That waking up scene was the most "wake up to reality" scene I've ever seen. Waking up on a pool of his own blood with no one to help him, yet he must continue moving forward. This is just terrifyingly magnificent and captures human survival instinct.
Yup. Mud on the scope or moisture or something. The 1917 rifles were accurate when in good condition. Heavy on the recoil, no laser range finder though.
I would say he was sleep deprived because if he was drunk, he wouldn’t be camping at the window just staring and then almost hitting Schofield multiple times. Bro must hadn’t slept for days💀
Both most likely. Sleep would have been hard to come by on the front lines, and soldiers got booze rations, along with any booze they might come across in towns/cities they occupied.
@@stevehughes2133 anyways, there are real semi auto jewels like SVD Dragunov or M1 Springfield to do the job which have the right caliber and are faster than the ancient bolt action rifles...
That's the first thought that came to my mind when I watched the movie. The second thought was "Wow, the Lee Enfield cycles much faster than a Carcano."
@@denniss155 You're trying to make a comparison that doesn't work. That's like trying to compare a Guppy to an Angle Fish. They may be fish (like your comparison being guns), but they're different. Besides, you're only angry that you're too fat and lazy top operate a bolt action on a gun. Something any simpleton can do.
If the German sniper has a Gewehr 98, he has a five round internal magazine, so five shots before he has to reload. There was an extended magazine that was issued to snipers, so the German sniper could have that as an equalizer. The SMLE of the British soldier has a ten round internal magazine, which should give him a significant advantage in a close-quarters fight.
@@engiturtle65 And besides I don’t think that the guy here was even a sniper. He lacked aim and a scope and was likely more of a soldier they left behind to buy them some time.
It's interesting how deeply personal all of Schofield's kills are in this movie, no shooting it out with waves of enemy soldiers, he is just locked in these horrible, lonely, desperate struggles with another guy who is probably not much different from him and just trying to survive.
The art direction/production design and set decoration in this movie are all so good- some of the best I’ve ever seen. It’s totally believable that he is in that actual environment in that period.
This is WWI, idiot. And not even a sniper. As many have pointed out, his rifle was not scoped at all, he lacked aim and was probably a guy they just left behind to buy them more time.
@@RelicForgeCoand they didn’t learn how to shoot? If the british guy can shoot accurately then the germans can too. Your infantryman thing can’t be an excuse
I love that everyone in this comment section is suddenly a WW1 veteran who understands the ins and outs of warfare. People can't just watch and enjoy a movie anymore without pointing out every single little nit pick. It's very sad tbh.
A la guerre Monsieur on n'a pas toute sa tête....puisqu'on la fait....comme Mammifère....l'être humain veut toujours plus chez les autres....alors il tuent pour s'en approprier...il ne quitte pas son ANIMILTE.....qu'il a en lui....l'éveil n'est pas son point fort....l'homme se saoule, viole et tue.....avec une médaille Militaire en plus....
@hellohelloyeah that may be true,but in real life situations that would be the dumbest move you could make.unless your just ready to stop living of course.
The kid is not a sniper but a sentry duty. Look at him holding the G98 rifle only using his left hand. 2:38 Edit: you can also see his rifle here for proof 4:26
it's the movie 1917 I saw it in theaters a few years ago the plot is a British troop is delivering a message too a group of soldiers too call off an attack
This is how I envisioned things whenever I asked to be excused from class (with a hall pass made from wood) for the bathroom in Green Valley Elementary School.
The German sniper was quite clever. He silenced his weapon and aroused the curiosity of the English soldier who went up to make sure the enemy had been hit. Finally, two young men fighting and dying at the will and whim of the powerful. Human cruelty!
When I was 14 in something called HVU. We used actual surplus Nazi Mauser rifles, from the occupation in ww2. We were expected to hit the bullseye at 300 meters with iron sights. Point is, no one would miss a guy standing like that at ca 100 meters.
Because it’s a movie. A soldier behind enemy lines in any war would have a round chambered. Without a doubt. But, he would also have the safety selected to “safe”. At first contact, his finger would place the safety off to be ready to fire.
Context, for those who have not seen “1917”: Earlier in the movie, Schofield (the soldier) had shot/killed a German, but didn’t chamber another round due to a more pressing matter (no spoiler) 😁. Good continuity, from a production standpoint.
@@tubalcain6874 Yes that is true in the magazine but a switched on soldier would always put one up the spout then the 10 round magazine. My uncle was a WW2 veteran from PNG and as I am an ex-soldier myself he told many things of what they did over there during the Kokoda campaign.
Snipers were not nearly as common in WW1 as you might think ,those tactics would not be applied by soldiers at this point. Also the German soldier is clearly a watchmen of some type, not a designated sniper. He wouldn't have a scope.
@@ArcticWolf00Alpha0the germans left snipers on the retreat so this is clearly some bs. "Not as common" yeah but this tactic was leaving a sniper behind
@@archmagosdominusbelisarius8836 I understand what your saying, but a Sniper doesn't have to be a person with a scope all the time, if they have a good aim or marksmanship then that is sometimes more than enough. I can't imagine in 1917 the Germans were passing out Snipers with scopes at this point. Its not out of the realm of possibility.
Lee Enfield. 303, fastest large scale production military rifle in history. Still in frontline service in Canada and Afghanistan (the 'known ones anyway). Rimed cartridge and breech far safer than other competitors from that era. Headspace nonsense just that, nonsense. If I had a choice between a bunny Woke F88 Steyr, 'Jam a minute' SLR or Lee Enfield the latter would be preferred. Just takes a little weekend practice for the 'mad minute' rapid fire.
Being close range to a sniper that KNOWS your location and popping up your head multiple times in the same spot is like asking for your face to become mince meat. What a dumbass.
It'd be one thing to participate in a big chaotic battle, or to shoot artillery at an unseen enemy, or anything like that. It'd be totally different to coldly shoot at a lone kid who's jumping over a stream and doesn't even know you're there, like at the very beginning of the video. I know he's an enemy and it could be "kill or be killed", but still. Awful thing, war.
.223 is plenty lethal, especially at those ranges. And he could carry twice as much .223 (compared to the .303 he's carrying). And really, your brain stem doesn't care whether it's hit by a .303 or .223 or a .22lr - you're dropping dead regardless which size bullet it is.
I thought it would’ve been cool if when he goes to open the door the German guy is about to kill himself because he is also terrified just like the other soldier
@@Cole-Nano 0:04 He's standing on the bridge squaring up for a jump. He's stock still. "Sniper"'s first shot is a big ol miss. 0:09 Post jump he's hanging on to the bridge and the "sniper" again misses, this time well behind him. After this he only escapes being shot by the bridge supports, demonstrating that the "sniper" had zero reason to have that shot fall so far behind him. 1:00 He comes up the stairs and the "sniper" narrowly misses, showing that the "sniper" has successfully predicted where he will emerge. He then gathers his courage, hauls himself out of cover, raises his rifle and fires while the "sniper" AGAIN misses despite having the location pinpointed and not having to move from cover or raise his rifle. This scenario then repeats itself, but this time he hits the "sniper" before said "sniper" can even fire, again from a clearly more advantageous position.
That waking up scene was the most "wake up to reality" scene I've ever seen. Waking up on a pool of his own blood with no one to help him, yet he must continue moving forward. This is just terrifyingly magnificent and captures human survival instinct.
That sniper probably must have been sleep deprived or drinking on the job for missing the first and last shots.
Yup. Mud on the scope or moisture or something. The 1917 rifles were accurate when in good condition. Heavy on the recoil, no laser range finder though.
I would say he was sleep deprived because if he was drunk, he wouldn’t be camping at the window just staring and then almost hitting Schofield multiple times. Bro must hadn’t slept for days💀
It is a movie stupid
Both most likely. Sleep would have been hard to come by on the front lines, and soldiers got booze rations, along with any booze they might come across in towns/cities they occupied.
Doubtful he was even a sniper. Probably some poor kid they left behind to slow down the enemy. Snipers were to valuable to leave behind
Notice the fast bolt action cycle on the Lee Enfield, great rifles!!
@@stevehughes2133 anyways, there are real semi auto jewels like SVD Dragunov or M1 Springfield to do the job which have the right caliber and are faster than the ancient bolt action rifles...
@@denniss155 I thought the Springfield was a straight-pull, not a semi-auto?
@@jamesfinch6139 : yes it was a straight-pull action.
That's the first thought that came to my mind when I watched the movie.
The second thought was "Wow, the Lee Enfield cycles much faster than a Carcano."
@@denniss155 You're trying to make a comparison that doesn't work. That's like trying to compare a Guppy to an Angle Fish. They may be fish (like your comparison being guns), but they're different.
Besides, you're only angry that you're too fat and lazy top operate a bolt action on a gun. Something any simpleton can do.
If the German sniper has a Gewehr 98, he has a five round internal magazine, so five shots before he has to reload. There was an extended magazine that was issued to snipers, so the German sniper could have that as an equalizer. The SMLE of the British soldier has a ten round internal magazine, which should give him a significant advantage in a close-quarters fight.
I don't think so, the german sniper never uses a semi, they used kar 98k bolt action rifle
@@apbtmaxx lol no, snipers during ww1 did not use a kar98, and the kar98k didn't exist in ww1
pretty sure the snipers did not use the extended trench magazine, but could be wrong
@@engiturtle65 you right, I said that thinking in 2ww, my mistake
@@engiturtle65 And besides I don’t think that the guy here was even a sniper. He lacked aim and a scope and was likely more of a soldier they left behind to buy them some time.
It's interesting how deeply personal all of Schofield's kills are in this movie, no shooting it out with waves of enemy soldiers, he is just locked in these horrible, lonely, desperate struggles with another guy who is probably not much different from him and just trying to survive.
The art direction/production design and set decoration in this movie are all so good- some of the best I’ve ever seen. It’s totally believable that he is in that actual environment in that period.
That German sniper must be drunk😂 😂
he wasn’t actually a sniper. Just a regular infantryman
The cinematography in this movie is mesmerizing.
4:17 this was so trippy.
Like didn’t understand what was going on past the window
This is the snipers debut,first day in combat.
he wasn’t a sniper. Just a regular infantryman
USA WW2 sniper in movies：one shot one kill
German WW1 sniper in movies：stormtrooper
ww1 bruv
This is WWI, idiot. And not even a sniper. As many have pointed out, his rifle was not scoped at all, he lacked aim and was probably a guy they just left behind to buy them more time.
@@danielmadsen8047those rifles were accurate, dont comment if you dont know anything
he wasn’t a sniper. Just a regular infantryman
@@RelicForgeCoand they didn’t learn how to shoot? If the british guy can shoot accurately then the germans can too. Your infantryman thing can’t be an excuse
I love that everyone in this comment section is suddenly a WW1 veteran who understands the ins and outs of warfare. People can't just watch and enjoy a movie anymore without pointing out every single little nit pick. It's very sad tbh.
Yeah cuz its so immersive that the german sniper magically misses all the shots
Always, on almost any subject. The arrogance of mankind, and then they spend days arguing with ea other. 😂😂😂
It's the generation of morons making those comments
The sniper couldnt see straight and the soldier wasnt very smart walking out in the open not knowing if the sniper was dead or not.
A la guerre Monsieur on n'a pas toute sa tête....puisqu'on la fait....comme Mammifère....l'être humain veut toujours plus chez les autres....alors il tuent pour s'en approprier...il ne quitte pas son ANIMILTE.....qu'il a en lui....l'éveil n'est pas son point fort....l'homme se saoule, viole et tue.....avec une médaille Militaire en plus....
Bro that was 1917 the furst modern war 😊 they still unfamiliar with lots of war aspects
@@sofianelimari8013 basic survival wasn't new to ww1. Plus those countries in Europe had been doing war since ages
The soldier was probably supposed to walk out in the open because the director wanted to focus his subjects on just the soldier and the sniper alone.
@hellohelloyeah that may be true,but in real life situations that would be the dumbest move you could make.unless your just ready to stop living of course.
Knowing which window the sniper was in Flanking would have been a good option
he wasn’t a sniper. Just a regular infantryman
We appreciate how well you’ve articulated your insights. Keep working hard.
Reminds me of the sniper in Saving Private Ryan and Full Metal Jacket.
The German was just sitting there thinking of beer
The kid is not a sniper but a sentry duty. Look at him holding the G98 rifle only using his left hand. 2:38
Edit: you can also see his rifle here for proof 4:26
This is awesomely explained.. thanks mate
Given the location of the sniper, that 1st bullet hitting the wall of the stairs isn't possible. That location has complete defilade from the sniper.
Richochet
just a movie, dork
@@handlehead dumb comment
This shot might be possible actually. You cannot tell...
Dude shooting out a window does not equal "sniper" in this case.
Yeah he wasn’t a sniper. Just a regular infantryman
Just glad I can watch this as a movie.. what a horror show. Great movie.
The plot armour is strong in that Tommy.
Hi everyone! What grade (out of 10) would you give this video?
MINUS 10
Название фильма скажи
it's the movie 1917 I saw it in theaters a few years ago the plot is a British troop is delivering a message too a group of soldiers too call off an attack
And is miffed by a haughty Benedict Cumberbatch (who is probably really like that).
9
The sniper must’ve been a Storm Trooper
A tutti questi commenti degli "esperti" rispondo con un unica frase. Si chiama "finzione cinematografica" si usa da sempre nei film.
😂 Bro failed all the shots
The Lee Enfield is such a cool rifle.
The Enfield must have been a very strong rifle!
This is how I envisioned things whenever I asked to be excused from class (with a hall pass made from wood) for the bathroom in Green Valley Elementary School.
The sniper thought he could no scope that first shot.
he wasn’t a sniper. Just a regular infantryman
Excellent movie 🎬🏅
It looks like the sniper had so many chances to hit the soldier!!!
he wasn’t a sniper. Just a regular infantryman
The snipers biggest mistake was not setting a bouncing betty to cover his six.
The German sniper was quite clever. He silenced his weapon and aroused the curiosity of the English soldier who went up to make sure the enemy had been hit. Finally, two young men fighting and dying at the will and whim of the powerful. Human cruelty!
Who seems to be a sniper is actually the ordinary soldier cause took better shots than the so called sniper...
Sa frapper fort, sa fait 2 ans que je voulais voir la suite.
grandes recuerdos
When I was 14 in something called HVU. We used actual surplus Nazi Mauser rifles, from the occupation in ww2. We were expected to hit the bullseye at 300 meters with iron sights. Point is, no one would miss a guy standing like that at ca 100 meters.
German not nazi
@@archmagosdominusbelisarius8836he's talking about the weapons he used which is definitely Kar98K not Gewehr 98
@@guts-141 that is still german not nazi
‘Sniper’ shot from like 50 yards and missed by 4 feet, not much of a sniper.
he wasn’t a sniper. Just a regular infantryman
Why would a soldier move about without a live round in the chamber?
Probably for safety reasons😊
Because it’s a movie. A soldier behind enemy lines in any war would have a round chambered. Without a doubt. But, he would also have the safety selected to “safe”. At first contact, his finger would place the safety off to be ready to fire.
Context, for those who have not seen “1917”:
Earlier in the movie, Schofield (the soldier) had shot/killed a German, but didn’t chamber another round due to a more pressing matter (no spoiler) 😁.
Good continuity, from a production standpoint.
Clearly you haven't seen the movie, lmfao.
@@jayswee yeah, and if nervous enough like maybe one could be for good reasons, you would cycle anyways, so why lose another round
Franz "squinty eyes" Muller was probably one of the the worst sniper in WWI...
probably because he wasn’t a sniper. He was a sentry.
Yo limpie uno ❤
The sniper was the famous "blindman"
Wow what's the name of this flick
1917
Its in the title
"Don't Bother".
Что за фильм?
Playing COD Mobile taught me how to use the pump action. Don't let a single round go to waste and hit your target or die.
А зачем снайперу столько раз стрелять по солдиеру?
Он же свою позицию палит
How many rounds in that clip?
Lee enfields can carry 10 bullets
@@breakafreak That is correct. 10 round mag and one in the spout if you were on the ball.
10 rounds in a Lee Enfield.
@@tubalcain6874 Yes that is true in the magazine but a switched on soldier would always put one up the spout then the 10 round magazine. My uncle was a WW2 veteran from PNG and as I am an ex-soldier myself he told many things of what they did over there during the Kokoda campaign.
Run
A sniper never misses
What type of gun does Schofield use?
Lee-Enfield rifle.
How could He Miss the first Shot?Seriously?At the moment,Schofield's was ''Standing'' Ducks....
Sniping with a revolver.
I could shoot better with my bow than a sniper with that gun
One of the most unrealistic scenes in this otherwise 10/10 movie.
Isto é só um filme. Se fosse realidade seria diferente.
Снайпер перебрал со шнапсом 😄
What movie is this clip from
1917
Só que em combate real o soldado aprende a JAMAIS abrir uma porta com o corpo na frente.
Snipers only shoot 1 round, maybe 2, and then change position. Also, their rifle would be sighted in prior to going out.
Snipers were not nearly as common in WW1 as you might think ,those tactics would not be applied by soldiers at this point. Also the German soldier is clearly a watchmen of some type, not a designated sniper. He wouldn't have a scope.
@@ArcticWolf00Alpha0the germans left snipers on the retreat so this is clearly some bs. "Not as common" yeah but this tactic was leaving a sniper behind
@@archmagosdominusbelisarius8836 I understand what your saying, but a Sniper doesn't have to be a person with a scope all the time, if they have a good aim or marksmanship then that is sometimes more than enough. I can't imagine in 1917 the Germans were passing out Snipers with scopes at this point. Its not out of the realm of possibility.
In real, he would be dead at once😮
The guy has no scope. If his rear sight is not correctly set up... He's gonna miss... So totally likely...
he wasn’t a sniper. Just a regular infantryman
Lee Enfield. 303, fastest large scale production military rifle in history. Still in frontline service in Canada and Afghanistan (the 'known ones anyway). Rimed cartridge and breech far safer than other competitors from that era. Headspace nonsense just that, nonsense. If I had a choice between a bunny Woke F88 Steyr, 'Jam a minute' SLR or Lee Enfield the latter would be preferred. Just takes a little weekend practice for the 'mad minute' rapid fire.
Sure
Being close range to a sniper that KNOWS your location and popping up your head multiple times in the same spot is like asking for your face to become mince meat. What a dumbass.
It'd be one thing to participate in a big chaotic battle, or to shoot artillery at an unseen enemy, or anything like that. It'd be totally different to coldly shoot at a lone kid who's jumping over a stream and doesn't even know you're there, like at the very beginning of the video. I know he's an enemy and it could be "kill or be killed", but still. Awful thing, war.
That sniper was sure blind for missing all his shots
it's just a movie
Maybe he wasn't a sniper to begin with, just a regular soldier manning a post.
@@handlehead thats your best excuse for something being bad?
@@joseyzadoria7815 the germans left behind snipers during retreats not regular soldiers. Its not a post its an abandoned place.
@@archmagosdominusbelisarius8836 Were you there?
Full name movie
"Sniper for dummies"
1917
Those rifles had the right calibers to go to a war. Nowadays those bb guns (.223) are a kind of joke 🤣
.223 is plenty lethal, especially at those ranges. And he could carry twice as much .223 (compared to the .303 he's carrying). And really, your brain stem doesn't care whether it's hit by a .303 or .223 or a .22lr - you're dropping dead regardless which size bullet it is.
worst sniper ever
I thought it would’ve been cool if when he goes to open the door the German guy is about to kill himself because he is also terrified just like the other soldier
1917 (фильм)
Какой же это снайпер? 10 выстрелов и мимо. При такой позиции этот англичанин был бы уже трупом.
Joke. The sniper us even worse than regular soilder.
That was a regular soldier, though. He was a sentry
Стреляют с другой стороны😅
What the poet wanted to say?
Last 2 sniper sweats on wz
These rifles had a massive recoil. Which is missing in the clip😂
No era francotirador estaba escondido y asustado
This is the worst sniper scene ever, target is right in front of you like 50 mtrs and he misses.The first stair case shot was an impossible shot.
He did hit him. Did you not watch the clip?
Это какой-то начинающий снайпер. Столько выстрелов и все в молоко!
Soldat contre très très mauvais...sniper😂
Worst. Sniper. Ever.
yeah he missed like 6 time on a on running target😭
@@Cole-Nano 0:04 He's standing on the bridge squaring up for a jump. He's stock still. "Sniper"'s first shot is a big ol miss.
0:09 Post jump he's hanging on to the bridge and the "sniper" again misses, this time well behind him. After this he only escapes being shot by the bridge supports, demonstrating that the "sniper" had zero reason to have that shot fall so far behind him.
1:00 He comes up the stairs and the "sniper" narrowly misses, showing that the "sniper" has successfully predicted where he will emerge. He then gathers his courage, hauls himself out of cover, raises his rifle and fires while the "sniper" AGAIN misses despite having the location pinpointed and not having to move from cover or raise his rifle. This scenario then repeats itself, but this time he hits the "sniper" before said "sniper" can even fire, again from a clearly more advantageous position.
he wasn’t a sniper. Just a regular infantryman
@@Cole-Nano he wasn’t a sniper. Just a regular infantryman
@@asphaltmilkshake4596what sniper? he wasn’t a sniper. Just a regular infantryman
Worst sniper in the world
Косой снайпер против тупого солдата 😂
That wasnt a German sniper.
Like if you paused the video just to see what the german sniper looked like...
Like bait
Que mentira absurda.😂
Snipers are the most truly cowards
Not really, it was likely an automatic death sentence if you got caught a lot of times
They both can't shoot. So they end up killing each other. 😆😆😆What a joke. 😆😆😆
Only the sniper died. The soldier didn’t