I added links to two playlists in the description, one is title tracks and another is ALLLLLL B-sides! Lmk if you agree with the rankings ehehe (what's you number 1 b-side? if it doesn't match mine - explain yourself haux🤨🤨🤨
Psycho and peekaboo's album photobooks are INSANE I love when horror is eery and elegant because you can't take it out of your mind, you keep looking at it because it's beautiful but there is something quite off putting
I think it’s bc they rely on something subtle in poses/setting that makes it so much better than any other group that tries these types of concepts. I think it’s the fine art/art film backbone of creative directors that worked on red velvet across their careers
@@LisaFevralHonestly will never shut up about how red velvet (and sometimes loona) do subtle and subliminal horror in so many different ways. I love my cult girlies, every single concept has something you need to rewatch over and over because you don't understand completely what is going on. I do also really liked pixy and pink fantasy (and early days dreamcatcher) but their concept is more harsh it's not as welcoming to rewatch
I 100% agree with the cosmic photoshoot feeling empty , considering the chill kill art direction. I really hope they can do a good art direction in the next album with no AI
reveluvs we are EATING okay but seriously, red velvet is the group who rlly opened my eyes to how different and interesting kpop groups can be & they will always have a special place in my heart forever.
RV kept it fresh, they were the blueprint that everybody likes to copy from but never credit, I get it, it's like one guy directing, writing the script and producing, the ending credits can't have just one name, same thing with RV, everyone comes second to them, simply because RV had the range to pull it off, they created so many cores and aesthetics, the wacky whimsical, the kawaii kowai, the mature tastefully s3xy, they started the trend of importing cartoon, video game and referencing movies aesthetic. they are THAT group.
Literally, I hate when people say kpop isn’t interesting or just copies western trends because it’s like, girl you’ve obviously never heard Red Velvet or ARTMS or Pixy or sooooo many other groups that have such incredible conceptual work and really innovative and experimental music.
Same..RV is the one who makes me appreciate different genre of music because of how good their vocal harmonies and colour. I used to like rnb, ballad and regular pop that's why I like snsd back in the day. I cannot see any other group who can emulate RV's music.
I'm so glad that you are giving Automatic the flowers it deserves!!!!!! That was my first Red Velvet Song and one of the first in kpop for me, and its been 7-8 years and it's still my #1
For me, Reve Festival are the best Albums and concepts that they made. Fight me. Kpop wouldn't be complete without Psycho, Zimzalabim, Umpah Umpah, and Feel my Rhythm and I'll die on that hill. (with Cosmic being an upcoming favorite)
not this video making realize (again) how much i love red velvet... like omg they are just on another level, I can't beliebe they've been blessing us with slay after slay for 10 years already
chill kill is so quintessentially red velvet in a way i can’t fully describe. it’s like there were a couple comebacks in between psycho and chill kill that i didn’t really vibe with but this (especially the b sides) really made me feel like they were red velveting again. it honestly felt a bit like coming home. honestly definitely one of my favorite red velvet albums. i also have seen the error of my ways in regard to feel my rhythm (even before this video)
RIGHT?! I kinda got sad that Lisa didn’t like the song, I understand her not loving the concept, since it’s a japanese title track there’s not much budget and thought put into it, I guess it just comes to personal preference hahah, I really enjoyed wildside when it dropped, definitely a no skip for me
A great analysis Lisa. About Red Velvet I like that there's songs for any mood you'd have, if you feel like listening something wacky there's Rookie and Dumb Dumb, the velvet concept for ballads, that can be dark if you want. The novelty of Feel My Rhythm is that it could be considered velvet but with drops of red, same formula with Chill Kill.
One of These Nights also references Chilseok, a Korean festival, and the story related to it. There is also a theory that it's a tribute to the Sewol tragedy.
You would love BILLLIE. They are from Mystic Story which is owned by SM actually. Most the girls are also SM trainies. BILLLIE’s debut was a contemporary synth pop/punk pop with RING X RING as the title track, but over time they have explored many genres including bass house, garage band rock, funk pop, r&b, etc etc. They are very lore based and you can hear it in their lyrics but I think that if you do like Red Velvet, you would love BILLLIE and some of their title track.
I second this!! I love both rv and billlie and I feel like billlie also has a lore focused approach to their mvs that a lot of reveluvs would appreciate too🤭
I have the Psycho CD and it’s the same as streaming services not like in the MV. The producer who made Psycho intentionally removed it for the visual experience only or something like that which is stupid 😭
THANK YOU FOR GIVING RBB IT'S DUE i often hear its "not a fav" or "i hate the screaming" or just simply "not a good song" when its like bro the production the instrumental the vocals, that high note??????? yo you do not even achieve being able to make that note let alone make it work in a pop song the way red velvet does, its art!
I don't listen to much k-pop because I don't listen to much pop. However, the fashion and album concepts are always out of this world!! So thank you for covering this I needed some outfit inspiration
I think they probably don't wanna preform inn small concert halls bc they can't have an impressive stage design/etc for it, and after 10 years I'm sure they want to only perform in venues that can accommodate their ambition😭
seriously i get so happy when you upload even when i don't know much about the subject matter (and yes so many channels have been lacking originality bc of this algorithm ugh)
I miss the time when channels like Jenny Nicholson would get pushed😭 now it's mostly channels that repeat themselves over and over and I know it's bc if they do anything original - the algorithm will burry them! (also a lot of those people have never been original ofc, but the platform algorithms do determine if creativity will thrive or not)
SM ent really fucked up when they reshuffled all their groups and their creative directors, im happy for aespa getting a great creative team but now NCT 127 and red velvet have the short end of the stick :/ which is annoying because they have such refined concepts which need to be handled with care and condsideration
agree with you on the fact that only red velvet can deliver their songs the best , like the whole kpop industry covers rv songs and even some idols do have amazing vocals and tones they just can't deliver it the way rv does , vocally wise one every member adds a lot to the song even the sub vocalists irene and yeri add so much to the song that no one can ever add , I strongly believe that rv songs are made for them and them only and no one can ever do it like them, they've been in the industry for so long bu they're still consistent with their talent even when they release "underwhelming" songs for the public they are still relevent and known for their talent and music and concepts
Thank you for this omg I love you, having such an intelligent and cultured woman love RV is so incredibly fulfilling, I love your enthusiasm. They’re literally my favorite group ever and I just get so overwhelmed when I see their art being appreciated, you did them justice 🤍
My top 3 songs would be OOTN, Bad Boy and Zimzalabim, it encapsulate everything that makes RV and OOTN is probably my favorite concept overall with Chill Kill being close and the whole Perfect Velvet + repackage
i haven't gotten to the end of your ranking yet but in terms of concepts, my top 3 RV concepts are Feel My Rhythm, Chill Kill and Peak-a-boo. everything about these three comebacks (including the music) is just perfection to me edit: we almost have the same top 3 lol
the AI use started with aespa’s supernova and it just made me hate SM more cause why tf are they so money hungry that they want to replace creatives with inaccurate software. the pic of Seulgi in the cosmic AI bg looking so ethereal and cosmic could’ve been so much more impactful and deep with the added weight to the composition. Like I was on my knees worshiping the concept shoot goddess. SM just hates their artists at this point cause I’ve known SM artists for the majority of my life and they were top of the game with concepts. It’s not like they can’t make a fake motel and a highway like be fr
I'm not even bringing up the other concept, bc the hotel concept would've lowkey been one of my faves from them if not for AI bullshit stealing from an artist who actually built sets/found locations all on his own. The other "etherial" concept made me mad straight up bc not only is it AI, it's so poorly integrated into the background it looks like someone's first attempt at photoshopping
i’m not a reveluv but i am a fan of any girl group that pushes concepts the full way through (nwjns, aespa, ARTMS)… this video has convinced me to stan
I looove Wendy part on Cosmic’s bridge so much, you were basically speaking my mind when you were talking about the feelings it conveys, the Red Velvet girls just really know how to emote with their singing! Honestly I really liked the sailor outfits concept, specifically the outdoors pics, it’s disappointing that SM went with AI, it could’ve been such a good concept if they’ve put actual effort into it, but I’m very happy with the final product and the Midsommar concept. Can we talk about that album cover tho? Literally the worst one they’ve had and it’s for their anniversary 😭 even Yeri called them out Bad boy is my top 1 title track so I’m glad it’s close to your top 1 too 🤍 and yes OOTN is such an underrated gem Also yes RBB is one of their top minis, it’s really hard for me to pick a favorite b-side, but if I was held at gunpoint I’d probably choose So Good
that Seulgi photo with Crewdson inspired background was SOOOO gorgeous at first I was so excited, but then I noticed the backdrop details and was so pissed it's ai😭😭
OOTN m/v is SO GORGEOUS I CANNOT believe more people aren't talking about it! So Good is #2 in my playlist ranking all of RV's b-side tracks, like she's THAT girl
@@LisaFevralyeah OOTN deserves so much more love, kpop stans don’t know how to appreciate beautiful ballads What’s your #1 b-side? Spotify is blocked for me so I can’t see your ranking 😭
@@LisaFevral omg ELHL is my other contender for the top spot! it’s one of those RV songs that make me feel like I’m in love. in my head Time to love and Iced Coffee are her sister songs, but she’s the queen among them lol
I'm so happy to start my day with your video!!!! now i need to listen to all the ReVe's songs!! especially automatic (and make my own tier list)😮 '봐 Look' and 'Sunny Side Up!' - one of my faves and idk why but i have a strong connection between SHINee's song 'Orgel' and RV-core lol
If you haven’t listened to a lot of rv, based on your picks I would recommend checking out these: So good Time slip Talk to me I just Bamboleo Knock on wood Taste Oh boy Butterflies Better be Pushin’ n pullin Something kinda crazy In&out
I’ve been a casual fan since their debut and it’s been so cool to see the evolution they’ve made. Especially as a girl group from SM, where I feel like the company drops the ball on their girl groups time and time again. Which obviously RV has experienced, but I just want to appreciate their direction and focus after all these years!
this is everything i’ve ever wanted thank u lisa but fr, as a reveluv since ice cream cake, its so great to see other people who appreciate the group and understand rv and what they r abt! ESPECIALLY reveluvs who get into rv after bad boy because most ppl who did get into them at the time shat on RBB bc it wasn’t bad boy!! its so nice to see ppl who just get it, ty for ur service lisa
I had a hard time with the repetitiveness of RBB title track when it just came out but the b-sides and concept was so great that it gave me enough of an opportunity to grow to love RBB tt too ahaha and yeah, I noticed that most people who became reveluvs after bad boy like me expected only rnb titles from them, but we can always count on them making ANY genre spectacular
You said it perfectly! Their music has the most bizarre concepts and unconventional production. But we know we can trust them, so we give it a chance! And I’d say I loved 99.9% of their songs within the first 3 listens! They all grow on you when you go in with an open mind!
JUSTICE FOR BIRTHDAY!!! Some of my favorite creative direction of theirs ever + the song is turntina and perfectly weird! The era that made me a fan😭 sometimes i feel like her only shooter omg (thank u for this vid queen)
I get so so so happy when you talk about kpop because you always put my thoughts into words in regards to concepts or fashion, I know next to nothing about these topics but I always see and really deeply appreciate the intentions behind crafting kpop albums. When the teaser images dropped for chill kill I GAGGED, I love red velvet but I wouldn’t classify myself as a reveluv since I don’t know much about them, nevertheless, I truly considered getting the album just because of the concept, I tend to love traditional korean/east asian concepts and I’m also a big horror fan, and the way you can see both perfectly blended together for chill kill just stunned me, also the horror concept in kpop is one that is almost always done wrong or poorly imo, but not red velvet, they slay every single time. Lastly, I don’t think you’ll read this Lisa but I wanted to at least try. My favourite girl group of all time is LOONA, idk if you know this but because of their company’s negligence they got into a lawsuit and won to terminate their contracts, after that they split and five of them formed a group called ARTMS, all this yapping just to ask for you to check out the mvs they released for their album “” (there are 5 mvs), they are all amazing, three of them melodically reference previous work, the title track has insanely cool visuals and concept and the other one is called birth, please please please if you’re going to check out one video check “birth” out, they did the horror concept beautifully imo. Seriously excuse the yapping, It’s just that kpop holds a very special place in my heart and I’m very passionate about it. Please continue making videos regardless if they are about kpop or not, I always love watching them 🖤☺️
Yesss I love Red Velvet, they have inspired me in so many ways!! It’s so hard to pick a comeback, but my favorite eras are Ice Cream Cake, Feel My Rhythm, Bad Boy and Power Up (Blue Lemonade is like 95% of the reason, I love that song so much. I love the styling too!)
happy 10th red velvet and ty for an amazing video! this is why i love rv so much bec they give you a taste of everything. also, this ranking says it why i dislike people saying rv fell off with their post-psycho comebacks because they clearly didn't?! and personally, i think that their latest comebacks, specifically cosmic, chill kill, and queen fmr, were much stronger than their previous. with cosmic tho, i'm still saddened even after a month with its rollout and commitment to concept, especially it marks their 10th anniv. and the horrendous use of ai should've never happened (management flaw). i wish they leaned toward the adaptation of the sailor moon concept or created a modern look of their sailor look from happiness just for funsies and nostalgia. but, the trailer, the amazing music video, and cosmie vers saved the day. THANK YOU JOY! also, chill kill should've gotten the 'psycho recognition' it deserved.
Joy literally saved cosmic fr omfg also I think the sound of chill kill was too much for general public, but I think cosmic should’ve gotten a win!! It’s so annoying that it didn’t
Ooh, that sparkle on your earrings~!! Anyway, another great video of yours that I truly enjoyed watching and it's just fun getting to know your thoughts and opinions.
Seeing someone talk about kpop from an actual artistic perspective is so rare, I was prepared to hate your takes (because of how much I’ve been burned) but I basically 100% agreed with or at least understood and respected everything you said. Justice for One of These Nights!!!
Honestly speaking, Red Velvet is the group that I really listen to, not because of the music video or promotion, it’s the music itself. I’m saying this as someone that just follow them casually and an extremely picky person when adding it into my playlist(it’s like entering into my empire🙂) I don’t know if I’ll have this same approach I have with RV in the coming years.
See… this is why I’m subscribed. Yes I’m a red velvet fan but was finishing a different video and going to watch Netflix with my bf- but I ended up watching the whole thing and I told him he had to wait! This video hit so hard and I deeply appreciate your content. Thank you.
I agree with you 100%... and your talk about Psycho. I couldn't agree more. (EDIT) Hi, got right back to edit my comment when you started talking about 'Perfect Red Velvet' Teasers. I LOVE YOU SO MUCH, LIKE YOU. GET. IT.
So glad Feel My Rhythm got its flowers!!! I've always loved the creepy undertones of the group, my favorite being the cannibalism theory with #Cookie Jar
kinda freaked out by how similar our opinions are, the only thing i would’ve done is move #cookie jar up because it just hits for me. i’m a huge halloween/horror fan so you would think i would have a darker concept as my favorite, but nope, it’s feel my rhythm! it was my top song of 2022 and got me really back into red velvet after the long hiatus and queendom just not doing it for me in the way previous releases had. i actually based a lot of my makeup and fashion on the fmr concept for a while
the streaming version of Psycho is my 9/11, allegedly it was because it sounded better that way on radio or something?? idk but the synths are what really make the song for me and without them its an entirely different vibe.
lisa and red velvet is my favorite combo, i've been following rv since their debut was announced... i can't believe it's already been 10 years and i'm so grateful i was there for every era, because rv is one of a kind 💕
feel my rhythm was the one and only rv music video i've ever watched and i left so impressed i couldn't stop thinking about it and played the song on loop for a couple of days. later added russian roulette and peekaboo to my playlist as well thinking it's crazy good. didn't really like any other songs but girl that's already three!
the video is so well-done, kudos to you the editing is sooo gorgeous!! i know of red velvet but i wasn’t in the game if you know what i mean and those little album covers on the left and the generous video and concept snippets bring everything together
I added links to two playlists in the description, one is title tracks and another is ALLLLLL B-sides! Lmk if you agree with the rankings ehehe (what's you number 1 b-side? if it doesn't match mine - explain yourself haux🤨🤨🤨
My top bsides: mosquito, carpool, cool world, Mr. E. like... better than most groups title tracks!
mr.E is THAT girl
Kingdom Come should have been a title track and Bad Boy should have been their English/Global debut song >.>
Kingdom come, I just and In my dreams are just perfect!!
My favorite b-side will always be Eyes Locked Hands Locked
i love ice cream cake’s concept cause the video looks like a 2015 tumblr aesthetic blog
honestly yeah it's like time capsule eh ahaha
Yes! And the fact that I discovered them through Tumblr after I saw someone make a makeup cover, still grateful for that post💖
i remember seeing gifs from the ice cream cake mv on tumblr and they would have hundreds of thousands of notes!!!
its my fav!
RBB (Really Bad Boy) is a perfect 90s/80s Halloween movie concept, it's truly brilliant
lisa talking about EVERY red velvet concept... this video is so yummy and i will be eating it up
coming into kpop stanning aespa and then finding out about red velvet was honestly heaven we love you sm girlies
Truly a gift🙂↕️
Wait until you discover f(x), BoA and csjh
@@_mon_tego dw, already love all of those queens 🙏
Stan all sm GGs, you will not regret it
starting out with aespa woa… like i started stanning red velvet first and aespa wasn’t even debuted😭😭
Psycho and peekaboo's album photobooks are INSANE I love when horror is eery and elegant because you can't take it out of your mind, you keep looking at it because it's beautiful but there is something quite off putting
Cookie jar and russian roulette are more cheeky and corny like you said, it's playful horror. Even rbb can fall into that, it's more on the nose
I think it’s bc they rely on something subtle in poses/setting that makes it so much better than any other group that tries these types of concepts. I think it’s the fine art/art film backbone of creative directors that worked on red velvet across their careers
@@LisaFevralHonestly will never shut up about how red velvet (and sometimes loona) do subtle and subliminal horror in so many different ways. I love my cult girlies, every single concept has something you need to rewatch over and over because you don't understand completely what is going on.
I do also really liked pixy and pink fantasy (and early days dreamcatcher) but their concept is more harsh it's not as welcoming to rewatch
yes their cultish vibes are unmatched tbh ahah
I 100% agree with the cosmic photoshoot feeling empty , considering the chill kill art direction. I really hope they can do a good art direction in the next album with no AI
it would literally be one of my faves if it was done properly
reveluvs we are EATING
okay but seriously, red velvet is the group who rlly opened my eyes to how different and interesting kpop groups can be & they will always have a special place in my heart forever.
honestly they opened my eyes to girl group potential in general
RV kept it fresh, they were the blueprint that everybody likes to copy from but never credit, I get it, it's like one guy directing, writing the script and producing, the ending credits can't have just one name, same thing with RV, everyone comes second to them, simply because RV had the range to pull it off, they created so many cores and aesthetics, the wacky whimsical, the kawaii kowai, the mature tastefully s3xy, they started the trend of importing cartoon, video game and referencing movies aesthetic.
they are THAT group.
Literally, I hate when people say kpop isn’t interesting or just copies western trends because it’s like, girl you’ve obviously never heard Red Velvet or ARTMS or Pixy or sooooo many other groups that have such incredible conceptual work and really innovative and experimental music.
Same..RV is the one who makes me appreciate different genre of music because of how good their vocal harmonies and colour. I used to like rnb, ballad and regular pop that's why I like snsd back in the day. I cannot see any other group who can emulate RV's music.
@@idkidkidk170 oh artms & pixy too, your taste >>> but fr, ppl who say that usually only listen to 2 to 3 groups who have similar concepts anyway
I'm so glad that you are giving Automatic the flowers it deserves!!!!!! That was my first Red Velvet Song and one of the first in kpop for me, and its been 7-8 years and it's still my #1
Literally the best song ever in the history of this planet
@@LisaFevralAutomatic and Kingdome Come were always replays for me
For me, Reve Festival are the best Albums and concepts that they made. Fight me. Kpop wouldn't be complete without Psycho, Zimzalabim, Umpah Umpah, and Feel my Rhythm and I'll die on that hill. (with Cosmic being an upcoming favorite)
🙂↕️🙂↕️
not you completely erasing birthday when she's a part of the reve festival
@@chris-mm8zl I'm not erasing Birthday. I just stated my favorites in all 3 albums.
My favourite TH-camr being a fan of my absolute favourite k-pop group is insanely comforting for me.
Same ❤
the earrings are gorgeous with this sparcle light effect thingy.... v mesmerising
and the vid is fun, love your red velvet appreciation n enthusiasm
thank you🙂↕️ I'm really into this effect lately ahaha
not this video making realize (again) how much i love red velvet... like omg they are just on another level, I can't beliebe they've been blessing us with slay after slay for 10 years already
Also those EARINGS! Omg so sparkly and stunning
chill kill is so quintessentially red velvet in a way i can’t fully describe. it’s like there were a couple comebacks in between psycho and chill kill that i didn’t really vibe with but this (especially the b sides) really made me feel like they were red velveting again. it honestly felt a bit like coming home. honestly definitely one of my favorite red velvet albums. i also have seen the error of my ways in regard to feel my rhythm (even before this video)
Wildside is one of my favourites 😭😭 it’s so addictive
Yess omg. But all songs are so good.
RIGHT?! I kinda got sad that Lisa didn’t like the song, I understand her not loving the concept, since it’s a japanese title track there’s not much budget and thought put into it, I guess it just comes to personal preference hahah, I really enjoyed wildside when it dropped, definitely a no skip for me
I'm a simple woman, I see Red Velvet, I click
34:46 the iconic lisa album cover edit
A great analysis Lisa. About Red Velvet I like that there's songs for any mood you'd have, if you feel like listening something wacky there's Rookie and Dumb Dumb, the velvet concept for ballads, that can be dark if you want. The novelty of Feel My Rhythm is that it could be considered velvet but with drops of red, same formula with Chill Kill.
Chill Kill is the perfect encapsulation of a 'bright tragedy'
One of These Nights also references Chilseok, a Korean festival, and the story related to it. There is also a theory that it's a tribute to the Sewol tragedy.
Yeah I always though it was a tribute to sewol
You would love BILLLIE. They are from Mystic Story which is owned by SM actually. Most the girls are also SM trainies. BILLLIE’s debut was a contemporary synth pop/punk pop with RING X RING as the title track, but over time they have explored many genres including bass house, garage band rock, funk pop, r&b, etc etc. They are very lore based and you can hear it in their lyrics but I think that if you do like Red Velvet, you would love BILLLIE and some of their title track.
I second this!! I love both rv and billlie and I feel like billlie also has a lore focused approach to their mvs that a lot of reveluvs would appreciate too🤭
editing yourself into the chill kill album cover was so real 😂
This video was made FOR ME
🙂↕️🙂↕️
I have the Psycho CD and it’s the same as streaming services not like in the MV. The producer who made Psycho intentionally removed it for the visual experience only or something like that which is stupid 😭
😭😭😭
THANK YOU FOR GIVING RBB IT'S DUE i often hear its "not a fav" or "i hate the screaming" or just simply "not a good song" when its like bro the production the instrumental the vocals, that high note??????? yo you do not even achieve being able to make that note let alone make it work in a pop song the way red velvet does, its art!
Not Lisa clocking random people's bullshit in the first minute of the video lol😂 So nonchalantly too😅
Sometimes you gotta🙂↕️
I don't listen to much k-pop because I don't listen to much pop. However, the fashion and album concepts are always out of this world!! So thank you for covering this I needed some outfit inspiration
You’ll definitely find a million inspos in this or their full videos tbh, so many great looks!
Was not expecting this omg what a nice surprise! Happy R10 to my fellow reveluvs 💚
let's go another 10!🙂↕️
@@LisaFevral PERIOD. See y’all at R to the V 2028 😤🤞🏻
we can only hope that they pull a redmare and go on a world tour😩😩
@@LisaFevral so real…getting them to come to NA is like pulling teeth but may they have mercy on us 🥺🫶🏻
I think they probably don't wanna preform inn small concert halls bc they can't have an impressive stage design/etc for it, and after 10 years I'm sure they want to only perform in venues that can accommodate their ambition😭
I saw the title and I was SAT! Oh and you're giving me Feel My Rhythm Wendy, so cute!!!
Yesss omg love that you noticed ehehe
seriously i get so happy when you upload even when i don't know much about the subject matter (and yes so many channels have been lacking originality bc of this algorithm ugh)
I miss the time when channels like Jenny Nicholson would get pushed😭 now it's mostly channels that repeat themselves over and over and I know it's bc if they do anything original - the algorithm will burry them! (also a lot of those people have never been original ofc, but the platform algorithms do determine if creativity will thrive or not)
The cosmic bridge is so melancholic. You described the way I feel abt it perfectly ‼️
SM ent really fucked up when they reshuffled all their groups and their creative directors, im happy for aespa getting a great creative team but now NCT 127 and red velvet have the short end of the stick :/ which is annoying because they have such refined concepts which need to be handled with care and condsideration
agree with you on the fact that only red velvet can deliver their songs the best , like the whole kpop industry covers rv songs and even some idols do have amazing vocals and tones they just can't deliver it the way rv does , vocally wise one every member adds a lot to the song even the sub vocalists irene and yeri add so much to the song that no one can ever add , I strongly believe that rv songs are made for them and them only and no one can ever do it like them, they've been in the industry for so long bu they're still consistent with their talent even when they release "underwhelming" songs for the public they are still relevent and known for their talent and music and concepts
lisa 6th red velvet member confirmed
What about Suho? 😢 jk lol
Feel my rhythm is that girl. Best rv's era
2:53 the gasp I GASPED when it came in at 23 😭
SAME I ALMOST FELL TO MY KNEES I LOVE WILDSIDE
Thank you for this omg I love you, having such an intelligent and cultured woman love RV is so incredibly fulfilling, I love your enthusiasm. They’re literally my favorite group ever and I just get so overwhelmed when I see their art being appreciated, you did them justice 🤍
My top 3 songs would be OOTN, Bad Boy and Zimzalabim, it encapsulate everything that makes RV and OOTN is probably my favorite concept overall with Chill Kill being close and the whole Perfect Velvet + repackage
i haven't gotten to the end of your ranking yet but in terms of concepts, my top 3 RV concepts are Feel My Rhythm, Chill Kill and Peak-a-boo. everything about these three comebacks (including the music) is just perfection to me
edit: we almost have the same top 3 lol
just diff order ehehe
Your earrings are sparkling so much in this and it’s so cute!
thank you🙂↕️🙂↕️
@@LisaFevral girly pop how did you produce the sparkling effect? its so satisfying i cant take my eyes off of it
I added an effect on Final Cut Pro called “dazzle”!
@@LisaFevral Thank you so much love!!
@@LisaFevral Thank you so much love!
the AI use started with aespa’s supernova and it just made me hate SM more cause why tf are they so money hungry that they want to replace creatives with inaccurate software. the pic of Seulgi in the cosmic AI bg looking so ethereal and cosmic could’ve been so much more impactful and deep with the added weight to the composition. Like I was on my knees worshiping the concept shoot goddess. SM just hates their artists at this point cause I’ve known SM artists for the majority of my life and they were top of the game with concepts. It’s not like they can’t make a fake motel and a highway like be fr
I'm not even bringing up the other concept, bc the hotel concept would've lowkey been one of my faves from them if not for AI bullshit stealing from an artist who actually built sets/found locations all on his own. The other "etherial" concept made me mad straight up bc not only is it AI, it's so poorly integrated into the background it looks like someone's first attempt at photoshopping
GIRLLL YOU'RE REVELUV?? i''m soo happy!!!! our girls deserve the best and honestly they never miss. thank you for the video!! 🙏
I sure am🙂↕️🙂↕️
i’m not a reveluv but i am a fan of any girl group that pushes concepts the full way through (nwjns, aespa, ARTMS)… this video has convinced me to stan
These girlies really know what’s up
Red Velvet stans get into it, yuh!
i love creepy - cute concepts and red velvet EATS IT UP
they licherally invented it 🙂↕️
I looove Wendy part on Cosmic’s bridge so much, you were basically speaking my mind when you were talking about the feelings it conveys, the Red Velvet girls just really know how to emote with their singing! Honestly I really liked the sailor outfits concept, specifically the outdoors pics, it’s disappointing that SM went with AI, it could’ve been such a good concept if they’ve put actual effort into it, but I’m very happy with the final product and the Midsommar concept. Can we talk about that album cover tho? Literally the worst one they’ve had and it’s for their anniversary 😭 even Yeri called them out
Bad boy is my top 1 title track so I’m glad it’s close to your top 1 too 🤍 and yes OOTN is such an underrated gem
Also yes RBB is one of their top minis, it’s really hard for me to pick a favorite b-side, but if I was held at gunpoint I’d probably choose So Good
that Seulgi photo with Crewdson inspired background was SOOOO gorgeous at first I was so excited, but then I noticed the backdrop details and was so pissed it's ai😭😭
OOTN m/v is SO GORGEOUS I CANNOT believe more people aren't talking about it!
So Good is #2 in my playlist ranking all of RV's b-side tracks, like she's THAT girl
@@LisaFevralyeah OOTN deserves so much more love, kpop stans don’t know how to appreciate beautiful ballads
What’s your #1 b-side? Spotify is blocked for me so I can’t see your ranking 😭
#1 is eyes locked hands locked!
@@LisaFevral omg ELHL is my other contender for the top spot! it’s one of those RV songs that make me feel like I’m in love. in my head Time to love and Iced Coffee are her sister songs, but she’s the queen among them lol
lisa, u look sooooo damn good! hairstyle, makeup, lenses, shining earrings, dress - obsessed
omg thank you🥰🥰
The fact that you understood the Red Flavour concept 😭😭😭
I'm so happy to start my day with your video!!!!
now i need to listen to all the ReVe's songs!! especially automatic (and make my own tier list)😮
'봐 Look' and 'Sunny Side Up!' - one of my faves
and idk why but i have a strong connection between SHINee's song 'Orgel' and RV-core lol
If you haven’t listened to a lot of rv, based on your picks I would recommend checking out these:
So good
Time slip
Talk to me
I just
Bamboleo
Knock on wood
Taste
Oh boy
Butterflies
Better be
Pushin’ n pullin
Something kinda crazy
In&out
I’ve been a casual fan since their debut and it’s been so cool to see the evolution they’ve made. Especially as a girl group from SM, where I feel like the company drops the ball on their girl groups time and time again. Which obviously RV has experienced, but I just want to appreciate their direction and focus after all these years!
WE ARE SEATED!!!
the witch comics in the back! love
I love all the topics you pick!! This was so fun and looking forward to what you're doing the future
Thank you🥰🥰🤍🤍
this is everything i’ve ever wanted thank u lisa
but fr, as a reveluv since ice cream cake, its so great to see other people who appreciate the group and understand rv and what they r abt! ESPECIALLY reveluvs who get into rv after bad boy because most ppl who did get into them at the time shat on RBB bc it wasn’t bad boy!! its so nice to see ppl who just get it, ty for ur service lisa
I had a hard time with the repetitiveness of RBB title track when it just came out but the b-sides and concept was so great that it gave me enough of an opportunity to grow to love RBB tt too ahaha and yeah, I noticed that most people who became reveluvs after bad boy like me expected only rnb titles from them, but we can always count on them making ANY genre spectacular
this was an interesting video, there was so much context I was missing, but it was interesting still
if you're into any visual art you should check out their mvs! the ones in the top 10 especially!
Why am I literally crying to this video sjssjsj god i love red relvet
You said it perfectly! Their music has the most bizarre concepts and unconventional production. But we know we can trust them, so we give it a chance! And I’d say I loved 99.9% of their songs within the first 3 listens! They all grow on you when you go in with an open mind!
honestly i can see red velvet's influence in you and your work , what a lovely video!! reveluv forever💘
Always love a video deep diving on Red Velvet’s concepts 🥰
So happy to queen out about RV with queen Lisa
🙂↕️🙂↕️
THANK YOU FOR THE AMAZING CONTENT AS ALWAYS
Thank you for watching🥰🤍
JUSTICE FOR BIRTHDAY!!! Some of my favorite creative direction of theirs ever + the song is turntina and perfectly weird! The era that made me a fan😭 sometimes i feel like her only shooter omg (thank u for this vid queen)
I get so so so happy when you talk about kpop because you always put my thoughts into words in regards to concepts or fashion, I know next to nothing about these topics but I always see and really deeply appreciate the intentions behind crafting kpop albums.
When the teaser images dropped for chill kill I GAGGED, I love red velvet but I wouldn’t classify myself as a reveluv since I don’t know much about them, nevertheless, I truly considered getting the album just because of the concept, I tend to love traditional korean/east asian concepts and I’m also a big horror fan, and the way you can see both perfectly blended together for chill kill just stunned me, also the horror concept in kpop is one that is almost always done wrong or poorly imo, but not red velvet, they slay every single time.
Lastly, I don’t think you’ll read this Lisa but I wanted to at least try. My favourite girl group of all time is LOONA, idk if you know this but because of their company’s negligence they got into a lawsuit and won to terminate their contracts, after that they split and five of them formed a group called ARTMS, all this yapping just to ask for you to check out the mvs they released for their album “” (there are 5 mvs), they are all amazing, three of them melodically reference previous work, the title track has insanely cool visuals and concept and the other one is called birth, please please please if you’re going to check out one video check “birth” out, they did the horror concept beautifully imo.
Seriously excuse the yapping, It’s just that kpop holds a very special place in my heart and I’m very passionate about it. Please continue making videos regardless if they are about kpop or not, I always love watching them 🖤☺️
Red velvet concepts will age so well and I'm living for it
This was recommended to me by YT, your sparkly star filter is to die for and such a fun video idea! ✨
I never thought I'd see you do a Red Velvet video!!! Amazing stufff
Yesss I love Red Velvet, they have inspired me in so many ways!! It’s so hard to pick a comeback, but my favorite eras are Ice Cream Cake, Feel My Rhythm, Bad Boy and Power Up (Blue Lemonade is like 95% of the reason, I love that song so much. I love the styling too!)
happy 10th red velvet and ty for an amazing video!
this is why i love rv so much bec they give you a taste of everything. also, this ranking says it why i dislike people saying rv fell off with their post-psycho comebacks because they clearly didn't?! and personally, i think that their latest comebacks, specifically cosmic, chill kill, and queen fmr, were much stronger than their previous.
with cosmic tho, i'm still saddened even after a month with its rollout and commitment to concept, especially it marks their 10th anniv. and the horrendous use of ai should've never happened (management flaw). i wish they leaned toward the adaptation of the sailor moon concept or created a modern look of their sailor look from happiness just for funsies and nostalgia. but, the trailer, the amazing music video, and cosmie vers saved the day. THANK YOU JOY!
also, chill kill should've gotten the 'psycho recognition' it deserved.
Joy literally saved cosmic fr omfg also I think the sound of chill kill was too much for general public, but I think cosmic should’ve gotten a win!! It’s so annoying that it didn’t
@@LisaFevral agree! cosmic deserved an encoreee. and its bridge still sends me to heaven everyday. 🌠
ikr! honestly 2 weeks is too short of a promotion period tbh:(
Ooh, that sparkle on your earrings~!! Anyway, another great video of yours that I truly enjoyed watching and it's just fun getting to know your thoughts and opinions.
Seeing someone talk about kpop from an actual artistic perspective is so rare, I was prepared to hate your takes (because of how much I’ve been burned) but I basically 100% agreed with or at least understood and respected everything you said. Justice for One of These Nights!!!
couldnt agree more with u, this video slaps.
I do have the CD and a player, and yeah, Psycho in it is the stripped back streaning version 😭 the mv version hits so much hardet, it's such a shame!
That’s just messed up😭😭
omg your little face in chill kill so iconic
Honestly speaking, Red Velvet is the group that I really listen to, not because of the music video or promotion, it’s the music itself. I’m saying this as someone that just follow them casually and an extremely picky person when adding it into my playlist(it’s like entering into my empire🙂)
I don’t know if I’ll have this same approach I have with RV in the coming years.
I Ioooove seeing others geek out about red velvet, their music and concepts are so worth diving into
You’re so real for having Automatic as the n.1 song 🕺🏽
loved this video so much!! also im sure its intentional but you look like you jumped right out of their 2nd cosmic photoshoot!!
I actually dressed as Wendy in their garden photoshoot for FMR!
@@LisaFevral ah yes i see it now!! so pretty
i might not agree with some choices but the way you talk about them in the Cosmic bit I TEARED UP LIKE YOU REALLY GET IT!!!!
Thank you for keeping us nourished, mother 😊
i have the perfect velvet album i want to eat the cd
the amount of times i said exactly while watching!! glad to have found your channel!
I saw all three thumbnails Lisa 🤣 You was really putting in the work to make sure your video was seen in our feed 😂
Yeah I’m not letting her go under the radar she pretty or whatever ahahah
29:00 the demographic is me. The certain mood is always.
Same I literally live on this song💀💀
@@dtkeight yessss another rookie enthusiast 😻. Idk what they put in that song but it’s so addicting
Love the sneaky Lisa addition to the chill kill album!
See… this is why I’m subscribed. Yes I’m a red velvet fan but was finishing a different video and going to watch Netflix with my bf- but I ended up watching the whole thing and I told him he had to wait! This video hit so hard and I deeply appreciate your content. Thank you.
I'm so glad you like it🤍🤍
I agree with you 100%... and your talk about Psycho. I couldn't agree more. (EDIT) Hi, got right back to edit my comment when you started talking about 'Perfect Red Velvet' Teasers. I LOVE YOU SO MUCH, LIKE YOU. GET. IT.
Thanks for talking about automatic, its THE song
liked before watching, because Lisa and RV are my two fave things☺️💕
So glad Feel My Rhythm got its flowers!!! I've always loved the creepy undertones of the group, my favorite being the cannibalism theory with #Cookie Jar
kinda freaked out by how similar our opinions are, the only thing i would’ve done is move #cookie jar up because it just hits for me. i’m a huge halloween/horror fan so you would think i would have a darker concept as my favorite, but nope, it’s feel my rhythm! it was my top song of 2022 and got me really back into red velvet after the long hiatus and queendom just not doing it for me in the way previous releases had. i actually based a lot of my makeup and fashion on the fmr concept for a while
the streaming version of Psycho is my 9/11, allegedly it was because it sounded better that way on radio or something?? idk but the synths are what really make the song for me and without them its an entirely different vibe.
it just doesn't sound as emotional at all😭
lisa and red velvet is my favorite combo, i've been following rv since their debut was announced... i can't believe it's already been 10 years and i'm so grateful i was there for every era, because rv is one of a kind 💕
omg since debut??? that's so cool!
feel my rhythm was the one and only rv music video i've ever watched and i left so impressed i couldn't stop thinking about it and played the song on loop for a couple of days. later added russian roulette and peekaboo to my playlist as well thinking it's crazy good. didn't really like any other songs but girl that's already three!
Girl how is everything you post catered to my exact taste
the video is so well-done, kudos to you the editing is sooo gorgeous!! i know of red velvet but i wasn’t in the game if you know what i mean and those little album covers on the left and the generous video and concept snippets bring everything together
Really glad you liked it🥰🥹
i love your sparkly earrings!!
I LOVE their concepts. My fav is Feel My Rhythm but I love seeing other people’s opinions and rankings
This video is super interesting since im in my transition phase to rv fan. Thank you 🤲🏻
Достоевский in the background kept distracting me
i just love seeing people as passionate for red velvet as i am... 10 years being the best girl group fr!!
Automatic and Bad Boy are really songs that you can't enough of like they are just that good