@@Wandrative Thanks, but still, if you are a republic thats fine, no need to pretend and put on a big show. Just shows how insecure and empty Korea is.
Let's be honest. No one's certain where the person called 허황후 is even from. Some say she's from India. Some say she's from overseas but not India. Some say she's a local. The most dominant theory is that she was used to kickstart buddhism. I've seen far too many Indians who claim that she's from India when there isn't a solid proof. Let's not spread the rumors.
Are these active duty ROK troops, or are they re-enactors? i have to wonder what is the source for the movements of these troops, I can imagine the weapons would be known from historical artifacts & & the costumes could be known from historic representations. I am doubtful of how they would know the movements of the troops from that time.
It's an reenactment. Seoul city recruits several workers for this part-time job. Joseon Dynasty(former state of ROK) left a massive amount of documents describing national events in form of paintings. These documents are called Ui-gwe(儀軌)s. We referred to these documents a lot.
I see people are taking pictures with the guards. Doesn't that disturb the ceremony? Are tourists informed when they are allowed to take pictures standing next to the guards?
Yes, you can pretty much take pictures anytime and they did announce that at a certain point, we could walk right up to the guards and take photos and film them, which I obviously did.
It will be the same people that will carry Prince's George's bride and in 30 years you'll see them in Buckingham Palace when Prince George gets married.
That is up to the Seoul Metropolitan Police and the Army's Capital Defense Command. This gate and the plaza are within walking distance of the Presidential Palace, so the security is reinforced there at all times, also because the US embassy is on this very plaza.
조선도 16세기 이후부턴 총 덕후라 할만큼 일본에게 당한게커서 그런지 총으로 무장한 비율이 굉장히 높은데(정조 화성행차도만 봐도 거의 전원 총 무장) 활을 끼고 있는모습은 외국인들시선에 조선이 총기를 도입 안한 나라인줄 오해하게 할수도 있겠네요. 외국 왕실 근위대도 전부 총으로 무장했는데 21세기에 활이라니....
Highly unlikely that there would be a band playing music. That's a 18th century European tradition for long marches and has thus been a part of many changes of the guard since.
Numerous details remain in the preserved royal archives and administrative order documents (clothes color, ranks, event procedures, arrangement of musical instruments, etc.), and this is a maintenance of tradition. Beware of Western imperialism mentality. The world is wider and deeper than you guess.
Ehh ?! But South-Korea is a Republic or are they just as confused as the French who act more Royal in their Military habits then actual Monarchies do today ?!
ThatDutchguy well that is true...but the changing of the guard is a ceremonial and a way to keep the tradition of the Josen dynasty. Also this is a way to give a glimpse the foreign people of the Josen dynasty.
Han Bit Jang Then why not keep a member of the Royal House of Josen as a Monarch if it's so culturally significant to the South-Korean people, instead of playing make believe is my next question ? Democracy can go hand in hand with a Monarch quite well, it works in: The Kingdom of the Netherlands. (my country) The Kingdom of Belgium. The Kingdom of Sweden. The Kingdom of Norway. The Kingdom of Denmark. The Kingdom of Spain. The United Kingdom of Britain. The Principality of Monaco. The Principality of Andorra. The Principality of Liechtenstein. The Grant-Duchy of Luxembourg. And even to some degree in the City state/Principality/Kingdom of the Vatican. It seems to work in Asia too. The Empire of Japan. The Kingdom of Bhutan. The Kingdom of Cambodia. Oké not so much in the Kingdom of Thailand because of the internal politics, but the last King Bhumiubol Adulyadej wasn't at fault there it's the politicians and military. Not familiar how it's going in The Kingdom of Malaysia, but haven't heard anything really bad. And i believe there are 2 or 3 more Asian Kingdom's. This is just of the top of my head. I'm aware that the Middle-Eastern Monarchies aren't all too good with the exceptions of Kingdom of Jordan and the Kingdom of Morocco. The rest of the Middle-Eastern Kingdom's and Sultanate's aren't doing well.
ThatDutchguy well most of these are just a culture fest and the guards are volunteers. Also the total house of Josen are mostly gone, there are those who survived the occupation but the actual royal line are history.
@@nathanjangs I read the Joseon royal line is gone due to Japan occupation doing by made the royals cant have the heir/child. Such cruel way to end the other monarch by ending their bloodline I think.
@@rianaZeinF Well you are right as during the occupation, most of the noble princes married the Japanese imperial princess, thus making them traitors as Korea was liberated and gained their independence. I know from the history of pre-korean war, that any Korean collaborated with the Imperial Japanese government are no longer welcomed and are banished, even if they were forced to collaborate.
This has nothing to do with Japan. It's a re-enactment of an ancient Korean military ritual, and we still do it today so people can see it and have fun.
How pathetic that South Korea have a president but they also want to have a ceremony like this , perhaps it's time that South Korea should restore it's monarchy as many member of the Korean royal family are still alive and due to the historical record the royal family of Korea have done nothing wrong otherwise these show will be just something like in Disney Land...LOL [ this event also remind me of what is happening in France ..same situation lol ]
《续资治通鉴 卷二百一十四 元纪三十二》记载：“后亦多畜高丽美人，大臣有权者，辄以此遗之，京师达官贵人，必得高丽女然后为名家。自至正以来，宫中给事使令，大半高丽女，以故四方衣服、靴帽、器物，皆仿高丽，举世若狂。” At the end of the Yuan Dynasty, Korean costumes and customs were introduced to China. ,《菽园杂记》：：“马尾裙始于朝鲜国，流入京师……于是无贵无贱，服者日盛。至成化末年，朝臣多服之者矣。阁老万公安冬夏不脱……。大臣不服者惟黎吏侍淳一人而已。此服妖也，弘治初始有禁例。” During the Ming Dynasty, Korean costumes and customs flourished. It was banned in the late Ming Dynasty.(弘治帝,1470~1505)
《续资治通鉴 卷二百一十四 元纪三十二》记载：“后亦多畜高丽美人，大臣有权者，辄以此遗之，京师达官贵人，必得高丽女然后为名家。自至正以来，宫中给事使令，大半高丽女，以故四方衣服、靴帽、器物，皆仿高丽，举世若狂。” At the end of the Yuan Dynasty, Korean women were trafficked to China for emperor and Minister‘s hobby. . ,《菽园杂记》：：“马尾裙始于朝鲜国，流入京师……于是无贵无贱，服者日盛。至成化末年，朝臣多服之者矣。阁老万公安冬夏不脱……。大臣不服者惟黎吏侍淳一人而已。此服妖也，弘治初始有禁例。” During the Ming Dynasty, Korean costumes flourished with influence of Sovereign country It was banned in china in the late Ming Dynasty.(弘治帝,1470~1505)
I copied the Korean costume and the vestigial culture. During the Yuan Dynasty, Mongolia and Korea sent a girl to each other. The Princess of Mongolia has been married to Korea. The Han Chinese were just slaves.
It may seem funny because the Chinese are not interested in preserving and harmonizing traditions. They actually burned and destroyed their own history and culture. At the time of the Communist Party Youth Revolution ;)
Please click on this link to see my other Korea videos: th-cam.com/video/erXTfmiYZ7k/w-d-xo.html
어느 나라 경비병 교환식에 친절하게 여러 언어로 안내방송을 해주냐;
ㅂㅅ임? 이건 진짜 근위대가 아니라 보여주기 위한 목적으로 운영되는 쇼니 여러 언어로 알려줘야지
dont you just wish you can travel back in time and visit all these countries when these ceremonies actually took place
Very nice Andy. Thank you for sharing it with us!
You're welcome-glad you enjoyed it. It was fun to see it in person.
덕수궁 취타대 연주실력이 지금까지 몇년 관찰해왔지만 가장 낫다..이들을 추운 겨울에는 그리고 시간날때마다 해외 순방 공연시키면 안되나?관련 정부는 고려해 보세요.
전통군악대 해외 군악대 대회에 항상 나가고 있습니다.
니가 안보는거지 합니다
해설이 필요하다면 안내방송 대신 차라리 스크린 설치해서 해설 띄우는게 어떨지..
해외로 여성민속 무용단/악대 보내는것도 좋지만, 그보단 이 행렬을 해외로 보내 그들 실력을 외국인들에게 보내주는것이 한국의
대외 홍보에 엄청 효과 가 있다.
Fiji song
I am embarrassed to confess that I did not know Korea has a monarch.
Regardless the Guards are world class, most elegant.
They used to, up until sometime in the 1800
These are all actors only.
That explains much, thank you for the clarification.
Korea doesn't has monarchy system
@@SMCITW actually 1916......
@@Wandrative Thanks,
but still, if you are a republic thats fine, no need to pretend and put on a big show.
Just shows how insecure and empty Korea is.
I have watched this myself wile in Seoul three years ago. Just one of the amazing things to see if you ever travel there.
Love Seoul, Love Korea x
I respect Koreans brilliant talent and and their achievement. lots of love from India, the home of '허황후'
Let's be honest. No one's certain where the person called 허황후 is even from.
Some say she's from India. Some say she's from overseas but not India. Some say she's a local.
The most dominant theory is that she was used to kickstart buddhism.
I've seen far too many Indians who claim that she's from India when there isn't a solid proof.
Let's not spread the rumors.
@@Galm_1 아 한국 좋다고 나라끼리 인연 말하는 외국인한테 너무하네
@@김도현-t8d5b 하도 -환-이 설쳐대는 요즘 유튜브니 솔직히 이해됩니다. 외국인한테서까지 이런 이야기가 나오니 좀 씁쓸하네요
@@커싄 환빠들 너무하긴 합니다...
Wow you know her
interesting ceremony, also a good tourism attraction.
If you see Korean outfit, we always match with best colors. Now, we mixed that tradition with Kpop. Proud to be KOREAN
Unique & interesting 👍👍
Are these active duty ROK troops, or are they re-enactors?
i have to wonder what is the source for the movements of these troops, I can imagine the weapons would be known from historical artifacts & & the costumes could be known from historic representations. I am doubtful of how they would know the movements of the troops from that time.
It's an reenactment. Seoul city recruits several workers for this part-time job. Joseon Dynasty(former state of ROK) left a massive amount of documents describing national events in form of paintings. These documents are called Ui-gwe(儀軌)s. We referred to these documents a lot.
색감질감 열일하는거봐 컬러풀함
I see people are taking pictures with the guards. Doesn't that disturb the ceremony? Are tourists informed when they are allowed to take pictures standing next to the guards?
Yes, you can pretty much take pictures anytime and they did announce that at a certain point, we could walk right up to the guards and take photos and film them, which I obviously did.
윤동주 시인의 참회록에 "파란 녹이 낀 구리 거울 속에 내 얼굴이 남아 있는 것은 어느 왕조 유물이기에 이다지도 욕될까" 라는 싯구처럼
왕조가 사라진 지금에 문지기 한들 무슨 의미가 있을까.
문화 보존이지
안내방송을 안 하면 뭔줄 알고 보려고 시끄러운 게 이유라면 한국어 안내방송도 없어야지 애초에 사람들한테 보여주려고 재현하는 거 아닌가? 사람들이 저게 뭔가 멀뚱멀뚱 보고만 있으라는 건가
짧네...음악도 짧고....
그래도.. 조선을 잠깐이나마 보여주는건데...
개인적으론...태평소가 짧아요~~~
한국하면 음악이구만~~~
우라나라 태평소가 을마나~~기가막한데~~
Very colourful.
I want to know what they're playing
It will be the same people that will carry Prince's George's bride and in 30 years you'll see them in Buckingham Palace when Prince George gets married.
Very very cool!
Why return those Crown Estate/Lands to the Descendants instead?
Fabuloso que conserven sus tradiciones
100% 조선시대와 같을 수는 없습니다.
왕실근위대가 사라진게 언젠데....
아무리 역사서를 참고해서 만든다고 해도 당시와
똑같이 재현할수는 없죠.
그냥 관광상품이라고 보시면 됩니다.
사실 저렇게 소박하게 유지하는 데도 만만치 않은 비용이 들어갑니다.
이건 뭐 그래서 뭐가 불만인데??
왕실 근위대가 사라졌으니 다시 부활해서 행사하면 안된다는 개소리는 도대체 대가리에 뭐가 들어야 그런 개소리를 할수 있는거냐??
니 새끼 주장대로면 사극도 하면 안되겠네 사라진지 오래됐는데 뭐하려고 사극을 해..안그러냐???
히잡쓴 바퀴네스탄뽕닭알라 조선시대랑 다르다고 불평하는 불편러 보고 하는 말인 것 같은데요?
Can the traditional guard arrest or fight to suspect or protect people if there are any criminal or terrorism in there ?
You mean nowadays? Well.....I'm afraid not. There's no royal family in Korea anymore, so this event is a reenactment of that of Joseon Dynasty.
That is up to the Seoul Metropolitan Police and the Army's Capital Defense Command.
This gate and the plaza are within walking distance of the Presidential Palace, so the security is reinforced there at all times, also because the US embassy is on this very plaza.
풍년가 연주를 좀더 늘렸으면,,
As long as ur happy❤
바티칸 경비병보다 한껏 멋드러짐, 역시~
The goatee looks fake like it's glued on lol.
Probably back in the day they just said "hey my shift is over is your turn"
Name of the flute please
taepyeongso
太平簫(태평소, Tae-pyeong-so). It's Korean traditional flute made out of bronze, I suppose?
Great costumes so unique and different from traditional uniforms
What do you mean?
@@Ptation Traditional in a sense of a cap, jacket and matching pants
@@IZRElLO747 you mean the guardian's uniforms are imaginary costumes?
@@Ptation Nope! I'm not implying that! The costumes are nice and over the top
@@IZRElLO747 Ah sorry for misunderstanding. Pleased to hear you liked the costume!
Super
너무새롭네요
1:04 does that guy make lame jokes and owns over 150 automobiles?
No he’s the king
조선도 16세기 이후부턴 총 덕후라 할만큼 일본에게 당한게커서 그런지 총으로 무장한 비율이 굉장히 높은데(정조 화성행차도만 봐도 거의 전원 총 무장) 활을 끼고 있는모습은 외국인들시선에 조선이 총기를 도입 안한 나라인줄 오해하게 할수도 있겠네요. 외국 왕실 근위대도 전부 총으로 무장했는데 21세기에 활이라니....
yun hyuk 저는 오히려 총으로 무장하지 않아서 더욱 전통적이고 신선하게 느껴지네요. 총에 익숙한 외국인들이 보기에는 활이랑 칼로 무장한게 더 멋있어 보일거에요 :))
yun hyuk 외국왕실근위대는 왕가가 남아있기에 실제무장을 했지만 한국은 관광객들을 위해만들었기에 그럴필요가없습니가
애초에 이번에 복원한 조선왕실 수문병교대식 자체가 외국인 관광객들의 오리엔탈리즘을 자극시키기 위해 만들어진 거라 봐야 돼서..
yun hyuk
오오랑 우리나라 전통은 국궁이죠 조총은 유럽에서 들어왔으니까요. 님 의견에 동의합니다.
Highly unlikely that there would be a band playing music. That's a 18th century European tradition for long marches and has thus been a part of many changes of the guard since.
nope. They actually did it. Dedicated traditional instruments and batons for military bands were used.
Numerous details remain in the preserved royal archives and administrative order documents (clothes color, ranks, event procedures, arrangement of musical instruments, etc.), and this is a maintenance of tradition. Beware of Western imperialism mentality. The world is wider and deeper than you guess.
@@sos1380 Then I suppose I was wrong. Thank you for correcting and informing me :D
@@TechWechSech :)
이 취타대와 전통 군인들을 세계태투대회에 참가시키세요.세계군악대회에 참가시키시고요.
참가 했습니다.
Korea now don’t have royal family
본 수문장 교대식 중 가장 역동적인데?
Bring back Imperial Korea
я думал это шествие новогодних гномов, которые хором зовут Папу Ноуэлля и его Снегурку...оказывается "гвардия"....
일년내내 이집단을 세계대도시 거리행진공연 시켰으면/
정부와 삼성 현대 엘지 에스케이 등 대기업둘은 뭐하시나 ?해외에서 협찬 후원공연하게 하면 본전 뽑을텐데..
한국의 수많은 취타대가 있지만 ,이 취타대가 실력이 가장 높음,,
보러오게 하면 되지..뭔 광대들 처럼 거리를 누벼서 뭐 인정욕구 푸는 것도 아니고..영국왕실 경비대가 세게 곳곳을 누비벼 거리공연하는 거 봤음?
하나둘 구령넣는건 창작이죠?
그 술은 다녀와서 마시겠소
Ehh ?! But South-Korea is a Republic or are they just as confused as the French who act more Royal in their Military habits then actual Monarchies do today ?!
ThatDutchguy well that is true...but the changing of the guard is a ceremonial and a way to keep the tradition of the Josen dynasty. Also this is a way to give a glimpse the foreign people of the Josen dynasty.
Han Bit Jang Then why not keep a member of the Royal House of Josen as a Monarch if it's so culturally significant to the South-Korean people, instead of playing make believe is my next question ?
Democracy can go hand in hand with a Monarch quite well, it works in:
The Kingdom of the Netherlands. (my country)
The Kingdom of Belgium.
The Kingdom of Sweden.
The Kingdom of Norway.
The Kingdom of Denmark.
The Kingdom of Spain.
The United Kingdom of Britain.
The Principality of Monaco.
The Principality of Andorra.
The Principality of Liechtenstein.
The Grant-Duchy of Luxembourg.
And even to some degree in the City state/Principality/Kingdom of the Vatican.
It seems to work in Asia too.
The Empire of Japan.
The Kingdom of Bhutan.
The Kingdom of Cambodia.
Oké not so much in the Kingdom of Thailand because of the internal politics, but the last King Bhumiubol Adulyadej wasn't at fault there it's the politicians and military.
Not familiar how it's going in The Kingdom of Malaysia, but haven't heard anything really bad.
And i believe there are 2 or 3 more Asian Kingdom's.
This is just of the top of my head.
I'm aware that the Middle-Eastern Monarchies aren't all too good with the exceptions of Kingdom of Jordan and the Kingdom of Morocco.
The rest of the Middle-Eastern Kingdom's and Sultanate's aren't doing well.
ThatDutchguy well most of these are just a culture fest and the guards are volunteers. Also the total house of Josen are mostly gone, there are those who survived the occupation but the actual royal line are history.
@@nathanjangs I read the Joseon royal line is gone due to Japan occupation doing by made the royals cant have the heir/child. Such cruel way to end the other monarch by ending their bloodline I think.
@@rianaZeinF Well you are right as during the occupation, most of the noble princes married the Japanese imperial princess, thus making them traitors as Korea was liberated and gained their independence. I know from the history of pre-korean war, that any Korean collaborated with the Imperial Japanese government are no longer welcomed and are banished, even if they were forced to collaborate.
I see juicis in the crow
알바들 개불쌍해 ㅜ
돈받고 하는 일인데 불쌍하다고 하면 저사람들은 뭐가되는거임?
🤔❤️🔥😜
There is Japanese explanation, isn't it?
This has nothing to do with Japan. It's a re-enactment of an ancient Korean military ritual, and we still do it today so people can see it and have fun.
Yeah there is Japanese explanation too. Because many japanese visit Seoul
Carnevalata !!!!
The Bts army
규모기 작다
จูมง
How pathetic that South Korea have a president but they also want to have a ceremony like this , perhaps it's time that South Korea should restore it's monarchy as many member of the Korean royal family are still alive and due to the historical record the royal family of Korea have done nothing wrong otherwise these show will be just something like in Disney Land...LOL [ this event also remind me of what is happening in France ..same situation lol ]
”历代中国皆以我国有箕子遗风，文物礼乐，比拟中华。今别作谚文，舍中国而自同于夷狄，是所谓弃苏合之香，而取螗螂之丸也。“
箕封遗爱
《续资治通鉴 卷二百一十四 元纪三十二》记载：“后亦多畜高丽美人，大臣有权者，辄以此遗之，京师达官贵人，必得高丽女然后为名家。自至正以来，宫中给事使令，大半高丽女，以故四方衣服、靴帽、器物，皆仿高丽，举世若狂。”
At the end of the Yuan Dynasty, Korean costumes and customs were introduced to China.
,《菽园杂记》：：“马尾裙始于朝鲜国，流入京师……于是无贵无贱，服者日盛。至成化末年，朝臣多服之者矣。阁老万公安冬夏不脱……。大臣不服者惟黎吏侍淳一人而已。此服妖也，弘治初始有禁例。”
During the Ming Dynasty, Korean costumes and customs flourished.
It was banned in the late Ming Dynasty.(弘治帝,1470~1505)
属国向天朝贡献方物美女，事大之本分
《续资治通鉴 卷二百一十四 元纪三十二》记载：“后亦多畜高丽美人，大臣有权者，辄以此遗之，京师达官贵人，必得高丽女然后为名家。自至正以来，宫中给事使令，大半高丽女，以故四方衣服、靴帽、器物，皆仿高丽，举世若狂。”
At the end of the Yuan Dynasty, Korean women were trafficked to China for emperor and
Minister‘s hobby. .
,《菽园杂记》：：“马尾裙始于朝鲜国，流入京师……于是无贵无贱，服者日盛。至成化末年，朝臣多服之者矣。阁老万公安冬夏不脱……。大臣不服者惟黎吏侍淳一人而已。此服妖也，弘治初始有禁例。”
During the Ming Dynasty, Korean costumes flourished with influence of Sovereign country
It was banned in china in the late Ming Dynasty.(弘治帝,1470~1505)
I copied the Korean costume and the vestigial culture.
During the Yuan Dynasty, Mongolia and Korea sent a girl to each other.
The Princess of Mongolia has been married to Korea.
The Han Chinese were just slaves.
Who Would want to listen to that noise?
开头好喜庆，好像谁家大姑娘出嫁一样！
瞎掰
There's no king or queen in korea lol
Yeah just like most countries lol, yet changing of the guards is common in most
It may seem funny because the Chinese are not interested in preserving and harmonizing traditions. They actually burned and destroyed their own history and culture. At the time of the Communist Party Youth Revolution ;)
Squiggly line, squiggly line, squiggly line. Followed by lots more squiggly lines. Yep that's all I have to say on that, squiggly line.
Koreans: The chinese didn't influence our culture, we aren't wearing chinese uniform!!!11
their palace gate name: "Great han chinese gate"
Why are they carrying dirty laundry on sticks ?????
Ian Robertson It's not dirty laundry, it's a flag.
Mate get a bloody sense of humour please !!!
:>))))))))
Ian Not funny at all you lunatic
because dirty country ! what else
Unemployed actors.
東京オリンピックのボランティアユニホームに似てるなぁ...あっ...(察し)
韓国をたくさん付いて、したいようだね? 。ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
쫌 쩨때로 뽀고 지껄이떼요..(한쉼)
누운을 오디다가 두꼬 다니씨는쥐이..
이 궁뎅빠알간 웡숭이야아(붠역기 도올려도 닌줠뙈 해썩모태ㅋ)
괘니 부우러워썽 깝쏴는고냐?
@@choi4887 위에 일본분 그냥"도쿄 올림픽 유니폼이랑 진짜로 비슷하게 생겼네...하하.."라고 말했는데 왜 그렇게 호전적으로 말하세요ㅋ
조선왕을 개 버리듯 한 우리민족 참 왕 없는 곳에 뭐하는 곳인가? 일본한테 그리고 우리민족한테 버림받은 존재가 조선 왕이었네. 왕족이 없는 곳에 뭐하는 곳인고?
I wish Korea brought back the Monarchy