i badly want to sing this but my voice always fail me edit: Thank you so much for your kind words! And those who're like me, let's work hard and sing this until we are satisfied. Let music help us be happy. 💕 (sorry for my bad English)
This song is very hard for beginners mostly cause you need to be an expert using a mix voice, chest and head. She brings a lot of mask to her range too. Try mastering your middle and low range first using chest voice and open throat [low larynx]
Yea.. She said this is the most emotional songs she's ever written.. (She put her heart in it, completely.) About her and Gerald.. She says it's also about other relationships, things she saw her friends go thru.. Blah blah.. It's all her and Gerald. Her video (the regular one.. Newest one..), thats all about her and him. Now she's free (if you haven't seen her MTV EMA performance, you should. Right now! Lol.) Unbelievable. So telling.. 😲
It’s such a stupid argument because EVERY singer uses it. Mostly just to correct the notes you just can’t hit. I actually think your label would fire you if you never used it, they want their songs to be perfect anyways
hey guys. Anyone who is reading this - I hope you're doing great and staying safe. I know people dont like these kind of comments but hear me out, only if you are interested, i did a mash up of Halsey songs on my guitar. please check it out if u want. Peace.🧡🧡🧡👉👈
I think that’s the appeal of these live lounge versions to me. The original studio versions get over produced. Just let the awesome singer and musicians do their job and get out of their way. You know what I mean?
Her changing "Thinking you can live without me" to just "Live without me" affected me in ways I can't even explain. EDIT: Even if it is her just being out of breath, it personally changed the meaning of the song for me so y'all can stop commenting about that lmao.
@@ThanhPham-vt6kv I feel like her singing "Thinking you can live without me" implies that whoever she's singing about still has her in their life while "Live without me" implies that they don't talk anymore and the other person has to deal with the fact that she's not there for them anymore.
Why people have to judge her clothes, or her makeup. She is there to sing, so please appreciate her singing and her talent. People care more abt what she wears or looks.
@@cocainejesus65 No dude you have a great taste in people 😎 and I think even if anyone doesn't like what she's wearing, they should keep their mouth shut bcuz she's an artist, not a model!
Skin cleared Depression gone Wig flew Hotel trivago Dad came back Edit: OMG TYSM IVE NEVER HAD THIS MANY LIKES❤️❤️❤️ Edit 2: 1,800 LIKES OMG I CANT BELIEVE IT AHHHHH!!!
It's because in the track there's another take of her singing the chorus as a backup vocal. Instead of rushing to get to the next line, she just skips to, "live without me." It's easier on the voice and makes for a better performance. It's not to disappoint the crowd it's a preservation of breath to hit the next note without strain, and a cleaner performance.
her vocals just get better and better every year i’m so beyond proud of her, as a fan since room 93. she’s come so far and even though she could still work on some parts of her voice i think she sounds absolutely heavenly here.
Christina C I hated that fake-deep edgy persona she was trying to pull off in Badlands. Hopeless Fountain Kingdom is more experimental and vocally/lyrically impressing. The fake-deep constant overbearing mental health enforcing meanings was so annoying. I love when artists use their platform to break stigmas like that but in EVERY song she had to mention some sort of corny mental illness and drug related metaphor
Don't really understand the hype around these Live Lounges; I've heard so many people raving about it saying how good they all are. I've heard a few and in my opinion, they were all pretty bad. This, on the other hand is amazing. She has such an amazing voice both in the polished/finished version, and Live too, which is quite rare these days.
It really depends on the artist, but for some they improve on the original track by adding a bit of live flair and you get the real soulful performance too :)
Ste Bradbury Design ZARA LARSSON'S live was shit. Not because of her voice (she's frigging talented) but it's because of the mic or the person handling the sounds n stuff.
@@wheniwas15yearoldiwasraped92 Ummmm..... This person was complimenting Halsey. You like halsey right? Then respect her opinion. Dont make her/him regret complimenting halsey. Respect her/him opinion and respect the Artists she/he likes. And they will respects yours. PS. Grow up no one likes a hater
raf mpn check out her interviews on the song. It breaks it down. Every word really does have meaning. Even the Justin Timberlake verse from Cry Me a River. I think she carefully constructs her lyrics, which all artists should do but it’s obvious that many do not.
The stripped version of this song always hits me HARD. It’s a song so relatable. I love that she switched “thinking you can live without me” to “live without me” like she’s letting go officially. The stripped down album version has “go on and live without me”. Beautiful.
Watching this vid reminded me of when I first found Halsey in a video singing Hurricane live for Vevo Discover. The raw emotion and honesty are what set her apart from so many other singers.
Wow. Can we agree she is the most underrated artist out here right now. The kind of voice that gives me the tingles. Beautiful. She paints with her voice.
Heartbreak doesn't just happen to women, this song makes me smile and hurts all at the same time. This song is my last relationship down to the last word.
her voice is honestly has me in tears omg she works so hard for everyone and never fails to make them proud she needs to appreciated for how far she has gone and how hard she's worked like I JUST LOVE HOW HUMBLE AND COMPASSIONATE SHE IS.her voice is very beautiful I love it.
LYRICS ♡ Found you when your heart was broke I filled your cup until it overflowed Took it so far to keep you close (keep you close) I was afraid to leave you on your own I said I'd catch you if you fall And if they laugh, then fuck 'em all (all) And then I got you off your knees Put you right back on your feet Just so you could take advantage of me Tell me how's it feel sittin' up there Feeling so high but too far away to hold me You know I'm the one who put you up there Name in the sky Does it ever get lonely? Thinking you could live without me Thinking you could live without me Baby, I'm the one who put you up there I don't know why (yeah, I don't know why) Thinking you could live without me Live without me Baby, I'm the one who put you up there I don't know why (I don't know why, yeah yeah) Gave love 'bout a hundred tries (hundred tries) Just running from the demons in your mind Then I took yours and made 'em mine (made 'em mine) I didn't notice 'cause my love was blind Said I'd catch you if you fall (fall) And if they laugh, then fuck 'em all (all) And then I got you off your knees Put you right back on your feet Just so you can take advantage of me Tell me how's it feel sittin' up there Feeling so high but too far away to hold me You know I'm the one who put you up there Name in the sky Does it ever get lonely? Thinking you could live without me Thinking you could live without me Baby, I'm the one who put you up there I don't know why (yeah, I don't know why) Thinking you could live without me Live without me Baby, I'm the one who put you up there I don't know why, yeah You don't have to say just what you did I already know (I know) I had to go and find out from them So tell me how's it feel (oh-woah) Tell me how's it feel sittin' up there Feeling so high but too far away to hold me You know I'm the one who put you up there Name in the sky Does it ever get lonely? Thinking you could live without me Thinking you could live without me Baby, I'm the one who put you up there I don't know why (yeah, I don't know why)
Okay, I’m a Halsey fan, HOWEVER, for the people wanting clarification on the “auto-tune” debate, here it is: This is NOT Auto-Tune. It’s a live tool called Melodyne. It’s a subtle pitch correction tool that adds a metallic filter to the notes. A lot of artists use it, and as a music fan, I personally don’t mind it. The original Without Me has FULL BLOWN auto tune, which again is fine. Stylistically, the melodyne sounds awesome on this acoustic version. She has improved so much, and I sincerely enjoyed the raw energy she provided with amazing LIVE filtered production. Appreciate the style. If you can’t, exit the app or switch to your type of live music. Thanks for coming to my Ted Talk ❤️
Its auto tune, auto tune is just another name for pitch correction, melodyne is an auto tuning software so yeah she is auto tuned 👌 not a hater either.
Melodyne does not have a mode for live performances. Even tho this is Live Lounge they do post production before uploading it to TH-cam so it most likely is Melodyne.
So almost 9 month since my wife left me. This song helped me so much after those first few weeks. My ex wanted me to be a stay at home dad, so I left my career and did. After a 3 yrs, she decided that we were done. I was jobless and left in the wind co confused and desperate. Things are getting better but I’m still without employment and hurting.
Last January I found out my wife was seeing someone else she waited till my payday to tell me she wanted to build a life with him left me penny less I left on the weds the day after he was in my bed I know your pain .. 12months on got a new lady in my life who basically saved me from self distruct mode in a good place now the pain has died but the hate towards them is still present & will be for some time I think
Miguel Soliz i can feel that pain. I quit my job for my ex and he treated me as useless when im jobless. Some ppl they just don't see how much we sacrificed . They will never appreciate your efforts because they never did for you
We mustn't dissolve in people we are married to. We shouldn't sacrifice for them. They become uninterested in us. We lose our personality if we do that. The pain will go away, but we must learn the lesson they taught us.
@@DM-tk1gf я имел ввиду то как она берет ноты,чистоты диапазон и все остальное ,этому невозможно научиться это с рождения,есть многие люди которые не могут петь потому что генетика голосовых связок не позволяет,и сколько не тренеруй их один хрен будет не то.Вот что я имел ввиду.
She sounds amazing live. All the editing in her usual music background I think makes her songs worse. Deconstruct it. Break it down. I bet her acoustic record would sell more than a legit album.
Nessers she also did a killer acoustic on Bad at Love. I didn’t know she had those kind of vocals. I do enjoy the acoustic raw versions without all of the aesthetics as opposed to the ones with all of the bells and whistles. Both are great, however, and better than anything out right now. I just prefer Halsey this way.
The thing is I know Halsey can get pitchy and doesn’t have the best technique, but I always feel her raw emotions singing and that’s what matters more sometimes than someone who is technical.
Angela G Haha no worries! I’m not sure if she means anything by it, or if maybe her and G-Eazy have broken up. I just noticed that every time during that part she didn’t say “thinking you could.” It could mean something or not! I’m not positive! :)
When you have to perform but also have to immediately go paint a house.
Honestly this deserves more likes
😂😂😂😂
Or take a trip to Mars
underrated comment LOL
😂😂😂
i badly want to sing this but my voice always fail me
edit:
Thank you so much for your kind words! And those who're like me, let's work hard and sing this until we are satisfied. Let music help us be happy. 💕 (sorry for my bad English)
This song is very hard for beginners mostly cause you need to be an expert using a mix voice, chest and head. She brings a lot of mask to her range too. Try mastering your middle and low range first using chest voice and open throat [low larynx]
@@I_Am_Midnight-i thank you for your reply!! I'll practice more !!
Put those headphones on full volume and sing it
You don't need a good voice in these times. You just need auto tune and pitch correction programs.
Put your ear phones in full blast then you cannot hear your voice
This is so raw and emotional I can tell this song means a lot to Ashley.
Yea.. She said this is the most emotional songs she's ever written.. (She put her heart in it, completely.) About her and Gerald.. She says it's also about other relationships, things she saw her friends go thru.. Blah blah.. It's all her and Gerald. Her video (the regular one.. Newest one..), thats all about her and him.
Now she's free (if you haven't seen her MTV EMA performance, you should. Right now! Lol.) Unbelievable. So telling.. 😲
Ashley?
@@tiannahjankey i think Ashley is her real name but it represents her past self....
@@shelbygarcia2038 ohhhh makes sence thank you telling me that 💜
Tiannah Jankey
A - H
S - A
H - L
L - S
E - E
Y - Y
It sounded so painful.
The pain was felt. :((
It's a painful song ☹️
more painful when she got jimin's feelings.😀👍
@@geoycedegucena2379 ya girl😃👍🏻
Yea😥
I'm crying
She has a real voice without autotune.
Awesome Daughtry10 Did you mean no autotune??
Ya
@@indsexhibit8961
Halsey is better than BTS
When I was 15 year old, I was raped by three women no one asked you
When I was 15 year old, I was raped by three women - .....she’s a solo....
Haters: Halsey uses autotune
Halsey: hold my beer
*hold my eyeliner
Hahahha
Very repetitive comment.. idiot. Make your own shit up
Are you saying this because you think she sounds good or the fact that she obviously isn’t using autotune here and it shows
It’s such a stupid argument because EVERY singer uses it. Mostly just to correct the notes you just can’t hit. I actually think your label would fire you if you never used it, they want their songs to be perfect anyways
One of her best songs ❤ Love her voice it's so calming
wouldnt use the word calming
JohnBarrVlogs what word would you choose?
^ JohnBarrVlogs bitch answer
Soothing?
Mariaaa Karaiskaki one of THE best songs 💙
Haters: Halsey uses autotune
Halsey: Hold my paint brush
🤣🤣🤣🤣
LMAO 😭
😂😂😂
OMG 🤣🤣🤣
Wdym it was obviously autotuned. But i ain't hating tho i love her songs
Felt cute, might paint a wall later idk
I might cook later.
IM WHEEEZZINNGG
I'm seeing this painting the wall joke once in a while in the comments but I don't really get what it is about.
Szilárd Balog they're talking about her outfit
I was thinking she gonna jump into some plumbing pipes.
Director: How much autotune?
Halsey:No
Make up artist:Which eye liner?
Halsey:Yea.
mick jagger john mulaney?
#funny
hey guys. Anyone who is reading this - I hope you're doing great and staying safe. I know people dont like these kind of comments but hear me out, only if you are interested, i did a mash up of Halsey songs on my guitar. please check it out if u want. Peace.🧡🧡🧡👉👈
estoy segura que se maquillo ella misma
@@guillerminadutruel17 si yo tambien
_The emotions she's singing with gets me everytime, like, _*_Damm girl_*
_literally_
Ayati Bhatnagar you mean like Damm Gerald !
This is more beautiful than original version.
I like this version but original was best
No it's not
Totally agree
I think that’s the appeal of these live lounge versions to me. The original studio versions get over produced. Just let the awesome singer and musicians do their job and get out of their way. You know what I mean?
Don't exaggerate
neon eyeliner is a LOOK
Feminista allegados contemplad a las exclamaciones que nos mantendrán unidos. Te diré que te atrapare, y les diré que se vayan si te caes.
HER VOICE IS AMAZING. JIMIN: HALSEY YOUR VOICE SO HMMM(NICE). AND I AGREE WITH JIMIN
Putri Perona SAAMMMEEEE 😊😄😁😃😀😆💜💜💜💜
SAMEE
Dangggg ARMYs everywhere!
Sameee
I hate her voice... she just can’t sing maybe she should stick to autotune
Swear I was dead inside and these vocals brought me back to life 💀🦋
fuckn mood
Raw....supberbly raw ❤
she is so beautiful that she can wear absolutly every haircut, every haircolor, and every clothes... nothing will makes her look bad ♥
Touchwood ❤️
Every eyeliner also
Exactly!! 👌👌 she's perfect for me❤❤
RiGhT
So so soo. , KooL
She was trying pretty hard to look bad, but when someone has a voice like that it doesn't matter what they look like.
Love that neon yellow eye liner 😍 who else?
edit:1.5k
likes😱🥰
Me too
she took it too far in the VS performance this month
Ellie Dewar it's very cute
Me too
Ellie Dewar it’s better than the Penguin from Surf’s Up eyebrows she rocked at the VS show Lmao
Can I get a 10hour loop of just the guitar? That shit so relaxing
Ikr loool, it's just so calm
You can also learn this and ten record. It sounds easy
@@boletus2493 You can also take in note that 90% of the people in the comments have missing chromosones and cannot perform such acts
Oh i forgot
LMAO
The acoustic version is better than the original. It has for emotion in it
Yaa that is true.. I feeling that
Yup youre absolutely right. Thats why im always searching for the acoustic version of a song. Im glad im not the only one appreciating it🤭
And that’s a fact Mam 🙏🏾👍🏾
❤❤❤
someone listening to this in 2024?
Me right now
Me and i still love it✨️
just confused why most comments are in Russian
Abdullah Zedan because Halsey is come more popular in Russia, I think (Im Russian, sorry for mistakes) Im her fan after bts collab:)
Твоя мать лесбиянка
idk
cos she's gorgeous
bc there's quite popular yt blogger in Russia and she was watching this performance in one of her vids
Maya Flores I mean, she’s getting more popular
Her changing "Thinking you can live without me" to just "Live without me" affected me in ways I can't even explain.
EDIT: Even if it is her just being out of breath, it personally changed the meaning of the song for me so y'all can stop commenting about that lmao.
I didn't even realize this the first time I watched it 🙊 oh my goodness, I love it even more!
Yeah ,there must be something she wanna tell
It seems like the same meaning?
@@ThanhPham-vt6kv I feel like her singing "Thinking you can live without me" implies that whoever she's singing about still has her in their life while "Live without me" implies that they don't talk anymore and the other person has to deal with the fact that she's not there for them anymore.
@@melonratt yeah. You're amazing!
You can really feel her pain singing this. Chills are real.
Why people have to judge her clothes, or her makeup. She is there to sing, so please appreciate her singing and her talent. People care more abt what she wears or looks.
Yeahh!!! Fuck em all
no i don't care about looks i onky care about her voice & her talent i am a big fan
Only basic girls who are bitter will judge her
Why tf do i find her cool in whatever she's wearing. Is sth wrong with me?
@@cocainejesus65 No dude you have a great taste in people 😎 and I think even if anyone doesn't like what she's wearing, they should keep their mouth shut bcuz she's an artist, not a model!
She just have one of those voices that makes your heart beat faster...and you get chills over and over!
Theo Pretorius hey, is that you on profile photo? Or who is it? 🙏🏼
Oeh yt matchingg instead of Tinder
Olga Ermolaeva. Yeah haha its me :) why?
Hahaha
This song literally makes me cry💔
Dear heatbrokens stay strong..😢
the phenomenal well this song is related to mine heart ❤️😑😭
😘
Thanks bud
❤️
Thanks
I am a simple girl, i see halsey, i watch and give thumbs up! 👍
Im a simple girl, i see "halsey" i first give a thumbs up and then watch :)
She's got more control over her voice than I have over my life.
I can not only feel the pain but I can touch it in her voice....she is the perfect singer
Skin cleared
Depression gone
Wig flew
Hotel trivago
Dad came back
Edit: OMG TYSM IVE NEVER HAD THIS MANY LIKES❤️❤️❤️
Edit 2: 1,800 LIKES OMG I CANT BELIEVE IT AHHHHH!!!
Taylor binns 😂👌🏽
XD
Taylor binns what’s the hotel trivago thing from
You a legend
@@manar4120 A commercial lmao.
fair play to her, the original has so much autotune on her voice, but here she lives up to it, showing that she didn't need any in the first place
JohnBarrVlogs i hear a tad bit of autotune but it’s the perfect amount,
@@yakkowarner2764 exactly I hate all the over autotune on the original. I think it takes some of the emotions out of the song.
I think the autotune was used in the original for effects, not coz she couldn't sing. I agree here she sounds beautiful 🙌🏻😍💖💕💙
The autotune makes her sound robotic
CAN SOMEBODY PLS TALK ABOUT HOW AMAZING HALSEY LOOK IN THAT OUTFIT
Yes so cool
Those 493 dislikes are G-Eazy and all his youtube accounts
Lmao 😂😂 so true. I will say I like some of G-Easy's songs, but ultimately, I am a Halsey fan all the way
Just so you know, Halsey & G-Eazy are still together, lol.
Annan Ansari 🤦🏼♀️no
@@lmaoshawty7137 Lol, Halsey said it herself in a recent interview with 102.7KIISFM.
Lmfaooo
wow her voice makes me feel things that i can’t explain
wow your picture make me feel like i can't live without you
We call it "STRANGER THINGS" Nowadays Honey
@@hamzanino6779 pervert 😌
Isn’t that the truth... 🥺
Do you feel like your turning gay?
Is it me or is her singing alot better live than studio singing, in the studio she sounds mediocre, but this sounds really nice.
i think they autotuned the studio song too much
i think production made the voice less raspy
agreed
Live singing usually always sounds better bc in the studio they make her voice be the same volume throughout the song and they make it less raspy
Lotsssssssss offfffffffff reverb on her awesome vocals 👏👏👏👏👏
This girls voice stops me in my tracks!!! Unbelievable how good she really is..
notice how she never sang the line "thinking you could live without me" she just went to singing "live without me" in this performance
Woah
googol o she may be avoiding the high note but if she wasn’t then it is a powerful thing to do 😣
To be fair, the spacing in the original sounds like it doesn't give her much breath, this way she can sustain the way she wants.
It's because in the track there's another take of her singing the chorus as a backup vocal. Instead of rushing to get to the next line, she just skips to, "live without me." It's easier on the voice and makes for a better performance. It's not to disappoint the crowd it's a preservation of breath to hit the next note without strain, and a cleaner performance.
I'm glad you're listening close.
She's actually really cute, like the style too. Her voice is probably the most real I've heard in a good while.
EcchiSamurai listen Ariana if you wanna hear a very real voice
Watch Bishop Briggs..
EcchiSamurai 2 words. 1 name.
Ariana Grande.
: halsey how much autotune ?
:nah.
edit: whats up mga marurupok!!! don’t get me wrong , it’s just my opinion 🤟🏻
♡♡
Das a fact
Really•?
Autotone Or Autotune?
Y'all must be deaf as hell, cause I can definitely hear the autotune. Don't get me wrong, I love her voice. Just paying more attention.
When your broken heart sings 😭💔
her vocals just get better and better every year i’m so beyond proud of her, as a fan since room 93. she’s come so far and even though she could still work on some parts of her voice i think she sounds absolutely heavenly here.
Tyler Stranzl as a fan since room 93 also I have to absolutely agree
Tyler Stranzl I disagree. I was a fan of room 93 but her new music is boring and her personality is so annoying
Christina C I hated that fake-deep edgy persona she was trying to pull off in Badlands. Hopeless Fountain Kingdom is more experimental and vocally/lyrically impressing. The fake-deep constant overbearing mental health enforcing meanings was so annoying. I love when artists use their platform to break stigmas like that but in EVERY song she had to mention some sort of corny mental illness and drug related metaphor
All righty then 😂jeeez
As a fan since she was just a small youtuber named Ashley I'm speechless...
Don't really understand the hype around these Live Lounges; I've heard so many people raving about it saying how good they all are. I've heard a few and in my opinion, they were all pretty bad. This, on the other hand is amazing. She has such an amazing voice both in the polished/finished version, and Live too, which is quite rare these days.
It really depends on the artist, but for some they improve on the original track by adding a bit of live flair and you get the real soulful performance too :)
I agree, this is amazing. Blossoms on the other hand were terrible.
It sounds worse because most singers use auto tune and alot but some even though they use it they can still sing just lime the song with autotune.
Brett i thought the blossoms one was good. But why did you think so? (it was my first time listening to them)
Ste Bradbury Design ZARA LARSSON'S live was shit. Not because of her voice (she's frigging talented) but it's because of the mic or the person handling the sounds n stuff.
📂Documents
└📁Music
└📁Halsey
└📁 Bad Songs
└⚠️ This folder is empty
Would be great if it wasn't copied
Use Spotify man
We’re tf did all these Russians come from
эм
I thought i waas just me 🎤😇😎
Sneaky
Nick we love bts that’s why. Connect the dots
From Russia prob
She said “live without me ‘ instead of “thinking you could live without me “.
I think that proof how strong she is.
Rana Rose I think she just needed space to breath lmfao. It’s not that deep
ploob man correct
What's deep is that intake of breath. Coulda inhaled a bus
The "thinking you could" part is a little higher and she just had not enough strength I guess
ploob man she said in an interview this week that she deliberately sang it like this to change the message
Such a sweet and soulful voice, i'm envious 😍😁
She is better than BTS
@@wheniwas15yearoldiwasraped92 ik, but you shouldn't look down on BTS , both artist are friends, both talented and hard working
@@wheniwas15yearoldiwasraped92
Ugh, I saw you on so many comments. It sucks, that you only commend the same
@@wheniwas15yearoldiwasraped92 lol whats with your comment. They all got unique vocals. no need to drag others down
@@wheniwas15yearoldiwasraped92 Ummmm..... This person was complimenting Halsey. You like halsey right? Then respect her opinion. Dont make her/him regret complimenting halsey. Respect her/him opinion and respect the Artists she/he likes. And they will respects yours.
PS. Grow up no one likes a hater
I love her bbma 2019 performance GURL YOU MADE ME CRY.
I never see it 😔
@@martincanini7032 she uploaded it
She is better than BTS
@@wheniwas15yearoldiwasraped92 If that makes you sleep at night
When I was 15 year old, I was raped by three women
The fuck
Holy smokes she can sing
the pain in her voice oof :(
😣😢 yes
reminder: use earphones while listening to Halsey' live
Daisy Marguerite great reminder
8d audio
Use earphones while listening to Halsey PERIOD.
Daisy Marguerite got my earphones just because of this comment
So she can sing. Wow. Ultra crispy. Her tone is pleasing to my ears.
Well-said, though I'm unsure what "ultra crispy" means. Sounded funny.
@@sarahg2653 It means sharp, clean, fresh, nice.
Thanks for explaining. I will be incorporating that phrase into my everyday language as much as I can. It's very funny to me for some reason.
I must agree that her voice is really beautiful!
Her voice is so amazing 😍
Her voice, make sense she's featuring BTS
Yess
That's right
Agree
Yes
Bts voices sucks.
When she hits those high notes it hits my soul 😭❤️
there are no high notes?
@@kayahg6380 what are u smoking this isn't an easy song to sing
I hit high notes when i take a big shit.
Joe Mannix lol great now my day is disturbed 😁
@@Robert-yf1kn LOOOOOL MADE MY DAY
3 years later, I still love this song and her voice.
"You dont have to say, just what you did, I already know" 2:19 😞😭 her voice at those first 5 words 😔
isn’t that a justin timberlake song?
@@EmmaHernandezL probably a sample
@@EmmaHernandezL halsey did copped that line from JT's cry me a river 😁
bong dela cruz sweetie she did it in purpose! She merged this snippet in the song
@@EmmaHernandezL that's exactly what I thought about!!
Im addicted to this song omg, Thanks bts! Im excited for the BBMA'S COLABORATED
lucia gutierrez when is BBMAs gonna happen ?
@@cutiepi3_patti May 1st 😊
What time is it tho???
Over and over and over I Love this song
lucia gutierrez thanks halsey too😊🤗
She sings like she means every word she mentions, it is just beautiful
She does mean these words...
raf mpn yep and it can be seen in her live performances
raf mpn check out her interviews on the song. It breaks it down. Every word really does have meaning. Even the Justin Timberlake verse from Cry Me a River. I think she carefully constructs her lyrics, which all artists should do but it’s obvious that many do not.
Finally. Another singer that can actually sing.
One of her best performances ever! She put her whole heart in this song! Halsey you're on fire girl❤️
I'm crying and I don't know why.
Because You had a G eazy
I'm farting and i know why.
Me when i have my period
כולנו
You are a weirdo
What’s the guy doing in the background at 0:32
Hahahhahha
😂😂🤣😂😂😂
😂😂😂
Wtf I just saw it 😂
😂 😂 😂 😂 😂
The stripped version of this song always hits me HARD. It’s a song so relatable. I love that she switched “thinking you can live without me” to “live without me” like she’s letting go officially. The stripped down album version has “go on and live without me”. Beautiful.
Watching this vid reminded me of when I first found Halsey in a video singing Hurricane live for Vevo Discover. The raw emotion and honesty are what set her apart from so many other singers.
Dallas Coryell omg same i was just thinking of that. Immediately fell in love with her
Wow. Can we agree she is the most underrated artist out here right now. The kind of voice that gives me the tingles. Beautiful. She paints with her voice.
Shes far from underrated lol
Underrated ? LmAO
n she paints with her look
She's not that underrated. She's pretty popular
James Arthur has a muchhhhhhh better voice
Love the meaning behind this song! Halsey is way underrated, her voice is insane!!!
Heartbreak doesn't just happen to women, this song makes me smile and hurts all at the same time. This song is my last relationship down to the last word.
her voice is honestly has me in tears omg she works so hard for everyone and never fails to make them proud she needs to appreciated for how far she has gone and how hard she's worked like I JUST LOVE HOW HUMBLE AND COMPASSIONATE SHE IS.her voice is very beautiful I love it.
Chimmy Trash you couldn’t have said it any better :)
👌👏👏👏
Try some punctuation.
@@Timothy_VV ok boomer
Холзи не нужен автотюн, холзи нужна автотюну
ага
yeah i agree!
Почему Холзи? Правильно же Хэлси)
@@АлексейЕрохин-с9к нет)
Ухти я не одна русская
I get fucking goosebumps EVERY.SINGLE.TIME i listen to her voice! Especially with earphones!
LYRICS ♡
Found you when your heart was broke
I filled your cup until it overflowed
Took it so far to keep you close (keep you close)
I was afraid to leave you on your own
I said I'd catch you if you fall
And if they laugh, then fuck 'em all (all)
And then I got you off your knees
Put you right back on your feet
Just so you could take advantage of me
Tell me how's it feel sittin' up there
Feeling so high but too far away to hold me
You know I'm the one who put you up there
Name in the sky
Does it ever get lonely?
Thinking you could live without me
Thinking you could live without me
Baby, I'm the one who put you up there
I don't know why (yeah, I don't know why)
Thinking you could live without me
Live without me
Baby, I'm the one who put you up there
I don't know why (I don't know why, yeah yeah)
Gave love 'bout a hundred tries (hundred tries)
Just running from the demons in your mind
Then I took yours and made 'em mine (made 'em mine)
I didn't notice 'cause my love was blind
Said I'd catch you if you fall (fall)
And if they laugh, then fuck 'em all (all)
And then I got you off your knees
Put you right back on your feet
Just so you can take advantage of me
Tell me how's it feel sittin' up there
Feeling so high but too far away to hold me
You know I'm the one who put you up there
Name in the sky
Does it ever get lonely?
Thinking you could live without me
Thinking you could live without me
Baby, I'm the one who put you up there
I don't know why (yeah, I don't know why)
Thinking you could live without me
Live without me
Baby, I'm the one who put you up there
I don't know why, yeah
You don't have to say just what you did
I already know (I know)
I had to go and find out from them
So tell me how's it feel (oh-woah)
Tell me how's it feel sittin' up there
Feeling so high but too far away to hold me
You know I'm the one who put you up there
Name in the sky
Does it ever get lonely?
Thinking you could live without me
Thinking you could live without me
Baby, I'm the one who put you up there
I don't know why (yeah, I don't know why)
Always looking for lyrics thank u
bruh we can just google em
Your lyrics are wrong lol.
G Eazy needs to visit a Doctor after this..
her voice is so relaxing..
I'm gonna become famous just so I can marry her. Wish me luck
You don't gotta do that in order to marry her tho...just saying
Best of luck
Good luck my friend
Oh Lord ... I just cried, what a performance.
: *HALSEY* needs *autotune*
Me: What the actual F- , *autotune* needs *HALSEY*
*HALSEY* mom, keep slaying! *ily so much* 🖤🕊
You are right
@@yasirhassan 🖤🙏
She does use key correct though
she does use autotune
That was true!! Like wtf are the dislikes for
Okay, I’m a Halsey fan, HOWEVER, for the people wanting clarification on the “auto-tune” debate, here it is:
This is NOT Auto-Tune. It’s a live tool called Melodyne. It’s a subtle pitch correction tool that adds a metallic filter to the notes. A lot of artists use it, and as a music fan, I personally don’t mind it. The original Without Me has FULL BLOWN auto tune, which again is fine. Stylistically, the melodyne sounds awesome on this acoustic version. She has improved so much, and I sincerely enjoyed the raw energy she provided with amazing LIVE filtered production. Appreciate the style. If you can’t, exit the app or switch to your type of live music. Thanks for coming to my Ted Talk ❤️
Its auto tune, auto tune is just another name for pitch correction, melodyne is an auto tuning software so yeah she is auto tuned 👌 not a hater either.
BananaTimeYoo auto-tune and melodyne are two completely different softwares, but okay!
@@AustinKenneth12 auto tune is an effect not software, melodyne supplies autotune.
BananaTimeYoo 100%
Melodyne does not have a mode for live performances. Even tho this is Live Lounge they do post production before uploading it to TH-cam so it most likely is Melodyne.
literal chills down my spine. 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
new found respect for this woman. this sounds amazing. 👍🏻
To Me her changing the lyrics from “Thinking You Could Live Without Me” to “Live Without Me” is telling him to Go on without her 😢
Sthaappp😭
Oooohhhh omgg watch my cover.....i did the same!!!!!!😭
The one who is reading this comment have a good day!
Talha sohail thank you and you too 😊
Too late it's night now... Few hours left let's see...
dd
She looks sad i wonder what was in her head and her raspy voice ♥️
I keep wondering if it's her breakup with whoever's name I can't recall
@@monicag6993 G-Eazy
She was thinking about money
Can this version be put on Spotify?
Or just Rip it using the interwebs..
I have a major crush on this women.
So almost 9 month since my wife left me. This song helped me so much after those first few weeks. My ex wanted me to be a stay at home dad, so I left my career and did. After a 3 yrs, she decided that we were done.
I was jobless and left in the wind co confused and desperate.
Things are getting better but I’m still without employment and hurting.
Last January I found out my wife was seeing someone else she waited till my payday to tell me she wanted to build a life with him left me penny less I left on the weds the day after he was in my bed I know your pain .. 12months on got a new lady in my life who basically saved me from self distruct mode in a good place now the pain has died but the hate towards them is still present & will be for some time I think
@@adamball3944 no simping! get working brudda we can power on and self improve
Miguel Soliz i can feel that pain. I quit my job for my ex and he treated me as useless when im jobless. Some ppl they just don't see how much we sacrificed . They will never appreciate your efforts because they never did for you
We mustn't dissolve in people we are married to. We shouldn't sacrifice for them. They become uninterested in us. We lose our personality if we do that. The pain will go away, but we must learn the lesson they taught us.
And how and how
no wonder she was featured with BTS her voice goes so well with them
@@ancientaliensarecoming7201 if you don't like BTS okay, but stop talking like shit. They worked hard for that.
@@jamilija7914 you tell him/ her!!
ancient aliens are coming your acting like cancer right now. If u don't like them then just ignore the comment not that difficult
ancient aliens are coming people still use cancer as an insult ? fuck off w your xenophobic ass
Featured by BTS or not She has been a Queen ever since😊
I would literally buy an album of all her stripped/acoustic songs, anyone else???
I've never been a Halsey fan, but this totally made me do a 180. This was absolutely beautiful
You can hear it in her voice that it hurts. :(
G-easy? More like G-uneasy when this song released 😂
*Her voiceeee...* *OMG.. its soo* *gorgeous..* ❤️😍
*I was wondering how to marry a*
*voice* 😁😉❤️
🤣
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Halsey voice can cut ice and strait thru the heart ♥
Один из лучших голосов современности,дар,не иначе.
Ты понимаешь насколько человеку обидно когда говорят "дар" ?
@@inyomiom_aiganym ++
@@inyomiom_aiganym я не совсем поняла, объясни пожалуйста 😅
Улыбка Тэхёна человек долгими годами добивался, учился, ставил голос, работал над ним, а потом однажды ему говорят, что это просто дар.
@@DM-tk1gf я имел ввиду то как она берет ноты,чистоты диапазон и все остальное ,этому невозможно научиться это с рождения,есть многие люди которые не могут петь потому что генетика голосовых связок не позволяет,и сколько не тренеруй их один хрен будет не то.Вот что я имел ввиду.
She sounds amazing live. All the editing in her usual music background I think makes her songs worse. Deconstruct it. Break it down. I bet her acoustic record would sell more than a legit album.
Nessers she also did a killer acoustic on Bad at Love. I didn’t know she had those kind of vocals. I do enjoy the acoustic raw versions without all of the aesthetics as opposed to the ones with all of the bells and whistles. Both are great, however, and better than anything out right now. I just prefer Halsey this way.
Katrina Rector because appreciating music regardless of the fact that it’s an obvious number one hit warrants the need for a smart ass comment. 🙄
I love her so much 💘💘💘
thinking you could live without me
The thing is I know Halsey can get pitchy and doesn’t have the best technique, but I always feel her raw emotions singing and that’s what matters more sometimes than someone who is technical.
Anyone notice how she says, “live without me” instead of “thinking you could live without me?”
I'm sorry, not trying to be stupid (I swear).. What do you mean? Or what do you think she means by it? Reuniting? Over? (HELP 😁, Thank you.)
She just doesnt say the "thinking you could" to take some breathe and it sounds nice.
Lmao
Random I agree! She sounds amazing! :)
Angela G Haha no worries! I’m not sure if she means anything by it, or if maybe her and G-Eazy have broken up. I just noticed that every time during that part she didn’t say “thinking you could.” It could mean something or not! I’m not positive! :)
It’s not that deep she just ran out of breath.
Это просто волшебно 😍 я не фанат Холзи, но от её песен и голоса просто тащусь😍 Она идеальна❤❤❤
Поправочка. Теперь фанат ❤😏
Hey guys she is natural, great vocals she makes me have goose bumps