Why Manipur's History is Crucial to Understand its Conflict | Flashback with Palki Sharma
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 30 มิ.ย. 2023
- Why Manipur's History is Crucial to Understand its Conflict | Flashback with Palki Sharma
If you follow the news, chances are you must have seen something about Manipur. There's violence, death, arson and ethnic violence. Two communities in Manipur are locked in a conflict, the Kukis and Meiteis. But what explains this bad blood? How is Manipur's history crucial to understand this conflict? Palki Sharma tells you on this episode of Flashback.
Firstpost | World News | Latest News | Manipur | Manipur Violence | Manipur Tensions | Manipur Riots | Northeast India
#firstpost #worldnews #latestnews #manipur #meiteis #kukis
Firstpost is an Indian news and media website. Get all the incisive opinions, in-depth analyses and other visual stories that matter to you and the world right here on this channel.
Subscribe to Firstpost channel and press the bell icon to get notified when we go live.
/ @firstpost
Follow Firstpost on Instagram:
/ firstpost
Follow Firstpost on Facebook:
/ firstpostin
Follow Firstpost on Twitter:
/ firstpost
Do you think Manipur's history is crucial to understand its conflict? Comment below and tell us.
Yes,the correct history.
Shame on you! Palki.. you're just like the Godi media. Your reports are not factual.
Absolutely Yes
Very complex, but one thing is clear... All who came from Burma must be sent back... No Indian nationality.
Yes. The other point is: how many disputes/conflicts have occurred in carious parts of India becuase some group of peple want a downgrade of heir caste/ethnicity status to get more official jobs? Or is ths question too sensitive to ask?
Even in nagaland , Manipur and Assam history . Its written that kuki are brought by British from outside countiries (Iseral and Mynmare).
The kuki are isreal people
🇲🇲 I hope Meitei people Be safe, be safe.I am Burmese but I am related to Meitei(ကသည်း). There are meitei community in Myanmar, Mandalay,Amarapura city. My great grandfather was a Meitei. Meitei people from Myanma The Meitei royal families and artisans were brought over by the Burmese.
why can't you call back meitei people into your country , if they are yours
I am an meitei and I really want to visit mayanmar idk I feel connected to that place somehow
@@vetrugrahavasi5404 Meitei people have lived in Manipur from history recorded but kukis originally were brought in from Myanmar.
Call back all meitei refugees in India
As always, lies after lies without any backing by facts.
Life lesson: Unity is strength 💪
When there is no unity, this is what happens.. Stay united my lovely friends of Manipur.. Jai Hind 🇮🇳
It's not about the Kokis and Meiteis. All it takes, is for someone or a small group in high places, to poke the tribes and whisper into their ears. That whisper is the smoke, that causes the fires to burn.
I’m a Meitei and Thank you for explaining it the way it should be. I don’t agree all the kukis are refugees but the native kuki should help identify the immigrants kuki to stop this narco terrorism.
Meitei should also share power and development to hilly people.
Holding all powers and now trying to gain hilly lands is selfish and undemocratic.
@@Mr66Danzo power has been equally shared among all in india. Kukis have been represented by their elected MLAs in legislative assembly, and some of them are even ministers. If you think the nos of MLAs are less then you should demand for delimilitation of constituencies. All the developmental works are responsible by those elected MLAs... you can't blame meiteis for everything....you should questions your MLAs too for the whatever funds allocated are fully utilized for your own areas development or not. I am sure that 90% of hill MLAs built their houses in Imphal Valley and never bothered about development of the hills. Those MLAs are responsible for everything including the development of hill areas.
i dntknow what happen meitei people think that only kuki are dealing in drugs and immigrants, even meeitei are also immigrants from myanmar and the real drug dealers are meitei💯
@@ZG-bb4ngmeetei r illegal immigrants from Myanmar?! Lmao 😂🤣😹 boy the original home of meetei people is manipur that's y every meetei that resides outside manipur called manipur is their homeland while none of the kuki called manipur as their homeland!!
अभी क्या हालात हैं मणिपुर मे?
My GOD! I love how she summarized centuries old historical accounts. This is a lesson on summarizing a book effectively.
You watch a 7 minute video, go do some research there’s a lot wrong with the history
@thangkhual4769 Yes, I agree.
*Palki Sharma Upadhyay claims that Meitei occupy 10% of Manipur and Kukis occupy 90% . She speaks out of ignorance. 67% of Manipur is classed forests, so the inhabitable hills is no more than 23% occupied by Nagas and Kukis*
@@adnanrashtogi4553 guess you're right. Meiti vigilante groups keep repeating partial data to convey how cramped they are in small valley space.
@@adnanrashtogi4553 guess you're right. Meiti vigilante groups keep repeating partial data to convey how cramped they are in small valley space.
I am from Andhra Pradesh, India. The history is really complicated here. It is definitely not super difficult to solve the issue too.
Firstly, stop further kuki insurgency and treat native kukis like manipuris.
Treat all three sorts equally and assure the states development collectively.
Wow how simple.. all this by watching an 8min video.
@@jagadeeshgurana4490 Nobody is damn seriously trying to solve the issue. Trust me. If they try, they can. People's mentality there is not so good. The government should focus on convincing ppl.
Lpp
It
Lp lol l
L0o
0p
L
@@jagadeeshgurana4490Trust him, he's an armchair politician who can solve tensions that has lasted for decades.
@@nadiyaveman5576 if your mentality is good thats more than enough.my dear.
it would be fascinating and interesting if they include the history of northeast(each and every state) in our textbooks for our future generation
The books never go beyond the walls of Agra..😂😂😂
If changes are brought people will call them facism
Thank you palki as a meitei i feel happy for covering the history of manipur. N to all kukis and naga bro n sister, this is my heartfelt comment. I grew up loving your culture..dress cuisine everything. I have friends from all community living in manipur. Because of this current issue, my friends got distant from me n this is really sad fr me as I hv considered them as my dear ones which I wanna cherish fr all my life. The situation was all played by the people in power whether it's by politicians, narco mafias, etc. N we innocent from all community are suffering. I cried thinking about our future. Wht will happen fr people like us who genuinely love all community. Lets not be in the game played by stupid elders who drive fr power from all community
Atleast some meiteis like you are not radicalized by the communal cm of manipur
People should take caution when the politicians have motives …… , This scale of conflict and violence is not possible without political involvement, …..
@@danielkipgen3920 u also seem not radicalized by ur kuki terrorists
It should be the common spirit!
Hope kuki brothers realise that living together with love is the only solution....separate administration is evil dream of some powerful poppy drug lords
Protecting manipur from illegal immigrants from myanmar is very necessary for the central govt. and state government.
Yes
True..Illegal immigrants shouldn't be allowed at all.
Be very careful my meitei brothers.. You are just a product of thai and bengali.. The zos are the original inhabitants of the land between india and thailand. Once you unite us by your pure hatred.. You will taste your own medicine.. 2 million in the imphal valley doesn't make you a majority. We are 6 million in numbers and scattered everywhere. Pray that your lord will save you
And illegal immigrants comes from all tribes, meitei,naga, mizo, hmar, paite etc2 and not entirely kuki tribe. The central government should take strict action to this and not put the power to the State government particularly Manipur meitei CM(BIREN) in this case who entirely seems to see that illegal immigrants only comes from the kuki tribe
@@zalenclashers1142 Fuck the kukis go to your homeland of myanmaar and do rice farming 😂😂😂😂
Finally! Atlast somebody has bothered to read the HISTORY and make an effort to understand the complex ways in which identities are formed and the baggage of past that they carry in them. A glossy reporting with superficial and prejudiced 'expert opinions' that we see on TV is not just vulgar but also causes more damage. A big THANK YOU to you Palki and your team for the efforts you all have put in.👍🙏
Well researched and well presented! As much as the history of Manipur is complicated, to find peace among the communities at this time also needs hard work and patience from all communities. If there continues to be blaming and fighting each other, no community or tribe will enjoy peace and progress no matter how great the history was. You have to build peace for the present and the future.
Staying in Manipur for 7 years the thing I came to know about Meeteis and Kuki is that
Meetei people are the proudest people i know, they're pride is second to none
Kukis on the other hand are the most stubborn people to ever walk on this earth
What happens when an unstoppable force meets an immovable object?
Wtf 😆😆😆😆😆😆😆
The current situation in Manipur?
We knows meetei hates kukis
😂😂😂
@@Vuite1985 I am not talking about the current situation or anything. I was just talking about their characters,
I called them stubborn because say the smallest Kuki guy was fighting with a bigger boy, even though it was sure that he would get beaten up, the small kuki guy never backed down and fought,you can call it hard headed or stubborn
Many other examples are there
That's why reservation should be based on economic index not on tribe or clans . Many people in India enjoying such reservations .
India’s opposition parties are creating unrest right before election. They did it in Delhi and Karnataka
So, thousand years of oppression should be forgotten?
Also if that's the case anyone mentioning their 'caste'/jat should be jailed/punished
@@JS002 oppression!!! U are saying minority oppressed the majority!!! That doesn't make any sense. Lol
@@Ree-zi7rl ofcourse. Anyone who discriminate others on the basis of caste,creed should be punished
OMG, the way you interpret the history is just so fantastic. Brief but covering all the important points..♥️♥️ wish I had a teacher's and college lectures like you.. m starting to fall for you 🤭🤭
iam from manipur and this is 100%true channal like this deserve real support
Palki's explanation was truly impressive. She conducted thorough research and effectively presented the real history of Manipur. Her summary was concise and easily understandable.
She only speaks the script given to her!!!
Read the script sent by political papa
Some are true yet some are not.She didnt speak about the agreement about the meitei king chandrakirti singh and The kuki king sumkam
you are just her fan boy
@@dipsy241How about you?
Thanku Palki Sharma for giving such a fair unbiased analysis on Manipur Conflict😇Ur 7 minutes analysis is much better than any report on Manipur conflict❤
Yes.
Yes
No.
But it is hardly accurate for all the 3 communities involved. Nice to the ears though
@@OneHillsit’s accurate. Sorry, Kuki University graduate.
Wonderful History Lesson !! (I do understand that the actual history would be much more complex ... but it was great gist in just 7 minutes). Even as an Indian, I had absolutely no clue of what's going on in the N.East states. Our history books (Delhi's CBSE board) never even mention them.
That’s why NE people always says “we are ignorant”. Indian History cover only the mainland and some other parts of Pakistan. UPSC exam is more difficult for the NE people, because the History is new for us
India has a curse, violence & killing of innocent lives r a daily scene in this land of fakirs The half naked fakirs Mohandas karamchand Gandhi preached non violence, but sadly he died a violent death in the hands of his fellow Indian naturam godse,. he didn't get 2 see indepent India which he fought against the mighty British empire, Gandhi should have given the job of fighting the British 2 Netaji Subash Chandra Bose who single handedly created the INA(Indian national army) Subash was highly respected by the Germans & japanese govt for his fighting & negotiating skills, because of babujis blunder, India today is fragmented, when India got Independence the PM's post should right fully gone 2 Sardarji Vallabhai patel here again the old man intervened & recommend the fragile Nehru who was ineffective as leader of a new nation, if only Sardarji would have been at the helm Kashmir would not have been in control by the oaks, MOTHER INDIA TODAY IS A NATION DIVIDED BY CAST CREED, & NEVER ENDING VIOLENCE (sick! 2 say the idiotic corrupted politicians & the foolish cinema crazy Indians who idolise the cinema stars in a semigod manner& still utter mother India & Jai hind)
Yeah I heard a lot of Muhammed, Aurangazeb and Shah Jahans in my history classes.
After I left college I am leaning about Lachit Borphukan, Rani Gaidinlu etc
Thanks to JL NEHRU who gave academics to be written by leftist historian, who were not at all committed to BHARAT or its glorious past. Thanks to MOULANA ABDUL AZAD too, our 1st Education Minister .😬
Meitei history is very complex. Very true. North Indian are treated as 4thclass citizens in India's Manipur. The only problem that most Meiteis have is they hate every other community. Every one living in Manipur knows that. May God give peace of mind to them and to Kuki also to stop this madness.
I knew a Meitei person once. He used to tell stories how these people hate other communities like Naga. He also admitted that he himself hates Naga 💀
@@fishyfish6510thats his own opinion due to his personal reasons.
Only some people are rude towards North Indian people.
The other way around of your statement can also be said. Meeteis are treated as 4th class citizen in North India. North Indians hate each and every community of north-east, calling us Chinese, non-Indians, Nepalis, etc. and often harassing our people.
I really respect how Palki presented this whole issue without taking any sides, be it Kuki, Nagas, or Meiteis. This is how neutral and fair journalism should be. Approaching things holistically with historical facts.
Well she didn’t research the kuki-chin migration, the arrows are wrong and the dates, the whole thing essentially was made up after the Anglo-kuki war 1919
@@thangkhual4769 Yes, but she was just showing the earlier history and more so she briefly covered it with key points without being biased and she even said that whole issue is much complicated than what it seems
@@JayC0325 what she said was a re-writing of history after the Kuki had conflict with the British in 1917-1919, also her miss representation of history will cause more problems so it’s critical they correct themselves
Kalki read more books and try to find the Kiki country and please speak about that one day
Not a word about the PM or the CM …
Truth cannot be hidden. Thanks for revealing the history
Your lesson in history is a 7 minute TH-cam video, go do some actual research
Your listening fake news bro. She don't know anything about Manipur
Sounds kooky to me !
It's always a good idea to get to know more about history from 3 or more sources.
News are not 100% accurate. Some r biased
@@ok00 did you skip history classes bro ?
very well presented, i am meitei and i was not expecting that you would include Pakhangba in the story, it is very accurate and thank you so much for that. god bless you
Thanks for explaining the complicated situation in Manipur. I guess very few news anchors themselves know the situation so well.
Meiteis already have SC OBC EWS General quotas,why ST now?
What's that general quotas is there anything, & why not ST if not ST then we need a law that protect valley from tribals.
The crisis is not related with ST and Christianity. Do not play victim cards.
@@sapam855 as a fellow indian, just curious? Who to protect valleys from? In india everyone has the right to live or work in whichever state or region they want
I strongly feel the reservation systems in our country require thoughtful reform or reconsideration, as there are concerns about certain negative aspects associated with them. By prioritizing merit-based opportunities, we can foster a more progressive and competitive society, promoting healthy growth and development. My heart goes to everyone in Manipur (Both Meitei and Kuki) who have lost their loved ones and livelihood. I wish the conflicts ends for good and peace prevails in the region soon. - Indian from Tamilnadu
It's foolhardy on your part to rake up a controversial and well settled issue ,unrelated to the current burning topic. Learn to look beyond your tunnel vision.
@@nrg1323 What's irrelevant? Do enlighten me.
Dear Needesh
Please be informed that reservation started 100s of year ago in education and administration for a select group of so called divinely separate particular community in India. To set this diabolical scheme in perpetuation modern day reservation system was initiated in 1952.
If you are sincere about reforming the reservation policy, start with the first one. But I warn you in advance, you may have to leave India just to save your life.
Hope you'll read between the lines and save your life rather than destroying your life.
@@ddaadmndarjeeling6500 I can read between your lines, yes. It's sad to see how you have to warn me about how I shouldn't destroy my life. Thanks!
@@NidheeshGopalanthe problem is far beyond your comprehension
People are giving so many angles .. Thanku fr the explanation, ...
Thank you Pallaki for presenting your valuable explanation regarding the true history of Manipur specially the community of Meitei from a news channel like yours.I do hope in future you will bring true news and with the help of your news the whole world would be able to know who the real indigenous people are. Several kings only from the Meitei community used to rule Manipur in early days and now we have been shown in a wrong way in front of the whole world through some media. After having merged with India, our Meitei community represents India in the field of sports, arts and culture and always associate with the nation in the field of education also.We don't go against the nation. Different people from different states of our country have been living happily and peacefully in Imphal valley with Meitei community for many years and we still want peace. Once again thank you for your LOVELY PRESENTATION.... May God Bless You always.
In Meghalaya mostly in parts of plain belt areas of Garo hills, illegal bangladeshi immigrants & influx is going on. Meghalaya needs Inner Line Permit (ILP), & Meghalaya Resident Safety and Security Act 2016. We need to protect out land & state from foreign invaders. We don't want next Manipur like situations in Meghalaya. 🙏
This 8 minutes is much better than whole 1 hour longs videos of all channels put together😅
Very rightly said ..... moments like this test our democracy and union
It is really sad what is actually happening now..burning and riots..
We pray for the people of Manipur,India🙏
*WE INDIANS WANT PEACE IN MANIPUR ASAP*
Palki's report is sufficient to understand whole issue
So true
Read history yourself. She just told you the Meitei side of story.
What’s the story of the Kukis side?
@@awesomely9658what’s your written record?
This is a false history.
This has been insightful and 100% yes History is always important
Great explanation! Thank you!
Amazing way to explain how things unfolded
All I want to say plz plz plz tight up the borders at eastern regions. Buit solid borders with Bangladesh and mayanmar. A big population of Rohingyas, Bangladeshis, Burmese have managed to entered Indian land. Illigally they get the pan,voter and aadhar cards too ... Some politicians even supplying them to increase vote bank. We want NRC and CAA. My State West Bengal is under threat demography is changing significantly. Rohingyas, Bangladeshis have entered and entering in India. Its a sequrity threats. 🙏
@@jafferahamed1945 India can give entry to anybody but not Muslims because they have their countries Bangladesh and Pakistan. If they still want India why they even created these two countries? We are ready for tribal people or any oppressed minority. We are for them but no to robingyas, Our culture and religion is totally different, it will create riots in India. It's good for them they live in their land we live on ours peacefully.
@@jafferahamed1945 of course, India made for hindus. But not for rohingyas. If refugee tribal migrants want to live then they act like refugees not like home owner.
@@jafferahamed1945what u don't know don't even comment. Tribal groups and the backward classes people from Bangladesh already get sheltered in India. Mizoram is hosting a large no of refugees of the tribals ... And the concept of tribals in India and in America is completely different. Being non tribals doesn't mean they are not Indian.
*Palki Sharma Upadhyay claims that Meitei occupy 10% of Manipur and Kukis occupy 90% . She speaks out of ignorance. 67% of Manipur is classed forests, so the inhabitable hills is no more than 23% occupied by Nagas and Kukis*
ALL BECAUSE OF THE WEAKEST GOVERNMENT AND BORDER ARMIES WHO FAILED TOTALY TO PROTECK THEIR CITIZEN ,AND MILLIOND OF TRAITOR POLITICIAN ARE BEHIND THIS TRAGEDY
Let me add a few facts:
The population of kuki was 1% in 1901,the number of kuki Villages from 1969 to 2023 increased from 164 to 460 in chandel,68 to 326 in tengnoupal,179 to 721 in kangpokpi,116 to 146 in tamenglong,etc
Kuki had war with naga in 1992,with paite in 1997,they are fighting war in myanmar and Bangladesh too(they are peaceful people).. period
Excellent short and deep explanation over the origin of the conflict of Manipur. Thanks.
Hi palki I have been your follower Since wion or Gravitas
Thanks for this episode
I am a meitei and I am proud you cover this today
Please dig in furthermore and bring justice and normalcy to these people and let the world know the real problem of manipur
It's upto people like you who can
guide the entire planet the real reason for the issue and please let us not be separated from India, we want to be lived as Indians
@@arunkumarmangangplease share this report
Really informative👍Thank you👍
Fabulous Report..❤
Eye opened..🙏
Thank you so much palki for covering the violence in Manipur,
Truth is comming soon long live manipur
Yaifare ❤️
Yaifare…..
The sad part about the situation in Manipur is that even if this conflict dies down, there will be another flare ups in the future. The ethnic division is too deep rooted.
@@86kbp western miscreants ? Who are they ?
*Palki Sharma Upadhyay claims that Meitei occupy 10% of Manipur and Kukis occupy 90% . She speaks out of ignorance. 67% of Manipur is classed forests, so the inhabitable hills is no more than 23% occupied by Nagas and Kukis*
@@adnanrashtogi4553same fake narrative again
@@okji30709 you e.....diot northeast has the highest % of forest cover , over 50% , so do you expect people to live in forests like animals ???
@@adnanrashtogi4553 northeast has got huge forest cover,that's true...
But the percentage which was shown isn't true
Saint Rampal Ji Maharaj Ji has established peace and harmony in the whole world and by giving true devotion, we have come to show the path of salvation to humans, taking name initiation and doing our welfare
संत रामपाल जी महाराज जी का उद्देश्य भारत को सोने की चिड़िया बनाने का है। जहाँ सर्व धर्म, जाति के लोग प्रेम, भाईचारे के साथ रहें, जहाँ सभी सुखी रहें, सबको समान न्याय मिले, जहाँ किसी का शोषण न हो।
After going through hours long videos I can say it was perfect summary of the topic.
Just wow
Why you didn't mentioned about the Kukis who fought against the British during 1917 to 1919, Anglo Kuki war
Because there was no any Anglo kuki war neither in British record nor in Indian record accept it...only some group of kuki trying to create their history and innocent kukis are believing..
Because there was no such event 😂
Because it never happen 😅
It was a rebellion and she did mention about it
Kukis are cook and coolie for britisher foreigner in manipur.. When do they fought against british.. You are joking..😂😂😂
This is a good elaboration and gives a comprehensive pic of what is going on in Manipur. There are several factors that went wrong, let alone the impact of colonialism, especially the mindset of divide and rule. The important thing is many communities in India need healing. Acknowledging the problem in the first place is important and no political mudslinging. We can not change the past but definitely make an effort to look forward. The solution must come from the people of Manipur that may satisfy all the communities in peace and harmony.
Your lesson in history is a 7 minute video, go do some actual research, it’s good for the soul too
@@thangkhual4769
And you stop replying the same thing in every comment.
@@warrioryuvraj4311 I literally trying to get people informed, of course I am gonna reach everyone I can, think before you comment words that don’t help anyone
@@thangkhual4769 You can comment about this. NVM
Its alright
Very clear and concise. Kuki illegal immigrants from Myanmar are threat to Manipur and to India as a whole. This is National security issue now as majority are militants and waging war against India and to realize their so called dreamland. Govt of India sud take this seriously and take action before it's too late. #savemanipur
Sitting in the comforts away from Manipur one can easily say illegal immigrants from Mayanmar. First should understand that all Kuki tribes were spread out when there was no demarcation. These tribes have ties with their folks across the border and naturally they do visit to meet their folks across the border for cultural and other gatherings. It is either ways. Kukis from India too cross the border which is quite porus .
@@rajendrababu1593 i m manipuri from Imphal if you dont know where i m from. And to be precise, the fight is now a state vs Narco terrorism infecting like a virus in the region. Do you know much drugs worth getting caught in last 3 years and poppy plantation in Churchandpur and Kangpokpi in particular. I don't want to educate you about Manipur and the way how kuki refugees and Militants destroyed the rich culture. Better you do some research before randomly commenting on someone... #peace
You don't know the reality. Stop all your bulshit. See now what you have done to the tribals, total separation. That's what you wanted. That's what the Manipur and ruling centre govt. wanted. Shame on your narco- terrorism.
@@theSaviour213u r talking as if only Kukis r involve in narcoterrorism and ur community don't.if kukis cultivate poppy, then who r buyers or who r Incentiving them to cultivate more?. Mera bas chale toh want to erase whole manipur and mizoram from our neighborhood. Every drug supplies r coming from these two states through Assam to our state and destroying life of our young people.
Thanks very much for this informative video. Keep up the good work!
Oh god! The Kashmir conflict seems fairly simple compared to this complex situation in the North East. I hope all three communities reach a mutual understanding and stop violence. Even the army cannot do anything now as they are using women and children as human shields.
The marriage between meiteis, nagas and kukis into one administrative unit was arranged or forced by the Britisher and later solemned by Inidan Union.
Now, this forced union is facing tremendous deferences within them and separation seems to be the only option. So, let the present state of manipur trifurcated into three states, each for Meiteis, Nagas and Kukis. And let them do whatever they want to do in their own state. Then....
The meiteis will be allowed to live wherever they want in their own state. They can pursue ST demand without any resistance within.
The Nagas and Kukis will enjoy full control of their land and polity. They can also go for greater Nagaland or Mizoram without any resistance.
All will be happy....win-win for all😊
U want to grab lands.
That's a right point but these meitei are born liars not their land but still trying to claim theirs by telling liars. Soon they will loss the power of CM.
These r the persuade for power in land lock topography n commerce let's not compair to very old tiny advance Country.
Excellent talks.
Hats off!
Very well explained. Great narration as always.
Manipur's past history + present condition: a very good synopsis well presented in nutshell. Thanks 🙏
7 minutes and 46 seconds. Worth watching. I think Palki Sharma should debate with those West Media who are giving it a religion conflict outlook.
Tell that to the people who go with 'Hindu khatre me hein'
First of all the conflict isn’t about religion, and secondly she didn’t study kuki-chin history, if she did she would know the Hmar reached modern day india in the 1600s
*Palki Sharma Upadhyay claims that Meitei occupy 10% of Manipur and Kukis occupy 90% . She speaks out of ignorance. 67% of Manipur is classed forests, so the inhabitable hills is no more than 23% occupied by Nagas and Kukis*
@@Ree-zi7rlabhramic faiths are fascist and political ideologies...idol worship, polytheism, etc are classified as demon worship to justify their attacks...Hindu will always be khatre mein from these fascist expansionist ideologies.
Well detailed. Thanks
Explained the issue very well, this has to be solved with deep future insight
KUKI 90% and Meitei 10% then Where do Naga Stays? 🤣
Good question 😂
This is just a part of victim card
Focus is on Kuki & Meitei not Kuki, Naga & Meitei.
Sigh!
Common sense left the chat.
Guess Quota system should be abolished, it had made people dumber.
She said they live in the hills . Try to read between the lines morons
@@KangleiCha_nurafocus was wrong ! Guess you want to be st too 😂
Superb analysis
The aim of Sant Rampal Ji Maharaj Ji is to make India a golden bird. Where people of all religions and castes live with love and brotherhood, where everyone is happy, everyone gets equal justice, where no one is exploited
Excellently explained by Palki🎉. Great job.
Excellent analysis as always 👍🏻👌🏽
Thank you Palki Sharma for the beautiful compilation of facts.
Just one correctionr: Historical rebelling by tribes against Meitei Kings cannot negate the fact that they were under Manipur kingdom for centuries as proven by several centuries old maps of Manipur in gazettes of India, Myanmar and Britain.
Missing: You missed the geopolitical games played by India and other regional countries as one of the possible factors of the ethnic conflicts in the state.
You king didn’t administer the Zo villages so he has no claim over it, also the geo political game is still happening and meitei will be left with their valley
@RajkumarSingh-hw9uk
Nagas were headhunters and for a reason...Wild and Barbarians...
And in what form were they under the Manipur Kingdom as you claim to be....There is not one iota of cultural influence or food habits from the Meiteis..
The Nagas are the Tribe even the Britishers were apprehensive of venturing their territories. ....,😌
I love History. Thank you 'FirstPost'
Kudos to your explanations. At par with excellence.
Yes, you can indeed blame one factor. And that's the British Empire is to blame.
What the British did to India and Cyprus Greece and Australia and Africa and China and Asia and Europe is unforgivable and should never be forgotten, indeed.
Britain should be forced to give back the trillions of dollars and other peoples cultural identity artifacts they looted and leave Cyprus Greece too.
manipur has always been a hotbed of conflicts and its always the people of manipur who have been suffering
Thank you Palki for bringing this episode which is requires in this present crisis. You have presented so well❤, hope people will understand the root cause of this crisis. Kt seems some people misunderstood about the percentage of land mentioned. What she means is kuki live in hills which is 90 percent of land.
Yes correct
Wow I think this Place Manipur, is mixture of Multi Ethnic Groups. Each Claiming Group can be Called Separately and Asked to Define their Specific Problem Pros and Cons.Then a Central Line can be drawn to connect them to India's Mainstream . May take time but this seems to be only alternative. jai Hind Jai Bharat.
Kuki people and ZO ‘s generation were STARTED from CHINA to North Burma to North west BURMA to MIZORAM and lived at Manipur border and KABAW (myanmar).
Dear Palki, we really appreciate the analysis and issues you raise through your show. It's much needed and helpful for many people. Request you to also highlight the issue of thousand of families suffering due to corruption in real estate. Homeless and paying EMIs to banks and NBFCs . Supertech and Indiabulls in my case and there are many other
Palki you have given wrong statistics. The kukis(&Zomis) are around 17%, the Nagas around 24% i.e. 41% tribals in total living in the hills. The rest are meitei speaking population 53%(ethnic meiteis 46% and meitei muslims 7%). These figures are accordingto the 2011 census.
Meitei wants to be in ST list just to protect the Imphal valley land and whole state will be a schedule land, so that every community in the State can settle anywhere they like to settle whether in Hills or valley. Right now valley people can't settle in hills areas but hills people can settle to valley areas. So as a people of the state meitei wants to be live in equally distributed areas not restricted only in valley areas.
Meitei have OBC SC and EWS reservations. What about those reservations ?
@@sheelasundaram784do obc and ews protect our lands?
@@sheelasundaram784 it's not about job employees....we can compete exam without any of those ....we want valley land to be protected.
@@user-xe3ow5zo2cit's the same as u going n buying land in delhi but if delhites starts coming n wanting to settle n buy land Wil the manipuris feel secure..they Wil feel insecure saying they got all the privileges in delhi ..y want to come to delhi to grab land..won't u protest if that's the case right.. so the same thing is going on here
@@dgjin4871 Why are you asking this question to Meetei only? You can ask same question to the Kukis, Naga, and other ST communities.
Thank you Palki mam. I always admire yoor work. I'm from Manipur and have learned so much about my own state now
*Palki Sharma Upadhyay claims that Meitei occupy 10% of Manipur and Kukis occupy 90% . She speaks out of ignorance. 67% of Manipur is classed forests, so the inhabitable hills is no more than 23% occupied by Nagas and Kukis*
@adnanrashtogi4553
Those uninhibited areas can be inhabited legally by Kukis but not by Meteis so the uninhabited areas belongs to Kukis.
@@ashash9986 , you are again confusing issues, within hilly areas earmarked for tribes, it is still prohibited for anyone to live in designated forest areas as per forest act.
Mainland Indians don't know Manipur had its written Constitution adopted in 1947 and a council of ministers headed by captain Priyobrata. Manipur merged with India on 21 Sep 1949 with a written agreement. India adopted her Constitution on 26 Jan 1950. The chief commissioner of then undivided British Assam Mr Quinton and other four British officers were executed in Imphal by Meitei in 1891.
Modern Polo is a gift of Meitei people to the whole world. Indian classical dance Rasleela is another contribution. Manipuri language, the lingua franca of the state, has its own written scripnt.
Bollywood Hindi film's popular music director Sachin Dev Burman was born to a Manipuri Meitei lady named Sanasam Nirmala. (SDB's father Nabadwipchandra Dev Burman was also born to a Manipuri Meitei lady named Keisam Jatiswari who was one of the queens of Tripura King Ishan Chandra Manikya who ruled during 1849-1862. SDB's mother and grandmother both were Meitei ladies. Almost all Hindi film songs of Dev Anand were composed by SDB).
Apart from many medallists in Olympic and Asian Games, out of 634 athletes India will be sending to 2023 Asian Games in China, 42 players are from Manipur and Meitei except two or three other brothers.
dear 'Rasleela' is a part of katthak dance form that originated in state of Uttar Pradesh.
Kattak's part is 'Rasleela' a dance form, from Uttarpradesh state. But I know Manipur needs peace.
First time some one mentioned our religion 😭😭 proud to be sanamahism . But sadly this religion is dying with the adoption of hindusim 💔💔
bro what about christianity
i think someone should bring back sanamahism
are there people following sanamahism
Anchor BIAS for the Kukis is very evident.
May God save the Christians of Manipur from the hndutva mindset ,evident in the program .Lord save churches and Christians and the Kuki community,ameen.
Manipur needs liberation ❤
Short and to the point , thank you for being our voice 🙏
Thank u so much Palki madam 🙏🙏I was feeling so helpless n sad to see all the negative news. With ur 8 min video at least now I know the story behind the story Hope all people realize we all share the same country n future together n resolve issues peacefully by putting all people in front of leadership interests 🙏🙏
Nicely narrated and explained. Such a complicated situation and the opposition only wants to pour fuel into the burning fire. If they were so wise, why don’t they place a solution in bullet points so that Modi could follow it and bring peace to Manipur.
Good reporting 👍...
Thank you for covering this so well
Northeast has always been like that step child you dont love yet you cant let go
I hope some things change
I have faced ignorance from rest of India my entire life
But i am hoping it changes
I am hoping this clash ends
Amen❤️
Well addressed by Ms Palki as usual .
Could understand the issues clearly .Thanks a lot.
Indeed it is true like Ms.Palki said that is crucial to understand Manipur's history to understand the conflict.
For millennia Manipur was inhabited by the Mieties and the different Naga tribes. The Kukis as rightly pointed by Ms. Palki were brought in by the Britishers as late as the 1840s.Although the understanding and agreement of bringing in the Kukis from the Chin area of present day Myanmar into Manipur by the Bristishers could have been earlier than that of the 1840s.From a few villages, a mere trickle to today forming 28% to 30% of the population even out numbering the many local indigenous tribes is a perplexing reality.
We've three communities, three Insurgencies and their loyalties well all of them hate each other😂nice quotes❤
*Palki Sharma Upadhyay claims that Meitei occupy 10% of Manipur and Kukis occupy 90% . She speaks out of ignorance. 67% of Manipur is classed forests, so the inhabitable hills is no more than 23% occupied by Nagas and Kukis*
@@adnanrashtogi4553Do you know that more than 80% of the hilly areas is mostly likely inhabitable.
@@Rahulits85e68hlxigi , if State govt records show that a area is forest , then there cannot be a claim that it's inhabitable . Forest Act expressly prohibits habitation inside a forest area .
@@adnanrashtogi4553 The govts action in the legislation domain always has a ulterior motive,when the forest reserved were legislate why didn't the govt took consultation from the standing committee of the HACs which is an only institution estd. to protect the rights of the tribals. The assembly legislate any resolution whether it is something that would benefit the kuki or meiteis or hamper their rights,the tribals particularly stood no chance to oppose any bills that is being pass by the meiteis dominant assembly. If u look back at the past few year,most ulteration eminate out of from successive ethnic hatred that develops over the years.Let me cite some example,b4 the this unwanted war,there is case where the RIMs reservation was oppose by the meitei community even after they made an consensus with the central govt. The meiteis occupy more than 50% of the total jobs in the state but then they oppose a tiny fraction of the reservation for the tribals. And there are many others instances . Years after a year there has been many cases that fuel the communal mindset. I would like to share my view for the future, i say it wouldnt be possible to let two ethnic community settle in harmony after much altercation that heighten up to killing infants and old age persons.
Unfortunately Govts previously ( All partys) failed in handling the problem with diplomacy , did not define the border with Burma. Now is the time to sit with the people & resove it amicabally.
One of the best and lucid coverages!
Kudos, very well narrated, thanks a lot Palki, ❤ from Malaysia
I was always wondering why aren't you reporting the violence in Manipur, while you have covered news of all around the world. But now finally...better late than never, I'm glad.The only unbiased news report I have watched ever since the violence started. Well, Palki Sharma you never failed to amazed me.
The Kuki Zo are not brought into Manipur by the British but they were there many decades before the British regime.
Exactly exactly Ma'am Palki👍👍👍👍
Your way of imparting news is what I called Neo Style.... Love it❤❤❤
Madam,you knew & knows 100%...Thank you.
Thank you for this episode. Helped understand the situation.
Ma'am I would be more happy If you have specified the Manipur kingdom during the British times or before that. It is learned that many families were separated into India and myanmar when India got independence. This means Manipur was having much bigger area before India gained Independence
Yes manipur was a much bigger kingdom. At one point, it used to include parts of Bangladesh around the Chittagong hill tracts and even extended to big chunks of Myanmar in the east. However, there was constant war between Myanmar and Manipur, so there were fluctuations every now and then. By the end of colonial rule, the Map of Manipur had significant become smaller. In 1947, Manipur had its own Constitution, governing policies and Representatives. A merger agreement was signed in 1949 between the king of manipur and India and it officially became a part of India. However, for the sake of diplomatic alliance, a part of Manipur called Kabaw Valley was offered by the then PM Nehru to Myanmar and monetary compensation was asked to be given by Myanmar.
Save our metei Hindhu brothers n sisters, nowhere Hindhus r feeling safe, even in their own land,, salute to all my metei brothers who have stood against the tide..
@@Mar48uui pls brush up history, 😂😂😂, kukis r the settlers, all kukis came to Manipur in the first half of the 19th century,, now a population of settlers numbering 28% of the population occupy 90% of land whereas the indigenous metei occupy 10% where was the justice when u turn the indigenous ppl into second class citizens of that state.. more though given the opportunity the kukis would have meted out the same treatment to metei women, it was just a question of who did it first .. a lot of metei women r raped by kukis but that hasn't got publicised..
Who told you that India is Hindu land
I've gained a new insight after watching this. The situation is complicated so it's better not to comment if we don't know the facts. Kindly don't flare up issues based on rumours. Praying for the safety and peace of all in Manipur 🙏
You watched a 7 minute video, go do more research
@@thangkhual4769 yeah will do. Thanks for your suggestion.