Luke Mitchell Is Innocent - Detective Scott Forbes Tells All
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 9 ก.พ. 2025
- Anything Goes with James English Ep/311
Scott Forbes Tells His Story
Scotts book www.amazon.co....
You can contact James English on his social media platforms ⬇️⬇️
/ anything_goes_podcast
/ jamesenglish2
/ jamesenglish0
/ jamesenglish11
Website:
www.jamesengli...
You can also listen & download full Podcasts at the links below.
cms.megaphone....
itunes.apple.com
jamesenglish.p...
deezer.page.li...
cms.glb.samsun...
music.amazon.c...
player.fm/seri...
www.podchaser....
All Video and Sound Edited by Stephen Pettigrew
/ shinersp
/ shinersp
Featured Music.
'Filaments' by Scott Buckley is under a Creative Commons licence
Attribution 3.0 Unported (CC BY 3.0)
/ scottbuckley
Music promoted by BreakingCopyright: bit.ly/filamen...
Professor David Wilson, Criminologist has investigated the case and now telling the Herald: "Luke Mitchell should never have been charged, let alone convicted"
He told us on twitter he was going to write a piece, I thought it would have been more negative but I was delighted when I read it!!At Last people are listening and calling out this miscarriage of justice. From the family to the justice system, all needs to be held to account, 20yrs, a bloody lifetime gone for nothing . #justiceforlukeandjodi and ⚖️
Scott , is there any way police can tamper with the forensics thats not been destroyed before they get tested?
@@hailie8833 not really. They could destroy or contaminate but that would be an altogether dif level of corruption
I'm studying this case, and apparently they have just destroyed evidence.
@scottforbes7970 I wanted to see if I could contact you. I bought your book and my husband began investigating the case. Thank you.
Glad to hear Scott feels proud of what he's doing in this case because he certainly should. Thank you both.
Yeah because slandering innocent people and the family of a murdered child is so brave.he's scum.
@@andybear8847 only scum is those that protected the real killer/s.
@@andybear8847 You had no objections to the Press, the media and the public when they were all doing it to Luke and Corrine though. Remember, Corrine lost her son too in all of this.. when if the truth had been told from that dreadful night that Jodi was murdered, we wouldn’t be here now defending him and fighting the corrupt cops and justice system.
Read the recently made public court transcripts and I guarantee you dont feel the same way, scott the fraud forbes had been exposed for hundreds of lies👍
Yeah this is what this guy needs is the people coming together to support him. Well done. Commenting from the USA
20 years too late
@@ddc6321 unfortunately that’s true. But without the public support he could sit there for another 20 since they can’t get him to admit it. I know he’s innocent and you do too but the justice system has failed this guy. It’s too corrupt
The best podcaster, with Scott not skirting about, answering every question. First class. The police, courts etc haven't given luke justice but this will spread and spread and people know the system has failed luke and jodie. Shame on scottish justice system
I can't get over this story. I've just discovered it two weeks ago and I'm now binge watching everything I can find. I want to dedicate my life to helping get this boy free. Us Scots need to do the right thing by this boy and raise as much awareness as possible.
Definitely j this should be on the news constantly
Absolutely agree ! I have watched the murder in a small town and did not realise until this was released that there is No forensic evidence linking him to the murder at all ! Jodi killer still out there (if still alive )
Di'd you watch the documentary by the 2 cops sacked for fraud from a terrorisn unit claiming other cops were corrupt? Well buy this guys book he only blamed his mate until he died and now he has new fresh suspects with zero evidence to back it up. Maybe dedicate your life to something not so full of holes and conspiracy.
@@johnrosscampbell6187 what about the corrupt police lying and destroying evidence you keep ignoring that question for some reason 😂
@J S you keep going back to corruption while ignoring the real evidence that convicted him so swings and roundabouts pal. The corruption only exists if you ignore viable evidence, proof of deception, out and out lies and actual science based in reality. Even the claim there was no DNA is wrong so no I won't entertain this "corruption" bollocks buddy. You're backing a lad who spent years trying to get the name in the paper by blaming his pal, see through charlatans. Look into their other "cases" if you need more info.
Think you will be doing another interview with Scott Forbes in the future when Luke is released James, that one will be massive.
Great work James and Scott Forbes!
Brilliant, I hope that justice prevails
All 4 interviews have been great James. Heartbreaking story on so many levels. The longer this goes on the dirtier it gets. Young lives taken and ruined.
@Scott C Forbes is an inspiration. From his early life turnaround to get into University and a law degree, I believe. Just purchased the book from Amazon. Scott has done his research and I could only hope that any human who found themselves in a miscarriage of justice or accused of something they didn't do had Scott in their corner. He has the heart of a lion and has put himself and his reputation above the parapet. As bad as I believe the MSM acted all those year's ago I also believe they will be the ones to help push for something positive to happen alongside Scott and Dr Lean.
👏 👏 👏
@Scott c Forbes unbelievable man. Keep up the hard work mate. Where can I watch the other podcast you mentioned. Who was it with ? Initials will do haha. Cheers mate.
Scott you totally hit the nail on the head with this interview 👍 So much respect for you and for all the years of hard work you have put into fighting for Justice for Luke and Jodi ❤️ James thank you for using your platform to help spread awareness of this case and the curruption with the police and how an INNOCENT 14yr old child was given a life sentence. Shame on Scotland for the biggest miscarriage of justice.⚖️⚖️⚖️
Scotland's biggest miscarriage of justice might arguably be Lockerbie.
Free Masons ???
@@alisonhilll4317 Donald Findlay KC absolutely. The cops and other top ranking professionals involved, very probable. I fail to see how Findlay was otherwise so incompetent.
@@TGcomments I agree supposed to be brilliant QC Ha
James your support and channel is doing wonders for getting the word out my man 🙏
❤️
One of the best ways 2 gt the truth out there. Thanks 2 , James n the guests he's had on his channel 👍. Cldnt do it any better . Brilliant job once again mate. 👏
The most brutally honest podcast I’ve watched, unbelievable what an eye opener
👍🏼
@@JamesEnglish james I have asked to be on this show.... listen to my story you will wee scott is talking bullshit
@@gcarrol just tell it now
Don't hold back
@@gcarrol he was being sarcastic 😂😂 you take the lie detector test ALSO with the rest down that lane. Your own sister! And Steven Kelly's sperm on her teeshirt ALSO should do one blow that machine up🤐
@joe jones . Nobody wants to listen to your made up shite boy.
The only thing that's true is Luke is innocent, and you (If you are Jodis brother) are a mentally psychotic violent boy.
Nobody would believe yer patter anyway boy, but everyone believes Luke is innocent.
Away and take a lie detector test ya flump. Or do you take that many drugs that you would pretend that's what made you fail the test???.
Nobody's interested in your lies ya junkie!!!
I'm from just outside Glasgow and I've NEVER believed Luke Mitchell was guilty. What I want to know is why the Jones family have been so quiet? And won't take lie detector tests while Luke and his mother did? They're running scared and with the amount of people behind Luke they should be! Justice for Luke and Jodi!
Ted Bundy passed a lie detector twice, What a nice chap he was.
They are junk science.
Why should the Jones family speak out?
The case was Luke Vs The Crown, not Vs the Jones.
It was a jury that found him guilty.
Why would they be running scared?
Lie detectors are inadmissible in a court for a reason, they can't be relied on. As for the Jones family being silent, that's called a dignified silence. The guy speaking Scott Forbes, injected himself into this case when he practically accused another man, Mark Kane, of being the killer. It was alleged he offered Kane half of the £50, 000 he believed he'd get selling his story. Luke Mitchell may not be guilty, but he'd be better served by more credible supporters than this guy.
Why would the Jones family need to take lie detector tests? I'm from dalkeith and have yet to speak to anyone who agrees with anything scott and sandra say. Luke's mother is a known drug addict and proven liar. Terry Mullins doesn't even use the polygraph tests anymore but it was good publicity for his business.
It's poor Shane I feel sorry for, at least he had the courage to speak with the Jones family. He's has nothing to do with any of this nonsense.
Theyve just lost a daughter...they dont want to lose a son as well. Theyre content for Luke to take the blame
@@sickboy6663 it was the police that went after luke not the family!
Half of what is said on these podcasts are proven lies so it's impossible to believe anything they say.
Brilliant, had me gripped, the laddie should be freed and every one of those involved held accountable. They've all lived thier lives for 20yrs while an innocent laddie does thier time, bloody shameful #justiceforlukeandjodi ⚖️
All down to Bent Scum Cops 2003.
A lot of them back in the 2000’s thats for sure
How many times are the Police in Scotland going to get away with this type of stuff, focusing only on one person??
Happened to me in 1997 when i was arrested for fuck all and went to the High Court for a crime I didn't do and thankfully I was found not guilty and the judge accused cops of lying etc....there are defo corruption in police dept in Scotland for sure.
It’s disturbing look at the Rhys bonner case that’s so shocking. That says it all about the police
Police Scotland are corrupt, i widna ever trust em
Totally agree with scott
Ideal man. Scott you’re a good man keep this ball rolling and James thank you for allowing them to use your platform , they can’t keep Luke banged up forever! #freeluke
This is absolutely unbelievable- been following your coverage of this one James!
Cannot get to grips with how he has been jailed for this 🤯
The public need to understand that you have Never been told the Truth from Lying Leany & now her Clone Scott Forbes, who Both say Whatever because they have a book of BS to Sell ya. Go to her live vid - Case Revelations June 14, 2019. You will hear sandra say that Jodi was sexually assaulted. This is a Blatant Lie. One of a Great many told by Her & Corrine & now Forbes. This is because she Knows how the public will react when she talks about the condom, found quite some distance away, but she knows that won't matter at all, the public will 'conjure up' exactly what she wants them to. She also says in relation to DNA on her sister's Tshirt, just 'DNA'. She Knows the public will think, sperm. It was an old blood spot that hadn't washed out properly but so many of the public have been in a frenzy because it was her sister's boyfriend's DNA. And sandra has a book to sell, so she just says DNA & leaves it at that. These 2 guys had full-proof alibis by the way. Luke was seen with Jodi at about 4.50 p.m. at the east end of the path & the witness said he had a bulge in his jacket pocket & it looked as if they were arguing. He was seen at the other end of the path by himself 50 minutes later by 2 women who said he looked like he was up to no good. The police Know that time the attack occurred because of Leonard Kelly who was riding that path to go home from work as he did daily. sandra likes to say that the police made up the time of Jodi's death. Leonard heard a 'human noise' & he stopped near the V, so did the noise. He described the noise as like strangling & the time was 5.05 - 5.15. The medical examiner said the there were 'signs of asphyxia' & likely clothing was used. Signs of - means the strangling stopped. He also talked about the 12-20 cuts at the neck, previous to the last deep cut. A few of these were a little deep, most were superficial. Was this done to Try & hide the 'started asphyxia' which stopped because Luke heard the guy on the other side of the wall? Obviously Jodi was unconscious Only when Leonard stopped there or she would have started screaming. The ME talks about the severe blow to the head from a blunt weapon that produced a contusion on the brain. sandra has Never mentioned this Fact. The public need to ask themselves why not. sandra has never mentioned that Jodi was unconscious either. Why not? That severe blow to the head means Jodi was knocked out. Jodi's clothes were extensively cut & torn & strewn around. Luke described her clothes yet supposedly hadn't seen her. She got changed after school. Her hands were tied behind her back with her trousers, a Highly unusual thing to do. Would trousers hold someone's hands tied together if conscious? There was no shouting, screaming or crying heard & that place was a very open area yet a public walkway just on the other side of that High wall. The person who did this would Not Know if someone was standing on the other side of the wall & anyone could have come through that V at any moment. Who would take the time to extensively cut & tear clothes? He Staged Many aspects at the scene because he thought he was smarter than the cops, he wasn't. sandra tells the public that Jodi 'fought to her death'. This is another blatant lie. The bruising was to the face & head only. The ME said punches, blunt weapon & likely kicks. Kicks means - on the ground. It is Very clear Jodi was unconscious when the Whole of the attack happened. There were a few cuts on the hands & a few bruises on the top of the hands. I'm not going into the details of why the police know that was staged. The fingernails were undamaged & no abrasions on the knuckles. There was no bruising or abrasions anywhere else on the body. He was behind her when the deep cut happened & this is evidenced by the blood on the wall. A few cuts were before death Most after. In total Luke was unaccounted for - Three hours. The prosecution put forth that he went back. He premeditated all he did & was well prepared. In the taped interview with the detectives he let them know just how forensically aware he was. It is a fact that it's not very often that a killer leaves forensics on a body. It was proven that his torch didn't have the reach to have seen the body from where he stood - that's also forensics. The body was behind a big tree & in bushes, only one foot could be seen when Very close & with the right torch. The body was under a canopy of low hanging branches & leaves. The way her socks were pulled down off the ankles & just half on her feet told the police a great deal also. He left school & went in a different direction than he would usually go. He called Jodi's house 2 times after the murder thinking he was establishing an alibi & on the 2nd call her step-father answered & told him Jodi had left to meet him & he said "cool". He didn't call back. He later told his friends Jodi wasn't coming out yet he had been told she had left to see him. He knew she was dead. He denied to the police that he called the house. His phone records proved he did. He was with her at lunchtime at school, he knew her phone was broken. Jodi used her mother's phone to text him & they arranged to meet. He only called the house phone because he had to make sure someone Answered, the phone. Jodi wasn't allowed to walk that Very isolated walkway on her own & is why they would meet at the east end of the path when going to his place or to their other meeting place, through that V & in the area where she was found. The body was near the tree that had their initials carved into it. He told the police he had never been through that V before. He told the police he had never been in that area through that V before. His friends refuted those lies. He told the police he hadn't even seen that V in the wall before, yet he went past it to his mother's work & with Jodi. One could hardly miss it. At 10.41 Jodi's mum texted his phone to tell Jodi to get home. He called her right back & offered to search that walkway. It wasn't likely that Jodi was in the woodlands. He was prepped & good to go in 3 minutes. His dog didn't 'alert' on the way past the V. Strange. He met her family & asked them if they had anything of Jodi's for the dog to sniff. Why would they have anything of Jodi's for the dog to sniff? they thought she was at a house. He said to the dog "find Jodi". Within 10 minutes of meeting her family he said he found her. He was in the woodlands mere seconds.
He was known to wear The jacket/parka in the months prior & was seen wearing it that day at school & that afternoon & evening. Many testified to that fact including one of his teachers. The jacket disappeared after the murder. Corrine told police he never had a jacket, never wore jackets, hated jackets & is on a vid years later, saying this as Well. After the murder Corrine went out & bought him the Same jacket that disappeared. She was caught-out doing this. He was known to have many knives & carried a 4" skunting knife in it's pouch - Daily. The ME described the knife used as stout. All knives & the knife pouch disappeared after the murder. So did his balaclava. Many testified about his knives including a cadet leader who had to take a 6-7" blade knife off him. Google Karen van Nuil & read what he did to her one month before, with a knife. Corrine told police he never had Any knives. His friends testified that he used to cut his hash with that 4" skunting knife. When they thought the heat was off Corrine bought him the Same 4" skunting knife. She was caught-out doing that too. sandra talks about 'others' who smoked pot & 'others' who sold pot. It is a Fact that Luke smoked pot & hash Daily & was Also a drug dealer. He was convicted of drug supply as well, Caught with the the drugs, scales & relevant items for selling drugs. Who stores their own urine in jars, 20 plus, & stores that under the bed? A neighbour testified that she saw Corrine burning clothes in the log burner that night. Neighbours testified to the burning in the backyard 2 times that night & said it smelt weird. A friend testified that Luke had said he could imagine himself getting stoned & killing someone. A school fellow testified that when Luke was showing him his knife he said he knew the best way to slit someone's throat. The friends he met that night testified that they thought he killed Jodi. When the police searched the house again Unannounced April 2004, the 3rd time & they located a small knife pouch. He had written Jodi's initials & her date of birth & death & a quote from the Nirvana singer. He added 666. Only the killer would write all that on a Knife Pouch. That was his Trophy. Some skunting knives are folding knives. Two days after the murder he bought & viewed the Marilyn Manson DVD, The Golden Age of the Grotesque, images depicting naked women tied together, subjected to a form of abduction. His friends testified that Luke was obsessed with the Black Dahlia murder & looked up to MManson. Sandra & Corrine tell different 'versions' about a MManson CD & was Always just a CD, til this vid. There is No CD mentioned in the crown documents. They tell different versions about MManson & he didn't like MManson & someone bought him a calendar & it was ripped up in a bin. It just so happened to be ripped up in the bottom of a bin, the day the police searched the house the 2nd time. The police had enough 'just cause' to get a warrant & search the house July 4th, the first time. His brother testified that Luke was Not home & so, he sure wasn't cooking dinner & he also said his mother coerced him into giving Luke a False alibi before, as She did. Whining about the media still But, he & Corinne Invited them Into the house for an interview, the Day of Jodi's Funeral ffs. Courting celebrity straight away? Absolutely. And lowlife Sandra jumped on the Bandwagon - for Money. Now her partner in crime Scott Forbes, is doing Exactly the Same.
Scott is such a likeable guy. Well done for doing this James.
So much respect for the time and effort Scott has put into this!!
Scott is very likeable and believable but more like a social worker than a lawyer. Very down to earth and normal.
I remember this being fairly local, it was just assumed it was Luke, they spun it like that, there was no internet to investigate like there is now, absolutely shocking that this has happened, am so glad for this podcast. Grateful to be Scottish to understand it as well 😂
Much respect to Scott, you see in his eyes and the way he articulates he will not stop until the truth is out and Luke gets his freedom ❤
You see in his eyes he's on drugs.
@@KJosef24🙄
Absolute class this was , loved how Scott never fucked about and just named them 👏👏 Boy is defo innocent , fact he won't admit it to get out says it all for me.👍
Spot on. This should be on every news channel/paper.
Said it all for me sitting in munro 2 , 2 halls under luke mitchells protection wing i had a feeling he was innocent it didnt make sense then either
Great interview James, what a breath of fresh-air Scott Forbes is not a man in it for himself only fighting for justice... Top-man
The opening trailer for this is VERY powerful. It took about ten seconds to be able to tell this was a man with a story. Plenty of people doing podcasts loving the clout...but something very different about this man. You just have to see it in the eyes.
Well done James, this is defo Scotland's shame. Poor Luke & Jodi. 😢
mental man, ordered his book today, due on Thursday, come on here & see this is scheduled. Class! Scott's a brilliant speaker.
I've just read his full book. Wait until u get to the final page. Powerful words
@Lucyboyce looking even more forward to it now!
Have you read Sandra's book, Innocents Betrayed? Another great read..
@Jem Jemz ill need to get that, cheers for the recommendation
Ohhh the book is amazing... be prepared to read it all in one night x
Well Done James. Lets get this info out there. Get people talking and questioning the narrative. Hope to see Luke free in the near future.
Well done James for doing this interview and very well done Scott for speaking out and telling the world the truthful information held back from the public for all these years. I truly hope Jodi and Luke get the justice they both deserve
This is a tragic travesty of justice. Too many unanswered questions and strange anomalies to this case. James you consistently shine a light on people who have no voice and for that I genuinely commend you.🙏❤️👌.x
Keep doing the work Scott we are behind you
I was inside when luke got convicted into polmont and he walked wis his head held high not guilty in my eyes hes a brave lad , everyone in Polmont was out to get luke mitchell to make a name for themselves and luke has carried himself through this wrongful conviction as an innocent man and rightly so he deserves justice and compensation for the time he has lost with his ill mother , ridiculous from the police not surprised tbh.
Well done James for keeping this alive, absolutely tragedy for both jodie & luke
Aye your right it was a tragedy and he’s where he bloody well belongs because he did it
l always believe luke never done it himself
Love listening to you Scott, Just purchased your book from amazon cant wait to get stuck in, so sad this case have been following it for years had the book that Sandra released a few years back too, wow what an eye opener that was. Keep doing what your doing and hopefully we can all get justice for Luke ♥
Brilliant interview again Scott Forbes 👏 Justice for Luke Mitchell
What an absolute fucking gent of a man, i really hope he gets what hes been fighting for !! And even more so for luke!! Keep in the fight for this one james, is there anywhere i can get this on audio book? Another fantastic episode , good luck scott forbes👍👍👍
This has been worth waiting for. Now send in James Matthews from SKY TV for a public confession by the killer, and we know it’s not Luke. Thank you.
James, yet again another Fantastic Guest 👏 this case is tragic I remember Joe steele speaking about Luke on your podcast. Scott is an amazing man he has dedicated 17 years to this case he paints pictures with his words .I cannot believe about the crime scene being contaminated NO DNA on Luke but he still got charged .This is a total miscarriage of justice Police Scotland and the Press should hang their heads in shame an innocent boy is imprisoned when clearly they know he's innocent. I hope Scott keeps fighting for Luke until he gets released
Where's the world at when this so-called Scotsman 'presenter' is using the F word & all the way through. What a disgrace. I hope English is proud of himself for being a Promoter for the Incitement of Hatred against every member of this poor girl's family & half the lads & fathers in Dalkeith. Shame on them Both. That highly Sadistic child killer is Exactly where he will Stay.
After watching this series I'm absolutely gobsmacked. Lots of unanswered questions. Not sure what normal people like us public folk can do so have bought the book as a small show of support. Full credit to James for highlighting this and to Scott for all his work 👏
🤦🏼♂️ your dialect is a headache , us public folk ? What ????
Fantastic interview Scott & James very interesting indeed! Could have listened to you all day! Justice for Luke & Jodi x
Very informative podcast, thank you James and Scott. Hopefully Luke gets a retrial or release on appeal soon. I don't know much about the judicial processes, but if it transpires that the evidence destroyed is significant, he should be exonerated and have the ability to raise legal action for the years spent behind bars for a crime he did not commit.
He’s appealed twice. So thats 3 court cases stating he’s guilty. This man is lying in the podcast to try and sell books. If you google the case, it is soooo clear Luke murdered her.
Scott don’t mince his words does he the absolute legend more people like this needed in the world.
One one the most bizarre cases in Scottish legal history...a young boy let down by the legal processes.
I pray a retrial is granted in order that this case is looked at again and hopefully the case reopened to find the real killer.
Can not wait to see this about time this boy gets justice and real people be caught shocking after all these years he still locked up for crime didnt commit
Definitely jean
Well done for sticking to this to both of you , this is absolutely the RIGHT FIGHT to be on board with - He was 14 years old and the world is aware that Scotland abused a child's human rights , too shameful for words, poor Jodi how disrespectful to that beautiful girls memory by allowing this and worst to stick by it when it is so blatantly a Miscarriage of Justice . 😢😢⚖⚖✌✌
This is heavy. This just proves how corrupt the system can be. Keep up the good work Scott. James brillant podcast.
Jones Family know who killed Jodi shame on them letting a innocent child take the blame. The darkness will come to light 😢 Justice for Jodi and Luke 🇬🇧
My guess is that they already lost one child and that they didn't want to lose another.
Sadly, this put an innocent man in prison.
@@michellemooresingsthat's one of the things that I think too it's crazy that police Scotland of Edinburgh could setup Luke Mitchell and this has been through this case that's exactly what they did rest in peace Jodi Jones GBNF #freelukemitchell
I get it but to have an innocent man in prison for 20 years is on a whole new level of crime that they might just have to face I hope they get a 20 each and the police who were involved
@@ALitScottyB323Aye it's absolutely disgusting bud I'm convinced it was Jodi's brother
I agree it was someone who was psychotic. Its the worst crime of the 21st century? That An innocent man is in jail. I feel strongly going by the evidence it was Jodis brother and the family are protecting him, and that family has blood on their hands.
Lots of respect for Scott! Amazing work! 💕 Free Luke Mitchell!!
Keep it up Scott. Just will prevail.
Showing this commitment is commendable. Great guest and everyone in Scotland who listens to even one podcast on this case knows Luke is innocent. Cheers James.
@Bobo Balde not alleged essays the police actually had the essays and hid them from the defence!!
#justiceforlukemitchell keep at it James I reckon all of Scotland is with you on this 👏👏great effort
I’ve always thought Luke is innocent, I’ve watched and read as much as I can on this case and the police should be ashamed. Poor Luke and his family will never get over this, ever. Scott thank you for doing all that your doing to help Luke. Keep fighting the fight.
This guys straight to the point a love him x
Always thought LM was innocent. A life ruined by a corrupt system. He never stood a chance. Hopefully those involved in LM’s case can get a re-trial asap and the get justice for JJ💔
I always thought Luke Mitchell was innocent .
From the T.V. interview of him and his Mum, on the sofa, my gut reaction was that this boy was not the killer.
What a terrible injustice !
It shocking poor guy in prison for something he never done thats ur corrupted law
You mean the Mother he shared a bedroom with. The Mother who lied about him being at home and who’s neighbours stated seeing this very Mother burning stuff in the garden hours after the murder. Luke’s coat that he was seen wearing the night of the murder at the location of the murder mysteriously went missing (burnt in the garden). Research the case instead of listening to a fame whore on the internet trying to make money off spewing lies about the case.
I was at school with Luke & Jodi, Luke was immediately treated like a killer when he was brought back to school it was under police escort & he was isolated & forced to sit in class by himself this was almost a year before he was arrested. He was condemned from day 1 no chance of a fair trial when you've been convicted in the court of public opinion!
take the opertunity to talk,you never know even a small bit of your info could drop a piece to the puzzle 🙏
I remember you…your cal Hamiltons little cousin..
Your right about the school treatment…ms docherty let that happen..guilty before proven..
Thanks for speaking up..family member here.
@Scott c Forbes I was in Shotts with luke. I asked him outright if he killed her. He told me he didn't and I believed him. I reckon I'm pretty good at spotting lies and I'm convinced he wasn't. I was convinced he never done it just by listening to him. He then gave me a book about miscarriages of justice, which his case featured. I was raging after reading it.
@@scottforbes7970 I personally know at least 30 or 40 people who have met luke inside and every single one of them say he's not capable and that he never killed her ...... my dad said to me around 05/06 that luke would never get out until then at the top who are responsible for this miscarriage are in the ground but that he never did it (dad met luke inside) .....
@scottforbes7970
So happy to see this 🙌
Keep it going Scott!!
The door is well and truly getting kicked in🙏🙏🙏
Hoefully we can see Luke M on the podcast in the future. The miscarriage of justice towards a 14yr old kid who's girlfriend was murdered is heartbreaking. Never mind being accused and having to live being tarred with a brush. Luke must be a very strong man. Total respect to him. He could have his freedom simply by admitting it. Luke would rather die first. No money in the world could buy him. Although that's certainly what him and his family deserve for what they have been put through, and still battling with. Justice for Luke and much respect for highlighting an issue many are still not in the know. Keep the fight going guys. Much Respect. 💪💯
Google the case and the facts, he killed her. This man has stated lies in this podcast.
That’s so sad. That poor lad what kind of life will he have when he gets out His mental health ❤. Your doing good James
The truth has come out, let's go and get those responsible for this unjust conviction.
Poor lad, not only will he be haunted by seeing the most horrific images of his girlfriend but was also robbed of his childhood, utterly heartbreaking.
Absolutely disgusting Donna
@Dava Wilson Certainly is, poor lad and has made his poor mum ill too, cover up as per.
I know it sickens me to the stomach
@C Stewart I believe police knew it wasn't Luke, innocents always pay for their incompetence and cover ups.
Deluded.he is guilty.
This is heartbreaking, for Jodi who lost her life and for Luke also who has his life destroyed also. It’s scary to think could be one of our own children being convicted of a crime they didn’t commit but corrupt police officers and legal teams. Don’t know how them or her family can lay there heads on the pillow at night. Hopefully this podcast can force for the case to be looked into and for the investigation to be opened up again
Well said x
Absolutely nathalie I’ve got a bad feeling he will spend much more years in prison
Who do you think done it? Any I dear?
@Gary lineker nps GAZ lol
@NancyBears what's funny?
Well done James and Scott.. now all that’s needed is for the killer, and accomplices, now men, to own what they did and set Luke free, he’s done long enough of their time.
I think if they are innocent and know what happened they should grass .the grasses are the police's bestfriend's Better than being called out in way they can't control. Ok they lied in court but they can make it right and sleep at night
@@MsBluesmother Absolutely agree, but they wont.
These things happen... they were young and scared. If it was my son who had helped cover-up etc.. i would be encouraging him to do the right thing now... before being caught out
Fair play James. I thought you had gone cold on this subject after speaking to Lukes mom and the lie detector guy. Very interesting subject and #freelukemitchell
This case is a shit show, a high profile guy like yourself James, bringing attention to this case deserves a lot of respect. No many people would go near this. But I was in Polmont when he first came in, I never seen him but heard how he was treated. I was 17,n I'm 35 now, I remember a couple of screws down the work party saying luke should never have been convicted, although only screws it did plant a seed in my head about the case. Now more information just seems to be coming out all the time. Massive respect James for highlighting this case, I'm not your biggest fan tbh, but takes some balls to give this miscarriage of justice attention.
EVERYONE know's the truth now. It freaks me out knowing Luke Was Set Up....
Great interview. I’ve watched this case from the beginning and cannot believe the police have got away with this. 14 year old boy who didn’t fit the norm of society. This is sickening and I still pray he will get out asap. Thanks for a great video and please let people know how we can help him. This reminds me of the USA case of Brendan dassey. No evidence whatsoever it’s frightening. People need to be held accountable. Justice for both kids. There’s a murderer still on the loose.
Well done Scott, a truly sad case but great you have devoted a large part of your life tying to help the lad. I hope you manage to finally get justice. All the best mate
@@scottforbes7970 I think this is a case of police tunnel vision, where they've become fixated on one person early in the case and just doggedly stuck to their man regardless of the fact that there is no sustainable incriminating evidence against him.
Know Scott from back in the day in Edinburgh. Seriously passionate and intelligent man. This interview has made me think. Enough said.
#justiceforluke
#justiceforjodi
We the public will not be silenced until the truth comes out.. WE WILL FIGHT TO CLEAR LUKE’s NAME AND GET JUSTICE FOR JODI..👊🏼
Absolutely outstanding. All I can see from haters of what scott is doing is personal attacks. Not one arguement contradicting what has been said.
How about contradiction of his essay that nobody else saw? The main person being the teacher. How about no dna evidence from jodis nails regarding the deceased man's alleged scratches scott seen? How about the fact he wanted 50k for his story or evidence from a newspaper, to which he still hasn't sued for apparent defamation? Some laywer he is if he can't even clear his own name for that
@@bobobalde7871 Did you actually watch this, or further more watched anything he has said.
@@bobobalde7871 it's ok he has dedicated a whole chapter in his book to the 50k story. You should buy it 😂😂😂
@Bobo Balde you talk pish. If you knew anything you would know that actually the police had and hid the essay from the defence it was titled "no remorse" DNA from 1 hand of jodis nail scrapings came back with NO REPORTABLE RESULTS stop babbling shite you're boring 😴
You were saying about the essay @bobo balde.
Big up Scott for this only guy who really has tried for Luke a remember when this happened don’t stay far from this had it in for Luke from day one
This is your calling James , your job has been keeping this story alive with your massive following , it's a tragic story obviously 1st for jodie lost her life so young , however luke is innocent and deserves his life back for a crime I don't believe he done ... Well done james
Agree, 100%
Ye can see him being on the last part of this doc already 👍🏼
Every time Scott is interviewed we learn something new about this horrendous case. I admire Scott’s unabashed honesty and his fearless endeavour to expose the truth about who was really responsible for killing Jodi. He has proved with out a doubt that this is likely the biggest miscarriage of justice in Scotland. I am so delighted to hear that people in the community are coming forward and tipping off Scott with new information. All I can say now is the net is closing in on the guilty parties! They can run but they cannot hide!
Yeah, he can't hide cause he's already in the jail pal. Love the while fact you think SF is shining a light. Spend a decade blaming his mate until he died so now it's other folks who he suspects......see through charlatans
@@johnrosscampbell6187 who do you mean?
@@johnrosscampbell6187 tut tut Johnny Boy you know fine well Scott wasn’t accusing MK you know he was pointing out that MK wasn’t investigated properly like the rest of them you silly sausage ..you call Scott a charlatan but yet he’s exposed all these lies found out about the police destroying evidence and got it stoped do you realise how daft your comments are 😂
@J S funny not what Mark Kane said.
@@johnrosscampbell6187 they will all get weeded out one by one and nothing you say is gonna stop us
Scott deserves great credit for working tirelessly to show the 🌎 how poor the Scottish Police were in this case.
Two innocent children lost their lives on this sad day.
No evidence to suggest Luke killed the wee lassie. The killers still living free (sadly).
Keep up the hard work Scott and top effort James on keeping this in the public eye.
No forensic evidence to say he’s guilty.
I could listen to Scott aw day.
He's a compulsive liar.
Luke & his family were put in the media, from day one , Jst for the fact she was ment to b meeting him . But she left her family hme with family members. And it amazes me the way the Scottish police hve nvr looked into the family members the way they shld hve , Aswell as checking out other lines of inquiry, and the way they treated the crime scene , What happened to standerd police crime protocols. They were nvr used by the police, n forensic team tht were involved in ths crime scene. As a watched the interviews James has done with different guests, As I was listening 2 the way the police handled the interviews, with the public. Thn the way they interviewed the brother, & the sisters boyfriend, and the others tht shld hve bn looked at , Indepth the way they were doin to a 14 yr old kid, Ths jst assures the way I hve always thought abt the way they treat certain ppl if they fit the criteria of the case there tryn to put to the justice system. ⚖️ , so they got sumone 4 the crime . But the evidence that they put 2gether was unbelievable. The police, n the rest of the criminal team tht worked on ths shld b ashamed of the fact that they made so many mistakes from day one. 🏴💯%
@@jamesmowles6575 she left on her own to meet him and the mitchells used the media but it backfired ob them and now they (luke/corrine) claim they were hounded.i dont think so.
@ghost rider. Am not sure if ur sumone connected to the victims family , ?? But if ur lookin at the same podcasts as I am , U dnt c were ths case has so many mistakes, as well as evidence that was nvr showed to the defence, or the media . If anyone knows anything abt ower justice system , Well they wld like to know more about the way it was put together,!!??
@@jamesmowles6575 why is that according to you luke supporters anyone who thinks he's guilty is a jones 🤔 its ridiculous and makes you look stupid ( which im sure you aren't. Youve been lied to by sandra lean for years
Time there was a full judicial review of this case
Scott Forbes efffn star he,es well clued up big time very streetwise as for yourself James keep up the gr8 work
Great to see Scott doing so well.. friend from a long ago.. go Scott! 😊
Another great podcast James & Scott , the truth will always out ,hopefully sooner than later ..#justiceforluke & Jodi hopefully the media get on this, they played a massive part in convicting Luke after all
Definitely Suzanne I hope he gets justice and gets out
Can't wait for this! Thank u James x
Hopefully Luke gets his retrial ASAP as he's totally 100% Innocent Scott Forbes and Dr Sandra Lean are amazing for what they do.
Good man James ! Law systems stacked against Luke ! Lies against him and his family from the people were meant to trust ! So you got a platform James ! Let’s hope people listen
I got handcuffed and thrown into the back of an unmarked police car by 4 plain clothes coppers while walking to the 24 hour garage one night. Before 12 but after 10 pm. Not too late. Really scary had no idea WHO, WHY or WHAT was happening. Cautioned and locked in a cell under suspicion of a violent robbery, mugging someone basically. Whoever had been robbed had seen me walking to the garage phoned the police and told them it was me that mugged him. Arrested me on way back from garage. Nightmare. I'm no older than 21years of age at that point, and absolutely no criminal convictions or criminal record whatsoever. I was told to attend an IDENTITY PARADE come as you would dress normally, be yourself the detective told me. I was the only one in the line-up styling facial hair! Why? Because stubble, that's why. It's just who I am. The victim picked me out in seconds. I even heard him, from behind a two-way mirror, pick me out "that's him, number 7" he said to the detective. I'll never forget that sinking feeling. I just can't put those feelings into words. "You're looking at 2 years minimum" he said " even with no previous convictions "
After what seemed like forever all charges were dropped. Not enough evidence. My word against his. Those few weeks were Hell and put me in a very very dark place. I wouldn't wish it on anyone.
Thats awful and im glad the charges where dropped against you..And scary thing is you wont be the first and certainly wont be the last 😔 Police curruption needs to stop!! Luke mitchell has been in prison longer than he has been on the outside which is absolutely tragic 💔 Justice for Luke & Jodi ⚖️
Not one single word of this is true
@Seneca Knowledge not 1 single word of what is true ???
@@senecaknowledge2274 eh?? Single word of what,??
This guy knows his stuff Scott keep at it buddy
I have been wondering for ages why the family didn’t want this case re opened with all the doubts about Luke’s guilt because if it was my family member murdered and so much doubt about the killers guilt I would want to make sure if they weren’t the real killer then that would mean the real killer was still free which I would never want but after watching this it makes sense why they wouldn’t want the real killer caught but I hope Jodi and Luke get the justice they deserve x it must have taken a lot of courage to go public with all this but this was one podcast definitely worth hearing xx
BEST PODCAST AVE SEEN ABOUT LUKE MITCHELL, SCOT HAS DONE A FIRST CLASS JOBE ON THIS CASE, WELL DONE ,
Biggest miscarriage of justice ever. Police know the truth that Luke didn’t do it but they won’t let him out because then they would need to admit their wrongdoing and apologise
That's exactly why I think they'll never admit they got it wrong. Too many people in high up positions stand to lose status and perhaps freedom.
Definitely but if Luke’s supporters keep doing protests and that then they will need to do something hopefully he will get out
Agreed. Think people would have more respect if they came out an admitted if they completely fkd this case and rectifyd whatever they could out of the case
Defo mate it makes my blood boil
Lets hope karma
I agree with your theory of what happened Scott. I’ve thought that all along. The interesting thing with this is that I believe that if there is a confession from any of the 4 mentioned, whilst the killer has likely been Joseph, Ferris and Gordon Dickie could be pursued under the joint enterprise law. David Dickie could be done for interfering with a dead body and perverting the course of justice. All 4 of them would be jailed if this comes out. Not to mention the other member’s of Jodi’s family perverting the course of justice aswell.
We still have 3 unknown full dna profiles. That's what is being protected. We need Everyone within 5 miles of Jodi to be submitted to DNA checks. Including police
4ppl cld never ever keep a secret for 20yrs.just wouldn't happen.probably just 1person.
This is shocking and scary! The family knew more information and knew what to say and do 😡 such a shame for that poor girl and that poor boy
Well done james and Scott keep up the great work!!!
God bless Scott and Sandra 🙏🙏
Pmsl
Thanks James!! Go Scott!!
I knew there was controversy over the conviction but I had no idea how deep this ran. I can't say I'm completely convinced but it certainly has opened my mind more to the possibility
Read the court transcripts then come back and spot the lies.
I can’t believe Luke hasn’t just been released conviction quashed and paid millions in damages. Shockingly disgusting
He can't get comp unless the real killer is caught
Can't wait for this! Justice for Luke Mitchell & Jodi Jones!
How would Jodi get justice? Killer ain't been found.
@@geeman.8081 that's what they mean obviously 😆 🤣
👍 Scott and Sandra. 🙏 Luke 22 is a good sign!!
Thanks James for continuing to give this miscarriage exposure
Brilliant from Scott guy speaks so much sense re the actual facts
Hopefully someone who actually knows what really happens has the courage to come forward and help free this young lad and hopefully get the real killer before the courts to face trial
This is scotlands biggest miscarriage of justice ever and it started with 2 14yr old kids 1 dead 1 in jail for 18yrs this has to be spoken about in the public domain imo her brother and 2 guys on moped need looking at badly why they weren’t before is mind blowing
Those 2 moped men can't remember what they were doing between 1700-1800
@@scottforbes7970 that's good
So he will remember his dad giving Jodi sexual advances That 14 year old jodi rejected
I think this was brought to the attention of the police by his father trying to get his story in first
Totally shocking the guys is a nonce
@@scottforbes7970 Excellent interview Scott...well done and good luck moving forward.
Ice cream wars is up there also absolute farce for this boy
@@scottforbes7970 is David Dickie still alive?
When my then boyfriend was 16 in Polmont I was up visiting him and Luke Mitchell was sitting right on the next table from us and when the visiting time was up he had to be taking back to his cell first and there was a commotion when he got up. Always remember that back then I was just want to get out of there asap as I was only 15 and like you said we all thought he did it as well then but as I looked back on the case when I got older I strongly believed how innocent Luke actually is. He deserves a retrial now in this day in age definitely in my opinion.
There's no way that coerced "evidence" made under duress without legal representation should have been admitted to court. Ever. Case closed.
Looking forward to this
The way she was killed- the frenzied attack. Look up how criminologists give their opinions on this.. it’s usually a sustained attack and it’s PERSONAL! Meaning, someone they knew done it. Luke had never been violent towards Jodie but her brother had.. plus the folding of the clothes and putting the socks back on shows someone showing empathy towards her I fully believe it’s been her brother killed her and has been allowed to hide under the guise of mental health issues.
None of that is True.
@@bethryan9077 really??
@@bethryan9077 you need to seriously stay off the meth …what’s not true enlighten us
Scott/James, very informative, I have been looking forward to this for ages. Have been following this story for many years , I believe he's innocent but I can't understand why jodis family have never spoken out especially after various interviews over the years or why luke is still in jail if he didn't do it, that continues to confuse me over the years. Could listen to you all day Scott your very passionate about getting justice. Great work guys ❤️x
❤️❤️
They haven’t spoken out in defence of him because they fully believe he was involved in it I think they where all involved in it but Mitchell took the brunt of it he’s in way innocent I can you tell you get better specs ya mutant
@@rf8620 eh? 🤣
@@rf8620 So your saying LM was involved?
When did Scott Forbes take mark cain to the police ?-if hes came to his house the day after the murder with scratches on face and no explanation of how he got them?-he says he picked him up from college?-surely he would have reported him right away?its a wee lassies murder in a relatively small area?