Can Sanctions Deter Russia From Invading Ukraine?
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 13 มิ.ย. 2024
- Economic sanctions remain one of the most powerful tools the United States has in its foreign policy arsenal. And as Russian forces continue to amass along the border with Ukraine, officials in the U.S. hope the threat of those sanctions can deter a full-scale invasion.
Besides sanctions that target individuals or specific companies, some proposals involve cutting Russia off from the SWIFT system, which would remove Russian institutions from an important global financial network.
Another target is the near-completed Nord Stream 2 gas pipeline, which when operational would double the amount of natural gas moved from Russia to Germany through the Baltic Sea and likely reduce the need for other pipelines, such as the Urengoy-Pomary-Uzhhorod pipeline that runs through Ukraine.
Republican Sen. Ted Cruz of Texas has proposed a bill that would require automatic sanctions against Nord Stream 2 operators within two weeks of Russia invading Ukraine. The bill failed to pass on Thursday, but picked up a handful of Democratic votes in the final tally.
Democratic Sens. Robert Menendez, of New Jersey, and Jeanne Shaheen, of New Hampshire, proposed an alternative bill that would “impose crippling sanctions on the Russian banking sector and senior military and government officials if President [Vladimir] Putin escalates hostile action in or against Ukraine.”
Watch the video above to find out how U.S. sanctions work, whether the U.S. can persuade allies to cut off Russia from the important SWIFT financial network, and what’s next in the foreign policy standoff between the West and Russia.
» Subscribe to CNBC: cnb.cx/SubscribeCNBC
» Subscribe to CNBC TV: cnb.cx/SubscribeCNBCtelevision
» Subscribe to CNBC Classic: cnb.cx/SubscribeCNBCclassic
About CNBC: From 'Wall Street' to 'Main Street' to award winning original documentaries and Reality TV series, CNBC has you covered. Experience special sneak peeks of your favorite shows, exclusive video and more.
Connect with CNBC News Online
Get the latest news: www.cnbc.com/
Follow CNBC on LinkedIn: cnb.cx/LinkedInCNBC
Follow CNBC News on Facebook: cnb.cx/LikeCNBC
Follow CNBC News on Twitter: cnb.cx/FollowCNBC
Follow CNBC News on Instagram: cnb.cx/InstagramCNBC
#CNBC
Can Sanctions Deter Russia From Invading Ukraine?
![Yoshi Rinrada - 'มาทำไม' [Official MV]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/r41xbfRLkLs/mqdefault.jpg)
US/NATO: you will pay a great price for invading Ukraine!
Russia: so you sell it? deal!
Russia don't have to invade or intervene in Ukraine, let it fall. Ukraine is help by western powers on both financially, and military aid
pay with russian lives
@@lilBabyBornInCalifornia I disagree. Ukraine is having problems financially, back by same countries whom also facing the same problems. at the other hand, Russia don't want to intervene in Ukraine as long as NATO military bases aren't there. Russia don't like to be surrounded by NATO military bases
@@basook6116 thats all a lie, russia annexed crimea in 2014 without any valid reason other than selfish greed... russia will use a false flag attack to invade ukraine and weak sleepy joe will let them take it.
@@lilBabyBornInCalifornia russia did annexed crimea to deter the NATO. But, Russia never invaded Ukraine. yes, sometime, Russian troops were there to protect 'Pro-Russians.' western media really took off with this story. ironic thing, western media never reported any transaction between IMF and Russia, when Ukraine owes Russia for its energy bill. western media never reported any action by Ukraine forces without NATO's back up..
As you know, Russia is big with half the population of US. they don't need to take Ukraine, what Russia really wants is security treaty from NATO. if you look at map of the middle east, US/NATO military bases everywhere. Putin don't want this
The answer is no!
Putin himself said they have been sanctioned for decades. Due to this they have learned to be independent. Because of this, he laughed at the idea of heavier sanctions several years ago. If by any chance they needed something, I'm sure their allies China would help out anyway.
Neither of you have any idea what you’re talking about. But that’s the power of American “News” at work. One nation controlled by the media. Completely misinformed; just like they want you to be.
Russia has as much right to invade Ukraine as the U.S had to invade Korea, Vietnam, little Grenada, Iraq, Afghanistan etc. Get your war on Russia. Just don't send any nukes.
@Tbone lol you clowns have been saying this for decades and still find a way to blame Russia for every problem you have in the world. It’s funny really.
Russia is a declining super power on its way out, while simultaneously causing all the worlds problems. Lmao.
Sounds like America is the declining power to me. Can’t get its way anymore and is now resorting to sanctioning Allie’s! Lololol.
This isn't entirely true. The nature of sanctions Russia will face if they invade Ukraine will be unprecedented and unlike any sanctions they've faced in the past
Sanctions effect Americans more than russians. We have lawns and supermarkets.
Russians have gardens and grow their food.
When was the last time sanctions ever worked on deterring aggression? It’s the Neville Chamberlain approach to appeasement.
agression is not a constant variable. what is constant are the sanctions. no money is coming in. which is why north korea is a major hacker of financial institutions. those sanctions you believe don't work; are exactly the way they're supposed to work. which is why like i said; north korea's only option of making money now is to resort to stealing of money through technical means from other financial institutions.
There is no Russian aggression anyway. It's a myth created by Hilary Clinton and the liberal Democrats and the fascist government in Kiev
@@ChickenMcThiccken let me sum this up here. Sanctions work because when we put very heavy sanctions on North Korea instead of earning money through trade and commerce the state now makes their money through cyber crime....or in other words the sanctions didn't work because they just found a different way to fund things, and the people of the country suffer. So great
@@Snuffalaffagas North Korea was never a player anyway. It was artificially created by China which was heavily supported by USSR Army at the time. NK is still controlled and supplied by China, and Russia. Sanctions only align NK better with CCP will, changing nothing. Do you really believe in NK hackers?
@@meganreed4619
Here's the sarcasm
And waaay down here is you watching it go right over your head
December 19 2014, 44 imposed sanctions on Russia for illegally invading the Ukraine and annexing the Crimea. January 16, 2022, Russia is still in the Crimea.
The soldiers in those tanks don't look like "economic sanctions" will deter them.
People living in Crimea voted for joining Russia. Does democracy have double standards?
@@dementor8625 Democracy has stadards, thankfully ! The vote results and even the referendum were not recpgnized by any internationnal institution.
If my neighbour and I decide that we want our entire region to leave the country and are the only 2 voters, the result will be 100% wants to live but it will be a farce of a democracy, just like the one that happened in Crimea, do the vote again with UN observers (and no Russian soldier / mercenaries) and the result would probably be very different...
@@dementor8625 Democracy has double standards, when it suits NATO and not Russia, in fact Crimea is doing better under Russia than Ukraine. Crimea did the right thing and the UN refused to acknowledge the fact that the people voted in favor of joining the Russian Federation, so much so that Russia invited the UN council to see for themselves and they refused and rejected the invitation so what is NATO and the UN crying about. Another example is the Catalan region and its urge to become independent, the Spanish government rushed into the voting offices and destroyed the voting booths that's the democracy under NATO and its double standards.
@@zn74 emmm... Budapest memorandum? Anyone?
North Korea on sanctions: "We eat sanctions for breakfast."
Russia: "Lol"🤭
North Korea has breakfast? Never knew
Wait North Korea has food?
Basically any communist country who has ties with China. China has this thing, they can do everything by lower prices by paying lesser to the workers, and if they die or resign they will just hire some others since there's always lack of jobs and tons of people if you live in the eastern part of China.
@@chandelier6811 they don't have McDonald's..
If sanctions worked Iran and North Korea would be democracies by now.
Sanctions is not a powerful tool as many people believe it is. The whole purpose of sanctions is to punish the citizens of that country, creating chaos through economic warfare, which hopes leading up to a civil unrest and a war so US can move in with their military. Sanctions can target individuals but can't hurt anyone powerful or rich in any country. NK is one of the poorest countries out there, has sanctions done anything to it at all? does NK really have any business with any countries that dislike them in the first place? If NK doesn't care about sanctions, why would Russia care at all.
NK has one of weakest economies on earth. Starvation frequently threatens and people are executed for leaving the country. Sanctions have utterly destroyed NK.
@@carlabroderick5508 as I have said, it only hurts the common people who has no real power in deciding where the country is headed.
You know, the USSR from it's existence 1918-1991 was under sanctions.
The USSR made use of a black market economy.
Look it up.
Sanctions doesn't stop a black market economy.
Sanction only hurt normal citizen... Business owners and their workers lost job, people starving or even famine occur. This is cruel tactic. See yemen, Venezuela and Iran..
People are well informed nowadays.People will only hate the country that imposes sanctions
Like Russia is worried about any type of actions from the U.S., we are literally a nonplayer currently. Besides the Afghanistan debacle shows that our administration is not worth taking seriously.
lets not forget that after trump surrendered to the Taliban Terrorists during February 2020 and then abandoned 20,000 of our Military behind Enemy Lines our mighty and powerful President, Joseph R. Biden, stormed Afghanistan and saved the Personal trump abandoned
God Blessed America
He sent Us Joseph R. Biden to right all the failures of failed conservatism
Since the end of WWII, our foreign policies have been disastrous. We can't win wars, we can't make peace, our influence is dying, our economic power is dying (we gave it all to our enemy China) and Trump is as much to blame as Biden.
@@4NickAder bwaaaa hahahaha you 2 party rubes would be laughable if you were not so delusional.
Georgia, Ingushetia, Ossetia, Chechnya, and Crimea.
@@4NickAder we didn’t withdrawal in February 2020. Put the crack pipe down. I swear people who still defend this administration have IQ’s a n like the 40’s.
No matter what's going on in Ukraine or Taiwan it is no justification for U.S. soldiers to be sent to die because politicians want to talk tough. Anyone who wants to vote for war should have to go themselves. Our sons and daughters were sent to IRAQ all based on lies and over 5000 were sent back in body bags.
I stand by this. I'm currently serving and I see that we're are just pawns in a old man's game.
Biden has ALREDY stated he will not send any US troops to the Ukraine if Russia decides to invade. Keep up.
Yep.
Well said. Why send other people's sons and daughters to die in a faraway land.
Tell usa to mind their own business and the whole world will be peace and quite no war no sanction
did sanctions ever deter anyone from anything?
I was gonna buy a 12 pack of beer, but sanctions made me by a case
Less money in their pocket. What do u buy when u r poor?
@@michaelboano7183 more beer
daniel collins humor is almost always a good thing. Bravo to u!
@@michaelboano7183 bless you Michael. Hope life is going good for you
so basically, our president just threatened Russia. That sounds like a really bad idea!
USA is more powerful than ussr in terms of economic strength, geography and quite comparable militarily. Putin will not be here in 25 years. In 25 years the USA will still be most or second most vibrant economy in the world and still capable of supporting our huge military. Russia has not invested in the technology of the future and thus will have a hard time trying to keep their economy from shrinking. The USA is a favorite destination for foreigners wanting to attend college. Many then stay here, eg Elon musk. No one is immigrating to Russia. Russia’s lack of long term economic growth will negatively affect their ability militarily. Happy and proud to be an American despite many of our elected officials who r quite self serving. USA is great despite them.
US to European nations:
We will sanction you for buying Russian gas. Now you have to buy our gas for a higher cost or be sanctioned. That’s how Allie’s work. Lmao
Yep we should be spending our tax dollars to guarantee your freedom. Want our dollars or rubbles instead?
If they sunction russian by swift banking system. Russian will be isolated in global transaction. All investor will go out of the country. Russian will be doom
Since when have sanctions ever worked as a deterrent? If anything, it usually make the intended recipient double down on their own stance
Because of trump/pence republicans, Russia won - trump sold out America.
*trump froze US military aid to Ukraine*
CRIMINAL DICTATOR trump/pence (putin’s bootlicker) conspired with our enemy Russia.
As usual, democrats will CONFRONT RUSSIA and FIX AMERICA.
@@alltogethernow121 I guess that's why Trump shipped weapons to Ukraine, unlike Obama, and the Russians waited for Biden to safely invade. Too much MSNBC can cause delusions.
@@dbergerac9632 We ALL know what the republican platform is:
More HATE, more LIES, more RACISM, more traitors, misogyny, greed, planning the destruction of the US Constitution, and allowing criminality without consequences.
And the very worst - denying HUMAN CAUSED climate change (Don’t Look Up)
LOCK trump up
*REMEMBER* republicans ALWAYS sound 'reasonable' BEFORE elections
- then it's back to HATE, RACISM, LIES, etc.
@@alltogethernow121 it was Biden who approved the Russian oil pipeline to Germany. A pipeline that military advisors warned would empower Russia with war funds for a potential power grab in the future against Ukraine by undercutting Ukraine’s own oil production.
And this is just after Biden killed Keystone XL, an almost completed Canada-US pipeline that would’ve not only given our country a vast amount of income, but also a quicker delivery of oil to fuel our national defense if needed. But Biden and his crooked Progressive backers killed the pipeline in the name of “environmentalism” when it was actually to boost the wealth of Democrat businessman Warren Buffet’s freight train lines.
Don't rely too much on the NORD stream to affect Russia. It would affect the EU more than Russia.
Russia’s main export is energy. If they cancel Nord and get cut off from Swift, how will they conduct business moron?
@@mlsmoothe8774 Ahmm. That is why Russia is in building spree on RUSSIA CHINA GAS PIPELINE. Haven't you known that CHINA is the largest market of energy. 🥴
They have optional revenues from mines, weapons, nuke n hydro power plant, infrastructures,, oli refineries, forex trading, space technology with BRICS, SE Asia, Mid-East, Africa ...
@@mlsmoothe8774 Nord stream 2 is not delivering gas right now. so sanctioning it would only mean that europe needs to look elsewhere für its increasing gas demand. that does not come cheap. So far, no one has explained to me how we (I'm from germany) are able to pay our gas bills, if russia is snctioned with swift. I doubt russia is willing to deliver gas for free.
@@dersimon perhaps if you’re government wasn’t hadn’t made the idiotic decision to close down all nuclear plants and revive the coal industry then you wouldn’t be facing this issue. I don’t think France will be concerned about gas when 85% of their energy comes from renewables and nuclear.
The story: russia and ukraine on the brink of a major military conflict
The music: 😊👍
What are they gonna do? send bunch of CTSO troops to patrol streets and leave again like they did in Kazakhstan?
@@MrPolandball I would wish, but those brain dead communists are still in the 1960's and they really love to suffer from starvation at all times, that's the reason they actually want to restore their wet dream of thesoviet union which is bs.
Quick, where is Hillary to derail Trump's '24 campaign with another wild tale of 'collusion'?
USA DESPERATELY WANTS THAT "CONFLICT" TO HAPPEN HUH? JUST WONDER WHY
@@felipearenasbarr 🤣😂Yeah... of course... "Brain dead" huh... Said the "south american"...😂😂😂😂😂
Ukraine: "We need military assistance against Russia"
US/Nato: "Don't worry we'll sanction them"
Ukraine: "Aw **** we gonna lose..." 😐
“People think Russia is less friendly so hopefully that would stop Putin” HAHAHA. Who’s this Senator?
What should really scare you is that democrat senator had a hand in Afghanistan withdraw and sits on the foreign affairs committee.
No, because sanctions don't deter anyone from doing anything. Sanctions are an economic form of terror bombing, and we discovered during WW2 that bombing a country to smithereens doesn't actually reduce the support of the ruling regime therein, rather it does the opposite and cements the hatred of the regular people against the aggressor.
Sanctions aren’t meant to reduce government support they’re meant to cripple economies.
It reduces government support in the long run maybe not in the short run cause it increases tensions making people feel attacked and nationalistic but in the long run lack of jobs lack of economic growth
and what Is usually a sign of protectionism in small countries and the laws preventing competition monopolies can pop-up because sanctions prevent certain types of trade meaning products made not be available or have to be produced domestically by domestic companies
@@reggie69. or not look at japan ww2 that trigger pearl harbor.
Huh? I don't know what WW2 you've seen the effects of but I'm more than sure Japan and Germany are completely different countries than they were in the late 30s
@@cc23001 sanctions to starve some regime can make then act like mad dog when cornered.
The real question is how all the "law makers" will make money off the situation?
How they will make money? Buy oil and gas stocks
Invade Russia
Easy Money for US politicans
"If they Win"
The real answer is: they created this situation among others to justify the gigantic transfer of taxpayers' money to the privately owned military industrial complex, and to move NATO closer to Russian borders, of course.
War is money and politicians make millions of dollars in profit ,that is the reason why I didn't join the U.S military.
You guys promised that Russia is to invade Ukraine at January 7th.
Then you promised it's gonna be January 12th.
It's still not there. What an awkward situation!
Just some perspective here, the US moving NATO into Ukraine would be like China moving military bases into Canada.
The thing is Ukraine wants the us there Canada doesn’t want China there
And before u bring up Cuba am sure the deal they made in the pass banded Cuba from ever having any foreign forces there
@@XxDAOGJAYYxX Ukraine is kind of split though. The west wants to be closer to the EU, the east is more sympathetic to being in the Russian sphere of influence. Regardless, in the hypothetical situation that the majority of Canada did want Chinese military bases, the US would feel threatened, which is the case Russia feels.
@@OleOlson You are exactly right.! NATO needs to back off. NATO cannot continue to expand around Russia. Think about it. Russia feels threatened with this expansion. This situation could explode at a moments notice between forces that have nukes!
@@XxDAOGJAYYxX and Russian wants its borders and country protected if started world war 3 means doing that so be it that’s what they will do
Russia has no reason to fear us with the administration we have. He laughs at Bidens weakness
Agree 1,000%
hate trump all they want.. but Russia, China and NK literally listened to Trump than Obama and Biden combined
@@rsombrero97 Indeed, funny how crazy tyrannical dictators get along so well with each other. Except Trump wasn't even that, he was just crazy.
@@cristi724 It takes a crazy person to stop another crazy
@@maybeasinner8007 Well Biden has blood running across his face and hands, from earlier this year. There's that.... How many civilians got killed in Af.?
Yeah that's not important....
@@cristi724 It's called projection of strength.
Germany has really been making stupid moves lately, turning anti nuclear and pro gas are so incredibly stupid it completely changed my opinion of Germany.
My country Sweden is doing the same, prices are through the roof
@@TheEnabledDisabled my country The Netherlands isn't doing the same, yet the prices are still through the roof
@@joostglas5631 Mainly about eletricity and fuel prices, hundreds of percent higher
Germany needs the Gas to manufacture cars to sell to China. Uncle Sam says no.
Arm chair politician, maybe you should become the leader of Germany and show them how it’s done.
The answer is no, sanctions will not deter Putin. Russia has many pipelines going through Ukraine that feed Europe and have billions in investments there.
Sactions never were terribly effective, much less such selective and symbolic. Also times have changed: 40-50 years ago "West" was semi united and held all the card: technology & agricultural production. Now Russia is simply prepared after previous financial crisises, has very low foreign debt and can buy what they need and wherever they want. Times of meaningful COCOM are over.
Well Nato has really moved East without much push back. But at some point it's going to be a problem. Like the country next door. If Mexico or Canada invited Russian troops I think ot might be a similar problem. I'm a freedom loving Westerner who sees the plain logic.
The difference is the US can do something about it. Russia cant. Weakening and dying country looking for relevance.
@@mlsmoothe8774 The point is not looking for relevance, but national security. From Russian perspective, Western expansion to the East is a threat. And it's not like Russia can't do anything. They annexed Crimea. The West didn't want USSR expansion back then, and Russia doesn't want Western expansion now, same thing.
paranoia LOL. so how much land does russia need to conquer to finally feel safe? all of Europe and then there'll be no threat of nato. oh but then russia's half is in the asian continent so ig they need to conquer Asia too, huh? maybe once russia conquers the whole world turning it into a new soviet union russians can finally sleep in peace.
imagine owning a house and being noisy and controlling of your neighbours because of "security concerns" - isn't that type of paranoia considered a mental illness. what was it called, schizophrenia? or something similar lol.
@@3xitthissid3 not really. Note that Asian Russia already has a sea as a buffer between them and Japan, Mongolia as a buffer for most of China, and Kazakhstan as a buffer for the rest of Central Asia. The only border that really needs guarding is the strip with China.
Meanwhile, European Russia is a plane, not at all mountainous, and Ukraine right under their nose on the verge of joining NATO. The security concern is legit. Not saying what they do is right or wrong, but the geopolitics is understandable.
No. Russia has done whatever it feels is necessary regardless of a threat of sanctions. They are more worried about NATO expansion.
Understand this. Putin has done very little to get Russia ready for the economic growth the world will have in the coming decades. Putin wins r short term. The winners will be the nations that push education, trade with military partners, technology, innovation, culture etc. USA still nation everyone wants to come to for college and to live. Our culture is robust and if we stay that way, we will be more than ok. Fortunately for us, russia is working off a 20th century playbook. Where will russia be after Putin? Where will USA be after trump and Biden? USA will survive and prosper after those 2 r gone.
@@michaelboano7183 and you're living in the 80's...
I agree
@@michaelboano7183 Understand this. You have no understanding of what is motivating Putin. Bottom line: Russia sees NATO as a force with the potential to invade and particularly with German assets. Russia has plenty of power on the field and WILL utilize it in a swift attack that will at least secure up to the Dnieper River. What happens next will likely see more Eastern European Nations including the remaining parts of the Ukraine joining NATO. IF I was in charge of those Russian forces I would tale all of the Ukraine as a demonstration of resolve. They have the combat strength in the field to do it.
scrag0416 u r looking at short term military objectives. I focus more on the long term which Putin has not concerned himself with. Long term Russia has no real ability to grow their economy. Without a robust economy, a nation will eventually be weakened militarily. I have a background in economics and so I tend to focus on the long term.
how would they? anything that either country needs is bought and sold through shell companies routed through other countries. both have been doing it since the '50s
Wow, an actual in-depth informative foreign affairs video...
meh MS NBC is wrong 100% of the time… even if it is factually correct one said by MS NBC it instantly becomes wrong. they spent this long destroying their credibility nothing they say should be ever taken serious again.
i don't think kicking off Russia from SWIFT is a threat, if they have their own alternative system. While a painful transition, this on the long term will boost their system. It could be what they want.
Hello... But Russian "alternative" system is based on MasterCard and will be useless if Russia will be kicked off from SWIFT
@sooje niteOk if you're right with whom Russia will trade through it's own pay System? That system is working only inside of Russia and support only RUBS currency that will be pointless for international trading. How do you think how many counties will trade with Russia in rubles?
@@vergil7185 It's called Mir - "World" and it's not related to Visa or MC
@@punn1187 but it's using theirs technologies such as 3-D Secure and that pay system's using only rubles and is being support by only Russia and couple of post Soviet countries.
@sooje nite I agree with your point that it's kind of a tragic to discuss something with people like yourself. I'm not sure how Iran sells its oil but I'm sure that they're using dollars for theirs transaction definitely not rubles (which Russian "system" only is support)
"What will happened if Russia cuts the supply of gas in Europe" could be alternative title on this video
@lovepumper and Europe will have crisis like never seen before. Currently energy prices are double even triple with 15% less natural gas being shipped to Germany comparing to 2019. If Russia cuts it completely energy prices will be 10x.
Lolx
Nigeria is looking for new market for her large supply of gas she will gladly sell to europe
@@henryeghaghara9385 its far away from ideal, shipping gas is not cheap. Its much cheaper sending gas trough existing pipeline.
@@ristekostadinov2820 still cheaper than financing a neighboring state that is leading a hybrid war against the west and Europe. At least in the medium and long term.
@@ristekostadinov2820 The pipeline is Russia's last chance, Germany is giving Russia a chance to see reason, should Russia show that it is mad enough to actually cut the pipeline ....
It will mean it will have to be taught sense by other means
Germany has sworn , it will fight on the right side of history this time 😁
The sanctions might impact Russia for some years insignificantly , but in the long run, it can give rise to another economic power block like the Euro.....it will serve as a boomerang to us too.
You can't hurt a man who has everything of his own. but America, Europe will be bent from their own sanctions. recent history has shown. thank you very much for the sanctions. we rebuilt what was destroyed in the 90s
never gonna happen. Europe will disconnect from Russia before anything like that could happen. The Russians can NEVER be trusted.
Well this is frightening...
Sanctions literally means 'its ok, go ahaed'
If they attack they are out of NATO for good
@@richardwainwright507 what does nato have to do with that
@@richardwainwright507 But if Russia can occupied Ukraine next will be Poland, Lithuania, Latvia and so on. What a great logic you have... And you've forgot for hundred thousands or even millions refugees in Europe.
@@vergil7185 No Poland and the others are part of NATO, Ukraine isn't.
@@priyanshsahay3573 Yes they are. But if Russia can succeed in occupation Ukraine, do you think Russians will stop? Of course they not. And next targets will be...
There was once a sanction on importing cheese to Russia, so Russia made the cheese instead, what’s there to stop them in this economy doing that
It was stupidest thing to do: to forbid to IMPORT the groceries. Let the nation suffer from the sanctions. Not to mention, how much groceries were destroyed by excavators , in the meanwhile Russian pensioners were fishing food from the trash bins.
SWIFT isn't for cheese.....
@@ecognitio9605 How western will pay for russian goods then? Russia is netto-exporter, they sell to west more than bought from them
@@andrew6274 Not buy from Russia or bypass the swift system. China developed CIPS system, which is what China used for energy trade with Russia. So this is an alternative system to SWIFT.
"Blessed are the cheesemakers"
My country (The USA) is acting like a bully who has long ago gotten used to always getting his own way, but now is faced with a would-be victim who is finally standing up to his bullying. I'm not saying Russia is blameless in this "crisis" - far from it! There is enough blame to go around. But the USA definitely has to stop trying to be the world's policeman. We are well past our sell-by date as far as that's concerned.
@Powerage Scott "Robert.. you don't know your history."
And you don't know me! I have spent my entire adult life studying Russian history and politics. I was a Soviet analyst for the Department of Defense from 1975-1991, when the USSR fell apart. I am fluent in Russian (are you?) and even now keep up with current affairs in Russia.
I think I know my history.
Where was the ussr from? Who invaded Poland first?
@Powerage Scott Prove? The problem is, your "points" are IRRELEVANT to the current crisis. Focus on today, not on events decades ago. By your standard, we should mistrust Japan because they attacked Pearl Harbor. The Cuban Missile Crisis? I remember that. Do you?
Хотят ли русские войны?
Спросите вы у тишины,
Над ширью пашен и полей,
И у берез, и тополей,
Спросите вы у тех солдат,
Что под березами лежат,
И вам ответят их сыны
Хотят ли русские,
хотят ли русские,
Хотят ли русские войны ?
@Powerage Scott you meant staged,paid protest all over the world by your country becouse what oil?I think you dont know your country history what happened with native Americans?Whats happening now with black people?If you have just a bit knowledge about your history you would know that the Russians have the most casualties in the WW2.And Ukraine have been on the enemy side like Croats,Hungarians,Italians,your country was playing role like its playing now,just give them arms and yours country will benefit
@Powerage Scott and just one more thing where are yours native Americans 🤔 Your nation is really English colony😂
Have sanctions ever stopped any country from doing anything ?
Yes, and you can see the results in North Korea right now. They are "saber rattling" again, launching more missiles into the sea. Clear sign that sanctions are having an effect.
Well, sanctions went into place when Russia moved into Crimea in 2014. Today, in 2022, Russia is still there.
@@TheStockwell My point exactly
@@TheStockwell Those sanctions were hardly the same as the ones being contemplated right now. And there were not SWIFT sanctions. SWIFT sanctions brought Iran back to the table.
@@RCSTILE What do you suggest? We are already sending billions in military and logistic aid. The Ukraine is not a member of NATO so there's not much we can do in that respect.
While Russia and United States are going at it. China is expanding like crazy
Syria just joined the BRI just yesterday
China is just waiting on Russia to invade Ukraine before they invade Taiwan.... Russia and China have this planned out!
@@Didshesmileatme that's what im thinking also. Doesnt mean they will. But you know China is just sitting on the fence watching how this all plays out so it can use it for its own leverage however that may be.
@@EuroMaidanWasAnInsurrection we wish for peace
@@Didshesmileatme India is also waiting China to invade Taiwan to take advantage of reclaiming Ladakh and Kashmir from China. While Pakistan May also attack India in Kashmir.
Damn that looks scary. Third world war in the making
Sanctions does not work and will not work on Russia, because we have seen how US sanctions has not work for the last 2 decades. And what made US think that it’ll work this time around if they imposed it once again.
If US imposes more sanctions to Russia, they will harm Europe more than Russia at this point. This is why Europe needs to make decisions for itself, not America
My friends I think the USA is not really interested in a military showdown with Russia. And this is why Russia is He is literally pushing to see how far and how much he can get away with.The problem with this approach is that it can get out hand pretty fast.And this is what I am most disgusted with Mr Putin for. He has so much going for his country. Why start a conflict that can affect him too I wonder if he feels the west will just allow him to get away with this?.
If he feels strength he will respect it. Everything else is laughed off.
If you're an American in Ukraine and you're not ready to fight get out. Don't think you can ride the trains out don't wait. Stay safe. Prayers to you, Ukraine.
Indeed prayers. They are once again stuck in the middle. "Clowns to the left of me, jokers to the right."
The problem with journalists and analysts in the US and in the West in general is that they somehow lost the ability to think in a realist way and Putin is obviously a political realist par excellence. He thinks in balance of power, correlation of forces and buffer states way. In this view security trumps economics. That’s why Russia is willing to endure enormous amounts of pain before let the Ukrainian join NATO and no amount of sanctions will deter the Kremlin from doing what it has determined is in it’s national core interest. (i.e. stop ferther NATO expansion)
And in a way is better, Ukraine joining nato is a secure pathway to a Cold War with Russia again, since America will have the upper hand
NATO never twisted anyone's arm to join. Russia's ex-soviet neighbors hate him and plenty have their own coalition against him. They joined NATO because they had the foresight to see how greedy he was. Georgia and Crimea weren't so lucky
@@cc23001 that's not the point. if Russia was setting up camp in Cuba, Mexico, or Canada, we would be preparing for war. You can't blame Russia for wanting buffer states.
It's not even Russia. US has actively deterred Russia from gaining any influence in Latin America for decades and remember all the fuss Australia/US threw up when China started giving loans to Pacific island nations? NATO isn't an economic entity like EU. It's literally set up to 'fight' Russia so only an American would be shocked that Russia is pushing back. Let's see these same people talk about how anyone is free to join any group when Russia decides to put a few silos in Cuba again.
@@xingincool9672 Yes, and Cold War didn't let to any direct conflict between alliances. It sets up the borders.
But really we have to understand that originally Ukraine never wanted to have to chose one side or the other, they wanted to be friend with both and that both be friends. It's just that in 2014 Moscow forced them to make a choice for which the (majority of the) population made the decision.
No matter what happens it will be the people of Ukraine who will lose. So say no to war!
You mean just give up and let the imperialist do what they want.
South Africa gave up their nukes, but they're the dominant force in the region, so they could afford to.
Ukraine gave up their nukes... then their neighbor invaded them. No country will ever give up nukes again. I suspect (hope) that Japan has secret nukes despite their history and official stance.
ukraine never had the launch codes nor the infrastructure to operate them, stop spreading misinformation
@@kirillholt2329 Absolute lies. This was a HUGE geopolitical topic back in the 90s-- are you old enough to remember that or were you just born then? Ukraine had more than 1700 operable nukes and gave them up, and when they did they also gave up their sovereignty.
@@dp7933 that doesn't refute anything that I said but ok, nuclear weapons are not artillery, they require extensive upkeep
@@kirillholt2329 Which also makes me think that Russia might no longer be a nuclear power.
I'm pretty sure somewhere deep underground in Japan they have thousands of 3 inch tall hello kitty figures that can each blow up half of Russia! They most likely have Laser weapons and own the "ufo's" we see lol
Basically, it is like telling a bully that you wont talk to them any more if they beat you up....
Finally a reasonable length time video ❤️❤️
The last few videos were omnibuses, consisting of several older videos sharing the same topic put together.
America os laughing stock of the world wahaha
Sanctions are telling your kids you can't do drugs while they have a back alley connect.
Ok
US: Stop that
Russia: No
us: okay. good luck finding a mcdonalds in north korea.
Nordstream 2 should be on the table. It shouldn't have gone through to start with. It was Germany's insistence that made it happen.
trump should never have allowed the fact that Putin has the pee pee tapes allow himself to be black mailed by russia .. and thus allowed Nordstream 2 to be completed
Since when can your neighbor say what you can do in your house or property. I suppose you can say but the city has rules and yes but in this case your neighbor is telling the whole neighborhood what dose rules are. Germany is not stupid and it sees your world domination is coming to an end.
@@4NickAder It was Biden who lifted the section but alright
Nord Stream 2 is a commercial project. Its people over geopolitical ramblings. Why the heck is it the US business disrupting European matters? NATO expansion is the problem. The US need to pack up and go home. There's enough problem in America to take care of. Cut the godamn excessive defense spending and put the money to properly warranted use. America is now viewed by the rest of the world as actors in opposition to peace. Its ridiculous.
So Germany should stop Nordstream 2 and frizz to death in winter and along with stopping their factories just because US wants so ?
US is in no position any more to dictate the world what to do.
and second what US would do if Russia would install missile luncher systems in Canada/ US and Mexico/ US orders ? They are independent counties so they can do whatever they want right ? is that your stupid argument ?
I think Cuba should just invite Russia with some of its modern military hardware and let's see what these so-called political analysts with have to say about it. Today's Russia is not going to be dictated to as it's determined to protect its borders and preserve its core security interests. No country in the West would have ever allowed what is happening to Russia with the encirclement by NATO. Let sound minded people voiced their concerns in the West as we are dangerously gearing towards an all out war with Russia in which everyone will be the looser
Joe created this mess. Allowing the Russian pipeline to finish when it was at a dead stop was a mistake. He thought it would mend fences, instead it gave russia unlimited power.
And why exactly should Cuba do that? What exactly does Cuba hope to gain other than place their people more in harm's way? Maybe there's a reason Cuba is keeping quiet about all this talk in using their nation to host missiles again. Unless of course you think Cuba has as much right to their sovereignty from Russia as the Ukraine does!
@@covertpuppytwo3857 because it's been under the US and its allies unfair sanctions for more than half a century. Why do you also think other countries in Europe and around the Russian borders should host NATO weapons? This is common sense
No because Russia refuses to trade the dollar & only holds a small amount of petro dollars at any 1 time.
US can only hurt EU as a consumer & that wont be taken kindly very long by EU.
Germany has a pipeline, if US needs some oil they can pay for it just like everyone else dose.
Now lets talk about Chinas BRI recently acquiring Syria and Australia 😁
Russia also holds its currency in the Euro. Something that Europeans do have control over.
The US has been the largest producer of oil for almost a decade.
Clearly you're a product of Russian propaganda and have been denied the truth. The US EXPORTS OIL. Australia blocked the hong kong company from buying the oil company. Get out from under that rock
Lucky Russia is strong, if Russia is weak, we all know what happens to those countries in the past when you try to change your international trade currency from US dollar, especially for trading oils
@@malakatan3235 lolx Russia is strong😂🤣😂🤣 you're joking right?
Excuse my ignorance but how important is Swift when money can be moved by the blockchain using a Cryptocurrency?
Those are not words of people who are interested in peace.
no. How many countries can the west impose sanctions on before it starts to affect the west as well? Eventually, the countries being sanctions will not only get 'use to it' but will work with each other.
what do you mean affect the west? america is not a trade partner of russia. you mean "other western style countries".
@@ChickenMcThiccken Google trade between Russia and the US.
@@devondevon3416 you mean russian federation. we don't trade with "russia". we do with the "russian federation"> that is different.
@@devondevon3416 we trade with the "ex soviet countries". that is what is called the "russian federation". like i said. i stand by my statement.
@@ChickenMcThiccken Google Russia Wikipedia and you will see that Russia and Russian Federation are the same.
It would only force Russia to reconsider options that will make them less vulnerable to economic sanctions.
And that is by securing strategic assets (like Ukraine) that will give them economic leverage over Europe.
They already have been for the last 8 years. If Russia wants to do something it doesn’t matter if you plan on going to war with them they are going to do it. Period!
Yeah..... let's do it
Since then Ukraine is a strategic asset? There’s nothing there that Russia lacks. Even its one decent heavy industry is now gone
@@zadornov128
Ukraine is a major transit point for Russian gas pipelines to EU. That is why it is important to Russia.
Then there is Crimea which houses Russia Navy in the Black Sea. While Russia control the island for now, it is very vulnerable if it doesn't have access to Ukrainian mainland.
Finally Ukraine is a major buffer zone that separate Russia from Europe.
Without it under their control, NATO can just park their forces in Ukraine and would practically make Moscow a stone throw away from NATO forces.
there is nothing the European countries can do to stop russia from invading, because they belong to NATO which prevents them from entering ukraine even if ukraine asks for them to. because ukraine is a neutral nation its on its own. the US and NATO stirred the pot now ukraine will burn for their ambitions. ukraine should of joined russia atleast then they wouldnt be in this situation. ukraine should of also kept up their legal obligations for the minsk accords.
• First, sanctions do not work, at least not to the degree we are trying to have them work. Indeed, I cannot think of one serious instance in which they have produced the desired result, certainly not when the target country sees some critical security interest at risk or the regime in power believes its rule to be in jeopardy. The greatest value of sanctions is for domestic political purposes: to "feel good" that we are "doing something," and to help avoid more
Just making them more desperate and unpredictable. Great idea!
no matter what its gonna be the normal citizens who are going to pay the price
Russia : Sanctions ? O.K. Our oil prices just went up !
Biden: Come on man !!!
Nice video.
I’m Russian and we need more sanctions, because it helps our own economy. Our agriculture grows very rapidly after sanctions 2014 and economy now more powerful compare to before sanction times. So, I’m want that. And it will helps ally with China if Western countries wants NATO more.
The Senator from New Hampshire appears well equipped at reading text supplied by her party. Otherwise she has little credibility.
school girl is tretning Russia
Super in depth, and the propositions at the end were really intriguing...
Yeah... don't hesitate....put the sanctions...be brave and go down with dignity.
While everyone is looking at Ukraine they're reclaiming Kazakhstan in the guise of a peace keeping effort.
Not sure you even understand the meaning of words you are using.
Yes
No, sanctions cannot prevent Russia from doing anything. We continue to push Russia towards China.
The west sanctions are so effective that make Russia wanna keep doing more 😄
Hope springs eternal and all that. I don't recall but a handful of situations where sanctions have ever worked other than against minor powers.
Russian 50 centers earning their keep on here
Did sanctions deter Russia from invading Ukraine's Crimea? You got your answer. As a Turkish who lived in Russia for 7 years I can tell you Putin doesn't get weaker by sanctions it gets stronger as it citizens get poorer. Erdogan is trying to do the samething. As citizens get weaker they become more powerful not less.
Erdogan is trying to break turkish economny yep man u a right he`s literally trying to "do something" what erdogan can do? dont sell tomatos or fruits? please no!!!!
@@jackshadows8073 By distrubting democraacy, freedom and free-market capitalism you can destroy the whole economy and make your citizens suffers. It's really quite easy to destroy a country within 20 years. He is trying to brainwash citizens with religion nonsense. Turkey's Lira has never been that invaluable in its history even in spite of this US monetary inflation era.
@sooje nite Russian Empire is not Russian Federation, and not USSR. Russian Federation agreed that Crimea is Ukrainian territory, but later broke all international laws and agreements. You know that Russian Empire by some time hold Warsaw? You understand that such fact not give to modern Russia any right to occupy Poland.
How is it working for Erdogan these days? At least Putin didn't fell too much into ideology over reason yet (but it's coming).
Most of Russians Love Putin's politics and wars that their country is waging i.e. Russian people must pay for their country's action. If they were truly against Kremlin's politics they would've overthrow the government and Putin. Even yourself absolutely don't care about Russian's wars, but you care only about your money that depend from Russia.
They sure spent a lot of money on a pipeline , so I guess you'd have to ask the customers.
If the US restarted it’s energy industry and then imposed sanctions--maybe it would work.
The solution is in NATO itself, not sanction.
Gonna have to change out that desert camo...
@@patrickkenyon2326 I bet our boys look good in White.
lol NATO
Real solution is both Russia and NATO should leave Ukraine alone. You guys are creating unnecessary tension to those citizens. There is place in hell for all of you 😡🤬
@@lucashurley7612 Russians like to think they know winter.
So do midwestern farm boys.
Russia just does it
No, the answer is no
If Russia (well Putin really) want to do something they will
If the US keeps up the sanction strategy on so many countries, all those countries are going to join economies closer and closer. There is a point where these sanction will not work.
Oh yea, the Russians can use China to trade with more,
The rest of the world is getting to an extend that they will not take sides . There will be new groups In Middle East , South America and Asia to get away sanctions . The more sanctions impose on other countries the more distance there will be for US. Europe will not follow if their trading and supplies are hurt. Besides Ukraine is creating trouble in the region and it is not in the Eu or NATO.
You and everybody else are constantly reiterating on "if Russia invades Ukraine, then ...bla bla bla". But Russia has already invaded Ukraine! It has been here, in my country, for 8 years on and running so this "if" statement is grossly wrong
Yes it is sad. People have got used to this situation.
No it has not.
Agree. And as EU and NATO don't do anything about this, this is grossly affecting the hope you guys have for those organizations. Obviously sanctions don't have the expected result we would like them to have. As an EU supporter and observer I really hope this conflict gets resolved without more bloodshed. Sadly EU doesn't have much military power to deal with Russia right now and this conflict is like walking on the edge of a blade. How we handle this will determine how Putin will act in the future, not just with Ukraine, but with other sovereign countries as well. Hopefully Putin is as scared as the other nations of starting a new world war and wouldn't act more aggressively.
@@harry.cromberg i meant outside ukraine.
@@arvopohja7693 I was saying that Russia has not invaded Ukraine.
How bout stop expanding NATO to Russian doorstep?
Seems straight forward to me. No collateral financial dmg there.
Apparently not
Last time, Germany sent cash to Russia and didn’t break Russia, so as long as there is something Russia has and others want removing Russia from SWIFT only speed up the development of digital currency to bypass SWIFt.
Exactly. If we keep on this path the rest of the world is going to go off the dollar and the USA will accept its status as a burned-out, bankrupt colonial has-been like the UK. Meanwhile, the irreponsible, insane, war-mongering crap spewed out by the MIC/CIA/plutocrat-controlled government is just pushing Russian and China closer and closer together and will cut us out of the deal. Bad enough to be ruled by psychopaths, but worse yet to be ruled by STUPID SUICIDAL psychopaths.
More likely they will be forced into an uneven trade deal with China
Look up Gesara.
Still don’t get it why would Russia want to attack Ukraine?
I wouldn’t worry about it as nothing will ever come if this. People just like to be dramatic and tell you that the world is ending
Russia wants to be closer NATO.
Russia is aggressive towards Ukraine because nato wants to set up military bases in Ukraine which may compromise Russia's security
Supposedly because Ukraine wants to join NATO, but the whole conflict is in fact manufactured to distract public (in US,EU and Russia) from bigger problems such as out of control inflation and looming huge recession. (The latter will probably start after midterms, up until then they will artificially keep stock markets high for obvious reasons)
Because the main street media needs a distraction for Bidens many failures here.
Wait, has USA not sanction Russia before today? Do we miss Russia all along in our sanction policy?
Sanctions - the diplomatic equivalent of thinking Starbucks will go out of business if you stop buying their lattes.
Russia's Long term cost of NOT invading Ukraine was not discussed. China openly stating that it would support Russia's taking part of Ukraine. Russia supplies the majority of gas, oil, natural gas, etc from Russia's pipeline to supply many Western European countries' winter energy needs. Not discussed that China needs Russia because Russia supplies significant oil and gas to China from pipelines and also tankers. This leads me to believe that if NATO and/or US invoke sanctions then China will support Russia and then the follow up question is can Western Europe and USA afford to sanction both Russia and China at the same time.... Thoughts please.
You obviously don't know China very well
China will have Russia over a barrel and force them to sign a very unequal trade deal. That would be something that could cause Putin to accidentally fall out a window
James Ricker
You obviously think you know China very well.
Well, you don’t.
Yours is the typical American
/Western mentality.
I applaud this guy for trying to disguise his Russian accent, you did pretty good ..
That being said, as an white American girl, I have a REALLY hard time attempting a Russian accent, and Australian..
Why don't you call and talk dirty to me for practice......
I have no money. I am attractive though. Lift weights a lot and train jui jitsu. My personality just sucks. I have an ego because I weld pipeline for a living. You seriously are cute in your photo. Just a compliment ☺
Where was the Russian guy? I only see a guy named Michael
What nonsensical and foolish comment!!!!
@Ron García I believe it is spelled Maykl, or Майкл, if you will
The sanctions are so severe, that I suspect Russia will take military action.
Remember what happened when Japan was hit with an oil embargo.
The embargo worked, then. Japan needed oil so urgently that it was forced to make a mistake that ended in its defeat.
In a word - NO.
I don't think Putin gives af about sanctions sadly.
Swift: We might kick off Russia from Swift.
XRP: Make my day Swift....Make my day.
blockchain records, exactly where and when a transaction takes place. you use vpn to hide location LMFAO.... vpn don't work on blockchain.
@@ChickenMcThiccken You must be new to Crypto or some one who hasn't done a deep dive into Crypto. Yes XRP is public though if Russia wanted their transactions to be private they can. They can use coin mixers or build an automatic one on top of XRP. They can also put their money through a private coin or they can build a private coin on top of XRP. There is a lot they can do if they wanted privacy.
you cannot deter Russia with threats. Since 2014 some "experts" should've learned that.
Russia will call your hand.
Gotta treat Ukraine like Taiwan.
@@jbone9900 Hawaii, Guam and Puerto Rico too
A big fat NO. 😢
Sanctions literally is just a word and meaningless. Europe and the USA continues to do business as usual under the table to recover losses on both sides, and Northern gas line under commissioning and startup.
One to thing to note was there was nothing new in this video. The title made me worry if US had put sanctions on Russia even though it didn't invade Ukraine
USA DESPERATELY WANTS THAT "CONFLICT" TO HAPPEN HUH? JUST WONDER WHY😂
Really, nothing new
Mum: if u don’t behave I will not give u pocket money
Son: you have not been giving me money all along, what difference does it makes?
Nope hadn’t worked until now. Why would it start?
Respect for those that fight for Ukraine's freedom and self-determination of their own future. Ukraine deserves better.
Love from the EU, I wish we could do more to help 🇺🇦 ♥️ 🇪🇺
You could volunteer to serve in the Ukrainian military. They accept foreigners in their armed forces.
Thanks a lot for support to my country ! Where are you from ?
@@lemfarba4827 It's asking a lot of people to give their lives for a country that they have never even been to. EU countries have professional armies that should support Ukraine if they want the help.
@@AmazingJohnny The Netherlands :)
@@JD-jl4yy Okay. And thank you for support to my Ukraine 👍
Thats also a question for the US: would US accept any sanctions be given to them by intl' community for illegaly being involved in syrian war or when it invaded iraq or probably to deter the US from invading any country in the future? Russia want the US to treat them on equal ground, not as some sort of rogue "small" states like Cuba or iran, considering Russia have its own national interest as well as power, just like the USA. Everytime US media look at other nations, they always try to legitimize their country's actions on the base of US national interests like America is the only country to have one 🙃
Well the US doesn't go into the Middle East annexing swaths of land.
@@hydroaegis6658 Because if you annex something, then you have to take care about people who live there. USA acts more like raiders, which is worse.
The Syrian war was started by Europe, Barack said he would assist, but he insisted that the US wouldn't lead the charge.
everybody know that the US is a double-talk country, country that work with them either is corrupter or the US have something that threated them with something that make their country economy unstable.
@@hydroaegis6658 the US tried for couple years, didn’t work out well for the US. US doesn’t annex land in Middle East not because it is honorable but because US can’t do it.
How can I stop this channel from showing up on my ❓
Western readiness for action and overwhelming firepower can easily deter Russia.
No good without the will to use it. Biden doesn't have it. He's weak. Nor does he have the know how to do it. His "advisers" are political hacks, leftist zealots. They are not policy people. They don't know how, or care to know how to achieve a policy goal. They are not doers, they are preachers for the cause and the cause as quoted by Obama is to "fundamentally change America".
Don't you think a military win for Russia will have a much greater impact then sanctions?
Who would dare to mess with Russia yet again
@@anacarvalho2833co-ask
no
Special love content over 18 years old
NUDE-DATTING.ONLINE
tricks I do not know
Megan: "Hotter"
Hopi: "Sweeter"
Joonie: "Cooler"
Yoongi: "Butter
So with toy and his tricks, do not read it to him that he writes well mamon there are only to laugh for a while and not be sad and stressed because of the hard life that is lived today.
Köz karaş: '' Taŋ kaldım ''
Erinder: '' Sezimdüü ''
Jılmayuu: '' Tattuuraak ''
Dene: '' Muzdak ''
Jizn, kak krasivaya melodiya, tolko pesni pereputalis.
Aç köz arstan
Bul ukmuştuuday ısık kün bolçu, jana arstan abdan açka bolgon.
Uyunan çıgıp, tigi jer-jerdi izdedi. Al kiçinekey koyondu wins taba algan. Al bir az oylonboy koyondu karmadı. '' Bul koyon menin kursagımdı toyguza albayt '' dep oylodu arstan.
Arstan koyondu öltüröyün dep jatkanda, bir kiyik tigi tarapka çurkadı. Arstan aç köz bolup kaldı. Kiçine koyondu emes, çoŋ kiyikti jegen jakşı dep oylodu. # 垃圾
They are one of the best concerts, you can not go but just seeing them from the screen, I know it was surprising
💗❤️💌💘