@@DreamSniperGodits all about the lighting technique , mw19 has a natural and almost entitely photo realistic lighting . Mw23 carries that ugly tint from mw22 which almost entirely ruins the lighting , many players are dissapointed of that (or this community alone)
(Adding to my own reply) some games with ugly tint for example has Bad Company 2 vietnam on the Hill 137 map , Battlefield 3 has a yellow tint on mainly gulf war maps , Rainbow Six Vegas with the yellow tint combining with the bloom effect
What I loved about MW19 is the realism in the reloads. Most were perfect but some had imperfections like bumping the mag on the mag well. Or pulling on the charging handle once slightly, then quickly pulling harder because it wouldn’t go. Made them feel way more realistic and immersive
Overall I think MW2019 still has the best sound design. The depiction of sounds were high quality, realistic, and some were even accurate. It sounds like the sound design team actually got their hands on a Desert Eagle and recorded the distinctive sounds it makes in action.
They did , IW also bought a massive and extensive sound library which has real gun recordings for their use in which i think is a total ammount of over 50gb
@@fifteen8850 what i am trying to imply is tom clancy is known for ganes with lots of replayability and generally being high quality , city however known for making copy after copy of budget games and is generally mediocre (that doesn't appplies anymore) . The comments implies MWIII is a more like a knock off game comparing to a game like MW19
the only upgrade to animations was on the rpk in my opinion, in mw19 the ak with a drum doesn't feel heavy as it should, but in both mw2 and mw3 the rpk is reloaded slowly because of its heaviness
@LuckySeven50507 They're basically for like to balance out the speed for the large magazines. Especially if you look at the Cor 45 extended mag, where the operators intentionally missed in order to extend a bit of time
Animation - Tie Guns - MW19 Gun name - MW19 Engine - Tie since MW19 is more of Photorealism meaning water physics isnt a thing in that time while MW2023 and 22 pretty a hard sacrifice for water physics and improvement A.I. Audio - MW19 Story - MW19 Operators - MW19 Only thing I enjoyed about MW2023 was when you fire the gun, its not that shaky compare to MW19 and 2022 if I put an LPVO or any scopes in my gun
Honestly the animations sledgehammer made are kind of downgraded they fit well but iw just does it better. At least Sledgehammer is using better sound design for mw3
@@epj0211 In my opinion. Mw2023 wins but yours not. And wait. It’s that you that you repiled on my comments? Your total comments in this channel has more than 100 comments. I know you replied me that I commented on operation showcase
I think everyone forgets they literally arent allowed to make it a good as 2019 rn. They had a lawsuit for that game 😂 just be happy with mw3 they probably doing something so that in the future they can give us that 2019 quality back but rn they sinply can't
MW2019 is always my favorite looks very real graphics MW3 (2023) other hand still look Adult Swim Cartoon graphics. Hopefully BO5 Make it look real graphics up top tie to 2019
animation wise, they’re still similar and amazing, the only thing MW2019 wins this is the lighting and contrast
I think that in terms of detail, MW2 wins, especially with the RPG animation
@@Kurdati yeah, i really like that addition to the animation
I would say the sound design is also better in MW2019.
how does a 4 year old game look so much better than a brand new game
Idk. Mw2019 was a 4 years old game, plus. It’s a ps4 game and they use the iw 8.0 version. How could be better than iw 9.0, and ps5 version?
baby duck syndrome
@@DreamSniperGodits all about the lighting technique , mw19 has a natural and almost entitely photo realistic lighting . Mw23 carries that ugly tint from mw22 which almost entirely ruins the lighting , many players are dissapointed of that (or this community alone)
(Adding to my own reply) some games with ugly tint for example has Bad Company 2 vietnam on the Hill 137 map , Battlefield 3 has a yellow tint on mainly gulf war maps , Rainbow Six Vegas with the yellow tint combining with the bloom effect
Maybe it's all the content they're trying to squeeze into 2 games.
What I loved about MW19 is the realism in the reloads. Most were perfect but some had imperfections like bumping the mag on the mag well. Or pulling on the charging handle once slightly, then quickly pulling harder because it wouldn’t go. Made them feel way more realistic and immersive
In my opinion MW2 / MW3 added more of this detail
Overall I think MW2019 still has the best sound design. The depiction of sounds were high quality, realistic, and some were even accurate. It sounds like the sound design team actually got their hands on a Desert Eagle and recorded the distinctive sounds it makes in action.
just for the deagle
They did , IW also bought a massive and extensive sound library which has real gun recordings for their use in which i think is a total ammount of over 50gb
I feel like I've seen this comment before, I might be trippin though
Just barely
MW2019 Still looks better
Clean facts
fr
Mine is not better
Of-fucking-course lol
and sound better too imo
Next: Modern Warfare 2019 vs Modern Warfare III Gun Comparison Showcase
Bro, You are watching it right now, and you just copy the title here
Do you mean the original one from 2011 ? Or the reboot just released this year ? Because if it's tye reboot you are watching it right now
@@steveman0420 bro. Mw III means 2023. Mw3 means 2011
@@DreamSniperGod then the guy is watching that right now , this comment is just confusing as there are no explanation replies whatsoever
2019 has better lighting. But both are almost the same😂
Yes. 2019 has more better lighting and raytracing than mw3 but mw3 reload and inspect animation is way more better than mw1.
@@DreamSniperGod a lot of the reloads like the Uzi and M4 are literally re-used. I agree the inspects are better but some are lazy re-uses
Comparing Mw19 vs mw23 is like conparing a tom clancy game to a city interactive game
Wut
@@fifteen8850 what i am trying to imply is tom clancy is known for ganes with lots of replayability and generally being high quality , city however known for making copy after copy of budget games and is generally mediocre (that doesn't appplies anymore) . The comments implies MWIII is a more like a knock off game comparing to a game like MW19
@@steveman0420 funny you say that because honestly MWIII mp is so much better than MW2019’s
the only upgrade to animations was on the rpk in my opinion, in mw19 the ak with a drum doesn't feel heavy as it should, but in both mw2 and mw3 the rpk is reloaded slowly because of its heaviness
@LuckySeven50507 They're basically for like to balance out the speed for the large magazines. Especially if you look at the Cor 45 extended mag, where the operators intentionally missed in order to extend a bit of time
In less words: If you see that sledgehammer games develops a COD, it means that it will be dissappointing. 😢
Because animations are apparently the most important thing in a game
@@jayjay1343 It certainly shows quality over quantity and Sledgehammer does both.
I mean SHG had like one year of development at least the animations are great
Based on what?
@@fifteen8850vanguard
the animations are so fuckin realistic
0:09 X16 should be perfectly compared with COR-45 as they are both G21's.
COD MW2019 is ahead of its time.
shame they still haven't fixed the fennec reload
wdym
Animation - Tie
Guns - MW19
Gun name - MW19
Engine - Tie since MW19 is more of Photorealism meaning water physics isnt a thing in that time while MW2023 and 22 pretty a hard sacrifice for water physics and improvement A.I.
Audio - MW19
Story - MW19
Operators - MW19
Only thing I enjoyed about MW2023 was when you fire the gun, its not that shaky compare to MW19 and 2022 if I put an LPVO or any scopes in my gun
Mp - MWIII
Honestly the animations sledgehammer made are kind of downgraded they fit well but iw just does it better. At least Sledgehammer is using better sound design for mw3
it's the same picture :-)
No, it ain’t bro. It wasn’t the same picture
Idk what it is but the newer cods have this weird grain to every shiny metal, but MW2019 doesn't. Their shiny metals look shiny and not grainy
MW2019 wins
Bro ❤ ur videos
Plz reply I have a request
Are they gonna copy paste MW2019 for the next 15 years ?
Some of them just reused assets
I mean, that's nothing new in Call of Duty so... Sounds changed though.
1 min ago. How about mw2 vs mw3? Mw2019 and mw2023 are just both better than mw2022. OFC, Mw2023 wins
No.
@@epj0211 In my opinion. Mw2023 wins but yours not. And wait. It’s that you that you repiled on my comments? Your total comments in this channel has more than 100 comments. I know you replied me that I commented on operation showcase
How about no ?
MWII has its weapons and operators carried over to MWIII, so it isn't possible to compare them
@@Hopy practically a damn port and a reskin
MW2019 good, other game bad.
I did the thing; now gimme likes.
The models are different but the animations are the same (most of the time)
I think everyone forgets they literally arent allowed to make it a good as 2019 rn. They had a lawsuit for that game 😂 just be happy with mw3 they probably doing something so that in the future they can give us that 2019 quality back but rn they sinply can't
Which game is going first?
I miss the p90
MW2019 is always my favorite looks very real graphics
MW3 (2023) other hand still look Adult Swim Cartoon graphics.
Hopefully BO5 Make it look real graphics up top tie to 2019
Mw2019 graphics is peak
The most expensive dlc ever
MW2019 wins with everything except the AKS74u's gun model
MW3 is basically just copy and paste of MW2 and MW19 because sledgehammer can’t make decent animations😩
*MW19 compared to MW22
I wish Infinity Ward would do another WWII Call of Duty. Seriously, Modern Warfare is played out.
MW3 get a yellow filter, look boring. MW still the best ! Contrast and lighting are very nice
MW2.5
У MW2019 анімції значно кращі та правильніші, більш достовірні.
Анімація перезарядки ПКП в MW3(2023) - просто туфта, а от по помповим дробовикам навпаки...
The added rpg animation is stupid tbh
L
MW2019 Still look better
MW2019 Still looks better