ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 1 ส.ค. 2024
- Best Item Sorter Minecraft Bedrock 1.20
In this video I'll be showing you guys the EASIEST item Sorter in Minecraft Bedrock! This will work on ALL Bedrock Edition platforms. This farm was built in Minecraft Bedrock 1.20!
Join this channel to get access to perks:
/ @1upmc
WORLD DOWNLOAD AND TEXTURE PACK: / discord
My Links
● Second Channel: / @benarbour
● Discord: / discord
● Instagram: / benarbour05
Time stamps:
00:00 - Intro/Materials
00:10 - How To Build
08:15 - How To Use
09:24 - Outro
Music:
Song: The 25th Hour - Shlatt Crossing
Creative Commons ► Attribution 3.0 Unported ► CC BY 3.0
creativecommons.org/licenses/...
"You are free to use, remix, transform, and build upon the material
for any purpose, even commercially. You must give appropriate credit." - เกม
![เบิ้ล ปทุมราช - อ้ายกินดอง น้องลาบงัว ft. สแน็ก อัจฉรีย์ [OFFICIAL MV]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/-OK--KaSPcI/mqdefault.jpg)
Ok, let's do this.
So after hours of testing, I've come to a conclusion as to why filter blocks will sometimes go through the system.
This system is not overflow-proof.
This means once you put a stack of items in the sorter hopper, it sends a stronger redstone signal than normal and therefore unlocks the other hoppers and sends filter items through the system.
A simple way to counteract this is to NOT put a stack of items into the hopper while configuring them. The reason it worked for 1upMC is because he only put 6 items, rather than a stack.
Also, if you fill all 5 double chests with items and and the hopper fills to 64 as well, the system will also break.
Thank you for reading, and give feedback if this helped or not.
God bless you. You have no idea how many different ways I have tried to build this and had it fail repeatedly. It was because I was adding a stack and everything was filtering out. I have finally gotten one working. 🙏
legend bro
So how do I fix this? Can it be fixed? Also, I use barrels not chest, less lag. Please help
@@momfox7711 no. unfortunately, i have no idea how that problem could be fixed. it seems to be that literally every item sorter breaks after being filled to the brim, which is honestly expected.
I guess a way to counteract that issue is simply to just add more storage, but it definitely doesn't FIX the problem.
Using barrels might be less lag, but you're gonna have to use double the amount you would usually use to hold the same amount of items. At the end of the day, it's up to you which you prefer, less lag or more storage.
If you stagger the chests and hoppers, you can ensure all the items go to the bottom chest no matter how full it gets. Get something from the bottom and it will fill back up from the top.
thank you for this i was having some trouble with the filler blocks going into a different chest because of the redstone but i figured it out
This is amazing and the tutorial is easy, understandable, and fun!!! Got a new subscriber!
In order to do the system overflow proof u need to use only 4 filter blocks and 41 items to be sorted. this way it wont break. i used it in my guardian farm (produce over 40k item/h) and it works smooth. hope it help somebody
Thank you, I knew there was a way from building this a long time ago. Just couldn’t remember how.
Yooo you are so underrated love this imma be using it on my world
This can work as a waterless sorter. Set a fence post on a hopper then push a minecart with hopper into it. This will work in the nether and saved water constantly flowing in your world
I’m very new at all this, do you have a reference video or a photo of what this might look like?
@kevinaccinelli1898 no because it's not widely known and my channel isn't a minecraft one. I haven't been on my world in a year while also not being able to screen record things and would have to use my phone to record which wouldn't be the best quality
@@AtkataffTheAlpha no worries, I’ll try and see if I can find a good video of it.
@kevinaccinelli1898 there is none of my design. I'd have to suck it up and record with something then upload it on probably an alt so it doesn't disrupt this accounts content
@@AtkataffTheAlphayou could post it as private on your channel and provide a link to him
i’ve been needing one of these
Thank you for this, I’ve been working on a sorting system for about a week now and this works perfectly. You even told me what I was doing wrong, thank you so much 😊😊😊
Nice ill try it on my friend smp server thank ya
Joined! Thank you for the clear how to videos!!!
Hey man I appreciate it:) It means a lot I’m glad you enjoy the tutorials!
How do you do this with only 1 chest for each item. Can you still have them stacked to make a compact storage system? I just wouldn’t want 4 chests for each item.
Thank You!
Finally a sorting tutorial that works on consoles.
This is great however my items for some reason get stuck and don't go all the way down until they despawn so i am constantly losing tons of items.
im thinking of building a massive chest sorter for basically every item in the game. now i keep seeing that if you put in more than 41 items it overflows. is there anyway around this and would there be any issues doing this build on a large scale in bedrock 1.20 realm?
So I extend this out....slot and fir some reason only the first 12 sorters work. The redstone doesn't even show its powered on. Any ideas as to why
I think I messed up somewhere because no matter what I do whatever item I’m trying to put in a different chest and up going in the same one pls help
You should outline the build area so that way if someone's building this in an already made base they can tell if it's gonna fit. I'm making this fit no matter what because I'm in a bunker but if someone has an above ground base that would be a pain to reconstruct it all over again to fit the build and then make it all look nice afterwards.
yes, this is what is needed. could you provide a list of items with icons for those items? so it is much better to orient people who do not know English at a sufficient level
That's a brilliant idea! I will give it a shot soon:)
that’s as help me so much thanks for the video pal
No problem 👍
It can be a good idea to put the list of materials needed in the description so people who don't understand english can translate everything👍
Materials
- 10 Chests
- 2 Hoppers
- 6 Hoppers
- 1 Dropper
- 1 Redstone Comparator
- 1 Redstone Comparator
- 1 Redstone Repeater
- 1 Redstone Repeater
- 1 Redstone Torch
- 2 Redstone Torch
- 3 Redstone Dust
- 2 Redstone Dust
- 6 Blocks
- 9 Blocks
- 43 Glass
- 1 Chest
- 1 Packed Ice
- 1 Button
- 1 Water Bucket
The list was copied and pasted from a screenshot, so nothing is in order per sorting system, but this should help a little
@@speediablo thanks
@@speediablobut the video shows you needing more than the screenshot shows. Not your fault but what’s up with that? He gives a number then proceeds to use like 10 more than he said in the second step alone
@@lildrives709 He miss counts probably bc he’s in creative. I haven’t seen one person get it 100% accurate yet
If you got an iPhone you might be able to screenshot then copy/paste it from the screenshot
Am I able to make this both ways? Like you have the chests on the right. Can I have some on the left and some on the right?
I’ve noticed if I name cobble stone but also want to have cobblestone as a item I want sorted it breaks the system also I’ve noticed if u put too many things in the chest it all breaks and puts all the named item in the chests
When I put the filler items in the hopper they just went straight to the chest instead of staying in the hopper
Double check your redstone
The first row of hoppers where the water is shouldn’t be connected to chests.
I have this problem too, idk why but even when the hopper isn’t facing down, it still drop the item
@@CBFlims644redstone isn’t done properly then. the hopper should remain locked until it sees a 6th item of that type
The items just stops moving at the first packed ice. Please give me a solution
How do you get the hopper to stop taking your stuff when you trying to make the sorter?
Please can you add a shulker unloader into the design (one that unloads the shulker into the system then breaks it and stores it separately, I’ve seen it before but I can’t find a way to fit it in but you’re much better at designing haha
I just found a design from another person (don't remember who) and added a hopper line near the input chest to the unloader
this is firee, keep the good work😋
Thanks, will do!
Hey so i renamed iron bars Eeeeeeee but there just going into the chests how do i fix this
Yeah, literally any item I add, whether named or not, just gets put straight into the chest. Glad I waste my time...
why won't it let me set my filter blocks. it just starts sorting the 10 blocks i add into the bottom chest. Any Help
Damn I really want one on my survival world but I'm on mobile so it'll take ages but once I get enough wood I'll probably try it out. I also recently made a storage system but its not redstone and doesn't sort items out 😭
When I use the water across the hoppers items get stuck in the top of the hopper, any ideas?
When I try to put the dirt in the hoppers, it just goes through and ends up in the second to last hopper. Help!
why does my renamed blocks go straught through the dropper they dot stay in
my item got stuck in the hopper and it can't continue through the next water any advice?
Excuse me, bro, I've tried this system but when I enter something in the first box, the object in the second box also goes in. How to handle it?
Added this to my skeleton trident grinder, only hiccup is it’s only sorting the first item. All other items get stuck on the second row. Anyone else have this issue? Thx
When I was putting in the dirt, it kept on going in the chest
I followed the exact steps and mine doesn’t work. I’m on Xbox if that makes a difference
Bro can u help me u derstand why when I put a full chest in there it brakes the whole ststem
I keep having my items get stuck after the second hopper. How do I fix this?
i know its a little nooby to ask but i do i make it curve like a corner?
can this be changed to rows of 2 with no issue?
You can build this for auto sorting raids or something. Just don't build the tube part or make the items to into the chest.
facts
My items keep getting stuck on the third hopper any fixes?
Doesnt work at all, the items which are supposed to stay in the hopper dont stay there, help
It didn’t work when I tried the dirt that I named dir just went into the chests how do I fix this?
I’m having the same issue, how did you fix it?
@@nataliajohnson8382same, I am on PE so idk if that is effecting it
is there any chance you may be able to do an individual item sorter tutorial where you can do each individual box versus whole columns being dedicated to a singular resource?
Do the same but one chest instead of three
@@fe4revolution405 i think he means so all three would be something different rather than the same
Whenever I place the renamed items in the chest it just keeps taking them. Did Minecraft get updated since then?
I'm having the same issue was you ever able to figure out how to fix it
Id recommend using barrels instead of chests even tho its less space... chests tend to cause lag
My dirt keeps going into the hopper I renamed it but still goes in?
How do u conect it to another one but on the other side
Will this work without the packed ice?
So I made this and when my bottom chest got completely filled with cobblestone (full chest), it got stuck in the bottom hopper behind the bottom chest. Anyway to fix that?
It sorts great but when one chest gets completely full it doesn't use the chest above itself.
yeahhh right
Once the hopper behind the bottom chest fills, it’ll go into the chest above, almost sort of like an extra storage behind x)
And when you pull from the bottom chest, it will refill that spot from the hopper! :D
What if you want to sort single item stackable things (like tools/totems or something like that) or would it be impossible
Non stackable items, like tools and totems would require an alley sorter to sort into their own chest or just allow them to go into the overflow chest
You could also build a non stackable item sorter and I would recommend connecting it to a shulker loader or having a bit more storage chests depending what all you plan on throwing non stackable wise in the line as water/snow/lava buckets as well as tools and such can fill it up quicker than expected so just keep an eye on that slice if you plan on dumping alot of non stackables. Note that if you want non stackables to have thier own specific chest and be sorted individually and not in bulk all together then an allay sorter would be required
Going to get the beacon out and make it sort every. Single. Survival. Item
When I put my named items in the hopper they get sucked up like normal, why is this happening?
same
It's off..there should be one more row of blocks under the T (kitty corner from the block with the repeater on it) and a line of dust on there.
Should look something like this.
( = Being a block)
= = =
= =
=
=
is there any way to stop items being stuck in the hopper hit box and not going down the rest of the water?
Let me know if you find a solution for this as I am having the same problem
@@gilly_5695you have to change the water flow. so place the water source one block in front of the chest
Any solution?
I know it says bedrock but will it work in Java? Edit: does not work for Java. The hopper lock/sorter just emptied.
You can't put the dirt in becouse it sucks it down right away ?
Hmm. I tried to figure it out myself.
The system is too slow to handle more than one item (per hopper), but does well if that is considered.
changing the repeater to a slower tick helps.
how do you get the named items to not go through the hopper?
Check your red stone
I've double checked, the redstone is fine@@fe4revolution405
i just finished it and it doesn't work on Bedrock Minecraft even when i name the item different it still does not work
my items dont go into my chest even tho the hopper is connected to the chest
some items getting stuck in bottom and middle hoppers even tho they're all facing the chest as explained in the videob
Could you just put 3x 10 Dirt and then 5 Emeralds in the Hopper so that these 20 Chests aren’t just for diamonds
7 blocks wide, 8 blocks tall, 4 blocks long for sorter and 4 additional blocks per 3 items. So this 12 item sorter is 16 blocks long, 15 items would be 20, 18 is 24, etc.
If anyone could answer my question, will twisting the stream to go to the right or left, like making a square from a Birds Eye view for my sorting system alright?
Yes it wil work use packed ice and make shure there's water flow
When I made this some of the items will bring going across the water stream and get stuck on top of a hopper before it gets to its sorting spot. What do I do to fix that
just fixed it, u have to put the water source block on block in front of the chest
instead of having it just like a line is there a way to make it a + shape or just a U shape
?
Just build the sorters opposite of the first set and add a hopper line/water system to move the items around the corners
How are the items going through a solid block? I am so confused. I have everything but the pneumatic tube portion is not working
Glass isn’t a solid block
I built my item sorters by spacing with one block gap on realms cause of lag to my friends. Lol
When I put the place holder it disappears
Nice
Hi i am having trouble with the blocks you rename and place in the hopper with your souce block none of them will stay in the hoppers they all filter through is there a particular block you should use i have renamed dirt, stone, wood, neverrack thanks
The first row of hoppers where the water is shouldn’t be connected to chests
@@anthonybraden157 I have triple checked everything and top row of hoppers are not attached to chests but they still wont lock
I have got the hoppers to lock by removing them and replacing them now they are working properly thank you for the advice
hey are you in bedrock i'm having the exact same issue but when i replace them they keep doing the same thing
@@wendydavies1701
QUESTION: can you make it so it sorts two different items into the same chest?
For example bones and arrows are sorted together
Small issue for mine, when i try to sort the items, the hopper takes the blocks that are supposed to stay there, help
Same I was trying to find the problem but eventually gave up
Why does the button no stop the water and breaks
Does anyone know if you can do this without the sorter so its just automatically putting random items in random chests
I think if you just dont sort them they will go into the first hopper until all those chests are filled, then go to the next hopper over. So basically just follow all the steps except dont do the redstone on the back with the comparitors/etc and renamed blocks
Mine doesnt make the dirt stuck in the hopper:(
Does it work on the latest version of bedrock?
Does all your farm work on mobile?????
Can I use other block instead of ice pack? And what's the button use for?
The packed ice is used so that you can send the items further and the buttons is used to block the water from flowing the wrong direction. You can switch the buttons with signs or pressure plates if you like but not the packed ice.
Ok so I see a lot of people saying that got issues I built this and extended on too it it works very well and I think the reason why it might not be working for example the hopper eating the names blocks is that there putting a stack in of what they want in the chest so maybe put half a stack or less and it works fine for me but that’s how I fixed it
Nope. I can put a whole stack or one single item. Named or unnamed and it goes straight into the chest....
how can i make it 1 or 2 chests for each items because you put around 5 double chests for each item which is a lot.
Do the same thing but only do 2 rows of hoppers and chests. It doesnt affect anything.
oh ok I thought i has to be that hight.
Yes you are able to put as many or few chests as you want. I chose 5 because it allowed for easy access to the top chests.
Thanks i will definitely add this to my survival world
is it possible to use, for example, wooden shovels without a name instead of land with a name?
unfortunately no because they give out a different comparator strengths than stack able items
@@1upMC sad but thank you
I am on Xbox and I can’t get the filter items to stay they keep going through into the chest.
Are your red stone torches in the right place? The hopper should be locked until it has 45 items
Hi ! My blocks are stuck in th hoppers and don't go in the next water source, do you know how to fix it ? Thx for the tuto it's very well explained
Im at the same point. I throw items in the chest, they go up, they go across the first section and stop at the button. Ive tried different spot/positions for the water source and nothing.
Just fixed it. The block right before the first hopper, place a packed ice and a button. The water flow can't be more than 3 blocks for the items to go over the ice and button.
@@beefyply it worked for me as well, thanks a lot 🙏
Has there been some kind of bug update or did I just do it wrong? I cant get this to work.
If your hoppers are facing into the other hopper it wont work unless it is facing into the comparator
i changed mine to face the comparator and it sill dosn't work
@@topgaming6508
Any reason why when I put in my subscribe dirt it passes through and goes to the first chest? Mine didn't work as easily as you made it look
I’m having the same problem bro
@@overdrivegaming1646 Well I rebuilt it in creative and it works! I am not sure what happen before other than I did it in survival and without flying it makes it harder. When I rebuilt the material shot out the side haha luckily I didn't get mad and blow it up with tnt Minecraft has come a long way and I have not been playing for some time, had a stroke and out of work temporally to recover and picked up Minecraft again. Dude I was stoned and lost in a desert and stumbled on to a camel WTF! I love this game and this system is a must!!!!!
Hey also pretty sure this didn't help but instead of using dirt for the filler I renamed Scaffolding, since I am using mine half way down to bedrock you should never find Scaffolding caving? Then again its Minecraft, who knows haha
Any renamed item that stacks up to 64 works and on bedrock sometimes items skip over their respective hopper due to speed at which hoppers can pull in if its too many. Silent whisper if I remember correctly covers this in a video of his and all the mechanics of it since this was originally done on Java by impulse but the redstone parodies between the 2 versions cause some issues
@@phantomphoenix331 And they say this is a pointless stupid video game haha No its not!
How do you bend a corner with this design?
Set your chests so you can access them and then at the top let the water flow around the corner should be able to let it go up to 7 before placing ice button combo with new source or can cut stream right before corner and have new source block start in corner goin new direction
I modified it to make it secure now you need a Redstone torch to activate it, and this is super helpful :)
Why my item got stuck on a hopper?
Damn I’ve been trying to get this to work for the last few hours. My items keep getting stuck over the third hopper 😓
That's because the first water stream that you placed extends for too long, which prevents the items from going to the next ice block (it gets stuck right on top of the third hopper). What you need to do is place packed ice next to the first hopper and place a button/sign, then place water on top of the first hopper as well.
I can’t put 10 subscribes into the hoppers they don’t stay in like his does, they feed through to the chest. How can I stop that
@@Bongwell420 having the same problem dont rly know the issue
@@Bongwell420been having the same problem. I hope someone actually answers.
Same
why does the button breaks
Anyone know why I can’t get the stuff to stay in the hopper?
Make it link to the comparator
@@logandevorewhat do you mean by that though?
This is super cool thank you very much! With my ocd I modified it and well once you make 4 chest sections instead of 3 sections the water for me didn't flow correctly and broke my heart, I tried to turn it but have run into another problem, water flow! How do you turn a corner and keep the water flowing in the correct direction? I have been dinking around with trying to move water and starting to think its not possible. Thank you again for the very easy Item sorter that really works
I just noticed something, my items are going straight to the bottom chest of each row of hoppers, do I put the Subscribe dirt in every row of the hoppers? Once the bottom chest is done I have another 4 rows of chests to fill.
Cant figure out how to keep named items in the hopper it keeps going in the chest below help....... pls
double check the redstone is correct and all the comparators and repeaters are facing correctly, also make sure your hoppers are all pointed correctly, i got this working on my xbox world rn
I figured out I misplaced the Redstone tourches one block too low got it working now
I watch a different video that went 5 wide with chest because a space. Is that still doable or does it have to be 3?
I think 5 would work? but I'm not sure. I KNOW that 6 is too many because items would get caught on the Hopper,
@@1upMC funny enough it was your video from 11 months ago lol
Why is the dirt goin into the hopper?
No other items can go in