@@joagalo they are mutually intelligible to a certain level but of course it depends on which dialect of irish you speak. I personally as an Ulster Irish speaker am able to understand scots completely and 90% of Scottish Gaelic.
@@joagalo Depends the region of Ireland and Scotland If you put northem Eire and Ulster together with southern and western Scotland tou can have a normal conversacion in Basic to a pratical level passing by intermediate level, a well nice chat. But If you put central and southern Eire with northem and eastern southern and eastern Scotland maybe i can have a little conversation or a non conversation depending the culture's speakers in situation. But if you have a irish and scotish that domains protoceltic and protogaelic you have the most beautiful celtic chat cós they can speak gaelic and celtic in a old pure version and in a scotish and irish version together, in a higher erudite level its possible in a academic scientific level too.🍻🍻🍻🍻🍻🍹🍹🍹🍹🍹🍹
Scottish Gaelic is more closely to Romance languages, like French or Spanish than to Scots languages. This is because Scottish Gaelic is a Celtic language, while Scots is Germanic.
Good day! I've been waiting for a volunteer! Please help me with it! Here are the things we need from you: Text and Audio for the following: The native name of the language/ dialect Numbers 1 to 10 Greetings & Phrases Vocabulary Any story / Sample text Images for: Flag & Emblem Traditional Costumes Art/ Patterns Information about the language, people & culture! Suggestion for Background music :D Looking forward! :D The Wren The wren used to have his nest in the car shed. Once the old ones had both flown out they had wanted to get something to eat for their young and had left the little ones all alone. After a while, Father Wren returns home. “What’s happened here?” he says. “Who harmed you, children? You are all terrified!” “Oh, Dad,” they say, “some big bogeyman came by just now. He looked so fierce and horrible! He stared into our nest with his big eyes. That scared us so!” “I see,” Father Wren says, “where did he go?” “Well,” they say, “he went down that way.” “I see,” Father Wren says, “where did he go?” “Well,” they say, “he went down that way.” “Wait!” Father Wren says, “I’ll be after him. Don’t you worry now, children. I’ll get him.” When he comes around the bend, it is the lion who is walking along there. But the wren is not afraid. He alights on the lion’s back and starts scolding him. “What business do you have coming to my house,” he says, “and terrifying my children?!” The lion pays no attention to it and keeps walking. That makes the little loud-mouth berate him even more fiercely. “You have no business being there, I tell you! And if you come back,” he says, “well, then you’ll see! I don’t really want to do it,” he says and finally lifts one of his legs, “but I’d break your back with my leg in a second!” Thereupon he flies back to his nest. “There you go, children,” he says, “I’ve taught that one a lesson. He won’t be back.” Stay happy, Andy! Kindly send it to this email. otipeps24@gmail.com
Andy loves contrasts, scots dorics its germanics near to anglo saxon and yola and scotish gaelic is near to irish gaelic and manx gaelic, very strongly celtic. Cuddles to pretty and loved scotland scotland 🍻🍻🍻🍻💋💋💋💋💋🫂💙🌷❤️
It was in ancient era and ages when all uk and ireland were celtics, but with the germanics and latins invasions both becames independent from each,accussing the end of celtic era. Today both are independent langs for all linguistic as welsh and manx
Scottish Gaelic derives from earlier Irish Gaelic spoken by settlers from Ireland after the Saxon invasions. The Gaelic spoken before that is from a different branch, of which Welsh and Cornish are surviving members of.
No. It is sometimes called a dialect of Irish by people who want to diminish it, but both languages have different standards. They are closely related and have a degree of mutual intelligibility but so do Swedish, Norwegian and Danish and nobody would say they are the same languages.
(rish) Yeshua Dia ag teacht go han-luath. Tá Nibiru agus a plaineid ag teacht n taobh thiar den Ghrian. Glac pictiúr den ghrian le camara ar do ghuthán. Tá Nibiru cosuil leis an ngrian, agus deirtear go bhfuil pláinéad dearg, pláinéad bán, pláinéad dear sár-mhór, agus pláinéad sár-mhór i gcruth diosca ag teacht ó chúl na gréine. Anois feicfidh daoine anseo agus ansiúd pláinéad mór bán ar snámh mar scamall, dhá ghrian, plainéad dear an-mhor ag éiri agus ag luí na gréine, agus miotal a bhfuil cuma diosca air. Feicfidh tú pláinéad rick-daite (liath, airgead) ar snamh sa speir ban, feicfidh tú speir corcra, agus feicfich tú 24K solas daite óir ion ag titim sa spéir. Tá na pláinéid bhána an-mhor agus is cosúil le dathanna suilineacha tuar ceatha, agus is fearr a fheictear iad sa speir thoir nuair a ardaionn an ghrian. Thaispeain Dia dom an fhis, má ghlacann tú pictiúr den spéir, feicfidh tú pláinéid, agus na pláinéid ag éiri nios dlúithe agus nios dlúithe, agus tá siad ag eiri nios soiléire i rith an lae.
Scottish language doesn't belong there it's Germanic not Celtic Brotonic (Gaelic she'll only be speaking and sense other native tongue the country should have been speaking in Gaelic
They’re just two languages spoken in Scotland, and he likes to compare languages spoken in a country (regardless of language family), and he also like to compare languages that are in the same language family like a comparison of Icelandic and Norwegian or Portuguese and French etc.
@@Edarnon_Brodie The Irish, like the Angles and the Norse, most certainly were invaders. The Britons of South-West Scotland and the Picts have the best claim to being indigenous. Also new genetic evidence has pointed towards the Celtic languages (and people ?) only coming into the British Isles around 1000 BC. Their DNA is today found mostly in southern Britain but less so in Scotland, Ireland and Northern England. The Celtic languages aparently spread to Scotland and Ireland without much population movement from the south. The populations of Scotland and Ireland are mainly descended from the Beaker folk who came from mainland Europe in the Early Bronze age - and who were not Celtic.
Well, yeah. Scots is the only sister language of English that’s still alive, so it’s a Germanic language, whereas Gaelic is a Celtic language. They’re both Indo-European at the end of the day, though, and I think that relation was shown in the numbers, at least.
@@SinilkMudilaSama I’m from Norway and I’ve listened to and studied Scots (Doric), and besides the words ‘barn’ and ‘kirk’ and the fact they’re both of the Germanic subgroup of Indo-European languages, I see nothing that makes them “close” to each other…
Gaelic won’t do anything for you in today’s world, besides make for a hobby and a bit of cultural pride for those who speak it in their tiny part of the world; English, however, is one of the most valuable languages to be fluent in as far as being useful on the world stage (business and communications). It’s like my native Norwegian, only about 4 million or so people speak it, and 98% live in Norway (or the Scandinavian countries like Danmark). We all learn English at a young age so we can actually communicate with people outside of our small language group, and so we can have a better shot at being successful on today’s world. My parents had me learn German, too, as it has a major usefulness in European business. I certainly don’t think any language that is part of a country’s culture should be left to die out, but more prevalent, useful languages tend to take priority.
I'm getting a new microphone so I might be able to record lines for the Dundonian Scots dialect someday.
Looking forward to it! :)
Whats Dundonian?
@@CinCee- Dundee accent
@@MrNorth83 Is it different from Doric?
@@CinCee- Yeah Dundee accent is local dialect of Lowland Scots Fife/Edinburgh/Central Belt
How different do you want your spelling and pronunciation to be?
Irish & Scottish Gaelic: Yes
Could both speakers still understand each other?
@@joagalo they are mutually intelligible to a certain level but of course it depends on which dialect of irish you speak. I personally as an Ulster Irish speaker am able to understand scots completely and 90% of Scottish Gaelic.
@@joagalo
Depends the region of Ireland and Scotland If you put northem Eire and Ulster together with southern and western Scotland tou can have a normal conversacion in Basic to a pratical level passing by intermediate level, a well nice chat.
But If you put central and southern Eire with northem and eastern southern and eastern Scotland maybe i can have a little conversation or a non conversation depending the culture's speakers in situation.
But if you have a irish and scotish that domains protoceltic and protogaelic you have the most beautiful celtic chat cós they can speak gaelic and celtic in a old pure version and in a scotish and irish version together, in a higher erudite level its possible in a academic scientific level too.🍻🍻🍻🍻🍻🍹🍹🍹🍹🍹🍹
Scottish Gaelic is more closely to Romance languages, like French or Spanish than to Scots languages. This is because Scottish Gaelic is a Celtic language, while Scots is Germanic.
The most underrated channel in the world, thank you Andy for all your hard work!
I'd be glad to participate in a video for central Scots.
Good day! I've been waiting for a volunteer!
Please help me with it! Here are the things we need from you:
Text and Audio for the following:
The native name of the language/ dialect
Numbers 1 to 10
Greetings & Phrases
Vocabulary
Any story / Sample text
Images for:
Flag & Emblem
Traditional Costumes
Art/ Patterns
Information about the language, people & culture!
Suggestion for Background music :D
Looking forward! :D
The Wren
The wren used to have his nest in the car shed.
Once the old ones had both flown out
they had wanted to get something to eat for
their young and had left the little ones all alone.
After a while, Father Wren returns home.
“What’s happened here?” he says.
“Who harmed you, children?
You are all terrified!”
“Oh, Dad,” they say, “some big bogeyman came
by just now. He looked so fierce and horrible!
He stared into our nest with his big eyes.
That scared us so!”
“I see,” Father Wren says,
“where did he go?”
“Well,” they say,
“he went down that way.”
“I see,” Father Wren says,
“where did he go?”
“Well,” they say,
“he went down that way.”
“Wait!” Father Wren says,
“I’ll be after him. Don’t you worry now, children.
I’ll get him.”
When he comes around the bend,
it is the lion who is walking along there.
But the wren is not afraid.
He alights on the lion’s back and starts scolding him.
“What business do you have coming to my house,” he says,
“and terrifying my children?!”
The lion pays no attention to it and keeps walking.
That makes the little loud-mouth berate him even more fiercely.
“You have no business being there,
I tell you! And if you come back,” he says,
“well, then you’ll see!
I don’t really want to do it,” he says and
finally lifts one of his legs, “but I’d break
your back with my leg in a second!”
Thereupon he flies back to his nest.
“There you go, children,” he says,
“I’ve taught that one a lesson. He won’t be back.”
Stay happy,
Andy!
Kindly send it to this email.
otipeps24@gmail.com
It would be fun to see a video comparing swedish dialects
Andy loves contrasts, scots dorics its germanics near to anglo saxon and yola and scotish gaelic is near to irish gaelic and manx gaelic, very strongly celtic.
Cuddles to pretty and loved scotland scotland 🍻🍻🍻🍻💋💋💋💋💋🫂💙🌷❤️
Wow, amazing
I think Shetland Scots would be fun to see too
🍻🍻🍻🍻 Shetland Scots, Scots Doric and Doric Orkneyic, norn, nynorn wow , wonderful, Majestic comparison.
AS A SHETLANDER I AGREE SO MUCH
Is Scottish Gaelic is a part/variant of Irish language (Gaeilge)?
It was in ancient era and ages when all uk and ireland were celtics, but with the germanics and latins invasions both becames independent from each,accussing the end of celtic era.
Today both are independent langs for all linguistic as welsh and manx
Both are members of the Gaelic languages.
Scottish Gaelic derives from earlier Irish Gaelic spoken by settlers from Ireland after the Saxon invasions. The Gaelic spoken before that is from a different branch, of which Welsh and Cornish are surviving members of.
No. It is sometimes called a dialect of Irish by people who want to diminish it, but both languages have different standards.
They are closely related and have a degree of mutual intelligibility but so do Swedish, Norwegian and Danish and nobody would say they are the same languages.
SCOTLAND FOREVERRRRR
Doric was spoken in Brave.
Hi
hi! how are you today? 😊
@@tribaounidadedonstania good you
We(singular) love these languages.
Very scottish!
Discord server?
Where my Ionian and Aeolic Scots peeps at?
ΛΩΛ
Scots gaelic sounds like aaurghaurhgreeugh aaurghrughgughguhg sheen yachaaurauur
Chan eil thu ceàrr. You aren't wrong, lol
This isnt Doric Scots. Doric Scots is spoken in North East Scotland. This is a central dialect.
I live in aberdeen so I hear doric a lot but i never understand it
i wanna learn it
Different language families
Gaelic seems to be a very guttural sounding language
Yep and musical, rhymed too
If you need a volunteer for Eastern Scots (Edinburgh & Lothian) i could do a recording for you
Yes, Please send me an email. otipeps24@gmail.com
(rish)
Yeshua Dia ag teacht go han-luath. Tá Nibiru agus a plaineid ag teacht n taobh thiar den Ghrian.
Glac pictiúr den ghrian le camara ar do ghuthán. Tá Nibiru cosuil leis an ngrian, agus deirtear go bhfuil pláinéad dearg, pláinéad bán, pláinéad dear sár-mhór, agus pláinéad sár-mhór i gcruth diosca ag teacht ó chúl na gréine. Anois feicfidh daoine anseo agus ansiúd pláinéad mór bán ar snámh mar scamall, dhá ghrian, plainéad dear an-mhor ag éiri agus ag luí na gréine, agus miotal a bhfuil cuma diosca air. Feicfidh tú pláinéad rick-daite (liath, airgead) ar snamh sa speir ban, feicfidh tú speir corcra, agus feicfich tú 24K solas daite óir ion ag titim sa spéir. Tá na pláinéid bhána an-mhor agus is cosúil le dathanna suilineacha tuar ceatha, agus is fearr a fheictear iad sa speir thoir nuair a ardaionn an ghrian. Thaispeain Dia dom an fhis, má ghlacann tú pictiúr den spéir, feicfidh tú pláinéid, agus na pláinéid ag éiri nios dlúithe agus nios dlúithe, agus tá siad ag eiri nios soiléire i rith an lae.
Very similar to Latin, while the scots is utterly Germanic! Interesting.
Bruh there is
Scottish language doesn't belong there it's Germanic not Celtic Brotonic (Gaelic she'll only be speaking and sense other native tongue the country should have been speaking in Gaelic
As a native speaker of Doric and a 'reclaiming' L2 learner of Gaelic, why tf would you compare them?
They’re just two languages spoken in Scotland, and he likes to compare languages spoken in a country (regardless of language family), and he also like to compare languages that are in the same language family like a comparison of Icelandic and Norwegian or Portuguese and French etc.
Gaelic is from the Irish invaders. The pictish language is lost. Scots is from the Angles and Danish invaders
Yes. But irish are not invaders. They are celts too. And if we reed the pictish stones closely, we can reincarnate pictish language
@@Edarnon_Brodie The Irish, like the Angles and the Norse, most certainly were invaders. The Britons of South-West Scotland and the Picts have the best claim to being indigenous. Also new genetic evidence has pointed towards the Celtic languages (and people ?) only coming into the British Isles around 1000 BC. Their DNA is today found mostly in southern Britain but less so in Scotland, Ireland and Northern England. The Celtic languages aparently spread to Scotland and Ireland without much population movement from the south. The populations of Scotland and Ireland are mainly descended from the Beaker folk who came from mainland Europe in the Early Bronze age - and who were not Celtic.
Scottish Scots is more like English
Well, yeah. Scots is the only sister language of English that’s still alive, so it’s a Germanic language, whereas Gaelic is a Celtic language. They’re both Indo-European at the end of the day, though, and I think that relation was shown in the numbers, at least.
Its related to english thats why
Not much before til today, Scots doric is near to yola, flemish and Scots Shetlandic and Orkneyic and close to norn,nynor and norwegian today.
English today is very close to pitkarnese, frenglish, anglonormand,globish etc
@@SinilkMudilaSama I’m from Norway and I’ve listened to and studied Scots (Doric), and besides the words ‘barn’ and ‘kirk’ and the fact they’re both of the Germanic subgroup of Indo-European languages, I see nothing that makes them “close” to each other…
So embarrasing to neglect a rich Celtic language to another germanic generic one!
Gaelic won’t do anything for you in today’s world, besides make for a hobby and a bit of cultural pride for those who speak it in their tiny part of the world; English, however, is one of the most valuable languages to be fluent in as far as being useful on the world stage (business and communications). It’s like my native Norwegian, only about 4 million or so people speak it, and 98% live in Norway (or the Scandinavian countries like Danmark). We all learn English at a young age so we can actually communicate with people outside of our small language group, and so we can have a better shot at being successful on today’s world. My parents had me learn German, too, as it has a major usefulness in European business. I certainly don’t think any language that is part of a country’s culture should be left to die out, but more prevalent, useful languages tend to take priority.