Me at the beginning: I wondering what number 1 will be? Me: Wow the Jeff Blim appreciation is coming through I enjoy it Me: She really likes the characters that Jamie plays, especially Charlotte... Me:...I know what number 1 is jfkdsla;fjdskl For real though, Charlotte deserves the hype, that song slaps
inevitable is my favourite song for some reason, it’s been stuck in my head loads recently. I love how all the previous songs connect with each other, the entertaining / upbeat lyrics alongside Emma’s screaming and crying is just so gOOD
also!! emma screams when paul starts singing show stopping number because he wasn't there, so the only way he knows it if he's infected! that's how she knows he's really infected!!! i love this musical so much!!!
Your video reminded me just how much more DEVASTATING Inevitable is in the TH-cam version than the soundtrack. Don’t get me wrong, Inevitable is horrifying there too, but Emma’s breakdown is much more apparent in the live version. I’m this close to crying! (Also - wow, I forgot how touchy the Infected were in Let It Out. Bad, Pokey. Get away from Paul right now, please!)
Our rankings may be different within the community but our love for Charlotte is universal. Also just a thought, since the alien is a hivemind wouldn't it make sense if Deb and the other school kids were singing join us (and die) to Alice at the same time? makes sense why she was so shaken up on the phone with Bill
In moments like these, I wonder if we are hive. Although I thought, that when Alice saw Deb first, Deb sang to her first four lines of "I'm not your girl anymore" and then, after Alice said "Deb, you are scaring me", in sync with Charlotte, Deb sang Join us (and die) (it is extremely good coincidence, that both played by Jaime Lyn Beauty)
This ranking is great, and I love the lyrics in La Dee Da Day because both the homeless guy and greenpeace girls verses reference their “new bodies” and its excellent foreshadowing
join us (and die) is such a good song, the choice i strongly disagree with is that 2nd and 3rd should be switched. but all should be pushed down a rank for the best song: the beginning of moana
You are so fucking right, I don’t know if I’d have the strength to put You tied up my heart so high because it makes me very sad when I think about it for too long but damn, just love to see some Jaime appreciation
I just really try to appreciate it as its own thing! It's an EXCELLENT performance by Jeff and also Jaime's reaction to it, and I just really enjoy it so much.
Oh you hurt me with that "Ted Spankoffski DOES have a song after all guys!" joke. I love Time Bastard so much but it gives me the feeling of "ow this hurts me" that you have with Inevitable.
I love this list so much- First of all, I think You Tied Up My Heart is very underrated- ALSO YES JOIN US (AND DIE) APPRECIATION. I'M SO GLAD SOMEONE ELSE LOVES THIS SONG AS MUCH AS I DO-
Ok so here is the thing about not your seed, how I interpreted this song is that it’s not Alice anymore. It’s like saying since Charlotte said those things in her song she’s an awful person. It’s the monster manipulating Bill into wanting to kill himself. Like how she said “I’m fucking 17” when Bill said in the beginning of the show that she was 18. That’s not Alice anymore. I actually really like not your seed, but everyone has there own opinion I get that, this is just mine.
I was slightly shocked by show stopping number being third - I knew it wouldn't be first because of the controversial marking, and so I literally sat there like "I SWEAR TO GOD, IF JOIN US AND DIE ISN'T TOP OF THIS LIST...."
tbh i get not your seed being upsetting because Zombie!Alice is so so so horrible to bill but i watch it anyway bc corey's acting in it is torturous in a good way. ALSO someone agrees with me that zoey being the pilot makes no sense yay
ok watched ur commentary on inevitable and now i'm SAD i love all the hatchetfield characters sm and i want them to be happy if nerdy prudes must die has a sad ending again im gonna write so much fanfiction. btw i love your videos so much, am currently binging them :)
I'm glad you think that, I keep convincing myself that I've way overdone that joke by now but every time I do include it, people seem to enjoy it so I just keep doing it.
I’ve been making those jokes for so many videos I’m afraid people get bored of them but every damn time, everyone seems to be loving them so I keep shoving those in lmao
3:47 the appreciation of nora's strap game, hell yes this is queer representation in media 😍 i'm having so much fun revisiting older starkid shows now that the new show has come out, super glad i found this channel and can't wait to see if there will be a nerdy prudes ranking in the future!
@@GoodMorningButch wait do you not like Mariah? Did she do something that I don’t know about or do you just not like her characters? Or her voice? Idk, I’m so confused
@@GoodMorningButchjust stumbled upon this 2 years late, but um..MARIAH IS THE BEST HUMAN BEING THAT EVER STEPPED ON THIS PLANET. like wth is wrong with u
Join us and die is also my favorite! But I’m sorry I can’t understand not your seed in the slightest 😭 have you seen watcher world? Or listened to the lyrics?? I love Bill but he’s very overprotective and neglectful of Alice (he literally calls her the wrong age earlier in the play, hence the “I’m fucking seventeen” line). They both have their problems with each other that they need to work out, but Alice has every right to feel abandoned or mean, especially if she’s infected with an alien parasite.
HC that zombie/alien! Charlotte and Sam WERE going to kill Bill in JUAD but then Emma said he had a daughter- the hivemind likes killing people through who would hurt them the MOST (Sam killed Charlotte; Charlotte was about to kill Ted; Hidgen's friends killed him etc.)
@@paloma-alfaro I thought of those after the comment! also Alice would've killed Paul (he used to babysit her+ she knows him well enough that Bill felt comfortable saying she looked up to Paul). Deb presumably killed Alice; Zoey presumably killed Nora.
I actually agree with Not Your Seed. I feel it would've been more effective if we'd had more than...3 minutes? with Alice beforehand, or if the dad had a part too about how sorry he feels. Also "not your girl" sung by Deb and smoke club girl sounds like "nacho girl" and it really throws me off
TDLR: Agree with all the things your wrote in your video 6:02 agreed with that statement. Also Jeff appreciation !! And Jaime's !! Robert's amazing talent of doing a siren 😲 9:55 same. Lauren is an amazing dancer and about Nora I feeled you. Agreed with all the thing you wrote on #3, #2. Hehe Tumblr. Yes #1 (the shot's good and creepy, that's TGWDLM) !!!!! Also at 10:40 (ish) I always thought that Joey helped Robert to rise up at the right time 🤨
CETTE CHANSON A CHANGÉ LE COURS DU MONDE, NON JE N'EN DÉMORDRAI JAMAIS CAR ELLE EST ABSOLUMENT PARFAITE j'aime juste trop trop Charlotte et chaque moment où elle est sur scène lol
@@GoodMorningButch moi aussi. La première fois que j'ai regardé la comédie musicale elle était le seul personnage à qui je me suis attaché et elle est morte 2 fois Et c'est pour ça que je n'aime pas beaucoup Sam et le professeur.
My favorite part of What Do You Want, Paul? is that Jon said most of Paul's interjections are/were improvised Like the shit he comes up with is just so hilarious
Inevitable Let it out The guy who didn’t like musicals Join us and die Show me those hands Cup of poisoned coffee America is great again Lah Dee dah day What do you want Paul Cup of roasted coffee Show stopping number Let him come Not your seed You tied up my heart
i agree with you on "Show-stopping number not sure if it is also because I'm a lesbian but yeah it's not my favorite. I do love how much ted is into it though
I am going to be completely honest your ranking is the best I ever watched I completely agree with it your do truly spot the absolute best with this musical. Me to think that “A show stopping number” is a little bit overrated but Jamie and Jeff fucking owns a this shit like seriously they are more than angels. I know that I am to years late with your post and you probably not even gonna read the his comment but I got into tghdlm like this summer and I have fucking loved it sins. I have also watched everything in the hatchetfield series so your little quotes really landed like your joke about Paul’s clones. I would really appreciate if you took time to read this comment but I think understand if you don’t have time. Join Us (And Die) will forever stay in our hearts 🫶
I’m so happy you agree with the ranking and for your very nice words! I may not be very active on youtube anymore but this is the account with which I browse it as a viewer so I see every comment and they still warm my heart :)
lol I wish her the best in life, I'm sure she's a lovely person, but I can't say I've felt anything other than annoyance and boredom at any of her performances in anything lol
Man that placement of Inevitable made me, well, really angry. But your reasoning was completely fair. Edit: Finished the video. This is certainly the least traditional ranking I've ever seen, but its still a really good one.
Me at the beginning: I wondering what number 1 will be?
Me: Wow the Jeff Blim appreciation is coming through I enjoy it
Me: She really likes the characters that Jamie plays, especially Charlotte...
Me:...I know what number 1 is
jfkdsla;fjdskl For real though, Charlotte deserves the hype, that song slaps
inevitable is my favourite song for some reason, it’s been stuck in my head loads recently. I love how all the previous songs connect with each other, the entertaining / upbeat lyrics alongside Emma’s screaming and crying is just so gOOD
Ooo hit us with that Jeff appreciation girl
He's so good and talented and has such a gorgeous voice 😔
I still can't believe Aladdin, Sweet Tooth and McNamara are the same person
also!! emma screams when paul starts singing show stopping number because he wasn't there, so the only way he knows it if he's infected! that's how she knows he's really infected!!! i love this musical so much!!!
Your video reminded me just how much more DEVASTATING Inevitable is in the TH-cam version than the soundtrack. Don’t get me wrong, Inevitable is horrifying there too, but Emma’s breakdown is much more apparent in the live version. I’m this close to crying!
(Also - wow, I forgot how touchy the Infected were in Let It Out. Bad, Pokey. Get away from Paul right now, please!)
Our rankings may be different within the community but our love for Charlotte is universal. Also just a thought, since the alien is a hivemind wouldn't it make sense if Deb and the other school kids were singing join us (and die) to Alice at the same time? makes sense why she was so shaken up on the phone with Bill
In moments like these, I wonder if we are hive.
Although I thought, that when Alice saw Deb first, Deb sang to her first four lines of "I'm not your girl anymore" and then, after Alice said "Deb, you are scaring me", in sync with Charlotte, Deb sang Join us (and die) (it is extremely good coincidence, that both played by Jaime Lyn Beauty)
This ranking is great, and I love the lyrics in La Dee Da Day because both the homeless guy and greenpeace girls verses reference their “new bodies” and its excellent foreshadowing
I do disagree with some of your rankings, but I am 100% in agreement about "Join us (and die)"
It's SUCH a good song!!!
join us (and die) is such a good song, the choice i strongly disagree with is that 2nd and 3rd should be switched. but all should be pushed down a rank for the best song:
the beginning of moana
Same
let Emma sing PAUL
ALSO YES LET IT OUT IN TOP TEN AND JOIN US AND DIE APPRECIATION
You are so fucking right, I don’t know if I’d have the strength to put You tied up my heart so high because it makes me very sad when I think about it for too long but damn, just love to see some Jaime appreciation
I just really try to appreciate it as its own thing! It's an EXCELLENT performance by Jeff and also Jaime's reaction to it, and I just really enjoy it so much.
I am here for all the Jeff Blim appreciation. I also guessed your number 1 choice.
I just want Charlotte to rip me to shreds is it that much to ask???
@@GoodMorningButch not at all
Join Us (And Die) finally getting the ranking it deserves
Fr
Oh you hurt me with that "Ted Spankoffski DOES have a song after all guys!" joke. I love Time Bastard so much but it gives me the feeling of "ow this hurts me" that you have with Inevitable.
We’re all grieving our Time Bastard yes :(
I love this list so much-
First of all, I think You Tied Up My Heart is very underrated-
ALSO YES JOIN US (AND DIE) APPRECIATION. I'M SO GLAD SOMEONE ELSE LOVES THIS SONG AS MUCH AS I DO-
Ok so here is the thing about not your seed, how I interpreted this song is that it’s not Alice anymore. It’s like saying since Charlotte said those things in her song she’s an awful person. It’s the monster manipulating Bill into wanting to kill himself. Like how she said “I’m fucking 17” when Bill said in the beginning of the show that she was 18. That’s not Alice anymore. I actually really like not your seed, but everyone has there own opinion I get that, this is just mine.
I was slightly shocked by show stopping number being third - I knew it wouldn't be first because of the controversial marking, and so I literally sat there like "I SWEAR TO GOD, IF JOIN US AND DIE ISN'T TOP OF THIS LIST...."
eternally thank you for ranking You Tied Up My Heart so highly that song genuinely slaps and it is severely underrated
It’s SO DAMN GOOD!!!!!
Cannot believe the beginning of Moana is so low 😔
Wait,,, bills singing "its the circle of life" and hatchetfield might be in a time loop of like destruction and shit,,,, hmm,,,
holy shiiiiiiiiiiiitttt!!!!
YES I LOVE JEFF SM HES SO INSANELY TALENTED
PUTTING NOT YOUR SEED UNDER "THE BEGINNING OF MOANA" IS W I L D
tbh i get not your seed being upsetting because Zombie!Alice is so so so horrible to bill but i watch it anyway bc corey's acting in it is torturous in a good way. ALSO someone agrees with me that zoey being the pilot makes no sense yay
ok watched ur commentary on inevitable and now i'm SAD i love all the hatchetfield characters sm and i want them to be happy if nerdy prudes must die has a sad ending again im gonna write so much fanfiction. btw i love your videos so much, am currently binging them :)
yours is the only opinion on starkid shows besides my own that i trust completely.. lesbian solidarity
also the tumblr joke absolutely killed me because that is EXACTLY what i always think on that line klfsdjklsjdfkls
Every time you do the "me at the club" I giggle uncontrollably.
I'm glad you think that, I keep convincing myself that I've way overdone that joke by now but every time I do include it, people seem to enjoy it so I just keep doing it.
It's so interesting to see your reasons for the rankings.
(Also I love and miss your videos I'm so happy for this one!!!!!!)
I would have a lot of songs placed differently maybe but honestly you made Join Us (And Die) number one and i really appreciate that
I’m so glad they used America is Great Again as some kind of theme for McNamara in Black Friday
YESSSS JOIN US AND DIE IS LITERALLY MY FAVORITE SONG ESPECIALLY THE PART WITH "KICK HIM, PUNCH HIM" AND THE "ALL U GOTTA DO IS" AT 16:30 AND 17:15
Listen I’m a lesbian, however Jeff Blim and Robert Manion hit different in this show
It’s the talent, there’s no attraction behind it but I can recognize pure skill
So when are you gonna crack and deliver that Jaime Lyn Beatty song ranking we all know you want to do?
legit I already have the ranking ready I just gotta actually do it... same for Dylan...
I need this
I'm sorry but that "me at the club" in let it out was the peak of comedy
I’ve been making those jokes for so many videos I’m afraid people get bored of them but every damn time, everyone seems to be loving them so I keep shoving those in lmao
This just looks like you have a vendetta against Mariah but you know you balanced it with the Jamie and Jeff appreciation
oo i like that you use the tiny songs :)
I think that the only true controversial take of this video is the absolute slander of The Beginning of Moana
YALL AT 15:45 I JUST REALIZED CHAROLETTE GOES “yes Ted” WHAT.
IT’S VERY IMPORTANT
3:47 the appreciation of nora's strap game, hell yes this is queer representation in media 😍 i'm having so much fun revisiting older starkid shows now that the new show has come out, super glad i found this channel and can't wait to see if there will be a nerdy prudes ranking in the future!
WOOOOO I AM HERE FOR THIS
This is an extremely controversial ranking but finally someone agrees with me on my ranking of Not Your Seed
lol I hate it, I'm glad for others if they enjoy it but I just actively dislike any moment Alice (or any mrf let's be real) is on stage 🤷♀️
@@GoodMorningButch wait do you not like Mariah? Did she do something that I don’t know about or do you just not like her characters? Or her voice? Idk, I’m so confused
@@GoodMorningButchjust stumbled upon this 2 years late, but um..MARIAH IS THE BEST HUMAN BEING THAT EVER STEPPED ON THIS PLANET. like wth is wrong with u
"HERE'S HOW UTS GONNA-"
*SHOTGUN*
"OOWAAOOOOOOOOOOOOOOH"
*SHOTGUN*
Join us and die is also my favorite! But I’m sorry I can’t understand not your seed in the slightest 😭 have you seen watcher world? Or listened to the lyrics?? I love Bill but he’s very overprotective and neglectful of Alice (he literally calls her the wrong age earlier in the play, hence the “I’m fucking seventeen” line). They both have their problems with each other that they need to work out, but Alice has every right to feel abandoned or mean, especially if she’s infected with an alien parasite.
finally someone who doesn’t hate ‘you tied up my heart’
also people should appreciate jeff more :)
thanks for giving him the adequate appreciation
HC that zombie/alien! Charlotte and Sam WERE going to kill Bill in JUAD but then Emma said he had a daughter- the hivemind likes killing people through who would hurt them the MOST (Sam killed Charlotte; Charlotte was about to kill Ted; Hidgen's friends killed him etc.)
😭😭😭😭😭 Hi I'm so sad now
Alice killed Bill
And Paul killed Emma
@@paloma-alfaro I thought of those after the comment! also Alice would've killed Paul (he used to babysit her+ she knows him well enough that Bill felt comfortable saying she looked up to Paul). Deb presumably killed Alice; Zoey presumably killed Nora.
Annnnnnnnnd I need to rewatch all of their things now
Jeff Blim (and mr Davidson) appreciation hell yeah!
only recently did the line " i hire you pauls " hit me . and it hit me HARD .
idk why but the "i hate zoey" in the beginning made me laugh so hard i needed to pause
join us and die is, too, my favorite song from this musical, is sooooooo gooooooooood ;u;
Yes! Why is it Zoey in the helicopter?
i completely agree with ur first choice also thst show stopping number is lower. ngl im kinda sick of it after how many ppl constantly talk about it.
hell yes TASTE with that number one!!
callout: op just loves high femmes SO much /lh
how you doing mariah like that 😔
I'm sorry Mariah I'm sure you're a wonderful person irl
I just noticed that, for someone who doesn't like musicals, Paul sings Moana the best out of the four of them
oh I am HERE for the jaime thirsting
I actually think this rating is spot on! IDK if you've done one already or not, but could you please do a ranking of starship songs?
please if ur still a starkid fan, i NEED a npmd ranking
I actually agree with Not Your Seed. I feel it would've been more effective if we'd had more than...3 minutes? with Alice beforehand, or if the dad had a part too about how sorry he feels.
Also "not your girl" sung by Deb and smoke club girl sounds like "nacho girl" and it really throws me off
0:49 I only just realised they do the dabbing/ vampire thing there too
Okay but I like 100% agree with your ranking
I know I can't be the only one who's obsessed with Charlotte and can't stand mrf lol
@@GoodMorningButch Charlotte deserves the world and honestly I would gladly give it to her,,, plus Jamie and Jeff make my bi self go absolutely feral
black coffee has a full version in ep 1 of nightmare time 2
TDLR: Agree with all the things your wrote in your video
6:02 agreed with that statement. Also Jeff appreciation !! And Jaime's !! Robert's amazing talent of doing a siren 😲 9:55 same. Lauren is an amazing dancer and about Nora I feeled you. Agreed with all the thing you wrote on #3, #2. Hehe Tumblr. Yes #1 (the shot's good and creepy, that's TGWDLM) !!!!!
Also at 10:40 (ish) I always thought that Joey helped Robert to rise up at the right time 🤨
I respect your opinions. Lesbian supporting lesbians. (How many are in this fandom and is it because of Lauren Lopez's arms in Firebringer?)
For me it’s all about Meredith’s round cheeks and smile but yes
@@GoodMorningButch THAT TOO
Im here because of mariah rose faith and jaime
Ummm..
I've been brewing up your coffee is above not your seed.
Yeah she really brewed that coffee just right, man
I am personally offended at the ranking for Let It Out (nsrs) but i think that one’s just me, otherwise not too controversial a ranking
Je suis totalement d'accord pour le #1 et #2
C'est le premier classements que je trouve avec mon préféré en première place 🤩
CETTE CHANSON A CHANGÉ LE COURS DU MONDE, NON JE N'EN DÉMORDRAI JAMAIS CAR ELLE EST ABSOLUMENT PARFAITE j'aime juste trop trop Charlotte et chaque moment où elle est sur scène lol
@@GoodMorningButch
moi aussi.
La première fois que j'ai regardé la comédie musicale elle était le seul personnage à qui je me suis attaché et elle est morte 2 fois
Et c'est pour ça que je n'aime pas beaucoup Sam et le professeur.
I couldn’t disagree with not your seed it’s in my top 5 but to each their own.
My favorite part of What Do You Want, Paul? is that Jon said most of Paul's interjections are/were improvised
Like the shit he comes up with is just so hilarious
Inevitable
Let it out
The guy who didn’t like musicals
Join us and die
Show me those hands
Cup of poisoned coffee
America is great again
Lah Dee dah day
What do you want Paul
Cup of roasted coffee
Show stopping number
Let him come
Not your seed
You tied up my heart
girl i get it i too desire charlotte carnally 😤
Yes! I do not like Not Your Seed AT ALL. I’m so glad someone agrees on it being so low! And join us and die being so high warms my heart as well.
There’s SEVERAL of us lmao
Charlotte appreciation:3
When will u do npmd
For some reason I interpreted “I hate Zoey” at the beginning as “I hate Mariah”, and almost threw some punches
Haha zero hate to anyone on Team Starkid :)
i feel like i’m missing something, can someone explain what “jane a car’ is?
Jane's A Car is my favorite story from Nightmare Time, which are Hatchetfield stories released on TH-cam that aren't stage musical.
mann, inevitable is my fav song lmao
There's all sorts of taste! I'm glad others think differently, we're all unique human beings, this is just my subjective order
Jon, Robert and Jeff are the only people keeping me going
i agree with you on "Show-stopping number not sure if it is also because I'm a lesbian but yeah it's not my favorite. I do love how much ted is into it though
2:30 - so kind of like Charlotte?
Too soon
@@GoodMorningButch soon is not an option for me :)
Blessed be the Jeff Blim appreciation
I appreciate him really hard
Every single one of the starkids people I am extremely and utterly attracted to
Controversial? I just see Hatchetfield facts, nothing wrong here. Best boys: Paul, McNamara, and Hidgens.
lol everyone is just so obsessed with mrf and I can’t stand any moment she’s on stage
@@GoodMorningButch why D: do you just not like her acting/voice or did she do something?
I am going to be completely honest your ranking is the best I ever watched I completely agree with it your do truly spot the absolute best with this musical. Me to think that “A show stopping number” is a little bit overrated but Jamie and Jeff fucking owns a this shit like seriously they are more than angels.
I know that I am to years late with your post and you probably not even gonna read the his comment but I got into tghdlm like this summer and I have fucking loved it sins. I have also watched everything in the hatchetfield series so your little quotes really landed like your joke about Paul’s clones. I would really appreciate if you took time to read this comment but I think understand if you don’t have time. Join Us (And Die) will forever stay in our hearts 🫶
I’m so happy you agree with the ranking and for your very nice words! I may not be very active on youtube anymore but this is the account with which I browse it as a viewer so I see every comment and they still warm my heart :)
SHIT WAIT YOU MEAN TO TELL ME 'TED' IS SHORT FOR 'THEODORE' I SHARE A NAME WITH TED SPANKOFFSKI????
I… don’t know how you went your whole life without knowing that…
@@GoodMorningButch neither do I, it just never occurred to me that 'Ted' could be short for 'Theodore'
You're last name is spankoffski? Wow im so sorry
@@bi_beans9011 Im sorry, I'm bad at this but were you joking or not-
@@possums154 yes
dang you got something against Mariah LOL
lol I wish her the best in life, I'm sure she's a lovely person, but I can't say I've felt anything other than annoyance and boredom at any of her performances in anything lol
@@GoodMorningButch that's fair
LOL PHANTOM
You really don't like the actress who played Alice/Zoey do you
lol I don't
Thompson Jason Hernandez Mary Clark Jose
BaRiSta yEaH
Man that placement of Inevitable made me, well, really angry. But your reasoning was completely fair.
Edit: Finished the video. This is certainly the least traditional ranking I've ever seen, but its still a really good one.
lol people are gonna disagree with you and I did title this as controversial because most of fandom agrees with you
@@GoodMorningButch Yeah fair enough lol.
joey richter is why i am gay
Walker Daniel Taylor Betty Perez Sandra
I hate Sam/Charlotte, but infected!Sam/infected!Charlotte are the best
Rodriguez Ruth Martin Jessica Moore Richard
Hall Helen Robinson Susan Jackson Christopher
TGWDLM is my least favourite star kid musical it felt like wasted potential and the ending was underwhelming
It’s def in my bottom half as well cause I can’t stand mariah and every second she’s on stage annoys me lmao
@@GoodMorningButch they did Mariah a bit better in nightmare time
15:51 i am GAY