Never seen or imagined this much of an equal battle. I mean they are really both are the same level, both the type of singers that can stand next to ANYONE and shine.
definitely THE BEST vocalists of the 2000s (and from texas). here are my thoughts: low notes - bey mid belts - tie upper belts - kelly head voice - tie
My opinion: C#3 - Beyonce Eb3 - Beyonce E3 - Beyonce F3 - Beyonce F#3 - Beyonce G3 - Tie G#3 - Beyonce A3 - Tie A4 - Tie A4 - Kelly Bb4 - Tie Bb4 - Tie B4 - Tie B4 - Kelly C5 - Beyonce C5 - Tie C#5 - Kelly C#5 - Kelly D5 - Kelly D5 - Beyonce Eb5 - Kelly Eb5 - Beyonce Eb5 - Tie E5 - Kelly E5 - Kelly E5 - Kelly F5 - Kelly F5 - Kelly F5 - Kelly F5 - Beyonce F#5 - Kelly F#5 - Kelly F#5 - Tie F#5 - Kelly G5 - Kelly G5 - Kelly G#5 - Tie G#5 - Kelly A5 - Tie A5 - Beyonce Bb5 - Beyonce B5 - Beyonce C6 - Tie C#6 - Tie D6 - Beyonce Eb6 - Beyonce F6 - Beyonce Overall: Beyonce - 29 Kelly - 31 Pretty close battle. In the low notes, I prefer Beyonce's fuller overall sound. In mid belts, just depends on the listener which tone they prefer. But Eb5 and above, I prefer Kelly's more open and brighter sound, and it's also more controlled. It just sounds SO good! In hv, both are amazing but I prefer Beyonce's hv more. I dunno but for me it sounds more developed(?) Amazing video as always!
Beyonce takes the lows and mid-belts, Kelly takes the upper belts, and the head voice is a tie. Beyonce's lower-to-middle area is extremely powerful, while Kelly's voice blooms more as she ascends...which makes sense, given their respective voice types (mezzo vs. soprano). One thing I will say that makes it difficult to compare is that Beyonce uses a ton of reverb, which makes her voice sound constantly ENORMOUS, whereas Kelly mostly uses a dry mic. If Beyonce used less reverb we could judge her voice's natural power a little better. Overall though, I do think Bey is the slightly superior vocalist...she can pull some pretty insane, hyper-flexible tricks. Kelly is a bit more of a straight-singer.
Im gonna differ a little bit from the rest of the comments: Lows: Beyoncé Mid belts: both (but Kelly’s my personal favorite) Upper Belts: Kelly Head voice: Beyoncé 😬 (sorry but I think her control and support are just a little superior and I like the tone of her head voice better) Overall favorite: Kelly (she’s my favorite voice 😌🤩)
I don't know why you guys like to find any means to discredit Beyoncé. The writer obviously pointed out they're both extremely talented but out of your hunger for attention you decided to comment Kelly isn't into lipsynching. Like tf? Nobody's talking about lipsynch, we just talking about talents here for crissake @@carshe209
@@carshe209Kelly isn’t doing excessive tours all over the world, for hours and hours and hours on end. Pay attention to why the great lipsync. And Beyonce only lipsyncs for specific situations like during rigorous (over the top) dance routines.
@@Them-x4p no offense, but that's borderline insane. Kelly's 3rd octave notes have like half the volume and sound way too light. Making faces while singing with your full voice in the lower or higher extremities is completely normal as well...
@@Them-x4p😂Are you joking? Beyonce has the strongest low notes. Natalie Weiss's lows are even better than Kelly's. And do you even know what support is? Making faces or expression is part of singing technique. That's a common knowledge.
They both just need to collab. Like the song will literally be freaking incredible. Just two goats doing their thing. Kelly needs to be included in more conversations when it comes to vocalists. Cuz she’s insanely talented but so underrated
Though her tone isn’t for me, I definitely agree that she should be included as one of the greatest vocalists. It’s a bit sad but she and Beyonce are among the last true vocalists in Pop music. These other pop girls can’t sing.
Thank you for doing such a respectful video with Kelly vs another artist 🫶🏼 sometimes it can be hard bc some people don’t know other artists’ clips like that
It's kinda funny how these two used to be lumped together with Christina, but they've both completely outpaced and outgrown her in recent years. Kelly and Beyonce are both some of the best vocalists we have right now
Sigh. Christina's voice was so hurly burly and low even when she was in like her early 20s. She was fighting so hard to achieve just normal female chest notes, not even super high belts, and now that she's older she sings mostly in the range of baritone other than when she's in her head voice. Still a great singer with a phenomenal tone and EXTRAORDINARY understanding of dynamics, but her voice type caught up to her eventually.
We can clearly see Kelly is definitely one the best out there, Beyoncé has more agility and a more developed voice, Kelly is able to keep up though. Both are definitely amazing👌🏼 I was thinking, Can you do a Kelly Vs Xtina Video?
It's very crazy how Kelly's lows are from recent times when that place of her voice is more developed and Bey's from years ago are more resonant and supported
I have to give it to Beyonce. Although BOTH of these ladies are the best vocalist from their generation and even currently honestly. I have to give it to Bey for 2 reasons. She really doesn't have a weak register. From the bottom of her range to the very top, everything is damn near flawless. A literal vocal technician. Kelly clearly took upper belts. A true soprano. And they went toe to toe for mid belts. But again, I give Bey the slight edge because she she's a mezzo keeping up easily with a soprano all the up till F5. Crazy.
This is really tough. They’re both so good in very different ways. With the exception of some really low mezzos, it’s hard to find a woman with better lows than Beyoncé. Kelly’s are very nice, but she’s a true high soprano, and it shows here. I’ll give mid belts to Kelly because her chesty mix allows her to retain so much depth tonally. They’re both so good here though. I’ll give upper belts to Kelly too. Beyoncé naturally has the edge in low notes, so Kelly naturally has the edge in higher chest notes. Kelly’s barely making an effort up to G5. She’s just full sending it with great breath support. Beyoncé probably cant get away with that, so she mixes A LOT more. This just means Kelly once again has a richer tone. Kelly has such a nicely supported head voice, but I can only name like 3 people with a head voice as good as Beyoncé’s. Bey’s head voice is so well controlled, so well developed, and so consistent. Beyoncé is seriously one of the few people that can contend with Kelly. I have no idea why people randomly say she’s as bad as Jennifer Lopez. I’m so sorry girl. 😭
Haha I doubt anyone ever said as bad as jlo 😅. But the thing is.. Even when showcasing her perfect notes like in here, her voice does nothing to me. It's like she's missing the x factor that moves you (in my opinion obviously)
I love them both and they are 2 of the greatest singers ever. Let’s also note that most of Beyonces upper clips were old AND from world tours (wear and tear vs rested vocals)
@@doctorits when you’re on tour, voices can get tired vs a lot of Kelly’s clips are from her show which mostly likely means she rested and she can record multiple takes before posting.
@@doctorits I’m not knocking anyone so that I’m clear. Those weren’t the best Bey clips. And again Kelly is rested and singing 1 song vs a 2-3 hr show during 90% of those clips
While Kelly is a Soprano, and Beyonce is a Mezzo-Soprano, I'd say Bey wins, overall. Her voice is just stronger. Even when Kelly begins to sound good in her upper range, she still doesn't have much volume output. She also lacks the stability in her low notes and overall agility that Beyonce has. Beyonce's voice is more distinctive -- but Kelly's voice is more versatile.
Bey sounds stronger than kelly is a big joke, Kelly's voice has cut through an orchestra, while your fave lipped the same day, having a mid sized vocal Kelly has overpowered Ariana, and she even drowned fantasia on their duet. and has withstand singing with singers like Martina McBride, Reba, Trisha yearwood etc. nice try
@@carshe209 Beyonce didnt "Lipped" anything, if you pulled your bias head out of your butt and actually listened, you can actually hear beyonce singing along with the prerecorded version. Hence why she took her ear piece out in order to hear herself. Why would she need to take her ear piece out if she was lip syncing ? Lets use our brains for a min, and show a bit less bias, especially with trying to downplay Beyonce as a vocalists and powerhouse singer.
@@sammy-ly5tq your fave fell of the f*cking stage with her face down and the music still plays, she's known to do pre recording on her performances and lip synching from time to time. It's very common for beyonce, and the same cannot be said to Kelly who sings 100% live all the time, now and then.
Kelly easily on the upper belts. I think one thing is that since Kelly’s voice is higher overall she can full belt and have better resonance that much is very obvious. But the other part is that when she’s feeling up for going up for a G5+ she makes it sound very “easy”. Beyonce either by choice or necessity adds more “drama” to the performance which is part of what makes her beyonce. Kelly doesn’t go for those kinds of theatrics, she literally stands and delivers and I think it feels more understated because of that. I think it’s partially why she gets overlooked because her belts are insanely higher and fuller sounding than pretty much everyone but she just makes it look so easy
I completely understand what you’re saying and it’s okay that you prefer Kelly but you seem to downplay Beyoncé’s talent to “theatrics” and seem to imply that she can’t do what Kelly does. As a singer, reducing what she does to just “theatrics” is unfair and simply attempting to replicate it tells you that it is no mean feat.
My opinion: C#3 - tie Eb3 - Bey E3 - Bey F3 - tie F#3 - tie G3 - Kelly G#3 - Kelly A3 - tie A4 - tie A4 - Kelly Bb4 - Kelly Bb4 - Bey B4 - Bey B4 - Kelly C5 - tie C5 - Bey C#5 - Bey C#5 - Kelly (THE RESONANCE MAN) D5 - Kelly D5 - tie Eb5 - Bey Eb5 - Kelly Eb5 - tie (their money note) E5 - Kelly (so satisfying) E5 - Kelly (resonance for days) E5 - Kelly (interesting lol) F5 - tie F5 - Kelly F5 - Kelly F5 - Kelly F#5 - Kelly F#5 - Kelly F#5 - Kelly F#5 - Kelly (DANG GIRL) G5 - definitely Kelly G5 - Kelly G#5 - Kelly G#5 - Kelly A5 - Kelly A5 - tie Bb5 - Kelly (so operatic 😭😭) B5 - tie C6 - Kelly C#6 - tie D6 - tie Eb6 - Kelly F6 - Bey Bey has 21 points and Kelly has 40 points, Kelly wins!! The best vocalists of the 2000s and definitely one of the best we have today 😍
Lol just the first note, youre already dead wrong. Kelly’s C#3 is nowhere near beyonce’s more grounded and rounded note. Kelly did good as soprano, she had to lower her larynx to hit that low. But Beyonce is a mezzo, its not even a comparison.
As duas cantam muito bem. O que torna Beyoncé um grande fenômeno, é que tudo que ela faz é muito bem feito: cantar, dançar, interpretar, as performances, as músicas conceituais, etc.
My opinions: C#3: Beyonce Eb3: Beyonce E3: Beyonce F3: Tie F#3: Kelly G3: Kelly G#3: Kelly A3: Tie A4: Tie A4: Kelly Bb4: Kelly Bb4: Beyonce B4: Tie B4: Kelly C5: Kelly C5: Beyonce C#5: Kelly C#5: Kelly D5: Kelly D5: Tie (Beyonce had an open vowel, so it was probably a bit easier) Eb5: Kelly Eb5: Beyonce Eb5: Beyonce E5: Kelly E5: Kelly E5: Beyonce F5: Kelly F5: Kelly F5: Kelly (dang) F5: Kelly (this is just ridiculous) F#5: Kelly F#5: Kelly (Beyonce is awesome but there is NO MATCH for Kelly in this clip) F#5: Kelly F#5: KELLY G5: Kelly G5: Kelly G#5: Kelly G#5: Kelly A5: Kelly A5: Tie Bb5: Beyonce B5: Kelly (What the heck) C6: Tie C#6: Kelly D6: Beyonce Eb6: Beyonce F6: Tie Realistically, I think I prefer Kelly's tone, her belts are so resonant and beautiful. Really awesome video!
I love both of their voices. So polished and every performance is amazing. I will say I prefer Beyonce just because to me, she’s the whole package. A true entertainer, dancer, vocal beast. And I prefer her music.
@@doctorits Show me were. Kelly has never had a clean belt, she always has that pushy noise that makes her lose depth and resonance. And don't get me started on her headvoice, it's just very underdeveloped and white.
@@doctoritsThis kind of comment should not have come from the maker of the video. Your fact is untrue. Even Mariah fans would agree that Bey is the queen of F5. Bias much?
first of all, I want to start off by saying thank you for even considering me to collaborate with! these are two of THEE greatest vocalists of ALL time. if we’re talking VOCALISTS, don’t forget to mention these two! there’s no one that has the vocal longevity that Bey & Kelly have…both debuted in the 90’s and still getting better with time! C#3 - Beyoncé! Eb3 - Beyoncé! E3 - Beyoncé! F3 - Beyoncé F#3 - Beyoncé G3 - Beyoncé G#3 - Beyoncé A3 - Beyoncé A4 - Kelly! A4 - Beyoncé! Bb4 - tie! love both of their placements! Bb4 - Beyoncé B4 - Kelly! B4 - Beyoncé…RESONANCE! C5 - Beyoncé! C5 - Beyoncé! C#5 - Kelly…I loved how open it was! C#5 - Kelly…RESONANCE! D5 - i’m leaning more toward Beyoncé for power D5 - Beyoncé…vibrato! Eb5 - BEYONCÉ…RESONANCE WAS INSANE! Eb5 - Beyoncé! Eb5 - Kelly! E5 - tie E5 - KELLY…DAMN!!! E5 - Bey F5 - tie! F5 - BEYONCÉ!!! F5 - BEYONCÉ…RESONANCE! F5 - Kelly…I loved the power! F#5 - KELLY! F#5 - KELLY! HANDS DOWN! F#5 - Kelly! F#5 - KELLY!!! G5 - Kelly! G5 - KELLY!!! THE RESONANCE OMG! G#5 - Beyoncé G#5 - KELLY!!! SUCH A SAVAGE! A5 - KELLY! A5 - Beyoncé…the fullness! Bb5 - Beyoncé! B5 - Beyoncé! C6 - BEYONCÉ! C#6 - Beyoncé…vibrato! D6 - Beyoncé…more ease! Eb6 - tie F6 - Beyoncé Beyoncé - 32 Kelly - 19 I think what pushed Bey ahead in points is how much more developed and well rounded her low notes and head voice is. if this battle was solely belting, Kelly would win. GREAT BATTLE! ❤️❤️
Lows: Bey...... Mid: Bey to F5..... upper belts: Kelly ugh so good!..... Head: Bey! Is sup! But Kelly was excelent too. I don't know why they say you would have posted better videos of Kelly, if the ones you posted are excellent!.
@@Artemis-cd2pf low, mid, hv, and agility goes to Beyoncé. Kelly has the upper on lock. Kelly doesn’t have the fullness like a true mezzo would in low and mid, that’s the only reason. If it had been another soprano, Kelly would’ve won.
There are a lot of people in the thread remarking on register. Register is nothing without agility and I believe Beyonce's singing in a lower register is a style choice. She started going for a more full-bodied sound starting in her 4 era and I think it gave her a more robust huskier tone that commands more presence and allows one to be more agile. Also, it's important to note that lower registers work better for touring which Beyonce does more of. However, whenever this practice of comparing artists comes up I always judge an artists on their AGILITY along with the range. There are performances that Beyonce has done vocally that Kelly simply could not do agility wise; runs, variance in volume, vibrato, traversing between voices, etc. This along with doing it many times while dancing, and her cultural significance is what makes her the master of this current pop generation. I'll note some specific performances of Beyonce's which Kelly could not do. 5. OTR II Resentment 4. MTV Lemonade Medley 3. Live at City of Hope Gala 2. Stevie Wonder Tribute Medley 1. Beautiful Ones - Glastonbury I like Kelly but she is not in the same stratosphere as Beyonce in vocal technique. Range yes. But technique. NO!
@@doctorits I know it well. It's good. But it's not at Beyonce's level. I stand by the performances of Beyonce I pointed out. Kelly couldn't replicate those performances vocally. It's nothing against her. I think she is a fantastic performer but it is what it is.
@@doctorits Kelly can't replicate Beyonce's vocal dynamics such a run and riffs at the same time with shift in volume. In the performances I mentioned Beyonce utilizes vocal techniques that I've never seen Kelly do. You keep mentioning notes that they can hit. Notes are just one part of vocality.
@@paulthebohemian i think kelly range ends in like A2 or Bb2. i mentioned range because there’s nothing she can’t do on these performances. if you’ve never seen kelly doing these techniques you definitely don’t know much about her voice
OMGGGGGG Anyways, this is my opinion: Lows - C#3: Beyoncé Eb3: Beyoncé 100% without a doubt E3: Beyoncé F3: Tie F#3: Beyoncé G3: Tie G#3: Kelly A3: Tie Belts - A4: Kelly A4: Beyoncé Bb4: Tie Bb4: Beyoncé B4: Beyoncé B4: Beyoncé C5: Beyoncé C5: Kelly C#5: Kelly C#5: Kelly D5: Kelly D5: Kelly Eb5: Kelly Eb5: Beyoncé Eb5: Tie E5: Tie E5: Kelly (Beyoncé's sounded a little bit strained) E5: Kelly F5: Tie F5: Kelly ATE F5: Kelly F5: Beyoncé Everything F#5 and above: EASILY Kelly (9 points) Head voice - A5: Beyoncé Bb5: Beyoncé B5: Kelly C6: Beyoncé C#6: Beyoncé D6: Kelly Eb6: Kelly!! F6: Tie Lows - Bey > Kelly Belts - Kelly > Bey Head voice - Bey > Kelly Beyoncé has 23 points and Kelly has 24 points so it's REALLY close. Honestly, if it weren't for Beyoncé's vocal agility, they would be pretty even vocally but Beyoncé has a slight edge because of her vocal agility, which is also why her vibrato is so quick and fluttery and SO ADDICTING 😍😍😍
Briga boa! Beyoncé é uma excelente cantora! Que notas graves! Porém, na totalidade na minha opinião e gosto musical é Kelly! A voz da Kelly e a forma com que ela canta é muito impressionante! Eu gosto demais, demais, demais.......! 😍🥰🎼🎵🎶
both tied imo for best vocalists of their generation. Kelly can outbelt anyone and Beyonce's lower notes and runs are unmatched. They both sing in such different ways they really fill different roles.
Kelly makes it look so damn easy, while Beyoncé looks like she’s fighting for her life a lot of the times 😭 Kelly’s F#5s are out of this world! So glad you included that new F#5 :P
C#3 - Beyoncé Eb3 - Beyoncé E3 - Beyoncé F3 - Beyoncé F#3 - Beyoncé G3 - Beyoncé G#3 - Beyoncé A3 - Beyoncé A4 - Beyoncé A4 - tie Bb4 - tie Bb4 - Beyoncé B4 - Beyoncé B4 - tie C5 - Beyoncé C5 - tie C#5 - Kelly C#5 - Kelly D5 - Kelly D5 - tie Eb5 - Kelly Eb5 - Kelly Eb5 - tie E5 - tie E5 - Kelly E5 - Kelly F5 - Kelly F5 - Kelly F5 - Kelly F5 - Kelly F#5 - Kelly F#5!- Kelly F#5 - tie F#5 - Kelly G5 - Kelly G5 - Kelly G#5 - Kelly G#5 - Kelly A5 - Kelly A5 - tie Bb5 - Beyoncé B5 - tie C6 - tie C#6 - Beyoncé D6 - Beyoncé Eb6 - Beyoncé F6 - Beyoncé
The selections for could have been better, especially when she has so many professional recorded tours(i am vegas concert, i am world tour, Mrs carter world tour and The formation world) and live performances to select from. Beyonce is my pick, she had the fuller voice , with a fully connected range from top to bottom.
it’s just reverb lol. it’s something that she’s played around with since Destiny’s Child whenever she sustains notes..but that’s why I also included clips of her hitting the same note WITHOUT reverb so no one can say she relies on it. it’s just a stylistic choice and for extra dramatics.
Kelly is a great belter and has such an amazing voice to truly keep up with and at times surpass Beyonce. I thought Beyonce was the queen of vibrato(she is) but Kelly has a great one as well.
@@rydercdaniels4475 I didn’t say anything about her personality. I said that I, personally, don’t gravitate towards her voice or her music. Someone can technically “sing” but you may or may not connect with or feel anything about it when they do. Personal preference does weigh in here, as well as what/how their singing makes you feel. Singing is about more than just perfectly hitting the notes. It’s also supposed to connect with people. I prefer Kelly any day of the week, but I’m not saying anything bad about Bey. They can both technically sing very well. That’s why some of this does come down to personal preference, if they can both blow! And yes, part of what people do or don’t gravitate towards, with a singer, is their tone.
Lows: Bey - Kelly was all air and no substance down there. Beyoncé's mezzo nature makes her voice more robust here Mid Belt: Tie: They both took certain notes Upper belt: Kelly - Here Kelly's soprano nature started to shine from F5 up. Far more ease and ability to sustain Head voice: Beyoncé dominated here. More agility and development here and arguably a more textured and interesting tone in this area than Kelly.
@@Artemis-cd2pf I think Kelly did and has always been phenomenal! And I also think she’d agree with me that Beyoncé beat her in these areas. However these days, I think she has a lot more accessibility to her belts Eb5 and above than Beyoncé and I’ll give her that, but in the video we saw a mostly younger Beyoncé that still had lots of ease up there. The belts lower than that are close to a tie, but I give them to Beyoncé because she’s a mezzo and they’re more beefy in her voice.
C#3 Beyoncé Eb3 Beyoncé E3 Beyoncé F3 Beyoncé F#3 Beyonce G3 Beyoncé G#3 Beyoncé A3 Beyonce A4 Kelly A4 Beyonce Bb4 Beyonce Bb4 Beyonce B4 Tie B4 Beyonce C5 Beyonce (Preference) Kelly did great too C5 Kelly C#5 Kelly C#5 Kelly D5 Tie D5 Beyoncé Eb5 Beyoncé Eb5 Beyonce Eb5 Tie E5 Beyonce E5 Beyonce E5 Beyonce F5 Beyonce F5 Beyonce F5 Kelly F5 Kelly F#5 Kelly F#5 Tie F#5 Tie F#5 Kelly G5 Kelly G5 Kelly G#5 Kelly G#5 Kelly A5 Kelly A5 Beyoncé Bb5 Beyoncé B5 Kelly C6 Beyonce C#6 Beyonce D6 Beyonce Eb6 Beyonce F6 Beyonce
Why didnt u use kelly's low note when she sing home by marc bloussard on tkc show? One of my fav performance by her, and then at the end boom, badass strong, growling kelly😍
Beyoncé is overall better to me based on fullness of her lows and I love her mid belts, agility, and versatility of her voice (I also prefer her tone and vibrato) but these two are the BEST vocalists out. I kills me that Kelly is hardly ever in the convos that I see when she’s literally better than everyone else they talk about. They try to play like Beyoncé isn’t one of the greatest but they can’t back that up. I would love a Collab from them
C#3: Bey Eb3: Bey E3: Bey F3: Bey F#3: Tie G3: Kelly G#3: Bey A3: Bey, not low for them both A4: Tie A4: Bey Bb4: Bey Bb4: Bey B4: Bey B4: Kelly C5: Bey C5: Bey C#5: Tie C#5: Tie D5: Bey D5: Tie (leaning to Bey) Eb5: Bey Eb5: Kelly Eb5: Tie E5: Kelly E5: Tie E5: Beyonce s was Eb5, so none F5: Tie F5: Kelly F5: Bey F5: Tie F#5: Tie F#5: Kelly F#5: Kelly F#5: Beyonce 's was F5, Kelly was amazing, but mislabeled, so none G5: Kelly G5: Kelly G#5: Kelly G#5: Tie A5: idk, Kelly because bey wasnt clean A5: Bey Bb5: Bey B5: Bey C6: Beyonce is just fuller and head voice, not falsetto C#6: Tie D6: Beyonce Eb6: Kelly F6: Bey I think it was all biased towards Beyonce, because some clips of Kelly werent nearly as good as Beyonce
hi, this is not a bias toward Bey considering this channel is a Kelly Clarkson vocal channel and they didn’t choose the Beyoncé clips, I did…so obviously they was choosing the best Kelly clips and i was choosing the best Beyoncé clips. both have amazing clips and both are INCREDIBLE vocalists but I think some of you guys underestimate Bey as a vocalist and was expecting her to get washed, but she’s literally just THAT good! thanks for watching tho ❤️
@@mykeyonce I know she s great, the clips were one of the best possible, i felt like these weren't for Kelly, but if they were, then.... Beyonce wins easily
@@eyesnightmareAnd many of the clips were of Beyonce touring so her voice wasn’t operating at full potential while Kelly’s were far more rested and recorded for her show where she’d have also had more than one take. So yes, Beyonce is incredible.
I don’t know if it’s just me but i loved some of Beyonce’s higher belts than kelly’s especially Eb5-F#5. It’s not as sustained as Kelly’s but her vibrato + the high note just gets me every single time. For low notes = Beyonce; mid belts = Beyonce; high = Kelly; headtone = both are great but Beyonce for me. Her headtone sounds sooooo crisp and soulful
Beyonce is the best, nobody can ever top her. She has that special magic in her voice. Kelly is also amazing and has such incredible technique and talent but for the sake of comparison I prefer Beyonce's voice every time but it all comes down to preference they are the masters of their voice!
In My Opinion: C#3 - Bey Eb3 - Bey E3 - Bey F3 - Bey F#3 - Bey G3 - Kelly G#3 - Tie A3 - Bey A4 - Tie Bb4 - Bey B4 - Kelly C5 - Bey C#5 - Tie D5 - Bey Eb5 - Bey E5 - Kelly F5 - Bey F#5 - Kelly G5 - Kelly G#5 - Bey A5 - Kelly A5 - Bey Bb5 - Bey B5 - Kelly C6 - Bey C#6 - Kelly D6 - Bey Eb6 - Bey F6 - Bey
Never seen or imagined this much of an equal battle. I mean they are really both are the same level, both the type of singers that can stand next to ANYONE and shine.
definitely THE BEST vocalists of the 2000s (and from texas). here are my thoughts:
low notes - bey
mid belts - tie
upper belts - kelly
head voice - tie
queenss
True
hesd voice is undeniably bey
their operatic technique 😍😍
yeah 😍
Neither of them have operatic technique 😭, still excellent vocalists though
@@debutriah2854Beyoncé does
@@jK-mb7imbey is a Mezzo with coloratura qualities, but she doesn't have the legitimate Operatic technique.
@@carshe209 She literally has opera/classical training
My opinion:
C#3 - Beyonce
Eb3 - Beyonce
E3 - Beyonce
F3 - Beyonce
F#3 - Beyonce
G3 - Tie
G#3 - Beyonce
A3 - Tie
A4 - Tie
A4 - Kelly
Bb4 - Tie
Bb4 - Tie
B4 - Tie
B4 - Kelly
C5 - Beyonce
C5 - Tie
C#5 - Kelly
C#5 - Kelly
D5 - Kelly
D5 - Beyonce
Eb5 - Kelly
Eb5 - Beyonce
Eb5 - Tie
E5 - Kelly
E5 - Kelly
E5 - Kelly
F5 - Kelly
F5 - Kelly
F5 - Kelly
F5 - Beyonce
F#5 - Kelly
F#5 - Kelly
F#5 - Tie
F#5 - Kelly
G5 - Kelly
G5 - Kelly
G#5 - Tie
G#5 - Kelly
A5 - Tie
A5 - Beyonce
Bb5 - Beyonce
B5 - Beyonce
C6 - Tie
C#6 - Tie
D6 - Beyonce
Eb6 - Beyonce
F6 - Beyonce
Overall:
Beyonce - 29
Kelly - 31
Pretty close battle. In the low notes, I prefer Beyonce's fuller overall sound. In mid belts, just depends on the listener which tone they prefer. But Eb5 and above, I prefer Kelly's more open and brighter sound, and it's also more controlled. It just sounds SO good! In hv, both are amazing but I prefer Beyonce's hv more. I dunno but for me it sounds more developed(?) Amazing video as always!
thank you torish 🥰🥰
Kelly holds the upper belts.. beyonce touches the note then leaves it alone.
I prefer Kelly’s HV, but to each their own 😊
@@krisl1283exactly 💯👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽
💙🪬🔺♾🧿
Beyoncé’s lows are unmatched. Even Mariah, who has a lower range, doesn’t have the the power that Beyoncé carries down to the bottom of her range.
@@RonnieStewartJr yess, i love mariah’s lower register but bey’s is fuller
@@doctoritsmariah can hit the high (whistle) & low because of her nodules. Mariah’s soprano’s low cant compare to an actual mezzo.
@@yureino Mariah is not a soprano, she has said herself that she is an alto, but writes in the key of a soprano
Both are great. I personally can listen to Kelly longer though without getting tired.
@@ZuhaLoveMusic they are insane
oohf kelly got those top belts that sound like they’re also an octave above at the same time. mad good
THE RESONANCE IS INSANE
I could listen to their C5s all day
Beyonce takes the lows and mid-belts, Kelly takes the upper belts, and the head voice is a tie. Beyonce's lower-to-middle area is extremely powerful, while Kelly's voice blooms more as she ascends...which makes sense, given their respective voice types (mezzo vs. soprano).
One thing I will say that makes it difficult to compare is that Beyonce uses a ton of reverb, which makes her voice sound constantly ENORMOUS, whereas Kelly mostly uses a dry mic. If Beyonce used less reverb we could judge her voice's natural power a little better. Overall though, I do think Bey is the slightly superior vocalist...she can pull some pretty insane, hyper-flexible tricks. Kelly is a bit more of a straight-singer.
Im gonna differ a little bit from the rest of the comments:
Lows: Beyoncé
Mid belts: both (but Kelly’s my personal favorite)
Upper Belts: Kelly
Head voice: Beyoncé 😬 (sorry but I think her control and support are just a little superior and I like the tone of her head voice better)
Overall favorite: Kelly (she’s my favorite voice 😌🤩)
Beyoncé level!! Imagine a collab!😍
@@ClarksonLive my dream 😍😍
Yes! Great vocal battle between iconic 2000s vocalists. It just shows how both of them have preserved their voices so well over time.
YES, thank you 🥰🥰
oh my gosh one of the best vocal battles ive seen, I personally think Bey won but Kelly is insane too ❤
Two incredible vocalists! They complement each other well too in a lighter timbre for Bey and a darker timbre for Kelly.
@@Kellyfan88 definitely!!! 😍
What a great and fair comparison some people use extremely bad notes for Beyonce this was such a great showcase of both ladies vocals.
@@Mo_B-xv2hv yess, thank you 🥰
So both are extremely talented singers. We know. They should collab. That would be epic.
YES
Kelly is not into lip synching
I don't know why you guys like to find any means to discredit Beyoncé. The writer obviously pointed out they're both extremely talented but out of your hunger for attention you decided to comment Kelly isn't into lipsynching. Like tf? Nobody's talking about lipsynch, we just talking about talents here for crissake
@@carshe209
@@carshe209Kelly isn’t doing excessive tours all over the world, for hours and hours and hours on end. Pay attention to why the great lipsync. And Beyonce only lipsyncs for specific situations like during rigorous (over the top) dance routines.
Both super talented. But Kelly owns my heart. ❤❤❤
@@ramonpadilha9987 yess 😍
They would sound so good together!!!! Let's get them to collaborate!
@@afrostar8 yess
Beyonce may not be open to it, since they are from different genres.
@@yebostephen6307 both sing a lot of genres hahah
Loooooveeeee kelllyyyyyy❤❤❤
samee
Lows: Bey
Mid Belt: Tie
Upper Belt: Kelly
Head Voice: Tie
Agility: Bey
yess
I think Kelly takes the lower notes. She effortlessly phased down there without even making a face.
@@Them-x4pno… Kelly sweeps the belts
@@Them-x4p no offense, but that's borderline insane. Kelly's 3rd octave notes have like half the volume and sound way too light. Making faces while singing with your full voice in the lower or higher extremities is completely normal as well...
@@Them-x4p😂Are you joking? Beyonce has the strongest low notes. Natalie Weiss's lows are even better than Kelly's. And do you even know what support is?
Making faces or expression is part of singing technique. That's a common knowledge.
They both just need to collab. Like the song will literally be freaking incredible. Just two goats doing their thing. Kelly needs to be included in more conversations when it comes to vocalists. Cuz she’s insanely talented but so underrated
@@brianrod1 YES
Though her tone isn’t for me, I definitely agree that she should be included as one of the greatest vocalists. It’s a bit sad but she and Beyonce are among the last true vocalists in Pop music. These other pop girls can’t sing.
She has always been included.
Beyonce is the one who needs to be included more.
@@squarcircle2254 there are NO true vocalists. You are either a vocalist or you are not.
@@yebostephen6307 but beyoncé is always included lol it’s literally the opposite
Thank you for doing such a respectful video with Kelly vs another artist 🫶🏼 sometimes it can be hard bc some people don’t know other artists’ clips like that
@@rhettmitchell oh yess 😍 you’re welcome
Beyoncé is just the GOAT 😭 Kelly is great too, both Texas queens.
Both technically brilliant
@@aaronmiddleton5842 yes they are 😍😍
I would actually love to hear a duet with these 2! Manifesting it now FR
@@Spiritualemperor28 samee
It's kinda funny how these two used to be lumped together with Christina, but they've both completely outpaced and outgrown her in recent years. Kelly and Beyonce are both some of the best vocalists we have right now
YES
Sigh. Christina's voice was so hurly burly and low even when she was in like her early 20s. She was fighting so hard to achieve just normal female chest notes, not even super high belts, and now that she's older she sings mostly in the range of baritone other than when she's in her head voice. Still a great singer with a phenomenal tone and EXTRAORDINARY understanding of dynamics, but her voice type caught up to her eventually.
@@vsings1091 Yeah, her natural talent is undeniable; I think she has more raw talent than either Kelly or Bey.
We can clearly see Kelly is definitely one the best out there, Beyoncé has more agility and a more developed voice, Kelly is able to keep up though. Both are definitely amazing👌🏼
I was thinking, Can you do a Kelly Vs Xtina Video?
@@englishwitheduart12 probably the next vocal battle
Kelly will win against Christina nowadays.
@@yebostephen6307 i’m sorry but since her debut she ends her lol
ATEEEEE
thank youuu 💗💗
Beyoncé techniques and dynamic are insane
I love Kelly's tone.
Beyonce D5 @ 5:22 and Kelly B5 @ 10:10 are truly some of my favorite notes EVER witnessed.
@@ItsMellowB yess
Neither are resonant
It's very crazy how Kelly's lows are from recent times when that place of her voice is more developed and Bey's from years ago are more resonant and supported
I have to give it to Beyonce. Although BOTH of these ladies are the best vocalist from their generation and even currently honestly. I have to give it to Bey for 2 reasons. She really doesn't have a weak register. From the bottom of her range to the very top, everything is damn near flawless. A literal vocal technician. Kelly clearly took upper belts. A true soprano. And they went toe to toe for mid belts. But again, I give Bey the slight edge because she she's a mezzo keeping up easily with a soprano all the up till F5. Crazy.
This is really tough. They’re both so good in very different ways.
With the exception of some really low mezzos, it’s hard to find a woman with better lows than Beyoncé. Kelly’s are very nice, but she’s a true high soprano, and it shows here.
I’ll give mid belts to Kelly because her chesty mix allows her to retain so much depth tonally. They’re both so good here though.
I’ll give upper belts to Kelly too. Beyoncé naturally has the edge in low notes, so Kelly naturally has the edge in higher chest notes. Kelly’s barely making an effort up to G5. She’s just full sending it with great breath support. Beyoncé probably cant get away with that, so she mixes A LOT more. This just means Kelly once again has a richer tone.
Kelly has such a nicely supported head voice, but I can only name like 3 people with a head voice as good as Beyoncé’s. Bey’s head voice is so well controlled, so well developed, and so consistent.
Beyoncé is seriously one of the few people that can contend with Kelly. I have no idea why people randomly say she’s as bad as Jennifer Lopez. I’m so sorry girl. 😭
There are many singers with lower registers & head voices just as good & better than Beyoncé’s lol
@@Reikyellah Maybe just as good but I don't know about better 🌚
@@connor8099 there absolutely are
oh definitely 😍😍 THE JLO COMMENT LMAO I CANT
Haha I doubt anyone ever said as bad as jlo 😅. But the thing is.. Even when showcasing her perfect notes like in here, her voice does nothing to me. It's like she's missing the x factor that moves you (in my opinion obviously)
I love them both and they are 2 of the greatest singers ever. Let’s also note that most of Beyonces upper clips were old AND from world tours (wear and tear vs rested vocals)
what do u mean in the last sentence 😭😭
@@doctorits when you’re on tour, voices can get tired vs a lot of Kelly’s clips are from her show which mostly likely means she rested and she can record multiple takes before posting.
@@UsherFan05 yeah she does all in one take and bey’s clips were chosen by a bey fan
@@doctorits I’m not knocking anyone so that I’m clear. Those weren’t the best Bey clips. And again Kelly is rested and singing 1 song vs a 2-3 hr show during 90% of those clips
@@UsherFan05 the voice gets warmer during a concert
While Kelly is a Soprano, and Beyonce is a Mezzo-Soprano, I'd say Bey wins, overall. Her voice is just stronger. Even when Kelly begins to sound good in her upper range, she still doesn't have much volume output. She also lacks the stability in her low notes and overall agility that Beyonce has. Beyonce's voice is more distinctive -- but Kelly's voice is more versatile.
@@chocolateangel8743 just saw your old comments on my channel… trash
Bey sounds stronger than kelly is a big joke, Kelly's voice has cut through an orchestra, while your fave lipped the same day, having a mid sized vocal Kelly has overpowered Ariana, and she even drowned fantasia on their duet. and has withstand singing with singers like Martina McBride, Reba, Trisha yearwood etc. nice try
@@carshe209 this chocolate os just a hater
@@carshe209 Beyonce didnt "Lipped" anything, if you pulled your bias head out of your butt and actually listened, you can actually hear beyonce singing along with the prerecorded version. Hence why she took her ear piece out in order to hear herself. Why would she need to take her ear piece out if she was lip syncing ? Lets use our brains for a min, and show a bit less bias, especially with trying to downplay Beyonce as a vocalists and powerhouse singer.
@@sammy-ly5tq your fave fell of the f*cking stage with her face down and the music still plays, she's known to do pre recording on her performances and lip synching from time to time. It's very common for beyonce, and the same cannot be said to Kelly who sings 100% live all the time, now and then.
Kelly easily on the upper belts. I think one thing is that since Kelly’s voice is higher overall she can full belt and have better resonance that much is very obvious. But the other part is that when she’s feeling up for going up for a G5+ she makes it sound very “easy”. Beyonce either by choice or necessity adds more “drama” to the performance which is part of what makes her beyonce. Kelly doesn’t go for those kinds of theatrics, she literally stands and delivers and I think it feels more understated because of that. I think it’s partially why she gets overlooked because her belts are insanely higher and fuller sounding than pretty much everyone but she just makes it look so easy
@@erictsang7047 yess
I completely understand what you’re saying and it’s okay that you prefer Kelly but you seem to downplay Beyoncé’s talent to “theatrics” and seem to imply that she can’t do what Kelly does. As a singer, reducing what she does to just “theatrics” is unfair and simply attempting to replicate it tells you that it is no mean feat.
@@jamiedisu727Clock it. They tried it lol.
@@DROIDX40its their opinion chill kiddo
@@quefloyd4294 Eat it. And thats my statement chill kiddo. I didn't even type anything bad. I could've went in but I didn't.
My opinion:
C#3 - tie
Eb3 - Bey
E3 - Bey
F3 - tie
F#3 - tie
G3 - Kelly
G#3 - Kelly
A3 - tie
A4 - tie
A4 - Kelly
Bb4 - Kelly
Bb4 - Bey
B4 - Bey
B4 - Kelly
C5 - tie
C5 - Bey
C#5 - Bey
C#5 - Kelly (THE RESONANCE MAN)
D5 - Kelly
D5 - tie
Eb5 - Bey
Eb5 - Kelly
Eb5 - tie (their money note)
E5 - Kelly (so satisfying)
E5 - Kelly (resonance for days)
E5 - Kelly (interesting lol)
F5 - tie
F5 - Kelly
F5 - Kelly
F5 - Kelly
F#5 - Kelly
F#5 - Kelly
F#5 - Kelly
F#5 - Kelly (DANG GIRL)
G5 - definitely Kelly
G5 - Kelly
G#5 - Kelly
G#5 - Kelly
A5 - Kelly
A5 - tie
Bb5 - Kelly (so operatic 😭😭)
B5 - tie
C6 - Kelly
C#6 - tie
D6 - tie
Eb6 - Kelly
F6 - Bey
Bey has 21 points and Kelly has 40 points, Kelly wins!! The best vocalists of the 2000s and definitely one of the best we have today 😍
nice 😍
Lol
Lol just the first note, youre already dead wrong. Kelly’s C#3 is nowhere near beyonce’s more grounded and rounded note. Kelly did good as soprano, she had to lower her larynx to hit that low. But Beyonce is a mezzo, its not even a comparison.
@@yureino you literally explained the fact why i tied the C#3
this is soooo biased lmfaoooo from just the C#3 alone 😭🤦🏾♂️
As duas cantam muito bem. O que torna Beyoncé um grande fenômeno, é que tudo que ela faz é muito bem feito: cantar, dançar, interpretar, as performances, as músicas conceituais, etc.
@@vitormorttara simm
Both elite! I love Kelly's Blaze of Glory note at 8:10. Talk about healthy belting!
My opinions:
C#3: Beyonce
Eb3: Beyonce
E3: Beyonce
F3: Tie
F#3: Kelly
G3: Kelly
G#3: Kelly
A3: Tie
A4: Tie
A4: Kelly
Bb4: Kelly
Bb4: Beyonce
B4: Tie
B4: Kelly
C5: Kelly
C5: Beyonce
C#5: Kelly
C#5: Kelly
D5: Kelly
D5: Tie (Beyonce had an open vowel, so it was probably a bit easier)
Eb5: Kelly
Eb5: Beyonce
Eb5: Beyonce
E5: Kelly
E5: Kelly
E5: Beyonce
F5: Kelly
F5: Kelly
F5: Kelly (dang)
F5: Kelly (this is just ridiculous)
F#5: Kelly
F#5: Kelly (Beyonce is awesome but there is NO MATCH for Kelly in this clip)
F#5: Kelly
F#5: KELLY
G5: Kelly
G5: Kelly
G#5: Kelly
G#5: Kelly
A5: Kelly
A5: Tie
Bb5: Beyonce
B5: Kelly (What the heck)
C6: Tie
C#6: Kelly
D6: Beyonce
Eb6: Beyonce
F6: Tie
Realistically, I think I prefer Kelly's tone, her belts are so resonant and beautiful. Really awesome video!
thank you thomas 🥰🥰
I definitely prefer Beyonce ❤❤❤
I love both of their voices. So polished and every performance is amazing. I will say I prefer Beyonce just because to me, she’s the whole package. A true entertainer, dancer, vocal beast. And I prefer her music.
@@ambycarr1695 queens
Wow, both are amazing. Never realise how close they're both are vocally. You can tell they've been trained by professionals.
@@Sttephy30 definitely 😍😍
I don't think theybare close, at all. Kelly strains most of her belts.
@@Ignasimp bro i think u changed the name lol the only one straining above Eb5 here is bey
@@doctorits Show me were. Kelly has never had a clean belt, she always has that pushy noise that makes her lose depth and resonance. And don't get me started on her headvoice, it's just very underdeveloped and white.
@@doctoritsThis kind of comment should not have come from the maker of the video. Your fact is untrue.
Even Mariah fans would agree that Bey is the queen of F5.
Bias much?
first of all, I want to start off by saying thank you for even considering me to collaborate with! these are two of THEE greatest vocalists of ALL time. if we’re talking VOCALISTS, don’t forget to mention these two! there’s no one that has the vocal longevity that Bey & Kelly have…both debuted in the 90’s and still getting better with time!
C#3 - Beyoncé!
Eb3 - Beyoncé!
E3 - Beyoncé!
F3 - Beyoncé
F#3 - Beyoncé
G3 - Beyoncé
G#3 - Beyoncé
A3 - Beyoncé
A4 - Kelly!
A4 - Beyoncé!
Bb4 - tie! love both of their placements!
Bb4 - Beyoncé
B4 - Kelly!
B4 - Beyoncé…RESONANCE!
C5 - Beyoncé!
C5 - Beyoncé!
C#5 - Kelly…I loved how open it was!
C#5 - Kelly…RESONANCE!
D5 - i’m leaning more toward Beyoncé for power
D5 - Beyoncé…vibrato!
Eb5 - BEYONCÉ…RESONANCE WAS INSANE!
Eb5 - Beyoncé!
Eb5 - Kelly!
E5 - tie
E5 - KELLY…DAMN!!!
E5 - Bey
F5 - tie!
F5 - BEYONCÉ!!!
F5 - BEYONCÉ…RESONANCE!
F5 - Kelly…I loved the power!
F#5 - KELLY!
F#5 - KELLY! HANDS DOWN!
F#5 - Kelly!
F#5 - KELLY!!!
G5 - Kelly!
G5 - KELLY!!! THE RESONANCE OMG!
G#5 - Beyoncé
G#5 - KELLY!!! SUCH A SAVAGE!
A5 - KELLY!
A5 - Beyoncé…the fullness!
Bb5 - Beyoncé!
B5 - Beyoncé!
C6 - BEYONCÉ!
C#6 - Beyoncé…vibrato!
D6 - Beyoncé…more ease!
Eb6 - tie
F6 - Beyoncé
Beyoncé - 32
Kelly - 19
I think what pushed Bey ahead in points is how much more developed and well rounded her low notes and head voice is. if this battle was solely belting, Kelly would win. GREAT BATTLE! ❤️❤️
you’re welcome, hope to work with you again soon 🥰
@@doctorits”Beyoncé & Kelly Clarkson vs The World” COMING SOON 😂😍
@@mykeyonce hahah yeahh, nice idea!!
Lows: Bey...... Mid: Bey to F5..... upper belts: Kelly ugh so good!..... Head: Bey! Is sup! But Kelly was excelent too.
I don't know why they say you would have posted better videos of Kelly, if the ones you posted are excellent!.
i think they mean it because i used some underrated clips for her upper register, thank you 🥰
They tied for mid, upper and head voice Kelly did better
@@Artemis-cd2pf low, mid, hv, and agility goes to Beyoncé. Kelly has the upper on lock. Kelly doesn’t have the fullness like a true mezzo would in low and mid, that’s the only reason. If it had been another soprano, Kelly would’ve won.
now, do the 2000s trinity: bey vs kelly vs xtina
the next one is probably Kelly Vs. Xtina
Truly no one compares to bey but Kelly is so good
There are a lot of people in the thread remarking on register. Register is nothing without agility and I believe Beyonce's singing in a lower register is a style choice. She started going for a more full-bodied sound starting in her 4 era and I think it gave her a more robust huskier tone that commands more presence and allows one to be more agile. Also, it's important to note that lower registers work better for touring which Beyonce does more of. However, whenever this practice of comparing artists comes up I always judge an artists on their AGILITY along with the range. There are performances that Beyonce has done vocally that Kelly simply could not do agility wise; runs, variance in volume, vibrato, traversing between voices, etc. This along with doing it many times while dancing, and her cultural significance is what makes her the master of this current pop generation. I'll note some specific performances of Beyonce's which Kelly could not do.
5. OTR II Resentment
4. MTV Lemonade Medley
3. Live at City of Hope Gala
2. Stevie Wonder Tribute Medley
1. Beautiful Ones - Glastonbury
I like Kelly but she is not in the same stratosphere as Beyonce in vocal technique. Range yes. But technique. NO!
you don’t know kelly’s voice… her agility is GREAT
@@doctorits I know it well. It's good. But it's not at Beyonce's level. I stand by the performances of Beyonce I pointed out. Kelly couldn't replicate those performances vocally. It's nothing against her. I think she is a fantastic performer but it is what it is.
@@paulthebohemian she definitely could. one thing she couldn’t do is like hit a G#2 like beyoncé but despite that, there’s nothing she can’t do
@@doctorits Kelly can't replicate Beyonce's vocal dynamics such a run and riffs at the same time with shift in volume. In the performances I mentioned Beyonce utilizes vocal techniques that I've never seen Kelly do. You keep mentioning notes that they can hit. Notes are just one part of vocality.
@@paulthebohemian i think kelly range ends in like A2 or Bb2. i mentioned range because there’s nothing she can’t do on these performances. if you’ve never seen kelly doing these techniques you definitely don’t know much about her voice
OMGGGGGG
Anyways, this is my opinion:
Lows -
C#3: Beyoncé
Eb3: Beyoncé 100% without a doubt
E3: Beyoncé
F3: Tie
F#3: Beyoncé
G3: Tie
G#3: Kelly
A3: Tie
Belts -
A4: Kelly
A4: Beyoncé
Bb4: Tie
Bb4: Beyoncé
B4: Beyoncé
B4: Beyoncé
C5: Beyoncé
C5: Kelly
C#5: Kelly
C#5: Kelly
D5: Kelly
D5: Kelly
Eb5: Kelly
Eb5: Beyoncé
Eb5: Tie
E5: Tie
E5: Kelly (Beyoncé's sounded a little bit strained)
E5: Kelly
F5: Tie
F5: Kelly ATE
F5: Kelly
F5: Beyoncé
Everything F#5 and above: EASILY Kelly (9 points)
Head voice -
A5: Beyoncé
Bb5: Beyoncé
B5: Kelly
C6: Beyoncé
C#6: Beyoncé
D6: Kelly
Eb6: Kelly!!
F6: Tie
Lows - Bey > Kelly
Belts - Kelly > Bey
Head voice - Bey > Kelly
Beyoncé has 23 points and Kelly has 24 points so it's REALLY close. Honestly, if it weren't for Beyoncé's vocal agility, they would be pretty even vocally but Beyoncé has a slight edge because of her vocal agility, which is also why her vibrato is so quick and fluttery and SO ADDICTING 😍😍😍
yess 😍😍 texas queens
@@doctorits Real 💕💕💕
This is what it's all about! So glad you understand it too.
0:47 This performance has some of her best low notes ever
definitely
Briga boa! Beyoncé é uma excelente cantora! Que notas graves! Porém, na totalidade na minha opinião e gosto musical é Kelly! A voz da Kelly e a forma com que ela canta é muito impressionante! Eu gosto demais, demais, demais.......! 😍🥰🎼🎵🎶
@@adrianadonascimento1833 simm adri 😍😍
*Lows*
C#3-F#3: Beyonce
G3: Tie
G#3: Beyonce
A3: Tie
*Belts*
A4-B4: Tie
C5: Beyonce
C#5/D5: Tie
Eb5-F5: Beyonce
F#5-A5: Kelly
*Head Voice*
A5-C6: Beyonce
C#6: Kelly
D6: Beyonce
Eb6: Kelly
Kelly - 13 semitones
Beyonce - 23 semitones
Beyonce wins 🎉
both tied imo for best vocalists of their generation. Kelly can outbelt anyone and Beyonce's lower notes and runs are unmatched. They both sing in such different ways they really fill different roles.
@@LitrallyAJ yess
They’re both extremely good, crazy talented, but Kelly brings more emotion with her voice.
queenssss
I disagree.
@@mlh1367 🤷🏻♂️
Beyoncé has such a versatile range. Mind up she also raps… ✨🌟💫👑
Kelly has a nice voice too.
Kelly for the win💯
yess
Do another Beyonce vs please 😭😭😭
Kelly makes it look so damn easy, while Beyoncé looks like she’s fighting for her life a lot of the times 😭 Kelly’s F#5s are out of this world! So glad you included that new F#5 :P
@@justinvaughn-xy7mg that F#5 was I N S A N E
0:56 Kelly actually slides down to a D3 there. it is a really slight offset but it's still sm
ohh i never noticed
C#3 - Beyoncé
Eb3 - Beyoncé
E3 - Beyoncé
F3 - Beyoncé
F#3 - Beyoncé
G3 - Beyoncé
G#3 - Beyoncé
A3 - Beyoncé
A4 - Beyoncé
A4 - tie
Bb4 - tie
Bb4 - Beyoncé
B4 - Beyoncé
B4 - tie
C5 - Beyoncé
C5 - tie
C#5 - Kelly
C#5 - Kelly
D5 - Kelly
D5 - tie
Eb5 - Kelly
Eb5 - Kelly
Eb5 - tie
E5 - tie
E5 - Kelly
E5 - Kelly
F5 - Kelly
F5 - Kelly
F5 - Kelly
F5 - Kelly
F#5 - Kelly
F#5!- Kelly
F#5 - tie
F#5 - Kelly
G5 - Kelly
G5 - Kelly
G#5 - Kelly
G#5 - Kelly
A5 - Kelly
A5 - tie
Bb5 - Beyoncé
B5 - tie
C6 - tie
C#6 - Beyoncé
D6 - Beyoncé
Eb6 - Beyoncé
F6 - Beyoncé
@@kellandino 🥰
The selections for could have been better, especially when she has so many professional recorded tours(i am vegas concert, i am world tour, Mrs carter world tour and The formation world) and live performances to select from. Beyonce is my pick, she had the fuller voice , with a fully connected range from top to bottom.
Two vocalists that i trust when in comes to LIVE singing
Is it just me or I hear lots of vocal effects added on Beyonce's performances in these clips...
i haven’t noticed while editing
it’s just reverb lol. it’s something that she’s played around with since Destiny’s Child whenever she sustains notes..but that’s why I also included clips of her hitting the same note WITHOUT reverb so no one can say she relies on it. it’s just a stylistic choice and for extra dramatics.
5:36 I love that the conductor here is waiting for Kelly to stop the strings
@@rhettmitchell LMAO I LOVE THAT
Beyonce 👸
Kelly has the wider range and greater versatility, and it's not even close.
@@anndickerson7496 yess
Wider upper range. Not wider range in general.
@@yebostephen6307 no, wider overall
@@anndickerson7496 no. Only upper range. In general, Beyonce has a wider range.
Kelly is a great belter and has such an amazing voice to truly keep up with and at times surpass Beyonce. I thought Beyonce was the queen of vibrato(she is) but Kelly has a great one as well.
@@Mellowron yess
I’m wanting for someone to do a video with beyonce and Kierra sheard
Beyonces high notes are mostly old videos.
@@ivanfromhell2560 i didn’t choose her clips 🥰
Well, that's before her voice settled into womenhood. 35+ and older. Her voice NOW is her real fully matured mezzo.
They’re pretty much a tie, beyonce is a show giver, while Kelly is a vocal provider.
@@addictedtovocals yess councoun
@@doctorits thank you dodo
@@addictedtovocals mommy
@@doctorits texas fanboy
Um no. Beyoncé gives BOTH. Whether together or apart. So stop
Beyonce
Kelly's voice gives me chills. Beyonce's voice doesn't make me feel much at all. It's all about the tone that you prefer.
@@samsong24 yess
Same. I’m not saying that Bey can’t sing or anything like that. I just don’t gravitate towards her voice or her music personally.
@@kendrabryant4738this a VOCAL battle. This isn’t about tone or personality
@@rydercdaniels4475 I didn’t say anything about her personality. I said that I, personally, don’t gravitate towards her voice or her music. Someone can technically “sing” but you may or may not connect with or feel anything about it when they do. Personal preference does weigh in here, as well as what/how their singing makes you feel. Singing is about more than just perfectly hitting the notes. It’s also supposed to connect with people. I prefer Kelly any day of the week, but I’m not saying anything bad about Bey. They can both technically sing very well. That’s why some of this does come down to personal preference, if they can both blow! And yes, part of what people do or don’t gravitate towards, with a singer, is their tone.
@@kendrabryant4738 Kelly’s voice has never done it for me. It’s in her tone. But that doesn’t take away from Kelly’s vocal abilities.
Kelly has a tonal quality to her voice that Beyonce just doesn't have and tbh Beyonce really over does it so much I can't listen that long
You doesn't make sense
Kelly over all takes it 💯....she has one of the best voice and this is proof
yess
Low notes: Bey
Mid belts: tie
Upper belts: Kelly
Head voice: I think slight edge to Bey.
Kelly: 2
Bey: 3
Both two of the best vocalists of the 2000s!
@@musicalkavya definitely!!
Lows: Bey - Kelly was all air and no substance down there. Beyoncé's mezzo nature makes her voice more robust here
Mid Belt: Tie: They both took certain notes
Upper belt: Kelly - Here Kelly's soprano nature started to shine from F5 up. Far more ease and ability to sustain
Head voice: Beyoncé dominated here. More agility and development here and arguably a more textured and interesting tone in this area than Kelly.
It's 15:15 points imho (sometimes I didn't give anybody a point because it was a tie)
@@oskarm646 yess
👏👏👏👏👏👏👑
@@Mary-rd2zl obg heleee
I think Beyoncé wins everywhere except for upper belts F#5 and above, and 6th octave head voice
I take that back, I loved bey’s C and C#6s haha
Bey won the low notes and tied the mid belts,
@@Artemis-cd2pf I think Kelly did and has always been phenomenal! And I also think she’d agree with me that Beyoncé beat her in these areas. However these days, I think she has a lot more accessibility to her belts Eb5 and above than Beyoncé and I’ll give her that, but in the video we saw a mostly younger Beyoncé that still had lots of ease up there. The belts lower than that are close to a tie, but I give them to Beyoncé because she’s a mezzo and they’re more beefy in her voice.
Beyonce Bethesda MD
C#3 Beyoncé
Eb3 Beyoncé
E3 Beyoncé
F3 Beyoncé
F#3 Beyonce
G3 Beyoncé
G#3 Beyoncé
A3 Beyonce
A4 Kelly
A4 Beyonce
Bb4 Beyonce
Bb4 Beyonce
B4 Tie
B4 Beyonce
C5 Beyonce (Preference) Kelly did great too
C5 Kelly
C#5 Kelly
C#5 Kelly
D5 Tie
D5 Beyoncé
Eb5 Beyoncé
Eb5 Beyonce
Eb5 Tie
E5 Beyonce
E5 Beyonce
E5 Beyonce
F5 Beyonce
F5 Beyonce
F5 Kelly
F5 Kelly
F#5 Kelly
F#5 Tie
F#5 Tie
F#5 Kelly
G5 Kelly
G5 Kelly
G#5 Kelly
G#5 Kelly
A5 Kelly
A5 Beyoncé
Bb5 Beyoncé
B5 Kelly
C6 Beyonce
C#6 Beyonce
D6 Beyonce
Eb6 Beyonce
F6 Beyonce
If I wasn't looking at the screen I would think Bey was singing most of the low notes, on shocked at how similar Kelly's tone sounds like Bey's
Kelly has a more emotive vocal performance in her mid belts-top belts, Beyoncé has good agility and texture.
@@Iamniko__ yess
Why didnt u use kelly's low note when she sing home by marc bloussard on tkc show? One of my fav performance by her, and then at the end boom, badass strong, growling kelly😍
@@thatYguy because you ain’t subscribed 😔
If we use this last year in review. compare then.
@@krisl1283 wym?
Kelly❤
Oh this a Kelly fan page makes sense lol
@@whip1720 what?
Beyoncé is overall better to me based on fullness of her lows and I love her mid belts, agility, and versatility of her voice (I also prefer her tone and vibrato) but these two are the BEST vocalists out. I kills me that Kelly is hardly ever in the convos that I see when she’s literally better than everyone else they talk about. They try to play like Beyoncé isn’t one of the greatest but they can’t back that up. I would love a Collab from them
C#3: Bey
Eb3: Bey
E3: Bey
F3: Bey
F#3: Tie
G3: Kelly
G#3: Bey
A3: Bey, not low for them both
A4: Tie
A4: Bey
Bb4: Bey
Bb4: Bey
B4: Bey
B4: Kelly
C5: Bey
C5: Bey
C#5: Tie
C#5: Tie
D5: Bey
D5: Tie (leaning to Bey)
Eb5: Bey
Eb5: Kelly
Eb5: Tie
E5: Kelly
E5: Tie
E5: Beyonce s was Eb5, so none
F5: Tie
F5: Kelly
F5: Bey
F5: Tie
F#5: Tie
F#5: Kelly
F#5: Kelly
F#5: Beyonce 's was F5, Kelly was amazing, but mislabeled, so none
G5: Kelly
G5: Kelly
G#5: Kelly
G#5: Tie
A5: idk, Kelly because bey wasnt clean
A5: Bey
Bb5: Bey
B5: Bey
C6: Beyonce is just fuller and head voice, not falsetto
C#6: Tie
D6: Beyonce
Eb6: Kelly
F6: Bey
I think it was all biased towards Beyonce, because some clips of Kelly werent nearly as good as Beyonce
hi, this is not a bias toward Bey considering this channel is a Kelly Clarkson vocal channel and they didn’t choose the Beyoncé clips, I did…so obviously they was choosing the best Kelly clips and i was choosing the best Beyoncé clips. both have amazing clips and both are INCREDIBLE vocalists but I think some of you guys underestimate Bey as a vocalist and was expecting her to get washed, but she’s literally just THAT good! thanks for watching tho ❤️
@@mykeyonce I know she s great, the clips were one of the best possible, i felt like these weren't for Kelly, but if they were, then.... Beyonce wins easily
@@mykeyonce I never underestimated bey haha
@@eyesnightmareAnd many of the clips were of Beyonce touring so her voice wasn’t operating at full potential while Kelly’s were far more rested and recorded for her show where she’d have also had more than one take. So yes, Beyonce is incredible.
@@squarcircle2254 Beyonce has 3 huge tours, one was for 132 shows, crazy
Beyoncé better in low notes, Kelly better in all another 😍
queens
Lows: Beyonce
The Rest: Kelly ✨✨
yess
I don’t know if it’s just me but i loved some of Beyonce’s higher belts than kelly’s especially Eb5-F#5. It’s not as sustained as Kelly’s but her vibrato + the high note just gets me every single time. For low notes = Beyonce; mid belts = Beyonce; high = Kelly; headtone = both are great but Beyonce for me. Her headtone sounds sooooo crisp and soulful
I mean.. obviously Beyonce has much better low notes, and Kelly completely loses Beyonce in the high note area.
Beyonce pretty much cleared everything except for the G5-A5 range
Could you make Kelly x Demi Lovato??
i have it already, it’s on @popvocalstv channel
Beyonce is the best, nobody can ever top her. She has that special magic in her voice. Kelly is also amazing and has such incredible technique and talent but for the sake of comparison I prefer Beyonce's voice every time but it all comes down to preference they are the masters of their voice!
The competition starts at A4, anything lower was for Beyonce.
In My Opinion:
C#3 - Bey
Eb3 - Bey
E3 - Bey
F3 - Bey
F#3 - Bey
G3 - Kelly
G#3 - Tie
A3 - Bey
A4 - Tie
Bb4 - Bey
B4 - Kelly
C5 - Bey
C#5 - Tie
D5 - Bey
Eb5 - Bey
E5 - Kelly
F5 - Bey
F#5 - Kelly
G5 - Kelly
G#5 - Bey
A5 - Kelly
A5 - Bey
Bb5 - Bey
B5 - Kelly
C6 - Bey
C#6 - Kelly
D6 - Bey
Eb6 - Bey
F6 - Bey
Both a great. I give kelly the slight edge
yess