pun kerajaan tak dapat selesaikan. Malah lebih teruk dalam sejarah pentadbiran Malaysia setakat ini..Inikan pula nak buat sistem yg merepek repek bagai.
Adakah anda tidak perlu isi minyak kereta lagi? Atau adakah anda sudah tidak perlukan apa-apa bantuan dari kerajaan lagi? Kalau semua dah cukup, alhamdulillah.
The very reason the gov need rakyat to key in the data themselves is fishy. Kwsp act prohibits the declaration of information to 3rd party, which the government couldn't gt their hands on
Just do a data field CVSmethod porting& mapping.. less than 3hr.job using main frame computer. 1 mth for a team to verify & data entry for corrections. Cost abt rm300k only or less.😅🎉
How much did the Madani Govt. spend on this PADU thing?. Its rakyat's monies..There are so many other sources to obtain such info for free.. How do the banks gather personal data. Do they need a grand scheme like PADU?
Menteri Sarawak ini salah. Privasi data? Maklumat privasi kita ada di hospital, sekolah, bank, insurans, SPR dan merata tempat. Tujuan PADU adalah untuk mengelakkan mana-mana rakyat tidak tercicir dalam bantuan kerajaan dan tiada orang menipu dalam bantuan. Kenapa sekarang bantah? Masa Menteri Ekonomi bentang di parlimen kenapa MP2 GPS diam je?
setuju sangat. dengan cara kumpulan data sebegini. barulah subsidi bersasar boleh dilakukan. semua subsidi diberi terus kepada pemilik mykad, dengan amaun mengikut kelayakkan. selepas dah padu, baru tarik subsidi barang. semua pemilik mykad dah dapat haknya. jd yg tinggal, barang yg takde subsidi. Dalam masa sama, tiada isu sorok minyak, seludup petrol lagi,
Mintak gambar ic depan belakang,tak cukup tu suruh ambil gambar muka pulak.belom pernah aku daftar bantuan kerajaan mintak detail macam ni. Macam tak percaya kita ni rakyat malaysia. + detail yang dia mintak tu bagi aku tak logic. Bersih cukup mudah sampai pada rakyat kenapa bila ada dap pkr dalam kerajaan semua benda nampak macam makin rumit?.
To me, I'm an ordinary citizen with low income, no property except for a house am living now and a 15 years old car. I needed a susidiary items given by the government including petrol to support daily expenditure. I've got nothing to hide, so be it. As for those who are rich and wealthy may be it's too risky for them to register.........Tepuk dada tanya selera😂
Jadi awak suka la terima bantuan dari kerajaan. Cuba awak tolong kerajaan bangunkan negara. Kalau setakat ordinary excuses macam ni sampai bila bila pun negara tak maju. Kita yang minority kerja memang kuat. Saving pun bagus. Kita bayar tax pun lebih. Sampai sekarang majority kami tak terima apa apa pun bantuan dari kerajaan..
Dulu ms jadi pembangkang janji mcm2 nk bantu rakyat...skg bila dah jadi kjaan buat lain...nk bagi subsidi tapi paksa rakyat telanjangkan diri sendiri dlm PADU...masa zaman BN/PN senang shj kjaan bagi subsidi
Masa Bn/Pn dulu kerajaan support subsidi dengan hutang hampir 100 billion setiap tahun. Sekarang beban hutang terkumpul dah terlampau berat. Negara boleh terus bagi subsidi, tapi bersasar.
Rafizi is not the righteous person I thought he was!! He talks too much nowadays and the flaws are showing with all the initiative he is handling on subsidies. With Padu he is showing his arrogant side n naive and instead of being receptive of the feedback/criticism, he seem to be aggressively defending. He is asking for info as if this is a ideal and just world without thieves, hacker, scammer, .....There must be a reason why so many ppl are not filling the PADU information. PADU to me is like LHDN, Banking info, CV, Asset Declaration, Family Tree etc all in one. It is a honeypot for scammers, thieves and hackers. The Sarawak minister is the only main person to voice out. I am disappointed with DAP AGAIN. Imagine if this was BN Govt's PADU, DAP would have voiced out loudly against the PADU but here silent like a church mouse. HOPE PMX Anwar pls wake up. This is a serious breach of privacy while scammer activities are so rampant and not dealt with, this information shared will cause/create further chaos !! While on one hand, Rafizi says PADU is not compulsory, on the other hand he is silently threatening that subsidy or funds will not be channelled if failure to receive those info.
Masalahnya sekarang ni ramai yang menipu. Contohnya ada yang pakai kereta Mercedes, datang klinik swasta nak ambik ubat under skim perubatan Madani. Kalau semua org jujur, tak perlu dah nak isi padu. Sebab tahu data pengurusan kerajaan tu betul.
Itu Pendirian peribadi yb Karim.sepertimana yg yb RR bagitahu telah ramai rakyat Sarawak b40/rakyat biasa mendaftar padu ,cuma yg bekerja dgn kerjaan Belum mendaftar.
Sebab siapa banyak aset takut di dedah sebab itu cakap padu tak betul dan tak bagus .saya mahu tanya kepada yB kenapa warga sarawak umur 60 keatas mohon kenyalang gold card ngambil masa sampai 6 bulan lebih cuba yb jawap kenapa ngambil masa terlama sila beri jawapan .
PADU ni untuk yang memerlukan bantuan; yang kaya dan dah tak perlu bantuan tak perlu comply with the requirement. Cuma, later when Govt float semua harga barang (petrol, diesel, gula, garam, minyak masak, etc) at market rate, jangan pula geng “tak PADU” ini complaint harga mahal, kos sara hidup tinggi dll. The choice is yours. In fact, lagi sikit orang comply dengan PADU, lagi baik kepada kewangan Negara kerana tidak perlu keluarka dana yang banyak untuk penyasaran semula subsidi kepada rakyat; lalu dana boleh disalurkan kepada urusan pembangunan lain.
The Government has to address the issue of privacy. However when targeted subsidies are to be implemented, it will be a challenge without the right data which will definitely lead to dissatisfaction.
Very well said sir I just dont understand why PADU need ..Bank Statement or bank info bukan ke itu P& C.😭 Bukan ke dalam kad KP IC sudah ada byk maklumat peribadi😫 kita.Then every mth pihak pengurusan/Management hantar penyata berkenaan EPF ke PEJABAT HASIL DLM NEGERI . 🙄😳😭 Lagi pun i tak pernah dapat apa2 bantuan/ SUMBANGAN selama ini .Jadi saya pun tak mahu, tak akan Daftar PADU. full stop.
More taxation in due course as Govt. coffers run dry. Check your spending first and reduce expenditure. No short cuts. Fortunately, decided finally to scrap the Commonwealth Games offer.Australia declined. Birmingham went bankrupt by hosting it. Do fall for traps just for pride reasons.
kalau tak buat macam tu how do they know yang u layak dapat bantuan bersasar. Saya rasa ianya adalah prosedur yang betul the way nak force people declare.
@@lookup90 LHDN, KWSP, agensi-agensi kerajaan semua tu ada. Seperti BKM, BRIM sebelum2 ni. Sistem PADU tu lebih seperti mahu tahu maklumat privasi org. Cth. pendapatan berapa, tanggungan, hutang, insuran semua tu, jumlah bayaran hutang semua. Itu semua maklumat sensitif, darak!
Well said Sarawakian. Is confidentiality maintained after personal information is disclosed to PADU. Why introduce PADU just to give out subsidies.? Let the needy ask and then ask them to disclose personal data for verification purposes. Don't use PADU as a threat for future subsidies. The rich do do not need fuel subsidies. Its just the B4 group and below
takut sangkut income tax boleh jadi, ada bisnes itu ini, sangkut pulak SSM tak byr cukai pendapatan compny itu jer y dia takutkan. Untuk org yang sush betul-betul memerlukan, dia tak takut pun nak declare sebab takde apa nak dirahsiakan, sebb diorg takde aset.
persoalannya kerajaan malaysia ditunggang oleh siapa? kerajaan kena laksanakan padu tapi tak bertanggungjawan atas data, ada pihak lain yang bertanggungjawab, kerajaan just tolong buat je
Tak perlu la nak politikkan pasal ambik data utk PRU ke apa, tak pasal pasal menakutkan org. Maklumat utk PADU disyorkan isi sendiri utk kemas kini & elakkan keciciran. Kalau rasa dah kaya & tak perlu bantuan, tak perlu la isi. Data pentadbiran dah ada cuma ada yg dah outdated. E-kasih guna pengkelasan B40, M40 etc, PADU nak fokus dekat disposable income, sebab tu kena ada format baru.
@@sarwakigunet2807 exactly, I'm worried for the people who needs the most: the poor & the people who salary in the M40 region but their monthly commitment resulted them to be B40. If you don't like the current gov, it's up to you but don't mislead people.
There had been data theft. Banks have lost such data like name, IC number, address and phone number. Also bank balances. If PADU loses data, it as far worse.
He is not politicised about it just he raise his concern....bcoz all the while there is lhdn...jpn & banks already have our personal data....so why need to declare ur whole privacy matters to the system? There is ekasih platform so for those who affected & needed bantuan then let them fill in just like previous system....that what he mean...bcoz after Padu has been implemented there a lot of reports that they money in the bank has been stolen....why want to complicated things if previous system has been established for few yrs?
Secondly why u want to force whole citezens to fill in padu yet as what pizi said it is just for those who qualified for those bantuan? With excuses to avoid some ppl will manipulate their income to get the bantuan... come on this is 2024 & rkyt are not stupid bcoz with previous system also they can identified to those who eligible or not for the bantuan...that ia why majority rkyt suspicious about this padu system...unless they as menteri2 also tgther fill in their personal data sme with rkyt then oklh...
YB karim jangan cakap pasar padu kenyalang gold card kenapa Kerajaan GPS tak dapat di urus dgan baik kenapa ngambil masa yg lama sehingga 6 bulan atau 1 tahun sila yb karaim .
PADU tidak jauh bezanya dengan BANCI PENDUDUK....perlunya diketahui pendapatan rakyat.Larangan untuk isi PADU adakah untuk cuba mengelak dari diketahui "rahsia" pendapatan atau tahap kemiskinan rakyat disesebuah negeri?Orang kaya.....akan berlakunya "pengubalan wang haram"
Subsidi adalah tanggungjawab kerajaan tanpa membezakan kaya, pertengahan atau kurang mampu. Bagi yang kaya mereka telah dikenakan bayaran cukai yang banyak dari setiap perbelanjaan begitu juga pertenghan yang dipotong dari gaji bulanan dan juga bagi yang kurang mampu mereka diberikan bantuan STR dan lain-lain, ianya adil jika dilihat. Adakan ini adalah jalan mudah atau disebut sebagai CABUT dari tanggungjawab ???
@@ShahrulJohan ni sorg lagi kaki kencing kaki fitnah. camne pulak ko tau aku bagi google mcm2 data? camne pulak ko tahu aku tak complain? kalo kau suke bagi pada rafizi, bagi je. terpulang pada ko😂nanti ape2 jgn complain pulak weh.
ikut sahaja saranan kerajaan ini.. apa yg penting nnt.. Kita nak tengok kesan drpd formula PADU ini kpd kehidupan rakyat yg miskin susah.. kalau setakat bantuan Rm100 - 300 utk 3 - 4 bulan.. mcm bantuan Str.. apa la sangat.. duit Rm200-Rm300 sekali beli barangan dapur dah pun lesap sekelip mata.. jadi kita sama2 tunggu dan lihat keberkesanan formula PADU ini kpd kehidupan rakyat yg miskin susah di Malaysia.. apakah ianya benar2 bole membantu rakyat.. itu yg penting.. kalau tak sia2 saja kita sokong kerajaan ini..
Padu is the best system made for citizens to check if they eligible for help..only sarawak gps dont want this so that thier citizens wont be able to expose their financial backgrounds....which is one of poorest in Malaysia
If government want to help poor, easy just go through epf. Can know through the amount that cut.then help. If kerja sendiri there should be another way.
Yes. If the govment wants to help the poor, let the poor fill up padu & qualify for aid. Those who do not need padu aid do not need to fill. Then this fair & democratic
Cakap besar yB karim sila jawap saya kena kenyalang gold card tidak dapat di lulus atau tidak dapat di buat satu hari kenapa ngambil masa sampai 6 bulan .
![[KINI JELAS] Mampukah Najib terlepas kes 1MDB? Sorotan skandal $4.5 bilion](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/t5b76tdDknU/mqdefault.jpg)
![ไข้ขึ้นเลย! เมื่อแฝดโดนจัดเต็มวัคซีนครบ2เดือน🤒 [cc] แดนแพทตี้ SS2 | EP.54 |](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/z2VHItnyyvY/mqdefault.jpg)
Thats not the way to ask for information .. i totally agree with you ..why need another system 🤦♀️🤦♀️🤦♀️
"I don't think that is a proper way to treat your citizens" So true...exercise your vote wisely in the next GE.
Vote lanun again. So vip like karim will be kaya bertambah kaya
Agreed. No more votes for Madani Govt, at next GE
But last time mysejahtera also diff govt. Wats the difference?
@@l_ifeefi_l1998The difference betwwen mysejahtera and padu is the sheer amount of personal data concentrated within one database. When there's a leak in mysejahtera, you lose vaccination and some check-in record, bad as that may be. When there's a leak in padu, all your financial data is exposed.
If you can't even see the difference between the two, then please don't vote, because your vote would be highly uninformed.
@@TerenceTHNgvote penyakau yang tak declare income?
Boleh nampak dah bakal KETUA MENTERI SARAWAK.. HUMBLE & TEGAS 👍👍👍
Tak layak jadi ketua menteri .
Saya mahu awak tanya bos awak yg awak kata bakal jadi ketua menteri swak kan datang bila kenyalang gold card holder dapat free medical check up di private hospital .Abg jo cakap siapa 2 yg ada kenyalang gold card free medical check up di private hospital atau private clinic semua di kos di tanggung olih kerjaan GPS .
Saya mahu awak tanya yb karim dan Abg Jo kenapa rakyat sarawak berumur 60 ke atas mohon kenyalang gold card sampai 6 bulan atau lebih .maknya GPS tak dapat urus atau laksana kenyalang gold card dgan baik ..
@@akiburung746 SAYA MAHU AWAK PERGI JABATAN KEBAJIKAN SARAWAK, NUAN PERGI SANA, TANYA GOLD CARD HOLDER DAN MOHON ENTI BULIH! ANANG KAMU CAKAP DISII, KAMU SUDAH BESAR, UTUH PUN UDAH BEBULU, ANANG KAMU KOMEN SINI SAJA, TAPI TIDAK BUAT APA2 😂😂😂😂😂😂
@@akiburung746 JANGAN KAMU TANYA SAYA SAYA UKAI SAPIT KEPALA MENTERI SARAWAK, KAMU MAU TANYA, PERGI PAGE OFFICAL KERAJAAN NEGERI SARAWAK, INI KAMU CAKAP DALAM KOMEN SURUH SAYA TANYA BUAT APA? 😂 SAYA UKAI SAPIT KEPALA MENTERI, SAYA CUMA RAKYAT BIASA KOMEN PEMIMPIN KITAI SARAWAK MANAH ARI ORG MALAYA, TAPI KAMU ENDA SETUJU, MAU KOMEN SINI.. AKAI 😂
Padu have no respect for rakyat Privacy...
100% yes..I agree with yr openion concern!! Ada pro n cons or bnyk yg buruk akan berlaku diblkng hari nanti..!!!
That time we have no choice but to register for MySejahtera with the IC and facescan all that. This is giving me the same vibe.
I was told it is now available in dark web.
True And Incompleted They Want People To Register But Langkawi Not Even In System Did Langkawi Became Independent Country
you give a lot more information to google, your locaiton, you photos, what you search, what you type etc, Dont want to complain?
Betul tuan🎉
When my son registered for haji, then he got strangers callings. They're selling ours and semuanya bogel publicly ❤❤❤
Are you you because your registered for haji? Maybe because you or your son visits or download pirate, malicious website, software on the internet?
@@ShahrulJohan let's not simply accuse his son or any parties yet. We can still hear the gentleman/lady above's comments without jumping to negative conclusions. You might be stressing people out for no reason.
Definitely am not trusting PADU. I have lots of reservations concerning privacy of data. These info can be obtained from LHDN.
Find out first why so much reluctance to fill PADU data before making assumptions. Get feed back. This Sarawakian Ministers podcast tells the real story. He has spoken with an open mind and we voters share his views 100%
@@TerenceTHNg, same like portal basmi kemiskinan & My Sejahtera? To control & access private informations regarding finances. Dangerous
Every info that we all key in will be used against us. If you are B40, Padu will reject your application as you may owned a million ringgit property which is inherited. The reason we need to provide all private info is to used against us in future.
@@joshwai , nahhh... It's for something else. Not everyone who's B40/M40 is interested in applying for assistance.
So, don't register with PADU...sit still then!
Scammers are at the door step, waiting for the right time to strike.
Kepala bapak hang
The reason is like this minister. The govt will always introduce a new system or new initiative so that there will be crony 3rd party contractor or service provider that will get the multimillion ringgit project. If just maintain the current system how to award new million2 project to the cronies meh? 😊
Sad. Victims are the Rakyat, the users of the ill thought off system
Agreed with the minister ,its like you are throwing yourself to be naked, that's summarized the whole PADU is..
Practically asset declaration in the guise of census data. Use for dishing subsidy and aid? Even now, how they decide to give is so suspicious.
Given Rafizi's background as the founder of Invoke Malaysia, it's wise to bear some degree of suspicions on that data pooling system. There is definitely something fishy with PADU considering Invoke Malaysia is his political tool in stategizing for electoral advantage. Also, bear in mind that Invoke Malaysia is assisted occasionally by Andrew Caster, an analytics officer from former US President Barack Obama's 2012 reelection campaign. Just hope that the CIA isn't involved in this fiasco.
The CIA is always involved.
exactly..
Is this conflict of interest . Or something like that? Just asking .. but write in bahasa Malaysia pls..so that people can understand more.
CIA expect returns on their investments through NED funding PKR, Anwar and his "boys" for 20 plus years. Where do you think a convicted sodomite get money to run a political opposition?
@@Jrdtt8okye. Mmg konflik, tapi susah nak dibuktikan di mahkamah. Nak file kes pun belum tentu dapat.
Agreed fully. That why people were so hesitant to fill PADU. So many things to fill. Half way fill. Give up already.
The computer guys did not test run its project. Just launch first and try luck. So many obstacles encountered.
exactly. it's a tool for political strategy before the next election.
Not sure voters want to give madanis Govt. a second bite of the cherry with all recent happenings to our disappointment..
Exactly..this is lapiji "formula" for next GE..
Totally agree
Setuju.
It's illegal without consent from the individual 🎉❤
Rafizi the Minister wants PADU, why?
Rafizi has the Big Data company Invoke. How can we ever be sure that Rakyat's sensitive datas are being manipulated by Invoke for political aims, as he did before for PKR?
Let LHDN do their Job as before. It is LHDN inherent Job to get accurate datas pf Rakyat because our Taxes, government income also depends on LHDN. And secure these Rakyat datas at all cost.
A repeat!
They shd extend the deadline to register for PADU so that the concerns of citizens can be addressed first. They shd tell us what sort of subsidies will be affected if we do not register for PADU.
Ask ministers, MPs, YBs to declare their hidden assets first before asking normal citizen to do so.
We don't want to live in a police state. Thank you for speaking on our behalf
Its silly and redundant to have a 'padu'. Where the personal data are already with income tax dept and other government agencies. This only make it harder for the common folk, who really needed help and assistance. Dumb idea as it is, and wasting resources. Is malaysia being a police state.
Nama pun rafizi...
I don’t think you understand…
PADU already has the data for 300 government agencies .
This is just ask you to kemas kini.
@@mokt7717LOL
Then why the rakyat have to do LHDN efilling every year?
Sarawak minister no need declare income tax?
My question is why you as stateman only now you voice up? It is not right and unfair for padu.... Itu sebab bantuan tak sampai poket yang perlu...
Look like this is one of the ways to force the people to declare their assets in order to assess their qualification for govt financial assistance eg BR1M, STR, subsidy etc
this is true, but the problem is, guarantee is that your data secure or not. I hve group, someone told me his bank acount missing some money after rgster padu about 2 days later. another group share, someone hack PADU server and show people ID, the ID information price sell about 140K USD to someone.
This is what I am saying the whole time. I think the government failed on this issue
Dare to admit and rectify?
Agree… Why don’t just linked it with ctos & ccris.
Data peribadi dah ada di pangkalan data kenapa nak lagi buat pangkalan data yg lain, bukankah ini akan membuka ruang untuk kecurian data peribadi berlaku. Klu mahu bantu rakyat data dah isi. Gunakan data yg sedia ada.
Kepala bapak hang
Apasai nak maki bang? @@azharyaacob6845
@@azharyaacob6845 rajin..... menyedihkan...
Padu hanya minta kemaskini data sahaja ĺa!
Sarawak 👍💪💪💪
Dah ada ic cukup. Nak data kerajaan kena make the rakyat percaya kerajaan dulu.
Most rakyat dah hilang kepercayaan kpd present govt
Betul tu
Dengan PADU ni baru subsidi bersasar boleh dilancarkan. Aim nya, hanya pemilik mykad yg dapat benefit. Macam sekarang, warga asing, pati, unchr semua dapat manfaat dari hasil tax pemilik my kad dan pemilik syarikat...
bayangkan, suatu hari nanti sistem ni dah "padu" semua pemilik mykad telah diperuntukkan mengikut kelayakkan masing2, dan pada ketika itu semua subsidi ditarik balik,
apa jadi?
-pati , unchr atau bukan target subsidi bersasar akan auto balik, sebab malaysia MAHAL
-tiada lagi isu sorok barang subsidi atau seludup, sebab harga SAMA 😂
-peluang pekerjaan bertambah(ramai dah balik)
-link kan dengan mykad, dan jabatan2 lain(macam pdrm) supaya jika individu buat jenayah, masuk dalam rekod sekali.
sistem PADU ada potensi yg besar utk jadi intelligent system. JIKA ia berlaku sebegini, bukankah ia menguntungkan rakyat malaysia juga?
ini yg saya nampak, bukankah ini yg kita mahukan?
Dulu, kita diugut kalau tak amik baksin (walhal, baksin tu sukarela). Sekarang, kita diugut kalau tak daftar PADU (walhal, PADU itu sukarela). Itu padahnya kita pilih pembohong2 sebagai YB2 kita.
Dah try isi belum PADU? Dh tgk data apa yg dia mintak ? 😂😂😂 tgk dlu mat, data dia mintak. Takat nak sahkan citizenship, JPN ada, LHDN ada.
Sebenar BOGELkan kekayaan mereka yang merompak Harta rakyat
@@norsilakhalid5923 Siapa yg sebenarnya rompak harta rakyat? Hampir semua YB2 kita (dulu dan sekarang)!!! Mrk buat undang2 halalkan rompak duit rakyat melalui politikal fund, politikal appt dan peruntukan YB rm 3.5 juta setiap tahun, kononnya utk 'pembangunan'.
sy tak nampak lagi apa yg awak nampak boss, kos sara hidup rakyat yg semakin pedih dan menyakitkan pada hari ini pun kerajaan tak dapat selesaikan. Malah lebih teruk dalam sejarah pentadbiran Malaysia setakat ini..Inikan pula nak buat sistem yg merepek repek bagai.
Saya dalam golongan senior citizen why should i register dalam PADU
Adakah anda tidak perlu isi minyak kereta lagi? Atau adakah anda sudah tidak perlukan apa-apa bantuan dari kerajaan lagi? Kalau semua dah cukup, alhamdulillah.
@@takafulnosatu2117betul bro klau tak mahu isi padu bonus tak perlu di beri klau pesara .
@@takafulnosatu2117....tf
The very reason the gov need rakyat to key in the data themselves is fishy. Kwsp act prohibits the declaration of information to 3rd party, which the government couldn't gt their hands on
Just do a data field CVSmethod porting& mapping.. less than 3hr.job using main frame computer. 1 mth for a team to verify & data entry for corrections. Cost abt rm300k only or less.😅🎉
How much did the Madani Govt. spend on this PADU thing?. Its rakyat's monies..There are so many other sources to obtain such info for free.. How do the banks gather personal data. Do they need a grand scheme like PADU?
TERBAIK YB JAGA RAKYAT SARAWAK 👍👍👍👍👍
They are hunting for something...😂😂
I feel the same… thank you for speaking up.
Menteri Sarawak ini salah. Privasi data? Maklumat privasi kita ada di hospital, sekolah, bank, insurans, SPR dan merata tempat. Tujuan PADU adalah untuk mengelakkan mana-mana rakyat tidak tercicir dalam bantuan kerajaan dan tiada orang menipu dalam bantuan.
Kenapa sekarang bantah? Masa Menteri Ekonomi bentang di parlimen kenapa MP2 GPS diam je?
setuju sangat. dengan cara kumpulan data sebegini. barulah subsidi bersasar boleh dilakukan. semua subsidi diberi terus kepada pemilik mykad, dengan amaun mengikut kelayakkan. selepas dah padu, baru tarik subsidi barang. semua pemilik mykad dah dapat haknya. jd yg tinggal, barang yg takde subsidi. Dalam masa sama, tiada isu sorok minyak, seludup petrol lagi,
Tak boleh kata begitu GPS jangan dicabar bro ...nanti bukannya kerajaan Anwar saja boleh tumbang malah Sarawak sekali pun boleh keluar juga tahu ...
Sarawak nak keluar Malaysia ke? by all means, dipersilakan@@hamdisalleh9283
Saya sokong PADU!
Mintak gambar ic depan belakang,tak cukup tu suruh ambil gambar muka pulak.belom pernah aku daftar bantuan kerajaan mintak detail macam ni. Macam tak percaya kita ni rakyat malaysia. + detail yang dia mintak tu bagi aku tak logic. Bersih cukup mudah sampai pada rakyat kenapa bila ada dap pkr dalam kerajaan semua benda nampak macam makin rumit?.
Camera henpon ciikaii murah takkan Lepas 🤣🤣
Gambar kat IC pun kena update dulu buat ic baru
@@msah.fitribahari9022kalau hp mahal daftar boleh ke layak dapat bantuan? Selalu ramai yg pakai hp biasa atau bajet murah
To me, I'm an ordinary citizen with low income, no property except for a house am living now and a 15 years old car. I needed a susidiary items given by the government including petrol to support daily expenditure. I've got nothing to hide, so be it. As for those who are rich and wealthy may be it's too risky for them to register.........Tepuk dada tanya selera😂
Jadi awak suka la terima bantuan dari kerajaan. Cuba awak tolong kerajaan bangunkan negara. Kalau setakat ordinary excuses macam ni sampai bila bila pun negara tak maju. Kita yang minority kerja memang kuat. Saving pun bagus. Kita bayar tax pun lebih. Sampai sekarang majority kami tak terima apa apa pun bantuan dari kerajaan..
🤣🤣ORANG YANG CERDIK JER YANG TAHU PADU ITU NAK MENIPU RAKYAT,,,,IC DA CUKUP DATA RAKYAT MSIA//JUST SIMPLE,,
Kepala bapak hang
@@azharyaacob6845 sedih...
PADU is the begining of a "Police State". Once you submit your data, what is stopping them to enter into your home and property to verify your data.
Jangan susah hati sebab lepas PRU16 tukar kerajaan. Sudahlah gagal hendak menyusahkan Rakyat😮😮😮
Pas welcome u all😊
konfem lepas tukar get better goverment?? naahhhh 2x5 kong kali kong!
Ketua pembangkang semua rasuah juga😅
Very good analysis by this minister.
In the age of scams n AI, personal data must be secretive!
He spoke of good intention, ulterior motives, etc....👍
Penerangan terbaik dari D.A.Karim.
GPS.
Apa gunanya rakyat Malaysia ada IC canggih semua bantuan termasuk subsidi masuk jela ke dalam IC warganegara
Dulu ms jadi pembangkang janji mcm2 nk bantu rakyat...skg bila dah jadi kjaan buat lain...nk bagi subsidi tapi paksa rakyat telanjangkan diri sendiri dlm PADU...masa zaman BN/PN senang shj kjaan bagi subsidi
Masa Bn/Pn dulu kerajaan support subsidi dengan hutang hampir 100 billion setiap tahun. Sekarang beban hutang terkumpul dah terlampau berat. Negara boleh terus bagi subsidi, tapi bersasar.
@@adenanwasli61pergi bukak bank negara, cek berapa hutang madani buat thn 2023,dats y kne byk membaca, hutang madani buat plg tggi dlm sjarah,dkt RM104b siap klhkan hutang waktu covid yg mmg sluruh dunia prob,bkn dulu kte nk kurangkan utang ke?plz kne rajin slalu bkk external source utk dpt info lbh tepat, jgn dgr 1 pihak je, itu la br org yg ade akal
Tak telus,yg sepatutnya dapat tak dapat,yg sepatutnya tak dapat orang itulah yg dapat.adilkah namanya?
Rafizi is not the righteous person I thought he was!! He talks too much nowadays and the flaws are showing with all the initiative he is handling on subsidies. With Padu he is showing his arrogant side n naive and instead of being receptive of the feedback/criticism, he seem to be aggressively defending. He is asking for info as if this is a ideal and just world without thieves, hacker, scammer, .....There must be a reason why so many ppl are not filling the PADU information. PADU to me is like LHDN, Banking info, CV, Asset Declaration, Family Tree etc all in one. It is a honeypot for scammers, thieves and hackers. The Sarawak minister is the only main person to voice out. I am disappointed with DAP AGAIN. Imagine if this was BN Govt's PADU, DAP would have voiced out loudly against the PADU but here silent like a church mouse. HOPE PMX Anwar pls wake up. This is a serious breach of privacy while scammer activities are so rampant and not dealt with, this information shared will cause/create further chaos !! While on one hand, Rafizi says PADU is not compulsory, on the other hand he is silently threatening that subsidy or funds will not be channelled if failure to receive those info.
Spot on Sir. All Malaysia feel the same. Dah mcm Korea utara pulak Rafizi ni nak buat negera kita
Kalau takut di bogel why not we ask for independent from malaysia
Masalahnya sekarang ni ramai yang menipu. Contohnya ada yang pakai kereta Mercedes, datang klinik swasta nak ambik ubat under skim perubatan Madani. Kalau semua org jujur, tak perlu dah nak isi padu. Sebab tahu data pengurusan kerajaan tu betul.
Itu Pendirian peribadi yb Karim.sepertimana yg yb RR bagitahu telah ramai rakyat Sarawak b40/rakyat biasa mendaftar padu ,cuma yg bekerja dgn kerjaan Belum mendaftar.
Sebab siapa banyak aset takut di dedah sebab itu cakap padu tak betul dan tak bagus .saya mahu tanya kepada yB kenapa warga sarawak umur 60 keatas mohon kenyalang gold card ngambil masa sampai 6 bulan lebih cuba yb jawap kenapa ngambil masa terlama sila beri jawapan .
It is reasonable for those who apply for help especially those who are poor, to fill in forms for PADU for verification etc
PADU ni untuk yang memerlukan bantuan; yang kaya dan dah tak perlu bantuan tak perlu comply with the requirement. Cuma, later when Govt float semua harga barang (petrol, diesel, gula, garam, minyak masak, etc) at market rate, jangan pula geng “tak PADU” ini complaint harga mahal, kos sara hidup tinggi dll. The choice is yours. In fact, lagi sikit orang comply dengan PADU, lagi baik kepada kewangan Negara kerana tidak perlu keluarka dana yang banyak untuk penyasaran semula subsidi kepada rakyat; lalu dana boleh disalurkan kepada urusan pembangunan lain.
Like u said,lg ckit org yg comply dgn "Budu" lg bgus utk ngara kn,so y si Labiji ya bz ugut n insist rkyt isik..mmg Ada yg plik2 n kta rkyt x nmpk..
The Government has to address the issue of privacy. However when targeted subsidies are to be implemented, it will be a challenge without the right data which will definitely lead to dissatisfaction.
Very well said sir
I just dont understand why PADU need ..Bank Statement or bank info bukan ke itu P& C.😭
Bukan ke dalam kad KP
IC sudah ada byk maklumat peribadi😫 kita.Then every mth pihak pengurusan/Management hantar penyata berkenaan EPF ke PEJABAT HASIL DLM NEGERI . 🙄😳😭
Lagi pun i tak pernah dapat apa2 bantuan/ SUMBANGAN selama ini .Jadi saya pun tak mahu, tak akan Daftar PADU. full stop.
This government will squeeze us dry.
More taxation in due course as Govt. coffers run dry. Check your spending first and reduce expenditure. No short cuts. Fortunately, decided finally to scrap the Commonwealth Games offer.Australia declined. Birmingham went bankrupt by hosting it. Do fall for traps just for pride reasons.
True, Sir! Do we need to reveal our private information? Account bank, our loans, debts etc.
kalau tak buat macam tu how do they know yang u layak dapat bantuan bersasar. Saya rasa ianya adalah prosedur yang betul the way nak force people declare.
@@lookup90 LHDN, KWSP, agensi-agensi kerajaan semua tu ada. Seperti BKM, BRIM sebelum2 ni. Sistem PADU tu lebih seperti mahu tahu maklumat privasi org. Cth. pendapatan berapa, tanggungan, hutang, insuran semua tu, jumlah bayaran hutang semua. Itu semua maklumat sensitif, darak!
SPRM, please check how many asset this sawarak minister have?
What is his yearly income he declare?
He sound like never file income tax E-Filing.
Well said Sarawakian. Is confidentiality maintained after personal information is disclosed to PADU. Why introduce PADU just to give out subsidies.? Let the needy ask and then ask them to disclose personal data for verification purposes. Don't use PADU as a threat for future subsidies. The rich do do not need fuel subsidies. Its just the B4 group and below
Bantuan bayar loan rumah cth harga rmh 450k, tolong byr separuh ada tak. Balance kami byr sendiri tiap2 bulan
well said
Orang kaya je takut nak bg data tu😅😅😅 fhm2 sudah la
Setuju YB..move on Sarawak..sokong
Subsidi dan bantuan patut diberikan kepada rakyat yang layak.... Bukan anak menteri , warga asing atau kenalan politik...
betullah dia cakap,,, orang kaya mesti takut semua kekayaan dia orang tau...
orang gaji 3000 ke atas tak semestinya perlu isi padu..., apa nak ditakutkan....
Kalau duit haram takutlah
takut sangkut income tax boleh jadi, ada bisnes itu ini, sangkut pulak SSM tak byr cukai pendapatan compny itu jer y dia takutkan. Untuk org yang sush betul-betul memerlukan, dia tak takut pun nak declare sebab takde apa nak dirahsiakan, sebb diorg takde aset.
Menteri..yb. tycon harus declare aset mereka rakyat biasa jgn nak di nganggu
Sangat betul, what for ic ,passport.cukai registration?? Buang masa rakyat..
Terbaik menteri Sarawak 👍👍👍
When you change too often or too many times then nothing changed
Sistem kena update selalu baru lah syarikat IT buat duit
Syarikat mana ? PADU ni 100% penjawat awam yg buat
Minta pencerahan tuan lhdn, kwsp, jpn, jpj ada kena kn Syarat T&C kah seperti padu
persoalannya kerajaan malaysia ditunggang oleh siapa? kerajaan kena laksanakan padu tapi tak bertanggungjawan atas data, ada pihak lain yang bertanggungjawab, kerajaan just tolong buat je
@@slumber44 buat in house Patutlah buat syoik sendiri
@@nas7013 apa benda ni ? Cuba explain pakai bahasa mudah
PADU..😂😂😂ada aku kesahhhhhhh..tak layannnnn..
well done Sarawak.
Respect for Sarawakians.They dare to speak up for all Malaysians.
Sarawak minister don’t need to pay income tax? SPRM and LHDN, please check his asset and the tax history!
Tak perlu la nak politikkan pasal ambik data utk PRU ke apa, tak pasal pasal menakutkan org. Maklumat utk PADU disyorkan isi sendiri utk kemas kini & elakkan keciciran.
Kalau rasa dah kaya & tak perlu bantuan, tak perlu la isi. Data pentadbiran dah ada cuma ada yg dah outdated. E-kasih guna pengkelasan B40, M40 etc, PADU nak fokus dekat disposable income, sebab tu kena ada format baru.
good one...many gullible people out here....
@@sarwakigunet2807 exactly, I'm worried for the people who needs the most: the poor & the people who salary in the M40 region but their monthly commitment resulted them to be B40.
If you don't like the current gov, it's up to you but don't mislead people.
There had been data theft. Banks have lost such data like name, IC number, address and phone number. Also bank balances.
If PADU loses data, it as far worse.
Well said Sir
VERY GOOD
Agreed 💯
Be positive...dont politicised
everything Datuk Karim.Our government is trying very best to help who really deserved get the aid.
He is not politicised about it just he raise his concern....bcoz all the while there is lhdn...jpn & banks already have our personal data....so why need to declare ur whole privacy matters to the system? There is ekasih platform so for those who affected & needed bantuan then let them fill in just like previous system....that what he mean...bcoz after Padu has been implemented there a lot of reports that they money in the bank has been stolen....why want to complicated things if previous system has been established for few yrs?
Secondly why u want to force whole citezens to fill in padu yet as what pizi said it is just for those who qualified for those bantuan? With excuses to avoid some ppl will manipulate their income to get the bantuan... come on this is 2024 & rkyt are not stupid bcoz with previous system also they can identified to those who eligible or not for the bantuan...that ia why majority rkyt suspicious about this padu system...unless they as menteri2 also tgther fill in their personal data sme with rkyt then oklh...
YB karim jangan cakap pasar padu kenyalang gold card kenapa Kerajaan GPS tak dapat di urus dgan baik kenapa ngambil masa yg lama sehingga 6 bulan atau 1 tahun sila yb karaim .
PADU dah diakhir tarikh daftar baru nak bising....kenapa tak dari awal bagi ulasan?Tidak mahu isi PADU...adakah takut diketahui lambakkan harta?
Orang kaya tak perlu isi padu. Mereka tak perlu kan bantuan.
PADU tidak jauh bezanya dengan BANCI PENDUDUK....perlunya diketahui pendapatan rakyat.Larangan untuk isi PADU adakah untuk cuba mengelak dari diketahui "rahsia" pendapatan atau tahap kemiskinan rakyat disesebuah negeri?Orang kaya.....akan berlakunya "pengubalan wang haram"
Takut diketahui harta berlambak.....Dan takut diketahui pendapatan rakyat sesebuah negeri..
Good speech sir 👍
Bagaimana pula Sarawak pay...(??) As compared to Padu (??)
Terbaik YB.
Terbaek Sarawak minister, kabinet Selangor tengah tidor lagi.
Subsidi adalah tanggungjawab kerajaan tanpa membezakan kaya, pertengahan atau kurang mampu. Bagi yang kaya mereka telah dikenakan bayaran cukai yang banyak dari setiap perbelanjaan begitu juga pertenghan yang dipotong dari gaji bulanan dan juga bagi yang kurang mampu mereka diberikan bantuan STR dan lain-lain, ianya adil jika dilihat. Adakan ini adalah jalan mudah atau disebut sebagai CABUT dari tanggungjawab ???
Mende ni kerajaan nak menyusahkan rakyat. Bantu rakyat sebenarnya alasan je kot supaya kerajaan dapat kutip data melalui Padu.
Ko bagi macam macam data kat google takde pulak ko complain
@@ShahrulJohan ni sorg lagi kaki kencing kaki fitnah. camne pulak ko tau aku bagi google mcm2 data? camne pulak ko tahu aku tak complain? kalo kau suke bagi pada rafizi, bagi je. terpulang pada ko😂nanti ape2 jgn complain pulak weh.
I'm not registering PADU . fishy la .. scary .. account bank big NO NO . anything can happen. I agreed with Sarawak minister
We need more Sarawakian Ministers in Cabinet as check and balance.The speak with an open mind and not take sides.
Terlalu byk harta sebab itu takut untuk isi. Most of the Sarawak politician are very2 rich. For rakyat i dont think problem for them to fill PADU.
Dulu saya menerima bantuan dari Kerajaan tapi semenjak Kerajaan baru memerintah saya tidak mendapat satu sek pun bantuan dari Kerajaan....
Sebab itulah kena isi PADU. Biar kerajaan tahu keadaan terkini anda.
Karim ni akan malu sendir spt mana ketika dia berbalah dgn Nazri Aziz tempoh hari
Saya sokong Datuk! Kasi goyang itu meja Kerajaan Madanon
ikut sahaja saranan kerajaan ini.. apa yg penting nnt.. Kita nak tengok kesan drpd formula PADU ini kpd kehidupan rakyat yg miskin susah.. kalau setakat bantuan Rm100 - 300 utk 3 - 4 bulan.. mcm bantuan Str.. apa la sangat.. duit Rm200-Rm300 sekali beli barangan dapur dah pun lesap sekelip mata..
jadi kita sama2 tunggu dan lihat keberkesanan formula PADU ini kpd kehidupan rakyat yg miskin susah di Malaysia..
apakah ianya benar2 bole membantu rakyat..
itu yg penting..
kalau tak sia2 saja kita sokong kerajaan ini..
Dasar x pnh bersyukur...sbb tu Allah turunkan bermcm2 musibah....
Setuju... kelemahan Kerajaan Madanon
P:Pastinya
A:Ada Alibaba
D:Dalang Penyamun
U:Untung Banyak
Padu is the best system made for citizens to check if they eligible for help..only sarawak gps dont want this so that thier citizens wont be able to expose their financial backgrounds....which is one of poorest in Malaysia
If government want to help poor, easy just go through epf. Can know through the amount that cut.then help. If kerja sendiri there should be another way.
Yes. If the govment wants to help the poor, let the poor fill up padu & qualify for aid. Those who do not need padu aid do not need to fill. Then this fair & democratic
Very fair comments
Food for thought for the one who implemented this program, hastily.
Cakap besar yB karim sila jawap saya kena kenyalang gold card tidak dapat di lulus atau tidak dapat di buat satu hari kenapa ngambil masa sampai 6 bulan .