⚠️Exposing The Truth About The Tablighi Jamat😮| Shaykh Uthman Ibn Farooq
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 6 ม.ค. 2025
- In this thought-provoking session, Shaykh Uthman ibn Farooq addresses a crucial question regarding the Tablighi Jamaat. Drawing from personal experiences and deep Islamic knowledge, the Shaykh provides a comprehensive analysis of the movement, highlighting its principles, practices, and their alignment-or lack thereof-with the Sunnah.
Key Points Covered:
The Concept of Tabligh:
Tabligh (conveying the message) is an integral part of Islam, but the Shaykh questions the necessity of creating a separate "Jamaat" for this purpose.
He compares it to other aspects of Islam, such as Salah and Zakat, which are not organized into distinct groups.
Personal Experience with the Jamaat:
Shaykh Uthman shares his extensive involvement with the Tablighi Jamaat, including spending 4 months, 40 days, and 3 days in their programs.
He critiques some of their practices, such as their approach to da'wah and rigid schedules, which he feels are not derived from the Sunnah.
Da'wah to Non-Muslims:
He raises concerns about the Jamaat's avoidance of da'wah to non-Muslims, which contradicts the Prophet Muhammad’s (ﷺ) mission.
Citing Qur’anic verses and their context, he stresses that da'wah should encompass all of humanity, not just Muslims.
The Issue with Weak and Fabricated Ahadith:
Shaykh Uthman critiques the Jamaat's reliance on the book Fada'il A'mal by Zakariya Kandhlawi, which contains weak and fabricated narrations (baatil ahadith).
He contrasts this with earlier authentic works like Bulugh al-Maram and Riyad al-Saliheen that focus on Sahih Ahadith.
Encouragement and Advice:
While acknowledging the good intentions of the Tablighi Jamaat, such as fostering an Islamic environment and ikhlas (sincerity), he urges them to align their practices with authentic teachings.
He calls for da'wah efforts that include outreach to non-Muslims and a return to foundational Islamic principles.
This video is an essential watch for anyone seeking a deeper understanding of the Tablighi Jamaat, its strengths, and its shortcomings. Shaykh Uthman’s balanced yet firm approach encourages critical thinking and adherence to the Quran and Sunnah.
This video is open-source and not subject to copyright restrictions. It has been uploaded with the explicit permission of the rightful owner. As with all content shared on this channel, I strive to ensure that every video complies with applicable copyright laws and reflects the spirit of openness and collaboration.
Tableegh jamaat helped millions,alhamdulillah, they must continue their good work.❤❤❤
@@holimolibebalanced9348 ❤️
They also need to change certain ways aswell
✅✅✅
They helped them to misguidance
Helping Allah means working for his deen. Reach out to people and make them jannatis which the jamat of Allah so called by people Tablighi jamat do. They die hard to restore the imaan of people like the imaan of Sahaba. In the process their imaan also gets stronger. BTW Allah doesn't need our help. But we are the best of the ummah as I have mentioned in Arabic above so we need to propagate good and stop evil and bad by going out in the path of Allah fi-sabilillah
Imagine growing up in the west and living a sinful life, having bad habits such as smoking drinking or spending too much time on your phone and not praying 5 times a day only to stop all of that and go on jammat for 40 days or 4 months, where you spend most of your time offering 5 times prayer and around people with a higher level of iman than oneself. How can one possibly think this is bad? There must genuinely be darkness in ones heart to think so. this comes from an ex athiest
It all filters down to the working manual that you're following. This is how things are getting normalized where you can't even know whats wrong with this. Narrating weak and fabricated hadith and with stories that contains shirky elements have all become acceptable in the name of da'wah. It's like the man who was very keen in doing every salah throughout his life, except that he didn't had wudu!
If one gets proper knowledge and firm akidah, one doesn’t need to enter this circle, if he gets ilm-knowledge which is lacking in tabligh jamaat system. Seeking knowledge is far superior to anything that TJ does, it is a fatwa of non educated TJ leaders that doing work and seeking halal rizk is not important as going out for long periods of time
Just to expand on this.
Leaving your day to day duties, your family, work, school etc. and then disappear for months. How do you even justify it?
Then there is made up stories (Hikayat) that accompany these sermons. I don’t need a made up story by a human to justify the god’s or the prophet’s word.
And then somehow it is meant to make you a better Muslim. How? When most of the stuff I am being told is not applied on me because I need to apply Islam in my day to day.
Don’t get me wrong. The lectures do help. But not when they are purposeful only to increase their own army.
We’ll said mashallah
@@Safeer2.0brother these people go door to door without hesitation for hundreds of time and call them to salah....
They get up in tahajjud and pray for the people (who are far away from masjid and faraiz,sunnah etc )for hours!!
Sadly,Which many people don't do for their own sake.
And now from markaz nizamuddin (headquarters) they have sidelined fazail e amal(which is making ummah a point of debate coz let everyone come and see what are they doing) and have adopted a book called muntakhab ahadees...which only contain authenticated ahadees.....
Many people don't know faraiz of gusl, although they have children....
They tend to bring them to masjid and try to teach them basics of islam so that if basics(farz and sunnah)are strong they can atleast make there life according to how sahaba lived.....
Title of the video is misleading. Exposing what? Do they have any neferacious agenda? Tablighi Jamath has spread so much deen among masses.
Haters wud only point out sth that has nothing to do with the movement.....any country that has tableegh is blessed,......someone is actually there to call back to Islam.....
Bidah 😂
It is a bid'ah and they don't call to tawhid. They don't seek knowledge too. In a ideal muslim country they would have been all rounded up and thrown out. May Allah keep them out of our masajids.
@@samrock8567they should people with actual knowledge
Taghleeghi jamat derived from the deobandi. Who are deviated sufis. It's Sufism not islam
I'm firm on my salaat because of Tableeghi Jamaat Alhamdulillah
Not because of ALLAH?????????????????? There lies the problem in a nutshell! May others learn from you!
@MujahidAMIN-h5e Brother Mujahid, I think you didn't get the meaning of what I said. Of course it is Allah SWT's order to perform salah and all the other aspects of Islam, but do we act upon it 100% times? As Muslim we need to be reminded of a lot because Insaan is forgetful. Tableeghi Jamaat's core ideology is surrounded around correction (Islah) of one's own self, Reminder to others and Pleasure of Allah SWT. I live in the West and have seen many Muslims of different schools of thought and even reverted Muslims benefit from it. Anyone having a doubt should try spending few days, In Sha Allah all doubts will be cleared
@@MujahidAMIN-h5e Hummdulliah Allah swt guided me to islam Australian revert tabligh jammah gave me dawah so Allah swt guided me but tabligh jammah was the dawah I received Hummdulliah
This sheikh himself said he was a gangster and the tabligh jamaah got hold of him and thats how he went to study deen.I cant understand how can he be against tabligh.
استغفر الله
If you listen carefully...he is never against the tabligh... rather he is against the system in which they teach from books having things outside the fold of islam...he is saying that the niyyah is good but the actions are somewhere not correct.
If i’m drowning and a christian saves me. Does that mean I have to agree with everything a Christian believes? I can be grateful but I don't have to agree with everything with him.
Cuz he is a clown. Sorry he needs a shaykh to mentor him and bring him down to the ground
He is a typical salafi
I don't think you open mind to understand the akhida he speaking about. There is nothing like tabling jamath in islam. Innovation....
Many gangster here in Cape Town has been rehabilitated by Tableegh Jamah. So Tableegh Jamah has lots of benefits. Young school children can go in Jamah during school holidays taking them off the streets. Fix the books of Ahadeeth and the sorts comings not trying to destroy Tableegh Jamah
@@ebrahiemdaniels6491 they are extremely firm on the Sunnah but lacking in 1 major Fard ie the acquisition of knowledge. Thousands of them use the miswaak but don't know the nieyyah. They quote ahaadeeth for years,many members doing it for 30 years and more, but personally they don't even know 10 ahaadeeth from memory. In that 30 years they can't recite Quran fluently with tajweed nor speak Arabic. They don't know fiqh,Sarf or balaagha. Imagine being in a deeni environment with scholars in close proximity but you study nothing of your Deen. I have never seen someone in the tabligh jamaat who married his daughter to her husband. He makes the imaam wakeel because he is too weak. The imaam must bury his family members because he is lacking. Yet they claim to be on the correct path
There are also christian rehabilation centres for druggies which algamdulilla many muslims have benefitted. Must the rehabilitated now take up christianity?
@UnknownHuman2000 I don't understand your Christian point. I'm talking about Muslim having an institution to assist them. What do your sect do promote the Deen of Allah. By the way I'm not even part of Tableegh Jamah
@UnknownHuman2000 you join your Christians.
@@ebrahiemdaniels6491 same in Australia, Hummdulliah I'm a revert 20 years ago Allah swt guided me to islam the tabligh jammah gave me dawah helped me alot alhumdulillah
And their main objective is to help those who are muslims already but not practicing start practicing again. Which is an amazing job and MāshāAllah they've done wonders. And they won't have any problem with you giving da'wah to kuffar. I know of many jamaats that have travelled around the globe to give da'wah to kuffar. Spain, brazil, italy, sweden and many others
Fine. What about narrating weak and fabricated hadith to the masses who has no understanding of the deen?
@@Safeer2.0 ask that to Imam Bukhari, who has also narrated many weak ahadith in his books apart from his Sahih.
Let’s break down about using da’if (weak) hadith in Fazail-e-Amaal and why it is valid:
---
What is Da’if Hadith?
A da’if hadith is a narration with some weakness in its chain of transmission or other minor issues, but it is not fabricated.
Scholars generally avoid using da’if hadith in fiqh (jurisprudence) or aqeedah (theology), but they allow its use in fazail (virtues) under specific conditions.
---
Why is it Permissible in Fazail (Virtues)?
1. Consensus of Scholars:
Renowned scholars, including Imam Bukhari, Imam Nawawi, Ibn Hajar Asqalani, and others, have permitted the use of da’if hadith in matters of virtues, provided:
The hadith does not relate to legal rulings or beliefs.
The meaning aligns with established principles of Islam.
Fazail-e-Amaal focuses only on encouraging good deeds, such as praying, fasting, and performing dhikr - not deriving rulings.
2. Example from Bukhari’s Adab al-Mufrad:
Even Imam Bukhari, known for his strict standards in Sahih Bukhari, included weaker narrations in his book Adab al-Mufrad, which deals with akhlaq (morals) and fazail.
This shows that da’if hadith is accepted in specific contexts.
---
How Fazail-e-Amaal Follows This Principle
Fazail-e-Amaal uses da’if hadith only in matters of encouraging good actions (e.g., virtues of salah, fasting, etc.).
It avoids using these narrations for jurisprudence or aqeedah.
---
Countering the Criticism of Fazail-e-Amaal
Many Salafis criticize Fazail-e-Amaal for using da’if narrations, yet they:
1. Accept Ibn Taymiyyah, Ibn Qayyim, and other scholars who followed the same principles regarding da’if hadith in virtues.
2. Do not reject other respected books, like Adab al-Mufrad, that also contain weaker narrations.
---
The use of da’if hadith in Fazail-e-Amaal aligns with centuries of scholarly tradition.
Rejecting Fazail-e-Amaal solely for this reason is inconsistent unless they also reject other works like Adab al-Mufrad or books by Ibn Qayyim and others.
@@Safeer2.0 😂Brother, the only time those weak and fabricated ahadith are used are in virtues, not actual rulings, and it is not a big issue to use weak ahadith in saying the virtue or reward of something, And those weak ahadith that have been used like that have brought millions of people back to the right way of Islam, Maulana Zakariyya kandahlawi was a great great great scholar and muhaddith, If you look into his life you will only alot of shocking goodness in it, the book is accepted by Allah, proof of that is you see it in almost every masjid you go to, and look at the comment above me, he said it best
@@TheDuaStudio @TheDuaStudio @coolfaceguy10 Brother, with all due respect, don't think I'm unaware of the explanation that you gave here and I'm simply doing blanket statements. Imam Bukhari undertook the himalayan task of collecting hadiths, verifying it's grading, separating it and granted the ummah with beneficial knowledge one cannot think of. And yes many of the texts of salafs does have daef hadith. Nobody is denying it! But there's a time and place to use it. Do you know any other group that does da'wah to the common man with the books you alleged? Even if somebody uses it they make sure the message is conveyed about the authenticity. Thats how the callers to ahlusunnah impart deen. And the discussion is not just about daef hadith. It's about the aqeedah and the use of many fabricated stories and hadith that goes to the level of bid’ah and shirk! Don't try to deny it as there have been plenty of occassions such things have been refuted with proper proofs from the books you carry. And the sad thing is you're carrying these stuffs to the common layman who is far away from deen and has no proper foundation about it. The common reader doesn't have a clue which is sahih, which one is daef and what's fabricated. Imagine the damage that it produces. He thinks everything is pure unadulterated deen straight from the time of sahabah. By the way, there are endless number of other books and narrations that are very authentic and safe to use for da'wah. Then why one needs to be adamant with bogus stuffs coming from your group? Interestingly you guys use Riyadhusaliheen at Arab countries which is a great book without a doubt but when it comes to india, pakistan, bangladesh things change. The thing is, until the scholars of ahlusunnah started admonishing the people about the dangers of such groups and their books, initially you guys were in denial. Slowly then tabligh jamat people started accepting the problems and are trying to cover up with tit for tat games. This is deen bro. It all comes down to Qaalallah wa qaala rasool wa qaala sahabah. If it doesn't fit this criterion then there's no point in such endless debates. Fix the basics first. Also to cover up the faults we commonly hear see how many people have started praying due to our work, leaving addictions, started growing beard, etc. Let me tell you, if you go to some de-addiction centre or to some saint/guru they also bring changes to your lives. Does that mean their path is the purest? It's a failed logic. I urge you all to leave all the prejudices behind, pray sincerely to Allah for guidance and start understanding the deen from the right sources. You will definitely change your opinions In Sha Allah. May Allah keep us in the straight path. Aameen.
This is true. But, it is also a fact that tablighi jamaat do not refrain from propagating dawah of complete Deen. They only follow amr bil ma'roof. They don't follow naHiy 'anil munkar, neither do they strive for it and they call those who do so as extremists.
Tabligh are needed in the West where unfortunately many 2nd, 3rd generation Muslim end up loosing their deen after having grown up in a kufr environment where haram is the norm.
I live in Spain and we have a whole generation of young Muslim Moroccans who know nothing about their deen and aren't practising, even if some have received an islamic education.
Rap music, social media, secular education at school combined with the desire to fit has ruined a whole generation.
And the tablighs are the only ones concerned about it.
i been on tabliqui jammat and it eas very helpful as a revert. Also, they have never said do not give dawah to non muslims. So maybe depends on who is the amir.
Ever you seen them giving dawah to non muslims. Tell your "Amir" let's give dawah to non-Muslims today you will come to know by yourself
@hashir4you470 I'm a revert in Australia tabligh jammah gave me dawah alhumdulillah, Allah swt guided me to islam threw tabligh jammah
That's not the problem, even so they don't spread the correct dawah of tawhid. And I'm sure you would have learned 100x more if you went to medina instead.
@@hashir4you470 He said we can. I guess it depends on the amir.
@@LearnTawhidWell how am i going to go to medina I live in Los Angeles. it's too far lol but Inshallah.
Giving a misal of Prophet (saw) is very easy nowadays. But one has to except that times have changed too much from Huzoors' time and now. Today Muslims need more hidayah than kuffars. Beshak Allah gives hidayah.
Jamaat is very beneficial I my self benefit from it I am not a jamaat worker alhamdullah
Sheikh uthman you itself are a product of this effort, more over jamat is a word for a group of people who do effort in certain way
@@abdullahshaikh6621 ❤️
Very well said !
Did you listen to his words? He never said that tabligh or giving nasiha to Muslims he even said that he is with it. So please brothers listen carefully to the words of other borthers and don't just hear what you want to hear
@@shahzad_bankaihe understands what the sheikh said, he is just intentionally ignoring the points because he cannot answer them.
وَلۡتَكُن مِّنكُمۡ أُمَّةٞ يَدۡعُونَ إِلَى ٱلۡخَيۡرِ وَيَأۡمُرُونَ بِٱلۡمَعۡرُوفِ وَيَنۡهَوۡنَ عَنِ ٱلۡمُنكَرِۚ وَأُوْلَـٰٓئِكَ هُمُ ٱلۡمُفۡلِحُونَ
And let there be [arising] from you a nation inviting to [all that is] good, enjoining what is right and forbidding what is wrong, and those will be the successful.
Spot on. Shaykh Uthman, here is an ayat asking there should be a jamaat! Please humble yourselve and fear Allah.
Tabligh jamat elders are now discouringing the use of fadail e amal and are encouring the use of muntkahab ahadith which only has sahih or hassan ahadith. There were prophets that spent time giving dawah to people who already believed and reminding them about the hereafter. How many hundreds of millions of people are there that dont even pray salah and do not know the basics of deen. Are they not important? Giving dawah to non muslims is important yes, but one should not discourage the amazing effort that the tabligh jamat does.
@@mohammedumarsiddiqui1944 Who does? Moulana Saad, who says that the earning of an Imam for Quran is like of a prostitute, Naudhubillah? Or the other Saadies who follow him blindly?
Read Fazail-e-A’mal. It was written by Sheikh Zakariya, Rh.A, whose Tashree of Mishkat is still taught at Madinah university.
You can give dawah and give advice to your Muslim brothers without being part of a group.
@@raulrahaman9863
Sura 3 (Al-Imran), ayah 104
"Let there arise among you a group inviting to all that is good, enjoining righteousness and forbidding evil. Those are the successful ones".
@ check the tafseer for that ayah akh, we have to follow the Qur’an and Sunnah with the understanding of the salaf and not interpret the ayahs according to our own understanding.
@@raulrahaman9863 please tell me what the tafsir is
Shaitan can mislead people. Here is an example of how he misled an Islamic scholar using his pride of his knowledge. May Allah save him and those who believe in him.
Tableeque Jama'ath is a noble work in line with the sunnah of the Prophet (pbuh) to correct the Eeman of the Believers.
Dear bro they have problm with aqeedha
@findingthetruth7923 Brother, while we are debating the aqeedah, Muslims are moving away from the path of Islam. Today, the plight of Muslim ummah is in despair not because of their aqeedah but it has moved away from the Tawakkul of Allah to be dependent on the Yahud and Nazaarah
@ dear bro aqeeda is important
th-cam.com/video/qhH9N5__afQ/w-d-xo.htmlsi=tuLwCgiD3Us4ybly
@@nakeebissadeen1606 dear beloved bro u study thouheed verywell in sha Allah u will understand what am saying
Barak Allah feekum love you brother
May Allah barakha in your ilm
@findingthetruth7923 I appreciate your dua for me to acquire Ilm. However. Ilm without Dhikr, the rememberance or consciousness of Allah has no benefit. Today, the so-called Islamic countries with strong Thowheed aqeedah have taken the USA and Israel as their Awliya or their friends and protectors instead of Allah.
Have you ever seen them label themselves tablighi jamat - signs/posters/title of books? No, because this name for them came about, as is normal for any organised effort to be labelled.
You clearly didn't spend enough time with them to fully understand their work - the 72hrs is encouraged just as you would encourage someone to complete a 3 month course on tajweed etc.
There are some valid criticisms of the work and the people involved but those coming from this brother are not very academic. Instead, they are fuelling further animosity and division and overlooking the masses of good this effort has brought to the ummah. The proof as they say is in the pudding.
Tajweed you say! Three months. I know of elders that have been in jama'ah Tableegh their entire life but still can't recite Surah fatiha. Wallahi I swear on the Rabb of this world and Hereafter, they say Allah is everywhere, they state Shaytaan knows when the day of Qiyamah. They state never to ask about aqeedah. Don't blind follow them as they make it a K ligation to follow them tacitly under the guise of doing taqleed of abu hanifa rhm. Syay away.
@@rathernot6660 Their main objective is to increase their Imaan and if you were to compare the elders of tableegh with ourselves, they'd blow us away. It's true they do lack in other fields. And they know it's importance as much as we do.
@@rathernot6660I've been jamaat and I've never heard of what you said about shaytaan knowing yawmul qiyaamah. Why would you ask them about in depth aqeedah questions when you know they're not the people to ask as well
I had spent time with jamat tableegh people but never once I heard them say about tawheed, shirk and bid’ah. Infact I used to wear an amulet on my hand and never knew it was wrong until somebody else outside the fold of tabligh jamat warned me and thereafter understood the seriousness of matters I pointed out.
@@rathernot6660 Brother May Allah forigve me and you for coming with heavy misinformation about Islam, this isnt true at all, Maybe some scholars of the past have made mistakes saying it, but even if you did the slightest bit of research "deobandi" isnt a sect AT ALL, the reason they "scholars of deoband" is because deoband IS A CITY IN INDIA, and the scholars from there and around there are called "scholars of deoband" bc they are FROM THERE, it is not a sect at all, and so if a scholar makes a mistake which would happen to be from deoband, ur just going to say every single person and scholar from there is in a sect? what is wrong with you? do you have any idea how much the indian subcontinent did for Islam in the past 300 years, through THEM Allah Ta'laa spread Islam towards us, yes it is true, read any book on "the scholars of deoband" and you will see, like Shah waliulah dehlawi andthe other huge pious scholars after them, look at what they went through, they had wars for Islam, scholars were getting killed for the sake of Islam, But they held trust in Allah and now Alhamdulillah look at how many Muslims reside in Asia now, dont say things like this because Allah will ask you about it, May Allah forgive us Ameen
To be honest, I have observed the tablighi jamaat for many, many years though not actively involved. This shaykh (I'm intrigued to scrutinise his background as aside from his attire he doesn't appear very scholarly) has misrepresented the work of tablighi jamaat. The work of tablighi jamaat is conducted in a structured fashion to maintain consistency as it is a very large scale effort - its common sense really. There is no shar'i prohibition in applying organisation to any work that is done collectively. In fact, if you fail to plan a group activity, you essentially plan to fail - again, common sense. And thus, the usool applied in the work of tablighi jamaat is to uphold organisational consistency which isn't khilaaf-e-shari'ah. In terms of the dawah audience, this is also managed through same consistent principles to maintain standardisation - for the very same reason that it is an organised effort which all over the globe has been extremely beneficial to the ummah. I must admit, individuals do vary, and thus some stick to the principles while others don't - but the organisation cannot be held liable for the bad apples.
The most underrated comment here!
The obsession with Fazail amaal still has to stop. I am chilla saathi (spent 40days) and although it has many benefits, it's still not perfect and I have many constructive criticisms.
Tableeghi jamaat DO NOT STOP from giving dawah to non Muslims. They say learn your own Islam first before moving to the next level of giving non Muslims dawah. It behoves me how anyone can be against tableegi jamaat. All dawah is important, and theirs focuses on reinvigorating Islam in Muslims, which is much needed in this age. We all know our current decline is due to our decline in faith.
Tabligh elders themselves say that it was the public who named the Jamaat as “Tablighi” Jamaat. Basically it’s taking time out, staying in Masjid which is the best place on the earth, learning, teaching and visiting other Muslims and encouraging them to make efforts.
3, 10, 40 days, 4 months is to organise a group to spend time together.
Also 3 days reward is multiplied by ten for this Ummah and it’s as though you spent 30 days.
As for asking to organise a Jamaat to visit non Muslims, why don’t you organise a Jamaat to visit non Muslims? Rather how many Jamats have you organised to visit the non Muslims?
Shaikh Uthma, Tabligh has changed lives of millions of all around the world, lots of muslims made tauba , and lot many are accepting Islam too.
But many Bida'h they are doing bro
@Sheikh_Nishad_Hyder1948
Yes calling people towards Allah and his rasul is bidaah, Infusing love of sunnah in millions of hearts is bidah, bringing youths out club cultura is bidah, working day and night to populate the masajid is bidah, instilling love for zikr and Ikramul muslimeen is bidah, feeding people for the sake of Allah is bidah, establishing and opening the gates of masaajid in all the corners of the world is bidah...
Converting millions of name sake muslims into real practicing muslims is bidah...
Countless bidah of these types
How many of such types of bidaah are you inguled into my dear Shaikh?
@mdjaffer3286 when did Tableegi Jamaat establish?
When did Fazail e Amaal write it down?
Was there no Islam before Tableegi Jamaat??
Was there no DAWAH BEFORE Tableegi Jamaat??
I didn't say that calling ppl towards Tawhīd is Bida'h...
Fazial e Ammal is Sunnah ?? What a joke ?
Which contains a lot of Mawdoo and Daif hadith
@Sheikh_Nishad_Hyder1948
Islam has bern there since last 1400 years
My question is what slolution you have other than work of tableegh to save the Imaan of muslims who do not have talab and desire for number of reasons and yet hey are muslims in goverment registry?
@Sheikh_Nishad_Hyder1948
Tableeghi Jamat estabshid just before 100 years and it suceeded in changing lives of millions of muslims around the world and it is still doing it and wiil keep contunue doing it Insha Allah
Our dawah to non muslims in todays changing times (especially due to Western influence) is our akhlaq. This is what tabligh teaches in todays time! . Our deen will always be the same, but seeing todays situation in so many countries, ulema of tabligh they often say that our akhlaq hold the key in drawing non muslims towards us.
Tabligh is excellent and daawah to non Muslim is better....
This shaikh himself was guided by Allah through Tableegh Jamaa'a..
How ungrateful can one be.
Tableeghi Jamaat go around REMINDING Muslims of thier responsibilities and calling then towards Islam.
There's no doubt that waht the shaikh does ,giving dawah to none Muslims is better,but that shouldn't take away from what others do.
May Allah guide us all.
Dear bro problm with aqeedha
@@findingthetruth7923Brother please mention what's their aqeedah. And how is it wrong
I say one thing to who oppose to going in Tabligi Jamah don’t listen to anyone BUT go and experience for yourself for at least 40 Days continuously and you MUST follow rules and regulations then give give me feedback.
That is logically wrong. Imagine a christian says experience christianity by coning to church, reading bible, singing songs, acting in christian plays.... Would we do that ? Aodhu billah ! We dont do that because we know as evidence we received rhat is quran and sunnah of our messenger.
Whether to undertake a practice as part of deen depends on evidence. Not "cmon experience it. If you feel it ,you do if not leave"
This Pseudo Salafi guy can't sell anything without mentioning our Ulamas 😂.
He probably did more for the spread of Islamic information than all your Ulema. How many of your Ustaad's got the balls to stand in Balboa Park and tell christians to their face that the Bible has inconsistencies. I was also Jamaat person, spent 40 days, and now Alhamdulilla follow non-secular Islam
💯
This is the problem with u guys....atleast try to understand wht is his problem....
Thank you for your contribution of slander and labeling without any real value to this discussion.
He is a nut job, he literally believes that anyone who criticised the rulers is a sinner. He said that even if they take your property or wives you should bear cause it's Sunnah 😂 typical wahabis boot lickers
All of these points shaykh mentioned are not absaloute. I do the effort of tanleegh in Canada . We have been 100% encouraged to use riyadus saliheen , and never forced to stay for a full 3 days. Yes it is the structure but it is not forced. I have spent many 1 or 2 days with ease. I have also given dawah to non Muslims in my gasht and they have taken shahadah.
The only issue with tableegh is when people become extreme in it, as extremity in any effort of deen will taint it
Allah forgive us all for our shortcomings, and Allah knows best
No one gets an answer until the morning of qiama. So let's take courage and do encourage what one is doing.
So this guy who was a nobody, in gangs, changed his life, became a better muslim, went Jamaat and started preaching on YT now mocks other Ulema and Muslims??
In the time of the prophet, the imaan of people was strong and they were able to preach to non believers. Nowadays, the imaan of muslim youth is hanging by a thread and u want to call non believers to islam rather than saving our own ummah? There is a hadith mentioning that saving 1 muslims from leaving islam is better than calling non believers to islam.
This is why Tabligh promotes calling our own people closer to Allah and strengthening our own Imaan before calling others.
These YT comfort chair Sheikhs are the reason of the downfall and misguidance of our Ummah
Brother Uthman is just saying if what you are doing is part of the religion then is OK if not stop innovating things and making it part of the religion very simple.
It is arrogance on the side of Tablighi Jamaat to claim that someone was rightly guided because of Tabligh Jamaat. Allah didn't decide for him to be guided, it was Tabligh Jammat who decided he should change his life and come out of gangs?
@UnknownHuman2000 No, I didn't say that but Allah made the work of Tabligh a means of guidance for people.
Who else is going door to door knocking random houses talking about Allah and calling to masjid?
A person who is on the wrong path isn't going to listen to Sheikhs on YT, but will most likely listen if someone takes the time out to meet them in person like brothers of Tabligh do
Men a lot of Muslims in my country need Tabligh Jamaat.
People have reverted to Islam because of the effort of the tabligji jamaat.
Shaikh ,Shaikh, different domains of responsibility are assigned to different groups the Tableeghi Jamaat focuses on strengthening the faith of weak Muslims by providing a spiritual environment rooted in emotional appeal and religious knowledge. While their efforts are primarily within the Muslim community, they are crucial in mending the cracks within the Ummah.
Engaging non-Muslims and countering complex ideologies requires deep knowledge and skills, a field where you excel. In my view, the Jamaat plays a vital role in preparing spiritually uplifted individuals who may later join you in the intellectual defense and propagation of Islam.
But why do the people of tabligh say it is mandatory for every Muslim to go Jamaat?
This so-called Sheikh has gone far from Deen. Criticising our Fazail e Amal Book , it's writer shown his ignorance and arrogance about Tabligi Jamat. Our Ulama's from Darul Uloom UK are challenging these pseudo salafi guys,but they always run away from debates & discussions. Alislamproduction channel has exposed this liar very badly 😂.
@@drydatesBrother debate will not solve any purpose, read the true history of Prophet Mohammed SAW, anyone do anything from his own that does not belongs to Sunna is Baatil. We all one but Shaitaan is dividing us by asking us make additions, innovation so that all our good deeds converts to Bad depends. think and play role.
I'm a Molvie today because of Tableeg Jamaah. Thousands of Pious Ulama serve in Tableegh Jamaah.
Definitely disagree 😢 i could have corrected his opinions easily in defence of tabligue
Please enlighten us
@zulfiqarawan3407 the other comments have already done it. E.g. It's not fixed but recommended 3,40 and 4 months. The arguments were crap. I could go more but not worth it. Allah knows who funds these guys but everyone knows tabligue is funded by individuals by themselves. Ikhlas
This is when people without actually going to a madrassa, suddenly become a sheikh.
It is complete lie. It is never a principle of tabligh Jamaat to prevent daawah to non Muslims. Infact most conversion to islam is through tabligh jamaat in Africa and parts of the world. The thing is tabligh jamaat never adverties these conversion on social media. Sincerity to Allah is a key element in tabligh jamaat
The problem with doing this is not about giving Dawat to Kufaar…. It’s that our own Muslims including myself have gone so far away from deen to the point where if u have to give kufaar Dawah, they will turn and ask you to first go fix ur Muslim brothers who are doing haraam actions before telling me to become Muslim ! This is the main reason why we gather Jamaats to remind Muslims first, once we can come back to 100% deen then we can start looking at kufaar.
Tableegh is effective. I was a bad muslim. I spent 3 days few times. Thankfully now I know little about how to live an islamic life. What the sheikh is missing is understanding, how tableegh works jamat works. There are set rules so that their is uniformity and organization if there were no rules it would be chaotic. Sheikh is right when saying that we are not allowed to invite kuffars, when we should. That is because when the ummah straightens themselves the rest will follow automatically. However we should invite the kuffars in our own capacity.
I think his point is that it’s an innovation… you can’t add additional rules as part of the religion.
So if the the guccie shoes he wears 😂 show me where in the Quran it says you can't give Dawah as a group
Tableeghi Jamat is Allah's Rehmat
Tableegh Jamaat are doing very good work. We have to give dawah to muslims and non muslims but the reason why they focus more on muslims is because some of them are not very kmowledgeble and all their doing is reminding ppl going to the mosque. In this day and age with muslims leaving Islam or becoming athiest, it is very good to focus on muslims
This is the only group where you can learn the basics of deen.
problem is with some individuals who are in jmaat who are raised to a higher status that they make business out of it. even if they commit major sins like assualt of minors ppl dont believe that they did. many such ppl have benefitted by asking donations to the masjid and building madarsas that they used the business as their own. how can one ask donations to the masjid that is built on riba or build.a school from ppl's money and then become the sole owners. you dont own it. its not your money.
many gangsters were rehabilitated by nation of Islam. does that make them correct in everything they do?
Tabligh work is the way of reforming full communities as it works from the foundation level it has helped the Muslims of all communities that have migrated for work to Europe. We would all have lost our deen if it wasn’t for tabligh. It has opened our eyes to the value Amal’s acquiring religious knowledge and guiding our children regarding there deen plz don’t forget your hidayat came from tabligh as you have mentioned your self.
Assalaam Alaykum. With all due respect. I would like to add few points on the issue.
The Tableeghi jamat have done and continue to do so amazing work in calling people to the masjid.
Many people have been blessed for repentance and achieve a change of heart because of their dedication and sacrifice. Allah bless them.
If they have taken the task of focusing on muslims, then me and you can fill in to cover what they have missed. After we all complete each other.
If someone teaches science we can not criticize him for neglecting other subjects. Someone else can teach English while another one can take upon himself to do something else to compete the work.
It is harsh to look down upon one another.
May Allah accept their efforts and dedication and sacrifice and guide them to correct their mistakes
It's sad to see someone who claims to have spent time with jama'at tabligh and then think they dont give dawah to none Muslim is totally upsetting, the number of people who changed their lives because of brothers going out in the cold, rain, hot weather and sacrificing their lives so that people cam reconnect with the creator. May Allah swt protect all the muslims from harms Ameen
Tablighi Jamaat is doing fantastic work, bringing back Muslims to the correct path, who have unfortunately lost their way. DON'T condem the Tablighi Jamaat, if Shaykh Uthman has his way of propogating , continue , leave the Tablighi Jamaat to do what they are doing.
Whats the problem if they have a tarteeb? 3 days is fine. And if you go to maraakiz now, especially in the west, they have gone with the times and make tarteeb and assist with those who cannot do full 40 days or 4 months. I myself have only been 5 days or 10 days and even just a weekend without any animksity from anyone
Every institution has their own syllabus, rules and they make it mandatory to follow it for good results. Likewise Tablighi Jamat is an institution they have their set of rules extracted from religion only and with Tajurba. And they have their framework also and they focused on the Muslim who are away from Deen.
Now you can disagree with them, but you can't blaim them.
All your talk is just around this topic only.
And many scholars have given the answers to the questions you raised here. Either you didn't read/listened those. Or after getting clarification also you are raising the old questions and deviating people from this noble cause.
I know you are doing Dawah great work. But they are also doing Tableegh in more Munazzam way, so you should respect them and their Usools.
Don't try to cut people from the Khair they are doing.
Jazak Allahu Khairan
Don't underestimate the value of the hard work and foundation laid down
Tableegh Jam'at's main purpose is to make sure, their muslim brothers who live in villages, rural areas where people are muslim but don't know kalma, don't know how to offer namaz. Basic thing of eating with right hand and tableegh jamat make sure they spoon feed deen. Its not if they are reading authentic hadiths, its about making sure they are providing basic islamic knowledge to first make them muslim.
he is telling the truth.
Criticism is the easiest thing in the world,
And moreover many agents are being sent,paid, trained from London,Paris and US centers to disrupt and divide the Ummat as Bhai Ameen (Ameer of Karachi, trainee of Maulana Illyaas) used to say and tell facts
Fazail-e-A’mal
A brief introduction:
This kithab was compiled by Hazrath Shaikh Zakariya (Rahimahullah). It consists of Aayaats of the Quran, Ahadith, stories of the Sahabah and stories of the pious predecessors that explain the virtues of good deeds. The object of the book is to encourage the Muslims on doing good deeds, and not to explain any ruling of Shari’ah. Shaikh Zakariya (Rahimahullah) was not the first to write a kithab of this manner, but the likes of this kithab have been written by the authors of the past, like Kithab-u-Zuhd by Abdullah bin Mubarak (Rahimahullah), Fadhaiulul Quran by Imam Shafi’ (Rahimahullah), Al Adabul Mufrad by Imam Bukhari (Rahimahullah), Al Targheeb Wal Tarheeb by Ibnul Qayyim Munziri (Rahimahullah), etc.
The role of Fazail-e-A’mal in Tableegh Jama’at
It is a total misconception that Fazail-e-A’mal is the guide book of Tableegh Jama’at. This book only consists of the virtues of good deeds. The concept of Tableegh Jama’at was not derived from this book, nor is the jama’at dependant on this book to do the work of tableegh. They thought it necessary to stipulate such a book that would encourage people towards good deeds, and this book served the purpose; therefore, the people who join this work are advised to stipulate a specific time for the reading of this book. However, it is not compulsory upon each an every person who joins this effort to read this book. Many of the Arabs who are doing this effort chose to read Riyadu-s-Saliheen instead, and they are allowed to carry on with this work. Similarly, Riyadu-s-Saliheen is also read in many of the masjids in Colombo on certain days of the week. Therefore, it is totally incorrect to regard this book as the guide book of Tableegh Jama’at.
Some objections made against Fazail-e-A’mal:
A common comment made against Fazail-e-A’mal is that some of the narrations mentioned in it are weak and fabricated. This comment is not totally correct, as there are no fabricated narrations in this book. There are dha’eef (weak) narrations in Fazail-e-A’mal. However, it is important to point out that the word dha’eef, literally translated as ‘weak’, is a terminology and should not be understood in its general sense. Its application is based on the rules explained in the sciences of hadith. Moreover, weak narrations are not acceptable only in regards to aqeedah and the rulings of Islamic jurisprudence. Majority of the scholars have accepted weak narrations as far as virtues of good deeds are concerned. Even Imam Bukhari (Rahimahullah) has brought weak narrations in his book, Al Adabul Mufrad, which shows that he also accepts weak narrations in regards to virtues of good deeds.
Some scholars claim that there are such narrations in Fazail-e-A’mal, especially in Fazail-e-Durood, that prove that the author had beliefs of shirk and believed in the Omnipresence of Nabi (Sallallahu Alaihi Wasallam). These are false allegations made against the author, who was one of the most prominent scholars of the Ahlus Sunnah wal Jama’ah.
Firstly, such allegations are made mostly by Arab scholars, who are unaware of the difference between the Deobandis and the Barelwis. They regard both these groups to be one, as both of them are from , and attribute the beliefs of Barelwis to the Deobandis. It is some of the Barelwis who believe in grave-worshipping and the Omnipresence of Nabi (Sallallahu Alaihi Wasallam), and these beliefs have been attributed to the Deobandis. Some of these Arab scholars, like Shaikh Ibn Uthaymeen (Rahimahullah), retracted from what they said after the actual situation was explained to them.
Secondly, the author has mentioned references for each and every narration or incident he has mentioned. Therefore, any comments regarding these narrations or incidents should be attributed to the author of the reference provided, as Shaikh Zakariya (Rahimahullah) has absolved himself by giving the reference.
Thirdly, most of the incidents mentioned in Fazail-e-Durood are of pious predecessors. It is incorrect to say that these are fabricated Ahadith, as the word Hadith is used for the sayings of Nabi (Sallallahu Alaihi Wasallam). It is also incorrect to confirm the beliefs of the author through these incidents, as the object of the author was only to emphasise on the virtues of durood mentioned in them.
Moreover, most of the incidents mentioned are dreams, and no rulings of Shari’ah can be derived from dreams. It is farfetched to confirm someone’s faith from a dream, of another person, mentioned in his kithab.
It is incorrect to compare the Shias, Qadiani, etc. with Tableegh Jama’at as we have clarified above that Tableegh Jama’at is not based on the narrations of Fazail-e-A’mal; and none of the narrations of Fazail-e-A’mal are fabricated.
To end thereof, one should not be misguided with all the false accusations on this jama’at, but rather look at how the Ummah has benefited through this jama’at. We should always supplicate to Allah Ta’ala to show us the right path and save us from the misguidance of Shaitan. Moreover, we should always bear in mind that the pious and the learned amongst the Ummah cannot be unanimous upon something that is false or not part of Islam, as Nabi (Sallallahu Alaihi Wasallam) has mentioned:
إن الله لا يجمع أمتي أو قال أمة محمد صلى الله عليه وسلم على ضلالة ويد الله مع الجماعة ومن شذ شذ إلى النار
Allah Ta’ala will not unite the Ummah of Muhammed (Sallallahu Alaihi Wasallam) upon misguidance. Allah’s help is with majority. Whoever deviates from them will be thrown into the fire of Jahannum.
Sunan Al Tirmizi Vol.2 Pg.39 (H.M. Sa’eed Company)
A thought provoking act
How will one account for the many thousands of people all around the world, Arabs and non-Arabs, and of all works of life, be they great Ulama, Muftis, intellectuals or professionals, to be associated with this noble work. They all cannot be wrong. They must have encountered something positive in this work for them to be part of it. The solution is, come within and see for yourself.
@@TheDuaStudio very well said my brother
Jazak Allah khair
@mdjaffer3286 Aameen wa iyyak, my brother.
They helped my nephew leave life of sin and since then i respect them.the should keep up the good work and others who want to do dawah to the non muslims can also do that route peacefully
Dawah includes enjoining good and forbidding evil
@Halal_Dan which is exactly what they are doing.Allahu Aalam
Most of the Islamic Scholars are not mature enough to digest the fact that the condition of the most of the Present day muslims is no less than Quraish e Mecca.
: Dawah was- Qulu lailaha illallah , tuflihu
Untill Muslims gets strong enough , United and disciplined.
Then Dawah was : Aslimu, Taslimu. for the whole world.
Same process is being implented by our elders.
Imam Shafi'i emphasized that the correction or reformation of the Ummah (the global Muslim community) can only be achieved by returning to the same methods and principles that were applied during the time of the Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him)
Wandering answer. rather giving answer, he is more confusing .
Just like if you can't convince audience; confuse them.
I understand the Shaykh's question regarding the periods of 3 days,40 days etc,however i dont see why it should be problamatic.
Firstly these periods are recommended and encouraged,
but not enforced by the elders,certain individuals may try and impose this on others,but thats on them.
However in the same vein we can question the fact that, where is the period of 6 or 7 years of studying in an institution and using certain Hadith books etc to become a Shaykh derived from.
This form of becoming a Shaykh or Aalim was not present in the time of NABI s.a.w. yet no one questions this and is accepted by all.
Similarly does the Shaykh question why a child needs to spend 1 year in each grade up to grade 12,before entertaining university etc.
Or does he question the number of years it takes to qualify as a doctor,lawyer accountent etc.
These periods are all determined by so called "experts" in these fields.
So similar is the case in "tabligh".It must also be bourne in mind that "tabligh" started with the objective of bringing muslims who were astray back to tauheed and sunnah.
I also agree that dawah is for the non muslims and a reminder is for the momin.I also agree that every muslim should invite non muslims to islam,however for non muslims to come into islam in huge numbers we will need all muslims to dedicate daily time to our masjids to teach islam to these reverts.
To this end we need to train people to spend more time in the masjid so these periods of 3 days,40 days etc are merely training periods to prepare us to ultimately sacrifice our lives for deen.
The effort of "tabligh" is to remind and reconnect muslims to ALLAH,to love ALLAH and our Noble Master SAW and his illustrious companions.
Once this reconnection is made,a person can choose any other effort to continue on his journey of preparing for his aakhirah.
A person may choose to study to be a Shaykh,do hifz,etc.
Every individual is not suited or able to do everything,
fortunately ,
ALLAH has blessed this ummah with numerous different efforts to gain proximity to him and benifit humanity.
Reply: Tabligh is not a Jamaat
It's an effort.
2. Fazail e aamaal was written with the aim of a book for Tabligh effort. So we stick to that.
🔍 ARE THERE MAWDHU (FABRICATED) HADITH IN FADHAIL AMAL?
📚 THE HADITH IN QUESTION:
• Found on page 142 of Fadhail Amaal - Virtues of Dhikr (Hadith #28)
• Tells of Prophet Adam (AS) seeking forgiveness after seeing Prophet Muhammad's ﷺ name on the 'Arsh'
🤔 THE FALSE CLAIM:
• Pseudo-Salafis claim Maulana Zakariyya wrote "MAWDU" next to it
• They point to its source: Imam Suyuti's "Dhayl al-Lalai al-Masnu'ah fi al-Ahadith al-Mawdu'ah" (Tails of made up pearls in fabricated hadiths). They say this is a collection of Farbicated Hadith by Imam Suyuti 🤦♂🤦♂🤦♂
• They wrongly conclude it's fabricated and Maulana Zakariyya loves to use fabricated Hadtih
📖 THE TRUTH:
• For Allah's sake, please read the Arabic notes properly!! Don't just listen to the Pseudo Salafi parrots!
• As for the "MAWDU" word written by Maulana Zakariyya, what he actually said was: 'Mulla Ali-Qari said even though he believes it is fabricated, its meaning is authentic!"
• The source of Maulana Zakariyya's Hadith is from al-Tabarani, al-Hakim, Abu Nu'aim and al-Bayhaqi, not from Imam Suyuti's "Dhayl al-Lalai al-Masnu'ah fi al-Ahadith al-Mawdu'ah"
• Al-Hakim himself in Mustadrak Hakim says that the Hadith is Sahih. Even though some scholars disagree with him, there are Sahih Hadith that supports the meaning of the Hadith as mentioned by Mulla Ali Qari.
• As for Imam Suyuti, one of the purpose of his book "Dhayl al-Lalai al-Masnu'ah fi al-Ahadith al-Mawdu'ah" is to PROOF why some hadiths are NOT fabricated including the one mentioned by Maulana Zakariyya.
👨🏫 LETS NOT FORGET THE STATUS OF MAULANA ZAKARIYA
• Respected Sheikhul Hadith (Professor of Hadith)
• Taught Sahih al-Bukhari for many years
• Devoted his life to hadith sciences
• Authored major works:
- Badhl al-Majhud (Abu Dawud commentary)
- Al-Hall al-Mufhim (Muslim commentary)
- Al-La'ali al-Dirari (Bukhari commentary)
- Awjaz al-Masalik (20+ volume Muwatta commentary)
- Khasa'il al-Nabawi (Commentary on Shama'il of Tirmidhi)
- Numerous other works in Urdu
✅✅✅ CONCLUSION: There are NO fabricated Hadiths in Fadhail Amal.
#HadithScholars #IslamicKnowledge #FadhailAmal #TablighiJamaat
[Full Translation of Sheikh Zakariyya's Arabic Notes]
"Narrated by al-Tabarani and al-Hakim and Abu Nu'aim and al-Bayhaqi, both in the Dala'il, and Ibn Asakir in al-Durr, and in Majma' al-Zawa'id. Tabarani narrated it in al-Awsat and al-Saghir, and in it are those whom I do not know. I say that the end of the famous hadith supports it: 'I would not have created the heavens if it were not for you.' Al-Qari said in Al-Mawdu'at Al-Kabir that it is fabricated, but its meaning is authentic, and in Al-Tasharruf its meaning is established. The first is supported by what is reported in other narrations that it is written on the Throne and the leaves of Paradise: 'There is no god but Allah, Muhammad is the Messenger of Allah,' as Al-Suyuti elaborated on its chains in Manaqib Al-La'ali in several places, and he also elaborated on its supporting evidence in his tafsir in Surah Alam Nashrah."
Assalamualaikum I invite everyone to listen islamic speech from the heart ❤️ India 🇮🇳❤️😊😅😂😅
Sheik Uthman. Keep up the good work of spreading authentic islam, not cultural islam. All the negativity on the comments seems to be( allah know best) from Tabligh circles..... here in canada, the Tablighs are talking with no authentic sources? They have cause more harm than good by spreading wrong jinn up stories... for all those who say you're lying? They need to question their faith. Keep up the good work by spreading authentic sources.
Unity is key in Islam. Allah says, "Hold firmly to the rope of Allah and do not divide" (Qur'an 3:103). The Prophet ﷺ warned against division, saying, "Be brothers in faith" (Muslim). Respect the 4 Imams and Salaf as they aimed for the same goal: following Qur'an and Sunnah. No one gets a "paradise certificate" for their label-it’s Allah's mercy we rely on. Let’s focus on commonalities, not debates, and show the world Islam’s beauty through unity.
Shaykh Uthman is my favourite and Masha’Allah I have learned a lot from him and he will be my favourite in sha allah. But this is the first time I felt few things were not right in this video, and I just want to let that out to lighten my heart.
1. The caption of this video is very misleading & I would request the admin to please change it to something without fitna.
2. I’m sure they emphasise on 3 days, 40 days or 4 months for discipline and commitment but it’s not mandatory obviously.
3. Giving Dawah in India is not easy or quite impossible even unlike the west counties, so I’m guessing trying to make Muslims practising is the next good option. (there are few who still gives dawah but yes it’s quite less within the country for the known reason)
4. I agree with the book what shaykh has mentioned, it made sense to me and as many have mentioned I think they have changed it in few places, but I will surely check this in my hometown and convey this message there. Thank you.
4. I didn’t like the tone when the Shaykh used for Jamaath, I always thought it just meant like a team and nothing else, like I see Shaykh go with his team for Dawah I’m still thinking it’s the same thing
I’m genuinely confused right now.
It would be great of you Shaykh to release a video with proper understandings, it would be really appreciated.
Thank You
Why is this bloke using a derogatory accent when he is talking about the tablighis.
Have some respect for the sheikh
@@AsifIqbal-kz8ltthis alleged TH-cam internet “sheikh” should practice according to the sunnah and have respect in his speech.
@@ofdd1031respect, brother
This shakya is a a shark
Because Tablighis act like mangethars in many instances.
We all claim that we love Prophet Muhammad (pbuh) but we always get in trap and start finger pointing to each other start finding faults. Instead as a genuine believer we should come together, help to improve each other and emerge as a one strong Ummah who is united for the sake of Allah (swt) and Prophet Muhammad (saw). We have enough enemies out there, let's not get in fued among ourselves.
Her belongs to the MADKHALI school of thought brothers and sisters, So please be careful when you listen to him.
Having explored Uthman Pathan a bit more, it appears that he swings in all directions. Perhaps the drastic change in his life has something to do with it.
Tableeghi Jamaat Compelled me to listen to Sheikhs like yourself and they also convinced me to sit in the gatherings of people like yourself to increase my level of Imaan, and the Sheikh is saying otherwise
i’d say it is a kind of course, for 3, 10, 40 or 120 days, which makes you really firm on islam. once youre done you can come back and start working in your areas and to do think about your muslim brothers who don’t pray and to bring then back to salah! this is not bad thing and with due respect shaikh uthman spent 4 months and then decided to do aalim course then not before that… so yes there are weak narations and shall be avoided and now many ulemah in tableegue ask people that please don’t use then in your daily dawah… tableegi jamat is the jamat dedicated to do work of islam in all capacities and whenever they get a chance to talk to non muslims they chat and invite and many people are converting as well. Saikh uthman is doing great work in his capacity and in his vision, tableegue are following the guide set by ulemah..both are doing great and may Allah protect them
We should know and let others know that Maulana Zakaria was not an ordinary scholar or Alim , he was teacher and Ustad of all Ulema of Pakistan and India and Bangladesh,he used to give Dars in front of the Roza of Rasullulah and Arab scholars and Ulema used to listen and totally agree
Now that more than 40 yrs have passed from his passing some people criticize him and his works as Fazail e Amal, and Sadaqat
We should remember that he has a very high ranking with Allah as he was one of the Wali of our era
His is misrepresenting facts.
Care to share your version of facts
@@talhamurs3279you don’t understand the importance of tableeghi jamat in Indian subcontinent. Many Muslim families don’t even know the shahada are now on deen due to their efforts.
I know it’s easy to sit in front of a camera and talk ill of them. You can not imagine the hard work it takes to go to villages and spread deen to muslims who don’t even know how to pray.
Assalamu Alaikum wa rahmatullaah
It’s a matter of grave concern and pain that Hazrat has spent 4 months, 40 days, and 3 days in the path of Allaah with Tablighi Jamaat and has failed to understand the purpose and usool of this work. A man who spends 3 days with ikhlaas, Allaah SWT makes him understand this work and purpose of it. May Allaah grant hidayah to all of us!
Secondly, Maulana Iliyas ra said if he was to give a name to this mission, he would call it Tahreeke Imaan. This is people who popularized this work as Tablighi Jamaat. Hazrat hasn’t known this even after spending so much of time. Whoever is attached to this mission is attached with an intent of his own islaah and tarbiyah.
Hazrat is not expanding his mental horizon (the basirah) and understanding the benefits of this work - Alhamdulillaah millions of people have benefited hugely by this mission and have turned their life towards Allaah and Deen from Duniya and Dhalaalat. May Allaah grant taufeeq to understand this.
Who’s stopping hazrat to give dawa’h to others? Why is it mandatory that only a particular set of people do this? Let him go ahead and do that.
With respect to shaykh usman, he really needs to go markaz nizamuddin and see the things are updating now, we have Muntakhab ahadith in the nisaab now and workers are being encouraged to speak out of quran and sahih ahadith only.
You've been with the wrong tablighis . Ive seen some work in the UK giving dawah to non Muslims too
That's #1 point, he mentioned. Maybe they changed but Aqeedah, Quran & Sunnah is important
#2. They read the Fadhail Amaal book written by a scholar. They don't read Allah swt Quran and Hadith directly. Why so?
#3. They stay away from their own parents and families with tours and visits, when they are in need..
#4. They dont accept Hadith fully or understand.. like standing in prayer feet to feet, shoulder to shoulder..
Don't they follow 4 imams?..
Allah swt knows best..
The very bad thing about the tablig jammat is the persons holding positions lie invariably!😮😮
For readers, please find out the the elders of Tableegh didn't name it a Jamaat of Tableegh. People gave it this name. Also, Tableegh elders doesn't talk about not giving dawah to non-Muslims ( I studied Tableegh and all other Organizations in great depth). but Yes Sheikh is right, some people spread these rumors but not found in Tableegh Curriculum. Tableegh is mainly for Non-Mulsims and for Muslims, it is a reminder to protect yourself and your family from Hellfire.
He is right
He actually said there's no such thing as "making jamats" and said there's "no such thing as salat jamat" lol.
Why is this guy in fancy dress? He's an American Pathan dressed as an Arab from the Gulf.
Most of the self righteous are clowns in sheik s clothing 😮
I love tabligh jamaat only for Allah ❤
May Allah reward the Sheikh.
It is important to know that all the tertib used by the so named jam'a (because they are named by the public because of the work they engage in and not by their Ulama),undergo a lot of reviews over years.
Just like the field of ilm, Tabligh also used a lot of methodology which works over years, hence we have no problem with them .
Degree program in Islamic studies in university of Madina, is for certain years (based on their tertib), can I decide to graduate after a year with a degree even if I have finished all the curriculum on my own??
Obviously no,why can't we criticize the university for holding me for several years??
Likewise, the Daawah Tabligh jam'a (as so named), is Daawah of IMAN and not basically Daawah of ISLAM,
Their daawah is to reform Muslims on how to become mumin(which is more difficult) than making daawah to non Muslim.
In becoming mumin all the Daawah is towards the whole of Quran (how Muslim apply every verse of Quran into his life), however daawah to Islam is encouraging the non Muslim just on 5 pillars, which is more difficult.
To me the jam'a despite some shortcomings (due to human weakness), have more good than bad.
May Allah continue to assist them and accept us too, to the blessed efforts Ameen.
Well i had answer to all question of shykh inshaallah i will make a video on it soon
Sheikh Jihany ex footballer.
He has been in effort of Tabligh for many years.
Given Dawah to thousands of non muslims. Many have reverted.
Some things I can agree with what he says. But i think it comes down to the individual people that are fixated.
Well with anything, there is a point to understand the historical/ social context of the development of groups/organisations, what purpose they served in society at the time that they came about...
Maybe times today are changing and approaches may need to be evolved (?) ...
I have a question why use fabricate Hadith for aqeedah brother usman told Daniel at the aim conference that shiekh bin baaz, Albani, Usaymeen, and shiekh Fowzan are united on aqeedah and challenged deoabdis for a debate but when all Islam refuted him he changed his tactics oh I want to unite the ummah but you said you can’t unite with deoabdis because they are not United on Aqeeda using stupid arguments of Wahdatul wajud saying this is deoabdis aqeedah where in fact they use it for the science of Tasawuff not aqeedah.
Then you said I don’t belong to a Jamat that Tablighs also will say oh come due dawa to non-Muslims but will stop you saying it goes against there usul okay that’s fair but you also don’t let brothers do dawa like Daniel who said let’s unite thinking your a Athari but you proved that your a wahhabi defending abu zaid when he made Daniel do the Wahhabi shahada adding I will obey the ruler after the shahada imam Ahamd would never say obey holloween Saudia Arabia land of Saran to do dawa against feminism, liberalism but you said you can’t unite with people who’s aqeedah mentioning Taqi Usmani aqeedah is that people are alive in the grave that you can shake hands with
@@MasoodKhan-so9hv These so called Ulama were educated with Zionist Petrodollars
Shame on you... What is this title Exposing? What do u even mean why exposing.. What is tableegi jamah doing? Preaching Jewish or Christianity? Wallahi this is so so disappointing.. Muslim criticising another muslim...
Even Hindus are not preaching Christianity, so may be Hindus are right, isn't it?
@The_Musalman this isnt is about hindu muslim, its about muslims.. Ur comment was lame...
It is Tableegh Jamat due to which people are encouraged to send their children for hifz, Aalim and Mufti. It is teh only Jamat which pours energy in all the pillars of Islam. People are encouraged to make their iman strong, pray their salaah on time, give full zakat, do Hajj, and fast on Ramazan. Apart from thsi important pillars, it helps to build strong brotherhood amomg muslims and teaches moral and modesty among Muslim and muslimah. Every Jamat and individual are doing their work towards spreading Islam. Whats the point of reverting non-muslim and increase population of non-practising muslim. When theres a chance, the dawah is also given to non-Muslim in Tableegh Jamat. Many closed masajid were opened by this Jamaat. Many murtad muslim came back to deen because of this Jamat.
Tablligh is a blessing. People who dont spend time will not understand the spiritual fruits you gain.its a khalwa. Spiritual opportunities happen on tabligh if you spend your time in the corect manner
I m from india Delhi where is the headquater of tabligh jamat and i live in Bhopal as well from my childhood and tabligh jamat is dominating position over thier and trust me this shiekh said it right tabligh people never give dawah to non muslims they always go to sunni muslims bcoz they never call themselves sunni they said what they r tabhligi and praise abdul wahab najdi all the time . This jamat have less to do with deen but more to do with mazhub they r more focus to convert sunnis into thier sect specially barelvi sect
We need Muslims to give Dawat to everyone
Tabligh is a message of love,unity and discipline and to remove the ignorance from the masses esp Muslims
How dacoits, drunkards, prostitutes ,adultares (Zina ) , actors, actresses, players, musiciand have repented and done Tobah and changed
May Allah preserve this shaykh
Ameenmmm
Longlive TABLEEGHI JAMAAT
the guy who asked the question, the scholar who's answering and myself, have apparently only acquainted similar folks from Tablighi Jamaat than those who are commenting in this thread. When we do face the people these people are defending, may be we too will agree with them.
Time and time again, I gave many chances to sit and listen to the many groups who visit our masjid as part of their 'Jamat' and they preach the same.. 'you can pray, fast, pay zakat and do haj, but if you don't go for jamat, you're doomed' I often wondered if there's even a new hadith they found supporting their claims because of how confidently they're preaching these stuff.
It's also hilarious how they have ranks among themselves while the supposed 'amirs' can't even recite Fatihah with proper tajweed. don't get me wrong, even my uncle goes on these jamat and he's a learned man, yet humble. But most of the people I met as part of this group are pretentious nobodies.
Now I just don't even bother and walk away if I face these groups.
Point is he is saying that Tablighi jamaat prohibit giving dawah to non Muslims
If you make somebody muslim, and you're ready to take care of their needs, then give dawah to non Muslims. But if you can't take care of their needs, don't even try, because so many reverts have left islam after accepting Islam. If you don't believe me, check the statistics.
We are some times hard on one another.
If one group focus on giving dawa to Muslims then alhamdulillah others like brother Othman Farooq fill in on focusing on dawah to non Muslims.
If you teach math I shouldn’t criticize you for neglecting Arabic, I should do something else to fill in and at the end of the we call complete one another.
Even in soccer or other sports each one takes a specific tsk and this is how we build a strong team.
Please let us support one another. Let us complement each others efforts. Let us give support to each other instead of being harsh, speaking ill and dismiss each others
When you have read it... The sheikh doesn't hide that either but he continues its explanation.... But yes I agree that for today's age riyazu assaliheen is a better book
Tabligh is actually what shaykh has mentioned... The only point regarding fazail e amaal, so we now have muntakhab hadees. So it's time to come together.
Giving dawah to kuffar is also not prohibited, it's just that one must have the depth of knowledge and skills to give daawah.
There is nothing wrong with following a system
Its a shame we muslims are concentrating on these small issues. Why should we malign others when we are on the same aqeedah and path. These minor differences we oeave to Allah to judge. Taking oneself as holier than thou is not right. We shpuld be concentratong on the enemies of islam like the zionists.
I have a question... How can i reached to him
Don't add to religion. That is the whole point, people are missing.