Rafale Deal | The Complete Controversy Explained by Dhruv Rathee
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 20 ธ.ค. 2018
- This video will make you understand the whole Rafale Deal controversy from top to bottom. I explain the timeline of the events from when the original deal was in negotiation to the new rafale deal's supreme court judgement with it's typo errors. Basically, there are two accusations regarding the deal. First is that the deal is favouritism to Anil Ambani's Reliance and the second is that there has been corruption in the pricing of the planes. The cost per plane has increased from 526 crores to 1638 crores. I do not give any opinion from my side in this video and leave it up to you guys to judge for yourself.
Support my work: / dhruvrathee
Here is the link to the most important sources which have been mentioned in the video -
Link to Supreme Court Judgement: www.sci.gov.in/supremecourt/2...
Link to India-France Joint Statement: www.mea.gov.in/bilateral-docu...
Pricing Comparisons: www.rediff.com/news/special/h...
Hindu Business Line Report: www.thehindubusinessline.com/...
----------------------------------------------------
For more informative videos and discussion on important Indian and world issues-
Telegram channel to receive instant video updates: t.me/dhruvratheechannel
Support on Patreon: / dhruvrathee Subscribe: / dhruvrathee
Facebook: / dhruvratheepage
Twitter: / dhruv_rathee
Instagram: / dhruvrathee
More Interviews by Dhruv Rathee: th-cam.com/users/playlist?list...
All episodes of The Dhruv Rathee Show:
Ep 9 Black Money: • Whose Black Money is i...
Ep 8 RTI Activists: • RTI Activists in India...
Ep 7 Ache Din in UP: • Stupidity & Ache Din i...
Ep 6 Lairs Modi, Ivanka: • Modi & Ivanka Lied?! |...
Ep 5 Padmavati: • Padmavati Crorepati Pr...
Ep 4 Rajasthan: • Ache Din are here in R...
Ep 3 Jay Shah growth: • Amit Shah's son, Adani...
Ep 2 Indian economy: • Indian Economy is Cras...
Ep 1 Currency Notes: • New ₹200 Currency Note...
More videos:
Rahul Gandhi vs Modi: • Rahul Gandhi vs PM Mod...
PayTM reality: • Truth behind PayTM by ...
Air Pollution: • World's Worst Pollutio...
BJP IT Cell part 2: • Video
Maun Modi: • Maun Modi and Whatabou...
Indian Education: • Indian Education Syste...
PNB Scam: • Reality of PNB Scam & ...
Bitcoin: • Bitcoin in India by Dh...
Aadhaar Card: • Reality of Aadhaar Car...
Best State in India: • Which is the Best Stat...
Petrol Prices reality: • Reality of Petrol Pric...
Budget 2018: • Reality of Budget 2018...
Save Our Forests: • Save our Forests! | Na...
----------------------------------------------------
![[LIVE] : ONE ลุมพินี 62 วันนี้!! คู่เอก "มงคลแก้ว vs อีที"](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/q7QuSUtUN94/mqdefault.jpg)
Timestamps:
Old Rafale Deal 0:59
Modi’s Rafale Deal 3:21
What is an offset clause? 5:05 Favouritism to Reliance? 5:58
Pricing of the Jets 8:11
Supreme Court Judgement 11:35
🙌❤️🙌keep it up brø
A marvellous report on Rafale deal... Keep up the good work Sir👍
I like your video
Bhai aap bahut achha kam kar rhe ho but fir bhi kuch andhbhakt hai abhi tak
Which editor you use please tell me
People watching this after raffale frist batch delivery to India. 🙃
😂😂😂😂😂
Indeed
Yes me😹😹
You also
I'm here..😂😂
Who is here after 5 Rafale jets coming to India.
ME bro. No idea what this guy is saying. No scam
@@R4GS63AMG not totally scam but pricing thora upar niche kar diya hai sarkar ne
Here to laugh on face of anti nationals
Me👌👌
Me 😎😎
Bhai tu abhi mafi mang modi ji se kiu ke alredy rahul Gandhi ne bhi mafi manga hai 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Are Rahul gandhi ne iske liye SC se maafi mangi thi ki usme BJP pr ghotale ka ghootha arop lgaya tha aur isko dekho iski alg nautnki h 😂😂😂😂😂😂
Who is watching this after today's delivery of Rafale?
Here me
@Abay Roy i know he didn't write it but he meant it☺️
@@erenyeag982 every vdo on youtube, mean it.... he is not asking u to watch his vdo, you came here by searching or by youtube suggestion
Likes ki vik mangna chhor do
@@arshadshah999 maine dhruv ko nahi kaha.. 😅😂maine is comment likhne wale ko kaha..lol
Can you please confirm...
1. why UPA was not able to buy even 18 fly away condition of jet from dassault in its 6-7 years of negotiation .
2. If deal of UPA was so attractive then why UPA govt decided it to re-examine the deal as we have already lapse 5 year in discussing the original.
3. Why 126 jets global order has been made, if then defence minister A K antony clearly said in his media conference that we don't have enough money to even buy the 18 fly away jets.
4. Supreme court judgement typo is not first time ....hope you know the judgement on mr. Tharoor of SC on being hindu.
Kindly do the fair analysis without being judgemental to any party.
Thanks
Mere fellow bhakatards aaj ise desh ki SC bhi antinational ho gyi...jo bhi ho me toh bolunga Wah modi ji wah :(
@@PS-qr6tz जनरल एस पी सिन्हा भाजपा का सदस्य है वो कभी सही जानकारी नही देगा
@@ratandwivedi8398 ye pkde sahi baat
modi sarkaar ko kitna time lga mmrca 2 mein jet select krne mein?
5 saal mein select tk nahi hua?
Bhakts here 🤣🤣
Legends watching this after Last of 36 Rafael reached 😅
Qatar has purchased 24 rafales for 2391 crores per plane(7billion deal) , Egypt has bought 30 rafele jets for 1230 crores per plane (4.5billion deal) and India has has purchased 36 rafales for 1667 crores each (7.5billion deal). 🤝
Guys, stop fighting, don't be in favour of BJP neither Congress.. be in favour of nation.. Its good practice to asked question to the party who is in power.. let them answerable for their deeds.. this is the only way to make politician work for development work for nation in true manner..
70 saal me toh samjh aaya nhi
Or bjp lagi hai ki samjh hi na aaye.
Bevkoof log.
Congress kyu deal finalized nahi Kia pai yaa baat to Dhruv ji ne 1 minute mei explain kar dia, Lekin jab aai Modi government ka, toh unhone dal se lekar chaol tak Dana Dana kojhbin Suru kar dia!! Ye kaisa explain hei bhai, jab bol na hei to dono taraf bolo na; kyu old government couple of years mei yea deal kin kin failure se nahi kar pai? Yeah bhi to detail mei hum lok Sunna chate hei sir..
Dhruv ji jhooth BOL RAHE hai. So wahi jhooth BOL RAHE hain JO congress bolts HAI.
@@KARMA_SANDHAN Dhruv ji jhooth BOL RAHE hai. So wahi jhooth BOL RAHE hain JO congress bolti HAI.
I wish sbko itni samajh ho..
U have picked the line of judgement according to urs need ... Read the whole judgement sir .
Each and every point of decision is explained ...
1) procedure followed during procurement
2) offset clouse
3) cost comparison ( but it was for there self satisfaction .. expert advice need to be taken for accurate price comparison ...)
You cannot make willingly deaf to hear arguments. They are because they chose to. And go through the comments and you will know andhon mein kaana raja.
I am ias aspirants .. not the political party worker like u all .
Only sold factors r important
( No if or but ) .
If u r right ..go and file PIL ...
AFTER THE COURT JUDGEMENT OR PROPER AUTHORITY APPROVE URS COMMENTS WILL BE VALID .
Bro court can onlyngive decision based on facts brought by govt.
Here in SC judgement they said that CAG have check the details and as per d repprts of CAG everything ia fine. SC has not seen all original papers on the name of security
Watching now because of latest developments by French Judge. Need another video.
Huh you baseless freek the pil was send by the same bhi which already has send oil 2 times already
Before watching video I knew he was oppose of it since it was done by Modi
Because modi did this
2004 se 2014 tk kuch nhi kiya upa ne, kya kr rhi thi tb tk
Please I request u guys please don't be the blind followers of any political party or politician,, this is 21st century!!! Please be educated,, let us raise our voice against the corruption irrespective of their party....
@@kritikadwivedi7736 aur tumhara nda abhi kya ukhada. Voh bhi bolo. Instead of pointing other's mistakes first improve yourself.. and economic crisis worse under modi than corrupt Upa regime
Yea..
Mr. Dhrub bhai....
Kabhi kabhi ak video... .. National Herald or Agustawestland, Mayabati ke Elephant ke Murti per ak video banaooo bhai.... Sahi fact ke sath
Ak dum sai kaha aapne....bahi
video or criticism govt. k upr bnana chahiye..
dusri govt lao...ye unpr bhi video bnayegi... ise sachchi democracy khte h
@@perceptibleperson514
Nd. Faiz bhai my aapka dard samajh raha hu....aap chinta na karay. ....
Wo b bna lega jab wo power me honge Abhi present par dhayan di
Rocky yadav.. pradhmantri ho ya koi b neta bhagwaan nhi, hmara naukar h usko vote deke hmne Kursi pe baithya hm chahe usko Kursi se utaar skte h..
agr usne apne 1 tenure me mje financially tension free lyf nhi di ...to hm laat Marke usko Kursi se utaar skte h or dusre select kr LENGE.
govt. bhagvaan nhi hoti Jo request kre.
govt. se hmesha demand krni chahiye.
uske Tail nhi lgani chahiye.. isiliye neta janta ke samne hath jodkr vote mangta h.. neta ki aukaat janta k samne joote ki nok hoti h
I strongly recommend all to go n watch Arun Jaitley’s speech
Bro your comment will be deleted soon
Just Science it’ll be okay for me
@@adarshgupta3226 Bhai inke Pitaji krna bhul Gye honge ..
We know the judgement of Supreme court. And we have to accept it. We are not greater or supreme then SC.
But this guy can prove SC wrong..😑
Low IQ people 🖕
@@kanhamishra7014 leftists*
@@sigmachadtrillioniare6372 yea
I commend the way you started with the TYPO error!!!! Great work Dhruv
After this video, I feel like I am most knowledgeable person in my area about such a big scam.
Soo hard to listen about such big scams continously each year.
Epic Indian Scenes konsa scam beta katue konsa 2G scam ya CWG scam Coal scam ya Railway scam by congress 😁😁
@@abhigangwar2085 dude all parties are assholes, so stop ur bullshit of previous scams. It's like congress did scams, we bjp also should do the same.
😎😎😎😎
Ankit Magar toh bta na bjp k scams bhai mujhe bhi agar aisa hi h toh
Oh yeah, he was really impartial in his assessment. He skipped a hell of a lot of info like the IAF's involvement in the negotiations, the hangers they are building in India, 75% availability of aircrafts for 5 years(please keep in mind that non of our aircrafts have availability near to that), 40 India specific enhancements ( baffled how u missed that), no one and I mean no one transfers fighter jets technology to another country the best we would have got is license production of the Jets and we couldn't have done that without France. When Dassault said reliance will only get 10% of offset deal, it wasn't 10% of 30000 crores, Dassault's offset obligations are for rupees 8700 crore 10%of which is 870 crores, the rest of the obligations are distributed among 3 other companies (mbda, safran, and thales). 60% of the offset amount is to be spent on r&d, ie, that entire money will go to government institutions like drdo and bel(one billion dollars are spent just to develope kaveri engine by safran)
All this information is available on public domain, he purposefully left it out.
The facts which were put forward are correct but incomplete. Like
When you say Mr. Jaitley asked for JPC while 2G scam, then you should also mention that supreme court cancelled 122 license at that time and scam was identified by CBI, not a bunch of Politicians.
When you compare price of aircrafts, you should also be telling about escalation cost, which had been accumulated in so many years.
When there is a talk that HAL was to produce 118 Aircrafts, then why deal wasn't sign at that time. Moreover why UPA didn't sign deal during 7 years when initial step was taken in 2007.
Overall, some facts were there but it felt like somehow you are trying to convince that there is a scam.
Shoot up the cost over *3 times? Also, for the same older aircraft?
@@thefantasticcreator1 AAP jante ho kya kii aircraft purana hai yaar Naya.
Bhai gazab
@@thefantasticcreator1 jo mobile 2007 me use krte thi abhi bhi wohi use krte ho.......take it metaphorically
the motive here is to confuse the people.....not to reach any meaningful conclusion.
Its propaganda , Supreme court has given clean chit to Modi
True.
Tum to Suprime court sa vi upar ho vai.
Jo manma ma ayya bakdea. 😂😂😂😂
Kisliye???? 🧠🤏
Rahul Gandhi finally apologised to supreme court!
Apologised for supereme court statement
Not for what government did
Logical katha kuha prabhas... Democratic framework re check and balances thae...kintu govt. Questions ra answer deba paain chahuni...
Okay, where is a video on Augusta Westland?
hey
what can be the answer of “ how was the budget for the rafale deal managed?”
i have been searching for the answer since so long. i have to speak about this in school 😭
they gave me this stupid question 😭
Sad and rti is practically dead. So I don't know how will u get ur answer
Hi Dhruv, I have tried downloading the supreme court judgement pdf file, but it says file not available. Can you help me with the pdf ?
Can you make a video of Rahul Gandhi's development in his place?
Does it have anything to do with Modi? No. So he wouldn't. "You don't bite the hands that feed you." Dhruv Rathee
@@hulkdhiraj stupid deshbaktis
@vishnu s g: Pehli baat:Who is Rahul Gandhi to India? He is just an MP! Is he prime minister? why would he do development? second thing: India has a prime ministerial system and not a presidential one! so we don't choose Modi or Rahul. we can just choose our MP and that's it. Why is it being portrayed that if not Modi then who!! know about d contestants from ur constituency man!
Rohini Gaikwad exactly perfect answer.
@@rohinigaikwad2039 what is the meaning of he is just an MP? He is a MP and he can do somay things. As MP what is his achivement? No where he is mentioning I have done this Or I have taken care school, at least a bus stop waiting shed? Only for "44 lacks from MP fund" which we can see around.
Dhruv Bhai ek video Kashmiri Pandit par v bnao na plzzz
He will won't do ....it will expose cong
His bumps don't have that guts😂
Aur usmey bhi shayad BJP ko hei bolega unke vaje se huwa🖕
How will that expos congress? 😂 Do Bhakts even have a brain?
@@aaryansingh484 it will shows the appeasement of Cong toward muslim community, looks like Cong pimps don't have cerebrum in their brain....
@@raiirai2359 and exactly what appeasement they have shown in that issue ?
The Indian Rafales come with certain critical capabilities not offered to other countries, such as the ‘Hammer’ precision-guided munitions, advanced navigation systems, helmet-mounted sights and targeting systems, cold engine start capability to operate from high-altitude bases including Leh, radar warning receivers, flight data recorders with storage for 10 hours of data, infrared search and track systems, and many such enhancements.
Moreover, according to the Indian government, the IAF had sought some 13 India Specific Enhancement (ISE) capabilities to be incorporated in the Rafale aircraft.
“If you look at the first Egyptian Rafale deal signed in 2015 worth €5.2 billion, for 24 aircraft, the cost per aircraft works out to be around €216 million per unit. That is exactly the price that India got its first tranche of 36 Rafales for,” Abhijit Iyer-Mitra, a senior fellow at the Institute of Peace and Conflict Studies, told The EurAsian Times,
Rafale is default configuration already has these things:
- helmet mounted sights
- advanced navigation & avionics
- radar warning receivers 🤣 even 70s jet had that ability
- flight data recorders are there in all jets
- IRST is present in every 4th gen jets
Some Big SCAM happened with FEKU & Corrupt. Dumbo BABUs.
Dude but those technologies are twice the price unit per plane. Also no mention of tot by french company. Can u shed more light whether we will have tot under new deal
Make video on 2g scam ....
Dhruv Rathee
Purani chez ke bare me kyu bole ga vo
Make a video on Pegasus...
Make a video on Adani power scam.....
Make a video after French Court started investigating the issue....
Rahul gandhi ne bugat liya abb ye tondle jay shah ki baari
Now it's time to make another rafale video bro.
India bought rafale yesterday
Nahi banayega .... Us par kaise criticize krne ayega na 😂
Bhai National Harald ki bhi case study bata do.
kya national herald national issue h?
Bhai waha se to isko roti multi h tabhi to bhokta h
ise acha study iq wale hai
Ye nahni batayega
nahi bolega..aiso ki kuch acha hote hue dekh k pet me dard hota hai.. this a**hole is a foreign national..usko India ka kharab hona hi pasand hai.. youtube se paisa bhi milta hai faltu baaton me zyada publicity milta hai
How much offset money did go to reliance?
Do you have any update information about offset investment made in India by Dassault Rafael Company?
3% of 30000 crore is for Reliance
@ yes ,I verified later ,I have
Completely lost my trust 3 years ago due to his lies on rafale .He is definitely working on some agenda
Who is watching after the reopening of case
The good old days when dhruv had other shirt than his 5 tshirts
Now he is like mark Zuckerberg
He has many of the same color maybe 😂😅
Yes 😑
😀😀😀
Only 3% as offset is given to reliance
Then why reliance said in there annual report that they will gate 21000 cr frm Rafael deal
U should not believe in fake media reports .. Dassault had said in there official statement that they had given 800 Croces( 3% of offset amount) to reliance .
There r more then 100 offset partners .
Government data will come in month of oct 2019 .. after Dassault claim the offset amount .
Bhai tab bhi, ye naye reliance k defence companies kukurmutte ki tarah achanak se bane kaise Rafale deal ke beech me
@@shardulmandloi wahi toh khel he 🤣
You should explain on Mirage 2000 upgrade deal during UPA. when Israel offered the upgrade for 11 million but UPA govt gave deal to France for 43 million. We could have got a new MIG 29UPG at this price.
Russian jets have parts avalability issue, their operating cost is high.
It's not about a toy being repaired where you will always go for the cheapest shop lol. There are thousands of things that needs to be considered involving these matters.
When you will apologize bro even Rahul Gandhi apologize to government..about this Rafael deal ... it's purely authentic there was no scam ...
Mr. Druva Rathi please explain me why the old deal on Rafael not signed??? Why then defence minister said in a press conference that Govt. of India does not have money to conclude the deal???
What u think Indian people?? Gadha??
Sudarson Das .... Hi bro very nicely brought out facts by you... absolutely right...
Fully agree with you
We have to expose ppl like Dhruv Rathee
Even if he is incorrect, Why is the government refusing an investigation? If the government has nothing to hide, you don't have to run from an investigation. That means the government is guilty.
This is the main reason why people don't trust modi.
Rahul Gandhi's family has a history of scams and loot and he has not denied it. But modi is trying to "remove corruption" through "demonetization" and other plans. But modi is also guilty, that makes him also a chor. That makes modi also a liar. That makes modi also a criminal and That makes modi an Anti-national and hypocrite.
After watching complete video, i got the meaning of I HAVE EXPLAINED THE RAFAEL DEAL, TYPO
its 14th november and supreme court tells you what is rafale deal .
Abhi Jo Adani Wala Meter Chal Raha Hai Same .. 4years Wale Video Se Yaani Ki Es Video Se Link Samajh Me Aa Raha Hai
SC ne clean chit de diya bhai😂 koj stock manipulation ka proof mila hi nhi mil paya. Phir iske tatte bolenge Dhruv speaks facts and proofs🤣
Bha tu mafi kab mangega modi ji se 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Vai tu video pura dekh..,..😂😂😂😂
I’m here after rafale landed in india 🇮🇳
Me too
Proud of it
These 36 jets are of advanced version compared to what UPA had signed.
Good to see the jets coming in finally.
@@SMARTBOY-ld9mq abe anpadh search kar meteor missile ke bare me jo rafel me lagegi
@@SMARTBOY-ld9mq cold start capabilities meteor scalp new radar I derby er 36 india specific enchanegement
@@itssid7429
How foolishly he kept silent on India specific enhancements.
Comparing the deal with qatar and Egypt, he said details are not clear..only price is there..
But the idiot is weeping for details with price in indian rafale
Hello Dhruv, CAG clarify the Rafale deal is cheaper by 2.86 % compared to UPA government negotiate in 2007. What is ur opinion on this?
On behalf of Dhruv: we shouldn't believe CAG as its favouring bjp. I am in as long as its against bjp. I will not show anything positive about bjp.
@@manasbehera7409 you mean everyone is wrong and Dhruv is correct. Superb. Being positive is good.but believing one person based on video uploaded doesn't make sense. Please check basis and then speak. Fact will remain same whether you believe or not.
@@manasbehera7409 जब राफेल सस्ता था तब तो क्यों नही खरीदा ।
2 राहुल इतना क्यों चिल्ला रहा घोटाला हुआ उसे अगर सब पता है तो कोर्ट में क्यों नही दिया
3 कांग्रेस की पिछली घोटालो का क्या कहोगे
ଚମଚା ହ ନି
Since that have nothing left to blame on, they have adapted to cowardly hit and run policy. Allege something and runaway till elections. This was their strategy too against Vajapeyi ji
Manas dhruve pr sarcasm kr rha hai, itna samaj nhi aya
You never explained cost for training, over hauling facilities, maintenance, performance based logistics, weapons etc could increase the cost per aircraft. The way you found approximate cost of one jet, may be you can find out weapons cost etc to make some estimation. Basically aapko samajhnaa hai ke Aircraft costly kaise hua hoga aur haan, ant main opinion toh de hi diya boss....🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
Yes he has gave his opinion not at last almost many times .
Because it was clearly not mention , he clearly said that the other cost than basic planes are not public . You have iq equivalent to room temperature
10:45 , he didnt reveal their prices because their prices was actually more than India. He dont lie , he just dont share the essentials.
@@Aryan-qi3wo nope
In their 2015 deal(Egypt) , the price of each Rafael was exactly the same as for which the IAF bought it for.
But the Indian variant had 5 more additions to it.
@@Aryan-qi3wo also
Qatar bought 24 Rafael for 6b+ euros.
We got 36 for around 7.5b euros.
@@Aryan-qi3wo that's more than what IAF bought it for.
I have few que here.
1. What was the time quoted by HAL to build 108 rafel fighers ?
2. When the price of rafel came lowest in bid, which point was being negotiated further and a decision couldn't be made in UPA ?
3. Is UPA quoted price Rs 526 crore Vs 1600 crore NDA price , both are base price ?
4. At what price other countries recently bought rafel ?
5. If the configuration of rafel bought by other countries is difft than Indian one, what are the differentiators. ?
6. Which part of the plane will be manufactured by Reliance ?
Go read it on wikipedia
Go and search high IQ channel on TH-cam , you will get answer to all the questions
@@gourvi6339 Wiki is created by ppl like u and me. U jst need to create an account and write whatever u wish. If u have any legitimate proof and answers plz reply with that.
@@AnandKumar-oh7hd So u urself dont have the answer yet.
@@Ranamukeshchauhan tu bol rahh hai ki prove de , darling ye banda bhi toh Wikipedia ,aur newspaper se lata hai na facts ,kahi asaman mai se toh nhi lata na
Please make a video on emergency, commonwealth scam and 2g scam
Adarsh Manohar
modi was sitting on 2g scam and coal gate scam for hatching for 5 years then u bakhts have no right to make such comments in social media
@@secilrods5170 you of all people where promoting corrupt people to get away from India with tax payers money and only so called modi could bring malya back didn't see any dynasty there. So modis rule is better idiot eventhough I hate him.
Those cases were tried and sentence served . Which rock did you crawl out from ? N btw tell me why has there been not one investigation in this govt against all the scams or alleged scams that took or are taking place?
@@secilrods5170 u are mistaken all those scams are of upa
Who saw the news that Egypt bought 30 Rafael fighter jets for 4.5 billion in may,2020. Where as India paid 8.7 billion for 36 jets in 2016. Maybe prices got dropped by a lot. Hmmmm
Egypt brought 2nd batch of rafale for 4.5b €.
First batch of 20rafale cost them 5.8b€ that too F2 standard not like F3 standards of India with special upgrades.
India brought latest F3, standards almost same price of Egypt's first batch of F2 standard and not to mention that Indian Rafale carry metor missile, nuclear capable, new EW suit, new radar, new missile approach warning sensors etc.
1st thing when you buy a new aircraft 1st time you have to setup infrastructure you have to buy its weapon package you have to train piolots ground staff and iaf upgrade rafale by our needs so its cost increased.
And when you buy 2nd batch of aircraft you need to buy its weapon package and some important things but in the 2nd batch of aircraft you dont have to depend on training and infrastructure that's why the second batch of any aircraft you buys it will be cheap in price so I think you understand
@@mausenpai215 nuclear capable is not special in Rafael
@@sadnananik9907 so you missed all my points.
I'm coming here after watching 3 ads posted by dhruv chaati on TH-cam regarding this..😏
Dear Dhruv, The offset clause in which 50% (30,000 crore) of the deal amount would be invested in 12 to 14 indian firms for manufacturing different parts of Rafale jet. These companies includes Anil Ambani reliance, L and T, Govt firm BHEL, etc.
In this amount, only 3% amount would be invested in reliance and rest 97% amount will be invested in other Indian Pvt and govt firms by Dassualt company.
Please check into this and clear my confusion.
Abhe woh deliberately jhoot bol rha ha .tum log iske nashe si bahaar nhi aaye ,ma toh 3 saal pehle hi aagya
@Nameless guy just watching his video after court verdict
U commented after 1 year. Will Dhruv watch it
agreed. However, there's no difference between you and him if you don't stick your bibliography down!
Ufff finally, thanks to Arun Jaitley for teaching us the ABCD... that offset doesn't mean manufacturer. Otherwise we were almost misleaded
In case it may happen because you got your leader like Rahul gandi
Oh
Just love your presentation.. All the details are presented with facts. Keep it up bro..
Make video on 2G scam
The price of rafale aircraft was also heightened because it came with 13 India specific upgrades and also we should also see that our Rafale came in F3R configuration.....
Even then the price of each aircraft is still very high. Even the F4 standards have less price
Dear deb, please read the india france joint statement again there's clearly written that "The aircraft and associated systems and weapons would be delivered on the same configuration as had been tested and approved by Indian Air Force earlier".
There's no change or upgrade in that.stop defending government atleast at that time when you are paying a very high tax for it.Just ask the question to gov for whom you are paying tax.
@@chiragjariwala3264 oh cmon dude grow up. Getting knowledge from such yt videos is literally the worst thing you're doing to yourself. You're making yourself ignorant
@@chiragjariwala3264 dude, the overhauling equipment cost were also inducted. That's why it was expensive, plus France also wants to earn some profit
@@shubhammore7078 bruh the F4 didn't even had it's first flight and you have already estimated the price before Dassault
How can defence secrets can be told in front of clowns who led to the indo-china war by reveling all the defense ability a long ago and reason for loosing that war, people like you must understand this and act accordingly
Sir ek vedio augustawestland scam pr bhi banao ...
Nahi banaega. Woh BJP ke tenure ke problem pe hi video banaega.
Hahaha right
Are aisa karenge to iske papa g naaraz ko jaayenge wahi se to paisa milta h isko
Right only politics krna ata h ...... mind wash krne ki kosis krne k pese milte h Kya inko ?
@@ritusingh3815 ye sab leftist h rabish kumar kanhiyaa jignesh sab todna chahte h desh ko iski mother Sonia gandhi bale par bahar h vo nahi dikhta isko
Alay wah mere saste defence exfart 🤣
Rafale ki jagah Eurofighter typhoon ki photo laga kar Defence pay gyan de raha hai 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🐧🐧
Aap subah uthnte hi youtube me hav dete hain rathee jee, actual me Supreme court apna decision de chuki hai ki koi corruption nahi tha poore rafel mamle me, rahul gandi mafi bhi mang chuke but aapne na video hatai na mafi mangi
Bhakt Kripya Durr Rahe!
MANUVADI BRAHMIN
😂😂
@@kamalakantamohapatra6416 But Not AndhBhakt!😂
@@Shshunk ABE SALE MURKH TUMHARI EIS HARKAT KE WAJAH SE HAAR JAGHA KAAT TE REHE HOO TUM.............KON YAHA AANDH BHAKT NEHI??? AANDH BHAKTI ME KOI YAHA APNI PATNI KA HALALA KARWATA HE TOU KOI APNI PATI KO BALI CHADHATA HE PAR JAAB BJP, RSS KO KOI SUPPORT KARTA HE TAB ANDHBHAKT KYUN BOLTA SAB??? JOU POLICE KO HATWA NE KA BAAT KARTA HE WO KON HE??? YOU ARE NOT A MANUVADI BRAHMIN YOU ARE A TALENTED MAGNIFICENT PIECE MENE TUMHE MANUVADI BOLATHA BAAS EITNE KE LIYE TAAKI TUMHE SAMAJH AA SAKE TUM KISKO KYA BOL REEH HOOO.... RAMNUJAN HO YA SUNDER PICHAI YA MAHATMA GANDHI YE SAAB BRAHMAN HE HEEEA/
Sahi hai
Fantastic work, Dhruv ji: neutral, concise, to the point, pure truth. Viewers must think and form their opinion- its an obligation, to know and opine.
neutral , pure truth !😂😂
@@akashshakya1537 according to you what is the pure truth? Please enlighten us.
@@opinion9032 Sudhir Chaudhary opinion on facts are pure truth' for Bhakts like him
@@kaizen_monk bhakt!!!
in my opinion bhakts are way better than bootlicker chamchas !!!!!!!!!!!!
@@akashshakya1537 expired truth🐷🐷🐷
Dhruv bhai huge fan,,
Per uss ndtv article ki upar muje borosa nahi hai, bcz ndtv is against bjp and hindu..🙄😶
Haan to ho gaya saal bhar se uppar... Karwa liya supreme court judgement ko null and void...
Ravish Kumar has explained it earlier I was aware of most of the facts btw all things cleared in a video.. # Prime time. Thanks Dhruv... Keep shining..
Just google the facts described in the video. Or Go to Quora where you can find the facts along with verified sources. You'll get to know the fact manipulation made in this video. DON'T FOLLOW THE VIDEO BLINDLY.
Maine to suna Reliance ke sath sirf 3% ka business hai....
He is a paid reporter...he has not told many facts like that the deal will be secured and no one will know pricing...such pact was signed by Congress in 2009...watch his 4 more videos and u will realize he's just a paid assfucker here
And brother reliance is not manufacturing any fighter,all 36 are coming from France in a fly away condition (bane banaye).
Ye mil k logo ka pagal bana rahe h saale.
Aur ek aur baat Bhai, humne deal Kiya h *7.8 billion $* for 36 fighters,wahi qatar ko Mila k same 36 fighters *8.2 billion $* m
from where u collect these information
Thumbnail me ha eurofighter typhoon bol rehe hain Rafale... 😂😂😂... atleast yeha tho sahi pic use krlete... aur sb thik ha??? Burnol use kr rehe ho?
1:22 he talking about both
Dedicate to Modi G🙏🙏🙏
कभी-कभी अपनी नाकामियों से थककर बैठता हूँ तो सोचता हूँ- "सिर्फ नाकाम होना ही काफ़ी नहीं है, आदमी को बेशर्म भी होना चाहिए।"
Waise teri to aukaat bhi nahi hai Desh ka PM banne ki ... Landy hai tu. 😂
True😂
🙏🙏
@@shivasharma4120 Hr koi acha insaan PM nahi bn paata
Well said
Video on 1984 riots
Sir but it is really true that we can't disclose the weapons and others information
Boss_dk thumbnail pe "Typhoon fighter jet" ki pic lagayi hai😂😂😂
Pure saal main jo samajh main nahi aya woh bhai ne 16 min main bata diya
Agree bro
Yes you are right 👍
16:07 min see once again
Ji ha bat to sahi hii broo
I like ur video.......but ur video is more like Congress spokesperson.......all the fact is like them.....and u hvnt added anything new ...... Your theory and journalism is very much biased . I am not BJP supporter but I listen both voices so I found you biased . Hope to find your detailed video on other scam done by Congress or other......more recent like national herald or sacking of Alka Lamba and other loyal member from AAP which believes in the basic ideology of AAP but doesn't match Shri Kejriwal dream.
Please make a video on 2G spectrum scam and Coal scam.. Please Rathee ji..
For what?can you tell me which gov ruling india presently?
@@ananthunath4450
Hahaha...Jaali Teri .....
Ye kabhi in pe video nahi banayega uski rozi roti jo band ho jayegi
@@ananthunath4450 so then why are they fighting for other seats
There is no scam in it get the Supreme Court decision , the deal could be more beneficial which they did not did. But no Scam
hav seen tonight .. "Offset Clause" (what an idea for legal financial corruption - wow) what next after supreme court examination ... If there any video, link please
Sonia gandhi did " graduation from Cambridge university" cannot be a typing error
But will be and has been is a typing error
Ohhh 🙄
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Sonia Gandhi was Italian Bar Dancer😂😂😂
Bruh i am XI class science student From goa and i honestly love your hard word and i always share you videos. I wish i could also help you in your work by making a you Tube channel but hardly get any time escaping my studies ..... But trust me Goans are aware of the wrong doings of bjp and will surely Dispose this bellends party in 2019.....All the best and soon ill try to make videos like you since you are my role model.....
Same here . I m also the student of Xl standard. Having same thoughts..
@@abdullahbhure778 You are from which state ?? Can i get your whatsapp number?? Or any other social networking sites id ... We can work together to creat awareness among people .....
Meanwhile some bjp followers here in MH are only focused on how modi could create a hindu rashtra if they win in 2019.
Sorry but actully i m preparing 4 neet in mumbai so hardly i get some time so l can't. Sorry dude
Jst tired encountering these fckin stubborn idiots who do require a high level of enlightenment and intellectual perspective
U did not mention an imp fact regarding OLD DEAL that DASSAULT refused to take any 'QUALITY CONTROL' RESPONSIBILTY of 108(126-18) HAL (India) built jets.
You are only focusing on low pricing built in india jets but not about the QUALITY.
(not a blind supporter of any pol party)
obviously it would be the responsibility of Indians to do QC of the ones they would manufacture. Or you think Indians are not brilliant or capable enough for that?
@@ainymunnee7780poor progress of several projects under HAL clearly shows Indians capability in this field, if Indians are so capable of producing quality fighter jets then why we need to deal with foreign manufacturers like Russian and French
correct bro... ye dhruv congresy dalal hai
Broo facts ki expectations kis se kar raha har
HAL ne 4th generation aircrafts banaye hai already India ke liye. Toh quality ki toh baat hi maat karo
Dhruv bhai
Dassault aviation has a glorious history.
HAL has a glorious history.
Rafale is worked out Mirage 4000.
It's 5 gen since 76.
Bidding is different game.
Great Its Eye opener for all. Keep it up by sharing valuable information. Try to share your analyses before the issue has happened.
Why don't you make vedio on 2
G scam..??
Kyu ki abhi bhi ye scam chal Raha hai jo rok sakte hai
Because he is anti modi only
@@manjeetchauhan7130 2g scam expose ho Gaya hai kab ka. Par rafale deal ke baare me sabko pata nhi
@@suchitjadhav3995 so why doesn't he make it?
@@manjeetchauhan7130 bhaii 2g scam par sc ne sabko clean chit de di hai...
To supreme Supreme Court galat hai ??
Supreme Court ko khud govt n sahi krne ko bola h...study iq education dekhta....
Supreme court galat nhi h supreme court Ko wrong dastawej muhayya kraye gye Jese peshi pe Jane vale Ko maardiya jata h filmo m vese hi saboot nhi diye gye
Sunno Bhai supreme Supreme Court mein channa nhi khta.
@@shamoonali447 aur tum secretary general hoga.
@@shamoonali447 supreme court chutya nahi he teri jesi..ki wrong dastaevaj ke sahare judgement de de...!!
Qatar bought its Rafales at $292 million per unit, Egypt bought the same fighter for $246 million per unit and India paid $243 million. Therefore, the cost for India was pretty competitive and accusations of the Modi government paying a steep price, are simply a figment of the imagination of mischievous minds.
Their configuration is different from that of our plane.
Wrong data dude....egypt paid just $174 and qatar $167 😏😏 India paid $293
@@anshkalra3910 India has higher weapons in it
@@ritvikmilton7438 nice joke...
Deal for meteor missiles was seperate and announced after the rafale deal 😏😏
@Working Hard absolutely true bro but bhakts still defending their PAPA 😂😂😂😂 Sad truth is BJP had diluted all institutions to check them including supreme court 😔😔Democracy is really in danger!!
There was no old deal. UPA only made an offer which Dassault declined.
It's like I want to buy a car for 1 rs and company declines my offer and now someone bought it for 1 lakh and I'm shouting it's a scam.
Dassault chose 70 companies but people are making fuss about only one companies.
The time difference between UPA and NDA deal is almost 10 years so it's obvious that the price will increase.
In 2003 the proposal was made by the India Airforce for the requirement of jets but after one year the government changed and in 10 years they didn't even finalized the deal.
Please watch n sitaraman's ans in loksabha... Nn don't play with defence
True
Dhruv is congress agent and rattu tota of INC like RaGa ...Also isme me jijaji ka hath hai
Rightly Said Jagdish... Nirmala Mam have given the clearance.
cHOWKIDAR cHOR HAI
Watched it. She dodged the question dude.. Shameful...
Just now in July Rafael are being delivered,came to know that there was no corruption ,it was all alligations that congies maked to stop that deal☹️💯
Raffle deal not it's just a business for ANIL AMBHANI not to Hindustan aeronautics
Allegations? Questions that are must should be raised
@@venkat8973 how stupid you are believing a moron who told us that he will make a machine that would transform potatoes into gold
harsh sinha and how stupid you are believing a fake trimmed/edited video clip of rahul gandhi saying that as true
@@b18harshsinha83 go and search in internet then you know who will be stupid
You are the best man you are the best, I love the way you provide information, unbiased
Unbiased? Really?
Go read the full article on Google, then you will know the truth not the half picture which HE is showing us 👍
quality analysis. The best example of what quality journalism is.
8:30 nahi bhai rahul gandhi to 5se6 alag alag price bata chuke hai, 520cr se leke 740cr tak. Shyaad unhe yaad nahi rehta ya phir hava me baate karna unke khoon me hai.
Please listen to Abhijit Iyer Mitra’s speech on the rafale deal. He is an actual defence expert. I don’t know why people consider Dhruv Rathee as an expert in anything.
Agreed with you👍
druv sir sacche patrakar hey iyer mitra fake expert hey
i only trust druv sir and kongreshh
@@ehsankhan3129 and Pakistan too,
@@ehsankhan3129 Islam Murdabad
Dhruv sir ki vedios ko dislike krna antinationalist act . Is jurm ke lea apka account ban ho sakta h 😂.
Love you Dhruv Sir from Haryana.
the main thing is, government bought planes for the country, army can anytime open it and learn to build one, moreover they are investing in reliance nah! So that's after all make in India. Nothing wrong here.
What Sudhir chaudhary ,zee media ,India tv and rajat sharma weren't able to explain in 1 complete year Dhruv rathee made it very clear in just 16 minutes ....
WORTH WATCHING IT
keep up your fantastic work.....
Yes, its true
Dhruv rathee has clear very easily..
He explained it from those reports only
Sudhir bhai modi bhakt he
@@londeka1747 haan
My father is inIndian Air force and let me tell you all......Price of A fighter plane and helicopter is always asked and told with fully loaded aircraft......Bcz without weapons there is no use of fighter planes........So there is no sense of telling that hike of price is due to weapons and maintenance.
Good Bro, but blind bhakts will not understand this. My advise and appeal to all is not be a FAN of a politician or political party, but rather rate and judge them based on their work and will be very progressive.
@@greatdane4888 why supreme court gave decision in favor of govt. . Now you should know every JPC reports goes in favor of govt. until govt. Doesn't want. Because of majority. So what is solution only supreme court has that capability to solve it. govt. Is not going for JPC because it will be a degradable process to create rumors in election time although final report will favor govt. So I Congress, dhruv rathee and others should go to international jurisdiction. Btw I'm not a bjp supporter.
The UPA deal was was about 18 aircrafts and technology transfer. Weapons purchase were to be done separately. Air Force buys weapons (like missiles and bombs etc) all the time as they are consumables. Such agreements happen separately. For reference you can also look into the SU-30 MKI deal. It was done in a similar fashion.
@@anirbandhar7899 initnitially No fighters are supplied without any armers.....Transfer of technology includes the weapons which would be manufactured in india only.....So no truth behind the statement that A fighter without missiles and bullets.....Bullets and missiles are manufactures in india also.
@sweta Singh read it once.
Aj Rafel aa gaya he Dhruv Rathee 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
Ur Supreme court link is not found
Check it out.
i felt bad that congress fooling Indian people .....
thease are the fact :-
1) anil ambani is not going to make any plane he is just a offset partner
2) all 36 aircrafts are made by french company dassault
3) total deal price:58,000 crore
amount invested by dassault
in Indian companies around
30,000crore
4) out of 30,000 crore ONLY 3% amount is invested in reliance which is 850 crore ONLY ( it is chiller for anil ambani thats why i called only)
now tell mi chamcho what is the scam ????
DRAL is offset partner, as of now, or even next 3 years, they are not expected to make any parts for Rafale, DRAL will be making parts for FALCON business jets which is also part of Dassault product portfolio. Point 2 is correct.. Point 3 you missed to put "thousand" its 30,000 crores.
The ToT and Offset are into many things, including help on our own Kaveri Engine (which was supposed to power our own Tejas) but the engine was having higher weight than expected. So Safran (which makes the planes engines for Rafale plane will be giving consultancy for Kaveri engine and certifying the engine. This can be used (maybe) for the export versions of Tejas as then we can have control over sales of Tejas and not be Vetoed.
I really pity dhruv rathi ...what an waste of time
Make a vedio on 2g scam bro
tu chup reh
panga mat le hamse aur kangresh se
@@ehsankhan3129 kyu bei laudu
@@bro-ko3hd bhai current situation deko pichay jaa kar q sochtay ho mandbhudi
Yeah make a video
We will fight with stone???
Love you man you are great hats off!!!🙌
Make a video on "farmer loan waiver". According to me, result of "farmer loan waiver" will become as flop as "demonetization".
watch study iq
@@Koli949 sahi bolaa apnee
Bhai aap hame sach batate hai varna yahan to har koi bika hai
Is there any technology transfer to HAL in the new deal?
Im From Bangladesh but i know about this scams and this new deal they don’t give any technology Hal 🙂🙂🙂
Nope. And God knows when will HAL complete the production of 108 jets if TOT happens