Short Manchu Bows by Kadys Bows and Grozer - Comparison
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 2 ต.ค. 2024
- Quick comparison of two short Manchu bows today.
A laminated one by Sergey Tolochko, Kadys Bows and a biocomposite by Csaba Grozer.
Both great bows and in many ways very similar yet still different.
Let’s have a closer look, shall we?
Review of the Manchu Bow by Kadys Bows, from Sarmat Archery:
• Short Manchu Bow by Se...
Review of the Chinese Bow by Grozer:
• Chinese/Manchu Biocomp...
If you want to see even more in depth bow reviews and/or join my online course, check our Patreon project here:
/ arminhirmer
If you just want to buy me a coffee for no reason :D here we go:
www.buymeacoff...
And thank you all, who bought me already a coffee, you are the best :)
Subscribe! / arminhirmer
Follow: / arminhirmerarchery
Follow: / armin_hirmer_archery
Email me! info@arminhirmer.com
Please ask for my actual shipping address before you send items!
That bow circle idea is interesting. One of the major problems in archery is the fact that bow information sheets only go so far and there is no way to test how a bow feels without buying it or being lucky enough for a friend to lend it to us. Even worse is traditional shooters as our group is small, and these bows are quite rare. I'm tempted to see how this goes, however, I would be worried about bow damage. I'm hesitant to receive/send out a bow with unknown history as bow failures can be very dangerous.
I'm still in love with that Kadys bow, loved her in the original review and even more now. I want to try a Manchu but don't want my teeth to ache.
I think starting a bow "library" is a GREAT idea Armin! I've wanted to try so many bows you've reviewed like this Kadys and some of the Sipahi bows. I hope this idea works!
Thanks Armin.
this little manchu is looking for a new home ;)
damn its a good idea! :D
gonna visit malta for that :D
I ordered the Kadys bow from Sarmat Archery after your earlier review of it, they told me the price was indeed $350.
Those Kadys Bows look beautiful. Wish I can see more of them reviewed. I was thinking of their Khan model bow, but for a 53" it only draws 31" which worries me a little. Thanks for the reviews as always Armin!
Hi Armin. Thank you for this comparison. It is so good to watch in the evening a sensible person doing a matter of the heart like archery, in this crazy world (for you it was probably in the morning, although I miss the sound of the bells). - And there is the following: I've been asking myself one question for a long time. We always see two cool guys in the opening credits. Armin and Hirmer. In the vast majority of cases, only Hirmer can be seen in the videos itself. What about Armin? Let him also play a role again :-). Greetings from Switzerland.
okay I will ask my split personalities... ALL OF THEM!
I just finished watching a Korean movie called "War of the Arrows" Free on TH-cam. I want you to watch and review. Awesome timing i saw this video on my recommendation.
Saw the movie for sure 5 times hahaha but yeah a movie review would be something new
@@ArminHirmer Haha that's great to hear!
And oh yes, it would be awesome if you review archery scenes from Tv shows and Movies and even try and shoot them lol! I want to know what type of Bow and Arrow they used in the movie "War of the Arrows".
And i could listen to your voice all day.
A bow library- try it, like it, buy it
Awesome comparison :). Keep up the great stuff! Just curious: where could I get the glove? I've been searching for it before but everywhere I try, they're sold out or don't ship to the Netherlands (found a shop in germany which had it, but was too slow :()
That’s a marvelous thought?!
I have a entry level bow to contribute to the cause?
To serve the purpose of letting a beginners learn how to handle, store, and properly protect the instrument.
So much to learn, thanks for taking a element of pressure from the target of perfecting the moment?!
The Grozer bow seems to deliver better overall performance
I‘m still in love with the Grózer Chinese (Manchu) bow ☺️
I‘m looking forward to shoot the bow myself 🥰😁🙏
Thank you for the comparison, Armin!
Best wishes! 🏹🔆
great place and range. thanks for your expressions and impressions. thanks for sharing your experience.
Archery camps in a nice place would also be nice. To combine tourisme with archery.
Think I'd lean towards Grozer's manchu. Being biocomposite, i like the red, also the curves. Everything about the bow is beautiful. From the colors to the song.
I don't know why, but I find the short Machu Bows look more elegant than the long ones
they have for sure something. but its good that we can have all lengths :)
very nice vid!
"wich I will do a video...one day...or maybe...NEVER" XD
Interesting bows... Thanks for the video, and pronouncing Dingenskirchen right... once... 😉
yeah yeah, I did once a short explanation but it was not enough for some. The long explanation needs time
@@ArminHirmer No hurry, lockdown is coming...
It's coming, it's coming, we here have no fear... Oder so ...
@@dasMoto of course the next one is just around the corner, like the next flu season
With the Olympics, thanks to you, I'm interested in the bow.😙😁😁🇲🇹
I wanted to write you several times: yeees, now you pronounced “Grózer” correctly! :) ...By the way: excellent video as always, but... why don’t you “ever” test Kassai bows?
Yes sorry I always fall back in my old habit with the name…. Thank you
@@ArminHirmer Anytime. Otherwise I love to watch your videos and use them as reference and recommendations for fellow traditional archers. This is why I asked my question: why don’t you test Kassai bows?
@@Memorixt last time I shot a Kassai was 2007 I think :) was my first "Horsebow". If somebody will send me one, I will do a review of course. But I think Kassai does not need this kind of promotion
@@ArminHirmer Make sense, thank you for taking the time to reply! ...Keep making your videos and I’ll try to influence someone(s) to send you nevertheless some Kassai bows for testing.:D
Hi @Armin, may I know if it is proper to shoot a Manchu bow with front kahtra, or is Manchu style shooting with side kahtra?
The bow does not dictate the style of your shooting. It seems there were many different schools with different methods during this several centuries period... Maybe Armin or someone else around here knows more?
Surely a " bow circle " is an unstrung Traditional laminated Korean bow???
Just Kidding ... Great Idea , Aussies like me might pay more in shipping , but at least we can try for ourselves rather than hope for the best ... and both nice bows , but I still haven't mastered my Alibow 'Qinghai' ... so I can't justify buying either of them.
Nice review! Thumbs up!
I love the idea of the Bow Library!!! Check out a nice bow...appreciate it...and pass it to another person to appreciate! Great idea, Armin!!! With or without a quiver...you seem fairly smart to me. 😆👍🏹
hahaha thank you
I still think the grozer is the way to go. There alot of experience built into that bow. Even though the other performs well enough once you shoot a biocomposite it's hard to compare to a laminated bow in my opinion. The only bows I've shot that come close to the biocomposite in terms of draw feeling and shooting experience are the hybrids from Indonesia. They feel alot alike in many aspects. There's a couple bowyers from there experimenting with biocomposite technology using fiberglass cores which seem real Interesting. Real horn real sinew fiberglass cores. Anyway great comparison as always my friend keep up the great work.
Agree
Hey! I would like to get into archery and saw your video on horsebows you should get as a beginner. I saw you recommended to get a bow from alibow but what arrows would you recommend to accompany the Tatar alibow out of fiberglass at a draw weight of 25 pounds.
Hi. Simply order directly matching arrows with the bow and if if it is your first order at Alibow you can use vouchercode Armin 10 in the checkout and safe 10% :)
I always wondered, why do you continue shooting and testing arrows that are too light for a certain bow. What information is there to gain from this test? As no one is going to shoot arrows that feel like dry firing. So the speed test is kinda useless in that case.
I don't have many bows, only two, but I like this idea of sharing bows. It's an interesting concept. 😁
because there is no recommendation from the bowbuilder regarding GPP, so I use what want :D and it was not a test, it was a comparison
@@ArminHirmer I understand that. I don't mean in this video in particular, I mean usually, when you do reviews. You shoot arrows that "feel like dry fyring", but you still do a speed test for them. Is this to test the range of the bow, or something else? I mean, you are the expert here, not me, that's why I'm asking 😂
I feel like it's useless to measure the speed of an arrow that is obviously too light for the bow. It hurts my soul to see a bow being almost dry fired 😂
The information you can get from a light arrow chronograph lets you test the efficiency of a bow.
For example, suppose a bow shooting a minimum 9gpp measures 150 fps. That same bow shoots a 7gpp arrow at 150 fps. That would mean that the bow is working efficiently at it minimum poundage, as lighter arrows don't increase the speed of the bow. The minimum weight for the safety of the bow is also the weight where the bow will be the fastest it will ever be.
Now imagine another bow shooting its minimum 9gpp also clocks out at 150 fps. However, a 7gpp arrow measures 160fps. That would mean that the bow is being "slowed down" at even its minimum arrow weight. The minimum arrow weight for structural integrity is already too heavy for the limbs to push, and it has to exert itself to even keep up.
If that still doesn't make sense, imagine buying a "high-end" computer which overheats just idling (doing very little). You can already tell that playing video games or running intensive software will be even worse, because the computer can't even handle a minimum amount of stress.
@@MMOhawked Awesome response. Makes sense, and this is what I was thinking about. There has to be a reason. And efficiency of the bow design makes a lot of sense. Thank you 😁
@@gizmonomono No problem, I never really had to sit down and think about it until replying so that was nice.
Do you know anything that i can use as a target for archery
... a taxman, maybe? (I mean the picture of one, not the human itself :-)).
a card board box filled with old clothes or layers of cardboard. a burlap sack filled with old clothes.... a hay bale
@@SwissFiveNine I was going to say a politician. I mean a picture of a politician but I stopped myself.😂😂
Thanks
I use a (large) cardboard box filled with more cardboard at home ... (free from supermarkets).