They should make some crafting materials too but i think some more unique potions would be cool and it would match with organic feel of the pale garden
tall trees wont fix it we need a whole new tree type. also i think some kind of tall grass varient would fit the vibe well. so far, this is obvoiusly a retextured dark oak forest with some vines. im going to cry if this is the final product. edit: grey leaf particles kinda like in cherry groves. also cave licen would look cool on the trees giving the really dim light. also decoy creaking eyes would look cool. like some yellow mushrooms on the tree or something.
Hear me out, add fireflies here, they would be matching with the creaking's eyes, and it would make them look like they blend in and scare you a bit more
@@BigMastah79disagree, fireflies fits perfectly with fog and the biome. I also think there should be a grave stones around or even better. A graveyard as this biome unique structure with a unique loots
To add to the unsettling factor to this biome. It'd be neat if only the music would stop playing once you entered it. The only sounds that could be available would be the normal sounds of Minecraft walking, mining etc, Maybe a little ambience. And the sounds of The Creaking hunting you down the moss rustling, the wood creaking only for to turn around and it's just staring at you. Only when you step outside of this area would your music start playing again
Hear me out 1. Sleeping bags, you can sleep in them and the don’t reset your respawn point 2. Use sleeping bags, campfires and lanterns to make abandoned campsites 3. Fireflies the swirl in tight bunches to look like creaker eyes 4. Dense heavy fog 5. And a way to purify the creaker heart so we can use it like a guard alternative to the iron golem 6. Gray flowers that give you a second or two of blindness when to walk into them
I like this biome but it could be better 1. Add fog, just have turning off for in settings 2. Add some more plants! Its called a garden after all! (Maybe a new flower??? Idk) 3. Add a reason to go there (Maybe you could use the creaking heart for something cool) These are just my ideas tho, no need to feel pressured :D
Use the heart to make like a new item that’s op but you need that and netherite to make it Edit:1 nvm make it used for security cameras that stare at them so they can’t move but can also play sound for stuff like the warden
@@juliesheehan41it's not a horror game but it has horror aspects, the cave sounds have been a part of Minecraft since forever and the idea that something dangerous might be lurking around the corner even more so
@@juliesheehan41Minecraft is a sandbox, an adventure game, I would love this in Minecraft, cuz the point is to have fun while exploring, fighting, discovering, etc
I love the eeriness of the biome, fantastic concept but I think that it could be taken even further. I think a more unique tree shape would give more personality to the biome, right now it looks more like a sub-biome of the Dark Forest rather than a biome of its own. Next I would love to see the implementation of fog, which only occurs in the biome kind of like a low render distance. Lastly I think that there should be more new plants since after all it’s called a “Garden” overall very solid biome but I would love to see it be taken even further
Tbf, it will definitely be more than it is right now, this is most likely not the end product. I've just watched the Nether update reveal and they've added so much to the original concepts they had back then! :D
in terms of the trees, i think the shape fits bc there are now 3 oak wood varients, oak, dark, and now pale. I think using the same shape as dark oak makes sense, but i can definitely see why you'd want a different tree shape
Alright, I've got a slight problem with this. Sure there are new wood types. But If you really want us to explore the biome, add some sort of cool collectible item that lies there instead of just the creaking heart. And also what others are saying, add more ambiance, make it more dead, and make it have a dense fog. Make players feel something.
I kind of like the idea of a new biome that looks either frozen in time or dead. I can imagine a lot of storytelling and build concepts focused on the area when the update drops.
- My suggestion is to replace regular vibrant grass blocks with mud blocks or new dead grass blocks - Add fog when you enter pale garden are - Make a tree taller
Ok guys hear me out, we all know how cherry blossoms trees have their own unique falling pedals affect right, why not give this fog affect to these new types of trees to add a eerie one of a kind feel to this new biome and for potential suspenseful builds?
It gives the biome more personality with its overall atmosphere. It would be perfect to capture that feel if this were to be done. Then more ideas for players can come to mind for what they want to create
- make it so the creeking does poses like weeping angels do when you look at them - a fog is needed but i think they should add something new: mist! It will be only low to the ground unlike fog. - it's called the pale garden so i'd love to see a lot more flowers and plants, OR even a new crop. - add a new carpet like block called twigs. When stepped on it makes sounds like the creeking or has a chance to. - make it so the pale leaves stay white/gray even out of biomes. Other than that everything is perfect especially the woodset!
Also i think owls should be added, for another ambient mob that can drop feathers, attacks rabbits, is nocturnal, and is neutral (can attack player if bothered). Could have them spawn in with a nest block, that when broken makes the owl aggressive for a short time. This nest can be made from 8 sticks and 1 moss, drops 2 sticks and rarely eggs, and looks sorta like a half block composter. It would only spawn in taller trees that have branches, like acacia, oak, cherry, ect. During the day the owls sleep in their nests and bees (if any spawned) take their place roaming about. There has to be some level of mobs spawning in the biome, but limited for the erie vibe. Rabbits, Foxes, and Bees could fill most of that niche since they are quite mobs. Plus rabbits and foxes have pale color varients, as do frogs as well. I am undecided if sheep should spawn there, but definitely not pigs, chicken, or cattle. Also there would definitely have to be some variation to owl types, considering the different trees their nests could spawn in.
It really just needs some major objective, like ruins with unique loot, so that people have a reason to venture in and get rid of the creaking. I hope Mojang is paying attention to the fact that every single comment and reaction to this has been constructive criticism. We like the concept, it’s just not there yet.
Ya, right now it feels like the only reason you would go there would be to experience it and to get the blocks Also yes I hope they don't see it as us being needy and see that we think concept is really cool it just need a biiiit more.
so SCP-173 or weeping angels are coming with creppy looking forest, thats cool but we also need reason to come to that forest (except wood) and the Fog would be very welcome addition to game.
That’s the problem with Minecraft updates they only add decoration items and that’s okay I guess but most people won’t go looking for these places just to get a block
Here’s a couple ideas: 1. “Sap root”: A new type of plant or moss-like block that grows in thick, wide patches around the garden which slows your speed and saps your health whenever you’re touching it, simultaneously increasing the speed of the Creaking and healing it. It varies in height like sugar cane or snow, and the taller it is the stronger the slowing and sapping effects are. It could generate where the Creaking walks, like snow does for snow golems. It can’t be destroyed or collected until the Creaking is defeated. 2. “Loose dirt”: A new block that falls like gravel and sand when stepped on, but not when placed. Throughout the pale garden are randomly generated holes 4-8 blocks deep, covered with loose dirt that collapses under you when you walk on it and drops you into the hole. The holes could be filled with tall sap root, making them harder to get out of quickly while the Creaking closes in. The Creaking could also cause mining fatigue when it gets close enough, which makes escaping the holes even harder.
Suggestion list: 1. Add more designs to it and have it spawn with one of the designs randomly so that it can blend in with the forest better. Or players can easily identify where the creaking is purely based on its silhouette. 2. Add fog to decrease visibility but allows the eyes of creaking to be seen even in the fog. 3. Add taller trees instead of just a bunch of small trees cramped into one place. Visibility drop isn't just more trees, fog is the way. Instead, having taller trees while being in a foggy environment allows for a more space, which imo is more spooky cause it is too empty and quiet but you know something is watching you. 4. However, players won't be scared purely by the environment alone if they know there's no threat. The major problem with the creaking is that it does too little damage. Half a heart in iron armour????? make it higher! The threat level is toooooo low to be scared of! 5. at least add an effect when hit by the creaking like blindness or slowness or a new effect or sth! Having blindness is a great addition, cause players placing torches in the pale garden is a hard counter to the blend-in mechanic of the creaking, so making players blind can make it less effective against the creaking!
I love the concept and mood of the pale garden but it needs a second mob for the biome and a structure maybe a fast but weak mob and make the creaking stronger
It needs more, this is totally empty. Fog? Taller willow trees? An actual purpose to go here? Maybe be able to craft something with the creaking heart. Maybe a unique scary temple?
Make the biome rare but double or triple its size, add tall trees, some structure like a tower that you can kinda see at a distance before entering the biome to give the feeling that when you get inside the biome you'll imediatly get lost or some kind of underground maze (maybe both), put some unique loot there,a unique usefull item at least to encourage exploring that biome for a long period of time Maybe some creaking variants, like a taller one idk
yes I agree with this, right now the biome just looks really bland and the creaking isn't even that powerful to give a true horror element, would be nice to add fog and make the eyes a whole lot dimmer, and adding a sharp wailing or scream would be nice
Thatll probably be the creaking heart. Imagine being able to have your own creaking. Maybe even a new armor type that could make a creaking for you that acts like a dog in minecraft
@@smggl64 Fine. then stop making new shity updates and focus all the attencion in mod support, mine is only alive thanks to mods and servers (hypixel is a poison tho)
Things this biome needs; - New flowers that match the biome - Any placed flower that is not from the new biome slowly turn gray, (to match with the biome vibe) - Tall trees - Dense Fog - Distorted sounds/Echo in sounds But honestly, I liked the idea of the new biome.
The concept behind this biome is cool, but the execution is pretty poor. It should look more dead and unnatural, and there should be fog or something to add to the atmosphere.
Also a purpose, a reason why people shouldn't just ignore it the second time they see this biome. You will get a sapling and leave that's it, no new content other than the wood.
@@detto1998not everything in Minecraft needs a purpose, by this logic what’s the purpose of the Savannah? Or the birch forest? Mangrove swamp? Cherry Grove? It doesn’t need a purpose.
Ok big problem with this biome though. there is no real reason to go here besides the new trees. I feel like it needs more... Edit: I actually really like the update I'm just giving suggestions to make it better... Some of you need to calm down
That's true, but this biome is kinda like a dark oak forest or an average cherry Grove, no reason to go there, just part of the world. But, what would fix it would be like a spooky mansion that makes people have a reason to find it.
Things it needs: 1. Fog 2. Sine tall trees 3. Fireflies the color of the creaking eyes 4. Dead flowers 5. Rotting pumpkins 6. Music stops when you enter 7. Random sound around you like something stepping on twigs to make it feel like something is watching you 8. Abandoned/ruined campsites 9. Some sort of ruins that are abandoned and seemed like they were attacked 10. More spooky plants, it is a garden after all 11. Maybe they can add another small mob that hangs and swings from trees and seems to follow you, add more features if ya want 12. Some sort of ghost thing that you always seem to see in the corner of your eye but when you look at it, it isn’t there, maybe it never was 13. Pale dirt/grass 14. Twigs that snap and make sound when you step on them
I've said this once and I'll say it again because I like the idea, They should add White Pumpkins to the Pale Garden And when you wear a carved White Pumpkin the Creaking should ignore you Edit : For anyone who thinks it would make the Pale Garden too easy Maybe you could put the Carved White Pumpkin with other hard to obtain items To balance it Also maybe this Enhanced Carved White Pumpkin Could have orange glowing eyes Edit 2 : okay fine, How about to keep the "Challenge" there If you break a Creaking heart with the Pumpkin on The Creaking will attack you anyway, How is that?
Minecraft Story mode is where the White Pumpkins are from Edit : My Comment Got allot of likes and I'm hoping Mojang will see the Comment and add it Edit 2 : ( Because the original comment is getting a bit too big ) They could also make the White Pumpkin Instead, And they could call the White Pumpkins Pale Pumpkins instead
Honestly feel like they forgot about Sniffer. It wasn't done justice. Pretty sure there was meant to be AT LEAST 1 more flower type, but they kept it like this. Imo, going through effort of growing Sniffers only to get 2 flowers feels meh.. The flowers are unique, but that's it, all of that for some tiny decoration detail.
This is really cool im digging it! but as others have pointed it out it could be even better with: some orange fireflies to help conceal the creaking eyes (makes you pay more attention) unique plants like white pumpkins gravestones or graveyards as the biome specific structure and maybe some fog and use for the creaking heart
Do not copy and paste the dark forest biome and then talk about inspiration for the trees. Make the trees 1 block at base, taller, and make the leaves spread out and droop. If a weeping willow was the goal, a beautiful idea, then make the weeping willow. Make the tree 15 blocks high if you have to
It would be so much better to have the trees all high up like this! Would definitely give off a feeling of "there's no way to escape". Right now you jump up 2-3 blocks and now you can run on top of all the trees, but with this that would be much more of a challenge, if possible
We clearly see its unifinished.. Heres some ideas As others said fog, the biome needs fog Modify the creaking sound to have more deeper sounds and othrr types of creaks The trees needs to be redone, i agree with ecko. The pale garden is to much of a retextured dark forest. Make sure it doesnt move at all when looked at, no rotating ect
Bro it's the same all the updates "it's unfinished and it will be much better when they release it" and at the tease they just add 3 new pixels to the grass and a tree 1 block taller
My problem with this is no urge to explore it in actual gameplay. There is no reward. I'll walk in grab a tree, some saplings, moss and leave. The Creaking can be creepy but it's about as creepy as any horror game mod from the 2010s. In comparison the Warden uses your entire moveset and any prior knowledge of how the game works against you. Taking you out of your comfort zone and keeping you on edge at all times. Additionally it rewards you for getting over all the new hurdles it throws at you with some decent treasure. All I see here is ooh spooky... Thanks for the white wood though
@@r6scrubs126 what's the point of adventuring into a dangerous place if i won't get any rewards? I'll just go in for the first time, wander around, think is cool and never come back to it because there's no reason to
For the biome, I think it would be epic if it was constantly covered in fog at night. Like you can see the fog from the outside, but its not see through, and then when you enter the garden you can see through the fog. This would force you to enter the biome without being able to see it, and thus if a Creaking is waiting at the entrance, you can't see it until you're near it. Bonus points for a fog machine or fog in a bottle as extra incentives to actually come here. Both would let you create a veil of fog on your own.
Reasons why I think this should be an End's dimension biome: 1. There are already 8 types of different tree sapplings and up to 9 types of wood sets in the overworld 2. There isn't any exclusive trees & wood set in the End dimension, so that would be a perfect chance to let all dimensions have their own trees for the very first time. Very convenient for those situations in which you forgot to take your crafting table to the End 3. The new white wood set is powerful enough to remplace quartz in buildings, so having in mind it would be easily renewable in high amounts, I suggest it not being that easy to find in early game. Its just for a balance purpose 4. Childs who play Minecraft usually dislike grim & spooky stuff, so again, finding the biome that easy in the overworld could make them feel frustrated and uncomfortable with the idea. Then, having this exact same concept in the End dimension could be the best solution for both childs who want to avoid it and oldies/veterans who'd really want to accept that "fear" 5. We all want new things to come for the End dimension. It is unquestionable it looks quite lifeless compared to the other 2 dimensions 6. As the devs told us, once you get a creaking wood heart, you can place it wherever you want and make it summon the creaking mob. Now imagine the tipical person who enjoys placing and hiding tons of this blocks ir others houses. That's too OP to be an early game function, and could make life impossible for many players
The creaker should do more damage and/or be faster. Entering the biome should reduce the fog on the player or apply the effect of blindness. There should be tall trees. And a purpose would be needed to go there. Otherwise it's an excellent job! I love that more horror concepts are being introduced into the game
What if you could use the creaking heart to craft a sort of beacon for wooden tools. The creaking heart empowers wood so what if you could harness that power, like within the range of a creaking heart beacon, wooden tools are better than Diamond tools. But only within that range and it should be difficult to craft this new creaking heart beacon.
I can see some great potential for this mob! I have an idea... A few ideas, actually... The Creaking will drop a Creaking Shard when killed. Filling every slot in a Crafting Table with Creaking Shards can create Creaking Cores, which can be used to make Creaking Tools, like the Creaking Sword, Creaking Axe, Creaking Pickaxe, Creaking Shovel, and the Creaking Hoe. The crafting recipe, of course will stay the same, so crafting a Creaking Sword will be the exact same as crafting a Diamond Sword, but you use Creaking Cores instead of Diamonds. We could also have a new "Creaking" effect which makes it so that every few steps, you take a bit of damage. A creaking noise will also play when this damage occurs. The Creaking Tools can also have some special ability (for example, every hit from the Creaking Sword has a 25% chance to apply the Creaking effect on the target for a random duration from 15 seconds to a minute). It would also be cool to add Creaking Armor, and maybe even a Creaking Shield and a Creaking Bow! Maybe even a Creaking Banner Pattern! This would be really cool to have in the game. And if you (the reader) have made it this far, thanks for listening to me ramble on and on about some ideas that probably never will make it into the game. But if you're one of the devs, PLEASE consider this. I know it might be a stretch, but I would be honored if my ideas were once actually noticed. Thanks so much for your time reading this, and have a wonderful rest of your day. - FireLordSSBU 🔥
*enter panicking villagers right here* It could be a zombie Or a skeleton Blablaienduakwngdbakaj whshs “AND A STÆVE” No, it didn’t look like any of those
Needs 1. Tall trees 2. Fog 3. Make the heart useful for players other then decoration 4. Make a structure 5. Add more plants for the update 6. Add a creaking boss 7. Add white pumpkins 8. Make the creaking boss drop a unique item 9. Make the vines gives you damage 10. Make a creaking music
Add gray flowers that slow you down when you walk into them like the cobweb. It's a garden after all😅 Maybe twigs that can be layered like powdered snow and everytime you walk through it, a layer breaks off
3:40 "Don't blink, don't even blink, blink and you're dead, they're fast, faster than you could ever believe, DON'T TURN YOUR BACK, DON'T LOOK AWAY, AND DON'T BLINK" - The Doctor
First of all make the trees taller and the leaves themselves more drapey and the vines longer to go with the taller trees. Second you should maybe add fog and some type of flower that matches the biome color when the sun is out but then when its night it changes color to look like the creepings eyes so the creeping can blend in more at night. Last maybe make the creeping a bit taller and more lanky or is that too unnecessary?
As an archi student i'am feeling blessesd: finally we getting greyish/whie plank color set. I am genuinely thrilled. But as many others in the comment section i'd also add fog, and a bit taller and detailed, more unique tree design, the material is ok, but the form of the tree is a bit simimlar to the dark oaks and also its forests, which also tries to gather some creepiness, with its dense canopies, but we should keep it in a different way. So it could be a less dense, with unique approach when it comes to tree design. And i think there is some place to some new other mobs - maybe not that important as the creaking but more like its minions, or some thorns as plants which are harmful to the player.
Let’s all remind ourselves that this is all subject to change. This is *NOT* the finished product. It can get better. Edit: Wow, a lot of people in this community are pessimistic.
Community: "We want more minor updates more often, instead of one major update per year" Mojang: "Ok, here is a minor update with less stuff" Community: "This update doesn't have much" ?????????
My suggestion would be to completely overhaul the trees. Make them look more like actual willows, don't just copy the already existing design. Also, maybe add some other tall tree types for more variation, as others are suggesting. Some dead trees would also be cool. Also, fog is a must. If you really want it to feel eerie, some structures would also be cool, like an abandoned, decayed village or something. Maybe make the water in this biome poisonous/withered, so that it's more difficult and creepy. And most importantly, give players a reason to go there in the first place, because if you won't, it's just going to be useless and annoying - minecraft world already has a lot of biomes, so we don't want another one which will be simply avoided since there's no reason to explore it.
0:59 "Something lurking in the shadows" the first thing i thought about was "We are shadow garden, we lurk in the shadows in order to hunt the shadows"
Theory: The Creaking is an evolved Enderman. Its eyes are similar to the Enderman, and given they are tall, it’s quite possible that they were in the process of being Enderman, but somehow became The Creaking. It’s hard to say exactly to what the origin of this thing is, or how the creaking heart affects these creatures? Anyone have any ideas? 🤔🤷
I think we all like the higher trees idea same as the fog one, also it would be cool to see there rare glowing orange flowers or smthn like that so we could mistaken them for a new mob in the fog, that would definetly work for the atmospher i think
Hear me out, add fog into the pale garden but the second players go in, it hides name tags so it gives more of “lost in the woods” vibe and eerie feeling while being in that biome, even though you go in with your friends, you could still be very much alone…
i think grey flowers would be cool but i think also there should be a blood orange flower that is more rare, and has some sort of special property. like when you craft it into a potion along with a Creaking heart it allows you to heal from the creaking hearts when you are in that biome. Or like maybe there's a new boss in the garden and you can track it down by holding this rare flower in your off hand and as you get closer the flower with start to glow more and more. This boss would drop special loot and look like a giant mutant version of a creaking with reinforced mutant trees around it that have creaking hearts that are much more difficult to destroy, so they'd be keeping him alive kinda like the ender dragon. Or something idk
Should've gone all out for this one. It's a shame cuz this could've been really cool. Some cool additions would be Taller/different trees: the pale forest kinda looks like a great value dark oak forest rn Fireflies: make them look really similar to the eyes of the creaking so we can't just pick him out immediately every time he spawns. Cut the music: make the forest have no ambience or music at all. Also implement something similar to cave noises to throw off players Make a reason to go there: why would I risk a Creaking encounter in the first place if I don't have to? Maybe making it so player-spawned creaking(s) act as auto respawnable golems for villages. Fog: spooky Grass: pretty sure that's just a regular grass color. Make it grey or even black. Some other plant life like a unique mushroom or flower would go a long way too
It would be great if there were special parts of the forest where trees spawn less and are more likely to have multiple creaking hearts and tons of tall white grass spawned, after walking through the tall grass you’ll eventually find an abandoned village made out of the pale wood and with some different buildings. Also, they could make it so evoker hutches spawned in this biome, as well as mushrooms that look similar to the creaking’s eyes.
Idk why people thought this was gonna be an end update after saying they're doing smaller updates. Edit: Even if they were to do it in smaller updates, Mojang already said that they won't add the End Update until every existing feature in Minecraft like the biome votes are added. It's sad but true so don't be expecting an End Update anytime soon.
I like that it’s not trying to be overwhelming. It’s a part of the world, it’s there, it exists. Doesn’t have to have some revolutionary and groundbreaking new changes, it’s just a small thing to add to the world in a natural way
Love this so far.. BUT it needs a few Things Everyone is saying this - FOG Then - New Flowers or vegetation that are gray - Fire Flies Then something I have seen yet… - A new Structure that spawns in some Pale Garden biomes. It’s called a Pale Garden biome but it has no Creepy Garden structure, it needs one ASAP New Structure… a Creepy Garden
I like this idea, but I honestly think there are cooler and simpler things to add to minecraft. for example, add migration of certain mobs, add seasonal mobs that maybe only come out in snow, or on hot days, or just give the end an update. another idea is adding more depth to the villagers, perhaps fishers have large boats (like the sunken ship wrecks) that are communal. to use the fisher example again, maybe there are specialisations with in the fisher community, like one is a captain, some are deck hands, etc...
@@ConnorSemp I just kinda wish the trees and biome felt more distinctly different from the dark oak forest... Like at least change the trees or something
It's kinda hard to decide what to add to a game like minecraft and what to not add, with player's suggestions, they could turn Minecraft to another one of those mod games, what makes minecraft special is its simpleness, that's why updates are so rare.
I think that if you added ambiences like bird noise and wind and grass swaying in all the other biomes, and then got rid of the ambience in the creaking biome, then THAT would be waaaaay more eerie.
Deep dark- is ears Pale garden- is eyes Pale garden need seek block with mechanic works with creaking or creaking heart and can do Redstone signal Normal tree with eyes make pale garden scarier. I think pale garden need something like deep dark but another and with new mechanic +fog +more grass type to make the pale garden more thorny and more difficult to pass +make this biom bigger like small forest and add structure in centre of pale garden with exclusive loot for pale garden. This is garden you could add a greenhouse structure or something like that. This structure could fully live up to the name of the biome and make this biome more interesting for the player to go there and explore.
Idea way not add the zombie horse in the middle in the wood as a reward. Give the players a reason to enter the forest and finely a use for the zombie horse.
That actually would be so perfect. Maybe a dilapidated stable or something guarded by zombies. not a huge thing gameplay wise, but at least a reason to enter the garden
Everybody please remember that this is a Game Drop and not a major update so the added content is more of a seasonal based addition rather than a game expansion.
- Add tall trees (for spooky vibe)
- Add fog
- Add gray flowers
fireflies and temples
Which are skinny
They should make some crafting materials too but i think some more unique potions would be cool and it would match with organic feel of the pale garden
@@Mikooooooooocoooooooooooooooo your spooky castle idea is so sick and awesome!
tall trees wont fix it we need a whole new tree type. also i think some kind of tall grass varient would fit the vibe well. so far, this is obvoiusly a retextured dark oak forest with some vines. im going to cry if this is the final product.
edit: grey leaf particles kinda like in cherry groves. also cave licen would look cool on the trees giving the really dim light. also decoy creaking eyes would look cool. like some yellow mushrooms on the tree or something.
Hear me out, add fireflies here, they would be matching with the creaking's eyes, and it would make them look like they blend in and scare you a bit more
U are genius
not really fitting. It’s less scary and more eerie
@@BigMastah79disagree, fireflies fits perfectly with fog and the biome. I also think there should be a grave stones around or even better. A graveyard as this biome unique structure with a unique loots
@thedace7670 mabye they will add a part 2 to the pale garden
@@CulturesEnthusiast A graveyard would be too on the nose honestly. I think people are approaching this in far too much of a typical “creepy” fashion
Things this Biome needs:
1. Fog
2. White pumpkins
3. Gray Dirt
4. Fireflies the color of the creaking eyes (not many tho)
white pumpkins would be so cool ngl
@@ThatDigitalDemon minecraft story mode 💀
@@noir7640 but still, white pumpkins are pretty cool for decorations and such.
bro, they need to add vines that attack you
What if someone made a mod where if an enderman or the creaking spawn they'd have 50% chance of having swapped skins
All that's missing is:
1. Fog
2. Fireflies
3. Gray dirt (the normal dirt kinda ruins the pale forest vibe)
4. Tall trees( so it'll feel more creepier)
It needs fog and tall trees
That’s what I was thinking. Fog would really enhance the atmosphere.
I like those ideas
@@ChristoferPezetLol Fr
We need this in the game
This would actually be really cool
To add to the unsettling factor to this biome. It'd be neat if only the music would stop playing once you entered it. The only sounds that could be available would be the normal sounds of Minecraft walking, mining etc, Maybe a little ambience. And the sounds of The Creaking hunting you down the moss rustling, the wood creaking only for to turn around and it's just staring at you. Only when you step outside of this area would your music start playing again
"HEY KIDS IS ME" ahh moment
They need to add the monster from the movie, The Ritual
That one player that plays with no music: 😊
Sleep
This ain’t no Elden Ring
I think you coud add fog in the pale garden too
that would be a great feature
Yes
Same
The Pale Garden isn't even a garden. It's literally a recolored dark oak forest with one mob and that's it
@@ChristoferPezetLolkeep crying 😂
Hear me out
1. Sleeping bags, you can sleep in them and the don’t reset your respawn point
2. Use sleeping bags, campfires and lanterns to make abandoned campsites
3. Fireflies the swirl in tight bunches to look like creaker eyes
4. Dense heavy fog
5. And a way to purify the creaker heart so we can use it like a guard alternative to the iron golem
6. Gray flowers that give you a second or two of blindness when to walk into them
and one more: original shape of tree
yea they should make the trees like weeping willows or something typically portrayed as scary
I loved your ideas!!
wait I actually love this
Cool ideas
I like this biome but it could be better
1. Add fog, just have turning off for in settings
2. Add some more plants! Its called a garden after all! (Maybe a new flower??? Idk)
3. Add a reason to go there (Maybe you could use the creaking heart for something cool)
These are just my ideas tho, no need to feel pressured :D
Yeah this all sounds great but I’m not sure a flower would suit it maybe some sort of fern like bracken or something similar
Use the heart to make like a new item that’s op but you need that and netherite to make it
Edit:1 nvm make it used for security cameras that stare at them so they can’t move but can also play sound for stuff like the warden
Also I want to recreate fnaf with these lol
A block that adds fog would be cool
@@brickstonesonn9276 I see the idea
It needs more ambient and creepy design to really feel unique . It needs some sort of fog and also weird curly looking trees
No Minecraft isn't a horror game this does NOT fit
@@juliesheehan41it's not a horror game but it has horror aspects, the cave sounds have been a part of Minecraft since forever and the idea that something dangerous might be lurking around the corner even more so
@@juliesheehan41 cry
@@juliesheehan41 The warden do not agree
@@juliesheehan41Minecraft is a sandbox, an adventure game, I would love this in Minecraft, cuz the point is to have fun while exploring, fighting, discovering, etc
I love the eeriness of the biome, fantastic concept but I think that it could be taken even further. I think a more unique tree shape would give more personality to the biome, right now it looks more like a sub-biome of the Dark Forest rather than a biome of its own. Next I would love to see the implementation of fog, which only occurs in the biome kind of like a low render distance. Lastly I think that there should be more new plants since after all it’s called a “Garden” overall very solid biome but I would love to see it be taken even further
Exactly
Made a graveyard that you can dig stuff up in.
Tbf, it will definitely be more than it is right now, this is most likely not the end product. I've just watched the Nether update reveal and they've added so much to the original concepts they had back then! :D
in terms of the trees, i think the shape fits bc there are now 3 oak wood varients, oak, dark, and now pale. I think using the same shape as dark oak makes sense, but i can definitely see why you'd want a different tree shape
StaleyMOV would love those ̶w̶e̶e̶p̶i̶n̶g̶ ̶a̶n̶g̶e̶l̶ Creaking
Alright, I've got a slight problem with this.
Sure there are new wood types. But If you really want us to explore the biome, add some sort of cool collectible item that lies there instead of just the creaking heart.
And also what others are saying, add more ambiance, make it more dead, and make it have a dense fog. Make players feel something.
I kind of like the idea of a new biome that looks either frozen in time or dead. I can imagine a lot of storytelling and build concepts focused on the area when the update drops.
- My suggestion is to replace regular vibrant grass blocks with mud blocks or new dead grass blocks
- Add fog when you enter pale garden are
- Make a tree taller
Interesting...
I think this is the best summary of most interesting improvements to pale garden. 👍
Yeah with height of 10 block that will be now way to towering up and escape those ent creature
As soon as i saw the grass i thought it looked out of place so im hoping they adjust it
Also make the Creaking taller. Kinda like siren head.
Ok guys hear me out, we all know how cherry blossoms trees have their own unique falling pedals affect right, why not give this fog affect to these new types of trees to add a eerie one of a kind feel to this new biome and for potential suspenseful builds?
It gives the biome more personality with its overall atmosphere. It would be perfect to capture that feel if this were to be done. Then more ideas for players can come to mind for what they want to create
Bro make a post on the Minecraft feedback page cuz amazing idea
This. This. This is how the fog would be implemented. Genius idea.
Yes please
Yessss this would be very cool
I get the biome should be creepy, but what if I just set it on fire? 💀
Bro thought outside the box
I was gonna say, here I come with my flint and tinder. Goodbye creepy forest
well maybe you wanna interact with it
@@adamjones9810Bro don’t just think outside the box, he thought outside the dodecahedron
Bro didn't think outside the box, bro tought about the unused matchbox
0:24 that one bit of green hurts me
- make it so the creeking does poses like weeping angels do when you look at them
- a fog is needed but i think they should add something new: mist! It will be only low to the ground unlike fog.
- it's called the pale garden so i'd love to see a lot more flowers and plants, OR even a new crop.
- add a new carpet like block called twigs. When stepped on it makes sounds like the creeking or has a chance to.
- make it so the pale leaves stay white/gray even out of biomes.
Other than that everything is perfect especially the woodset!
imagine if you stepped on a twig and there was a chance the creaking spawned
@@Cosm1cxzzor it’s some sort of trap, that catches u until u destroy it, like some sort of roots
Also i think owls should be added, for another ambient mob that can drop feathers, attacks rabbits, is nocturnal, and is neutral (can attack player if bothered). Could have them spawn in with a nest block, that when broken makes the owl aggressive for a short time. This nest can be made from 8 sticks and 1 moss, drops 2 sticks and rarely eggs, and looks sorta like a half block composter. It would only spawn in taller trees that have branches, like acacia, oak, cherry, ect. During the day the owls sleep in their nests and bees (if any spawned) take their place roaming about. There has to be some level of mobs spawning in the biome, but limited for the erie vibe. Rabbits, Foxes, and Bees could fill most of that niche since they are quite mobs. Plus rabbits and foxes have pale color varients, as do frogs as well. I am undecided if sheep should spawn there, but definitely not pigs, chicken, or cattle. Also there would definitely have to be some variation to owl types, considering the different trees their nests could spawn in.
@@TearfulZorua bro u gotta say this in the main chat where they can see it! I love the ideas.
What about sawblades?
It really just needs some major objective, like ruins with unique loot, so that people have a reason to venture in and get rid of the creaking.
I hope Mojang is paying attention to the fact that every single comment and reaction to this has been constructive criticism. We like the concept, it’s just not there yet.
If Mojang is spending a year on an update (which I am not saying is bad) then they should at least give players a reason to do stuff in the update
Ya, right now it feels like the only reason you would go there would be to experience it and to get the blocks
Also yes I hope they don't see it as us being needy and see that we think concept is really cool it just need a biiiit more.
at least you can still prank your friends and stuff
LOL you think Mojang is going to listen to its player base that's hilarious
yes it needs some ruins
so SCP-173 or weeping angels are coming with creppy looking forest, thats cool but we also need reason to come to that forest (except wood) and the Fog would be very welcome addition to game.
Be more kid friendly
@@Pancakeman-e4pwhy
@@Pancakeman-e4pWarden:
That’s the problem with Minecraft updates they only add decoration items and that’s okay I guess but most people won’t go looking for these places just to get a block
Forgot about the Lethal Company coilhead (which is a reference to scp173
Here’s a couple ideas:
1. “Sap root”: A new type of plant or moss-like block that grows in thick, wide patches around the garden which slows your speed and saps your health whenever you’re touching it, simultaneously increasing the speed of the Creaking and healing it. It varies in height like sugar cane or snow, and the taller it is the stronger the slowing and sapping effects are. It could generate where the Creaking walks, like snow does for snow golems. It can’t be destroyed or collected until the Creaking is defeated.
2. “Loose dirt”: A new block that falls like gravel and sand when stepped on, but not when placed. Throughout the pale garden are randomly generated holes 4-8 blocks deep, covered with loose dirt that collapses under you when you walk on it and drops you into the hole. The holes could be filled with tall sap root, making them harder to get out of quickly while the Creaking closes in. The Creaking could also cause mining fatigue when it gets close enough, which makes escaping the holes even harder.
Suggestion list:
1. Add more designs to it and have it spawn with one of the designs randomly so that it can blend in with the forest better. Or players can easily identify where the creaking is purely based on its silhouette.
2. Add fog to decrease visibility but allows the eyes of creaking to be seen even in the fog.
3. Add taller trees instead of just a bunch of small trees cramped into one place. Visibility drop isn't just more trees, fog is the way. Instead, having taller trees while being in a foggy environment allows for a more space, which imo is more spooky cause it is too empty and quiet but you know something is watching you.
4. However, players won't be scared purely by the environment alone if they know there's no threat. The major problem with the creaking is that it does too little damage. Half a heart in iron armour????? make it higher! The threat level is toooooo low to be scared of!
5. at least add an effect when hit by the creaking like blindness or slowness or a new effect or sth! Having blindness is a great addition, cause players placing torches in the pale garden is a hard counter to the blend-in mechanic of the creaking, so making players blind can make it less effective against the creaking!
I love the concept and mood of the pale garden but it needs a second mob for the biome and a structure maybe a fast but weak mob and make the creaking stronger
This.
listen to this guy minecraft
Yeah they could literally repurpose the darkness effect but change its hue
W suggestions
It needs more, this is totally empty. Fog? Taller willow trees? An actual purpose to go here? Maybe be able to craft something with the creaking heart. Maybe a unique scary temple?
You know this isn’t confirmed to be the full release, right? You still have the community suggestions and bug reports
in 5 years maybe. Cant put pressure on multi dollar company and expect more than 2 new blocks per year
It’s a drop what do you expect? Also this isn’t final, they could still add things.
@@noatouw this is quite literally a community suggestion that I commented, is it not?
@@tank-stubbs small size ≠ underwhelming feature quality. The biome is lacking and this is the community feedback on what they’ve made so far
Make the biome rare but double or triple its size, add tall trees, some structure like a tower that you can kinda see at a distance before entering the biome to give the feeling that when you get inside the biome you'll imediatly get lost or some kind of underground maze (maybe both), put some unique loot there,a unique usefull item at least to encourage exploring that biome for a long period of time
Maybe some creaking variants, like a taller one idk
yes I agree with this, right now the biome just looks really bland and the creaking isn't even that powerful to give a true horror element, would be nice to add fog and make the eyes a whole lot dimmer, and adding a sharp wailing or scream would be nice
Thatll probably be the creaking heart. Imagine being able to have your own creaking. Maybe even a new armor type that could make a creaking for you that acts like a dog in minecraft
YOU WANT A MOD JUST PLAY MODDED
@@smggl64 Fine. then stop making new shity updates and focus all the attencion in mod support, mine is only alive thanks to mods and servers (hypixel is a poison tho)
@@smggl64 theyre giving suggestions to add to the update drop.
Things this biome needs;
- New flowers that match the biome
- Any placed flower that is not from the new biome slowly turn gray, (to match with the biome vibe)
- Tall trees
- Dense Fog
- Distorted sounds/Echo in sounds
But honestly, I liked the idea of the new biome.
The concept behind this biome is cool, but the execution is pretty poor. It should look more dead and unnatural, and there should be fog or something to add to the atmosphere.
Also a purpose, a reason why people shouldn't just ignore it the second time they see this biome. You will get a sapling and leave that's it, no new content other than the wood.
they shoulda at least made new tree shapes, its just a light oak forest
@@detto1998not everything in Minecraft needs a purpose, by this logic what’s the purpose of the Savannah? Or the birch forest? Mangrove swamp? Cherry Grove?
It doesn’t need a purpose.
@@CooISkeleton96 Yeah thats the problem, thats why you never go there
This is just a preview many things are bound to change.
"Cool Update"
THEY ADDED WEEPING ANGELS 😭
What's wrong with that
Would be cool if they moved really fast like the angels, not just walking speed
@@unnamedweirdo3804this is a children game, not a horror
I WAS LOOKING TO SEE IF ANYONE MADE THE CONNECTION!
@@jewelv1600 i was thinking it too
Ok big problem with this biome though. there is no real reason to go here besides the new trees. I feel like it needs more...
Edit: I actually really like the update I'm just giving suggestions to make it better... Some of you need to calm down
Roblox has more games and its better than Minetrash 🗑️🚮
@@BellathewolfFan2020 i swear theres no way ur over 13
That's true, but this biome is kinda like a dark oak forest or an average cherry Grove, no reason to go there, just part of the world. But, what would fix it would be like a spooky mansion that makes people have a reason to find it.
@@Nijnuyhq143I mean their name is Bella the wolf fan there’s not a chance they are older than 7
@@Nijnuyhq143 well the name says 2020 so that would mahe them a 4yo lol
Things it needs:
1. Fog
2. Sine tall trees
3. Fireflies the color of the creaking eyes
4. Dead flowers
5. Rotting pumpkins
6. Music stops when you enter
7. Random sound around you like something stepping on twigs to make it feel like something is watching you
8. Abandoned/ruined campsites
9. Some sort of ruins that are abandoned and seemed like they were attacked
10. More spooky plants, it is a garden after all
11. Maybe they can add another small mob that hangs and swings from trees and seems to follow you, add more features if ya want
12. Some sort of ghost thing that you always seem to see in the corner of your eye but when you look at it, it isn’t there, maybe it never was
13. Pale dirt/grass
14. Twigs that snap and make sound when you step on them
I've said this once and I'll say it again because I like the idea,
They should add White Pumpkins to the Pale Garden
And when you wear a carved White Pumpkin the Creaking should ignore you
Edit : For anyone who thinks it would make the Pale Garden too easy
Maybe you could put the Carved White Pumpkin with other hard to obtain items
To balance it
Also maybe this
Enhanced Carved
White Pumpkin
Could have orange glowing eyes
Edit 2 : okay fine,
How about to keep the
"Challenge" there
If you break a Creaking heart with the Pumpkin on
The Creaking will attack
you anyway,
How is that?
Minecraft Story mode is where the White Pumpkins are from
Edit : My Comment
Got allot of likes and I'm hoping Mojang will see the Comment and add it
Edit 2 :
( Because the original comment is getting a bit too big )
They could also make the White Pumpkin
Instead,
And they could call the White Pumpkins
Pale Pumpkins instead
That would honestly make this so much better
AWESOME CONSEPT! This would be really cool.
That would explain the white pumpkins from MCSM
Genius idea
How about an eastwr egg???
Getting a sniffer on this biome gives you a very unique flower
Or if there is an flower and the creek is there and when u "blink" the flower will turn grey
The delicate flower from hollow knight would be an excellent Easter egg, just make sure you don't take damage.
Imagine it summons flowey
I think naturally spawning flower would be a must. But having the sniffer dig up an additional unique otherworldly flower would be cool.
Honestly feel like they forgot about Sniffer. It wasn't done justice.
Pretty sure there was meant to be AT LEAST 1 more flower type, but they kept it like this. Imo, going through effort of growing Sniffers only to get 2 flowers feels meh.. The flowers are unique, but that's it, all of that for some tiny decoration detail.
This is really cool im digging it! but as others have pointed it out it could be even better with:
some orange fireflies to help conceal the creaking eyes (makes you pay more attention)
unique plants like white pumpkins
gravestones or graveyards as the biome specific structure
and maybe some fog and use for the creaking heart
Gravestones would be sick
The White Pumpkin from Story Mode makes its return!
The white pumpkins are such a cool idea!! Love these suggestions >:0
Do not copy and paste the dark forest biome and then talk about inspiration for the trees. Make the trees 1 block at base, taller, and make the leaves spread out and droop. If a weeping willow was the goal, a beautiful idea, then make the weeping willow. Make the tree 15 blocks high if you have to
It would be so much better to have the trees all high up like this! Would definitely give off a feeling of "there's no way to escape". Right now you jump up 2-3 blocks and now you can run on top of all the trees, but with this that would be much more of a challenge, if possible
they really added SCP-173 to Minecraft and thought we wouldnt notice
weeping angels essentially
@@inkymcSCP-173 predates the weeping Angel episode
No way its mr phantom force, RIP launchtech
@@cj-3810 it does?
@@cj-3810 no.. no it does not
We clearly see its unifinished..
Heres some ideas
As others said fog, the biome needs fog
Modify the creaking sound to have more deeper sounds and othrr types of creaks
The trees needs to be redone, i agree with ecko. The pale garden is to much of a retextured dark forest.
Make sure it doesnt move at all when looked at, no rotating ect
add fireflies and temples
also they should add fossils as structures you can find there
remmber they said they will release smaller updates more often
Bro it's the same all the updates "it's unfinished and it will be much better when they release it" and at the tease they just add 3 new pixels to the grass and a tree 1 block taller
@ericnavarro8238 there improving atleast it's way better then the 1.19 era drama this is an improvement not making false promises
no that’s the herobrine biome
Exactly
Yum.
Maybe the creaking heart is made from the essence of herobrine’s power
Someone should make a texture pack the replaces the Creaking with Herobrine for those who want it.
Minecraft is trash so as technoblade lol XD
no music at all when you enter the biome. that would be terrifying.
100% spread the word we need this implemented lol
My problem with this is no urge to explore it in actual gameplay. There is no reward. I'll walk in grab a tree, some saplings, moss and leave. The Creaking can be creepy but it's about as creepy as any horror game mod from the 2010s. In comparison the Warden uses your entire moveset and any prior knowledge of how the game works against you. Taking you out of your comfort zone and keeping you on edge at all times. Additionally it rewards you for getting over all the new hurdles it throws at you with some decent treasure. All I see here is ooh spooky... Thanks for the white wood though
The point is to have an atmospheric area to build something in.
tbf most of minecraft has no point or reward. Its a sandbox/exploration game, not a proper RPG or whatever
@@r6scrubs126 fr, and about exploring, unless you wanna take the risk to get the reward.
@@r6scrubs126 that is a fair point
@@r6scrubs126 what's the point of adventuring into a dangerous place if i won't get any rewards? I'll just go in for the first time, wander around, think is cool and never come back to it because there's no reason to
For the biome, I think it would be epic if it was constantly covered in fog at night. Like you can see the fog from the outside, but its not see through, and then when you enter the garden you can see through the fog. This would force you to enter the biome without being able to see it, and thus if a Creaking is waiting at the entrance, you can't see it until you're near it.
Bonus points for a fog machine or fog in a bottle as extra incentives to actually come here. Both would let you create a veil of fog on your own.
Yo I’m actually down for that fog bottle thing. Have like a splash potion and make fog be around for little while.
@@BlanketFellaSMOKE GOING OUT
Yes a smoke grenade splash potion or even lingering smoke wall would be super cool
Why didn't they make the trees actually Willows? It's lighter in colour than Oak so would have made sense with the new blocks too.
they were too lazy to even make a new tree so they just recolored the dark oak 😭
@@Johnny_JD My thoughts exactly.
@@Johnny_JD Hey, that's rude! It's not laziness, it's efficient use of resources! /s
@@Johnny_JD They are probably going to make actual trees longer down the line
its not lighter, I don't get what you mean.
Reasons why I think this should be an End's dimension biome:
1. There are already 8 types of different tree sapplings and up to 9 types of wood sets in the overworld
2. There isn't any exclusive trees & wood set in the End dimension, so that would be a perfect chance to let all dimensions have their own trees for the very first time. Very convenient for those situations in which you forgot to take your crafting table to the End
3. The new white wood set is powerful enough to remplace quartz in buildings, so having in mind it would be easily renewable in high amounts, I suggest it not being that easy to find in early game. Its just for a balance purpose
4. Childs who play Minecraft usually dislike grim & spooky stuff, so again, finding the biome that easy in the overworld could make them feel frustrated and uncomfortable with the idea. Then, having this exact same concept in the End dimension could be the best solution for both childs who want to avoid it and oldies/veterans who'd really want to accept that "fear"
5. We all want new things to come for the End dimension. It is unquestionable it looks quite lifeless compared to the other 2 dimensions
6. As the devs told us, once you get a creaking wood heart, you can place it wherever you want and make it summon the creaking mob.
Now imagine the tipical person who enjoys placing and hiding tons of this blocks ir others houses. That's too OP to be an early game function, and could make life impossible for many players
The creaker should do more damage and/or be faster.
Entering the biome should reduce the fog on the player or apply the effect of blindness.
There should be tall trees.
And a purpose would be needed to go there.
Otherwise it's an excellent job! I love that more horror concepts are being introduced into the game
let's make a warden 2.0 then. Too easy? Let's make it do half your health in one hit, negating armor points.
What if you could use the creaking heart to craft a sort of beacon for wooden tools. The creaking heart empowers wood so what if you could harness that power, like within the range of a creaking heart beacon, wooden tools are better than Diamond tools. But only within that range and it should be difficult to craft this new creaking heart beacon.
Frfr, i was begging to have ANY more thing with horros aspects, and this update made me so happy, specially since it's just annouced bfore halloween!!
Also the Creaking should be tree sized. Would be possible with taller trees overall.
Please share this idea on the minecraft website at the community suggestion page.
"Mojang please add more biomes!!"
Mojang: haha yes dense forest with vines
That also looks kinda like the Halloween mashup
Yes? That’s a biome. What’s the problem?
??? What else do you want from them
It’s literally a new biome
@@Randomrainfrog it is bad biome
1.22 only a biome, a monster and new wood type...
💀 Minecraft will die
This thing feels like something Dipper and Mabel would encounter.
Gravity falls mentioned🔥🔥🔥
It’s the hide behind!
The hide behind. A fellow gravity falls fan.
@@MSM_Larvaluss ye
@@SebastienGendron-uk4po ye
I can see some great potential for this mob! I have an idea... A few ideas, actually...
The Creaking will drop a Creaking Shard when killed. Filling every slot in a Crafting Table with Creaking Shards can create Creaking Cores, which can be used to make Creaking Tools, like the Creaking Sword, Creaking Axe, Creaking Pickaxe, Creaking Shovel, and the Creaking Hoe. The crafting recipe, of course will stay the same, so crafting a Creaking Sword will be the exact same as crafting a Diamond Sword, but you use Creaking Cores instead of Diamonds. We could also have a new "Creaking" effect which makes it so that every few steps, you take a bit of damage. A creaking noise will also play when this damage occurs. The Creaking Tools can also have some special ability (for example, every hit from the Creaking Sword has a 25% chance to apply the Creaking effect on the target for a random duration from 15 seconds to a minute). It would also be cool to add Creaking Armor, and maybe even a Creaking Shield and a Creaking Bow! Maybe even a Creaking Banner Pattern! This would be really cool to have in the game. And if you (the reader) have made it this far, thanks for listening to me ramble on and on about some ideas that probably never will make it into the game. But if you're one of the devs, PLEASE consider this. I know it might be a stretch, but I would be honored if my ideas were once actually noticed.
Thanks so much for your time reading this, and have a wonderful rest of your day.
- FireLordSSBU 🔥
0:38 T- T- TWISTED LOG?!?!
AHHHHHHH
Where?
What?
AHHHHHHHH *scared*
*enter panicking villagers right here*
It could be a zombie
Or a skeleton
Blablaienduakwngdbakaj whshs
“AND A STÆVE”
No, it didn’t look like any of those
Needs
1. Tall trees
2. Fog
3. Make the heart useful for players other then decoration
4. Make a structure
5. Add more plants for the update
6. Add a creaking boss
7. Add white pumpkins
8. Make the creaking boss drop a unique item
9. Make the vines gives you damage
10. Make a creaking music
There's no such thing as a white pumpkin
@bluetube767 it's a story mode reference
@@jnkett *_🙂_*
they should use the creaking heart for a new potion effect
than **
This is actually a really cool concept. Also the creaking is scp 173/weeping angles made vanilla friendly
yeah except it deals no damage i wish they would make it deal more so it would be an actual threat like weeping angels or 173
Wow, an even smaller update, now that's fun!
Don't worry it's just an winter drop😊
mind explaining what exactly the "garden" part in "pale garden" there is? Because thats a "pale forest"
An outdoor area containing one or more types of plants, usually plants grown for food or ornamental purposes.
Mojang please put the Killer bunny back as a rare spawn in the Pale Garden
That would be awesome
YES
Mojang should just add a horror preset at this point, the pale garden blankets the surface and the entire underground is just the deep dark
They are not related tho
Add gray flowers that slow you down when you walk into them like the cobweb. It's a garden after all😅
Maybe twigs that can be layered like powdered snow and everytime you walk through it, a layer breaks off
the dirt still has vibrant colors tho ...
true
Mud would've probably been a better choice
The Pale Garden isn't even a garden. It's literally a recolored dark oak forest with one mob and that's it
yeah pls like me though i wannna be proud of myself
@@ChristoferPezetLolfr😂
3:40 "Don't blink, don't even blink, blink and you're dead, they're fast, faster than you could ever believe, DON'T TURN YOUR BACK, DON'T LOOK AWAY, AND DON'T BLINK" - The Doctor
Was looking for this comment! Especially after he said Don’t Blink in the video
@@phantaflame2889Same XD.
the creaking's eyes should be closed when he's not awake, and he should look more like wood. And he should make less sound when moving
This biome is cool, but they're talking as if they've made some kind of masterpiece.
well to be fair that’s how they talk about everything, and id kinda hope they have that kind of confidence about the thing they’re showcasing lol
This is the right biome for a graveyard
Mojang: We shouldn't add the realistic spider crawl because kids will be scared.
Also Mojang:
Bro fr tho I’m 12 and I’m shivering
@@MrGoatAtnthyou’re a baby
@@ImCreepur it’s a joke Mr big cool guy
@@ImCreepur I’m just sayin
@@MrGoatAtnth don't you mean creaking?
First of all make the trees taller and the leaves themselves more drapey and the vines longer to go with the taller trees. Second you should maybe add fog and some type of flower that matches the biome color when the sun is out but then when its night it changes color to look like the creepings eyes so the creeping can blend in more at night. Last maybe make the creeping a bit taller and more lanky or is that too unnecessary?
Maybe the Blue Sniffer flower would fit
@@Mohamed28ggnuh uh that literally has color which doesn't fit
@@UnknownX-Editscolour*
@@savitabagi127that's a regional spelling, little guy.
@@savitabagi127That's a regional spelling. Both color and colour are correct.
As an archi student i'am feeling blessesd: finally we getting greyish/whie plank color set. I am genuinely thrilled.
But as many others in the comment section i'd also add fog, and a bit taller and detailed, more unique tree design, the material is ok, but the form of the tree is a bit simimlar to the dark oaks and also its forests, which also tries to gather some creepiness, with its dense canopies, but we should keep it in a different way. So it could be a less dense, with unique approach when it comes to tree design.
And i think there is some place to some new other mobs - maybe not that important as the creaking but more like its minions, or some thorns as plants which are harmful to the player.
We must protect Agnes at all costs! ❤
Can't wait to build with the white wood blocks
ikr disgusting update
its supposed to be SMALL updates few times every year not big updates
I hate minecraft "fans"
Cherry-picking at its finest
@@seaguy8146not really it's not a disgusting update
Scp-173 "you can't do this to me... I started this company!"
What
Thats true ! Mojang copied !
Creaking "si puedo ademas los scp pasaron de moda hace 7 años"
WOW, what plagiarism!
@@LouTube_Veritable boo ghost had the same mechanic in super mario in the 90s LOL
Let’s all remind ourselves that this is all subject to change. This is *NOT* the finished product. It can get better.
Edit: Wow, a lot of people in this community are pessimistic.
it WILL get better. I am sure.
where were u when birch forest "concept art"😭
its awesome wdym
a beautiful birch forest concept art died for this
Understood
This actually gives me somehow Stranger Things vibes. What a great update idea!
I'd like it if no other mobs would spawn here naturally to make it more empty and eerie
Community: "We want more minor updates more often, instead of one major update per year"
Mojang: "Ok, here is a minor update with less stuff"
Community: "This update doesn't have much"
?????????
when did this even happen 💀 no one wants quantity over quality
@@dev7532 Literal years
The problem is that this doesn't change anything about the main game and there's no reason to go to the biom in first place
@@TheTigerPython it’s not supposed to change anything about the main game, it’s just a biome
@@TheTigerPythonthe wood? And i bet they will add a useful use to the heart
My suggestion would be to completely overhaul the trees. Make them look more like actual willows, don't just copy the already existing design. Also, maybe add some other tall tree types for more variation, as others are suggesting. Some dead trees would also be cool.
Also, fog is a must. If you really want it to feel eerie, some structures would also be cool, like an abandoned, decayed village or something.
Maybe make the water in this biome poisonous/withered, so that it's more difficult and creepy.
And most importantly, give players a reason to go there in the first place, because if you won't, it's just going to be useless and annoying - minecraft world already has a lot of biomes, so we don't want another one which will be simply avoided since there's no reason to explore it.
They should make abandon villages with moss carpet and stuff like that for a really creepy vibe.
0:59 "Something lurking in the shadows" the first thing i thought about was "We are shadow garden, we lurk in the shadows in order to hunt the shadows"
Sasuga Shadow-sama!
Atomic
Waga no nawa Shadow, kage ni hisomi, kage wo karu mono
Cid kageno
Eminence in shadow baby
1:06 what do you mean "feels unfamiliar" it's just a forest in grey scale
Fr
Real, they didn't think much on this one...
Jsut olay the game bruh
@@GoblinAttacForce ah yes, i will "jsut" "olay" the game bruh
It’s meant to be not right and odd and I think it cancels out sound
why is everyone obsessed with an end update? the poor desert has never really been updated since launch. it needs one badly.
Wait, no, you do have a point there--
Fr
cuz the end update is way more impactful
I'd like to add that "The combat update" was also an End update
probs bc the echoing void dungeons dlc was an example of what we COULD have if there was an end update, and how much better it would become
Theory: The Creaking is an evolved Enderman.
Its eyes are similar to the Enderman, and given they are tall, it’s quite possible that they were in the process of being Enderman, but somehow became The Creaking. It’s hard to say exactly to what the origin of this thing is, or how the creaking heart affects these creatures?
Anyone have any ideas? 🤔🤷
why not add more ambient sounds to the other biomes to make the lack of ambient sounds in the pale garden more out of the ordinary
That makes much more sense than having only that one have ambience
I think we all like the higher trees idea same as the fog one, also it would be cool to see there rare glowing orange flowers or smthn like that so we could mistaken them for a new mob in the fog, that would definetly work for the atmospher i think
Hear me out, add fog into the pale garden but the second players go in, it hides name tags so it gives more of “lost in the woods” vibe and eerie feeling while being in that biome, even though you go in with your friends, you could still be very much alone…
i think grey flowers would be cool but i think also there should be a blood orange flower that is more rare, and has some sort of special property. like when you craft it into a potion along with a Creaking heart it allows you to heal from the creaking hearts when you are in that biome. Or like maybe there's a new boss in the garden and you can track it down by holding this rare flower in your off hand and as you get closer the flower with start to glow more and more. This boss would drop special loot and look like a giant mutant version of a creaking with reinforced mutant trees around it that have creaking hearts that are much more difficult to destroy, so they'd be keeping him alive kinda like the ender dragon. Or something idk
What if you are able to tame the creaking heart. It can maybe protect a 10 by 10 area, hostile to everything but you
That would make it a lot less terrifying IMO.
oooh. They could have it so when you place it's heart back down, it will spawn again but this time not be hostile to you
No
6:13 This could be cool for making a build look abandoned.
Ik
Should've gone all out for this one. It's a shame cuz this could've been really cool. Some cool additions would be
Taller/different trees: the pale forest kinda looks like a great value dark oak forest rn
Fireflies: make them look really similar to the eyes of the creaking so we can't just pick him out immediately every time he spawns.
Cut the music: make the forest have no ambience or music at all. Also implement something similar to cave noises to throw off players
Make a reason to go there: why would I risk a Creaking encounter in the first place if I don't have to? Maybe making it so player-spawned creaking(s) act as auto respawnable golems for villages.
Fog: spooky
Grass: pretty sure that's just a regular grass color. Make it grey or even black. Some other plant life like a unique mushroom or flower would go a long way too
It would be great if there were special parts of the forest where trees spawn less and are more likely to have multiple creaking hearts and tons of tall white grass spawned, after walking through the tall grass you’ll eventually find an abandoned village made out of the pale wood and with some different buildings.
Also, they could make it so evoker hutches spawned in this biome, as well as mushrooms that look similar to the creaking’s eyes.
Idk why people thought this was gonna be an end update after saying they're doing smaller updates.
Edit: Even if they were to do it in smaller updates, Mojang already said that they won't add the End Update until every existing feature in Minecraft like the biome votes are added. It's sad but true so don't be expecting an End Update anytime soon.
@@ChristoferPezetLolyou do realize that they can change it during the snapshot phaze of development?
They can do multiple small end updates to make up for a big one..
@@ChristoferPezetLol true
Idk why yall expect an end update. Its too big job for mojang to handle
Small updates shouldent take a year
The mob is cool but the new wood set is AMAZING!
Hmmm white wood + cherry wood? 🤔
@@ChefGamrLafsur onto something fr IT SOUNDS LIKE A PERFECT COMBO
@@ChefGamrLafs Imagine Deepslate + pale wood
Your one of the best people in this comment section, thank for being positive!
@@ChefGamrLafs pale wood and cherry wood would work well for bridges over water with pale wood as the wet part
I like that it’s not trying to be overwhelming. It’s a part of the world, it’s there, it exists. Doesn’t have to have some revolutionary and groundbreaking new changes, it’s just a small thing to add to the world in a natural way
Roblox has more games and its better than Minetrash 🗑️🚮
@@BellathewolfFan2020I can smell the rage bait in this one
I’d rather play Minecraft on Roblox than this garbage
Least obvious rage bait
Yeah why would the mob or heart have any purpose when it can just be another one of those contents that everyone ignores.
A new flower like a pale rose or new bushes, mushrooms etc would make this place look so much more alive.
Amazing but it needs fog and a more detailed death animation for the creaking. ❤
Yeah!
It should like evaporate away when you break the heart, kinda like a thanos snap if that makes sense 😂
@@MTGApolloyes
Love this so far.. BUT it needs a few Things
Everyone is saying this
- FOG
Then
- New Flowers or vegetation that are gray
- Fire Flies
Then something I have seen yet…
- A new Structure that spawns in some Pale Garden biomes.
It’s called a Pale Garden biome but it has no Creepy Garden structure, it needs one ASAP New Structure… a Creepy Garden
Perfect for fireflies
I'm definitely not the only one who thinks that the Pale Garden looks exactly like the Dark Forest we already have.
Yeah, it's just a lazy copy and paste. Bot with moss
LADS! LADS I FOUND HIM!
*It's the bliggety bloke in the replies who thinks Sipover is worth the oxygen!*
That's right.
No one complaining when the did the same things to birch forst or taiga spruce forst
Yeah it’s just a more dull version of the dark oak forest and the only difference is the creaking and mansions only spawn in dark oak forests
Add fireflies and an option to bottle them or something to turn them into a nice light source
Light fog and some purely white flowers (including the stems) would really help, a garden needs flowers
4:32 THE PIGSTEP REMIX GOES HARD
Agreed!
sounds like terraria!
Fr we need this as an ost
Can anyone find it? I'm struggling to locate the remix.
If anyone here finds a clean version, send the link here
I am pretty happy with the drop. I would just add new special plant like flower with new proprieties + drop for a creaking
The problem is what it would be colored like and how big it is
Interesting.
The heart is literally the drop, as removing the block literaly unalives it.
Bro is happy with re-colored dark oak forest with recolored wood 💀
@@DundGyeah but I think their problem is that there is no reason to get the heart it has VERY little purpose except for just respawning the Creaking.
I like this idea, but I honestly think there are cooler and simpler things to add to minecraft. for example, add migration of certain mobs, add seasonal mobs that maybe only come out in snow, or on hot days, or just give the end an update. another idea is adding more depth to the villagers, perhaps fishers have large boats (like the sunken ship wrecks) that are communal. to use the fisher example again, maybe there are specialisations with in the fisher community, like one is a captain, some are deck hands, etc...
Did they work like 2 weeks on it ? Event the suggestions in comments are better
real
ikr, it’s genuinely insane that this was developed by a multi-million dollar company
Mf half these comments would ruin the biome. Graves? Firefly’s? Aggressive vines? Each one would ruin the dead vibe of this biome
@@ConnorSemp I just kinda wish the trees and biome felt more distinctly different from the dark oak forest...
Like at least change the trees or something
It's kinda hard to decide what to add to a game like minecraft and what to not add, with player's suggestions, they could turn Minecraft to another one of those mod games, what makes minecraft special is its simpleness, that's why updates are so rare.
I think that if you added ambiences like bird noise and wind and grass swaying in all the other biomes, and then got rid of the ambience in the creaking biome, then THAT would be waaaaay more eerie.
fr
Minecraft New Update
*Adds Weeping Angel**
yes weeping angels or scp-173 lol
@@tbhrex peanut has been added to Minecraft. I wonder how it works with multiple players looking at him.
And a new biome.
Deep dark- is ears
Pale garden- is eyes
Pale garden need seek block with mechanic works with creaking or creaking heart and can do Redstone signal
Normal tree with eyes make pale garden scarier.
I think pale garden need something like deep dark but another and with new mechanic
+fog
+more grass type to make the pale garden more thorny and more difficult to pass
+make this biom bigger like small forest and add structure in centre of pale garden with exclusive loot for pale garden.
This is garden you could add a greenhouse structure or something like that. This structure could fully live up to the name of the biome and make this biome more interesting for the player to go there and explore.
As a horror fan, this is the biggest dream come true ever. I wasnt really happy with the Warden, but this is just perfect. Add fog, and ur all set.
theres literally just one mob added, what dream? u want to stand in a low saturation forest and do nothing?
Idea way not add the zombie horse in the middle in the wood as a reward. Give the players a reason to enter the forest and finely a use for the zombie horse.
I think the skeleton horse would be more fitting.
@@bijivarughese5601 yes, but zombie horses cant spawn naturally/spawn in survival so this could be a chance for them to
@@ToiletDestroyer2000 but it zombie horses don't fit the gray-scale vibe of pale gardens. Zombie horses would fit the swamps the best imo.
That actually would be so perfect. Maybe a dilapidated stable or something guarded by zombies. not a huge thing gameplay wise, but at least a reason to enter the garden
Everybody please remember that this is a Game Drop and not a major update so the added content is more of a seasonal based addition rather than a game expansion.
yes, but they could at least think about adding fog or something or fireflies also. They want it to be creepy but in no way have done that
with the entire "garden" name, some sort of decayed greenhouse would be cool, maybe some loot, but a creaking heart also spawns in the greenhouse?