In my opinion, the opening monologue/intro to this episode is a gold-standard for programming podcasts. The questions raised by the topic, especially the technical ones, as well as the delivery of said questions was superb. Very compelling, and really got me excited about the episode, because I knew from the intro that all my burning questions were going to be addressed. Awesome job, Kris. This podcast is fantastic.
Kris, you are hands down, the best interviewer I’ve seen for programming related topics. Your questions and genuinely thoughtful and I love how much room you give the interviewee to answer the questions while you take it in. Wonderful stuff
VERY much enjoyed this interview. Loved all the technical detail. All those were the very same questions I really wanted answered. Would love to have been even more technically deep. Sounds like such an interesting tool. Really loves this talk
I gave Zed a try several months ago and was impressed by the performance. It has become my go to editor for anything else, where I don't need special debugger features or tool chain support. My wish would be, make it the go to editor for Rust! Rust really needs a good editor with toolchain support and remote debugging. Here all the big players have issues or are very complex to handle. I know that because I use it all the time. But for the record, great work! Zed is outstanding and I love it!
I work in a strongly regulated environment with heightened levels of security concerns, which has a tendency to be a little "isolationist," if you will. I've also said for a couple decades now that software development is a social endeavour, like any other creative acts have a strong social component. I absolutely loved the mentions here of the anthropological intersection. Concepts of subversion, of identity, of guile, of corruption, because of my work environment, are fascinating to me. On one hand, I think about orgs like ours being able to wrap the technology one day to leverage it within their isolated bubble, and on the other hand I think it would be so much more fascinating to think about how we might find ways to isolate and suppress those kinds of activities as a function of the technology itself. Is isolating a bad set of transformations from a hallucinating AI done asynchronously really any different functionally than an intentional set of malicious transformations by a subversive actor? At a lower level, what if these things were signed to ensure identity? So many fun questions. Great interview, really got my brain engaged. Thanks Kris for the continued thoughtful way you engage in these interviews, and the guests you bring in with so many damn cool ideas :)
Look forward to watching this, as I do with any of them. Though before watching, I had a disk die about a month ago now, and I'd been talking about moving to Linux, just too lazy to do it. So this felt like the perfect opportunity, so I did. Prior to that I'd been using VSCode as my editor, and moving away from Windows, it didn't feel right to use it still, so I thought I'd try other things out there, and one of them was Zed, and every couple of days it seems to freeze on me, but given it starts so fast, it's as if I just alt-tabbed away, and back again, I've been pretty happy with using it for the last month so far. Though I'm not someone who thinks about workflow, or other things like that, so I never really took advantage of the extensions in VSCode for example (or at least not enough that I miss what I had there), so my move probably easier than many.
I think for the "ambient awareness" social stuff they should maybe take some ideas from discord. I would sometimes have friends stream their work but actually have mic+headset muted (which is visible as an icon) - so you could join and look at what they do but they wouldn't get disturbed by you. Also different channels for different things, also both sides streaming at the same time. etc.
Nice to hear rope become more and more well known. I recall an ICFP contest where the challenge problem needed to be done using rope or it was nearly impossible, but easy with rope. Rope wasn't well known enough and some folks complained at the gotcha.
I like Rust and Zed is looking good. I keep it updated. But my impression is that it's evolving slowly, possibly because Rust is slow for iterative development where you have to keep rethinking and redesigning how stuff works. It's not at the point where I want to use it for doing my actual coding in yet.
Excellent content, thanks! Lots of technical and design choices in Zed that feel "right" to me, I'll definitely try it - fingers crossed for a huge success!
Why does vi not default to input mode when it starts? I do not use it for that reason. If I am the user of a software, I think that my preferences should be accommodated. That is, if I am expected to use it.
once they get a proper vim integration (directly connected like the neovim extension for vscode) and Linux support, I might switch from neovim. also just better keybinding support with keychords and stuff.
seems like zed still doesn’t have basic ide functionality such as drill down to function/class body in c++. It is yet another editor with just syntax highlighting
the reality is who is zed for? people who have taken up vim/neovim for its configuration, speed, and simplicity zed will just never be able to compete. Maybe some of the vscode crowd or people looking for something in between vscode/vim? Even then i believe the reason a lot of people continue to use vs code is due to its integrations and ecosystem. Which means it would be a long long long time before zed gets there.
No disrespect was intended. Sadly there were a few places where we talked over each other-almost inevitable on a transatlantic conversation-and for clarity's sake I muted Nathan or myself. I _try_ to be impartial on that,and just pick whichever side kept the conversation flowing best in that moment. 🙂
Them implementing AI stuff before a lot of other features just doesn't sit well with me. I think this is more like a jetbrains ide or maybe i think jetbrains fleet. But this is definitely not an editor that will become the top editor instead of vscode or even neovim.
AI needs so much infrastructure for its value to be fully realized. I’m starting to realize this. Probabilistic stochastic pattern matching machines still need stateful, reliable infrastructure to serve its users best. Platforms like iOS have so much reliable infrastructure and features for it to really deliver a tailored user experience with integration.
It really makes absolutely no sense at all. Like no refactoring capability? If I don't like the name of a function do you seriously expect me to do a find and replace? I mean I was doing that back in 2000, but now we have actually smart tools that can do that properly. I mean wtf?
What the actual f, when the guy was talking about segment trees/fold maps I did not understand literally anything. Judging by the reaction of the host, I don't think he understood much either. At around 13:20. Lots of hand gestures, trapezoids, ropes, CRDT's -- I guess the guest expects all viewers to be writing high performance text editors on their spare time, but I doubt it's the case..
That's just not true. I've done lots of pair programming, both in personal and professional work. It sounds pretty neat to be able to work on the same branch at the same time. Saves on merges which saves on CI which saves on time and resources.
@@JohnnySacc You could also just not use a language that requires a massive build system and unreasonable amount of resources and time to run - JS and Python I'm looking at you. Sad state of affairs when my fellow devs like you are now assuming Resource Intensive CI is somehow just a given now. "Save on merges..." ...wha?
@@JohnnySacc agreed, the amount of time I spend sharing control via a video call even when I'm not technicaly pairing dealing with problems with the call connection is a pain so it would be nice for me if there was low setup mechanism to be in the same space with imperceptible lag There's also potential for some interesting efficiencies if your working in the same feature but different modules, potentially allowing the LSP to flag ideas concretely to eachother in realtime where you're still building up the interface between modules so the need to explain ideas is low and the conversation can just be more about what your trying to achieve rather than what you just did
Hard disagree on the rust part. Its not going to perform as well as it should, and its going to be a nightmare to maintain and extend in the long term. Zed will fade into obscurity
It performs very well - I've used it quite a bit. It's noticably snappier than Emacs, VSCode and others. Not sure if you'd notice the difference against VIM, but then it does have a much richer UI. As for the maintainability piece, you may be right, I cannot say.
i don't get it. there's plenty of good fast editors. what's wrong with sublime text for example? its lightweight and instant and has lots of useful plugins
Sublime text is great, and I still rely on it for quickly poking around in SQL dumps. But it's held back in some ways due to it being made before certain features were figured out in the editor space. Particularly in features that are hard to add if they weren't already planned to be added when the editor was first made. For instance, it doesn't have any sharing features and AFAIK its plugins can't be as fast or sandboxed as something that runs in a wasm container.
@@spartanatreyu plugins are fast enough and i don't care if they're not sandboxed. sharing probably doesn't exist though so i guess if thhat's something you need, fair enough
Zed appears to be free and open source unlike Sublime. I also cannot think of another fast graphical editor, so it would be great to have more options.
@@JohnnySacc i think most people will say vscode is fast enough. and jetbrains products actually have 0 latency mode built in so they are really fast too.
@@JohnnySacc They don't seem to go for the extensible part though. Ain't nobody compiling to wasm. Sad, I really like the guy and loved the discussion.
Zed is the stupidest freaking thing I've ever seen. I don't need a text editor to be fast to be good at coding, what I need is good refactoring tools, discovery, and navigation. Not how fast I can fucking type.
Zed integrates language servers for every language - the exact same projects/code that gives VS Code its intellisense, navigation and refactoring features.
I mean it all matters. There’s too many development years into editors at this point that editors have tons of valuable features and the next editor has to compete against that and will have to catch up. Performance and language editing features are all important.
![[TH] 2024 PMGC League | Survival Stage วันที่ 1 | PUBG MOBILE Global Championship](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/FVFT-PFwU80/mqdefault.jpg)
In my opinion, the opening monologue/intro to this episode is a gold-standard for programming podcasts. The questions raised by the topic, especially the technical ones, as well as the delivery of said questions was superb. Very compelling, and really got me excited about the episode, because I knew from the intro that all my burning questions were going to be addressed. Awesome job, Kris. This podcast is fantastic.
You're a great host, Kris, and I'm usually amazed by the guests you bring on. Thanks for the great content!
Thanks! Glad you enjoy it. 😊
Kris, you are hands down, the best interviewer I’ve seen for programming related topics. Your questions and genuinely thoughtful and I love how much room you give the interviewee to answer the questions while you take it in. Wonderful stuff
Wow, thank you. That's really kind of you to say. ❤️😊
2:33 - holy shit that was smooth!
VERY much enjoyed this interview. Loved all the technical detail. All those were the very same questions I really wanted answered. Would love to have been even more technically deep. Sounds like such an interesting tool. Really loves this talk
This guy gives off the vibes of a funny drunk uncle at Christmas, who shakes your hand every five minutes. I love it.
I gave Zed a try several months ago and was impressed by the performance. It has become my go to editor for anything else, where I don't need special debugger features or tool chain support. My wish would be, make it the go to editor for Rust! Rust really needs a good editor with toolchain support and remote debugging. Here all the big players have issues or are very complex to handle. I know that because I use it all the time.
But for the record, great work! Zed is outstanding and I love it!
About the closing html tags - some (closing) tags are implicit and optional. Handling that correctly would be extra nifty.
If possible, would love to have someone from the warp terminal project on the show!
That's a great idea! Yes, I'll drop the team a line immediately. Thanks! 👍
You are the first Host that asked real questions like DSA and Project Design! God Bless You!
Always a pleasure watching Kris' interviews.
That was a very interesting watch. Thanks, Chris & Nathan. Just decided to spend a day working with Zed.
I work in a strongly regulated environment with heightened levels of security concerns, which has a tendency to be a little "isolationist," if you will. I've also said for a couple decades now that software development is a social endeavour, like any other creative acts have a strong social component. I absolutely loved the mentions here of the anthropological intersection. Concepts of subversion, of identity, of guile, of corruption, because of my work environment, are fascinating to me. On one hand, I think about orgs like ours being able to wrap the technology one day to leverage it within their isolated bubble, and on the other hand I think it would be so much more fascinating to think about how we might find ways to isolate and suppress those kinds of activities as a function of the technology itself. Is isolating a bad set of transformations from a hallucinating AI done asynchronously really any different functionally than an intentional set of malicious transformations by a subversive actor? At a lower level, what if these things were signed to ensure identity? So many fun questions.
Great interview, really got my brain engaged. Thanks Kris for the continued thoughtful way you engage in these interviews, and the guests you bring in with so many damn cool ideas :)
Look forward to watching this, as I do with any of them. Though before watching, I had a disk die about a month ago now, and I'd been talking about moving to Linux, just too lazy to do it. So this felt like the perfect opportunity, so I did. Prior to that I'd been using VSCode as my editor, and moving away from Windows, it didn't feel right to use it still, so I thought I'd try other things out there, and one of them was Zed, and every couple of days it seems to freeze on me, but given it starts so fast, it's as if I just alt-tabbed away, and back again, I've been pretty happy with using it for the last month so far. Though I'm not someone who thinks about workflow, or other things like that, so I never really took advantage of the extensions in VSCode for example (or at least not enough that I miss what I had there), so my move probably easier than many.
Bro like, became a text editor 😂 Respect the dedication!
I think for the "ambient awareness" social stuff they should maybe take some ideas from discord. I would sometimes have friends stream their work but actually have mic+headset muted (which is visible as an icon) - so you could join and look at what they do but they wouldn't get disturbed by you. Also different channels for different things, also both sides streaming at the same time. etc.
Nice to hear rope become more and more well known. I recall an ICFP contest where the challenge problem needed to be done using rope or it was nearly impossible, but easy with rope. Rope wasn't well known enough and some folks complained at the gotcha.
The editors "xi" and "lapce" use ropes as well IIRC
@@fredoverflow I'm pretty sure that most do.
@@evarlast Emacs and Eclipse use gap buffers.
IntelliJ uses ropes, too, I believe
great interview! chapters would be super helpful.
54:00 imagine a text editor getting a replay system before valorant does. that'd be funny
Ok
We've toyed around with the idea of being able to replay all of your edits in Zed!
I like Rust and Zed is looking good. I keep it updated. But my impression is that it's evolving slowly, possibly because Rust is slow for iterative development where you have to keep rethinking and redesigning how stuff works. It's not at the point where I want to use it for doing my actual coding in yet.
Excellent content, thanks! Lots of technical and design choices in Zed that feel "right" to me, I'll definitely try it - fingers crossed for a huge success!
Looking forward to this making it to Windows and trying it out
Sounds like they are using a take on a HAMT. Very cool!
Great as always Kris!
I miss the theme fade in at the intro and outro
Yeah, sorry about that. It's in there, but I mixed it too quietly this week. 🤦♂️
Consider to make the same with helix editor creator. I ended up using helix for everyday work. Its great
Another vscode that’s maybe faster probably won’t win the war.
Boy it would be a lot of fun to work on though!
fantastic podcast by the way!
Thanks!
using Neovide and I"m quite happy with it.
Are you using windows? Just curious
@@howdoiexitvim-sg2xl nope, macos (M1) :)
Great talk.
Until zed has plugins that can add the features that are must haves it is a cool toy.
Do you need GIT if you have the entire edit history in the file? Can it grow beyond a file to a project? Is this the future?
I really see no issues with vs code.. a new x code though.. that would be cool!
Why does vi not default to input mode when it starts? I do not use it for that reason. If I am the user of a software, I think that my preferences should be accommodated. That is, if I am expected to use it.
once they get a proper vim integration (directly connected like the neovim extension for vscode) and Linux support, I might switch from neovim. also just better keybinding support with keychords and stuff.
Everyone is too busy with building a nice cozy caravan while these guys are going straight for the Ferrari
Does it support Remote Development using SSH? Can it connect to linux box? Many people use VSCode to develop on Linux from MacBook Pro.
seems like zed still doesn’t have basic ide functionality such as drill down to function/class body in c++. It is yet another editor with just syntax highlighting
Odd - it works for me in other languages, so it should just be a question of whether your LSP server supports it...
I think that relies on LSP and C++ is probably the most difficult language to make a really good LSP for.
@@andrewdunbar828 C++ has a first class LSP - clangd. Zed integrates clangd, but there are a few major issues with the integration atm.
This guy is good vibes
You guys are really smart. A lot smarter than i am. I'm barley keeping up. I love it.
Zed sounds interesting, but I'm not buying a Mac to use it.
Linux and Windows releases can both be built from the source code.
the reality is who is zed for? people who have taken up vim/neovim for its configuration, speed, and simplicity zed will just never be able to compete. Maybe some of the vscode crowd or people looking for something in between vscode/vim? Even then i believe the reason a lot of people continue to use vs code is due to its integrations and ecosystem. Which means it would be a long long long time before zed gets there.
Notepad++ users, students, web dev
Need a windows release hopefully not too far in the future.
Alright, I'll give Zed a try.
Thanks for that very interesting discussion & insight in the Zed development. Sadly, it is so disrespectful that the guest is regularly muted away...
No disrespect was intended. Sadly there were a few places where we talked over each other-almost inevitable on a transatlantic conversation-and for clarity's sake I muted Nathan or myself.
I _try_ to be impartial on that,and just pick whichever side kept the conversation flowing best in that moment. 🙂
Them implementing AI stuff before a lot of other features just doesn't sit well with me. I think this is more like a jetbrains ide or maybe i think jetbrains fleet. But this is definitely not an editor that will become the top editor instead of vscode or even neovim.
You must implement AI if you want to be on the hype train or attract investor money. :(
AI needs so much infrastructure for its value to be fully realized. I’m starting to realize this. Probabilistic stochastic pattern matching machines still need stateful, reliable infrastructure to serve its users best. Platforms like iOS have so much reliable infrastructure and features for it to really deliver a tailored user experience with integration.
I liked Atom, but left it for Sublime Text
10:52
sure, but there is just no way this beats nvim + tmux for me. like it's not in the ballpark.
TIL Zed is the opposite of everything i look for in an editor -- no git or plugins + live collab + LLMs? What is this - an editor for Gen Z?
It really makes absolutely no sense at all. Like no refactoring capability? If I don't like the name of a function do you seriously expect me to do a find and replace? I mean I was doing that back in 2000, but now we have actually smart tools that can do that properly. I mean wtf?
And also no editin capability?? Just watching random text appearing or changing without being able to do anything??
Did Microsoft buy GitHub solely to give atom the axe? Lmao
I think it's more that they bought Github and didn't care what extras it came with. 😁
What the actual f, when the guy was talking about segment trees/fold maps I did not understand literally anything. Judging by the reaction of the host, I don't think he understood much either. At around 13:20. Lots of hand gestures, trapezoids, ropes, CRDT's -- I guess the guest expects all viewers to be writing high performance text editors on their spare time, but I doubt it's the case..
Programming, like writing or maths, is not real-time collaborative.
Exactly - the focus on collaboration features has largely been misguided, often times just straight up goofy and useless
That's just not true. I've done lots of pair programming, both in personal and professional work. It sounds pretty neat to be able to work on the same branch at the same time. Saves on merges which saves on CI which saves on time and resources.
@@JohnnySacc You could also just not use a language that requires a massive build system and unreasonable amount of resources and time to run - JS and Python I'm looking at you.
Sad state of affairs when my fellow devs like you are now assuming Resource Intensive CI is somehow just a given now.
"Save on merges..." ...wha?
@@JohnnySacc agreed, the amount of time I spend sharing control via a video call even when I'm not technicaly pairing dealing with problems with the call connection is a pain so it would be nice for me if there was low setup mechanism to be in the same space with imperceptible lag
There's also potential for some interesting efficiencies if your working in the same feature but different modules, potentially allowing the LSP to flag ideas concretely to eachother in realtime where you're still building up the interface between modules so the need to explain ideas is low and the conversation can just be more about what your trying to achieve rather than what you just did
@@JohnnySaccI agree, being able to properly pair program over a call is awesome. It's not a daily basis thing, buts it's pretty nice.
First, nice
Last
By assuming windows doesn’t exist?
Hard disagree on the rust part. Its not going to perform as well as it should, and its going to be a nightmare to maintain and extend in the long term.
Zed will fade into obscurity
from high productivity js to low productivity rust….
It performs very well - I've used it quite a bit. It's noticably snappier than Emacs, VSCode and others. Not sure if you'd notice the difference against VIM, but then it does have a much richer UI. As for the maintainability piece, you may be right, I cannot say.
i don't get it. there's plenty of good fast editors. what's wrong with sublime text for example? its lightweight and instant and has lots of useful plugins
Sublime text is great, and I still rely on it for quickly poking around in SQL dumps.
But it's held back in some ways due to it being made before certain features were figured out in the editor space. Particularly in features that are hard to add if they weren't already planned to be added when the editor was first made.
For instance, it doesn't have any sharing features and AFAIK its plugins can't be as fast or sandboxed as something that runs in a wasm container.
@@spartanatreyu plugins are fast enough and i don't care if they're not sandboxed. sharing probably doesn't exist though so i guess if thhat's something you need, fair enough
Zed appears to be free and open source unlike Sublime. I also cannot think of another fast graphical editor, so it would be great to have more options.
@@_starfarerNotepad++, Kate, Geany, Gedit, Vim
zed is a little too late
Way too late. And the extensions are coming at a crawl. By the time it’s viable i will have mastered both Vim & Sublime.
Fast, extensible, cross platform. Every editor on the market now let's you pick two, zed is the first going for all three.
@@JohnnySacc i think most people will say vscode is fast enough. and jetbrains products actually have 0 latency mode built in so they are really fast too.
@@JohnnySacc *ahem* what about NEOVIM
@@JohnnySacc They don't seem to go for the extensible part though. Ain't nobody compiling to wasm. Sad, I really like the guy and loved the discussion.
so tired of the mac-peepl doing the mac-peepl thing.
Zed is the stupidest freaking thing I've ever seen. I don't need a text editor to be fast to be good at coding, what I need is good refactoring tools, discovery, and navigation. Not how fast I can fucking type.
Zed integrates language servers for every language - the exact same projects/code that gives VS Code its intellisense, navigation and refactoring features.
I mean it all matters. There’s too many development years into editors at this point that editors have tons of valuable features and the next editor has to compete against that and will have to catch up. Performance and language editing features are all important.
frustrating the number of “… anyway.” … in the middle of sentences.