4:01 Personally, I think Dandidoo sounds good in the song because when there are all the monsters, you barely can hear the voice crack. The problem is... His track alone 💀
My heart dropped when I saw GIEP but I gotta respect Pro. He stated solid facts and even mention he put it in 1st NINE MONTHS AGO!! Really the kinda dude you get into am argument with states solid facts in your face and then you'd admit defeat
Is it just me or do I feel like this island is so overloaded? I feel like the music would be better without so many unnecessary monsters or monsters thst ruin the song.
I think another problem with Epic Wubbox is that ALL YOU CAN HEAR FROM HIM IS HIS PERCUSSION. Not the Growl, just the Percussion. I can’t tell you how many times I’ll turn my volume down because of Cold Phase’s loud *DING*.
honestly heavily agree with your ranking of the island to me the song should have felt like some type of final boss feeling similar to the ending verse but just for the full song
Personally i like the first and second parts more (the last part is just kinda basic for my taste) but either way they really should have just picked a vibe and stuck with in instead of gluing 3 songs together.
( IMO ) I think that the Gold Island can be appreciated decently if we take out some monsters here and there, and then we could better understand the melody, the rhythm, and the feeling that this music conveys. Because all the monsters together are a bit confusing and very crowded 🙂
Putting noggin below something is a crime, im going to do literally nothing about it. Imo quibble and bowgart are overrated In this island, they do the most basic beats for instrumental (excluding percussion) and are just boring
The purpose of a percussion monster is to help the song, not to do one. (Btw before someone say it, i know pianos are technically percussion but its more of an instrumental)
random things i wanna say lol (YAP SESSION) -shrubb actually does have rhythm, it’s just a bunch of smaller time signatures than 4/4 mixed in -wait does congle on gold sound the same as noggin on party? 💀 -ngl i kinda agree gold wubbox extended the song in a weird way (except i like the last verse extension) although i definitely think because of how its sound are it should play throughout the whole song nonstop to not make some parts seem empty -smoochle cool -rare wubbox is a vibe -riff is so peak last verse is def my fav -deedge super nostalgic overall interesting ranking imo the island is a solid 7/10, some transitions are off and they should’ve made epic wubbox play the entire last verse cuz now half of it is empty
I honestly forget majority of the tracks that this island has because of how crammed everything is. But i do love Riff in this a lot especially when he's together with Quarrister and Bowgart
My fav in this is island: Bowgart and quibble (both play for the full song I think) My Mid Fav in this island: Scups and Pango (I like scups okay?! Anyways scups and pango do a duet in my vision) My Least fav in this island: congle (Idk why I getting my congle to level 15 I think I just gonna do it bc to complete the collection) Reminder:That's My (Opinion)
2 things 1 respect how much courage it should’ve taken to do epic wubbox while knowing the little kids saying never cook again would be after you 2 don’t think I’ve ever seen someone talk about Pom Pom on this island and not call her first track bad
I don’t know, I don’t think epic wubbox’s drowny voice ruins the whole song. I know there’s lots of monsters crowding this island. I would give it a 5/10
In my opinion, the top 3 best monsters on this island are: 1) Quibble 2) Bowgart 3) Epic Wubbox I understand your points about why you dislike E.W, but for me, he's the best epic Wubbox out of all the other ones, because of his really creative concept and incredible sound. About gold island in general, for me, it is a good song, but at the same time, i feel it has the air island treatment, meaning that most of the song feels overcrowded with few monsters drowning almost everyone, but also having few monsters that don't drown out anyone and make the song a bit more enjoyable to hear. My general rank: 7/10. Good, but it could've been better.
My problem with earth wubbox is how they structure it The “tracks” where it just stays quiet and waits for the form change are so dumb It stops in the middle of the climax and it annoys the hell out of me
Pummel copying PomPom? Instrumentalist copying vocalist? First of all, this is impossible, you can "imitate" or "have the same rhythm" but not copy, because last time I checked PomPom didn't have a tom drum in her vocal chords. And guess what, it's quite common in music to have the same rhythm in both vocals and instrumental. Very common. So in what world does that make Pummel worse? I haven't also checked if they have the same rhythm yet, and if they don't I will be mad... But bro, last verse is one the best musical pieces written in this game, don't you dare trash it any more,
Although i dont like your placement for epic wubbox, i can agree with you. Hes one of the reasons why i dont really like gold. His loud ahh voice drowns out the good monsters
Hey bro I am also Kinda A Msm TH-camr Want to subscribe or if you don't want to its fine I just did a cave island Ranking you can see it for yourself but anyways I can see you later
![Ranking All Earth Island Monsters! [Remastered] (My Singing Monsters)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/rUsc01c7KQw/mqdefault.jpg)
This is why I'm subscribed. You aren't afraid of what the community thinks and give your own honest and yet burtal opinions. Respect.
I feel bravity would be boosted by the knowledge that if you get rage comments it boosts you in the algo
i like fpg do but is that a *gawk gawk* i smell?
1:24 longest reason in msm history
Gold Island was created before the Monster Handlers knew how much potential the game REALLY had.
This particular Rare Wubbox is one of the greatest of all MSM in my opinion
real
Real
Imo
1-quibble
2-bowgart
3-clamble
4-shugabush
5-deedge
6-idk
7-maw
8-fwog
9-schmoochle
10-riff
11-shellbeat
12-reedling
13-mammott
14-rare wubbox
15-furcorn
16-oaktopus
17-quarrister
18-potbelly
19-jam boring
20-epic wubbox
21-trox
22-congle
23-toejammer
24-yool
25-cybop
26-wubbox
27-punkleton
28-spunge
29-pompom
30-hoola
31-dandidoo
32-tweedle
33-blabbit
34-pango
35-drumpler
36-thumpies
37-shrubb
38-noggin
39-pummel
40-scups
1:25 Never let bro cook again,
IM JUST JOKING, this is valid as hell bc gold wubbox kinda ruins it for me
It's amazing how this video has a two-letter argument and an argument the size of the Bible.
Dang, you have crazy guts for that Epic Wubbox placement (I respect your opinion, as always)
Fun fact: Yool uses the same animation for Cold and Gold island
Also Punkleton
4:01 Personally, I think Dandidoo sounds good in the song because when there are all the monsters, you barely can hear the voice crack.
The problem is... His track alone 💀
My heart dropped when I saw GIEP but I gotta respect Pro. He stated solid facts and even mention he put it in 1st NINE MONTHS AGO!! Really the kinda dude you get into am argument with states solid facts in your face and then you'd admit defeat
Respect to this man
Is it just me or do I feel like this island is so overloaded? I feel like the music would be better without so many unnecessary monsters or monsters thst ruin the song.
I think another problem with Epic Wubbox is that ALL YOU CAN HEAR FROM HIM IS HIS PERCUSSION. Not the Growl, just the Percussion. I can’t tell you how many times I’ll turn my volume down because of Cold Phase’s loud *DING*.
honestly heavily agree with your ranking of the island to me the song should have felt like some type of final boss feeling similar to the ending verse but just for the full song
Personally i like the first and second parts more (the last part is just kinda basic for my taste) but either way they really should have just picked a vibe and stuck with in instead of gluing 3 songs together.
0:19 plant island drumpler from temu ahh sound
(after watching this watch my gold island ranking i spent so much time on it)
I was genuinely not expecting the 3/10 overall ranking for the island. All I ever hear is praise for gold
All I ever hear is people saying it's mid and overcrowded, at least when anyone pays attention to it. Gold Island is so underrated.
@@CringusMcDingus ok so gold island is officially the most overhated island in the game
@@jurassicguineapig6697 yeah. That, Amber Island, or Party Island.
@@CringusMcDingus party island hate is justified
@@jurassicguineapig6697 not really
( IMO )
I think that the Gold Island can be appreciated decently if we take out some monsters here and there, and then we could better understand the melody, the rhythm, and the feeling that this music conveys.
Because all the monsters together are a bit confusing and very crowded 🙂
Putting noggin below something is a crime, im going to do literally nothing about it.
Imo quibble and bowgart are overrated
In this island, they do the most basic beats for instrumental (excluding percussion) and are just boring
Noggin is boring
The purpose of a percussion monster is to help the song, not to do one. (Btw before someone say it, i know pianos are technically percussion but its more of an instrumental)
@@Noggin-msm-u6pit’s his opinion if you think different make your own ranking
@@Noggin-msm-u6p Noggin is top 42.
@godzillaevans4321
And this is my opinion
random things i wanna say lol (YAP SESSION)
-shrubb actually does have rhythm, it’s just a bunch of smaller time signatures than 4/4 mixed in
-wait does congle on gold sound the same as noggin on party? 💀
-ngl i kinda agree gold wubbox extended the song in a weird way (except i like the last verse extension) although i definitely think because of how its sound are it should play throughout the whole song nonstop to not make some parts seem empty
-smoochle cool
-rare wubbox is a vibe
-riff is so peak last verse is def my fav
-deedge super nostalgic
overall interesting ranking
imo the island is a solid 7/10, some transitions are off and they should’ve made epic wubbox play the entire last verse cuz now half of it is empty
Dude this is in Scott's top three favorite islands
Ngl, I completely agree with your epic wubbox ranking.
Other monsters: well thought out reasons for their placements
Scups: “Ew”
I respect this ranking btw!
0:13 the shortest reason in history
Ew - Ethereal workshop.
Even though i may not 100 percent agree with ur placement of epic wubbox completely i respect you being honest!
Blabbit higher than epic wubbox is crazy
he did what.
from the ethereal island results, i can conclude that humbug will be in orange tier once earth island ranking is remastered🤓👆
3:29 skip epic wubbox
I agree in your opinion, but not a 3/10 in Gold Island with 2 monsters that are in purple tier.
As a 10 year old, Quibble made me cry so hard 😭
I honestly forget majority of the tracks that this island has because of how crammed everything is. But i do love Riff in this a lot especially when he's together with Quarrister and Bowgart
My fav in this is island: Bowgart and quibble (both play for the full song I think)
My Mid Fav in this island: Scups and Pango (I like scups okay?! Anyways scups and pango do a duet in my vision)
My Least fav in this island: congle (Idk why I getting my congle to level 15 I think I just gonna do it bc to complete the collection)
Reminder:That's My (Opinion)
(Never let bro rank again)
Jk, I respect your opinion on all the ranking videos
In My Opinion
1.Bowgart👑
2.Quibble🟣
3.Epic Wubbox🟣
5.Schmoochle🟡
6.Tweedle🟡
7.Shugabush🔵
8.Hoola🔵
9.Clamble🔵
10.Quarrister🔵
11.PomPom🟢
12.Reedling🟢
13.Mammott🟢
14.Deedge🟢
15.Jam Boree🟢
16.Blabbit🟢
17.Potbelly🟢
18.Punkleton🟢
19.Yool🟢
20.Rare Wubbox🟢
21.Wubbox🟢
22.Noggin🟢
23.Toe Jammer🟢
24.Entbrat🟢
25.Riff🟢
26.Shellbeat🟢
27.Thumpies🟢
28.Fwog🟢
29.T-Rox🟢
30.Furcorn🟢
31.Shugabush🟢
32.Dandidoo🟢
33.Congle🟢
34.Pummel🟢
35.Pango🟢
36.Shrubb🟢
37.Drumpler🟢
38.Oaktopus🟢
39.Cybop🟢
40.Scups🟢
That's my guy right there no bad monsters
Good ending
Wow, you are too friendly.
2 things
1 respect how much courage it should’ve taken to do epic wubbox while knowing the little kids saying never cook again would be after you
2 don’t think I’ve ever seen someone talk about Pom Pom on this island and not call her first track bad
Who says Pom Poms track was bad?💀
0:13 best sentence
6:49 *the minions* ☠️
Completely shameless Scups hate aside😭
I think this is a W Ranking
winner!
also, hoola above hoola?
@@xpotential editing mistake
I don’t know, I don’t think epic wubbox’s drowny voice ruins the whole song. I know there’s lots of monsters crowding this island. I would give it a 5/10
Honestly valid opinions. I wouldn’t really throw anyone in red but the common and epic Wubboxes, both don’t help the song. Rare Wubbox solos em both
i most certainly agree with the epic wubbox, although i think it isn't as bad as you say i do not like how the song was extended JUST for it to fit in
I love that you pull no punches
In my opinion, the top 3 best monsters on this island are:
1) Quibble
2) Bowgart
3) Epic Wubbox
I understand your points about why you dislike E.W, but for me, he's the best epic Wubbox out of all the other ones, because of his really creative concept and incredible sound.
About gold island in general, for me, it is a good song, but at the same time, i feel it has the air island treatment, meaning that most of the song feels overcrowded with few monsters drowning almost everyone, but also having few monsters that don't drown out anyone and make the song a bit more enjoyable to hear.
My general rank: 7/10. Good, but it could've been better.
Oaktopus above Reedling is... interesting... but pretty goog ranking!
So, noggin above congle?
You should swap them.
My problem with earth wubbox is how they structure it
The “tracks” where it just stays quiet and waits for the form change are so dumb
It stops in the middle of the climax and it annoys the hell out of me
Yo bro I really agree (only thing I would change is epic wubbox,reedling an qaurrister)
Epic wubbox gets drowned out by other monsters, its not extremely loud like you make it seem. Also he makes the song less empty
9:37 after all that time fpg finally gave quibble the right crowns
I completely agree besides epic wubbox would be last place and frog would be first place.
Pummel copying PomPom? Instrumentalist copying vocalist? First of all, this is impossible, you can "imitate" or "have the same rhythm" but not copy, because last time I checked PomPom didn't have a tom drum in her vocal chords. And guess what, it's quite common in music to have the same rhythm in both vocals and instrumental. Very common. So in what world does that make Pummel worse? I haven't also checked if they have the same rhythm yet, and if they don't I will be mad...
But bro, last verse is one the best musical pieces written in this game, don't you dare trash it any more,
I mean i don’t like the epic wubbox ranking but it’s understandable
I would put epic wub a teeny bit higher but I pretty much agree with you
At first I was like Why is Epic Wubbox in 31?! But then I remembered that you called Gold Island Mid
Not a fan of D major I guess
I think honestly the gold air epic box sounds more better than air epic wubbox
The only gold form I like is water and earth
Although i dont like your placement for epic wubbox, i can agree with you. Hes one of the reasons why i dont really like gold. His loud ahh voice drowns out the good monsters
Why did i already know quibble and bowgart would be the top 2…
Fwog is my fav on this island
And hoola
8:40 This was not the last time Shugabush was on an island. Shugabush island released after it.
This might be the most controversial ranking yet.
All because epic Wubbox 😭
Which I mostly agree with
Hey FPG90, how's it going? Can I use your ranking criteria for my video? I'll be giving credits
@@folhamavel sure
@@FutureProGamer90 thank you!
I like the epic wubbox for some reason but I understand why you put it on orange tier
Not gonna hate it while I like the epic wubbox :)
Bro I’m not going to say it but putting epic wubbox lower is a huge crime
agreed
I can agree most of the opinions but 3/10!?? It should Atleast 8/10
I agree
I thought you liked epic gold wubbox, what happened?
2 words, “recency bias”
@@FutureProGamer90oh that makes sense
yeah I when listen to gold island, i can't hear the gold wubbox properly
A new update released on light island (Reminder)
Epic Wubbox came from 1 to 31
Day 2 (idk) Of Asking To Rank Atlantic Aquarium
Bro, you should've at least put the Epic Wubbox in Green, that would be fair
5:24 and it duets well with rare wubbox
Hey bro I am also Kinda A Msm TH-camr Want to subscribe or if you don't want to its fine I just did a cave island Ranking you can see it for yourself but anyways I can see you later
Dude I’m missing shugabush I wish it’d be back on other island some day…
Huh?? Shugabush is always avalible.. did something happen?
@@3D_PUPPO no I mean he’s unlikely to appear on new islands
You worded that so weirdly
@@flammer5039 oh
@@FutureProGamer90 mb
1:43 i cant even hear blud in the full song
9:33 cloudy with a chance of meatballs reference?
??? I never watched that movie
@@FutureProGamer90 Oh lol
While I could see why you thought it was a reference it is not
r.i.p. Epic Gold Island Wubbox on Number 1, is dead!!!
Tbh epic wubbox almost inaudible
THE FULL SONG IS OUT FOR RANKING RARE WUBLIN ISLAND PLS RANK
But is there individual sounds
@@FutureProGamer90 yas
@@FutureProGamer90 seperate vids tho
@@MSM_Monculus yeah not happening until the official ones release
@@FutureProGamer90 they did release, check ghostympa
Fwog = goat 🐐
HOW DARE YOU DISRESPECT THE EPIC WUBBOX
7:52 and it carries the second verse
0:39 msm content would like to know your location
can you rank plant island played by ethereals pls
No
He only ranks official/fanmade islands
My fav is Rare Wubbox
Quibble is overrated imo
How?
2:12 no it was 7 months ago
Wubbox over epic wubbox💀
Wait where's rare Wubbox??
7:39
@@fakemickeymouseoh tysm!!
I like quibble
7:41 and quarrister
4 videos 1 week
Nice
Quads riff the goat
Entbrat trash as crap
Deege deege
Shelbeat ur
mom
Qurrista godly
Entbrat 💀 ☠ 💀
Ey we hablas español??????
Si
Early tickets! Claim them now before it’s to late!
Yess :D
Claimed!!
Also claimed
9:33
and the others by thowk
That would be intersting but that's not happening because that's not a fanmade island nor is it official
Error
74th liked