I thought that meme culture was flourishing in the brain rot era but as it turns out I couldn’t even find enough sound effects to replace all the tiers of my list. Edit: for those wondering about mirror islands. I included them in my rankings I just didn’t separate them from their normal counterparts. I probably should have clarified this in the video.
This is the most unique tier list I’ve ever seen!(not that it’s a bad thing!) Why I don’t disrespect your opinion…just be prepared for people to tear you to shreds for Party being higher than Continent.
@@bloxycrew7697 I have been teared to shreds for years for stuff like disliking the dipsters. I don’t mind getting turned to shreds by an actual valid opinion for once.
Party island is great why does no one listen to me. Seriously havet hey actually heard the song? I immediately loved it after remixing it. Very unique song.
dipsters were annoying to me when they were first added to the game but for some songs like bone island and faerie island, it feels like they add pretty nicely and i cant imagine the song without their singing anymore. ESPECIALLY for bone island. dipsters r overhated imo
Seasonal Shanty is my favorite island in the game. I love it so much. I just wanted to let you know, because honestly, I agree with your criticisms, but those aspects of Shanty don't bother me at all. While they may be annoying to you, I absolutely adore the goofy vocals, they are so charming once you let them grow on you. I used to hate them, especially Gobbleygourd, but I don't know, I gave them a chance Keep being awesome, buddy
One thing every one always forgets about light island it’s meant to be a lullaby which is repetitive in nature it’s not the devs fault it’s repetitive it’s what they were going for to fit the vibe and honestly to me they pulled it off perfectly
I was on board with the video and agreed with most of your opinions until we got to the Shanty slander. I think the vibes of the island are absolutely amazing, as this festive, nostalgic respite from everything. Even as a Gobbleygourd hater, he doesn't detract from the entire song's vibe bc he's offset by so many other singers. I was initially annoyed with the ratio of vocalists to non-vocalists but after some time, the vocals just kinda become melodies like those of an instrumentist For what they had to work with, all of the monsters are balanced really well and they nailed the unique atmosphere of holidays
I'm just confused how you think that dipsters on Bone Island ruin the song, its their best track and a few like Bone and Faerie are actually good! ( MY OPINION NOT YOURS )
ik its your opinion but magical nexus is so good. the way the monsters just combind and just it hits the part in my brain so much. i would put it more higher but THATS YOUR OPINION!!
I don't why people don't like Seasonal Shanty, I understand Hoola is quite annoying but Gobbleygourd is way better on Seasonal Shanty than the other islands they are on. There are also some good monsters that carry the song like Yool and Ffidyll. Then there are the ultimate Seasonals, Monculus and Spurrit. (Yes, Spurrit is GOD Monster)
Okay tierlist except for, like… wdym party is above continent😭😭 i don’t understand the dipster hatred but its not very relevant to me. I also despise seasonal shanty … thank you
these are my rankings personally god tier: wublin island, nexus, mythical island, ethereal island, ethereal workshop, fire haven epic: bone, light, magical sanctum, earth, cold borgir: plant, fire oasis, gold good: celestial, psychic, shugabush ok: faerie, air, amber, water bruh: seasonal shanty i think i got every island i dont play dawn of fire so im leaving those islands out
@@nebula_zombies No, it is not worth it. I have a video about wublin farming which is my second most recent. You should go and check it out and and skip forward to the part where I talk about why you should not get a monculus farm.
@@willcrafters. That’s my kayna farm. Depending on who you ask it may be the best way to generate relics in the game. It’s so that I can fill my mirror islands with werdos. I have a video on this btw.
@littleawesomeapple they right, the only redeeming thing about it is the bass, other then that, it's just a lazy attempt to make a song out of like 10 vocalists.
I'll start by saying I agree with most of the placements. I appreciate Party Island getting some love, and I do very much agree about Space Island's last verse. However... I am MAD that you called Seasonal Shanty the worst song in msm!! It's my favourite song, and I believe it's one of the best. I like it so much that I occasionally sing some of most of its vocals. I guess what can be so annoying about it is how bubbly and high-pitched the vocals are, but I see that as more of a preference than a notable critique.
Me personally I also had to agree that Shanty is the worst island. It’s the only island I leave barely touched, and I’m currently level 71. I just hate Hoola so much, that she stays muted.
The thing that i HATE about the continent is monsters that sound like dog toys or chipmunks for example blabbit is a dog toy and EONT EVEN GET ME STARTED ON HOOLA SHE RUINS ONE OF THE BEST PARTS OF THE SONG RAHHHHH. also oasis needs to have top tier because HUZZAH and wynq
Sure, Shellbeat carries cloud island, but he goes too hard at points, both drowning out some of the monsters and kinda ruining the calm feel the island was going for
Ethereal island is the sole example on why wubbox doesn’t work on most islands He is just way too chaotic on most islands Only islands I think he sounds good on are wublin and earth, which are more chaotic in nature so they are a perfect fit for wubbox, and haven, which he is not chaotic on
I like light island I just wish Kayla and potbelly would stfu. They play so much it genuinely ruins the island for me, that’s why I actually really like the mirror light island simply because they play less.
You can always just mute them, ik a fair few people (including myself) mute most of/all of the natural monsters just leaving the light monsters (and fire expansion, furcorn and sooza if u want)
@@squirlyvgc That’s very true, I was more talking about ranking because he was ranking the islands without taking into consideration muting monsters, which is the correct way to rank them in my opinion.
@@WeyovLest Yes. I didn’t want to use the sound from my own recordings because I have multiple copies of many monsters. That wouldn’t display the objective song as these monsters become louder.
I thought that meme culture was flourishing in the brain rot era but as it turns out I couldn’t even find enough sound effects to replace all the tiers of my list.
Edit: for those wondering about mirror islands. I included them in my rankings I just didn’t separate them from their normal counterparts. I probably should have clarified this in the video.
Where are you ranking:
Epic G'joob
Epic Yawstrich
G'joob (DoF)
Yawstrich (DoF)
BeMeebEth
Phosphoran Phlox
@@PomPomthePigtailGirl Epic G’joob: good
Epic yawstritch: bruh
G’joob (dof): ok
Yawstritch (dof): bruh
Bemeebeth: epic
Phosphoran phlox: borgir
7:23 ah yes theres so much creativity behind each of the cereals:
Lucky Charms, Fruity pebbles and cinnamon toast crunch
@@iAteRobTop haha, I left that intentionally. I use a transcriber and sometimes it makes really interesting guesses.
@@MrReedling lmao
"Donald fries" at 19:54 lol
I agree with your cold island ranking, some people think it is worse than plant island but nostalgia a side, cold island is great and is underated
I agree tbh i feel like plant is heavily overrated due to nostalgia
All the natural islands are amazing but I think cold is the worst just behind plant but by no means is it bad
@@TheFirstKAfair opinion personally water is my least favourite of the original 6
A side of what?
This is the most unique tier list I’ve ever seen!(not that it’s a bad thing!)
Why I don’t disrespect your opinion…just be prepared for people to tear you to shreds for Party being higher than Continent.
@@bloxycrew7697 I have been teared to shreds for years for stuff like disliking the dipsters. I don’t mind getting turned to shreds by an actual valid opinion for once.
@@MrReedlingnow everyone dislikes the dipsters. How ironic
Party island is great why does no one listen to me. Seriously havet hey actually heard the song? I immediately loved it after remixing it. Very unique song.
@@JackWithAburgerThat isn't true. They are largely hated though.
@@HarperTuneZparty island is very good
Saying that the dipsters ruined bone island is a crime in my opinion.
In my opinion, he spitting facts. I swear if the dipsters EVER go to celestial island, I'm deleting the app
dipsters were annoying to me when they were first added to the game but for some songs like bone island and faerie island, it feels like they add pretty nicely and i cant imagine the song without their singing anymore. ESPECIALLY for bone island. dipsters r overhated imo
Seasonal Shanty is my favorite island in the game. I love it so much. I just wanted to let you know, because honestly, I agree with your criticisms, but those aspects of Shanty don't bother me at all. While they may be annoying to you, I absolutely adore the goofy vocals, they are so charming once you let them grow on you. I used to hate them, especially Gobbleygourd, but I don't know, I gave them a chance
Keep being awesome, buddy
Nobodys talking about how he missed Tribal Island!
Fuck tribal island
hey in his defense it IS the most forgettable island in the game
@@gooberr_manAHEM
Collusingum?
@@Amorningbearmusic AHEM shugabush island???
I actually like shugabush island in all actuality, but It is forgettable.
@@simplewormonastring6869 AHEM
yes i agree but i still havent gotten any monsters on shugabush island cuz i have only a little food
you said no one can be mad at saying seasonal shanty is the worst
i am here to say
i am a little miffed at you saying that
I AM ALSO MIFFED
One thing every one always forgets about light island it’s meant to be a lullaby which is repetitive in nature it’s not the devs fault it’s repetitive it’s what they were going for to fit the vibe and honestly to me they pulled it off perfectly
7:41 certified auglur moment
literally makes my day every single time
11:32 i agree, it sounds something like from TLL to me at least
It’s always nice to see how other peoples tier list even if our opinions don’t match because it’s always nice to see other perspectives. Nice vid 👍
Am i the only human being who likes the dipsters?
Nah
I like them as well
@@ThatOneCrazyFanOfPapyrus cool👍
I like them too
I like them
How do y'all hate them wtf
i'm just mind-blown, because our opinions are so similar, like Bone island, Reedling being our favourite monste, both loving stogg
W list but party island above starhenge is WILD
saying party island is above anything is wild
@@nospamgaming6682 true
@@nospamgaming6682yes
What on earth are those in the bottom tier
…also Cool Mirror Islands (im fully aware they’re all just worse)
I was on board with the video and agreed with most of your opinions until we got to the Shanty slander. I think the vibes of the island are absolutely amazing, as this festive, nostalgic respite from everything. Even as a Gobbleygourd hater, he doesn't detract from the entire song's vibe bc he's offset by so many other singers. I was initially annoyed with the ratio of vocalists to non-vocalists but after some time, the vocals just kinda become melodies like those of an instrumentist
For what they had to work with, all of the monsters are balanced really well and they nailed the unique atmosphere of holidays
WE’RE SO BACK
AIR ISLAND WERDOS ARE NOT NEGATIVE, in my opinion 😝
“The continent was doomed to age, just like your mom”
-Mr Reedling, 2024
I'm just confused how you think that dipsters on Bone Island ruin the song, its their best track and a few like Bone and Faerie are actually good! ( MY OPINION NOT YOURS )
Dipsters on faerie are amazing, they filled this empty gap In the main part of the song
Finally, someone who loves cold island godly
Yay, we're back for some more msm tiers!
W opinions! The only one I disagree with is Shanty, I love how joyful it is
I’d like to point out that Light Island was created during the coronavirus pandemic so I agree with its ranking.
This tier list hits as hard as a paper🗣️🔥
The werdos don’t ruin Air Island, it’s the rare and epic wubbox. They make that one verse sound really overfilled and too loud
ik its your opinion but magical nexus is so good. the way the monsters just combind and just it hits the part in my brain so much. i would put it more higher but THATS YOUR OPINION!!
Cave island is probably packed with reverb as it's in a cave, *caves are echoey*
fam u GOTTA do msm monsters on a tier list remake next 🙏
What about the mirror islands?
I don't why people don't like Seasonal Shanty, I understand Hoola is quite annoying but Gobbleygourd is way better on Seasonal Shanty than the other islands they are on. There are also some good monsters that carry the song like Yool and Ffidyll. Then there are the ultimate Seasonals, Monculus and Spurrit. (Yes, Spurrit is GOD Monster)
Your islands look really good love the layout and decoration
Guys shut up it’s his opinions you can’t change it like you don’t control him
Sees top 4 islands in good and ok. Leaves.
imo magical nexus is my fav island bc its egyptic vibe
Ethereal workshop is great but reedling on every island would make the game better lol
bro 'donald fries' 💀 19:49
I agree with your opinion on bone island
6:57 ARE THOSE PATHS SLIGHTLY OFF CENTER??!??!1
Yes, I think so. I designed my natural islands ages ago and didn’t use a grid lol
@@MrReedling You know what? No. You're fired. This is my channel now. Shoo, go home.
Finally someone who hates the bone island dipsters
Why do people like them so much anyways?
Tbh i was kinda hurt when continent was in OK tier cuz it's my fav island 😢 ( or song )
Wow, you appreciate Light Island for the same reasons I do!!!
He's back!
“There is not a single wublin thats lazy”
Bruh half of them are stolen loops
Man dipsters in bone got cooked for that
I think party island is almost a little creepy with the come on over from the monsters 😅
Nice
OH GOD,AN ARMY OF KAYNAS
the dipsters aren't always ruinous
Finally someone who doents say Party island is bad. Party island is literally the best one in the whole DOF
What’s your friend code for msm?
Okay tierlist except for, like… wdym party is above continent😭😭 i don’t understand the dipster hatred but its not very relevant to me. I also despise seasonal shanty … thank you
Bone island dipsters (While not AS good as everything else) Are the best dipsters and accually do something positive
these are my rankings personally
god tier: wublin island, nexus, mythical island, ethereal island, ethereal workshop, fire haven
epic: bone, light, magical sanctum, earth, cold
borgir: plant, fire oasis, gold
good: celestial, psychic, shugabush
ok: faerie, air, amber, water
bruh: seasonal shanty
i think i got every island
i dont play dawn of fire so im leaving those islands out
Is a monculus diamond farm worth it?
@@nebula_zombies No, it is not worth it. I have a video about wublin farming which is my second most recent. You should go and check it out and and skip forward to the part where I talk about why you should not get a monculus farm.
Party island above starhenge, cave and fire heaven is diabolical
Strange, but you can have your opinion
Are werdos hated? I think they're cool
1:27 Count how many kayna's are there
Now, when will be mirror island ranking science they now have their own songs (magic mirror island included)
COLD ISLSND TRUBTER HERE THANK YOU
Why do u have 400 kaynas on amber island
@@willcrafters. That’s my kayna farm. Depending on who you ask it may be the best way to generate relics in the game. It’s so that I can fill my mirror islands with werdos. I have a video on this btw.
Ok @@MrReedling
why no explanation for not liking galvana???? and why hate galvana and not plixie 😭
You didnt rank the 9 mirror islands
NEVER LET THIS BRO COOK AGAIN!!🗣🗣🗣🔥🔥🔥
NEVER COMMENT AGAIN AND GET A LIFE🔥🔥🔥
@@curtiswalls1070 bruh the author is really overrated islands on top and overhated islands on the most down places
Author 🗿
@@TomAchins_ how about not make a big fuss and respect his opinion
5:34 *holds a gunpoint*
Everything in the middle is wrong, but you got seasonal and ethereal spot on.
NOPE
THEY GOT SEASONAL SHANTY SPOT OFF
@littleawesomeapple they right, the only redeeming thing about it is the bass, other then that, it's just a lazy attempt to make a song out of like 10 vocalists.
@@Bawl16 Nah Seasonal Shanty is the best song in the game lol
@littleawesomeapple Other than the carrilong verse, I don't get the appeal. though tbf, I saw someone whose favorite island is mirror air.
I can also agree with wublin beinng best
Am I the only one who loves the Werdos 😞
Hej! din åsikt är bra Mr. Reedling!
Never touch a tier list again plz
why
It’s his opinion 😑
@@NoahShieldssdoesnt mean people cant disagree
@@ShadowPlagueMSM it’s telling him to do something he could’ve simply said something like “in my opinion”
@@NoahShieldss the comment is a joke, obviously they didnt mean it.
Don't let bro cook again
you put starhenge and space island THAT LOW??
Bluds back!
Bro is speaking swedish with English words (i dont mean it in a bad way) my accent is the same when speaking english
Nah air island dipsters go hard
Tribal island:
but where tribal😭
In my opinion, the seasonals ruined the continent. They did not have to be that high pitched
i almost fully agree lol
Your not from USA or the UK?
15:16 WRONG
SEASONAL SHANTY IS MY GOD
Diddling
Bruh what about the mirror islands songs
I'll start by saying I agree with most of the placements. I appreciate Party Island getting some love, and I do very much agree about Space Island's last verse. However...
I am MAD that you called Seasonal Shanty the worst song in msm!! It's my favourite song, and I believe it's one of the best. I like it so much that I occasionally sing some of most of its vocals. I guess what can be so annoying about it is how bubbly and high-pitched the vocals are, but I see that as more of a preference than a notable critique.
Me personally I also had to agree that Shanty is the worst island. It’s the only island I leave barely touched, and I’m currently level 71. I just hate Hoola so much, that she stays muted.
Yeah Seasonal Shanty is the best song
@@kaimantubehd6450same, but if I were to rank, I’d put it in crap, who was in the studio bro 😭
@@Vindicator971 idk bro 😭
The thing that i HATE about the continent is monsters that sound like dog toys or chipmunks for example blabbit is a dog toy and EONT EVEN GET ME STARTED ON HOOLA SHE RUINS ONE OF THE BEST PARTS OF THE SONG RAHHHHH. also oasis needs to have top tier because HUZZAH and wynq
Ima list my opinions here
Sure, Shellbeat carries cloud island, but he goes too hard at points, both drowning out some of the monsters and kinda ruining the calm feel the island was going for
Ethereal island is the sole example on why wubbox doesn’t work on most islands
He is just way too chaotic on most islands
Only islands I think he sounds good on are wublin and earth, which are more chaotic in nature so they are a perfect fit for wubbox, and haven, which he is not chaotic on
Candelavra just sucks on haven
I hate wynq, ruined kayna’s verse
Other than him I think oasis is pretty darn good, it’s catchy, it’s goofy, and it’s calm, all at the same time
Nexus made me like tootoo, poppette, and clavi gnat
Party island isn’t even half bad 🙏🙏
Hating starhenge galvana is nuts
15:16 NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO 🥺
Cold island is so underrated that its overrated
Borgir 🍔
you forgot tribal island
Cold Island gets carried by Strombonin and deedge hardly
You forgot Tribal Island!
And the Mirrors, but I understand not including them
Bro you forgot tribal island
I like light island I just wish Kayla and potbelly would stfu. They play so much it genuinely ruins the island for me, that’s why I actually really like the mirror light island simply because they play less.
You can always just mute them, ik a fair few people (including myself) mute most of/all of the natural monsters just leaving the light monsters (and fire expansion, furcorn and sooza if u want)
@@squirlyvgc That’s very true, I was more talking about ranking because he was ranking the islands without taking into consideration muting monsters, which is the correct way to rank them in my opinion.
Well I think Kayna carries and Potbelly solos
Outdated already (mirror magics)
THE ANIMATIONS DON'T MATCH UP WITH WHAT'S PLAYING!!!!!!!!
@@WeyovLest Yes. I didn’t want to use the sound from my own recordings because I have multiple copies of many monsters. That wouldn’t display the objective song as these monsters become louder.
Where’s tribal island?