Actually it makes sense, for me of... like, the story progress and when you do some things you just left behind that part of the story and it evolved itself
To anyone that's confused and can't find him someplace - the way this works is you automatically fail the quest if you ever beat the final boss of a chapter before speaking to Bojack Horseman. In my instance, I talked to him in chapter 1 and 2, completely forgot about him, I'm now in chapter 5 and was going to go back and talk to him in chapter 3 and 4, not happening. Just make sure you exhaust his dialogue in every chapter BEFORE beating the final boss.
This is not true at all. I was all the way to chapter 5 before I even knew he existed. I went back to chapter 1 and was able to do them all and complete the quest.
@@davidmcwhirter7960 what! That's weird. Maybe if you start the quest by talking to him in chapter 1 you'll fail like my comment describes, but if you don't talk to him at all you can go bactrack? Idk
Man I never know this horseman exit until Chapter 6 final boss. Yes I beat all secret bosses and now I cant find him anywhere. He never appear in my game progress.
Please help me, im at chapter 5, i dont know if the lava cart got something to do with horse guai from chapter 1. Then i go back again to chapter 1-4 to find the horse but I CANNOT FIND ANY HORSE GUAI from cptr 1-4. Wht the heck is happening to me 😭😭😭🙏
Right I'm like ok he's gonna help me in a fight or give me some cool items and no he fights you in a fight and you just get his transformation. Idk how good it is but I was disappointed
for those who don’t know if you only activate the first shrine of chapter 2 you can still go back to chapter 1 and find horse man he’ll still be sitting on the rock hope this helps someone
This horse man stuff is really buggy, the very first time I arrived at thunderclap temple, he wasnt even leaning on the pillar; and now he’s not in the cocoon. But if i go back to rat area, he’s still tied up. Guess bro’s stuck there forever.
Thank you for this! I accidentally got too far and went into the game files and found my archived saves and copied the old save to paste over the new one.
Looks like the quest fails if you don't find him before you leave a chapter; I'm on CH. 5, haven't done the firekeeper boss yet but can't find him in any of his previous locations.
You will have to open the village main door in map 2 for him to flee:)) he will then flee to map 3. If the door stays close he will be in map 2 forever even when you clear out the entire map 2.
So I never spoke to him in chapter 1, and I’m on chapter 5 now. I went back to chapter 1 and the subsequent areas and he’s nowhere to be found. I guess I’ll just have to do this quest line in NG+
I spoke to him on every locations already prior to knowing about this video.... Today I was wondering why I never had a follow up on him in Act 6. Now I see .... I completely missed this Damaged Cart in my Chapter 5 play through. Goes to show how you can easily overlook things in this game.
Please help me, im at chapter 5, i dont know if the lava cart got something to do with horse guai from chapter 1. Then i go back again to chapter 1-4 to find the horse but I CANNOT FIND ANY HORSE GUAI from cptr 1-4. Wht the heck is happening to me 😭😭😭🙏
Already talk to the horse in chapter 1,2,3.. currently still in chapter 4 , but it seems the horse didnot appear in the spider cocoon. I don't know where he's right now since there's no cocoon.
In chapter two he's right by the mini boss you fight by the shortcut door you open and there's a bunch of enemies and bowmen. The boss kinda looked like a big lizard from afar.
Bro…. I spoke to him in legitimately spoke with him in all chapters I found this thing and pulled it and then I went on to fight the flame keeper boss. Your telling me because I interacted with the whip before beating the boss I can’t get this form?
I seen him at all locations. Was confused when I fought him in that boss fight. Found the cart tried to pull the whip and couldn't. He said I had to find his body and destroy it or something like that so I left continued the story eventually remembered it and went back and he let me pull the whip out. Idk what activated it because i didn't find the cart till after the boss fight.
So i defeat the boss and I don’t complete the quest … i Miss it ? I already pulled the rope to the waggon and it didn't give me anything ... I miss the chapter 3 and 4 horse
I went to the bull god thing in chapter 5 or rather his location after i best the yashka king and the fox girl is standing there. I cant talk to her and can actually run through her so i think something is bugged out. The location up the hill from the giant frozen door in chapter 5.
I talked to him in all 1-4 chapters and after i beat the ying yang boss i go to the cart to pull the whip out but it didnt let me so after i finished the game i went back but the cord or whip whatever call it was dissappeared like why tho i did everything that shown in the video in correct order
I guess the quest bugged out for me.... Freaking lame.. I did every part ... Then went and fought the boss ...then when I went back the rope was gone and I can't pull on it wtf
I talked to him in all 1-4 chapters and after i beat the ying yang boss i go to the cart to pull the whip out but it didnt let me so after i finished the game i went back but the cord or whip whatever call it was dissappeared like why tho i did everything that shown in the video in correct order
@@bigsadge747 and to get to chapter 5 secret area you need to do the iron cart quiet, and you can’t finish that unless you’ve talked to horse Guai in every chapter
@@austinbearup9309exactly this is pissing me off. I’m legit missing certain boss fights because of this fucking quest and i’m not really ready to play ng+
I talked to him in all 1-4 chapters and after i beat the ying yang boss i go to the cart to pull the whip out but it didnt let me so after i finished the game i went back but the cord or whip whatever call it was dissappeared like why tho i did everything that shown in the video in correct order
I am just before the yin yang fish and i went back to chapter 4 multiple times and i was thorough through chapter 4 and 3 i went back to chapter 3 as well to see if he was still at the pillar and he was not. Iv cleared the entirety of chapter 3 and 4 and everything up to the ying yang fish boss.
Can anyone help me with my problem, when I first went to the sand villiage I didn’t kill the two headed buff rat enemy, but went into the boss first. Once I came out, he’s gone, and nowhere to be found so now I can’t complete the quest with the guy hiding in the shack at the top, and the horse is also not moving for me 😂 thanks guys
Damn I did all of those steps except breaking him out of the web cocoon thing in Chapter 4 in my first play through entirely accidentally.. time to get him in NG+ I guess. Damn.
I like the game but I really don’t understand how someone completely independent to the main story can get their quest line blocked by progress.
I really believe it’s one of their ways to strongly push players to do New Game+
Actually it makes sense, for me of... like, the story progress and when you do some things you just left behind that part of the story and it evolved itself
Guessing you don’t play souls games, pretty normal at this point. It’s shit imo, especially with a game that auto saves every 20 seconds 🙄
@@Tom-bv1scagreed but this aint a soulslike
Several other games do this. It's not new, but it is uncommon enough to be surprised.
To anyone that's confused and can't find him someplace - the way this works is you automatically fail the quest if you ever beat the final boss of a chapter before speaking to Bojack Horseman. In my instance, I talked to him in chapter 1 and 2, completely forgot about him, I'm now in chapter 5 and was going to go back and talk to him in chapter 3 and 4, not happening. Just make sure you exhaust his dialogue in every chapter BEFORE beating the final boss.
This is not true at all. I was all the way to chapter 5 before I even knew he existed. I went back to chapter 1 and was able to do them all and complete the quest.
@@davidmcwhirter7960 what! That's weird. Maybe if you start the quest by talking to him in chapter 1 you'll fail like my comment describes, but if you don't talk to him at all you can go bactrack? Idk
I went back to him from chapter 2 and i found him in his place! 👍
Man I never know this horseman exit until Chapter 6 final boss. Yes I beat all secret bosses and now I cant find him anywhere. He never appear in my game progress.
Please help me, im at chapter 5, i dont know if the lava cart got something to do with horse guai from chapter 1. Then i go back again to chapter 1-4 to find the horse but I CANNOT FIND ANY HORSE GUAI from cptr 1-4. Wht the heck is happening to me 😭😭😭🙏
I did this quest fully on accident but I was invested bc I thought it’ll end up being rly cool and was rly disappointed when It was over
Right I'm like ok he's gonna help me in a fight or give me some cool items and no he fights you in a fight and you just get his transformation. Idk how good it is but I was disappointed
@@anthony6929 I feel it, had the potential to be a goated quest, the transformation is alright
Same here 😂. All he ever did was get caught or hide. I would have like to fight alongside him like we do the weak pig.
Yeah i sold.. fully completed the game after him being tied up in Chapter 2… thought i could come back and do it .. NG+ it is
If u havent started NG+ i got news, u dont need horse guai if you're looking to get bull armor.
@@adawg7069 i havent started ng+ yet but i do got the full set apart from the head piece tbf.. i just wanted the spirit you get tho
@@adawg7069 how?
@@YxngBrilla i'm sure you're missing the bull weapon (dark iron staff) still & ofc headpiece. start NG+ and you're good
@@adawg7069 I'm in ng+ chapter 6 about to fight the last boss...how do I unlock this horse quest??
Tbh I was disappointed we didn't get to fight alongside him and all he ever did was get caught or hide….. RIP HORSE GUAI GUY.
for those who don’t know if you only activate the first shrine of chapter 2 you can still go back to chapter 1 and find horse man he’ll still be sitting on the rock hope this helps someone
This horse man stuff is really buggy, the very first time I arrived at thunderclap temple, he wasnt even leaning on the pillar; and now he’s not in the cocoon. But if i go back to rat area, he’s still tied up. Guess bro’s stuck there forever.
Ok i just went back to him and went over the same conversation again, and somehow he’s at the temple now wtf
Same I had to go and come back 3 or 4 times to get him there then still didint get the whip out in chap 5 so it's just bugged bro.
I havent done the boss fight, but hes nowhere to be found, weird
@@Bee-cd9eh check the last spot where you saw him, if he's there exhaust the conversation a few more times, that's how i solved it
@@zixiongwang9659 hes not on chapter 1-4
i found the cart and the whip was there but i couldnt fully pull it.
i killed the fish boss and come back, whip is gone.. wtf happened
Legit same thing with me. It’s so dumb
@@2MuchQuenton i read if you pull it more than 4 times before you kill the boss, it dissapears.
@@LucheteeI think it might be the opposite. I just finished this quest line. Pulled the rope like 8 times until I exhausted his dialogue.
Kill the chapters final boss and go back to pull it. You get to transform into horse yao guai as a reward.
@@VChong1991 didnt work for me
Thank you for this! I accidentally got too far and went into the game files and found my archived saves and copied the old save to paste over the new one.
He doesn’t appear for me in chapter 3
Looks like the quest fails if you don't find him before you leave a chapter; I'm on CH. 5, haven't done the firekeeper boss yet but can't find him in any of his previous locations.
me too
Nah it doesnt, just continue off without him
Same, but without it I can't start the quest with Erlang, what do I do?
@@ЛёваПевец Erlang's quest has no relation to the horse guai
@@carlg7418 I watched the tutorial how to find him and the guy said it's necessary to find him
Im sure I exhausted the dialogue in chapter 2
And he didn’t appear in chapter 3, I even came back and still not there… any tips ?
I’m not finding much answers either. I’m pissed
You will have to open the village main door in map 2 for him to flee:)) he will then flee to map 3. If the door stays close he will be in map 2 forever even when you clear out the entire map 2.
when you mentioned cart i feared the worst :( they turned my boy honse into a cart
So jarring I can’t believe I can’t come back and do this when I’ve past to the next chapter
So I never spoke to him in chapter 1, and I’m on chapter 5 now. I went back to chapter 1 and the subsequent areas and he’s nowhere to be found. I guess I’ll just have to do this quest line in NG+
Same thing happened with me ts dumb and im only doing this so i can pull the 3rd cart string smh
I spoke to him on every locations already prior to knowing about this video....
Today I was wondering why I never had a follow up on him in Act 6.
Now I see ....
I completely missed this Damaged Cart in my Chapter 5 play through. Goes to show how you can easily overlook things in this game.
the 1 with the pull cord? i found that one earlier apparently u gotta go back to it
I talked to him in every Chapter but i cant pull out the Whip .. whats wrong :(
Arbuckle, you're redefining what it means to create content
Is the horse quia the broken cart?
Please help me, im at chapter 5, i dont know if the lava cart got something to do with horse guai from chapter 1. Then i go back again to chapter 1-4 to find the horse but I CANNOT FIND ANY HORSE GUAI from cptr 1-4. Wht the heck is happening to me 😭😭😭🙏
W mans, W guide, W channel
Already talk to the horse in chapter 1,2,3.. currently still in chapter 4 , but it seems the horse didnot appear in the spider cocoon. I don't know where he's right now since there's no cocoon.
Spoke to him in chapter 3 and now he's missing in chapter 4 after iv'e defeated yin yang fish in chapter 5
Same
Yeah i dont think you can go back and talk to him if you already completed the yin yang fish@calvinbright7983
Egg
Yup, same.
@@TheJonnyrocker93jfc
Yea idk where this guy disappeared to. Oh well
Mo
Go to chapter 1 and in chapter 2 you’ll find him tied
@@aniskun2812 I already found him there
In chapter two he's right by the mini boss you fight by the shortcut door you open and there's a bunch of enemies and bowmen. The boss kinda looked like a big lizard from afar.
@@anthony6929shrine name?
APPRECIATE YOU BRO!!!!!!
Bro…. I spoke to him in legitimately spoke with him in all chapters I found this thing and pulled it and then I went on to fight the flame keeper boss.
Your telling me because I interacted with the whip before beating the boss I can’t get this form?
I seen him at all locations. Was confused when I fought him in that boss fight. Found the cart tried to pull the whip and couldn't. He said I had to find his body and destroy it or something like that so I left continued the story eventually remembered it and went back and he let me pull the whip out. Idk what activated it because i didn't find the cart till after the boss fight.
Dude did it all but missed him before the chapter 5 fight damn
I believe this one is the most missable side quest one can experience. Too many ways to miss.
So i defeat the boss and I don’t complete the quest … i Miss it ?
I already pulled the rope to the waggon and it didn't give me anything ... I miss the chapter 3 and 4 horse
I went to the bull god thing in chapter 5 or rather his location after i best the yashka king and the fox girl is standing there. I cant talk to her and can actually run through her so i think something is bugged out. The location up the hill from the giant frozen door in chapter 5.
i missed him in chapter 3 and cant seem to find him anywhere else
Cus its missable if you dont speak to him every Chapter You Cant Go Back
@@Jarikkzif i go back to chapter one and talk to him can i still do the quest?
@@thepersonyouneverseen1774 nope
@@Jarikkzstarted a ng+ to do this and forgot to talk to him in chapter 1 ngl so basically… I’m cooked again?
@@donavonhanson5949 yeah😭,i just did it on ng+2
I talked to him in all 1-4 chapters and after i beat the ying yang boss i go to the cart to pull the whip out but it didnt let me so after i finished the game i went back but the cord or whip whatever call it was dissappeared like why tho i did everything that shown in the video in correct order
I guess the quest bugged out for me.... Freaking lame.. I did every part ... Then went and fought the boss ...then when I went back the rope was gone and I can't pull on it wtf
I talked to him in all 1-4 chapters and after i beat the ying yang boss i go to the cart to pull the whip out but it didnt let me so after i finished the game i went back but the cord or whip whatever call it was dissappeared like why tho i did everything that shown in the video in correct order
i already finish boss in chapter 5 and back to chapter 4 to find him. but i didnt see him. seem like i miss the quest
i started the fight but i didnt beat it do i still need to talk to him in the hollow
5:27 bro I don’t even see the whip. I just wanna do the secret boss and get the true ending bruh
Secret ending u just needa do the secret areas i believe
@@bigsadge747 and to get to chapter 5 secret area you need to do the iron cart quiet, and you can’t finish that unless you’ve talked to horse Guai in every chapter
@@austinbearup9309exactly this is pissing me off. I’m legit missing certain boss fights because of this fucking quest and i’m not really ready to play ng+
@@HabibiC are you still stuck?
@@austinbearup9309no, you don't need to do the horse guai quest at all, I missed it and I still got the secret ending
I went to the cart first , and not on the keeper of flaming mountains.. i tried to pull the rope, and I cant, the cart told me to leave him
I talked to him in all 1-4 chapters and after i beat the ying yang boss i go to the cart to pull the whip out but it didnt let me so after i finished the game i went back but the cord or whip whatever call it was dissappeared like why tho i did everything that shown in the video in correct order
He was not at chapter 1 not at chapter 2 chapter 3 or chapter 4
I swear bro I don’t see him in no chapters
I never found him in chapter 1. On chapter 5 now 😅 went back to all these locations, he never appeared for me
I am just before the yin yang fish and i went back to chapter 4 multiple times and i was thorough through chapter 4 and 3 i went back to chapter 3 as well to see if he was still at the pillar and he was not. Iv cleared the entirety of chapter 3 and 4 and everything up to the ying yang fish boss.
Same happened to me. I went to chapter 3 and he was not there
yup same here, buggy fn quests.
I played the entire game to the end and never encountered this horse at all.
Can anyone help me with my problem, when I first went to the sand villiage I didn’t kill the two headed buff rat enemy, but went into the boss first. Once I came out, he’s gone, and nowhere to be found so now I can’t complete the quest with the guy hiding in the shack at the top, and the horse is also not moving for me 😂 thanks guys
I’m all the way in ch5 and just looked this up…. I’m cooked
I just defeated the fish in chap 5 before watching this. XD
Damn so the cart ate him?
life is tough!
I guess im screwed i must of missed him at some point
I missed this, he is nowhere now, gotta play NG+
He is not there for me in ch2. He is still at ch1 for some reason
you must complete all the dialog to him, keep talk till he repeat the same dialog, then go to next chapter
I can't find him anywhere
I don’t understand how he became a cart
This sucks if I never played the first part of my PlayStation portal I would’ve seen the cave in Ch 1.
This is how it ends? Bruhhhhh pretty Dark souls ending for an npc....
guys i can confirm you dont need horse guai to get the armor at ALL
what about the tri point double edge?
@@Zeroalwayswins u need to fight erlang for that, just look up tutorials on how to get there
It's definitely glitching because I did everything u said still want let me...
why are sum of these quests so fn buggy. thats 2 i lost out on. i love this game but goddamn it!
This game is cool but bugs like this are so annoying.
Damn I did all of those steps except breaking him out of the web cocoon thing in Chapter 4 in my first play through entirely accidentally.. time to get him in NG+ I guess. Damn.
10% gameplay
90% loading screens
@@ALIMUNTH What? You only load when traveling or when you respawn 🤣 sound like you just a broke boy
OOF, not for a PC player :)
What game are you playing this is game of the decade
Exceeded his dialogue in Chapter one and he never appeared in Chapter two.
So much for that drink he promised am i right guys🥹