@@janicewinning2847 I've always felt that it had no specific meaning. Like many of the best "psychedelic" songs from those great years, the surreal images it evoked were what was important, and to heck with the meaning. Another perfect example of that is "I Am The Walrus," by the Beatles. My sister said to me, "It doesn't make any sense." I said, "It doesn't have to!" If it makes you FEEL, that's the main thing, and that is what's completely missing in today's popular music. Maybe someone else has an idea of what Keith Reid intended when he wrote the lyrics to this song and could better answer your question.
@@TPOrchestra I recently saw an interview on TH-cam where Gary Brooker explains how he came up with the song composition. Keith Reid describes his love of abstract art and visuals and how he wrote the lyrics in the same fashion.!
In my opinion Mr Brooker's voice HAS changed. It's richer, thicker, a little raspy and a whole lot better than 40 years ago. Absolutely frickin' love this 🎼
This was done almost 40 yrs after Procol Harum recorded this, and lead singer's Gary Brooker's voice still sounds crisp and clean. Just spectacular, warms my heart on this cold, dark day. Thanks for this Jovaughn 💯💯
Yeah. Holy shit!!! This man's voice has not deteriorated one little bit. I remember this song from the sixties and it sounds exactly the same. It brings me back to a place I can't describe.
My God, this man's voice sounds just as good as when he was a young man, cudo's to keeping his voice in tact, and still being able to bring it to the table...😊
So many singers think they still have it when they get older but, sorry most dont, this man does, I've said it before ,we were very lucky with music , born at the best time.
This is the Danish National Orchestra with Procol Harum, 53 years after they recorded it. BTW, he said he was trying to remember a Bach song when he got this melody. It was Air on G String and you can hear the similarities.
I saw Angebie Drake react to this version, and as soon as Gary Brooker started singing, she burst into tears. She said his voice just hit her heart. Everyone mentions what a good voice he has, but it really goes a lot further than that, he is singing from a really deep place.
It's absolutely amazing for a singer to have kept the quality of their voice this good for all these years. Most can't hit the high notes anymore. Truly a rarity for a singer to sing this well so far into the game...
Gary booked, the lead singer and one of the writers of this song just passed away at age 76 from cancer. Jayvee I know you lived this song- RIP to a great man!
So glad this was recorded - awesome voice, maybe even better than his youthful voice. Reminds me of how Winwood’s voice remains remarkable. We’re fortunate to benefit from their amazing gift
Gary Booker absolutely NAILED IT! His voice has aged like a fine single row scotch. Everyone on stage is showing their love and respect of and for the music. When the music swells and G.B. hits those notes, my goosebumps get goosebumps, a frickin Masterpiece. Who else has this version of the song on their funeral play list?
you can tell it's special... when u play in an orchestra and a singer does a solo.... it;s like meh..a singer.... but here.. you see the joy and pleasure of the orchestra..they know this is special ... a pleasure both to see and hear
Great performance. Song is full of a lot of symbolism. The 60s were a time of deep messages and complicated relationships and events. Literally every line is has a hidden meaning but basically it’s the end of a relationship before it ever started. Performance is just lovely tho....
Always awesome to see another Maine Coon Cat lover! We have a 3 yr old male named Rhys (Welsh spelling of Reece)....anyhow, i have a pretty involved analysis of this song, but it would probably end up being a "too long, didn't read", still i think i have a pretty accurate take on the overarching meaning it encompasses.
@@kilgoretrout3966 the Mainecoons are so special. I have two girls, Belleza and Lucia, they are eleven. They are my constant companions. As far as the song, there is a great detailed interpretation that you can google.
Spectacular…. Gary Booker Rest in Peace the world has lost an incredible musician, you have been part of the backdrop of my life since the 60’s thank you for your service to Music. Xxx
Gary Brooker’s voice just gets better with age just like a fine wine . . it’s hard to comprehend that he sung this song in the 1960’s god bless you Gary and the entire orchestra.
I love the orchestra because the song itself is so beautiful, but his voice. WOW Just the same as the original recording. I love this song, but this version just added to it which is rare. Thank you.
Loved Charlie Pride, what an outstanding singer and man, his voice was surely a gift to our ears, he had so many #1 HITS! Gonna sure miss this awesome Country and Western Singer ☺️ RIP and God love you ❤️🖤❤️🖤❤️🖤 PS IF YOU WANT TO HEAR ANOTHER GREAT AFRICAN AMERICAN COUNTRY SINGER THATS COME OUT, YOU JUST HAVE TO HEAR "Tony Jackson" singing The Grand Tour...Hope you give this talented man a listen, because he is this good!!
YAAAAAAS!!!! My Collage housemate got married to this, at their formal wedding. And yes; it is Very beautiful, Jovaughn. And among the finest Rock groups, EVER. Wait till the Rabbit hole opens for you~ . . . David . . . R.I.P.
@@turdferguson400 Turd, me luv. Always great to bump into your, hither OR yon~ Too busy to ponder the question . . . 😏 TY for that meditative moment. . . . Still breathing and occasionally smiling 😁 🤶 . . . and you?
For this song, in this moment and for this version he was the finest male vocalist on the planet. I am 65 and just realized this version is my favorite song ever of all time followed by everything from Nightwish and then Pink Floyd.
Never heard this version,love it ,It made me cry,he still sounds great. High school boyfriend got me hooked on this song. Absolutely Beautiful 🤩💯👏👏⚡️✨❤️❄️👩🏼🦳
I had just come back from Viet Nam in 1967 when I first heard this song and I really loved it , I think this is an amazing version of it. I will listen to this again.
I am weeping at the beauty of this Live version. I’ve loved this song since the 70s when I was a preteen. Thank you for turning me on to this! Much Love! 😎☮️
One of my favourites, it's a beautiful song and this live performance was outstanding. He kept his voice in such good shape, aged like fine wine. Great reaction aswell :)
@@patricklemeur6360 Non, Patrick! It's a rough approximation. The song was him attempting to play the Bach piece. This version has the orchestra playing the Bach piece - they are extremely similar as you would expect
@@thesolitaryadventurer c'est drôle , plus j'écoute cette chanson moins je pense à Bach !.... mais pourtant Gary Brooker sort du classique , le son les arrangements de M Fisher à l'orgue donne cet impression de Bach au public !salut!
The opening chord progression is Bach, but the melody is totally original, though somewhat Bach-like. Listen to Air on a G-String and tell me that it's the same. I love Bach, but this is better.
I’m in a webinar & can’t listen til later but I’m commenting anyway because you said it helps! Update: WOW! I hadn’t seen this before. He still sounds incredible! The oboe & organ were so beautiful too! Thanks for this. 💕
Hi from the UK, this song makes you want to fall in love again , 40 years ago this amazing voice hit us , wow this live version is amazing, love it and you never forget 🤗🤗🤗🤗🤗🤗 .
I’m 41 and growing up this was one of my mothers favourite songs. I’ve always loved it myself but haven’t heard it in a while, and I’m truly BLOWN AWAY by how good this guy still is. If I was wearing a hat, I’d take it off to him right now
Hi from the UK just letting you know that the song white shade of pale is actually based on Bach's air on g string that's why it was played with full orchestra 😀
Saw these fellas 4x and they always wowed me with their music! Thank you Brother JV. They could rock you or hit you with heavy blues. Your exactly right his voice is hitting those notes like he did in the sixties
I've loved this song since 1967...... then I saw this video a few years ago and was STUNNED! I immediately went looking and found a DVD of the entire concert that this is from. It is one of my most prized possessions!
Fun Facts: In 1977, the song was named joint winner (along with Queen's "Bohemian Rhapsody") of "The Best British Pop Single 1952-1977" at the Brit Awards. More than 1000 recorded cover versions by other artists are known.
“This has got to be one of the best songs ever.” said everyone who has ever heard it.
Truth
I have heard this song many times and love it but could someone please tell the meaning of it x
@@janicewinning2847 I've always felt that it had no specific meaning. Like many of the best "psychedelic" songs from those great years, the surreal images it evoked were what was important, and to heck with the meaning. Another perfect example of that is "I Am The Walrus," by the Beatles. My sister said to me, "It doesn't make any sense." I said, "It doesn't have to!" If it makes you FEEL, that's the main thing, and that is what's completely missing in today's popular music. Maybe someone else has an idea of what Keith Reid intended when he wrote the lyrics to this song and could better answer your question.
It is so obviously true that I want to reiterate how classically beautiful it is.
@@TPOrchestra I recently saw an interview on TH-cam where Gary Brooker explains how he came up with the song composition. Keith Reid describes his love of abstract art and visuals and how he wrote the lyrics in the same fashion.!
AND HIS VOICE HASNT CHANGED AT ALL
Yes it has...it's gotten better!
@@brucethrasher8551 agree
IT CERTAINLY HAS....IT'S GOTTEN DEEPER AND RICHER. LOVE THIS..
Yes!!! After watching this clip, I checked one out from 67ish. It was good no doubt, but this was , WOW!! 👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼
In my opinion Mr Brooker's voice HAS changed. It's richer, thicker, a little raspy and a whole lot better than 40 years ago. Absolutely frickin' love this 🎼
10 million records sold.
Agree!
It's like a fine whiskey & tobacco sound.
❤❤❤😂❤❤❤😂❤❤
This was done almost 40 yrs after Procol Harum recorded this, and lead singer's Gary Brooker's voice still sounds crisp and clean. Just spectacular, warms my heart on this cold, dark day. Thanks for this Jovaughn 💯💯
He sounds FANTASTIC after all these years !!!! 👍💜☮️
Amazing x
He sounds better xx❤️
R.I.P. Gary. The angels have been waiting for you to sing to them
R.I.P Gary Brooker Lead Singer Procol 19.02.2022 blessed with a voice from the Music Gods
OMG!!! I have always loved this song but this... The orchestra, that organ, that voice after so many years!! Just absolutely spectacular!! 🎶💕
Yeah. Holy shit!!! This man's voice has not deteriorated one little bit. I remember this song from the sixties and it sounds exactly the same. It brings me back to a place I can't describe.
You are so right,it can't get better in heaven
This is a phenomenal live performance. No question. It's an 11 on the scale.
This mans voice has matured soooooo well. The song is Iconic and this version is amazing.
This might be the most perfect performance I’ve ever seen...
My God, this man's voice sounds just as good as when he was a young man, cudo's to keeping his voice in tact, and still being able to bring it to the table...😊
I think he sounds better so much more richer tone
This is better than the original.
I think he sounds better now!!
He sounded better in Denmark than in the 60's RIP 🙏 😢
He hasn't lost an ounce of his remarkable voice. This is amazing
Every single person on that stage crushed it. They should all be very proud. Perfection!
So many singers think they still have it when they get older but, sorry most dont, this man does, I've said it before ,we were very lucky with music , born at the best time.
I haven't heard this version before - the original is stunning but damn, so is this!
this is what is meant by music that touches the soul, simply beautiful !!!!
Jeez, J you have found one if TH-cam’s Golden Nuggets here. So great performance
Found this with only a few views four years ago so happy to see that ppl have found this golden nugget. So beautiful
A beautiful classic, I hadn't heard this live version either. Epic. That orchestra heightens it remarkably.
Thank you.
Me neither and it was awesome.
And the choir!
RIP Gary Brooker. Thank you for blessing us with your incredible talent all these years.
So many older singers loose there voice. Not here still magic
This is the Danish National Orchestra with Procol Harum, 53 years after they recorded it. BTW, he said he was trying to remember a Bach song when he got this melody. It was Air on G String and you can hear the similarities.
This performance was from 2006, so actually 39 years after they recorded it.
Literally crying because of his voice. What an amazing song and voice; his voice hits my soul
I saw Angebie Drake react to this version, and as soon as Gary Brooker started singing, she burst into tears. She said his voice just hit her heart. Everyone mentions what a good voice he has, but it really goes a lot further than that, he is singing from a really deep place.
Same. 😢
It's absolutely amazing for a singer to have kept the quality of their voice this good for all these years. Most can't hit the high notes anymore. Truly a rarity for a singer to sing this well so far into the game...
Gary Brooker's voice, which has not changed at all, is sending us more than 50 years back. Back when there were no confinement. We were free
Yes,sends me back,😢so beautiful,never thought it could sound even better.
This live version is amazing, great musicians, great voice. thanks Jovaughn.
Gary booked, the lead singer and one of the writers of this song just passed away at age 76 from cancer. Jayvee I know you lived this song- RIP to a great man!
39 years ago my husband and I danced to this song when we first met and we have been together ever since!!! We consider this as our song!!!
RIP Gary Brooker, loved this song since you first recorded over 50 yrs ago, You Will Be worldwide missed, 02/19/22
I don't know if you'll see this, but this singer, Gary Brooker, passed last week. My heart is broken.
I am in tears for a man I never met. His music has meant so much to me
So glad this was recorded - awesome voice, maybe even better than his youthful voice. Reminds me of how Winwood’s voice remains remarkable. We’re fortunate to benefit from their amazing gift
I too, just found out that this legend has passed away. out of the 73 million views of this video, I am probably responsible for 1 million of them! 🙁
Count me in for at least a million of those views!
I like it that your eyes seem to sparkle when you love a song.
Eric Clapton once said that Whiter Shade of Pale was the perfect song!.
Gary Booker absolutely NAILED IT! His voice has aged like a fine single row scotch. Everyone on stage is showing their love and respect of and for the music. When the music swells and G.B. hits those notes, my goosebumps get goosebumps, a frickin Masterpiece. Who else has this version of the song on their funeral play list?
Played it at my brother's funeral. So poignant, & emotionally powerful.
Great performance and song 🎧
You played the studio version for my patreon request. I didn't even have to request this! Love this song. On my all time top 100. Thanks JV!
Same, RJ. Just brilliant. 💖💖💖
@@turdferguson400 In fact it's actually quite high up in my top 100.
@@RJohnson2024 I’m going top 40 on this one...
@@turdferguson400 OK. You made me look up my playlists. I have a top 20 playlist and it's in there!
@@RJohnson2024 Even better! 💖👍
you can tell it's special...
when u play in an orchestra and a singer does a solo.... it;s like meh..a singer.... but here.. you see the joy and pleasure of the orchestra..they know this is special ... a pleasure both to see and hear
Beautiful, trippy song. 😍 Not surprised an orchestra jumped on playing it. Never saw this performance before. Cool.
I dreamt once of playing this on an organ, and I don't even play one.
@@kentclark6420 that's awesome😁
@@kentclark6420love that! 🤣🤣
"Although my eyes were open, they might just as well be closed" So true today it makes me 😪
@@mysterytabby that’s for sure
Great performance. Song is full of a lot of symbolism. The 60s were a time of deep messages and complicated relationships and events. Literally every line is has a hidden meaning but basically it’s the end of a relationship before it ever started. Performance is just lovely tho....
Always awesome to see another Maine Coon Cat lover! We have a 3 yr old male named Rhys (Welsh spelling of Reece)....anyhow, i have a pretty involved analysis of this song, but it would probably end up being a "too long, didn't read", still i think i have a pretty accurate take on the overarching meaning it encompasses.
You are so right✌️
@@kilgoretrout3966 the Mainecoons are so special. I have two girls, Belleza and Lucia, they are eleven. They are my constant companions. As far as the song, there is a great detailed interpretation that you can google.
Spectacular…. Gary Booker Rest in Peace the world has lost an incredible musician, you have been part of the backdrop of my life since the 60’s thank you for your service to Music. Xxx
Gary Brooker’s voice just gets better with age just like a fine wine . . it’s hard to comprehend that he sung this song in the 1960’s god bless you Gary and the entire orchestra.
RIP GARY BROOKER JUST PASSED AGE 76 (PROCOL HARUM thanks for the music 22 /2/22
I am stunned!
I love the orchestra because the song itself is so beautiful, but his voice. WOW Just the same as the original recording. I love this song, but this version just added to it which is rare. Thank you.
J, you'll like their "Conquistador", reached #16 in the US.
Top 10 in the UK in '71 !! 😁
🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰
The version from this concert is epic
I didn´t like that song. A Whiter Shade of Pale is the best.
We lost a legend yesterday: Charlie Pride. He’s worth a listen. Try “Kiss an Angel Good Morning.”
th-cam.com/video/ueRS8ZVqJFo/w-d-xo.html
@@JayveeTV you’re on it
Loved Charlie Pride, what an outstanding singer and man, his voice was surely a gift to our ears, he had so many #1 HITS! Gonna sure miss this awesome Country and Western Singer ☺️ RIP and God love you ❤️🖤❤️🖤❤️🖤
PS
IF YOU WANT TO HEAR ANOTHER GREAT AFRICAN AMERICAN COUNTRY SINGER THATS COME OUT, YOU JUST HAVE TO HEAR "Tony Jackson" singing The Grand Tour...Hope you give this talented man a listen, because he is this good!!
Vale Charley. 💖💖💔💕💕
@@rhondamcbath6279
Darius Rucker is pretty good too!
My goodness I needed something this beautiful today. It's wonderful seeing you feeling that too. Great reaction. 🎧
You have to wonder how many artists wish they had written this. Unbelievably beautiful...decade's later..voice still incredible...
I'm glad you played this version. The guy still has his chops.
If anything this is the better version.
1967 I was 17 and music and dancing was great. This song is still great.
Omg!, this is so unbelievably good. Emotions everywhere. So glad u picked this performance. This is why we love your channel. Kudos to u my friend.
WOW!!! You made my day today!! This is Totally Phenomenal!!! Thank you Jayvee you Rock!!!
Mr. Gary Booker - his voice like a fine wine has aged beautifully ! Glad you got to this one brother !
I was 9 years old when this song was released, I have loved this all of my life❣️
Classic. Credit to J. S. Bach the composer too o e of the greatest who ever lived.
YAAAAAAS!!!! My Collage housemate got married to this, at their formal wedding.
And yes; it is Very beautiful, Jovaughn.
And among the finest Rock groups, EVER. Wait till the Rabbit hole opens for you~
. . . David . . . R.I.P.
Leslie! How ya doing, sweetie?! 💖💖💖
@@turdferguson400 Turd, me luv. Always great to bump into your, hither OR yon~
Too busy to ponder the question . . . 😏 TY for that meditative moment. . . . Still breathing and occasionally smiling 😁
🤶 . . . and you?
That was absolutely amazing! I was stunned myself Jay! I love this song. Awesome reaction.
Wow....This made me so emotional....after hearing it for decades, this was simply breathtakingly beautiful.
Yes,yes, it was so amazing
getting chills at the first note.
Another great one from the great days of music !! 💖💖💖
Voice got even better with the years
For this song, in this moment and for this version he was the finest male vocalist on the planet. I am 65 and just realized this version is my favorite song ever of all time followed by everything from Nightwish and then Pink Floyd.
Remarkable performance - just outstanding.
Never heard this version,love it ,It made me cry,he still sounds great. High school boyfriend got me hooked on this song. Absolutely Beautiful 🤩💯👏👏⚡️✨❤️❄️👩🏼🦳
He still has it. Love all your reactions, from Australia
G’day from Sydney, Debbie! 💖🇦🇺🇦🇺
Omg !!!!! His voice !!!!! Better , richer than ever. Goose bumps right now . Incredible
I had just come back from Viet Nam in 1967 when I first heard this song and I really loved it , I think this is an amazing version of it. I will listen to this again.
Yes! This is the one! This song is epic 💯♥️ never saw the live version before
The moment when we realize that the old people we see today are actually a lot cooler than we first thought.
This is the definitive version. It took a long time to get here, but it was worth it.
My goosebumps have goosebumps! Thank you sir,
Ur sweet soul spills out. Thank you peace ✌️
We have just heard a Masterpiece 😌 Thank you Jay for honoring him! ☮️
Wonderful! I hope you try their "Conquistador" next.
It does my heart good to see your genuine love of beautiful music ☺️
I am weeping at the beauty of this Live version. I’ve loved this song since the 70s when I was a preteen. Thank you for turning me on to this! Much Love! 😎☮️
I was 17 when I first heard this on the radio in 1967... wow Gary Brooker still sounds like he did back in the day...53 years ago...
Outstanding!!!!! As was your reaction 👍🏼👍🏼
One of my favourites, it's a beautiful song and this live performance was outstanding. He kept his voice in such good shape, aged like fine wine. Great reaction aswell :)
RIP Gary Brooker the lead singer of Procul Harem
The music is by Bach, Procol Harum just added lyrics.
No - inspired by Bach, but it’s not just a Bach tune.
@@PhilMasters OUI Phil c'est exact !
@@patricklemeur6360 Non, Patrick! It's a rough approximation. The song was him attempting to play the Bach piece. This version has the orchestra playing the Bach piece - they are extremely similar as you would expect
@@thesolitaryadventurer
c'est drôle , plus j'écoute cette chanson moins je pense à Bach !....
mais pourtant Gary Brooker sort du classique , le son les arrangements de M Fisher à l'orgue donne cet impression de Bach au public !salut!
The opening chord progression is Bach, but the melody is totally original, though somewhat Bach-like. Listen to Air on a G-String and tell me that it's the same. I love Bach, but this is better.
I’m in a webinar & can’t listen til later but I’m commenting anyway because you said it helps!
Update: WOW! I hadn’t seen this before. He still sounds incredible! The oboe & organ were so beautiful too! Thanks for this. 💕
It’s stunning, Nicole! 💖💖💖
@@turdferguson400 Just heard it! You aren’t kidding!
Hi from the UK, this song makes you want to fall in love again , 40 years ago this amazing voice hit us , wow this live version is amazing, love it and you never forget 🤗🤗🤗🤗🤗🤗 .
5 star performance, amazing how his voice remains the same, my all time favorite, hands down
This always make me cry. I cry because it is so beautiful. I also cry because it reminds of a really great time for music.
THANK YOU! I have never heard this version 💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💗
That man has not lost one bit of his amazing voice!
I'm having this at my funeral.
one of the best I've seen recently. band is still kicking out this tune in great version and style
I’m 41 and growing up this was one of my mothers favourite songs. I’ve always loved it myself but haven’t heard it in a while, and I’m truly BLOWN AWAY by how good this guy still is.
If I was wearing a hat, I’d take it off to him right now
Dang !! Gary Brooker sounds the same now as he did back in 1967... Amazing..at 75...I still have my 45 of this song.
The reason this song sounds so good with an orchestra is because it's melody is based in part on a Bach piece.
Nice to know that Gary's still got that voice 40 years later! This was an amazing performance! And you're right. This IS one of the best songs ever!
Rest in peace Gary Brooker. 💜
Hi from the UK just letting you know that the song white shade of pale is actually based on Bach's air on g string that's why it was played with full orchestra 😀
Happy to see you play this version, my favorite version.
🙌🏼🙌🏼🙌🏼🙌🏼🙌🏼🙌🏼👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽 OMG
I've FOREVER PLAYED & LOVED THIS SONG Even my Kids Grew up loving listening to it ❤🙌🏼❤❤❤❤
This is MAGIC
Saw these fellas 4x and they always wowed me with their music! Thank you Brother JV. They could rock you or hit you with heavy blues. Your exactly right his voice is hitting those notes like he did in the sixties
I've loved this song since 1967...... then I saw this video a few years ago and was STUNNED! I immediately went looking and found a DVD of the entire concert that this is from. It is one of my most prized possessions!
Yes , it is one of the best performances ever.
Just learned today that he passed away from cancer on February 19, 2022. RIP Gary Brooker!
Thank you for introducing this to me. I've been a little low and this just put a massive grin on my face. TYSM 💜
Fun Facts: In 1977, the song was named joint winner (along with Queen's "Bohemian Rhapsody") of "The Best British Pop Single 1952-1977" at the Brit Awards.
More than 1000 recorded cover versions by other artists are known.
Certainly a different take on this classic hit... so used to hear the church organ opening on this.
very beautiful..