Charles Richard-Hamelin - Polonaise in F sharp minor Op. 44 (second stage)
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 10 ต.ค. 2015
- Narodowy Instytut Fryderyka Chopina/ The Fryderyk Chopin Institute
All rights reserved 2015
The Fryderyk Chopin Institute, Polish Television TVP
Zapraszamy do śledzenia transmisji z Konkursu na kanale/ Broadcasts from the Competition can be followed on the Chopin Institute's TH-cam channel: / chopin2015
Oficjalna strona Konkursu/ The official Competition website: chopincompetition2015.com
Oficjalna aplikacja iOS/ The official iOS app: appsto.re/pl/jBvv6.i
Oficjalna aplikacja Android/ The official Android app: goo.gl/u93t9T - เพลง
The fortissimo at 10:10 totally woke that guy up on the left side of the screen
lol so true
lol no-one but only you cared the audience during his play
lol i didn't notice that
exactly
Luke Holmes lol
The Op. 44 is my favorite of Chopin's polonaises, and over the years I've heard many different interpretations. I have to say in my opinion this performance ranks very close to the top of the best.
Also, I've always considered myself a Steinway man but this Yamaha has an amazing voice!
And.what about the Horowitz interpretation?(referring to that CBS LP "H on Television")
Yes, in general, yamahas are not the best for classical music, but chopin institute's yamaha is one of the best.
i think Yamaha just sounds great in his hands
Who’s do you consider to be the best performance of this piece?
Many pianists played this polonaise, but I agree this is absolutely outstanding performance!! Even 18th Chopin competition, just finished, I couldn't find any players that surpassed this performance!
17th Chopin competition would be one of the most memorable competition...lots of talented pianists...just in my opinion.
totally agreed
Yeah, I think the most talented participant last year was Hayato Sumino (Bruce Liu was good but in my opinion not winner worthy). However in the 17th Chopin Competition there were many talented people, and the winner of it was exceptionally talented.
Agreed. Honestly I was a bit disappointed when listening to the 18th Chopin competition. I was expecting someone (especially the winner) to be able to surpass my favourite interpretations. But that didn't happen. Just compare Bruce Liu's ballade no.2 and Seong Jin Cho's and you will see the difference. Cho's could surpass Zimerman's yet Bruce Liu's couldn't IMO. I actually like the top 3 competitors' performances very much for the 17th, yet I don't even like Bruce Liu for the 18th. Maybe I just set my expectations too high. 17th was definitely fantastic.
Agreed. I am expecting to enjoy Seong-Jin Cho's Handel, Brahms and Schumann this October. I also look forward to Charles Richard-Hamelin's performance in Taipei. He is really good.
I think this polonaise has the most untapped potential. So difficult to balance power, tempo, finesse, and phrasing in this one.
Chopin to najpiękniejsza spuścizna dla ludzkości.
Nope its jesus
Ale moja też jest niczego sobie, jak twierdzi przyjaciółka
Honestly, this guy's performances of Polonaise-Fantasise (no 7) and Polonaise F# minor (no 5) are superb. They easily stand comparison with Richter, Pollini, Rubinstein.
He treads the right line everywhere, sound, rubato, fullness of volume, pedal/no pedal. Fantastic performances indeed in spirit; deeply felt, fluent, constantly shifting moods, technically flawless.
The quality of sound production is second to none. And these are live, not studio. Magical.
Completely agree
Agree😊💕
The only pianist l could listen to all day long! I tell you he's got it! The imagination, the killer instinct, the maturity, the individuality. Made me listen to him immediately
Way to make us Canadians proud Charles, amazing job!!
I think it's the best Polonaise op.44 in this Chopin Competition(until now)
Krzysztof Ksiazek also good.
To me, Ksiazek was better. His interpretation was more majestic the way the character of the polonaise is
Blechacz all the way
17 year old Ivo Pogorelich is also quite stunning.
I'd prefer pogorelich
Absolutely in love with this performance! That's exactly how I've always wanted to hear it :)
This is by far my favourite interpretation of this piece, there is so depth in his playing
Brilliant interpretation!!! Perfect clarity despite the speed and bass! And the piano is absolutely perfect for this piece. Very crisp and clear and not too warm in its character.
Definitely my favorite performance of this piece!
Charles-Richard Hamelin is a pianist who studied in the town of Joliette, in Québec, Canada. We are very proud of his performance all over the world… ❤
@@louiseplante1256 Rightly so! He's a great pianist!
So beautiful, sensitive, sorrowful. My favorite interpretation of this polonaise. 👏🏻🎹✨
for me, this interpretation comes 2nd after Kultyshev's. This is a great version too.
This is the perfect performance for this piece ! I've listened to Rubinstein and others but none is as good as this !
l agree. The perfomanse is veri good! But Vladimir Sofronitski plays simply divine!!! The rekording is old without video,but from the first chords carries away.Good luck!
하이
what about Witold Malcuzynski?
plz don't compare the epic version of Rubinstein with this! Like plz!
@@qualityvigilante599Rubenstein was an old fart who didn’t understand chopin, people have far surpassed his level😂
Remarquable. Je crois que Chopin, lui-même, n'aurait pas cru que l'on puisse parvenir à une telle densité.
Bravo, Monsieur Hamelin.
Znakomity. Wierzę, że sam Chopin nie uwierzyłby, że można osiągnąć taką gęstość.
Dobra robota, panie Hamelin.
Very good performance. He doesn't get lost in the long piece like some others do
Thank you for performing two of my favourite pieces in all of classical music: this polonaise and Chopin concerto #2
Absolutely beautiful! This is by far the most emotional performance of the tragic polonaise I have ever heard.
Il ne suffit pas d'avoir un talent rare, et d'avoir, en sus, travaillé comme un forçat, pour parvenir à ce résultat. Il faut vivre intensément la musique, jusqu'à cette limite dangereuse, ce seuil fragile, qui sépare maîtrise et folie. Respect, Monsieur. Wielkie dzięki dla Instytutu Chopina.
Absolutely Outstanding performance! Highly commendable and so rich in every aspect imaginable! Great interpretation of this Op.44 Polonaise in F#! Simply magnificent...
I could not find any better interpretation of this piece...
Beautifully played, and very easy to listen to without losing interest. Each note has it's own place and contributes mightily to the whole. Really clear piano, gorgeous.
Extremely beautiful !
Superlative in every aspect !
Bravo !
His playing is so nice! So rich but not like an orchestra more piano wise! I love it!
what a beautiful interpretation !!
A+ fantastic playing on a fine instrument. I loved every note!!
His transitions are flawless. Outstanding.
何度も拝聴しています🎹🎶シャルルさんに合っていてとても素敵❤です💐🎵
So far I'm a fan of his performances
Wow! Absolutely WOW! Definitely one of my favorite Chopin Polonaises. So passionate, he is just in the Music the whole way through! Mmmmm goodness! ♥️🎼🎹🎵🎶
Thank you for an amazing rendition!
So many play this with too much power and a harsh tone. This was certainly special. A true talent and wonderful musician. Bravo.
Yes that was exactly the issue when Fedorova played the piece
beautiful performance
Great interpretation and greatest pianist!
Charles, you are Unbelievable, very good work: this is CHOPIN.
This is incredible. Amazing play.
The best interpretation of this polonaise that I ever listen
아 진짜 겁나 좋구만...
Clean and beautiful interpretation of this polonaise, bravo!
Polonaise award!
Did you notice he used his left hand to play the C# of A-major theme at 00:40 ?
It's been 2 days that I've been blocking on this passage that requires a huge hand and I finally understood how to do it
Excellent!
+morinoroba Absolutely fantastic.
It was really great:)
Superb interpretation!❤
WOW!!!!
it is wonderful!!~~
Incredible performance!
it is one of the great pieces on the world
Maravilhosa interpretação!!!!
It's all there, masculine aggression combined with feminine sensitivity.
This is the miracle of fantastic music written by such composers as Chopin and overall Brahms!!
I couldn't have put it better, this sentence defines Chopin to me.
I want to like this comment million times. I always felt this through this song but didn't know the words to describe it.
Perfect!!! Bravo!!!!👏👏👏
i always wonder if chopin were to take part in this competition how would judges critique his performance and, if chopin were a a judge here, how would he judge him charles and other in this competition.
never would agree to take part in such!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Liszt would definitely win. Chopin loved to see Liszt play his work and wrote in a letter to a friend how he wished he had Liszt's hands even though Chopin was probably more carefully and delicately emotive in his playing, Liszt's sheer skill (probably the most skilled pianist of all time) perhaps dwarfed Chopin's abilities
I've read that Tausig won over Liszt in terms of playing skills
Yes but Chopin much preferred Liszt's playing of his pieces.
People at that time thought that Liszt played things best the first time he sight-read them. After that he improvised a lot! He could transcribe an orchestral score to the piano on the fly, while making critical comments to the author, Wagner, who swore Liszt's spontaneous transcription was better than the orchestral version!
Oh! Merveillex. Le preux chevalier, la guerre, le drame! Il a tout!
Truly amazing
Just discovered this polonaise today. Wish I’d known about it sooner
What a performance !!!! BRAVOO !!!!!
BRILLIANTTTTTTTTTTT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
wonderfull!!!
Wow. Ça me fait brailler.
Talking about a piece being a proverbial “wall of sound” this is it! ‘Ole Frédéric Francois Chopin just did NOT play. Then He afforded you the scenic respite of gorgeous glistening lakes and singing larks and such. And everything in between? He knew exactly what he wanted and achieved it. So very uniquely genius. PWG
beautiful
Je n'aimais pas particulièrement cette Polonaise jusqu'à aujourd'hui. Interprétation d'une musicalité et d'une puissance exceptionnelles!
What a complex piece! I should listen again to absorve it better.
Hier je suis allé voir votre spectacle à St-Hyacinthe, c’était merveilleux!
Vous êtes vraiment un très grand musicien.
Merci pour cette magnifique soirée.
Jestes wspanialy alicja
What an brilliant play❤👍
His polonaise Op.44 is the best🎉
I like your way! Wow...
너무 멋있어..
Amazing pianist
perfect !!!
I'd love to hear him playing Brahms!
He sounds like he could do it! (richness and "fullness" of sound)
+Poudre Noire Absolutely. and I would also like to hear him play Bach-Busoni.
So would I
速いテンポの演奏になるんだろうけど音はしっかり聴こえる、、さすが安定のアムラン
Wysadziło mnie z kapci 😳
Poziom arcy pro!!!!!!
Słucham z 10 raz 👍🏻
Bravissimo!
Hey Chopin Institute, I'm not sure exactly when it happened, but congratulations on 100K subscribers.
彼の多彩な音色には、本当に魅了されます。
Chopin it the best of pianist
this is a winning performance right here
Awesome! COMPOSER AND INTERPRETER !! Simply unbelievably ingenious ! Genial !! KOMPONIST UND INTERPRET !! Einfach unglaublich genial !
oh mon dieu..........trop intense
Ottimo, bravissimo!!
Green with envy. As a 4th year (very interrupted) player from 1989-91 and 2022, this piece is becoming doable.
It is a great oo 44 version indeed but my favorite remains the same: Malcuzynski
I'm only 14 years old (been playing since I was 6) and so far I can play things as difficult as Debussy's Reverie, and Chopin's Raindrop Prelude. One day, I want to be able to play this piece in a church when I'm all alone.
I also started playing the piano when I was 6 and had similar but slightly faster progress when I was 14. Now I am 17 and am learning this one. It isn't as hard as the others that I have been playing (4 ballades). So you definitely can do it! I think you will be able to pick up this one at 17 or 18 given your progress.
i’m 14 and playing this now. I believe you can learn it as long as you build up to difficult pieces like this. sight reading definitely helps or gradually learning more and more difficult pieces. don’t give up because i really wanted to quit piano 2 years ago and it just started to click with me and now i’m in love with piano. also, be patient with your progress!! piano takes a lot of time and this piece took me awhile to learn because i would always put it off. i recommend learning the main theme/section before you learn the easier part (a little before the mazurka). i hope this helps!
I'm older and have been playing longer. I can play the Hammerklavier fugue in the shower)
I'm speechless.
Hands down the best version of this piece
Frederic Chopin is the most talented and most creative composer in human history!You can't change my mind!
bravo👍🏼
Bellissimo....
WOW!
Polonaise in F# minor, Ballade No.2 in F major and Ballade No.4 in F minor.
Something about that F key hits different.
He has some truly exquisite moments and evokes quite a marvelous sound (even from the Yamaha!).
"even"?
Yamaha CFX is on par with the best European piano
J'ai assisté à ton concert MOZART ce soir, 9 février 2017, au Palais Montcalm de Québec. Tu as inspiré les Violons du Roy et tu nous as gâtés de façon supériorissime. You are a God gifted Young man. Take care of those ten fingers of yours! May God bless you .
너무 아름답습니다.
母の死をお金で勘定したことはありません。本当にお金に困るとこんなことを考えてしまうのですね。母の死後、お金の勘定なしに生活してきました。本当に悲しいです。母とのお別れをお金何かで勘定するなんて、母の追悼文を無くしたことも非常に悲しいです。母の死を少しは飾る凄い追悼文でした。
Rubinstein would be proud , bravo excellent performance
bravo
Bravo
良いですね💖🥇👏
This piece is so underrated.
This song has so many different components that makes it awesome to listen to!
とてもかっこいい
私もこの曲を弾いたことがあり、気に入っています
うますぎる
感動
今までに30回は聴きました
Middle section octave apart or two fast notes are hardest to play clean. Thats Thea achilles heel of this, Chopin,s best polonaise. Awesome playing. Trills are tough too. Though szcherzo one might be even tougher.