Romany's expression of the lyrics through her vulnerable voice is perfect for this song. It has been stuck in my brain's ear worm since I first heard it days ago. I hope she gives us more.
My wife felt the same way as you. I played her Dark Side of the Moon, looking at a meteor shower in the hills. She said the same, that the heartbeat made her feel anxious. Pink Floyd, and David, make you feel things and it can be uncomfortable. But that’s when you know it somehow speaks to you on a human experience level. Most music doesn’t do that.
I am a big David Gilmour fan. I like the title track "Luck and Strange" because he's playing with Richard Wright. This cover is amazing with the solo and Romany's voice. Scattered however, is the one I like best on this album. Great reaction!
Thanks for reacting to both the original and the sublime cover by Romany and David Gilmour! I also recommend checking out the live "Tour Rehearsal" video they did of the song 🎶🎶
I am a man with 64 years on my body and i cry every time i hear that angelical voice of Romany Glimour but not only the voice is the music and the words that makes me cry. I think is the new song in my BOX of GOLDEN TREASURE SONGS. The Blame on you it is in your side if you let them abuse of you and that happens very often when you are young and unexperienced.
Hola desde Mallorca Nikki 😊 Sin ninguna duda tienes que escuchar mucho más de Pink Floyd, uno de los mejores grupos de la historia. Si no te gustan los sonidos de campanas y relojes te recomiendo por ejemplo "Wish You Were Here", "Us and Them", "Comfortably Numb" y "On The Turning Away". En cuanto a la canción "Between Two Points" para mí también es más profunda la versión de los Gilmour debido a la voz de Romany y al toque "guitarrero" del maestro David. Saludos!
His wife is a novelist. But, after meeting David Gilmour she started writing lyrics for his songs. Romany has videos on TH-cam where she is singing in a pub.
I've listened to this song a number of times now, it's kind of stuck in my head. Sad but deep and reflective. This was a nice gift from father to daughter to place this cover on his album. Romany has a really nice voice. My understanding is she just learned to play the harp during covid lockdown.
David Gilmour has been an influence on many artists over the years including TheWarning.Ive never seen them in concert LIVE but have seen the cover band Wish You Were 3 or 4 times very close to the sound of the actual band.A Genuis in the music business for sure. Yes agree I like the version with his daughter better too,she is on other songs on his latest released lp and it also looks like Romany is an actress.OK now that you mention it yes I get the Dido vibe too.I loved her collab with Em on Stan. Yes on more Pink Floyd for sure.
I wonder if my husband has heard of that cover band. 🤔 We saw one called Brit Floyd and for me not knowing much of Pink Floyd's work, it was still a really good show. All of them were very talented. And yeah, that song with Eminem & Dido was great! I haven't thought about her for a long time until this song. 😅
@@nikkireviews [edited] There are a handful of songs by The Warning that are quieter but still have impact - some of the lyrics might hit the spot. If you feel inclined, here are some links: - th-cam.com/video/oqXcNOVmcjc/w-d-xo.html ("Revenant" live 2022 - Pau on lead vocal) - th-cam.com/video/YWjhsVdIH2o/w-d-xo.html ("23" live 2023 - Pau on lead vocal) - th-cam.com/video/OFNORZKpS1k/w-d-xo.html ("Black Holes" live 2023 - Pau on piano & lead vocal) - th-cam.com/video/2idDr72FYA8/w-d-xo.html ("Breathe" live 2023 - Pau on piano & lead vocal) PS: edited after finally(!) noticing you have already reacted to "The Warning".
@nikkireviews My personal favorite is Scattered. It is the perfect end to this whole exploration of the theme of the album: his life, his hopes, his dreams, his understanding, and acceptance that it will end.
I LOVE PINK FLOYD!! BEEN A HUGH FAN FOR YEARS! HAVE YOU REACTED TO THEIR ALBUM OR MOVIE "THE WALL"? I'VE SEEN THE WALL 3 TIMES AT THE THEATER AND BOUGHT THE ALBUM A FEW TIMES BECAUSE FRIENDS KEPT BORROWING IT AND GIVING BACK TO ME. I LOVE THE SECOND MORE I AGREE. THANK YOU NIKKI, THAT WAS AWESOME!! 😊💓🤘✌️JUST TO MENTIONED EDDIE VEDDER AND ROGER WATERS SINGING "COMFORTABLY NUMB" IS PRETTY AMAZING! IT'S 2012 RAISING MONEY FOR RELIEF FOR THE HURRICANE KATRINA I THINK.
@@Mr.Mecanik No, I don't. I was thinking of making a Patreon soon but just for free right now to put my blocked videos. I hear that's an option for that which would be great. But I appreciate the support! ❤️
I did not know this was a cover. It's probably my favorite song on his new album, but that's not a knock on his songwriting. I just think this was a brilliant execution, and Romany's voice is gorgeous. I hadn't heard the original before, and I didn't hate it, but obviously the cover is much better. Great guitar solo too.
I have to say, dissing Pink Floyd because occasionally they use unconventional sounds for a tiny fraction of their tracks, is very irrational. That said, Romany is incredibly talented and looks very much like a young David. Here is David speaking about how Romany was given a sheet, heard the song once and knocked out this performance in essentially one take: th-cam.com/video/hCQcKUtg9kc/w-d-xo.html ( David Gilmour - Between Two Points (Explainer) ) And here is a lovely photo album of Romany growing up, set to one of David's tunes, and you can see how incredibly similar she looks compared to the young David: th-cam.com/video/T_gQ_D5yhAE/w-d-xo.html ( David Gilmour and Romany Gilmour - Kokineli ) Can you imagine having David Gilmour as your dad and music teacher? They did a series of "home movies" with family, wine and song during covid lockdowns and she shines there too: th-cam.com/video/dGdEe8yp2TI/w-d-xo.html ( David Gilmour with Romany Gilmour - Yes, I Have Ghosts (Von Trapped Series) )
Ok, I will admit off the bat that I haven't heard the original until just now... I had a feeling that I wouldn't like the original. I have been a massive fan of Pink Floyd and David Gilmour ever since I played the Pink Floyd album "The Division Bell" 30 years ago. Ok, well David's version featuring his daughter Romany Gilmour on vocal... is by far my favorite song from this year so far. I said I don't like the original, but it's not song... so much as the execution of the performance. But also, the the end guitar solo is sublime to me.
You are a great reviewer. Congratulations . Subscribied. II'm gonna watch more of your reviews. And you are excused for not being a Gilmour or Floyd fan. It's ok. But don't do it again. God bless you. Cheers from Rio 'de Janeiro
Its sad young people today just want songs to be happy, fast and quick ( over 3 min is just to long for the smartphones). Patience, depth and art are lacking today.
Su comentario es muy pobre y obvio desconoce a Gilmour. El arreglo es excepcional, voz, guitarra, acompañamientos etc. En total desacuerdo pero se respeta su comentario
I'm disappointed that it was a cover version I never knew I've also disappointed that David Gilmour can no longer write his own songs I don't think Roger Waters would approve.
Thanks for the input. 👌🏻 It's hard to judge sometimes the right amount. When I didn't say anything people said I was too unenthusiastic and boring. I do know sometimes I talk too much though so I'll keep that in mind going forward.
That Montgolfier Brothers song is one of the most achingly beautiful songs I have ever heard
Romany's expression of the lyrics through her vulnerable voice is perfect for this song. It has been stuck in my brain's ear worm since I first heard it days ago. I hope she gives us more.
@@yttkuar It really does get stuck in your head. Whenever my husband listens to it once, that's the song of the day to my brain lol.
I loved this version.
A beautiful remake of the original version with David's touch and Romani's angelic voice.
@@gustavocomeli She really does have an angelic voice. 💞
My wife felt the same way as you. I played her Dark Side of the Moon, looking at a meteor shower in the hills. She said the same, that the heartbeat made her feel anxious. Pink Floyd, and David, make you feel things and it can be uncomfortable. But that’s when you know it somehow speaks to you on a human experience level. Most music doesn’t do that.
The GOAT and the Kid. 🐐👧
Absolutely gorgeous!
Romany is a revelation and I love her
I am a big David Gilmour fan. I like the title track "Luck and Strange" because he's playing with Richard Wright. This cover is amazing with the solo and Romany's voice. Scattered however, is the one I like best on this album. Great reaction!
Thank you! I know my husband has talked about that one as well, I will have to give it a listen. 😊
Thanks for reacting to both the original and the sublime cover by Romany and David Gilmour! I also recommend checking out the live "Tour Rehearsal" video they did of the song 🎶🎶
@@BarleyC I will have to do that. Thank you!
I am a man with 64 years on my body and i cry every time i hear that angelical voice of Romany Glimour but not only the voice is the music and the words that makes me cry.
I think is the new song in my BOX of GOLDEN TREASURE SONGS.
The Blame on you it is in your side if you let them abuse of you and that happens very often when you are young and unexperienced.
Perfect comment
I am in love with Romany's version. But I'd never heard this before and it's sooooo nice. Thank you for getting me to listen to it.
Romany is just the spitting image of her Dad if you search up pictures of David when he was young, you'll get what I mean.
Also the Live At Pompeii movie. The resemblance between father and daughter is striking.
His new album is really good, the man can still play the hell out of a guitar
Hola desde Mallorca Nikki 😊 Sin ninguna duda tienes que escuchar mucho más de Pink Floyd, uno de los mejores grupos de la historia. Si no te gustan los sonidos de campanas y relojes te recomiendo por ejemplo "Wish You Were Here", "Us and Them", "Comfortably Numb" y "On The Turning Away". En cuanto a la canción "Between Two Points" para mí también es más profunda la versión de los Gilmour debido a la voz de Romany y al toque "guitarrero" del maestro David. Saludos!
Sim, concordo! Abraços desde Rio de Janeiro
His wife is a novelist. But, after meeting David Gilmour she started writing lyrics for his songs. Romany has videos on TH-cam where she is singing in a pub.
I've listened to this song a number of times now, it's kind of stuck in my head. Sad but deep and reflective.
This was a nice gift from father to daughter to place this cover on his album. Romany has a really nice voice. My understanding is she just learned to play the harp during covid lockdown.
I also found some interesting short collabs posted from an acoustic show where his Daughter plays a guitar as does David .
Oh that's cool. 😊
David Gilmour has been an influence on many artists over the years including TheWarning.Ive never seen them in concert LIVE but have seen the cover band Wish You Were 3 or 4 times very close to the sound of the actual band.A Genuis in the music business for sure. Yes agree I like the version with his daughter better too,she is on other songs on his latest released lp and it also looks like Romany is an actress.OK now that you mention it yes I get the Dido vibe too.I loved her collab with Em on Stan. Yes on more Pink Floyd for sure.
I wonder if my husband has heard of that cover band. 🤔 We saw one called Brit Floyd and for me not knowing much of Pink Floyd's work, it was still a really good show. All of them were very talented. And yeah, that song with Eminem & Dido was great! I haven't thought about her for a long time until this song. 😅
@@nikkireviews [edited] There are a handful of songs by The Warning that are quieter but still have impact - some of the lyrics might hit the spot. If you feel inclined, here are some links:
- th-cam.com/video/oqXcNOVmcjc/w-d-xo.html ("Revenant" live 2022 - Pau on lead vocal)
- th-cam.com/video/YWjhsVdIH2o/w-d-xo.html ("23" live 2023 - Pau on lead vocal)
- th-cam.com/video/OFNORZKpS1k/w-d-xo.html ("Black Holes" live 2023 - Pau on piano & lead vocal)
- th-cam.com/video/2idDr72FYA8/w-d-xo.html ("Breathe" live 2023 - Pau on piano & lead vocal)
PS: edited after finally(!) noticing you have already reacted to "The Warning".
Nikki thanks for playing the original.
This is a profound song. For me it's about Mass Media or herd mentality that can persuade a young person wrongly.
Perfect
Great song! Great album!!
I'll have to check out some more by him. 😊
@nikkireviews My personal favorite is Scattered. It is the perfect end to this whole exploration of the theme of the album: his life, his hopes, his dreams, his understanding, and acceptance that it will end.
I LOVE PINK FLOYD!! BEEN A HUGH FAN FOR YEARS! HAVE YOU REACTED TO THEIR ALBUM OR MOVIE "THE WALL"? I'VE SEEN THE WALL 3 TIMES AT THE THEATER AND BOUGHT THE ALBUM A FEW TIMES BECAUSE FRIENDS KEPT BORROWING IT AND GIVING BACK TO ME. I LOVE THE SECOND MORE I AGREE. THANK YOU NIKKI, THAT WAS AWESOME!! 😊💓🤘✌️JUST TO MENTIONED EDDIE VEDDER AND ROGER WATERS SINGING "COMFORTABLY NUMB" IS PRETTY AMAZING! IT'S 2012 RAISING MONEY FOR RELIEF FOR THE HURRICANE KATRINA I THINK.
What a great song. I do like Gilmore's remake more, alas, he always was amazing at composition. Love it.
I'm the bad guy, I'm a savage...
Are you really the bad guy though? 🤔 (Thank you once again! 👀)
@@nikkireviews You wouldn't believe it... and your most welcome. Do you have any other links for support?
@@Mr.Mecanik No, I don't. I was thinking of making a Patreon soon but just for free right now to put my blocked videos. I hear that's an option for that which would be great. But I appreciate the support! ❤️
I did not know this was a cover. It's probably my favorite song on his new album, but that's not a knock on his songwriting. I just think this was a brilliant execution, and Romany's voice is gorgeous. I hadn't heard the original before, and I didn't hate it, but obviously the cover is much better. Great guitar solo too.
Funny watching younger folk who aren't very familiar with Gilmour and or Pink Floyd. Perhaps as they mature😊.......
I prefer DAVID and ROMANY GILMOUR versión of the song.
I have to say, dissing Pink Floyd because occasionally they use unconventional sounds for a tiny fraction of their tracks, is very irrational. That said, Romany is incredibly talented and looks very much like a young David. Here is David speaking about how Romany was given a sheet, heard the song once and knocked out this performance in essentially one take:
th-cam.com/video/hCQcKUtg9kc/w-d-xo.html ( David Gilmour - Between Two Points (Explainer) )
And here is a lovely photo album of Romany growing up, set to one of David's tunes, and you can see how incredibly similar she looks compared to the young David:
th-cam.com/video/T_gQ_D5yhAE/w-d-xo.html ( David Gilmour and Romany Gilmour - Kokineli )
Can you imagine having David Gilmour as your dad and music teacher? They did a series of "home movies" with family, wine and song during covid lockdowns and she shines there too:
th-cam.com/video/dGdEe8yp2TI/w-d-xo.html ( David Gilmour with Romany Gilmour - Yes, I Have Ghosts (Von Trapped Series) )
Ok, I will admit off the bat that I haven't heard the original until just now... I had a feeling that I wouldn't like the original. I have been a massive fan of Pink Floyd and David Gilmour ever since I played the Pink Floyd album "The Division Bell" 30 years ago. Ok, well David's version featuring his daughter Romany Gilmour on vocal... is by far my favorite song from this year so far. I said I don't like the original, but it's not song... so much as the execution of the performance. But also, the the end guitar solo is sublime to me.
ha you had to add Dido Armstrong in the last few seconds, well... I want to 'Thank You'. 😉🎶
You are a great reviewer. Congratulations . Subscribied. II'm gonna watch more of your reviews. And you are excused for not being a Gilmour or Floyd fan. It's ok. But don't do it again. God bless you. Cheers from Rio 'de Janeiro
Its sad young people today just want songs to be happy, fast and quick ( over 3 min is just to long for the smartphones).
Patience, depth and art are lacking today.
Romany in the industry? She is now.
compare her with an old photo of David in the 70's.......
Su comentario es muy pobre y obvio desconoce a Gilmour. El arreglo es excepcional, voz, guitarra, acompañamientos etc. En total desacuerdo pero se respeta su comentario
No wonder the song is “sad”; it is about domestic abuse.
I'm disappointed that it was a cover version I never knew I've also disappointed that David Gilmour can no longer write his own songs I don't think Roger Waters would approve.
You talk too much. You should wait till the end
Thanks for the input. 👌🏻 It's hard to judge sometimes the right amount. When I didn't say anything people said I was too unenthusiastic and boring. I do know sometimes I talk too much though so I'll keep that in mind going forward.