What would be helpful to me would be to have categories of AI tools (e.g. Chats, podcast gen) and rank tools there. Also having a chart that is easy to determine the name, rather than the icon so those of us who don't have an hour to watch a video can quickly understand the results at the end and then dig into the video for more detail.
If you pay for Chat GPT and Perplexity, you don't need to pay for Claude, but if you pay for Chat GPT and Claude (my preference), you don't need to pay for Perplexity. Chat GPT has the more features, but I just feel that Claude + Chat GPT is just such an insane combo when used together.
Putting kling below Runaway is crazy IMHO. They have one of the most generous plans out there. Not only that, their video output is simply incredible, especially image to video, even the text to video is far better than that of runway for example
I find it interesting that you have Adobe in F tier. As a corporate designer that uses Adobe products everyday, I would probably put it in S tier for me personally because I use their AI features every day on real projects for Fortune 50 companies. It really streamlines stuff that would've taken a lot of time and truncates that, saving a ton of time for me.
" As a corporate designer that uses Adobe products everyday, I would probably put it in S tier" Could it be because You are using paid versions ? I used it only as a trial on a 220 pages PDF document ( a course) and it almost immediately failed such that I won´t use it any more.. For me with that limited experience it´s an F. But I´m just an amateur at AI. My only paid version is ChatGPT. After seeing this video I will try out other tools. But what´s the point of offering a free "trial" if it is not representative of the quality of the paid tool ?
Great video gentlemen! Just a suggestion for the future, please group or have a visual separation for the different TYPES of AI tools i.e. Chat , Image generation, video, etc.). Also, suggest publishing the most up to date version on your website with links to the tools.
One strong disagreement here. Among image generation software, it seems to me that mid journey simply has no competitors. Stable diffusion , Leonardo , Ideogram, they aren’t even in the same ballpark. The quality and stylistic aesthetics of Midjourney are superior in every way. The blend tool , where you can simply upload two images and mid journey will create an image that is composed of elements of both. It’s absolutely fascinating and I haven’t seen any other tools do that.
Yes, for quick wow generations, MJ is great but it doesnt offer the same level of customization, edperimentation and flexibility. It is also too censored and expensive.
I actually compared those in a recent video - th-cam.com/video/_9OE1KA1Wfs/w-d-xo.html but since then Windsurf came out and it's pretty solid actually. Will do a Cursor vs Windsurf video soon.
I wish you would compare by category rather than across the universe. A deep dig into image and video generators would be very useful to me, but not really to people looking to build AI agents or write technical papers. GREAT VIDEO though.
Should be an American sort of valuation at school where A is Good 👍 and F is bad 👎I am still unsure about what the S is. It is still above the A, so it should be better than good.
My S tier is ChatGPT and Gemini 1.5 pro There is no LLM that you can put in it hundreds of pages and hours of audio and you ask anything with 99% certainty that you will get an accurate information about your documents even if the information is cut out over hundreds of pages, you just cannot do that in GPT nor Claude and to top it all you have 2 million tokens input, the most accurate audio transcription especially in non English languages (arabic and finnish for me) I think gemini is quite underrated
Interesting that all the video generators were referred to as 'played with' rather than 'used'. That's why it's hard to see why they would rank highly at the moment (though fun is good). Can see that being different in a year's time, of course. Plus if you gripe about Midjourney's cost for unlimited images, the pretty steep costs for more than a bit of fun a month on video could have been mentioned
I the think notebookLM is/or could be used plenty by students. The podcast is the cherry on top but the default briefs, FAQ and ability to chat with documents is very useful. Also, you should probably have included Udio as a rival to Suno. The latter has more features but even it's v4 version is probably less authentic and Udio provides more user control
Claude is still way better with English composition. It sounds less stilted. It does not give me stuff I have to rewrite every time - Claude is the clear winner right now. Agreed that it can be touchy about certain subjects and that needs to be fixed. The rate-limiting problem also needs fixing asap or I’ll be forced to go back to GPT or pay for Gemini and start seriously testing that.
I think Google employees must be posting about Gemini in the comments. Your ranking seemed accurate to me. I would have liked to see your ranking canva and ideogram
Kling 1.5 is better than Runway. Should be an A - and the fact that you haven't really used it explains why you put it in B. And Kling won't do everything - it will refuse certain things, although the censorship is far less than many other tools.
But it’s so difficult to compare all these llm as one is better in one field while other in other field , you should need to create a ladder per purpose (coding, automation, writing, visuals, audio,…) like 5-6 tier lists
If you are ranking these tools and what they do it makes no sense to compare chatGPT with Midjourney for instance. If Midjourney is the best text to image generator it should be ranked S tier because that means It is the best out there. Same with any tools that have a specific purpose. It doesn't make any sense to put Runway on A or B when you agree that it is the best video generator. They don't compete with chatGPT so why say they don't deserve the same spot as them?
u can do better. we know what the peak looks like. agentic, accesable within seconds, tool based, always running and processing our 100's of long term goals.
Thumbs down! You did not do your homework on Gemini in AI studio and it's free. It also has the newest beta llm's which are awesome. Another pro is it saves your 2 million context windows. It essentially is a GPT like builder. Then the Gemini API is the best free API. 👎👎
Nothing about this video is low effort though 🙃? actually using (most of) these products, making the chapter titles useful, etc More like low effort criticism
Thanks for watching!! Get Agent AI's Company Research Tool for free 👉 clickhubspot.com/wdu
What would be helpful to me would be to have categories of AI tools (e.g. Chats, podcast gen) and rank tools there. Also having a chart that is easy to determine the name, rather than the icon so those of us who don't have an hour to watch a video can quickly understand the results at the end and then dig into the video for more detail.
If you pay for Chat GPT and Perplexity, you don't need to pay for Claude, but if you pay for Chat GPT and Claude (my preference), you don't need to pay for Perplexity.
Chat GPT has the more features, but I just feel that Claude + Chat GPT is just such an insane combo when used together.
you can use both on poe or perplexity even
No Ideogram? It's easily the best image generation solution out there
It’s flying under the radar. I’m using for art direction and some crazy mockups. Great stuff!
The chapter titles are truly remarkable. The creative naming adds depth and makes the content discoveries enjoyable.
Awesome! Thank you both for the analysis. Chat GPT is S as in the Sun is sunny 😎 I use it every day - think with it, create with it, discover with it.
Putting kling below Runaway is crazy IMHO. They have one of the most generous plans out there. Not only that, their video output is simply incredible, especially image to video, even the text to video is far better than that of runway for example
I find it interesting that you have Adobe in F tier. As a corporate designer that uses Adobe products everyday, I would probably put it in S tier for me personally because I use their AI features every day on real projects for Fortune 50 companies. It really streamlines stuff that would've taken a lot of time and truncates that, saving a ton of time for me.
Which AI features in Adobe do you use daily
" As a corporate designer that uses Adobe products everyday, I would probably put it in S tier"
Could it be because You are using paid versions ? I used it only as a trial on a 220 pages PDF document ( a course) and it almost immediately failed such that I won´t use it any more.. For me with that limited experience it´s an F. But I´m just an amateur at AI. My only paid version is ChatGPT. After seeing this video I will try out other tools. But what´s the point of offering a free "trial" if it is not representative of the quality of the paid tool ?
Both kling and minimax are better than luma even better than runway a lot of the time..
Great video gentlemen! Just a suggestion for the future, please group or have a visual separation for the different TYPES of AI tools i.e. Chat , Image generation, video, etc.). Also, suggest publishing the most up to date version on your website with links to the tools.
I learned more from this show than any other AI video. Thank you!
Same
One strong disagreement here. Among image generation software, it seems to me that mid journey simply has no competitors. Stable diffusion , Leonardo , Ideogram, they aren’t even in the same ballpark. The quality and stylistic aesthetics of Midjourney are superior in every way. The blend tool , where you can simply upload two images and mid journey will create an image that is composed of elements of both. It’s absolutely fascinating and I haven’t seen any other tools do that.
Yes, for quick wow generations, MJ is great but it doesnt offer the same level of customization, edperimentation and flexibility. It is also too censored and expensive.
Loved this episode - great insights 😊
Where would you put bolt.new with regard to Cursor and Replit?
there are like 3 or 4 tools similar to bolt and 2 similar to cursor, one actually better (waverider)
@ Waverider is better than Cursor?
@ did you mean Windsurf Ai?
I actually compared those in a recent video - th-cam.com/video/_9OE1KA1Wfs/w-d-xo.html but since then Windsurf came out and it's pretty solid actually. Will do a Cursor vs Windsurf video soon.
Adobe premiere has built in transcription so in most cases I don't use any other app for it. But I will check Descript out. 1:03:45
I wish you would compare by category rather than across the universe. A deep dig into image and video generators would be very useful to me, but not really to people looking to build AI agents or write technical papers. GREAT VIDEO though.
What do the different Tier letters mean? They didn’t cover it at the start. 2:38
Should be an American sort of valuation at school where A is Good 👍 and F is bad 👎I am still unsure about what the S is. It is still above the A, so it should be better than good.
This is comment 9, climbing up the ladder… love you work! You should have 1M followers!! Keep it up. Trough fan!
My S tier is ChatGPT and Gemini 1.5 pro
There is no LLM that you can put in it hundreds of pages and hours of audio and you ask anything with 99% certainty that you will get an accurate information about your documents even if the information is cut out over hundreds of pages, you just cannot do that in GPT nor Claude and to top it all you have 2 million tokens input, the most accurate audio transcription especially in non English languages (arabic and finnish for me)
I think gemini is quite underrated
Nice y’all, fascinating that only ~1k have viewed this. That’s the exciting part
Interesting that all the video generators were referred to as 'played with' rather than 'used'. That's why it's hard to see why they would rank highly at the moment (though fun is good). Can see that being different in a year's time, of course. Plus if you gripe about Midjourney's cost for unlimited images, the pretty steep costs for more than a bit of fun a month on video could have been mentioned
I the think notebookLM is/or could be used plenty by students. The podcast is the cherry on top but the default briefs, FAQ and ability to chat with documents is very useful. Also, you should probably have included Udio as a rival to Suno. The latter has more features but even it's v4 version is probably less authentic and Udio provides more user control
Very helpful. Thx
i like the idea of category specific ranking. ie just ai art or just ai video... do one on agents! crewai etc...
Great video guys
Perplexity is top tier. But started to use Google AI studio and Google vertex AI.
Claude is still way better with English composition. It sounds less stilted. It does not give me stuff I have to rewrite every time - Claude is the clear winner right now. Agreed that it can be touchy about certain subjects and that needs to be fixed. The rate-limiting problem also needs fixing asap or I’ll be forced to go back to GPT or pay for Gemini and start seriously testing that.
I think Google employees must be posting about Gemini in the comments. Your ranking seemed accurate to me.
I would have liked to see your ranking canva and ideogram
love your vodeo style
Kling 1.5 is better than Runway. Should be an A - and the fact that you haven't really used it explains why you put it in B. And Kling won't do everything - it will refuse certain things, although the censorship is far less than many other tools.
Sure, you can upload the whole Lord Of The Ring series to Gemini, but it'll probably turn the elves BIPOC
What’s the app you use for the editing of videos to remove the filler words??
Try Cascade AKA Windsurf too!
llama setups with ollama is s tier for my projects.
Do the category vids!!!!
But it’s so difficult to compare all these llm as one is better in one field while other in other field , you should need to create a ladder per purpose (coding, automation, writing, visuals, audio,…) like 5-6 tier lists
S tier: Suno, Udio, RipX, Midjourney, Claude, ChatGPT, ElevenLabs, P***works, Cursor...
why Copilot wasnt in the list ?
I am pretty sure Grok had real time profile interactions but they stopped it because it was too intrusive..
leonardo over midjourney is crazy . both are s or midjourney is better
I have better results on editing text and humor. But yes, rate limits are insane, like 30 messages
amazing.
Forgot KREA
I think AI Infinite Memory with MemGPT is a S
Perplexity AI in Pro mode, can read a YT video
If you are ranking these tools and what they do it makes no sense to compare chatGPT with Midjourney for instance. If Midjourney is the best text to image generator it should be ranked S tier because that means It is the best out there. Same with any tools that have a specific purpose. It doesn't make any sense to put Runway on A or B when you agree that it is the best video generator. They don't compete with chatGPT so why say they don't deserve the same spot as them?
Too bad AI doesn't help the host with audio desync
Is it me, or does it seem like Nathan doesn't really use alot of these tools.
44:05 Dude, try the apps before you get record the show.
When ChatGPT even the chef GPT for oh preview, doesn’t know the answer to something it just makes shit up all the time
Perplexity gives me wrong info all the time.. Plus idl the u.i ..
midjourney S by far
Claude is S 😭😭😭
u can do better. we know what the peak looks like. agentic, accesable within seconds, tool based, always running and processing our 100's of long term goals.
playground is better than Leonardo, by far. unfortunately it won't be in game for too long.
minimax / hailou is S
Why would anyone be a fan of Elon Musk unless you just love shit in general
claude is s
Yes claude is S
Thumbs down! You did not do your homework on Gemini in AI studio and it's free. It also has the newest beta llm's which are awesome. Another pro is it saves your 2 million context windows. It essentially is a GPT like builder. Then the Gemini API is the best free API. 👎👎
Gemini is an F-
Gave these video tools a shot. Kling is S tier imo. I agree with the rest mostly. th-cam.com/video/xgucR0h5l0A/w-d-xo.htmlsi=JTV8hj7s9xikOVMn
I don’t know who that guy with Mat is, but he has obviously no idea what he is talking about. He is not informed at all. Bad match up Mat. Thumb down.
Anything that requires Discord Server... {F}3
Elevenlabs is S
Hi, from Taiwan. at Lance. You should try using Claude for Japanese translation. My wife is also Japanese and we find Claude has better Japanese
Claude is so fkn overrated, smh. It’s a D for me
....1114.......
Low effort , ai wave riders lol
Nothing about this video is low effort though 🙃? actually using (most of) these products, making the chapter titles useful, etc
More like low effort criticism
bait comment
I learned more from this show than any other AI video. Thank you!
Why would anyone be a fan of Elon Musk unless you just love shit in general