Why Are People Getting Caned In Indonesia? | ASIAN BOSS
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 7 ก.ย. 2024
- Indonesia is the world's biggest Muslim-majority country and has been in the international spotlight recently for publicly caning people for their “crimes” under what’s known as “sharia law.” Sharia law is only implemented in Aceh province, and follows Islamic traditions and condemns certain behavior such as drinking alcohol, extramarital affairs and having gay sex. But how do ordinary Indonesians feel about this law? We hit the streets of Jakarta to find out.
The opinions expressed in this video are those of individual interviewees alone and do not reflect the views of ASIAN BOSS or the general Indonesian population.
Special thanks to our Asian Boss team in Jakarta, Indonesia.
Ramzy (Reporter)
Instagram ► / ramzyasmoro
Ryan (Videographer)
Instagram ► / ryanmelandi. .
Chris(Host)
Instagram ► / marcianochrists
Our vision is to build a lasting grassroots movement of young people from every country to report on real social and cultural issues. We believe having meaningful discussions with people with different opinions is extremely important.
For business or media inquiries, reach out to us at inquiries@asianboss.io
Reach out to our founders, Stephen and Kei, directly if you have any questions, feedback or suggestions:
Stephen on Twitter ► / theasianboss
Stephen on Instagram ► / theasianboss
Kei on Instagram ► / asianbossk
Are you curious about real people's perspectives from Asia on various cultural and social issues? Subscribe to ASIAN BOSS for more informative and thought-provoking videos ► goo.gl/TRcSbE
#Sharia #Islam #AsianBoss
The truth is, although Indonesia is predominantly Muslim, only the Acheh province in Indonesia follows Sharia law, whereas the rest of Indonesia follows secular law, even in predominantly Muslim areas outside of Acheh province.
The plague always starts from one region before it spreads all over.
For now :)
@@gostavoadolfos2023 most Indonesians would be glad to keep suppressing Aceh and their Sharia-derived rebellion if not because we were told by the West to "stop for humanitarian reasons" after 2005 Tsunami.
@@saraissak3957 You don't understand.
Vid me Do you condone applying Sharia law to your state?
Asian boss Indonesia’s video:
1st: ISIS.
2nd: Polygamy.
3rd: Getting canned.
You brought our country into another level.
Why did you repost this?
But, one of the man in the video said, "Don't judge Indonesia from things you've seen on the Internet.
Hmmmm. *Spiral Face*
When religion is a drug in the country.
Welcome to Indonesia.
@@rifaimuhammad8069 you and your negative thought. Have u watched Asian Boss' video of Japan and Korea? You don't need a foreigner to frame this country as its own people already done it. In case you're not aware
@@chintyatjoa1385 eleh kalau mikir secara netral tanpa bawa2 agama pribadi sih pasti setuju apa yang ku bilang. Jelas2 aku protesnya maslaah "judul" menyatakan indonesia, yg kuprotes ini kan 1/33 Provinsi yang menerapkan mestinya ga mewakili indonesia. Kalau anda sinis sih ya saya paham dr komentar anda sebelumnya. Meski saya ngga tau, saya bisa narik kesimpulan jika agama anda psti bukan bagian dr agama mayoritas :)
Each person has opinion based on their paradigma
the video title should be "why are people getting canned in ACEH?"
Well at least Aceh - a province in Indonesia
Its still in indonesia
They dont tell lie, they just dont give u all the information
Thats how society works, ull either manipulated information or get manipulated by other
@@CharDhue but the tittle make Some person fail to understand Like all Indonesian Do that Law
Yups
the title should be " in Aceh province of Indonesia" and aceh Granted a special autonomous status so the local government can practice the sharia law there. unlike other regular province.
As an Indonesian, it's very hard for me to not cringe at the interviewees' responses. A constant reminder that Indonesians still have a lot of growing up to do. Indonesia's infrastructure is steadily developing but the people are still very much infantalised. Not all of course but most.
They're also the kind to oppose our development
I am glad that there are people like you there. i was getting a very bad perception of indoniesio watching this video. Like the young man saying that shaeria law should be implemented thoughout Indonesia, that didn't seem too tolerant or inclusive with minorities.
Why? Not all things that considered normal, not backward i.e. 'up to date' are correct. What if canning does have has strong reasoning base? If the use of canning does have a positive effect and better compared to other method, why should we forbid it? The law exist to foremost prevent unlawful behaviour and canning does just that. Of course there need to be further research on this, but my point is don't just follow something because it's considered normal or modern. Think before first before accusing something. Thanks
@@TrinariZen canning as once normal in Western countries too, they abandoned it, you should follow them because they are obviously smarter.
@@TrinariZen do you think premarital sex should be punished? why? because your "Allah" said so? well not everyone believes in your so called "Allah", and even if they do, why should humans be the one to execute the punishment instead of the almighty "Allah" himself? this is where sharia law breach human rights.
Semi-syariah law. They just do the law (caned) for sexual activity before married, but not for robbery (cutting the hand)... The corrupt Aceh governor go to jail, not getting his hand cutted. So, double standar
Lol the double standard jumped out
ibu2 diatas juga dah jelasin dulu ga se syariah seperti sekarang aceh.. tapi pelan tapi pasti akan menuju ke syariah yang benar2 totalitas..
Gamungkin bisa, gw berani jamin ga akan prnh ada koruptor yg dipotong tangannya, dari dlu smpe kapanpun pasti jongos2 doang yg kena siksa
@@farel-168 lu pastiin kyk gitu emang lu Tuhan cuy.. Semua atas kehendak Tuhan entah itu masuk akal atau tidak.. bisa aja Tuhan berkehendak di luar expektasi kita.. dan itu sering..
@@lastshelter6597 ngapain lu tiba2 ngomongin agama lol
Wanna know something funny?
Stealing - caned
Corruption - not caned
What funnier is coruptor go to jail but STILL CAN GO OUT OR THE ROOM IS LIKE 5STAR HOTEL,,,,😒😒😒😒😒😒😒😒😒😒😒😒😒
@@parkyeol3268 yeah..
And also they can rent any cells (jail) and bring their belongings to the cells..
But only for corruptor..
sorry but actually they just do canned law for forbidden sexual activity, not stealing one.
@@moneyworks3006 actually, theif can be caned or worst, decapitated their hand if they get caught at aceh..
But corruptor can't be caned..
Have you seen Aladin?
Steel from a person, you are a thief
Steal a nation, you are a statesman
Aceh province, it was no big surprise since it was given status of Special Region, that means Aceh has been given Autonomy regarding their law to keep sharia law, it was the same case as Yogyakarta to keep Monarchy to rule the province...
@@mysoulyourbeats8826 oh fellow otaku voh bhi India se 😂🤣
@@mysoulyourbeats8826 Well hi there, nice to see someone so excited haha
Before colonized by holland, aceh is one of ottoman vassal
I like how this comment section are just weebing out, while the others are sparking up debates
@@kiosukeueki lies. before all indonesia are part of a hindu kingdom
This is why countries should separate church and state, people should be able to believe what they want without getting attacked by others
Steven Matthews Religion and state are already separate in Indonesia, it's just that only one Indonesian province follows Sharia law, whereas the rest of Indonesia follows secular law.
@@ekmalsukarno2302 2:40 just got to that part of the video that is interesting haven't heard that before
Why are you bringing church to a Hallal table!? 😂😂😂 This is just sub-humanly stupid!! The average liberal wanabe Voltaire are more disgusting than islamic terrorists.
No they shouldn't, religion especially Islam isn't a religion for books & mosques, it's for PRACTICE.
And huge part of Islam is practicing it in state & laws.
Because of liberal & secular brainwash you might see that backwards, but it keeps the society intact.
Look at all the secular countries & how their moral & family systems are falling.
xtemma How does it not make any sense at all? I just said that only the Acheh province follows Sharia law, whereas all the remaining provinces of Indonesia follow secular law, what's so hard to understand?
In this corrupted society, law can hardly touch high social class people.
I believe someone rich there can have a sex party without being caned publicly
In Indonesia there is a saying:
"Semua orang sama di hadapan hukum, tapi tidak semua orang sama di hadapan aparat hukum."
or can be roughly translated as:
"Everybody is equal by law, but not everybody is equal by law enforcer."
@Maulana Iskandar Very good point.
Maulana Iskandar 😭😂😂😂😂😂
tubester4567 🤣😂😂😂😭😭😂
@Maulana Iskandar 'raped by blacks' sounds a bit prejudice. Anybody can get raped or rape another.
I live in indonesia, where is this interview usually occured? I'd love to be the one that giving different opinion from these people, to save the face of our country. We're not that close minded
unfortunately this was in Jakarta hahahaha most of them still close minded, what a shame
At least there was that one guy from 3:21 who you could tell was answering question with what he really thought but you could also tell he still had to pull it back a little incase he went to far
@@TheShadowofDormin they're afraid with their own religion that's why most of them holding back with their opinion
Honestly this video puts indonesia in bad light. Thanks for saying this. At least there are people who have different opinion on this.
@@manofcultur3191 That's the main point of ANY religions: social behaviour control.
You want to steal, suddenly you don't want because the religion told you not to steal, and vice versa.
Asian boss showing crazy things that happen in Indonesia.
Indonesians: /TRIGGERED/
No im not 😂
i'm indonesian and i'm happy to see other countries starts to know how bad our country are
“muslims indonesian” : /TRIGGERED/
martinus chiu yes so true
martinus chiu finally after all this time evil acts in our country starts to get noticed
Tbh implementing sharia law in indonesia will be an impossible task. Our culture is too varied for it to be accepted in indonesia. Besides, indonesian still uphold local wisdom more than public law
it is not impossible, by seeing the things happening in Indonesia right now. majority of the muslim in Indonesia want sharia law to be implement in our country
@@martinus5747 it's a half half, btw.
martinus chiu no, not majority.
@@martinus5747 not majority tbh
@@multiplayergamer544 more like 60 40
People in the comments trying to defend Indonesia by saying that this is exclusive to the Aceh province and that the rest of the country is more secular, are pretty much telling us that the less Islamic influence on society, the better.
It kinda is the truth, lol. More like, too deep on religion, the wackier it gets, regardless of what religion it is.
You do realize that was wrong would Christianity allow divorce no people still do it or what about budha they still praise statue of only the people and law that matter if you are a Muslim or something it doesn't mean that you have to do all the culture if the law do not imply
Clover Zero islamophobia much?
"Tolerance towards each other's"
StabbyMacStabStab separation of church and state is the only way to go. Religious ppl always find a way to unnecessarily ruin things
Gotta love the very last quote "come to Indonesia...it's not that terrifying"
It's not that terrifying actually.
err, he just mentioned a quote of the Prophet. It doesn't say anything about the reality of how the Muslim behave in Indonesia.
I am terrified to be honest of any place where some ones hands will be cut off because that is taking away some ones livelihood and passion if they need it for an art form. Plus its not just the laws but the kind of culture that breads where people are getting into your business looking to see if you are behaving and to punish you if not. I think I would rather visit the parts of Indonesia, I have muslim friends in parts of my life out side of partying or sex and I know they would be scared to go to most Countries where Sharia law is enforced because they could have some one accuse them of some thing they didn't do and they could be punished
@@moneyworks3006 read the comment properly
@@TheShadowofDormin Aceh don't cut hands, just caning. They're actually horrified with cutting hands
Pancasila is the reason behind Indonesia's unity since years and years ago. So it shouldn't be changed or removed. I still respect Aceh for implementing Sharia Law but let it be in Aceh only not the whole Indonesia.
I don't understand Why people still believe this Law will pass to others places in Indonesia. It only in aceh and Will never be apply to other place since Indonesia is multicultural nation. So different place different law.
I might have to move to other ASEAN countries if sharia are applied to all over indonesia
@@kiyomibear1187 easy peasy...i'll move to Bali if thats really happening hahaha
@@kiyomibear1187 agreed
Sorry sir, but actually Aceh is still a part of Indonesia, and yes it had broke the second point of Pancasila. Seems now Pancasila is just a joke lmao.
I think most of them seem frightened , what would happen if a person living under sharia law actually speak out against it? The reality is that real criminals find a way to evade the law or go around it.
You can try watching the VICE Indonesia's documentary of punk community in Aceh
Watch for a second and says like watching for a whole video. Hahah idiot one
They’re not frightened or afraid that they’ll be caned. Sharia law is only implemented in Aceh, and these interviews are conducted in Jakarta (presumably because journalists are banned from aceh) so there are no direct ramifications to speaking negatively about it. If they’re afraid of anything it’d be the celestial, religious consequence of criticising Allah. Saudi influences on the mosques and Muslim education is disappointingly, ruining the minds of young people. That’s why more of the younger participants seemed more closed minded than the older participants. Lady in the peach hijab said not to judge a book by its cover yet agrees that cutting off someone’s hand if they steal, or public caning for acts like gay sex and extramarital affairs is the right way to do things. There certainly is irony in that.
Edit for a correction: I apologise for misspeaking it was always taught to me as a child in Indonesia by my mother as a hand that would be cut off for stealing. If it is just a finger then I stand corrected. Perhaps it was just an exaggeration to scare me further. Nevertheless I retain that maiming someone for a petty crime like theft is a grossly exaggerated punishment.
@@jasminegulliver3250 wait a minute cutting head for theievery? Not hand?
That one kid at 1:36 looked scared because he didn't know all of sharia law, reminded me of a teacher asking the kid who wasn't paying attention all class to explain what they just learned. But yeah the lady in the black hat, people who had old people next to them, pretty much every one looked liked they had allot more they wanted to say on most o those questions
"It would be like Saudi Arabia so not that terrifying" OK...
@Smash 456 wasabism? What next? Chillism or pepperism?
@Smash 456 yes I'm wasabism I very wrong and goes against thing that are stated in the quran.
tuomopoika oh please tell me how are you “pretty sure” that men are allowed to rape women in saudi ? 😂!!! That’s funny cuz I’m Saudi living in Saudi Arabia and I can assure you that this is not allowed or acceptable whatsoever!😂
@@ranasrana3800
According to Wikipedia:
"Rape is a criminal offense under sharia with a wide range of penalties from flogging to execution. The law does not recognize spousal rape as a crime."
The source is from 2017 so it might have changed. However this seems to be the law in vast majority of Muslim countries.
If you have some better source that says othervise I am happy to take a look. You living in Saudi-Arabia is not a source though.
@@ranasrana3800 His only reference is the Aladin cartoon and 101 night children book i guess...
Me in Bali: "wow indonesia is awesome!"
Me in Aceh: "i wanna go home"
THEY WILL HAUNT YOOOU
@VALIR THE FIRE BOY but live there is like living in Brunei!
Haha bali, u just know the beach not all bali culture
@@sangpenyebar5988 i know a lot about hindus
@@uzochiokeke4328 haha... Really??? Hindu india is different then hindu bali
at any time, westerners will never understand a topic like this. they are used to living freely and even most of them don't even have religion. they are not used to seeing things like this
Indonesia has 34 provinces and just 1 province practice that caned and the title is wHy aRe PeOpLe GeTtInG CaNeD iN iNdOnEsIa? love asian boss
Its still part of Indonesia is it not?
@@KyLe-fn5rd
As it is applied all over the country? Just stay where you are heartless westerners
Muhammad Rizky Fernanda do you agree with Quran? The Quran explicitly says to kill the apostates, do you agree with this ?
@@KyLe-fn5rd true
These people are crazy. They'll do and support anything that their religion says so. So that means, death for apostasy, death for homosexuality, not making friends with people of other religions, treating them like second class citizens, allowing men to beat their wives, only giving women half the wealth that a man gets, making them cover themselves,etc.
"Because of I'm a Muslim so I should follow Sharia law"
*End of her education
@INDIA IS SUPERPOWER please change your name mate
Yes, because that rules created by our god allah, and its mention in our scripture al quran
And we as a muslim should obey and follow our god's commandement and rules.
We live in this world only for a test for the next life.
The one who believe in islam and practicing islam
They will go to paradise.
That is our believe
And you should respect it as i respect your believe.
We can live our life as our religion teach us.
And you can also live your life as your religion teach.
Just respect each other and dont force other people to think as the same as your thought.
Because we use this rules in our country not in your country.
cambo fm Idiot education means the life of democracy and human right, Education means to be a man who can take decision by his own mind irrespective of religious beliefs,
Well you are also a muslim so you too are uneducated
@Zeli Ang that was what i was telling him. These people live inside a bubble.
@@adhisharavind6393
Yeah 😂
this syaria law is only implemented in one province in indonesia (Indonesia has total 34 provinces), that's called Aceh. And it's only about 1/32 area of Indonesia.
The video makes that abundantly clear.
Yeaah its about 1/34 actually hehe
Yea but applied to non muslim too
@@Reenzia Nope, the sharia law is only mandatory for muslim. If there is any non muslims does any crime, he/she can choose whether to be prosecuted based on sharia law or based on Kitab Undang2 Hukum Pidana/KUHP (nation's criminal code)..
Argue all you want but deep down all know that it's only matter of time
Infact that's what you been taught in your holy mosques that you should kill disbelievers and entire globe should follow your pedofile
Girl be like OPEN UR MIND, GET A BROAD PERSPECTIVE AND THEN YOU WILL REALIZE GETTING CANNED IS TOATALLY FINE... PEACE GUYS
Girl gonna get canned if she says anything else so it's somewhat understandable
So having sex with anyone outside of marriage is okay...jeez...a society full of diseases...dirty
The convicted didn't get canned for no reason, they're broke the law and got canned as punishment
You may think getting punishment for sex before marriage is obnoxious, but remember, every country has its own value and moral as such some country doesn't allow its citizen to have egg-shaped-chocolate in their country, other killing cow is a sin
@@akmalfahrezzy3072 yup...most ppl who criticized sharia law doesnt even understand the concept of Sharia...and about killing cow is a sin...i know watcha talkin about..its India...Ironically India is the biggest cow exporter..
Akmal Fahrezzy Why didn't the man also get caned? Didn't he break the law too?
You should have gone to that specific city and done this
You'd be seen as heathen
That’s impossible
Oh no, I'm about to worrying their life
Yet another reason why people are distancing themselves from religion. This is barbaric. This should not be legal under civil rights to be punished under "religious law". It isn't fair. It isn't right. This should not happen. Period.
Weed 2 humanity🤭🤫🤐
Not all religions, specifically Islam. I recommend acts 17 apologetics and the apostate prophet they’re pretty good when it comes to the violence in Islam
Someone with a healthy mind. Thanks god.
If you are not Indonesian nor that you know informations or what's been with Indonesia best you be silent as you do not represent the entirety of the people here. Once again your comment and the topic that you brought up does NOT apply
In short, there's no separation of church and state.
WzOc *mosque LOL
A good video on why Islam is dangerous in the West, it's incompatible with Western values
r r not literally oh please 😅
@@tytube3001 Yes and still europe is getting flooded by muslims and europeans are expected to sit back and watch. (:
You should do this interview to people with different background. So that, you can get the answer more specific with many opinion.
Sorry for my bad English by the way.
Hi -sorry for my bad English
Why are all the Indonesia videos so negative. First ISIS then polygamy and now this Indonesia is one of the most liberal Muslim countries. It's like there's an agenda here.
As an Indonesian I actually agree with the topics they picked. It's almost impossible to have discussion due to the "taboo" labels we pin on them. It's actually nice for me to listen to several opinions although most of the negative ones do not surprise me. These topics being talked about is a first small step.
There’s so many good side of Islam that they can talk about... But, they decided not to, and the comment section is really toxic-
I'm indonesian and as someone that's not very religious (even tho i still do the basic prayers everyday) i wouldn't want to go to places that have a very strong religious influence in their area like aceh. There's other places like bali, lombok, papua, and others that're more interesting and diverse. Earlier this year i went to bali and they have the most chill and open minded people there. Even though i'm muslim and the majority people in bali are not, they still give us direction when we asked where's the mosque is placed. I definately think religion should be a personal matter because we saw multiple times when people start to mixed it with politics or laws it became a mess and only divide people which can make them resent each other. Even though majority are muslim there's still people with other religion that live here and i wish islam as a majority didn't act like the boss. I really wish sharia law stays only in aceh and never penetrate to bigger and more famous city such as jakarta because if it does, we're in a lot of trouble.
True. We have to cautiously avoid arab influences. What was good in medival times is no longer applicable.
Youre a good muslim. May god bless you :)
@@dsarah60 and muslim as followed the holy book is bad muslim??? Haha so good...
Why don't you want to? What's the problem in Aceh? I'm comfortable here and happy... Unlike in Aceh, outside Aceh the crime rate is very high.
@@sangpenyebar5988 lol wdym?
BTW on 0:40 the lady said "biasa aja" which actually means "i'm indifferent" in daily conversation. instead of direct translation of "its common" which would have been "itu sudah biasa" in daily conversation usage.
Translation isn't a piece of cake to do. That mistake is intolerable
@@qiqirizkyfernanda6848 it's totally misleading.
Ikr i was like wait what
Kamu tolol
many don't understand, sharia law in Aceh is the result of GAM rebellion, their demands are 2, give their province special autonomy or they will separate themselves from Indonesia and form their own country, the current situation is the result of the MoU Helsinki between GAM (Aceh Free Movement) and the Indonesian government. So if you don't know anything, stop barking
The man told this in the interview 4:00
Why didn't they just let them go then?? Whats the worst thing could happen if aceh seperate itself from indonesia?
@@alsimanche deeper issue is raised. We want all provinces to be still with nation clearly because they have resources. It's also political game. Just like when Britain didnt want Ireland and Scotland seperate years ago.
@@alsimanche bc indonesia needed aceh. Indonesia was really lack on military stuffs when the second expansion of dutch colony so aceh helped indonesia so that indonesia could buy a plane for diplomacy and etc. So indonesia couldn't let go aceh easily. Besides that aceh has alot of nature resources that can give alot of benifits for indonesia.
@@iinmuthmainnah9126 why samudra pasai's language was Malay not Acehnese?
They two guys at 1:03: “she should be punished for doing sex before marriage”. So the guy doesn’t need to be punished????
nope the guy will be punished too
no in Islam the guy would be punished as same as woman, he was just talking about that specific case he was asked about were there was a woman committed that sin
The man is punished the exact same way
Both girl and boy :v
@@el-mm3lb which is why we don't have things like aids and divorce and the married couple love each other not cheat each other like you're society
5:33 "The last election was...very much based on identity politics." *SIGH* Yours too, huh?
Basically happens in every country. Like India with Hinduism, US with race, etc
It's sad but true
Adawg420 I guess Islam is problem everywhere from Europe, China, India to Indonesia.
@Hartono then what do you think as a good system?
Picking up random dude from your religion and labelling him a Khalifa? Erasing representative of every member of society by favoring your side only?
Tell me, please!
@Hartono lol didn't you agree that those are part of so called democracy?
You explaining democracy branches won't change any nuance.
Stop using fallacies to excuse yourself out of your own misstatement.
Someone staying in a gray area like you is actually the one who worsen the status quo.
Anyway, meritocracy works under "direct democracy", counter balance does exist in the system. Trias politica complement one another with society as their total supervisor.
So under your world, how does your version of democracy fills up its chain, again? Who chooses the ones you said capable of choosing anyone capable of leading the country?
It's the society, right?
I don't know what you're running from.
They punish common people yet they ignore their corrupt governor. Talking about double standards..
Any corrupted individual left unpunished in this world will be dealt with an even far.....more severe punishment in the afterlife.
@@yellowbeez93 what if they won't?
@@Rand3mAnclrew
They will. No one can escape Allah's punishment including Death.
@@yellowbeez93 if so why are you prosecuting people on Earth? just a excuse to overlook real crimes...
Terr Di well.. we live in this world.. not in the afterlife.. if thats the case, just abolish every law and wait until afterlife for those suckers to get punished
Western countries are not an example nor a standard, can people let this country with their own laws ??! If people dont accept it they simply leave Aceh
Chahid Chahid okay then if we in the west ban Islam you can’t be mad cuz it’s our laws
Well the west is certainly much much better.
@@jacoblang7840 who talked about banning christians or something, we are talking about canning
Chahid Chahid well, you said if a country makes laws you don’t like, leave the area. Don’t like canning? Leave. Don’t like that we don’t want Muslims? Leave. According to your logic we can ban certain religions and no one can complain because you can just leave
Cringe at the lady who said that it's justified to cut someone's hand for robbery... You know... that probably won't stop anyone from stealing if they are struggling... and cutting body parts are just as inhuman asf... imagine if you got wrongly accuse of anything... You lose your limbs and what... Backward mindset always uses brutality and fear for control.
Then death penalty is the same too how inhuman can you be to take someone else life 🙃
@@kyumazu1926
Then why Islam also allow death penalty if the victim's family agree to it?
U know qisas right?eye for an eye?
BeaMonz That won’t happen. The shariah law gives out zakat to the poor so people wouldn’t need to steal.
@BeaMonz true
Please educate yourself in Islamic law before spewing nonsense again
That is no law. That is not just. It's cruelty under the pretense of religion
Toby islamophobia much?
So you would rather religion remove punishment?
If Islam doesn't punish anyone who breaks the law, you think that's more humane?
@@yellowbeez93 I'd rather live in a country with secular laws which punish whoever commits a crime. Besides, sharia isn't just a legal system, it's a way to regulate private and public life for everyone, with things that seem taken from 400 or 500 years ago.
it's just a excuse to watch people suffering, they are just sadists, if the islamics was true concerned about crime the islamics countries wouldn't be corrupt poor shitholes.
@@yellowbeez93 yes, because you can't just force your religion just to everyone and anyone, everyone has their own beliefs of what is right and wrong, thus law should not be based on religion, but rather human rights, because everyone has the same rights (but different religions).
Islam feels so anti-choice to me. I live in Aceh. My parents are muslims, so even before I knew how to think for myself, they indoctrinated me into the religion. Stuff like, "You'll go to hell if you don't listen to me (parents.)" But now that I'm an adult and can decide for myself, I no longer am trapped in the Islamic bubble of subconscious fear. Though I'm considered an apostate, I've never really chosen the religion out of my own accord. My family doesn't know yet. I don't make it public since it might threaten my life. Hopefully, I can leave this stifling city in the near future and finally live in peace. Thanks to AsianBoss for doing this interview. Some of the responses sadden me because I can understand where they're coming from, being taught to think in a certain way from a very young age. I'd love more Indonesian content from you, AsianBoss. Cheers.
@arif mark007 Haha, keren! Bakalan dipikirin deh. Trims :)
@@acelouerium7100 surabaya, malang, bali, and salatiga is the best place if you are looking for tolerance. Lets hope the rest of indonesia can follow their footsteps
@@TheWorldsMyth Yes, let's! Thank you for the info ^^
Who said that "you're going to hell if you don't listen to your parents"? Have you ever going to "ngaji", kid? Millions of Acehnese Muslims have not converted because what you said, you must have a problem in your brain.
Takut apaan tinggal di Aceh nak? Saya orang Aceh sangat nyaman dan senang disini. Diluar Aceh angka kriminal sangat tinggi. Kamu keluar Aceh karena hukum syariah saya ga percaya itu. Kalopun itu menakutkan tentu saya keluar Aceh juga dari sekarang.
If you love Indonesia and you think you are going to commit any crimes against Sharia law- than go to Bali. It's the best holiday destination ever- do whatever you like- just don't kill anyone.
@Jong Jonnot just Bali, other Indonesian provinces except Bali don't have Sharia law. Bali isn't special
Stupid islamic fuckwits
Im indonesian. This is just one of the things people do under their community. Indonesian law itself never allowed such a punishment
Apa-apa selalu “Saya Indonesian, ...blabla... ini kami tidak setuju ...blabla... ” merendahkan sesama bangsa. Kalian memalukan.
Saya translate kan yang saya tulis ya seperti nya anda tidak mengerti bahasa inggris. " saya orang Indonesia. Ini hanya hukuman yang dilakukan dibawah forum atau komunitas tertentu (dalam hal ini agama) tapi hukum di Indonesia sendiri tidak ada yang mengijinkan hukuman seperti ini (hukum cambuk didepan umum). Dari penjelasan saya harusnya saya bukan menghina bangsa sendiri tapi malah menjelaskan agar orang diluar sana tidak salah paham dan beranggapan Indonesia negara yang melakukan hukuman cambuk didepan umum seperti ini yang dimana hukuman sepeti ini dianggap hal yang melanggar hak asasi manusia diluar sana. Apakah penjelasan ini dapat dimengerti dengan baik bapak yang terhormat?
@@muhammadfajri3712 anda kenapa
@@muhammadfajri3712 perlu gw beliin pembalut ga lu?
Muhammad Fajri sakit jiwa ya bro?? Hhhh
Reminds me of the outrage in the United States when 18 year old Michael Fay was subject to caning in Singapore for theft and vandalism. Caning women however, is a whole another thing.
Vandalism is a very serious crime in Singapore. Women are more protected by law. Theft has varying degrees of seriousness.
Hello again
हानासाकी सं हर देश के अपने-अपने कानून होते हैं। जो दूसरे देशों के नज़रिए से अजीब लगते हैं।
भारत मे खुलेआम मूतना ठीक है लेकेन खुलेआम चोदना गैर कानूनी। पश्चिमी देशों में ठीक इसका उल्टा।
खुदी सोचो जापान में क्या आप चड्डी पहन के काम पे जा सकती हैं? जबकि अमरीका मे किसी औरत को ऐसा मना करने से आपपर कानूनी कारवाही की जा सकती है।
ameasdf a bit disclaimer but men and women if peer to peer and have equal standing, both of them will be canned.. It will be different case if you are a political figure like head of mosque or goverment official or someone with good conection or power.
In my personal opinion, I agree with you, Having sex as long there is CONSENT, should not be limited with law
@@ubuntuber1619 Except that isn't the reason why people are caned. lel. A lot of the women caned are VICTIMS of rape.
sharia law is 7 century law and not compatible with modern society and even though they said it only implemented in aceh,it's creeping through Indonesia and according pew research 72% Indonesia muslim support sharia as the official law of the Land.
sharia doesn't support woman right,minority right nor Human Right(even muslim),a Democratic sharia law is an oxymoron.
what's differences between 7 century and 21 century? only technology
robbery still there
killing still there
corruption still there
sex before marriage still there
so what's differences actually?
@@ajinkyathorat7502 can you please prove that minorities suffer in sharia law countries? plus, YES you can do or be all what you mentioned in any Islamic country without getting punished as you think, yet that doesn't mean it's a good thing to do, otherwise it won't be forbidden in Christianity and Judaism as well!
oh and about robers they don't get there hand cut off since very long time now they go to jail just like everywhere... I can't really blame you for thinking like that, thanks to TV that so many people thinks like you and that because you have got the wrong information's ONLY from yellow news and TV. Trust me it's not like that. please try to understand everything from the RIGHT source before you judge, Islam is not only one thing it's a complete system.
@@Omer20508
Nope, you couldn't.
You cannot be gay under sharia law. People still get their hand cutt of plus Saudi's just punished 3 moderate sunil Muslim.
Egypt does not have sharia law, they still banned atheism Sharia law is evil in any way you put it.
@@ajinkyathorat7502 Nope your information's are mostly wrong and here is why. 1st yes you can not be gay in Islam,Christianity and Judaism as well. But if you are gay no one will hurt you because of sharia law but people will criticize you because of the culture and if you show it so badly then yes you might be hurt because it's not acceptable in the Arabic culture to be gay, yet if you gay you can live normally just don't show it out and no one will care about you, so many gays exists in all Arabic and they live in this way.
People might still get their hand cut of in Saudi Arabia
ONLY (out of 57 Islamic country) yet if the king say this should stop it will stop even in sharia law this is possible because not only Muslims live in these country's. so it's the people and not the religion.
and NO there is no such a thing in like banned atheism in Egypt, the prove is there is so many Egyptian TH-cam channels speaks about atheism even in TV and they even make a lot of money and have big mount of people fallowing them to speak and discuss this topic and yet no one hurts them, they are free and they keep doing it from inside Egypt.
They only way that they get banned is when they turn there channel to hate speech and ask people aggressively to leave Islam,Christianity and Judaism as well. Because no one has right to do so.
fyi in Islam you are free to believe and do anything you wont as long as you don't hurt people in any way and you do respect them and their culture.
its very clear that most of your information's are wrong or extremely limited again thanks to TV and Toxic news, finally if "Sharia law is evil in any way you put it" as you said then why 1,800,000,000 Muslim around the world stick in Islam in both Islamic and non-Islamic country's like US and UK and more? and why Islam is keep growing more and more in non-Islamic country's ? think and read about it from the RIGHT source before you give the answer.. Good luck.
Oday Aubaidy
Islam is growing because of birth rates not because of conversion. I'm pretty sure there's more people leaving Islam than joining it. We will never sadly get any sort of news about that because most of them are still in the closet.
Something being in Judaism or Christianity does not make it okay. They're both shitty old religions as well used to control people. Please use better reasoning.
The Quran and the thousands of hadiths that exist out there contradict themselves sometimes.
In one verse or hadith it could say that you can do whatever you want unless you harm someone and in others it would be the absolute opposite.
If you want to I wouldn't mind a debate around Islam as long as it stays civil. Goes for both you and me.
Indonesia has a long history and many background!
Religion
Islam, Christianity, Protestant, Buddha, Hindu, Catholicism
Many Ethic groups
And many diversity of thought
Even more than simple left and right too!
Christianity dan Protestan different nya what ?
Wait christianity and catholism is different?
@@definzgoody5448 its different In Christian they usually didn't do symbol of cross when praying like Chatolic do
@@user-no7es3ue9i
Those are just man-made religion guys . Let's convert to Islam 💓👌
@@definzgoody5448
Islam is also man made religion.
i dont know why but i just feel asian boss try to portray indonesia as a radical country
@maya bakary i dont have any problem with the topic, but the way they deliver the info pissed me off
@maya bakary because they say, they just want to discover how "ordinary indonesians" feel about this issue but give question that need deep understanding about sharia law and this could be misleading. i think they should include expert answers to avoid that misleading information.
basically, in Indonesia minorities can't always do much.. 😥 things that always intersect with religion will turn out to be a big problem later on.
America did same for the minority...im very shocked what Trump did. However im not muslim, and i think not all moeslem are bad.
They can say "your God is naked" but we can't even say "teachers treat Muslim and non-muslim differently" aight let them do whatever they want. you're not a sinner just because you're Christian, and you won't get a free pass to heaven, just because you're a Muslim.
@_Rim fire_ lol but this isn't even abt money or position. Since u don't know the foundation of our country, you don't know why I say all religions should be treated the same
@@user-vt1ml7tb3k we can't get free pass. We have to do good. Because nobody sacrificed for us by dying on the cross, remember?
We all have to do good!
@@Princess-di2zx Christians don't get a free pass to heaven and we also have to be good people
Lmao women shouldn’t have sex outside of marriage 🤦🏻♀️ guys are never punished for doing such why should women.
Right!?!?
I've been waiting for anyone to mention what about the other person the woman had sex with? Nobody mentioned about it.
both of them are punished..
It applies both ways lol what an ignorant.
If she has sex outside religion she is most probably have to change her religion or her kids will be of her boyfriend /husband's religion (which islam doesn't accept and they can't grow in numbers)
And when a guy does that to non muslim well he is getting more ppl into their religion
And thats how they're growing
Traya lmao. Calling me ignorant. It does not apply both ways equally. Men be walking outside wearing whatever the hell they want but women have to be all covered up. Where TF does it “apply both ways”?
I think, its okay if asian boss want to talk about this sensitive issue about Indonesia, but it would be really helpful if they also invite an expert in this area to talk about this. Not just asking random people in the street.
The point of the video is to understand what random peoples mindset is toward this matter
@paisleyyama assian boss did invite an expert or people who directly involved in an issue before tho. But i do get your point. I just concerned with how people will missunderstood about indonesia and Islam. bc this issue and such as polygamy is a tricky issue.
@@andeszheiddinne706 what particular misunderstanding are you worried about?
@@ArtistProtagonist Sharia law is not as simple as you think. There are many procedures to be done. It's not as simple as punishing anyone who violates, However, the story behind it must also be investigated.For example, the law of whipping or stoning for adulterers cannot be done just like that. There must be 4 witnesses that must be brought in unless the perpetrator admits it himself. However, perpetrators are also not required to report these actions.
"Open your mind" says in english the woman who supports the Sharia Law, and wants to sound smart. A law that says "Criticizing or denying any part of the Quran is punishable by death". How ironic.
That lady saying Saudi Arabia is still open mined made me laugh
its getting better than the previous years though
Unlike in the US, people in Indonesia don't have sex before marriage and it is very forbidden, but only Aceh there are punishments, not in the other 33 provinces
@Riceee Balls for a fact I've heard of kids getting pregnant before marriage
@@prinxd fyi it just happend in several state, the other state not used to sex before marriage. Browse baby browse, be grateful that u have access to the internet.
I think the point of these videos was to show perspectives of people from around the world(mostly Asia), so that people from different backgrounds can become more open minded and understanding of their culture.
But more of the recent topic have become a tad bit "touchy". If possible, I want to suggest a longer intro that explains a bit more about the topic's background history, and how it lead to the ways things are the way they are now.
Agree. They need to explain a proper context first.
@@najkazu That's your thing then. I thought the purpose of Asian Boss is to introduce some differences cultures in Asia. Once you decided that it doesn't fit your logic, you ask, not debate. Religion & cultural issues are something you can't address without a proper context. Just because people don't understand or agree with something it doesn't mean people have to debate about it. Asking some questions is one thing. Asking to debate is another thing.
Wew i also agree
But i feel like (i may be 100% wrong)
If they have other topics to discover it will involve religion which i think this channel dont wanna show that and many people wont be interested in that too
I have also seen a trend that when indonesians speak (ofc not all)
Some of them always brings religion into it
Sharia law just can be implemented according to several factors. For example if someone steal something they can only be punnished based on some condition one of them is they steal not because they hungry. If the suspect steal because of poverty and the amount no more than 1/4 dinar ( 1 dinar around 2.500.000 IDR) the suspect should not be punnished. It's goverment role to protect the suspect and give them appropiate jobs. Fyi, each province in Indonesia they have own otonomy which means the Indonesia goverment give the authority to province to manage their land and system. Aceh region, in my opinion, they really into to Islamic practice, they know what, how and why this law implemented. Unfortunately, Asian boss did'nt give enough explanation and directly from the trust source , I think you guys need more research than just asking people randomly. Feel free to discuss. Thank you.
Your opinion sounds really ridiculous to me - and I don’t normally argue with some ridiculous opinions whatsoever. You mentioned ‘dinar’.. what does it have to do with Indonesia???? Indonesian currency is Rupiah, Dinar has NOOOTHIINGGGG to do with Indonesia - ROTFL.
@@matthieuahmed8318 just convert it to dirham then rupiah, Islam acknowledge dinar.
@@nindyaindah1149 .
If the man was also punished for having sex before marriage i could respect this. It's like the ban on drugs or abortion. I don't like it but i can respect it.
Yes,, ofc men punished for having sex before marriage too..
Of course
Punish someone just because you do not like what she did is wrong, if two people consented to have sex before marriage is their problem, but I know it is part of the culture and traditions, the culture of the West is more take care of your life
This is just what I think
(I don't speak english very well)
@@GDconta yeah but if i consent to get myself filled with coccaine then its my problem why should the country punish me for doing drugs then?
Law is made for good, I am Muslim and I come and live in Aceh, then am I afraid of caning or is sharia law terrible? The answer is not at all. The punishment applies to those who do wrong and I feel that sharia law has a deterrent effect on the perpetrators of crime. And I think that whatever form of law (which is made for good) if it is implemented will certainly create a peaceful environment. And I hope the media do not exaggerate more in telling something without being so understanding about the issue, I keep thinking why outsiders are so scared of sharia punishment, Even though we who are within the scope of the law feel safe and peaceful, I hope we can respect each other, the law is there to govern us in the good way, just follow our each other rules whatevr form it is. Make a better world. Greetings of peace!
What type of law is that such a garbage indonesians was a Hindu business country and under these two u can feel secure and freedom their is no restriction on clothing, all genders are equal etc
Every kind of work have a rule, also how do you live you have a rule right? Then that's our rule, why being so overthinking? They canned only in a day(5 times min. To 150 times max.) but they don't go to the jail, it just what punishment they can decide to receive
@@muhammadalaidinsyah 5mins really u r so called prophet can have sex slaves marry a six year old ,says beating wife is good
See if u believe in god I have no problem but believing in some stupid human made book is foolishness every human is given a brain and heart to think and feel to use common sense
@@aptituderec1120 that's what I always heard from people without knowledge, talk a lot and do not think critically and are lazy to learn and find out
@@aptituderec1120 cause human have a brain with its extraordinary ability should use to thinking about what to say and act, and how about u? Have u use that stuff?
Asian Boss, please make an interview on western countries asking them about Palestine. Israel have been killing people there from a long time ago until now. I am very curious what western people think about Palestine and Israel. Thank you
Too much watching Pallywood
@@epg96 and are you bothered by that ?
Israel punish no one for no reason at all , yesterday Israel blasted out 2 Palestinian schools , and people like you went crazy but that was the same school who used to launch rockets at midnight on northern part of Israel which cause few people lives . Keep it up with that fake tears.
@paisleyyama There must be a reason
Dear Asian Boss, could you please have the interview in other cities but Jakarta? You guys need to know more diverse opinions.
Yang interview tentang isis intervieenya di malang
The problem is that even non-Muslims are punished according to Shariah law. An elderly Christian woman is publicly caned for selling alcohol. 2 Buddhist men are also publicly caned for gambling. It is ok to use Sharia law if the offenders are Muslims. It is unfair to punish non-Muslims using Islamic Sharia law.
They live in muslim lands so they should follow the law of islam
@@franca9995Indonesia belongs to all religion. If Indonesia is only for muslim then west papua and bali should be given freedom. Those are of other religion.
Singapore also canes people and it is not a Muslim country, in fact, caning is a remnant of British colonialism. Way to fuel Islamophobia with this one.
Islam topic are popular bruh, and it attracts views. More views=more 💵💵💵
@@mbatayneh1299 yes they do
These punishments are in quram hadeeths. Including stoning. Your whataboutism erase what islam is
Thanks Asian boss show us what Uncivilized behavior look like.
Seeing couples where the woman is all covered up and the man is wearing whatever he wants - t-shirt, shorts, hair out - walking together so casually makes me sick to my stomach.
@@KimchiYeo 👍😂
Same lol
How Asian Boss represent a southeast asian countries:
Show them their countries' non-western ideology and them being Southeast Asians
Dear Asian Boss, I'm from Indonesia and want to give you a suggestion for your better contents. If the content that you want to talk 'bout is related with "religion", you must interview THE EXPERT about that things. Because this brings the image of a country and is related to religion, you must be careful in choosing interviewees. Thank you. 🙂
to be honest, we can all agree that there are two types of people in Indonesia. The one who think we should implement the Sharia Law in Indonesia and then there's the one who keeps holding on (desperately) to Pancasila (The real patriots 💛)
i don't know about yall but Pancasila was made for a reason so don't freaking change it :)
and guys, we Indonesians have a lot of culture here and idk about other culture, but my culture here won't ever allow this to happen lmao.
come to manado, north celebes. you'll see the difference, we're literally like the americans of Indonesia, a lot more free for sure.
I think you should interview more varieties of Indonesian people from different ethnic groups
Indonesia has so many districts and long history so everyone cant just judge it by its cover
But it's all on the cover....with all the blank pages underneath
It's a shithole of a country to be honest.
If only those corrupt gov’t officers in Aceh also got their hands chopped for stealing 🤷🏻♀️
This video had some holes I'm not used to from Asian Boss.
I feel the same as you too. I don't know about this, CORRECT ME IF I'M WRONG, but I think because the interviewee are mostly muslims? From my view, the young man with moustache and goatee in black shirt, and the first woman that first appeared in the video are the ones that I'm not sure whether they're muslims or not. I mean it's good to get the opinions from muslims themselves, but does it really stand for "ordinary Indonesians"? I'm not judging or anything, I'm an Indonesian myself. In my opinion, the interviewer can be more selective in choosing the interviewee so it can be more diversed.
Handy Soap Wikipedia states that Jakarta has 83.43% of Muslims so kinda hard to find anyone that’s not Muslim
@@eorzeal non-muslims that voice their opinions were jailed, do you think they'd want to be on interviews regarding sharia?
@@yanggang7828 Well, I'm just sharing my opinion on why the video had some holes in it. Chill out. Your reason does make sense tho.
@@LeeZX Oh yea, it's true. And they have to ask for permission too if they did find one. Not everyone want their face to be on the internet lol.
Im muslim and didnt want sharia law applied in Indonesia.
As an Indonesian Muslim, I must say: Honestly fck this bs called sharia law.
As an Indonesian Chatolic fellow, if this law applied in all Indonesia province , i'll definitely change my nationality 😂.
Even i'm not planning to do any wrong doings, it's just so scarry to watch someone caned in public (or getting another kind of punishment in public places)
@@harayukiaimi7689 me too you are not alone ... XD
@arif mark007 @Zo Honey 😂 i'm glad that i'm not the only one who think this way
Some critical translation is not accurate. Like "Buka pemahaman" is NOT "Open your mind" is actually more like "Get a better understanding"
Who the hell cares?? Their land, their belief, their own rules
they keep saying not to judge sharia law based on what we see and hear about it on the internet yet they've all confirmed that what it is said about it on the internet is very much TRUE. Wtf is wrong with these people.
bcs the problem is islam religion itself teaching hate and still they say its peaceful the most brainwashed people on earth are only muslims no wonder why islamic countries never achieved something or invented for the world.bcs they still living in stone age and following fake religion practices.
I live under sharia law and there are many many conditions that need to be applied for a punishment to go through. That man and woman that had sex out of marriage had to have 4 witnesses see them do it to get punished. Plus the witnesses have their own conditions such as being of a certain age and aren't crazy and honest people. That was all not mentioned in the video yet you say you know everything about sharia law? Huh.
@@user-rx7uh9mg4f was the man punished as well?? If the woman had sex without being married, then so did the man she had sex with!! Why does the video only mention the woman being punished? Plus, your comment has absolutely nothing to do with mine. What you hear on the internet about sharia law is still true and confirmed by everyone. You have not disproven any of it. Physically beating someone because they had sex out of marriage, witnesses or not is completely insane, goes against human rights, makes absolutely no sense at all and so on.
@@vsdude007 yup, you are right!! It's beyond obvious to anyone with half a brain!
I always thought Indonesia was Buddhist or hindu or something like that.... I always thought it was similar to Thailand..... Oh my perspective is changed now... I am never going to Indonesia... Thailand looks way more cool to me.. Now.
They used to be a Hindu/Buddhist country a long ass time ago, but when they started trading with the Muslim merchants they adopted Islam. There are still small populations of Hindus and Buddhists throughout the country, in places like the island of Bali you can see a Hindu majority.
On a side note, you can visit Bali.. it's a hindu province, so no need to worry.. plus, Bali is amazing :D
Seeker aroma
are u kidding? Most women there wear those long ass hijabs
@@yuccaafifah see dude i am gay... I know they don't make a big deal out of it in Philippines and Thailand... I am not sure I am going to take risks like these with my partner.. In Indonesia.
@@exstalle2736 Ohh I thought it was their cultural dress... Never knew it's that Islamic hijab thingy.
I'm so ashamed for that people respon... And the part that woman talk about saudi arabia is very cringe
i hate saudi arabian, and isis country
the comments section shows how different opinions indonesian people have about the sharia law, while in the video, peole kind of agree with the sharia law, indonesian people in the comment section... not.
sharia law only applied in 1 provinces from all 36 provinces in Indonesia, and the law is not fully implemented, since there should not be any sharia law that contradict the government's law (i.e stoning to death because of adultery, cutting hand for thievering, or beheading is not applied, since it contradict the human rights law in indonesia)
so i consider the sharia law in aceh is only, a "lite" version,.
and because the increasing mockery from indonesian people about aceh sharia law, the acehnese people are starting considering to do a referendum to separate them from Indonesia.
the problem is, even if many people don't want aceh to associated with indonesia, the government can't afford to lose aceh to a referendum, since aceh have a vast amount of natural resources, be it liquid gas, oil,gold, and agriculture. some sources say aceh is contributing up to 8% of Indonesia yearly revenue in national budget(APBN).
that's why aceh is given special autonomy to implement sharia law in the first place.
aceh won't lose much to a referendum, because socially, acehnese people are more closer to indonesia neighbouring country, Malaysia.
utsman zulhakim I think one of the reasons as to why the comment section show such different opinions is because it’s a different demographic? They mainly filmed around the streets and outdoors while the Indonesians who are commenting are doing so in English, onto a channel that’s quite international so a lot of them probably had the kind of education that allowed for open minded thinking? I’ve said it before but I really wished the team would’ve interviewed people in areas such as a mall or educational institution to get a range of responses. And yeah you’re super right about everything Aceh related, I actually didn’t know they contributed such a large amount in revenue that’s super interesting.
@@kellenbudilay8305 imho even if they interviewed more of the "open minded" people, im.pretty sure the response will be kind of a diplomatic one, they wont say outright they refuse sharia law openly. And honestly jakarta is quite diverse enough, because you can watch a mosque full of devout muslims doing prayer while having a pork bbq with a prostitute in a night market lol.
Yeah aceh is very important to the indonesian government both geographically and strategically.
But right now, its kinda like a hate love relationship between aceh, indonesian government, and other indonesian people outside of aceh.
utsman zulhakim definitely agree though I’m sure it’ll at least be able to portray Indonesians in a more accurate light as opposed to the responses we received in this video. Even a diplomatic response can have overtones of a more logical reasoning even if they won’t explicitly say that they disagree. Pretty happy to see how a lot of people are vocalizing their opinions in the comment section, though!
Definitely have to look into the Aceh thing more thoroughly I feel so misinformed. Thanks mate!
This is why humanity can not progress, some of us are still living in the past, according to a rulebook of the past.
adultry and prostitution is illegal in Indonesia ,
and anybody caught indulged in prostitution will be punished by Canning in Public ,
If any body has problem with this ,then he should avoid doing sex out of marriage ,
specially in Indonesia ,
because soon this canning punishment will going to introduced in all over indonesia ,not only in Acheh province .
@@freethinker9630Hii idiot. People like you should be jailed. Followers of evil book. Prostitution is wrong. But what people do consensually is non of your business.
Simple, just don’t live in aceh.. problem solved 😂
Yah running from the problem is a nice solution!!
@@Ariyan300 umm well if considering how India handle their problem i guess you would be hypocrite
@@kryowl nice try but the way india facing their problems is beyond your capability.
@@Ariyan300 yeah your toxic community proves your point
@@kryowl we don't have to prove it to you. So stop being MADxeus.
It would be really cool to get the minority opinions. Fellow catholic indonesian here...
As an Indonesian, i did not know about this.
@Crim Sin hey chill out
Oh wait you're a comedian.
Dear Asian Boss: Indonesia is the largest archipelago country in the world, extending 5,120 kilometres (3,181 mi) from east to west and 1,760 kilometres (1,094 mi) from north to south, has 17,504 islands, 34 provinces, over 700 local languages, over 300 etnics, so many religions (including local religion).......and you...only review about : ISIS, polygamy and getting canned (sharia law's) ???
She said " open your mind" while they are all brainwashed by muslim rules. LUL
Dude aceh isn't an Islam majority province
ikrrr
Hahahhhhh.. Welcome to Indonesia 😂😂
Nice one bruhh 😄
Sam47S yeah welcome to Indonesia 😂
The question is did HE get caned for premarital sex too?
yes he did, the problem is, the media only frame the news around the woman only.
@@AngryKittens well the actual law is,
for first time offender, you can choose between caning and jail time actually. this is what media didn't tell, and just focus entirely on the caning issue.
if you don't want to get canned, just choose the prison, it's quite simple.
people choose caning over jail time because it's more simple to get canned for a day and then they get free, rather than spending their time in prison. also the caning beatings have maximum amount of 50 beatings.
but for repeating offenders, the caning punishment is not applied, they will get straight to jail following the conventional law in indonesia.
Its actually beneficial for them to get canned because they dont have to spend their time in prison
@@utsmanzu0907 Yeah. So beneficial, especially when they're going to be jailed for something that normal people don't consider a crime like talking to a male non-relative, or not wearing a hijab, or being NOT Muslim in general. lulz. /sarcasm
Maulana Iskandar muslims were the original cultural colonists. Look at a map of Arabia then a map of the Arab league
@@AngryKittens there is no caning punishment for that kind of actions. Caning punishment in aceh should align with the national law, so not wearing a hijab if youre a muslim is simply you get a fine/warning, thats it. And the sharia law didnt applied to the non muslim,premarital sex(adultery included) is actually punishable by law in indonesia for a certain degree.non muslim is not mandatory to wear hijab and they only subject to national law if they commit crimes in aceh. By all means, please do educate yourself first before trying to give a sarcasm comment, thank you.
in fact, people who having sex before marriage is just same as animal. they dont have attitude.
I am confused why this channel only covers religion for this country? I mean, does this only make you curious?
Edit : many people here who avoid discussing these sensitive matters and indeed there is still much debate in them. and in this case, Aceh can do this because there is indeed an area with special autonomy, you will understand why if you first study the history of Aceh, and Islam, instead of generalizing it throughout Indonesia overall.
It doesn't matter if there discusses Indonesian Muslims, but if all the coverage about Islam only I feel this will be different for Indonesia as a whole, because Indonesia is not an Islamic country. Muslims are only a majority not absolute, and we share the balance of law and all things with other groups. Like if you go to Bali, do you all see Islamist things commonly?
Edit (lagi) : ga paham saia kayanya yg dipuji2 terus secara umum orang luar cuma Bali sama daerah2 turis doang dah disini, soal yang lain rasa2nya kaku bener
Itu karena (kayaknya) cuma Bali yang lebih heart-warming penduduk nya dan kebanyakan lebih toleransi. Cuma puji Tuhan daerah saya juga ngga ekstrim amat sih. Dari apa yang gue tau banyak daerah Indonesia yang welcome...
Well, Indonesian culture is greatly tied to Islam(with Indonesia's population being comprised of almost entirely of Muslims) so you cant really separate the two. Moreover, the caning issue is one of the hottest topics in the country and even globally so its a given a lot of people outside Indonesia would be curious about it. I agree that there should be other culturally related videos like lifestyle or dating but the hottest topics today mostly concerns Islam and the Indonesian perspective is too important with regards to those matters imo.
@@benjago17 I don't think so. As a whole country, Indonesia's culture has it own diversity, depends on each tribes and regions. Perhaps if Asian Boss (and you?) 'curious' which country that has an islamic culture that deeply rooted, try look up to the middle east countries, especially Saudi Arabia. The whole region of that country already applied the sharia law since years ago, unlike in 1/34 regions, Indonesia. I think it would be more fit your description (culture that greatly tied to Islam).
My point is, religion is a really delicate topic (e.g: syria war & Palestine & Israel war been happening years, because of religion conflict). Rather than created delicate contents without a really proper context, I think the Asian boss team need to do their research better in order to deliver a sensitive content. If they haven't able to do that, then better stay away from that particular and just focus on another ones. Just please be better next time. Don't make things worse with the framing / missed leading information.
@@morningristretto7607 I respect your opinions but I would have to disagree. Firstly, with regards to your proposal of dodging current topics just because they are sensitive(like religion) is just unfair. True journalism should not be afraid to touch on important and sensitive issues just to appease a certain audience.
Next, I get your point about Saudi Arabia practicing Sharia more but that specific "Caning" incident happened in Indonesia and it became a hot topic in the country. Also, understand the current extent of Asian Boss right now. They are currently based on Korea and is slowly working up on nearby Asian countries and with Indonesia being close geographically and at the same time, holds the largest Muslim population in Southeast Asia, it only makes sense to get their perspectives.
Lastly and most importantly, I don't understand why you are upset about the issue being brought up in the first place. Watching the interviews didn't misinform me about Indonesia but it in fact, helped me understand it more. Many of the interviewees in the later parts of the video clarified that Sharia was in fact, not practiced throughout Indonesia. I don't know if you skipped parts of the video but please watch them next time. Thank you and as Asian Boss says, Stay Curious!:)
@@benjago17 because sharia law didn't explained as a whole. People only get the idea that sharia law is only about caning and most indonesian people agree, despite it whole systems. Same as well as ISIS and Polygamy issue that was created by Asian Boss before.
The reason why indonesian people thought that way is not explored enough with a good context because it's an islamic practices / knowledges which is best delivered by islamic teachers (ustadz/imam) not by common people in the street.
I understand your point and I just hope you get mine as well. Let's just agree to disagree for now. :)
As a non-muslim Indonesian conflicts regarding majorities-minorities in the past are common at this point. I'm not saying all people, but discrimination between religion and races exists literally everywhere (forming groups in public schools, for example). It's hard to unite a whole 240 mil people when the majority only cares about their own group's interests over everyone's.
This is the PG13 version of sharia law. When I was 17 years old I saw a video called “Buried in the sand” it was about the extremes of sharia law. They wrapped a woman who committed adultery from head to toe in a white cloth, then dug her waist deep. Surrounded her with people 10 feet away. All of them threw stones at her, varied in size. Some stones were the size of fists, some were the size of human heads. As the stones hit her you could see stains of red developing. At first she was erect, shaking with fear and anxiety. Then as the stones caved her bones in, you could see her body slump over as she crossed into the afterlife. Sharia law is not pretty. Adultery is wrong but people shouldn’t be punished so savagely.
Let those who are not sinners cast the first stones.
san sheng :/ but i’m pretty sure they’ve commited some sort of sin in their lives smh
@@1_claudiohervian850 who among us doesn't sinned? Nobody's perfect so don't be hasty with ur judgement.
san sheng yeah i know😅, i was talking about the one throwing the stones... i’m sorry if you dont understand my words. I’ve commited sin too in my life you know, i wasnt talking about people who were punished.
@@1_claudiohervian850 oh, my apologies then. I thought ur trying to excuse the evil deeds of this people.
Dear AsianBoss, I always watch your video and I love the way you brings out another perspective in each videos. But, I really disappointed by your videos which talked about Indonesia. You always brought up "a really rare case" that involves Religious beliefs which should be explained by an expert. So there will be no a misleading statement. These videos made ppl Islamophobia.
Why are you asking ppl that doesn't live in Aceh instead u asked ppl who live in Jakarta?
Why are u talking about Religion things in Indonesia but you always talk about Hallyu Wave opinion in Japan, China, S. Korea?
It's really different topic and the way u brought up this topic really made Indonesia and Islam looks so bad.
Pls do more research about diversity in Indonesia, a lot of topics can be talk about, such as:
- The uniqueness of Suku Dayak
- How big kpop fans in Indonesia
- How Ramadhan atmosphere in Indonesia?
- Why ppl get shorther worktime, got a long holiday because of Ramadhan?
- How Indonesian thought about moving the Indonesia Capital City (from Jakarta to another city outside Java)? What might be affected by that decision?
- How Bali ppl feels about foreigners?
- Social Experiment: How friendly Indonesian ppl to help out lost foreigners?
It'll be a fun topic rather than a sensitive topic :)
I really wish Indonesian ppl who are part of AsianBoss will bring a fun topics rather than a sensitive topic that resulted in misleading opinions :')
I agree with you, and I like your suggestions
Oh, I wait for this comment. Actually since the polygamy, I am disappointed with the topic Asian Boss brought, like what is the correlation and there's no further information that can be processed.
@Crim Sin the call for prayer only 5 times in a day, I think it's not that annoying. But for ppl who misuses the speaker for Qur'an Recitation is in the fault because it's not right even in Islam taught. I don't acknowledged the punishment for the women who protest in the news as we know. It's very sad because I admit that a lot of Muslims who misuses the speakers. I apologize behalf of them :(
Set this as top comment, no matter what
Iya, gak kreatif ya isi nya...kayak clickbait gitu.
Sharia law only implemented in Aceh Province, one of 34 provinces in Indonesia. The punishment, for example being caned, only applied for Muslim resident. If non-muslims break the rules, they could choose either be punished with regular law or sharia law. Many of them (i heard pretty much in number) choose to be caned 5 or 10 times instead of be jailed for several months.
Since the focus is on a specific region of Indonesia (as per the video and various comments), it would have been better to show some deeply researched content and include more opinions although it is a very difficult job.
IKR
The title itself is very misleading. It should be "why are people getting caned in Aceh, Indonesia" since the Sharia Law only being implemented there in the country. Please don't create unnecessary conflict for a click!
@Devesh Gupta how many?
@Devesh Gupta there's more isis fighter from small country like sweden and Belgium compared to almost 300millions-Muslims- country called Indonesia
@Devesh Gupta Bekasi, Indonesia
@Devesh Gupta Eka means First and Putra means Son :)
I attack my country (Mexico) and I say that it is the worst country to live in, but then I remember that there are Asian and African countries (some) and I am grateful to have been born in Mexico (West), my country is not perfect and has many problems, but we try to progress and not be completely guided by religions
I don't agree.
We shouldn't make one religion to be the standart of law. What will be happen to another?
If we want a better law, why don't we just create it? Our law is an old law, created by Dutch East Indies.
So, in my humble opinion, I dont think this is a new thing
I am an Indonesian Muslim. What I think about sharia law is stupid and against humanity.
you know how we're taught not to change Pancasila because it's our foundation
Becouse sharia law isnt islam law, its arab world law. Dont confuse between culture and religion
we have different culture and background, not to mention we are not muslim nation. Our elits are just to lazy to thinks and make new law that suitable for us
Deutch law is semi indesia law becouse its been implemented here for ages but still for the good for deutch not indonesia, we should modified it into our teste
If you are Muslim and doesn't agree with sharia laws, just shut up. You against God law.
Ok im not an indonesian but im an malaysian, indonesia is our neighbouring country, and honestly I feel like yall just doing this just because it is a muslim majority country and your thinking of twisted stereotypes towards islam. Like omg please, im sure indonesia is a nice country. And all you who're watching this, please dont judge contries or religion based on what you see online. Look at an authenthic source.
You're so childish.
What do you mean twisted stereotypes? It's nothing but facts that some Indonesian Muslims are so indoctrinated that they're intolerant towards sexual and religious minorities.
Of course there are nice Muslim Indonesians and there are places within Indonesia that are nice. But there are plenty of radical Indonesians with a backwards view due to their religious beliefs and that is just a fact.
How aren't the people of Indonesia an authentic source?
Thankyou my malaysian brother/sister
@@LB-wk9er well did you meet any indonesian people, lau? Secondly, all muslims DO NOT represent Islam. By authentic i mean scholars, prophet Muhammad, people of knowledge. Not some random people you meet on the street. You gotta make sure they are people of knowledge ('alim). What i meant by twisted stereotype is islam is already so many times misrepresented in the media.
@@Random-du4et no problem. Kita saudara❤️
Indonesia will always be a secular country. Population of Aceh is only like 1.8% of the whole Indonesia, they are a special province for a historic reason and have more autonomy than most other provinces. Unity in diversity is our motto. Some people might not know that the population of Christians in Indonesia is roughly the same as population of the whole Australia lol, yet they'd be quick to share their expert opinions once something like this appear.
Ah.. this is how it feels watching Asian Boss without reading the subtitle..
Hehe...same here, Bro 😂 it's quite fun actually.
yess true af
Anything that dehumanizes a human being should never be law.
I hate anyone who says people can't have sex before marriage. Avoiding sex is a crime against nature. Purity does not mean virginity. To be pure means to love & respect. I don't see any love in Indonesia. They're worse than Russia.
Indonesia is far worse than the lowest kind of animals.
2:56 she is so pretty
Not In Indonesia, but only in a province called Aceh.
They implement Syariah law .
it's stated in the video, chill
@@yanggang7828
Yesss, love from Thai. Coz I had been in Indonesia before
Its scary that some of my Indonesian ppl wants it implemented in all of indo
Theyre gonna regret it if theyre the one who get punished 👀
what’s so wrong about punishing people who misbehave though? I feel like canning is normal for many countries in east asia. I mean, my mum cane me if I’m naughty...🤣
Indonesia will become Indonistan and Indo Arabia, RIP rich culture, when sea people forget their ancestor wisdom n knowledge and copy paste wild middle east culture
It's funny cause I have seen some Indonesians claiming that they are Arab. But it makes sense, they worship Arabs since the prophet was an Arab.
@@-SP. they forget their ancestor... sea is island culture different from desert arab culture
They are in the mind are dlaves of arab. I font see any hope of them especially after watching young people casually supporting barbaric laws.
arif mark007 goblok ngomong sok open minded😁
Right bro Islam is monster