This show is SO brilliant because the songs that were given to Ivy and Karen were fit for their voices. You heard Ivy sing this song only a little..because Karen's light elegance on the song. It matches perfectly. Ivy gets "Let's Be Bad" because of her belt and power. Obviously just two examples, but they are both such talented women that they get to shine every episode, together or individually. Each song is delicatly selected for these two incredible vocalists. They are stars! :]
"Never Give All The Heart" (feat. Katharine Mcphee) As a girl, I lived in a million homes So I always would keep to myself And my lessons were learned From the stories and poems I would steal from a library shelf Yes, the books like the rooms Weren't mine to keep But the words weren't left behind And I think of them all and I can't sleep And a poet who read my mind As the wise men once wrote Never give all the heart Well, it's easy to see He was writing for me I just wish I could play that part Yes, he scribbled that love isn't worth thinking of That is fades out from kiss to kiss If I just learned those lines Well, just think of the misery I'd miss As the Irish men said Don't put your heart up to play When he warned of the cost And the heart that he lost Mister Yeats really paved the way For the men that I've known Who have clearly shown They've reading him from the start 'Cause when it comes to me Well, their kisses come free But they never give all the heart When he warned of the cost And the heart that he lost Mister Yeats really paved the way For the men that I've known Well, they've clearly shown They been reading him from the start 'Cause each time that I fall They never give all the heart
Хха! А по-русски говоря, дивный мюзикл, замечательные талантливые актеры. И спасибо за саундтрек! второй год слушаю в машине эту музыку и не надоедает. Уже все тексты выучены. Пою!!! Кайф!!!!
NEVER give all the heart, for love Will hardly seem worth thinking of To passionate women if it seem Certain, and they never dream That it fades out from kiss to kiss; For everything that's lovely is But a brief, dreamy. Kind delight. O never give the heart outright, For they, for all smooth lips can say, Have given their hearts up to the play. And who could play it well enough If deaf and dumb and blind with love? He that made this knows all the cost, For he gave all his heart and lost.
Can't get enough of this show or its music. Kathrine and Megan are both so good, really, really good. Actually the whole crew is. Come on NBC lets get Season 2 under way. We've waited long enough.
She sounds so beautiful here, but her vocal technique too contemporary for the Marilyn character. That's why I prefer Megan Hilty -- she does a better job of playing the character.
i don't know maybe it's just me but Ivy's voice sounds forced, wrathful and heavy for the song. the subtle, velvety voice of mcphee just suits the mood of this song
I don't know how people could prefer Ivy over Karen...Karen in my opinion was the best person for the part! This version of the song is just pure perfection!
I think Karen played one side of Marilyn vero well, but Ivy played her more well-roundedly. As far as mannerism goes, Megan did way more research on her, which shows a lot when it comes to how Ivy plays her and the realism of her work is obvious to anyone who's familiar with Marilyn's career, early life and person in general. Looks wise, Katharine (Karen) is way skinnier than Marilyn ever was, while Megan looks just right. Vocally and technically, she outshines Katharine, especially when it comes to ballads. Also, I think it didn't help how they obviously wrote Karen to be the hero: personally, as many other people, I tend to instinctively dislike characters that are written as the goody-two-shoes in an obvious attempt of the writers to make the audience root for them.
+Alyssa Smith I totally respect your opinion and thank you for explaining your reasoning behind it. It was just for me personally Karen just seemed better for the part, but again that's just my opinion and everyone is more then welcome to have their own.
The difference between Karen and Ivy singing this song is that I actually feel like Ivy knows what this song is about and can emote while she is singing. Karen sings it pretty enough but the song could be about anything and it would sound the same.
She has pure voice , but Ivy has more volume which personally I think the song needs a voice like Katherine's which is pure but needs the volume of Megan's after that the song would be amazon
This song is so sad, i prefer katherine singing this to megan although megan can do 'never met a wolf' better then katherine, i still love this song, smash is so awesome! i cant wait for my dvds to come!
I agree they are both amazing singers but when you think of the whole package, Megan/Ivy is Marilyn. She has the figure and she can do her voice better than Katherine/Karen. Even though I like Karens voice better.
Guys, try to watch this: /watch?v=6F175rHqyA0 What a fitting tribute to Marilyn, I even have tears in my eyes after I watched it. And yes, the video used Karen Cartwright's version ;-)
i like kat's version of this but i prefer the previous lyrics better..the time when the song was still incomplete...its sooo awkward..yeats paved the way?
Its good, but I have to disagree that its the better version. Megan Hilty has a more expressive voice that just blows Katharine (who is amazingly talented, don't get me wrong) away.
This "team" ridiculousness is getting a little out of hand. First THG was bombarded with this nonsense now Smash? What's next, Team Harry? Team Voldemort? Team Doctor? Team Master?
Karen all the way. She has so much innocence and ivy just is too much for Marilyn. Whatever tho they both have bitchin voices. But uh yeah team Karen bye
This show is SO brilliant because the songs that were given to Ivy and Karen were fit for their voices. You heard Ivy sing this song only a little..because Karen's light elegance on the song. It matches perfectly. Ivy gets "Let's Be Bad" because of her belt and power. Obviously just two examples, but they are both such talented women that they get to shine every episode, together or individually. Each song is delicatly selected for these two incredible vocalists. They are stars! :]
Smash we still havent forgotten about you
I just started it again for i think the 4th time
3 years later. .. and still in love with this song
Has it really been three years?? omg
Shawn Antonio almost 8 years now
8 years here...
@@theoperatripleaxel5417 Ditto!
@@theoperatripleaxel5417it’s been 11 years and it still slaps
"Never Give All The Heart"
(feat. Katharine Mcphee)
As a girl, I lived in a million homes
So I always would keep to myself
And my lessons were learned
From the stories and poems
I would steal from a library shelf
Yes, the books like the rooms
Weren't mine to keep
But the words weren't left behind
And I think of them all and I can't sleep
And a poet who read my mind
As the wise men once wrote
Never give all the heart
Well, it's easy to see
He was writing for me
I just wish I could play that part
Yes, he scribbled that love isn't worth thinking of
That is fades out from kiss to kiss
If I just learned those lines
Well, just think of the misery I'd miss
As the Irish men said
Don't put your heart up to play
When he warned of the cost
And the heart that he lost
Mister Yeats really paved the way
For the men that I've known
Who have clearly shown
They've reading him from the start
'Cause when it comes to me
Well, their kisses come free
But they never give all the heart
When he warned of the cost
And the heart that he lost
Mister Yeats really paved the way
For the men that I've known
Well, they've clearly shown
They been reading him from the start
'Cause each time that I fall
They never give all the heart
8 years later, still love this song
I love this song. Everything is perfect. The piano part is amazing.
:) Smash's lyrics are always so beautifully written... I have so much respect for the whole cast and crew. Can't wait for season 2 :D
2018 and this song still gets me everytime
One of my favorite songs of the series. Katherine's version is so vunerable and raw, like Marilyn's inner thoughts, not her public persona. 💞
4 years later...still gives me the feelz!
Хха! А по-русски говоря, дивный мюзикл, замечательные талантливые актеры. И спасибо за саундтрек! второй год слушаю в машине эту музыку и не надоедает. Уже все тексты выучены. Пою!!! Кайф!!!!
August 2016....still listening... still so in love and yet so hurt that it ended...
I LOVE THIS SONG EVEN THOUGH IT'S SAD BUT ITS EXTREMELY BEAUTIFUL AND MOVING. IT GIVES ME THE OPPOSITE OF CINDERELLA'S "SO THIS IS LOVE".
Katharine McPhee's voice is probably my favorite voice in the world!!
NEVER give all the heart, for love
Will hardly seem worth thinking of
To passionate women if it seem
Certain, and they never dream
That it fades out from kiss to kiss;
For everything that's lovely is
But a brief, dreamy. Kind delight.
O never give the heart outright,
For they, for all smooth lips can say,
Have given their hearts up to the play.
And who could play it well enough
If deaf and dumb and blind with love?
He that made this knows all the cost,
For he gave all his heart and lost.
What a beautiful song. I'm team Ivy all the way, but Karen did a really good job on this :)
I love this song so much. Soft voice which really compliments the song :)
Can't get enough of this show or its music. Kathrine and Megan are both so good, really, really good. Actually the whole crew is. Come on NBC lets get Season 2 under way. We've waited long enough.
Good thing this is up, they deleted the original video on their official page so thanks for this one!!!
I prefer this ballad version over the up-tempo one. Much more heartfelt
Is it just me or i love this version better than megan hilty's? both versions are great, but i like karen/katherine's voice better
This song sounds like something that Mr. Rogers would sing on his show.Its an amazing song.
I love this song and I love love love Smash so much.
Those ninth chords at the end!!! Chills every time.
So glad we got to hear Kat McPhee sing this. I think this suits her pure voice more than it does Megan Hilty's
This song should have won an Emmy
She sounds so beautiful here, but her vocal technique too contemporary for the Marilyn character. That's why I prefer Megan Hilty -- she does a better job of playing the character.
True
i don't know maybe it's just me but Ivy's voice sounds forced, wrathful and heavy for the song. the subtle, velvety voice of mcphee just suits the mood of this song
still my favorite from the show
It's such a beautiful song
Thank GOD finally someone seems to get what the song is about...! :)
absolutely beautiful!
Such a beautiful song. :)
Has anyone stopped to think that maybe both singers are amazing and either could be Marilyn?
still in love with this song in 2018
This song suits Katharine's voice perfectly. Megan's voice matches better with Second hand white Baby Grand.
NBC is getting their own streaming service! I’m sure Smash along with The Office will be there !
When i close my eyes I just think of a broken hearted girl walking down the streets of Manhattan during a snowy winter and singing this song.
she has a christmas album out!!! christmas for all year round!
This song is soooo beautiful and so touching! >.< Katharine has simply an amazing voice and she looks stunning, like, always! Love her
Yay! Another Ivy lover!
Since its a midseason replacement i think you have to wait until around feb before it starts again
Essa parte acaba comigo 01:29
Comigo também!
I love Katharine verison of this song, her voice is much more expressive !
1:49 Love the vocals there.
Who composed this song? It´s wonderful.
This and broadway here I come are my anthems.
This is my fav Smash' song
That sucks, I didn't want to wait that long. I guess I'll have to subscribe to hulu plus so I can watch the first season over again.
I don't know how people could prefer Ivy over Karen...Karen in my opinion was the best person for the part! This version of the song is just pure perfection!
thanks! i thinks the same thing Karen is soooo wonderful
I think Karen played one side of Marilyn vero well, but Ivy played her more well-roundedly. As far as mannerism goes, Megan did way more research on her, which shows a lot when it comes to how Ivy plays her and the realism of her work is obvious to anyone who's familiar with Marilyn's career, early life and person in general. Looks wise, Katharine (Karen) is way skinnier than Marilyn ever was, while Megan looks just right. Vocally and technically, she outshines Katharine, especially when it comes to ballads. Also, I think it didn't help how they obviously wrote Karen to be the hero: personally, as many other people, I tend to instinctively dislike characters that are written as the goody-two-shoes in an obvious attempt of the writers to make the audience root for them.
+Alyssa Smith I totally respect your opinion and thank you for explaining your reasoning behind it. It was just for me personally Karen just seemed better for the part, but again that's just my opinion and everyone is more then welcome to have their own.
Tasia Memmott I respect yours too. After all, people having different opinions is what makes the world fun, right?
Alyssa Smith definitely :)
this is still great
it's one of the VERY few songs i like sang by Katherine as i prefer Megan's strong voice.
So everything Katharine McPhee sings you don't like just because you think Megan Hilty's voice is stronger?? Weird Logic!
There used to be a full ivy version on TH-cam which was far superior. And I miss it...
Please release a version sung by Megan Hilty!
LOL! couldn't help it because it's too beautiful!
season 1 was brilliant. gosh, miss smash,k McPhee, d messing et al
Am I the only one who wants her to put out a Christmas album after listening to this?
The difference between Karen and Ivy singing this song is that I actually feel like Ivy knows what this song is about and can emote while she is singing. Karen sings it pretty enough but the song could be about anything and it would sound the same.
I totally agree but see that is where the dilemma is when picking Marilyn...together Ivy and Karen make up Marilyn
She has pure voice , but Ivy has more volume which personally I think the song needs a voice like Katherine's which is pure but needs the volume of Megan's after that the song would be amazon
2019 anyone?
perfect
This song is so sad, i prefer katherine singing this to megan although megan can do 'never met a wolf' better then katherine, i still love this song, smash is so awesome! i cant wait for my dvds to come!
Just read that poem and was wondering where I noticed it from: this song haha
Because this version is better. : }
I wish I could find the full version of megan hiltys
Why can't we just appreciate both amazing singers cuz they're both awesome
I completely agree. I love Kat, but Megan is the better Marilyn.
She put some stank on this song!
If you search "Never Give All the Heart Smash Duet" you'll find a video that at least includes some verses sung by Megan.
**TEAM IVY!!!**
I agree they are both amazing singers but when you think of the whole package, Megan/Ivy is Marilyn. She has the figure and she can do her voice better than Katherine/Karen. Even though I like Karens voice better.
Alyssa Gossard kkkk
fits her voice waay better. we all know that karen deserves this role. more than megan.
ikr!!!! i really want it too!!! :(
It mades me feel bad...
I THIS SONG AMAZING SONG!!!!!!!!!!!
Idk but I would love a version that makes me feel more sad for Marilyn
Karen can do Broadway just as good as Ivy, not her fault that the story line gave Ivy all the Marilyn numbers :( This and Mambo is gold.
Guys, try to watch this: /watch?v=6F175rHqyA0
What a fitting tribute to Marilyn, I even have tears in my eyes after I watched it. And yes, the video used Karen Cartwright's version ;-)
Where is ivy
i like kat's version of this but i prefer the previous lyrics better..the time when the song was still incomplete...its sooo awkward..yeats paved the way?
i literally re-enacting the scene where Karen sing along to this with her laptop on her lap. minus my own voice. just miming.
The Hunger Games... I think because she has Jennifer Lawrence as picture and her user means" the girl on fire"
you know that you can buy some songs by its self
I love katharine, but I have to admit I love Ivy's version of it better.
William Butler Yeats, the poet...
Poor Karen. :( I feel a little bad for Dev too, but he never told her anything about what was going on with him...
Whenever she says "Mr Yeats", all I hear is "mystery eights" -_-
@gisa09 Marc Shaiman and Scott Whittman
Its good, but I have to disagree that its the better version. Megan Hilty has a more expressive voice that just blows Katharine (who is amazingly talented, don't get me wrong) away.
lets not turn this into twilight
so after last night...no more respect for Ivy smh
Tobacco Holding Group.
Personally I'm "Team Cigar"
Katharine McPhee is seriously the best singer ever! No one can top her. Megan/Ivy can't either and we all know it! Don't be naïve!
what is wrong with that line?
I prefer Ivy's version :)
This and Broadway
This "team" ridiculousness is getting a little out of hand. First THG was bombarded with this nonsense now Smash? What's next, Team Harry? Team Voldemort? Team Doctor? Team Master?
Karen all the way. She has so much innocence and ivy just is too much for Marilyn. Whatever tho they both have bitchin voices. But uh yeah team Karen bye
Forget Ivy or Karen, I'm team Julia.
Megan sings this song so much better !