Palos Verdes High School yearbook controversy
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 26 ส.ค. 2024
- A yearbook at a Southern California high school is the subject of controversy after an article about Israel’s war with Hamas was included in the printing, prompting some students and parents to say the editorial is harmful to the local Jewish community. KTLA's Rachel Menitoff reports on June 4, 2024.
Details: ktla.com/news/...
KTLA 5 News - Keeping Southern Californians informed since 1947.
Man, I grew up so poor I couldn't even afford the yearbook. I could barely buy the pack with the graduation gown and such. These kids today are something else.
I couldn't afford mine either.
Fire the teacher who approved it.
yeah, they’re a lot less apathetic
It could have gone in the student newspaper, yes?
I love how she was able to fit thousands of years of history into one page. Amazing.
Vulgar and disgusting hate speech. Shame on you!
@@janeparish6507where's the hate? Did you read it?
@janeparish6507
Have you read it?
All I read was truth. There is no hate. It’s interesting , every time someone gets grumpy and doesn’t want to hear the truth, they call it antisemitism 😂 or antisemitic. Ya’ll are abusing that word🤣
@@janeparish6507 Didn't get your way Huh 🤔🤔
wait until a NATIVE AMERICAN writes a same opinion with the same title...
Perfect.
💯 True
and are you not from ALIGARH INDIA?
overreaction. Seriously? free speech people
the facts .... JUST the facts.....
Why does this belong in a yearbook? I would say the same thing of it were pro-Israel.
A learning experience? I thought yearbooks were just pictures and awards. Who changed and approved that?
There shouldn't be anything political in a high school yearbook for pete's sake, end of story.
K-12 is political as fuq🤔
We didn't even have any essays of any kind in the yearbook We just had a bunch of photos and captions (JV softball team) We didn't even have senior quotes cuz there was about 4,000 of us.
So who approved the year book?
I wish i lived in a place where this was the biggest issue in my city...
You can have a bunch of issues going on at the same time. I mean duhhhhh!!!
lol. true. This is so overblown
Obviously it's not the biggest issue
This should not be in a yearbook.
This feels like such a publicity stunt. 🤡🤦🏼♀️
You are way ahead of Me 👍 it's always this very look at the USC story yesterday??
The student-writer and the teacher who approved the article have not responded to a request to be interviewed. Shocker! 😮 Typical.
Shine a light on a bully, ask them to take responsibility for their words and actions and they are nowhere to be found. Cowards!
A yearbook isn't the place for such speech.
Just because you're against a genocidal army doesn't mean you're anti-Semitic because they happen to be Jewish. But at the same time my high school never had any type of essays like this in our yearbook. It was school photos and then clubs and sports and Senior superlatives and photos from homecoming and prom. That was it.
If you think the IDF is genocidal you need a quick trip to the dictionary. Then you need to read the Hamas charter.
Free speech, yes. Yearbook, no.
Can’t go saying anything against the most protected and powerful group in the world, right?
^ true
No, it's not about that, it's about content that belongs in a yearbook and content that doesn't. If this person wanted to publish their opinion piece it belongs in the school newspaper and not the Yearbook. You obviously have no clue what yearbooks are for...there to preserve our memories of the time we spent in school, not for political rhetoric. And no, you're definitely not a scholar since you know so little.
AIPAC HAVE SOOOOO MUCH POWER THAT'S UNDENIABLE
Sure you can. But this doesn't belong in a yearbook.
Ole california the most old Mexico state LEFTOVERS I america I see 🤡 🌮 🌯
❤❤ as far as I know it's a Freeeeeee Country
Does the truth hurt. Thank you young lady.
How did an editorial piece get published in a high school yearbook? No offense to the writer but, this op ed belongs on a campus newspaper.
Also what are you going to shell out another 70 bucks for another reprint?
This should never be in a year book. There is usually a year book community. They would have to approve this article not just a teacher. What student would want this in their yesrbook. The books are about Good memories!
Palos Verdes has a bunch of snobby kids because of their egotistic parents. Horrible
Palestine article, Harrassment, "Free Speech"
If THIS ain't [HATE SPEECH!!! HATE SPEECH!!!] I don't know WHAT is.
This isn’t anti-Semitic. It’s anti-Palestinian.
there shouldn't be anything political in a high school yearbook, end of story
More hateful ignorance - get a life!
@@janeparish6507 What hate? Oh! You’re one of those.
the girl seemed so happy to be getting attention smh
Facts become hateful rhetoric. We're in the clown timeline i see.
Describing this as a free-speech issue is as nonsensical as the decision to place this political essay in the yearbook. Comes across as someone using a yearbook of all things as an opportunity to force-feed ideology to other students and their families. Incredible that this decision was able to get cleared and approved. It's not about free speech, its about respect, and choosing the appropriate mode, time, and place. Teacher(s) who thought this was a good idea have a screw loose in the head.
Right
the person at the 01:28 mark … his eyes … what the hell…??? 😮😮
FREEDOM OF SPEECH
Whoever is against the first amendment, let it be known now.
Yeah good luck with that at a private workplace or a school. See if you can say bigoted or offensive things to your peers at your job and not get suspended or fired, Mr. Freedom of Speech. FoS only exists in a public place, and even there you might face consequences for speaking your opinion. Most business and a lot of schools are privately owned, meaning they can control what you can or cannot say.
why should a political article be in a high school yearbook in the first place?
Good!!!
Regardless of switch side your on, there is a place and time.
She’s a badass. Saw the opportunity and took it. Raising awareness too. Love that it was printed and there’s no undoing
This “kid” that wrote this doesn’t have a clue.
Allowing something like this content in yearbook is not just controversial but traumatic for many students. Education has gone far left with no truth or justice.
What was the school board thinking? What was the positive outcome of such a one sided view of such an article, bulling, harassment and division ? This article should have been in the school newspaper so kids with opposing views could debate it. This article does not belong in any high school yearbook. It has nothing to do with free speech. Someone should loose their job.
Democrat Utopia…. Wanna bet the School won’t allow the Opposite View point article…
I am a Democrat and support Israel
@@fremontpathfinder8463 sad… but the Democrats have been hijacked by crazy people who believe “men can give birth” and “sex changes” for minors is good for children….
@@fremontpathfinder8463 we know.
Not in the yearbook 😮 why wasn't it checked page by page before printing 🤨🧐🤔
🤦♂️
Ephesians 6:12
New King James Version
For we do not wrestle against flesh and blood, but against principalities, against powers, against the rulers of the darkness of this age, against spiritual hosts of wickedness in the heavenly places.
2 Samuel 14:17
New King James Version
Your maidservant said, ‘The word of my lord the king will now be comforting; for as the angel of God, so is my lord the king in discerning good and evil. And may the Lord your God be with you.’ ”
Exodus 20:13
New King James Version
13 “You shall not murder.
Romans 6:10
New King James Version
10 For the death that He died, He died to sin once for all; but the life that He lives, He lives to God.
Romans 4:4
New King James Version
Now to him who works, the wages are not counted as grace but as debt.
Psalm 56:5-7
New King James Version
5 All day they twist my words;
All their thoughts are against me for evil.
6 They gather together,
They hide, they mark my steps,
When they lie in wait for my life.
7 Shall they escape by iniquity?
In anger cast down the peoples, O God!
John 14:13-14 ESV
Whatever you ask in my name, this I will do, that the Father may be glorified in the Son. If you ask me anything in my name, I will do it.
Matthew 24:7
New King James Version
7 For nation will rise against nation, and kingdom against kingdom. And there will be famines, pestilences, and earthquakes in various places.
That is horrible... what happened on October 7th- the 3rd intifada on Israel- it was horrible- inhuman... what happened to people learning world history??? What are they teaching there? How big is the Muslim community that this was shoved down their throats in school? What the hell is going on in P.V.?????
This is a stupid news story
You kids need to be just kids before you regret not being able to live to be one to the fullest.
Crying bully 😂👍✌️
USA ! F the rest.