I shouldn’t be too surprised that no one likes Kerry Shale Henry lol. I don’t mind it personally but I wouldn’t say it’s one of the best. I would say that Keith Wickham OWNS Henry, especially as the seasons progressed S.18 and onward. Great job dude!
The Baldwin Henry voice is amazing. He sounds like a stuffy, bratty teenager. That’s so relatable to me and just shows he’s tired with life in general. I think Robin Smith is fine with Henry in the other DVDs, but the clip you used from the Steamies Vs Diesels DVD, with Henry’s voice is utterly terrible. Henry voiced by Robin Smith is the definition of inconsistency. Michael Brandon’s Henry voice in S11-12 is so terrible it pulls him down severely on my ranking.
the UK/AUS fans tend to have a weird….distaste for Baldwin as a narrator in general so i kinda get it. but like saying it doesn’t suit Henry is weird. “Flanderized” or not, Henry is an easily irritated and often sickly character. and that’s just Baldwin’s delivery in S5 of Henry in general, Haunted Henry and Something in the Air each kill me because of that.
This was a pretty nice ranking. Here's mine: 1. Keith Wickham 2. Kevin Frank 3. Michael Angelis 4. Pierce Brosnan 5. Simon Hepworth 6. Mark Moraghan 7. Alec Baldwin 8. George Carlin 9. Michael Brandon 10. Kerry Shale 11. Patrick Breen 12. Robin Smith Like you said, Keith Wickham does sound somewhat raspy at times, but I actually don't mind that. I'm honestly not surprised that people don't like Kerry Shale's Henry, but I've never had too much of an issue with that. But then again, opinions are opinions, so I very much respect yours.
I did have a feeling Kerry Shale would be the bottom of the list, but I didn't expect to see Pierce Brosnan at the top of the list. As for character voices you should rank next, maybe you should do Edward or maybe a TV series character, like Emily.
Same here, besides in terms of tone I couldn’t imagine if Kerry made Henry sound similar to Gordon or James and Sir Topham Hatt (both at the time from HOTR to S18).
@@bradleycotton3237 I would say the voice IS funny And fits i would say the Same For alce i would say It ironic enjoyable i Just Noticed taht in all of the Ranking Videos an American voice IS Last i dont think tihs gona Change soon to be honest
Like Gordon, Henry is a character who's (if not all) voices are manufactured due to how many times he had been written or much of a large factor his life is. And so it can be very hard to keep him sound natural and keep his character consistent at the same time. Side-note, I love Alec Baldwin's Henry voice. So the only two people that managed to get him right are both Kevin Frank and Simon Hepworth (Henry's subplot of being ill was written in the script/final cut of the film so the stuffed up part isn't like it was done on purpose, so Kevin Frank still gave it his all and I'm sure he'd still do a more fantastic job in two other scenes that were originally written in the script like how he was offended about Percy using the word 'silence' and thanking Thomas for bringing the new coal). So Kevin Frank is now my favorite Henry VA! However, outside those English-speaking voices, Ryō Horikawa really nailed his character and sounded natural too in the Japanese dub of S1-8!
I like Kerry Shale and Michael Brandon’s voice for Henry. I don’t like Kevin Frank’s performance as Henry as he made him sound too bland and young. John Cleese would have been better to make Henry sound more grumpy and dignified. That’s part of his character. If they were to make more episodes or good movies to have Henry in an active role like Thomas, Percy and James (instead of the crappy reboot), Henry definitely would have been Near Pure Good as he subverted most of his rude and selfish traits by season 8, despite still being arrogant. Gordon would have also been Inconsistently Admirable as he didn’t subvert many of his corrupting traits like Thomas and James if he did more heroic actions.
3:25, I agree with this for the most part, with a few exceptions. For instance Alec Baldwin dose my favorite Oliver voice of all time. But as far as Henry goes maybe he was shown season 5 Henrys angry face and based his voice on that. But I agree, its a poor voice for Henry.
Cool video, here’s my list 1. Kevin Frank (If he had done a British accent, he works) 2. Pierce Brosman 3. Michael Angelis 4. George Carlin 5. Keith Wickham 6. Patrick Breen 7. Mark Moraghan 8. Michael Brandon 9. Simon Hepworth 10. Alec Baldwin 11. Kerry Shale 12. Robin Smith Side note: Would you do Edward, Toby and Duck?
I don't mind Keith as Henry. Sure, it still doesn't sound like him, but, I agree, he's better than Kerry. Also, I think you should rank Emily's Voices next. That would be very interesting.
LETS GO IVE BEEN WAITING FOR THIS ONE I honestly am nostalgic for Kerry Shale, but it is still kinda bad I also like Alec Baldwin. Hot take but I love his voices a lot
ALEC BALDWIN DID THE ABSOLUTE BEST HENRY VOICE!!!! Same for Gordon and James, he’s literally the best f*cking narrator for the show and he narrated the best season. The main reason I love season 5 is because of Alec’s Henry voice and Henry’s attitude, season 5 was the most tough and stuffy he’s ever been, he wasn’t a scared wimp, he was pretty bad a$$. Season 5 is the best season! But Alec’s Henry voice for season 6 was so disappointing!
Alec Baldwin is my favourite Henry voice. He sounds like a grumpy, stuffy guy. And I agree about Angelis' narration in Season 7. Dare I say it, I honestly prefer it over his Season 5 and 6 narrations.
Idk why people dog on s7 Micheal Angelis. I genuinely enjoy his delivery in alot of episodes. Especially in Emily's new coaches, spotless record, and peace and quiet. His voice just works so well, with the more calm /monoton feel of s7. If someone like Carlin or Baldwin did the dub I think they would actually slightly ruin s7s whole vibe
I never knew why but Henry is by far my favorite of the first 10 engines. I kinda think that he’s trying to be posh cause he’s basically a badly designed Gordon and I know Awdry hated that they made Henry a nature lover because it’s not accurate to how railroads work but I like it. I think it’s nice to see engines having interests outside of favorite stations or types of trains to pull. Thanks for the rating of his VAs and I can’t wait to see what you do next
12:17 Nope your not the only one who likes Angelis in S7. I also rewatched the episodes as him being the narrator and honestly he was okay, sure he wasn’t excited in S6 but who cares. To me I think the best voice actor for Henry is Angelis, Carlin, and Ringo. As I started to rewatch the classic series of Thomas, and yes I was born in America and only watched US dubs as a kid, but I did try the UK dubs as well, Ringo and Angelis actually we’re alright. It’s well ashamed that the new voice actor for Henry in CGI didn’t go well, still I kinda find it funny in my opinion how they made him so young. Still though I have to agree with the voice actor of Henry in the CGI a D tier.
The thing about Robin Smith's Henry voice: It is inconsistent as all hell I'm pretty sure he has changed no character voice more frequently than Henry's. Sometimes he sounds like the Steamies Vs. Diesels DVD menu game (less said the better), other times he actually sounds fairly spot on Here's an example of what I mean: th-cam.com/video/n40Y4hlJHqU/w-d-xo.html
Thank you, I commented that too. His voices in the Steamies VS Diesels game, other than Henry, are pretty good. Harvey and BoCo are examples. Henry’s voice in the Best Of Thomas and the Early Years DVD games are pretty decent.
I had a feeling that it wasn't just me who adored Pierce Brosnan 's five line reading of Henry. That man could've saved S12 with his narration and GODLY VOICES!😊
Narrators 1. Michael Angelis 2. George Carlin 3. Pierce Brosnan 4. Mark Moraghan 5. Ringo Starr 6. Alec Baldwin 7. Michael Brandon 8. Robin Smith 👎🏻 Voice actors 1. Keith Wickham 👍🏻👍🏻 2. Kevin Frank 👍🏻 3. Kerry Shale 👎🏻👎🏻 Next ones: *Toby,* Sir Topham Hatt, Diesel
I think for your next voices ranked list, you should do The Fat Controller, my list is as follows: 1. Michael Angelis (When I think of character in general, Aneglis always comes to mind, he owns the Fat Controller's voice and remained consistent from classic to HIT) 2. Keith Wickham (Best CGI voice without question) 3. George Carlin (A good voice, but I prefer the UK counterparts for voices) 4. Alec Baldwin (Decent voice in general, good tone and all, but there's better voices) 5. Kerry Shale (Ok voice for the CGI series, one of the better voices he's done for the US audience) 6. Ringo Starr (I love Ringo, but while he can deliver angry/stern moments, the voice is too similar to other characters) 7. Michael Brandon (Not deep enough for the character in general, too similar to his narration voice) 8. Rob Rackstraw (It's basically just Mr Bentley from Bob The Builder)
Do you think you can cover Edward's voice actors next? You've already done gordon and Henry, now's your chance to complete all of the "Three Railway Engines" with the one who started it all. Edward: Oh, yes please!
If I had to chose any British Celebrity to voice Henry, I would definitely go for Gordon Ramsay. Because whenever I hear Ramsay talk more calm and relaxed, it really blends in well with Henry many different facial expressions, especially in the model series.
Thomas Percy James Gordon and Emily’s CGI US dub voices as well as Diesel Mavis Spencer and Cranky’s were good but Edward Henry and Toby’s CGI US voices were so “wtf?” and questionable
Oh yeah. I forgot to ask this when the video came out, but because all of the voices for Thomas, Percy, and James weren’t in their videos, how would you rank them now, including all narrators and temp voices?
I really wish they had Keith Wickham voice Henry in both dubs. No offense to Kerry Shale, but he SUCKS as Henry. Just about as much as William Hope sucks as both Edward and Toby (two other characters who I wish had their UK voices in both dubs).
I'm not surprised that Kerry Shale is at the bottom of the list. His voice for Henry is just too high-pitched and wussy for my liking. Alec Baldwin's take was abysmal, too. Due to making him sound like a stuffed-up, weak moron. But Pierce Brosnan making the Number 1 spot really surprised me. I have to admit, his voice fits Henry so well. If he only had more to work with.
George's voices for Henry is my personal favorite because of how I see in my headcanon. I headcanon Henry being done with life and very cynical view on most things except for nature and a few things but also sympathetic. George's voice has that grandpa hating everything around him type, but also that sympathetic edge to him like you said.
If I’m honest, Willie Rushton’s Henry (one of the people who recorded audiobook versions of Wilbert’s books) is one of my favorite interpretations of his character, along with Ted Robbins’s portrayal in his rendition of Henry and the Express (one of Christopher’s books). Willie Rushton’s work on The Railway Series in general is some of the best in the whole franchise imo, along with Angelis and Carlin in the TV series. His narration is very much informed by the lore of the books, being the only narrator in the whole franchise who pronounces Rheneas the way Wilbert Awdry intended it to be pronounced (RHEN-e-as, instead of the more widely known rhen-AY-iss).
Kerry Shale isn’t a surprise to me. Whilst he wasn’t bad as voicing Gordon in the US Dub, Kerry Shale is NOT my favorite Henry voice. Keith Wickham’s Henry Voice is way better in my opinion.
![[Live] ศึกมหึมันส์มวยไทยสังเวียนเดือด เวทีมวยชั่วคราวสวนสยาม | จันทร์ 30 กันยายน 2567](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/pM1k6f7JXUc/mqdefault.jpg)
I shouldn’t be too surprised that no one likes Kerry Shale Henry lol. I don’t mind it personally but I wouldn’t say it’s one of the best. I would say that Keith Wickham OWNS Henry, especially as the seasons progressed S.18 and onward. Great job dude!
Um, actually, I’ll have you know that I like Kerry Shale out of nostalgia. Also because Shale occasionally did his Gordon voice on Gumball.
@@DodotheWishFanboy and I care because…why exactly?
@@yamitay9258 fair enough (I somehow just realized that you were the same guy that replied to my comment lol).
@@DodotheWishFanboyI’m not a guy, but I’m done here
@@yamitay9258 Tay wehn IS the next Vid coming Out
The Baldwin Henry voice is amazing. He sounds like a stuffy, bratty teenager. That’s so relatable to me and just shows he’s tired with life in general. I think Robin Smith is fine with Henry in the other DVDs, but the clip you used from the Steamies Vs Diesels DVD, with Henry’s voice is utterly terrible. Henry voiced by Robin Smith is the definition of inconsistency. Michael Brandon’s Henry voice in S11-12 is so terrible it pulls him down severely on my ranking.
I agree!!!
I really like Baldwin’s Henry voice, he sounds stuffy and grumpy like how he should be.
the UK/AUS fans tend to have a weird….distaste for Baldwin as a narrator in general so i kinda get it.
but like saying it doesn’t suit Henry is weird. “Flanderized” or not, Henry is an easily irritated and often sickly character. and that’s just Baldwin’s delivery in S5 of Henry in general, Haunted Henry and Something in the Air each kill me because of that.
@@karseniberrai agree, i prefer alec baldwin in season 5 and michael brandon more just like some other users
Same here. I also feel his James voice was top notch
@@karseniberraI like Alac Baldwin and I'm British
This was a pretty nice ranking. Here's mine:
1. Keith Wickham
2. Kevin Frank
3. Michael Angelis
4. Pierce Brosnan
5. Simon Hepworth
6. Mark Moraghan
7. Alec Baldwin
8. George Carlin
9. Michael Brandon
10. Kerry Shale
11. Patrick Breen
12. Robin Smith
Like you said, Keith Wickham does sound somewhat raspy at times, but I actually don't mind that. I'm honestly not surprised that people don't like Kerry Shale's Henry, but I've never had too much of an issue with that. But then again, opinions are opinions, so I very much respect yours.
I felt Baldwin’s Henry voice actually works perfectly for it cause it gives him the stuffed up nose and his grumpy attitude like in the RWS
I actually like Kerry Shale and Michael Brandon's voice roles as Henry.
Not kerry he is a -99 / 10
I did have a feeling Kerry Shale would be the bottom of the list, but I didn't expect to see Pierce Brosnan at the top of the list. As for character voices you should rank next, maybe you should do Edward or maybe a TV series character, like Emily.
Sorry, but Alec Baldwin is my favorite voice for Henry. I think he fits Henry
I also really like Series 7 Angelis.
I actually don't mind Kerry Shale's Henry voice
Me too
Same here, besides in terms of tone I couldn’t imagine if Kerry made Henry sound similar to Gordon or James and Sir Topham Hatt (both at the time from HOTR to S18).
Kind of makes him sound like Lenny from _The Simpsons._
@@bradleycotton3237
I would say the voice IS funny
And fits i would say the Same
For alce i would say It ironic enjoyable i Just Noticed taht in all of the Ranking Videos an American voice IS Last i dont think tihs gona Change soon to be honest
@@bradleycotton3237 Alongside Rex from Toy Story, Archibald from VeggieTales and (now to think of it) even the Doorman from Curious George.
I love Alec's Henry voice. Sue me. Never realized how Brosnan's voice suits Henry so well though.
Me too, why does Alec get a few backlash even in Season 5 (which is the best season of the series)?
Me too, I love every Alec voice, especially Henry’s. His is the most accurate to what an American Henry would sound like
@@AndrewTheRocketCityRailfan4014But Henry's British not American
Like Gordon, Henry is a character who's (if not all) voices are manufactured due to how many times he had been written or much of a large factor his life is. And so it can be very hard to keep him sound natural and keep his character consistent at the same time. Side-note, I love Alec Baldwin's Henry voice.
So the only two people that managed to get him right are both Kevin Frank and Simon Hepworth (Henry's subplot of being ill was written in the script/final cut of the film so the stuffed up part isn't like it was done on purpose, so Kevin Frank still gave it his all and I'm sure he'd still do a more fantastic job in two other scenes that were originally written in the script like how he was offended about Percy using the word 'silence' and thanking Thomas for bringing the new coal). So Kevin Frank is now my favorite Henry VA!
However, outside those English-speaking voices, Ryō Horikawa really nailed his character and sounded natural too in the Japanese dub of S1-8!
Fun fact: Ryo Horikawa is also famous for voicing Vegeta in Dragon Ball.
He's also captain falcon in smash @@therenamonstan
And then in season 9 to 24 henry's japanese voice went from the prince of all sayians to the fastest thing alive.
@@AutZentus Junichi Kanemaru. Yes. He voices Sonic the Hedgehog.
And he also voices porter the dockside tank engine. @@therenamonstan
9:06 funny😂😂😂😂
Henry’s voice is as inconsistent as Thomas in the HIT Model Era
In the UK Dub
How did I rightfully predict that Kerry Shale would be at the very bottom of the list
You’re Raven Baxter?
1:53 well technically he is younger compared to edward thomas and toby.
Favorite voice is Alec Baldwin, I don’t know it’s just something about it that I love.
Maybe it if the stuffiness was tone down? Idk
Keith Wickham Henry sounds like he's gasping for air to breath.
All Diesel voices ranked next! :D
That would be great yes
I like Kerry Shale and Michael Brandon’s voice for Henry. I don’t like Kevin Frank’s performance as Henry as he made him sound too bland and young. John Cleese would have been better to make Henry sound more grumpy and dignified. That’s part of his character. If they were to make more episodes or good movies to have Henry in an active role like Thomas, Percy and James (instead of the crappy reboot), Henry definitely would have been Near Pure Good as he subverted most of his rude and selfish traits by season 8, despite still being arrogant. Gordon would have also been Inconsistently Admirable as he didn’t subvert many of his corrupting traits like Thomas and James if he did more heroic actions.
You should do Toby next just so you could put Colm Feore at the top lol
My ranking
12:kerry shale
11:micheal brandon
10:robin smith
9.patrick breen
8.mark moraghan
7.ringo starr
6.kevin frank
5.alec baldwin
4.keith wickam
3.pierce brosnan
2.goerge carlin
1.micheal angelis
this is great
@@ThomasAndRandomRobloxGames Cheers mait
I like Kerry Shale voice of Henry. If Hugh Laurie voiced Henry. It will be the good voice for Henry.
Not me, Mary shale doesn't sound like henry. Too cartoony and way too high pitched.
I find it kind of weird that Kerry Shale's voice for Henry is the same one provided for Kevin, but almost without the New Jersey accent.
Kerry Shale isn’t bad, but I wish that he’d re-sun his character to sound more calmer and not so coward like in the flatbeds of fear
10:20 MY MOM AND I LOVE THAT LINE AS WELL
Ngl Kevin frank From magic railroad is my favorite 🙌
Have you ever considered updating your original Thomas voice list to have more VAs?
3:25, I agree with this for the most part, with a few exceptions. For instance Alec Baldwin dose my favorite Oliver voice of all time. But as far as Henry goes maybe he was shown season 5 Henrys angry face and based his voice on that. But I agree, its a poor voice for Henry.
Cool video, here’s my list
1. Kevin Frank (If he had done a British accent, he works)
2. Pierce Brosman
3. Michael Angelis
4. George Carlin
5. Keith Wickham
6. Patrick Breen
7. Mark Moraghan
8. Michael Brandon
9. Simon Hepworth
10. Alec Baldwin
11. Kerry Shale
12. Robin Smith
Side note: Would you do Edward, Toby and Duck?
I don't mind Keith as Henry. Sure, it still doesn't sound like him, but, I agree, he's better than Kerry. Also, I think you should rank Emily's Voices next. That would be very interesting.
I think you should do Edward next
Yesss
Henry really got screwed by HIT and that stupid book…Carlin will always be my favorite VA but some of the CG voices are good but not Henry
LETS GO IVE BEEN WAITING FOR THIS ONE
I honestly am nostalgic for Kerry Shale, but it is still kinda bad
I also like Alec Baldwin. Hot take but I love his voices a lot
I don't like Pierce's Henry voice.
Kerry Shale fits the wimpy Henry, but my god it’s awful. Genuinely the only bad US dub voice to me.
ALEC BALDWIN DID THE ABSOLUTE BEST HENRY VOICE!!!! Same for Gordon and James, he’s literally the best f*cking narrator for the show and he narrated the best season. The main reason I love season 5 is because of Alec’s Henry voice and Henry’s attitude, season 5 was the most tough and stuffy he’s ever been, he wasn’t a scared wimp, he was pretty bad a$$. Season 5 is the best season! But Alec’s Henry voice for season 6 was so disappointing!
I Like Kerry Shale Voicing Henry
Alec Baldwin is my favourite Henry voice. He sounds like a grumpy, stuffy guy.
And I agree about Angelis' narration in Season 7. Dare I say it, I honestly prefer it over his Season 5 and 6 narrations.
5:17 ANGEL DUST?!
it's like angel was saying this sarcastically.
Keith wickham owns Henry voice
See?Finally someone who agrees with my opinion!I use his voice for Henry all the time when I read fanfiction and stuff.
Idk why people dog on s7 Micheal Angelis. I genuinely enjoy his delivery in alot of episodes. Especially in Emily's new coaches, spotless record, and peace and quiet. His voice just works so well, with the more calm /monoton feel of s7. If someone like Carlin or Baldwin did the dub I think they would actually slightly ruin s7s whole vibe
I'm guessing Edward is next in about... 5-6 months?
I never knew why but Henry is by far my favorite of the first 10 engines. I kinda think that he’s trying to be posh cause he’s basically a badly designed Gordon and I know Awdry hated that they made Henry a nature lover because it’s not accurate to how railroads work but I like it. I think it’s nice to see engines having interests outside of favorite stations or types of trains to pull. Thanks for the rating of his VAs and I can’t wait to see what you do next
12:17 Nope your not the only one who likes Angelis in S7. I also rewatched the episodes as him being the narrator and honestly he was okay, sure he wasn’t excited in S6 but who cares. To me I think the best voice actor for Henry is Angelis, Carlin, and Ringo. As I started to rewatch the classic series of Thomas, and yes I was born in America and only watched US dubs as a kid, but I did try the UK dubs as well, Ringo and Angelis actually we’re alright. It’s well ashamed that the new voice actor for Henry in CGI didn’t go well, still I kinda find it funny in my opinion how they made him so young. Still though I have to agree with the voice actor of Henry in the CGI a D tier.
The thing about Robin Smith's Henry voice: It is inconsistent as all hell
I'm pretty sure he has changed no character voice more frequently than Henry's. Sometimes he sounds like the Steamies Vs. Diesels DVD menu game (less said the better), other times he actually sounds fairly spot on
Here's an example of what I mean: th-cam.com/video/n40Y4hlJHqU/w-d-xo.html
Thank you, I commented that too. His voices in the Steamies VS Diesels game, other than Henry, are pretty good. Harvey and BoCo are examples. Henry’s voice in the Best Of Thomas and the Early Years DVD games are pretty decent.
PIERCE COULD'VE BEEN THE BEST VOICE FOR HENRY!😊😊
Cant wait to see the Edward voices video! 😊
I like Henrys us CGI voice more tahn the UK at least kery
Sounds Like he IS trying not like the uk voice but i see waht u mean
Do Toby next
Patrick Breen's Henry voice makes him sound a bit like James May, ngl.
I had a feeling that it wasn't just me who adored Pierce Brosnan 's five line reading of Henry. That man could've saved S12 with his narration and GODLY VOICES!😊
Can you do Edward
Is Edward next?
His first voice was zesty asf lmao in the cgi series
Edward and Hiro and a all set
New Jersey Henry is just......no..
5:17 Big Bird
Narrators
1. Michael Angelis
2. George Carlin
3. Pierce Brosnan
4. Mark Moraghan
5. Ringo Starr
6. Alec Baldwin
7. Michael Brandon
8. Robin Smith 👎🏻
Voice actors
1. Keith Wickham 👍🏻👍🏻
2. Kevin Frank 👍🏻
3. Kerry Shale 👎🏻👎🏻
Next ones: *Toby,* Sir Topham Hatt, Diesel
I couldn't agree more with the pick for #1 WORST. That voice just sounds so cringe.
Keith Wickham sounds like he has a stuffed nose
I think for your next voices ranked list, you should do The Fat Controller, my list is as follows:
1. Michael Angelis (When I think of character in general, Aneglis always comes to mind, he owns the Fat Controller's voice and remained consistent from classic to HIT)
2. Keith Wickham (Best CGI voice without question)
3. George Carlin (A good voice, but I prefer the UK counterparts for voices)
4. Alec Baldwin (Decent voice in general, good tone and all, but there's better voices)
5. Kerry Shale (Ok voice for the CGI series, one of the better voices he's done for the US audience)
6. Ringo Starr (I love Ringo, but while he can deliver angry/stern moments, the voice is too similar to other characters)
7. Michael Brandon (Not deep enough for the character in general, too similar to his narration voice)
8. Rob Rackstraw (It's basically just Mr Bentley from Bob The Builder)
Do you think you can cover Edward's voice actors next? You've already done gordon and Henry, now's your chance to complete all of the "Three Railway Engines" with the one who started it all.
Edward: Oh, yes please!
If I had to chose any British Celebrity to voice Henry, I would definitely go for Gordon Ramsay. Because whenever I hear Ramsay talk more calm and relaxed, it really blends in well with Henry many different facial expressions, especially in the model series.
Thomas Percy James Gordon and Emily’s CGI US dub voices as well as Diesel Mavis Spencer and Cranky’s were good but Edward Henry and Toby’s CGI US voices were so “wtf?” and questionable
Oh yeah. I forgot to ask this when the video came out, but because all of the voices for Thomas, Percy, and James weren’t in their videos, how would you rank them now, including all narrators and temp voices?
I really wish they had Keith Wickham voice Henry in both dubs. No offense to Kerry Shale, but he SUCKS as Henry. Just about as much as William Hope sucks as both Edward and Toby (two other characters who I wish had their UK voices in both dubs).
Bruh I’m having a hard time focusing on what’s happening cause you talk so fast I’m constantly having to check if thing is on 2X
I'm not surprised that Kerry Shale is at the bottom of the list. His voice for Henry is just too high-pitched and wussy for my liking. Alec Baldwin's take was abysmal, too. Due to making him sound like a stuffed-up, weak moron. But Pierce Brosnan making the Number 1 spot really surprised me. I have to admit, his voice fits Henry so well. If he only had more to work with.
I hate Kerry as Henry AND James!
Keith was the best Henry in my opinion
George's voices for Henry is my personal favorite because of how I see in my headcanon. I headcanon Henry being done with life and very cynical view on most things except for nature and a few things but also sympathetic. George's voice has that grandpa hating everything around him type, but also that sympathetic edge to him like you said.
Would you like to do Edward next?
If I’m honest, Willie Rushton’s Henry (one of the people who recorded audiobook versions of Wilbert’s books) is one of my favorite interpretations of his character, along with Ted Robbins’s portrayal in his rendition of Henry and the Express (one of Christopher’s books).
Willie Rushton’s work on The Railway Series in general is some of the best in the whole franchise imo, along with Angelis and Carlin in the TV series. His narration is very much informed by the lore of the books, being the only narrator in the whole franchise who pronounces Rheneas the way Wilbert Awdry intended it to be pronounced (RHEN-e-as, instead of the more widely known rhen-AY-iss).
I at least appreciate Kerry Shale Henry for fitting his nasal tone. I’d put Patrick Breen lower for not fitting the character at all
Most of the footage shown from season 7-8 comes from a dvd promotion for those season from 2006 😂
I grew up with keith and angelis, and those 2 are genuineally my favourite.
Need more
4:12 funny enough I actually have a friend who thought that.
CGI gave the engines separate voice actors the models only have one voice actor
You should rank Edward's voice actors next
since you’ve done engines number one three four five and six it’s only fair you do number two.
Can you do Emily Next?
Robin Smith's Henry sounds like Big Bird
Also wrong Linda for this one, Ballantyne not Cardellini
I love Kerry Shale Henry like in Hero of The Rails.
2:06 If Zach Hadel voiced Henry😂😂
Kerry Shale isn’t a surprise to me. Whilst he wasn’t bad as voicing Gordon in the US Dub, Kerry Shale is NOT my favorite Henry voice. Keith Wickham’s Henry Voice is way better in my opinion.
Maybe you could do Edward or Toby next?
You should make one of Edward
Can you do Edward next
What about Johnny Morris?
Alright mate now do Edward
*OvalFrannkie Wants to Know your Location*
Can you rank Toby’s voices
Can you please do Stanley next?
Love Keith wickam for life
Angelis makes the best henry
I like Kerry Shale Henry
5:46 I’m now trying to picture Velma’s voice with TATMR Percy.
5:47 *Linda Ballantyne.
Linda Cardellini voices Wendy in Gravity Falls.
My bad haha, got voice actors mixed up 😆
@@Thomasfan261 That's okay, it's a pretty easy mistake to make, I've done it before too.