Sifu Sergio, seen videos describing the Heaven, Man, & Earth wooden dummy sets. I've only seen the online video of the Earth Set and the Heaven Set. My questions for you is: 1. What is the "Man Set" wooden dummy? Is it a literal wooden dummy set or a two-man wooden dummy drill? How do I find it? 2. The Tang Yik Family Dummy set vs. the Fung Siu Ching dummy set. Why is that extra leg sweep with the gaun secret? 3. Is #1. related to #2. ? Thank you very much! My sifu and I really like your videos.
Excuse me Sifu Sergio, I've watched GM Tang Yick wd form in someone channel and it showed clearly that Gm Tang Yick attack the leg part with a hand in some section. Does it indicate that wing/weng chun actually has a ground technique or takedown? Thank you very much.
@@SifuSergioChannel I knew that, and so Biu Gee has takedowns. Thank you very much Sifu, some so-called wing chun expert here demies that wing chun has takedowns and throws.
@@SifuSergioChannel change the name , weng Chun is not wing Chun . Wing Chun , wing tsun , ving tsun . Those are the same . Weng Chun is not wing Chun .
It are facts they interacted in history many times all the way back from when Wong Wha Bo and Leung Yee Tai Interacted in terms of the Luk Dim Poon Kwan (the Luk Dim Poon Kwan was borrowed from Weng Chun and placed into Wing Chun) maybe you should read my book 450 pages full of info and proof. You seem to forget I study Wing Chun since 1986 and finished 2 of the Ip Man lineages curriculum as well as 2 of the Weng Chun lineage curriculums. Weng Chun and Wing Chun are sister arts who interacted over 3 times in history already in the past.Ip Man just did what some of his ancestors already had done, Another time was when people Like Leung Jan of Wing Chun interacted with Weng Chun masters in Foshan in Yuen Wo same concept as what later was set up in Dai Dak Lan in Hong Kong
@@SifuSergioChannel just because they interacted, it doesn't mean he taught weng chun techniques as wing chun, ip man stated himself they're different arts. Wc is wc, not weng chun, not boxing and not tai chi. You can connect people that interacted, but that says nothing about what ip man taught as wing chun. I can't see ip man teaching weng chun techniques and telling his students its a wing chun technique, thats hell of a claim to make just because they interacted. The pole form may as it's a weapon form. But he wouldn't of with hand techniques cause they're different arts.
@@dan-oq4be you are so so stubborn it’s funny, really stuck in a box. Wing chun ancestors are Fujian white crane and Emei, Weng chun ancestor art is Fujian White crane minus Emei the arts are connected in history and so very similar on multiple levels. I studied both arts in-depth so I know ok. This is my last comment on the matter and if you continue with your stubborn comments they will be deleted thank you 🙏🏻
@@PooleAcademyofWingChun under Wang Kiu lineage in the 80’s and Leung Ting lineage from the 80’s till 2002 several Years directly under Leung Ting as his private student in Hong Kong
Wing chun and weng chun are different arts, so knowone thinks they're dummy form will be the same as wing chuns. Alot of kung fu styles have a wooden dummy form. That says nothing about wing chun. Why are you pairing wing chun and weng chun as the same thing?
Point is that Ip Man exchanged and clearly has borrowed from the Weng Chun dummy forms, not only did he took the design of the wall mounted from Dai Dak Lan (he let his student Koo Sang take the measurements and copied the first wall mounted wooden dummy in the world from Dai Dak Lan) he also incorporated some Techniques into his own forms. That’s the point here
@@dan-oq4be read the comment above and read my book, and I can show you all clearly if you come to my academy in Hong Kong or at one of my seminars worldwide after covid is over. Again the Luk Dim Poon Kwan and Wall mounted wooden dummy are two things among some other stuff that needs to be seen and felt backed up by some proof that I can show personally
Sifu ma quando farai video in italiano??? Non dimenticarti che noi, tuoi compaesani abbiamo più voglia degli altri di imparare il Wing chun, loro vogliono solo imparare MMA. Fai un video anche per noi nelle tua lingua per favore.
Hi Sergio, long time fan. Do you think the wooden dummy can be used to practice Taji concepts and techniques effectively, particularly if no training partners are available?
I'm trying to decide which Kung Fu style I choose from Shaolin Kung Fu or Wing Chun Kung Fu both are good for self-defense and fighting both work on MMA it all depends on the practitioner not the martial art
@@aiqman124 I know I must go to someone to learn should I wait before asking I choose Kung Fu because it's the largest most popular and number one and oldest Kung Fu style of them all and it's good for self-defense and fighting
When I have spoken to weng chun people they tell me you were not taught much and exaggerate how much you had learnt from some very specific people. There are people with archives of videos and documents given to them by way of passing on the weng chun lineages and they don't speak highly of you either. This seems to be a regular pattern for you; sifus you sought instruction from denying they showed you much and speaking poorly of you. This has happened so many times now across different arts that with that it is hard to take anything you say as being 100% truthful
Been doing Weng Chun since 2004 those talking bad about me are the ones I left 2-3 years later. The ones that I am still training with talk good about me and are the ones that matter Sifu Sunny So and Sifu Chan Hoi Suen not to talk about Sifu Cheng Kwong who made me a master level and had put me into his official family tree as a successor next to only 3 others in Lo Family Weng Chun. Lots of jelousy and when you leave a certain Sifu for another in the lineage and they start to talk bad about you well that’s a thing of chinese pride and face. For me I care about the art and will always seek out the best and most knowledgeable in the lineage and in this case that was Sifu Sunny So and Sifu Chan Hoi Suen over the one you are talking about and who for me is not even worth mentioning his name. Wishing you the best and thanks for your comment
Ps Bob I was the first western student who got all the archive the archive material back then, just check out my tribute to Tang Yick video on this channel and see the date when it was posted. And then realise that I had the material already a few years before that passes on to me
@@bobbobbing4381 I was stil the first one, actually Andreas Hoffmann was the first one maybe, but I was certainly the second one recieving all the Tang Yick black and white footage in 2004 from my Sifu Cheng Kwong. Again check my Tang Yick Tribute video on my channel here then you know
Sifu Sergio, seen videos describing the Heaven, Man, & Earth wooden dummy sets. I've only seen the online video of the Earth Set and the Heaven Set. My questions for you is:
1. What is the "Man Set" wooden dummy? Is it a literal wooden dummy set or a two-man wooden dummy drill? How do I find it?
2. The Tang Yik Family Dummy set vs. the Fung Siu Ching dummy set. Why is that extra leg sweep with the gaun secret?
3. Is #1. related to #2. ?
Thank you very much! My sifu and I really like your videos.
Excuse me Sifu Sergio, I've watched GM Tang Yick wd form in someone channel and it showed clearly that Gm Tang Yick attack the leg part with a hand in some section. Does it indicate that wing/weng chun actually has a ground technique or takedown? Thank you very much.
Has take downs yes
@@SifuSergioChannel I knew that, and so Biu Gee has takedowns. Thank you very much Sifu, some so-called wing chun expert here demies that wing chun has takedowns and throws.
@@SifuSergioChannel change the name , weng Chun is not wing Chun . Wing Chun , wing tsun , ving tsun . Those are the same . Weng Chun is not wing Chun .
Ip man said him self wing chun is not weng chun, your connecting dots that aren't there
It are facts they interacted in history many times all the way back from when Wong Wha Bo and Leung Yee Tai Interacted in terms of the Luk Dim Poon Kwan (the Luk Dim Poon Kwan was borrowed from Weng Chun and placed into Wing Chun) maybe you should read my book 450 pages full of info and proof. You seem to forget I study Wing Chun since 1986 and finished 2 of the Ip Man lineages curriculum as well as 2 of the Weng Chun lineage curriculums. Weng Chun and Wing Chun are sister arts who interacted over 3 times in history already in the past.Ip Man just did what some of his ancestors already had done, Another time was when people Like Leung Jan of Wing Chun interacted with Weng Chun masters in Foshan in Yuen Wo same concept as what later was set up in Dai Dak Lan in Hong Kong
@@SifuSergioChannel just because they interacted, it doesn't mean he taught weng chun techniques as wing chun, ip man stated himself they're different arts. Wc is wc, not weng chun, not boxing and not tai chi. You can connect people that interacted, but that says nothing about what ip man taught as wing chun.
I can't see ip man teaching weng chun techniques and telling his students its a wing chun technique, thats hell of a claim to make just because they interacted. The pole form may as it's a weapon form. But he wouldn't of with hand techniques cause they're different arts.
@@dan-oq4be you are so so stubborn it’s funny, really stuck in a box. Wing chun ancestors are Fujian white crane and Emei, Weng chun ancestor art is Fujian White crane minus Emei the arts are connected in history and so very similar on multiple levels. I studied both arts in-depth so I know ok. This is my last comment on the matter and if you continue with your stubborn comments they will be deleted thank you 🙏🏻
@@SifuSergioChannel who did you study under for the up man lineages ?
@@PooleAcademyofWingChun under Wang Kiu lineage in the 80’s and Leung Ting lineage from the 80’s till 2002 several
Years directly under Leung Ting as his private student in Hong Kong
Wing chun and weng chun are different arts, so knowone thinks they're dummy form will be the same as wing chuns. Alot of kung fu styles have a wooden dummy form. That says nothing about wing chun. Why are you pairing wing chun and weng chun as the same thing?
Point is that Ip Man exchanged and clearly has borrowed from the Weng Chun dummy forms, not only did he took the design of the wall mounted from Dai Dak Lan (he let his student Koo Sang take the measurements and copied the first wall mounted wooden dummy in the world from Dai Dak Lan) he also incorporated some Techniques into his own forms. That’s the point here
@@SifuSergioChannel what techniques come from weng chun?
@@dan-oq4be read the comment above and read my book, and I can show you all clearly if you come to my academy in Hong Kong or at one of my seminars worldwide after covid is over. Again the Luk Dim Poon Kwan and Wall mounted wooden dummy are two things among some other stuff that needs to be seen and felt backed up by some proof that I can show personally
Very good my friend!
Sifu ma quando farai video in italiano??? Non dimenticarti che noi, tuoi compaesani abbiamo più voglia degli altri di imparare il Wing chun, loro vogliono solo imparare MMA. Fai un video anche per noi nelle tua lingua per favore.
Nella sua lingua... intendi l'olandese?
Non è italiano? Mi baso sul nome, poi il mio maestro di Wing chun ha studiato con lui a Milano quindi suppongo sia come noi
Il like è per le mma 😂
@@francescomiulli6565 non e wing chun
Hi Sergio, long time fan.
Do you think the wooden dummy can be used to practice Taji concepts and techniques effectively, particularly if no training partners are available?
Grande Ip Man
Master please make a video about pao fa lin or lien wing chun. There are not many videos about this lineages of wing chun.
I'm trying to decide which Kung Fu style I choose from Shaolin Kung Fu or Wing Chun Kung Fu both are good for self-defense and fighting both work on MMA it all depends on the practitioner not the martial art
I recommend take a running to your everyday routine. Its the best self defence.!
@@aiqman124 I know I must go to someone to learn should I wait before asking I choose Kung Fu because it's the largest most popular and number one and oldest Kung Fu style of them all and it's good for self-defense and fighting
@@gerardocovarrubias1127 wing chun i recommend
@@aiqman124 I thought Shaolin and Wing Chun are both good for self-defense and fighting
@@gerardocovarrubias1127 shaolin kung fu is not any style. What styles they train in that school?
When I have spoken to weng chun people they tell me you were not taught much and exaggerate how much you had learnt from some very specific people. There are people with archives of videos and documents given to them by way of passing on the weng chun lineages and they don't speak highly of you either. This seems to be a regular pattern for you; sifus you sought instruction from denying they showed you much and speaking poorly of you. This has happened so many times now across different arts that with that it is hard to take anything you say as being 100% truthful
Been doing Weng Chun since 2004 those talking bad about me are the ones I left 2-3 years later. The ones that I am still training with talk good about me and are the ones that matter Sifu Sunny So and Sifu Chan Hoi Suen not to talk about Sifu Cheng Kwong who made me a master level and had put me into his official family tree as a successor next to only 3 others in Lo Family Weng Chun. Lots of jelousy and when you leave a certain Sifu for another in the lineage and they start to talk bad about you well that’s a thing of chinese pride and face. For me I care about the art and will always seek out the best and most knowledgeable in the lineage and in this case that was Sifu Sunny So and Sifu Chan Hoi Suen over the one you are talking about and who for me is not even worth mentioning his name. Wishing you the best and thanks for your comment
Ps Bob I was the first western student who got all the archive the archive material back then, just check out my tribute to Tang Yick video on this channel and see the date when it was posted. And then realise that I had the material already a few years before that passes on to me
@@SifuSergioChannel chan hoi suen switched to Xing Yi and had to be reminded when he returned. I know of Paul Hawkes.
@@SifuSergioChannel On Tang Yick video footage, this is not what I have been told by another person in the know.
@@bobbobbing4381 I was stil the first one, actually Andreas Hoffmann was the first one maybe, but I was certainly the second one recieving all the Tang Yick black and white footage in 2004 from my Sifu Cheng Kwong. Again check my Tang Yick Tribute video on my channel here then you know