You also said one thing "They are the only Object of their kind" You talked about what that means, and if the BFDI universe is connected to the universes from BFUP, BFGG, and FAB, then this theory is false, but the only connection i found between any of these universes is the fact that the BFUP mainland looks identical to Goiky from BFDI seasons 1-2
It's a PERSONAL bubble recovery centre, meaning that only one bubble can use it. Plus, things can be released before it's advertised, so it's likely that bubble used the transformer before bfdi began
yellow face saw that bubble was doing well and fine after testing, so he released the bubble transformer to the public, didn’t know everyone else would be so careless
She is such a interesting character and im glad someone noticed her character and thIs is serves her character justice and i wish she got even more character
There's two glaring holes I'd like to bring up, both involving BFDIA. One, where does the HPRC fit into this? It's a Recovery Center that recovers _any_ object by just typing in a name and cranking, which if there were multiple Bubbles, I feel like it should narrow down which ones are which. Second, and most importantly, what about Pencil reviving Bubble through her bubble wand after Flower had destroyed all the Recovery Centers? There's no telling if it runs on the same functions as Recovery Centers, especially since it only ever got used once.
We've already established that only one bubble can exist at a time. All the dead bubbles form a sort of queue, likely in the order they were killed. So typing in BUBBLE would only recover the next bubble in line to be recovered. That solves the HPRC problem
It's probably some sort of Skylanders Mini situation for Firey Jr. And Evil counterparts are literally Shadows of the Characters if you wanna use Persona Wording
Interesting theory. I rewatched this several times it’s a very fascinating idea… though I wonder, if only one object can exist at a time- who is Ruby’s mother? ( that she mentioned in Balloony’s elimination scene ) and who laid Eggy’s egg? ( from the story she told TD ) I’m thinking about this quite a bit. If every Bubble spawned from the Recovery Center were originally someone else, wouldn’t that mean they’d all have different personalities? Food for the thought, loved the video!
There is a small, minor flaw, you said whenever bubble died before the ad, she respawned as herself, but the ad included a pi chart of the approval rating, meaning the bubble transformer was released earlier. So bubble could have been trapped in an eternal loop well before the ad.
I just think bubble has always been a bubble yet she still got the bubble transformer to see what would happen or because she's not the smartest object on the show
I feel like its less of faking it and its more of just...been a bubble. I also think, no, its not entirely yellow faces fault, bubble decided to buy it. I feel like its just being overcomplicated, and bubble was a different object, wanted to become a bubble, and they haven't popped till someone made the recovery centers, probably bubble did.
I think she already had the bubble transformer early because the ad had a buggy vhs effect meanwhile the other yellow face ads don't, showing us that it's actually an old ad re aired during the show, so she actually got the bubble transformer right after the bubble transformer ad originally aired (which was older than the show)
I love the theory! But I don't think I entirely believe it, for these reasons: 1. jacknjellify is not the kind of creator to hide or foreshadow deep lore like that. Except for maybe IDFB. Still hoping for a continuation there. 2. Battle for BFB is a joke show. Admit it, it's true. You even used a clip that perfectly represents this - at 3:32. Bubble consciously gets Gelatin to commit cannibalism, even mentions it, and Gelly boii is more worried about alternative motives. The 'Bubble Transformer' comment is likely just a throwaway joke that really should have been cut earlier. 3. There is a gaping hole in your theory that either you missed or you covered in that unintelligible barrage of loopholes. The Bubble transformer likely existed before the commercial on July 1st. Bubble probably bought it before BFDI, and even before she got her own recovery centre. She is very likely just one person, even if she wasn't always a Bubble. That's my theory. Still, I really enjoyed the video! This channel is like a mixture of two of my favourite topics, object shows and theories. I'm definitely hitting that red button, and can't wait for that Leafy theory! (and PS, I was fascinated by that point about how we never see two object of the same species, nor do they ever talk about family! I might think about that one!)
1. eh, that shouldn’t be a reason why my theory would be wrong. besides, who’s bozo? and there are so many more really dark things with bfdi, you just don’t know 2. bfdi isn’t a joke show, it’s a kids show. but being a kids show doesnt mean you can’t have dark plot lines that are never released. for example, all of the spongebob theories. a kids show, but dark theories that make sense. 3. how would it have existed before bfdi?
@@Objectsided I don't want this to be an endless stream of comments, each one replying to the arguments of the last, so I'll just say this about point 2: I didn't say BFDI was a joke show, I said specifically Battle for BFB, season 4b. And I didn't mean a joke show, more like... a show that prioritises humour over coherency and has frequent random unexplainable but ridiculously funny moments.
Sorry this is so late, but we do see 2 of the same species (I think) a few times. David and Dora are one, although they might not count because they aren’t objects, but Firey and Firey Jr. are both objects, so yes, we do see the same objects multiple times.
debunking time woop woop When objects have some kind of change to their forms, they usually lose it and revert back to their normal form after being revived. The most prominent example being Gelatin's dye and the yoyleberries' metal side effect. If objects who used the Bubble Transformer died, they would've been recovered to their natural form. Not to mention, there have been several recovery centers over the years including Four themself which leaves quite a few holes in your theory. Also, how exactly is Teardrop different from other objects? There has been no indication that Teardrop is "different" than other objects and you can't just say this like it's common knowledge without providing actual evidence. We do not know enough about objects' background to assume anything. They could have been made in labs or they could have actual families that they just don't mention much. Ruby and Teardrop are both implied to have families (though Teardrop's family could have just been mentioned as a joke by a very confused Firey). Ruby says "Sorry Mommy did I do a no-no again?" which implies that they are at the very least familiar with the concept of families. Before I post this comment I'd just like to specify that this is NOT meant to be rude to you in any way. I genuinely think your theory is well thought out and pretty interesting. I just like to respond to theories with my own information that I've gathered. Sincerest apologies if I came off as rude or passive aggressive. That was in no way my intention. I'd also like to apologize for any mistakes I've made, as English is not my first language.
for the first thing, you have a good point secondly, I said teardrop was different from the other contestants because she couldn’t talk, which I should’ve made more clear but I thought was obvious because my last video before this was about Teardrop for the families, we shouldn’t use one sentence from a character as a decider for this, for example Ruby could have easily been quoting something or something random because the sentence was not in context whatsoever also thank you so much! yea I do know that my theory could be incorrect (I said that in the video itself) but I love your ideas!! ❤️
@@Objectsided well ruby DOES have a canon family They participated in that weird gem battle thing made by cary And if i remember correctly, she mentions them at some point Although that sorry mommy thing was just to imply that ruby was childish (i think)
9:03 all objects can still her things when they die For xample lollipop in bfb 3 when Gelatin is throwing forks everywhere Barf bag says "I think Gelatin should stop throwing forks everywhere" Lollipop gets recovered after she says hat and says "Well, I think Pie should start wearing my patented fork repellent" So anybody can still hear things when they die, not just bubble
Bubble is actually my second favourite character, the first being Ruby. (You might recognise me from the BFB Wiki Commenters video) And I was really ashamed of how poorly she was treated in Post-Spilt. Mainly towards BFB 22, the story plot in that episode is why it makes it my least favourite episode in post-spilt, just because there were some stupid/dumb things that happened. Examples are: *Bubble being killed by Four, and doesn't get recovered at all and remains absent throughout the episode. *Besides this, Leafy somehow gets recovered when she also dies but Bubble doesn't. *They focused too much on the Leafy and Firey situation, and felt like an easy Firey/Leafy getting the most votes again when either of them are up for elimination. *This resulted in Leafy getting a huge unfair advantage, and Bubble getting getting an unfair disadvantage due to being killed and forgotten by the voters. *The Leafy and Bubble frenemy thing isn't built up nor revisited afterwards. *Bubble getting eliminated right after the episode, and Four indirectly eliminating her. It also almost feels like they were trying to get rid of her in the episode by getting her killed off, and not returning afterwards, and counts as Four indirectly eliminating her which is unfair. What make things worse is that she gets eliminated right after that episode, even though she couldn't control nor do anything about it to save herself, her elimination is also rushed and just awful because there isn't a special moment of her, and instead she just gets eliminated, and just doesn't do anything until the final couple of episodes. She was robbed, and could of done some more, if they gave more to her character and she stayed longer. Her and Lollipop's interaction was really nice, however, it was cut short due to Bubble's elimination, she also was cut in favour of other overrated characters due to some voters who thought she was a whiny boring character, when in fact they miss a big detail about Bubble's character. If she is in another season, she definitely needs a redemption arc and a better character development storyline. If you don't like Bubble, that's fine but I just wanted to say this because I wasn't happy on how unfairly her elimination was, and how she was treated as a character as well.
I think I know why Bob about the bubble transformer basically as a pre-order and the free order allows her to get recovered again so she changed her self to a bubble forever and the other ones are specifically dead because they didn’t got the prototype
Great video! But theres one problem. If bubble is a different character every time, then how does she have the exact same personality and shes aware of past lives.
There is a huge loophole in this. in TPOT 1 there is a scene where the audience is revealed and there's only one character in the seats. birthday cake that means there can be more than 1 type of the same object since there is cake seen in the same episode.
Another issue with this theory is that eggy states she was a little egg inside of a egg before she was born, which means that multiple of the same object can be animate at the same time.
I’ve actually been a Bubble fan for a long time, and watching BFB 23 the episode before bubble got eliminated it really seemed like the writers kinda screwed her over. With her avoiding leafy in the beginning of the episode, it seems like the writers saw this as an innocent joke, but that’s really what killed her, they even said that in BFB 24 and how it was surprising how bubble got the highest and lowest videos really close to each other. Me, many people, and probably the writers wanted Bubble and Leafy to be friends after bfdi 23 I think? Pretty sure they wanted to do that after Firey and Leafy became friends, unless Bubble died first. tdlr: Bubble’s elimination appeared really forced and accidental compared to many of the characters in the beginning of BFB 23, with a closure with Leafy that never happened. Also epic theory 8)
6:18 Question: what about all the exact clones of the contestants in bfdia 1&2? They were multiple living objects of the same species, so that means that this statement is false
8:15 or it was available before the ad (like most things) Or it got released the same time as the ad, but we don't see the ad until years after the ad first aired
What if she bought the bubble transformer to transform ANOTHER object into a bubble so she wouldn't feel so lonely (like you said at the start of the video she used to feel pretty lonely back in bfdi, wich is when the bubble transformer was released for sale) and she's always been THE Bubble we know and love.
hey here's a theory what if there's just one bubble she just constantly dies than theres a giant bubble blower in her recovery center and she just keeps getting recovered
Yeah...that's wrong Multiple times you see Inside of bubble's Recovery center Like when Blocky poured in Tacks or in BFB 1 when you see her jump out you can see that it's just empty
the only thing I can think of on the spot to counter a point in your theory is the Firey Recovery Center, since it has Firey's name in the title, it's meant to recover Firey. it's reasonable to assume that since Bubble's name is Bubble, that the BRC is meant to recover our specific Bubble. Every specific Recovery Center is tied to one version of a character, the only exceptions being the LPRC, HPRC, and the MRC, therefore why would the Bubble Recovery Center be any different? I will say that a good counter to this point is the Ice Cube Recovery Center in the episode with the frisbee tossing contest, where Leafy essentially has to recreate Ice Cube from the ground up personality-wise, but it's the only instance of a recovery center of this nature
9:28 But we don't have any other evidence? What about when Pencil recovered Bubble in BFDIA 3 and she asked who Ruby was, it sounded like she did not know Ruby joined the alliance in BFDIA 2
I want to say something that you missed In BFDI 7, in Yellow Face's Bubble Transformer ad, he says he doesn't sell "personal bubble recovery centers", which means if a bubble died it would have to use its OWN recovery center, not another bubble recovery center. In BFDI and BFB, Bubble has her own PERSONAL recovery center that she uses, telling us that she can only use it. (Ruby and Announcer say that)
But personal just means it's personally used for a bubble, it doesn't specify a single bubble, which means objects who transform into bubbles could also use the recovery center, I think.
@@soukadaBattleForGoldenPillow bubble has her own it is personally only made for her Even announcer bought some characters recovery centers for that character only
Another thing de-bunking Bubble's recovery center stuff is.. Black Hole. Black Hole destroyed all the recovery centers, the recovery is centered around Four, X, and possibly Two?? Also, 6:18 Uh, wait, then what's Firey JR? He is a canon character, we can't exactly ignore him (even though even I've tried to)
like I said in the video, the objects need to have some type of difference. firey jr isn’t Firey, hes a Junior version of him. the only way for my theory to be wrong is if something like who’s the real Firey was canon, but we know it wasn’t.
@@Objectsided Good point. I also thought of something. Who does the recovering now? Four and X. If we are to believe Four and X were recovering everyone EXCEPT Bubble, then there might be more to this than I thought. But Four and X (especially X) wouldn't do something like that. Those two would have no idea the Bubble Transformer exists in Bubble's possession, and they would be recovering the SAME Bubble each time. All in all, still a pretty good theory! Keep up the good work!
Well in the original add in BFDI for the bubble transformation machine, don’t they say that they don’t sell individual and unique bubble recovery centers? Forgot that.
I got one proof that can backfire this theory. You see, Pencil has an alternative way to recover her by using a bubble mill. So that means she's not a different object and transform into a bubble in the BRC.
i would like to point out that the bubble transformer could have existed before bfdi as it doesn't say it is new or anything. also the transformer could have made the original object's biology or whatever keeps them alive change to fit as a bubble, and finally if it recovered a different bubble each time there would be a big change in personality and they most likely wouldn't remember match, pencil or ruby being their friend or alliance member.
There is still things that break this whole theory, in IDFB 1 bubble says she is used to her life disappearing all over again. And Maybe she said she used the bubble transformer because she ate yoyleberries unintentionally. And also Bubble's personality goes up and down because maybe she is thinking and trying to realize too much on being competitive or being a true friend. 1 of the reasons of this is because of Blocky or and how Match and Pencil treated Fanny. And also how can the objects that used the bubble transformer be so brave to not be themselves? Also literally 2673 objects did that? Yellow face couldve have gotten lots and lots of money and use them when budget cuts come in. And also in the early times when the bubble transformer was literally not introduced to object kind I dont even think the bubble transformer existed. This is my theory and I hope it sounds very believable, there is no problem with Bubble and its just a normal thing.
Just one ity bity problem: The Ice Cube Recovery Center 2.0 shown in BFDI 17 proves there are multiples of objects and showing that multiple Bubbles can exist
Yeah I see lots of people referencing “but thats just a theory, a game theory” to everything but games and I always say to myself “..but film theory exists??”
Nice vid! However theory about only one of the same object existing at a time can be debunked from the existence of Firey Jr. He is fire like Firey, thus the same object.
When I was young, so hound I still ate my boogers and put pencils in my mouth, I watched bfdi and bfdia, in very non chronological order. I can no longer remember what the plot really was, but I can remember key characters like evil leafy and the announcer. I was obsessed with the show, even though my pea brain couldn’t comprehend what it is about. And knowing there are 3 more seasons (2 finished, 1 being made) just makes me very hopeful that the things I have loved are continuing to flourish and grab more attention To the point where more object shows are being made, such as Inanimate Insanity. I have watched the whole of bfb and 2 episodes of tpot (there is only 2 episodes in tpot in the time this comment is being typed) anyways, I love the show and almost always stay up to date, with the line being drawn at bfb 1.
My first thought clicking to this video; -Bubbles voice and accent change since the first episode -When pencil and match recovered bubble while making yoyleberry soup with a bubble blower it was a different bubble. -Bubbles actually die and everytime it's a different bubble but they all have the same mindset with a few changes. Eg: one is more vengeful than others or one is more scared that others etc..
I think that bubble might have used the transformer, and when she got it, she popped immediately and everyone else took note of it and didn't buy it. And when yellow face advertised it, he used just bubble as she had been the only one who bought it. She didn't have access to a recovery center just yet, so she hadn't been revived until they were created. in the middle of that yellow face made the advertisement. So maybe bubble is the only one to use it. But what do I know?
I think bubble had 2nd place Bc she got the same amount of votes as leafy and leafy would’ve gotten less if the contestant vote wasn’t added to the total
Let's not let this distract you from the fact that since the Ice Cube Recovery Center 2.0 only creates Ice Cubes based on specifics, the real Ice Cube is still dead, and has been replaced by an exact clone.
Unless it is a soul container contain every dead icecube soul, and the icecube's DNA,personality etc. And when the specifics are entered it somehow brings the soul back into an exact body
In the ad abt the transformer, YF said that the users popped before they could contact them, which means. This "fake" bubble would also pop if he actually used it.
your question on multiple bubbles has probably been awnsered in BFDI episode 25, flower says after destrying bubbles recovery center:oh and that was the last bubble recovery center, so maybe all bubbles actually have one.
I know this was like 2 years ago, but there was something said in the recent episode of BFDIA that ruins this whole theory, Yellow Face mentions that Needle is his very first customer during the fight scene, which means nobody ever bought Yellow Face's stuff before then. I know this might be wrong, since he says that people bought his stuff all the way back in BFDI 10, but it's still interesting to think about.
If it was different how would they keep memory, like bubble having an alliance ruby being her friend bubble knowing ruby was elinamated 1 episode later Im not throwing hate just a question
yeah so these characters would just keep their memories, as the experiences get transferred from Bubble to Bubble. it makes sense because if specific objects will always know how BFDI works, this should follow the same rule.
alternate title: bubble says something in bfb 21 so i make a literal documentary about it
Same
The theory has a flaw how dose bubble sound the same
THIS IS THE BEST TIME-WASTER EVER
This is a crazy theory!!!!!!!
You also said one thing
"They are the only Object of their kind"
You talked about what that means, and if the BFDI universe is connected to the universes from BFUP, BFGG, and FAB, then this theory is false, but the only connection i found between any of these universes is the fact that the BFUP mainland looks identical to Goiky from BFDI seasons 1-2
It's a PERSONAL bubble recovery centre, meaning that only one bubble can use it.
Plus, things can be released before it's advertised, so it's likely that bubble used the transformer before bfdi began
I 200000000% agree, I think pre-bubble volunteered for the testing
yellow face saw that bubble was doing well and fine after testing, so he released the bubble transformer to the public, didn’t know everyone else would be so careless
I agree
She is such a interesting character and im glad someone noticed her character and thIs is serves her character justice and i wish she got even more character
When you say character 4 times in the same sentence
@@Kormelion when you correct someone for no reason
Theory:Bubble turned into metal bubble and used a Bubble transformer so she can Be a bubble again
@@detectivebaconyt5737 good thoery but why would she do that when she could never be popped ever again and when would she have done it
@@AMHT-qd4to Maybe she dont want to be metal again but this video make sense tho
I Cant with the-
“Its just a theory. A G A M E T H E O R Y”
You mean a F I L M T H E O R Y
*A O B J E C T S H O W T H E O R Y*
@@RYLEEDURB
Ye, that makes more sense
Matpat's line A GAME,FILM,FOOD theory
@@notaspeakerlol56 theirs no food
what if bubble literally just got the bubble transformer to turn back into a normal bubble from eating yoyleberries
True lol.
tbh yeah
that makes sense, because people referred to her as “Metal Ball”
makes sense
This makes sense
"Because people don't buy things for no reason"
*aggressively stares at closet*
**stares at small rolling pin aggressively**
hold up
*Stares at decors aggressively*
*stares at cod black ops 2 aggressively*
*stares at painting of sad clown aggressively*
There's two glaring holes I'd like to bring up, both involving BFDIA. One, where does the HPRC fit into this? It's a Recovery Center that recovers _any_ object by just typing in a name and cranking, which if there were multiple Bubbles, I feel like it should narrow down which ones are which. Second, and most importantly, what about Pencil reviving Bubble through her bubble wand after Flower had destroyed all the Recovery Centers? There's no telling if it runs on the same functions as Recovery Centers, especially since it only ever got used once.
We've already established that only one bubble can exist at a time. All the dead bubbles form a sort of queue, likely in the order they were killed. So typing in BUBBLE would only recover the next bubble in line to be recovered. That solves the HPRC problem
@@gord.w.p The thing is that there's no evidence to prove any of that lol
@@GDNashit all conjecture, no need to believe it
@@gord.w.p im gonna be honest, thats a dumb theory.
@@Iemonic I'm not saying it's truth, it's a theory, you're allowed to think what you want, I don't care
These objects are the only object of their kind.
Firey jr. and Evil Leafy: Sad object noises
@Lucky Marshmallow I mean you're right
Theres other jrs that got reccomended
Same with evil charecters every bfdi contestant has a evil version.
It's probably some sort of Skylanders Mini situation for Firey Jr.
And Evil counterparts are literally Shadows of the Characters if you wanna use Persona Wording
but what about coiny and nickel hmmmm
Dora and David:
As someone who's favorite character is Bubble, I enjoy this.
Bubble
As someone who is Bubble, I enjoy this
@youthmaster_official
@@_cottony_ hi bubble I'm your biggest fan
@@lazyplushies1020 hoi there! Glad to knoio people loike me
WAIT TEARDROP IS NOT THE ONLY ONE WITH A FAMILY!
At 2:34 in BFB 18, Leafy gives a speech where she says “I’d like to thank my *family* and friends.”
And eggy
A other comment said he told a story
The other comment asked who laid eggy
I have two bunnies and one is named eggy lol
and now ruby and gelatin have family members lol
I love all these little theory/explaining videos you're making
Interesting theory. I rewatched this several times it’s a very fascinating idea… though I wonder, if only one object can exist at a time- who is Ruby’s mother? ( that she mentioned in Balloony’s elimination scene ) and who laid Eggy’s egg? ( from the story she told TD )
I’m thinking about this quite a bit. If every Bubble spawned from the Recovery Center were originally someone else, wouldn’t that mean they’d all have different personalities? Food for the thought, loved the video!
i agree
They said only one object can exist at a time in the show of bfdi, outside of the show, multiple objects could exist then.
Mabye Ruby's mother is like one of them other "Ruby Variants" Like Diamond, Emerald, Poo and the other ones
Rubys mother is a diamond LOL
maybe rubys mom wasn’t a gem cause
who wouldn’t send their said child to gem school
Yoylecake! That was an amazing theory dude! Everytime you upload something I just zoom as fast as I can.
There is a small, minor flaw, you said whenever bubble died before the ad, she respawned as herself, but the ad included a pi chart of the approval rating, meaning the bubble transformer was released earlier. So bubble could have been trapped in an eternal loop well before the ad.
That is true
Honestly I think Bubble was replaced after TFI
I just think bubble has always been a bubble yet she still got the bubble transformer to see what would happen or because she's not the smartest object on the show
Yoyleberries
@@otherlego ok
Ruby has a 'Mommy' in the end of Balloony's elimination.
I feel like its less of faking it and its more of just...been a bubble.
I also think, no, its not entirely yellow faces fault, bubble decided to buy it.
I feel like its just being overcomplicated, and bubble was a different object, wanted to become a bubble, and they haven't popped till someone made the recovery centers, probably bubble did.
I think she already had the bubble transformer early because the ad had a buggy vhs effect meanwhile the other yellow face ads don't, showing us that it's actually an old ad re aired during the show, so she actually got the bubble transformer right after the bubble transformer ad originally aired (which was older than the show)
This entire theory died with that collab with Nickel.
That’s not canon
@@3vr2d2lol this was a year ago please leave.
@@SirDanteYeet2138might as well continue the joke e
I love hearing the announcer tell me his theories about Bubble or maybe she they can't really tell it's a speaker
I love the theory! But I don't think I entirely believe it, for these reasons:
1. jacknjellify is not the kind of creator to hide or foreshadow deep lore like that. Except for maybe IDFB. Still hoping for a continuation there.
2. Battle for BFB is a joke show. Admit it, it's true. You even used a clip that perfectly represents this - at 3:32. Bubble consciously gets Gelatin to commit cannibalism, even mentions it, and Gelly boii is more worried about alternative motives. The 'Bubble Transformer' comment is likely just a throwaway joke that really should have been cut earlier.
3. There is a gaping hole in your theory that either you missed or you covered in that unintelligible barrage of loopholes. The Bubble transformer likely existed before the commercial on July 1st. Bubble probably bought it before BFDI, and even before she got her own recovery centre. She is very likely just one person, even if she wasn't always a Bubble. That's my theory.
Still, I really enjoyed the video! This channel is like a mixture of two of my favourite topics, object shows and theories. I'm definitely hitting that red button, and can't wait for that Leafy theory!
(and PS, I was fascinated by that point about how we never see two object of the same species, nor do they ever talk about family! I might think about that one!)
1. eh, that shouldn’t be a reason why my theory would be wrong. besides, who’s bozo? and there are so many more really dark things with bfdi, you just don’t know
2. bfdi isn’t a joke show, it’s a kids show. but being a kids show doesnt mean you can’t have dark plot lines that are never released. for example, all of the spongebob theories. a kids show, but dark theories that make sense.
3. how would it have existed before bfdi?
@@Objectsided I don't want this to be an endless stream of comments, each one replying to the arguments of the last, so I'll just say this about point 2: I didn't say BFDI was a joke show, I said specifically Battle for BFB, season 4b. And I didn't mean a joke show, more like... a show that prioritises humour over coherency and has frequent random unexplainable but ridiculously funny moments.
8:59
Sorry this is so late, but we do see 2 of the same species (I think) a few times. David and Dora are one, although they might not count because they aren’t objects, but Firey and Firey Jr. are both objects, so yes, we do see the same objects multiple times.
@@SeriouslySamuelyearsago wait what about recommend characters and every single 1-9 ball
0:56 The timing for that is so smooth
Ikr
debunking time woop woop
When objects have some kind of change to their forms, they usually lose it and revert back to their normal form after being revived. The most prominent example being Gelatin's dye and the yoyleberries' metal side effect. If objects who used the Bubble Transformer died, they would've been recovered to their natural form. Not to mention, there have been several recovery centers over the years including Four themself which leaves quite a few holes in your theory. Also, how exactly is Teardrop different from other objects? There has been no indication that Teardrop is "different" than other objects and you can't just say this like it's common knowledge without providing actual evidence.
We do not know enough about objects' background to assume anything. They could have been made in labs or they could have actual families that they just don't mention much. Ruby and Teardrop are both implied to have families (though Teardrop's family could have just been mentioned as a joke by a very confused Firey). Ruby says "Sorry Mommy did I do a no-no again?" which implies that they are at the very least familiar with the concept of families.
Before I post this comment I'd just like to specify that this is NOT meant to be rude to you in any way. I genuinely think your theory is well thought out and pretty interesting. I just like to respond to theories with my own information that I've gathered. Sincerest apologies if I came off as rude or passive aggressive. That was in no way my intention. I'd also like to apologize for any mistakes I've made, as English is not my first language.
for the first thing, you have a good point
secondly, I said teardrop was different from the other contestants because she couldn’t talk, which I should’ve made more clear but I thought was obvious because my last video before this was about Teardrop
for the families, we shouldn’t use one sentence from a character as a decider for this, for example Ruby could have easily been quoting something or something random because the sentence was not in context whatsoever
also thank you so much! yea I do know that my theory could be incorrect (I said that in the video itself) but I love your ideas!! ❤️
@@Objectsided No problem! I was worried I came off as too aggressive but I'm glad you like hearing my ideas!
@@Objectsided well ruby DOES have a canon family
They participated in that weird gem battle thing made by cary
And if i remember correctly, she mentions them at some point
Although that sorry mommy thing was just to imply that ruby was childish (i think)
@@toadsextracontent7149 so by that logic, we can consider _similar_ species families, but it can't be the same object more than once
@@gord.w.p no i think you dont understand what i meant-
It was explicitly said
Im not associating
Leafy mentions thanking her "family" in a bfb episode. I think it's in the one where she rejoined.
Edit: BFB 18, not 11 never mind
2:21 why did he dislike his own video-
9:03
all objects can still her things when they die
For xample lollipop in bfb 3 when Gelatin is throwing forks everywhere
Barf bag says "I think Gelatin should stop throwing forks everywhere"
Lollipop gets recovered after she says hat and says "Well, I think Pie should start wearing my patented fork repellent"
So anybody can still hear things when they die, not just bubble
Bubble is actually my second favourite character, the first being Ruby. (You might recognise me from the BFB Wiki Commenters video)
And I was really ashamed of how poorly she was treated in Post-Spilt.
Mainly towards BFB 22, the story plot in that episode is why it makes it my least favourite episode in post-spilt, just because there were some stupid/dumb things that happened.
Examples are:
*Bubble being killed by Four, and doesn't get recovered at all and remains absent throughout the episode.
*Besides this, Leafy somehow gets recovered when she also dies but Bubble doesn't.
*They focused too much on the Leafy and Firey situation, and felt like an easy Firey/Leafy getting the most votes again when either of them are up for elimination.
*This resulted in Leafy getting a huge unfair advantage, and Bubble getting getting an unfair disadvantage due to being killed and forgotten by the voters.
*The Leafy and Bubble frenemy thing isn't built up nor revisited afterwards.
*Bubble getting eliminated right after the episode, and Four indirectly eliminating her.
It also almost feels like they were trying to get rid of her in the episode by getting her killed off, and not returning afterwards, and counts as Four indirectly eliminating her which is unfair.
What make things worse is that she gets eliminated right after that episode, even though she couldn't control nor do anything about it to save herself, her elimination is also rushed and just awful because there isn't a special moment of her, and instead she just gets eliminated, and just doesn't do anything until the final couple of episodes.
She was robbed, and could of done some more, if they gave more to her character and she stayed longer.
Her and Lollipop's interaction was really nice, however, it was cut short due to Bubble's elimination, she also was cut in favour of other overrated characters due to some voters who thought she was a whiny boring character, when in fact they miss a big detail about Bubble's character.
If she is in another season, she definitely needs a redemption arc and a better character development storyline.
If you don't like Bubble, that's fine but I just wanted to say this because I wasn't happy on how unfairly her elimination was, and how she was treated as a character as well.
i agree, respec for typing all that
i agree aswell
Sweet jesus, do people really care this much about the writing of BFDI? We’re not dealing with Lovecraft here.
I think I know why Bob about the bubble transformer basically as a pre-order and the free order allows her to get recovered again so she changed her self to a bubble forever and the other ones are specifically dead because they didn’t got the prototype
Great video! But theres one problem. If bubble is a different character every time, then how does she have the exact same personality and shes aware of past lives.
There is a huge loophole in this. in TPOT 1 there is a scene where the audience is revealed and there's only one character in the seats. birthday cake that means there can be more than 1 type of the same object since there is cake seen in the same episode.
yea but one of them is a birthday cake and one is a regular cake.
Another issue with this theory is that eggy states she was a little egg inside of a egg before she was born, which means that multiple of the same object can be animate at the same time.
I’ve actually been a Bubble fan for a long time, and watching BFB 23 the episode before bubble got eliminated it really seemed like the writers kinda screwed her over. With her avoiding leafy in the beginning of the episode, it seems like the writers saw this as an innocent joke, but that’s really what killed her, they even said that in BFB 24 and how it was surprising how bubble got the highest and lowest videos really close to each other. Me, many people, and probably the writers wanted Bubble and Leafy to be friends after bfdi 23 I think? Pretty sure they wanted to do that after Firey and Leafy became friends, unless Bubble died first.
tdlr: Bubble’s elimination appeared really forced and accidental compared to many of the characters in the beginning of BFB 23, with a closure with Leafy that never happened.
Also epic theory 8)
'Bubble fan' 😏
@@owl3650 “what are you gonna do about it” - eraser
bubble had the fastest elimination
mf was on the screen for 10 frames 💀
6:18 Question: what about all the exact clones of the contestants in bfdia 1&2? They were multiple living objects of the same species, so that means that this statement is false
possible explanation with 3 words: illusions, hallucinations, clones
8:15 or it was available before the ad (like most things)
Or it got released the same time as the ad, but we don't see the ad until years after the ad first aired
I love this nice short document :)) ,MAKE MORE!
What if she bought the bubble transformer to transform ANOTHER object into a bubble so she wouldn't feel so lonely (like you said at the start of the video she used to feel pretty lonely back in bfdi, wich is when the bubble transformer was released for sale) and she's always been THE Bubble we know and love.
hey here's a theory what if there's just one bubble she just constantly dies than theres a giant bubble blower in her recovery center and she just keeps getting recovered
Yeah...that's wrong
Multiple times you see Inside of bubble's Recovery center Like when Blocky poured in Tacks or in BFB 1 when you see her jump out you can see that it's just empty
Bubbles my favorite character in BFDI history, so it makes me so happy someone else aknowledges how amazing and different she is.
A bubble superfan approves ;)
Edit:Wow,i never thought i would ever had 6 replies with the word "Same" xD
Same
Same
Ssame
Me too
Same
The scene were the announcer is hiring a new nickel there is more than one nickel
Doesn't Bubble say in BFB 19 that she uses aloe vera to prevent her from drying up and popping?
Bubble did say that
6:23
Bfdia: *multiple different kinds of ruby’s species appear*
"no one buys things for no reason"
MrBeast: okay
💀💀
it might have just been a joke because bubble was already a bubble
5:40 You forgot another evidence: If they were recovered, they could just call back
the only thing I can think of on the spot to counter a point in your theory is the Firey Recovery Center, since it has Firey's name in the title, it's meant to recover Firey. it's reasonable to assume that since Bubble's name is Bubble, that the BRC is meant to recover our specific Bubble. Every specific Recovery Center is tied to one version of a character, the only exceptions being the LPRC, HPRC, and the MRC, therefore why would the Bubble Recovery Center be any different? I will say that a good counter to this point is the Ice Cube Recovery Center in the episode with the frisbee tossing contest, where Leafy essentially has to recreate Ice Cube from the ground up personality-wise, but it's the only instance of a recovery center of this nature
Maybe the announcer did the other rcs before the episodes, because the icrc was created in the episode
4:07 gelatai: *hold up right there I just gotta get something rq.*
9:28 But we don't have any other evidence?
What about when Pencil recovered Bubble in BFDIA 3 and she asked who Ruby was,
it sounded like she did not know Ruby joined the alliance in BFDIA 2
See? Exactly why she’s an interesting character
No one gave attention to the bubble transformer because they were laughing at Firey’s demons.
I want to say something that you missed
In BFDI 7, in Yellow Face's Bubble Transformer ad, he says he doesn't sell "personal bubble recovery centers", which means if a bubble died it would have to use its OWN recovery center, not another bubble recovery center. In BFDI and BFB, Bubble has her own PERSONAL recovery center that she uses, telling us that she can only use it. (Ruby and Announcer say that)
But personal just means it's personally used for a bubble, it doesn't specify a single bubble, which means objects who transform into bubbles could also use the recovery center, I think.
@@soukadaBattleForGoldenPillow bubble has her own it is personally only made for her
Even announcer bought some characters recovery centers for that character only
Another thing de-bunking Bubble's recovery center stuff is.. Black Hole. Black Hole destroyed all the recovery centers, the recovery is centered around Four, X, and possibly Two??
Also, 6:18 Uh, wait, then what's Firey JR? He is a canon character, we can't exactly ignore him (even though even I've tried to)
like I said in the video, the objects need to have some type of difference. firey jr isn’t Firey, hes a Junior version of him. the only way for my theory to be wrong is if something like who’s the real Firey was canon, but we know it wasn’t.
@@Objectsided Good point. I also thought of something. Who does the recovering now? Four and X. If we are to believe Four and X were recovering everyone EXCEPT Bubble, then there might be more to this than I thought. But Four and X (especially X) wouldn't do something like that. Those two would have no idea the Bubble Transformer exists in Bubble's possession, and they would be recovering the SAME Bubble each time.
All in all, still a pretty good theory! Keep up the good work!
YOU JUST MADE 10K NO WAYY!!
character: *says anything but something that doesnt make sense*
the community: *d o c u m e n t i t*
0:35 the song matches well with the clip lmao
Well in the original add in BFDI for the bubble transformation machine, don’t they say that they don’t sell individual and unique bubble recovery centers? Forgot that.
Also when did cloudy get a bubble transformer? We see he has other yf products but he hasn’t collected the bt yet
This theory is false for one simple reason. In BFDIA 10, we see how recovery works, so this won’t happen
What? That makes no sense?
tpot 5 tear drop becomes the entire goinky cannal
0:29 bubble crying
I got one proof that can backfire this theory. You see, Pencil has an alternative way to recover her by using a bubble mill. So that means she's not a different object and transform into a bubble in the BRC.
"I can't believe people ignore key parts of the storyline and move on with their day"
ok not everyone is game theory lol
6:58 "uhmmm actually it's a film theo-"
i would like to point out that the bubble transformer could have existed before bfdi as it doesn't say it is new or anything. also the transformer could have made the original object's biology or whatever keeps them alive change to fit as a bubble, and finally if it recovered a different bubble each time there would be a big change in personality and they most likely wouldn't remember match, pencil or ruby being their friend or alliance member.
My personal theory is that since she is friends or knows two inventors (golfball and tennis ball) they built her a personal recovery center
There is still things that break this whole theory, in IDFB 1 bubble says she is used to her life disappearing all over again. And Maybe she said she used the bubble transformer because she ate yoyleberries unintentionally. And also Bubble's personality goes up and down because maybe she is thinking and trying to realize too much on being competitive or being a true friend. 1 of the reasons of this is because of Blocky or and how Match and Pencil treated Fanny. And also how can the objects that used the bubble transformer be so brave to not be themselves? Also literally 2673 objects did that? Yellow face couldve have gotten lots and lots of money and use them when budget cuts come in. And also in the early times when the bubble transformer was literally not introduced to object kind I dont even think the bubble transformer existed. This is my theory and I hope it sounds very believable, there is no problem with Bubble and its just a normal thing.
MY THEORY: she ate yoyle cake and became metal so she turned herself back into a bubble
Love this new video! Could you do Tree?
yeah!
edit; I might!
@@Objectsided Awesome!
My man forgot about Firey and Firey Jr.
Wait if bubble is changing person per death then why does her voice not change
Bubble vocal cords?
Just one ity bity problem: The Ice Cube Recovery Center 2.0 shown in BFDI 17 proves there are multiples of objects and showing that multiple Bubbles can exist
6:59 No, it’s a film theory
Yeah I see lots of people referencing “but thats just a theory, a game theory” to everything but games and I always say to myself “..but film theory exists??”
aaAAAAND... CUT!
matpat explaining the fnaf theory be like:
Me: wait what bubble noooo (bubble is my fav character)
7:43 ??????
"But that's just a theory, a game theory!"
Me: wait isnt it supposed to be film theory?"
6:42 lol bubble is now annoucer
Nice vid! However theory about only one of the same object existing at a time can be debunked from the existence of Firey Jr. He is fire like Firey, thus the same object.
When I was young, so hound I still ate my boogers and put pencils in my mouth, I watched bfdi and bfdia, in very non chronological order. I can no longer remember what the plot really was, but I can remember key characters like evil leafy and the announcer. I was obsessed with the show, even though my pea brain couldn’t comprehend what it is about. And knowing there are 3 more seasons (2 finished, 1 being made) just makes me very hopeful that the things I have loved are continuing to flourish and grab more attention To the point where more object shows are being made, such as Inanimate Insanity. I have watched the whole of bfb and 2 episodes of tpot (there is only 2 episodes in tpot in the time this comment is being typed) anyways, I love the show and almost always stay up to date, with the line being drawn at bfb 1.
Evil leafy is usually just Leafy. Also now there’s like 5 seasons. Watch it all from the beginning it will all make sense
My first thought clicking to this video;
-Bubbles voice and accent change since the first episode
-When pencil and match recovered bubble while making yoyleberry soup with a bubble blower it was a different bubble.
-Bubbles actually die and everytime it's a different bubble but they all have the same mindset with a few changes. Eg: one is more vengeful than others or one is more scared that others etc..
This makes me lose brain cells. In the end at least.
I think that bubble might have used the transformer, and when she got it, she popped immediately and everyone else took note of it and didn't buy it. And when yellow face advertised it, he used just bubble as she had been the only one who bought it. She didn't have access to a recovery center just yet, so she hadn't been revived until they were created. in the middle of that yellow face made the advertisement. So maybe bubble is the only one to use it. But what do I know?
ooo, this is really interesting 👀
Objectsided:but hey that's just a game theory
Matpat:hey that's my line
Me:don't you mean film theory
I think X is a sweet boi who became malicious over time or he was always this way but is or became mildly abusive or bossy. (not physically abusive.)
My theory is that Bubble was curious what would happen if she used a bubble transformer since she's...y'know, a bubble
I think bubble had 2nd place
Bc she got the same amount of votes as leafy and leafy would’ve gotten less if the contestant vote wasn’t added to the total
That was actually a visual error, Bubble got a few less votes than Leafy.
Bubbles
@@typicalburrito1527 yeah but she still got more then leafy when added contestant votes
so i’d say bubble and leafy are tied for second place
oh wait nvm
There's this one moment In bfdia 4 at 6:31-6:48 when The puffball speaker box said bubble isn't an official bfdi contestant
Let's not let this distract you from the fact that since the Ice Cube Recovery Center 2.0 only creates Ice Cubes based on specifics, the real Ice Cube is still dead, and has been replaced by an exact clone.
I mean yeah probably..
Unless it is a soul container contain every dead icecube soul, and the icecube's DNA,personality etc.
And when the specifics are entered it somehow brings the soul back into an exact body
and every plank second, your soul is replaced with an exact copy with sometimes a small amount of extra information
In the ad abt the transformer, YF said that the users popped before they could contact them, which means. This "fake" bubble would also pop if he actually used it.
You’re not object sided, you’re the announcer!
your question on multiple bubbles has probably been awnsered
in BFDI episode 25, flower says after destrying bubbles recovery center:oh and that was the last bubble recovery center,
so maybe all bubbles actually have one.
What’s the song at 0:23?
i like to imagine the announcer talking with the viewers
I'm eight minutes in and I've lost you. This is way too confusing which is annoying considering this is a KIDS SHOW
HAHAH I was confusing myself
I am not a fan of bubble but this is very interesting. My friend likes Bubble so I should show him this.
Amazing video!
THE D ANGELO WALLACE INTROOOO
this guy will be popular
Yes, I hope he gets to 100k by the end of the year
EDIT: HE WILL!!!!!
will not
I know this was like 2 years ago, but there was something said in the recent episode of BFDIA that ruins this whole theory, Yellow Face mentions that Needle is his very first customer during the fight scene, which means nobody ever bought Yellow Face's stuff before then. I know this might be wrong, since he says that people bought his stuff all the way back in BFDI 10, but it's still interesting to think about.
6:26 Firey and firey jr
Also nickel and rusty nickel
POV: after the inanimate insanity and tpot collab happened: *haha, yeah 2 objects can exist at the same time*
If it was different how would they keep memory, like bubble having an alliance ruby being her friend bubble knowing ruby was elinamated 1 episode later
Im not throwing hate just a question
yeah so these characters would just keep their memories, as the experiences get transferred from Bubble to Bubble.
it makes sense because if specific objects will always know how BFDI works, this should follow the same rule.
A fake!
@@BluePuffyy I DIDNT THINK THERE WAS ANOTHER IN THE UNIVERSE OMG
@@Objectsided also thanks for info
@@bluepuffball4380 lol