In my mind this is the perfect end song for a Fall of Gondolin movie! Truly amazing! But then again I hope there never is a Fall of Gondolin movie made, that way hollywood won't butcher it
This is crazy, I'm listening to a random playlist while reading the Silmarillion and this video started exactly when I got to the sentence of the excerpt the voice was reading 😭😭
This is so good I want to play it over and over, but it would lose its specialness that way. The Silmarillion quotes, and Maeglin and Idril's singing battle, especially give me chills.
Wow this is stunning! I am definitely subscribing. You all do a fantastic job humanizing Maeglin here. I feel bad for both him and Idril, honestly. Maeglin deserved better than Eol as a dad and Idril deserved to love Tuor and raise Earendil in peace!
Also HOW DID EOL SNEAK IN A FUCKING JAVELIN WITHOUT THE GUARDS NOTICING IF AREDHEL HAD LIVED MAEGLIN MIGHT HAVE HAD A CHANCE BECAUSE SHE UNDERSTOOD WHAT HE WENT THROUGH BECAUSE SHE WAS THERE
@@NiennaFan1 I'd never thought of this before. If it was snuck in, maybe the javelin was hidden in his cloak, like in a pocket or fold. Akin to General Grievous, if you'll excuse a Star Wars reference, and where he pockets lightsabers.
ok i'm back to say I genuinely feel like I'm listening to a Silmarillion / Gondolin musical whenever I hear your songs -- they're absolutely stunning (I listen to Aredhel's lament like, daily) and this one I've been repeating over and over you're incredibly talented!! thank you for sharing your hard work with us, it's amazing
This is magnificent! I don't even have words... The part where their voices overlapped sounded like a song battle, like Finrod and Sauron. The readings from the Doom of Mandos... Gorgeous. I need to listen to the rest of your music now. It's so cool that you're making this! Silm vids are rare but I adore them.
You deserve infinitely more subscribers but never let those numbers influence your self of worth (bc i know it sometimes can, not saying that's necessarily the case), you've touched more people than you could even fathom. Thank you (:
Ai! This. Is. AMAZING! Seriously, you guys! I'll definitely be sharing, and Lyra, tell the others how much everyone loves this!! You guys have some serious talent and I hope that you continue to put it to good use!
You can fight it - you just don't know how because none of you understand the psychology of trauma the way we do in the modern age having studied stuff and you were alone and had no one wiser to call on for help! None of you understand, and I doubt any of you know how to really listen either! (That goes for the Valar doubly.) All of this was preventable! Feanor was preventable, Turin was preventable, Maeglin was preventable, all of it! But the worst part is that we're still making these same mistakes, and real world evil is preventable, too.
This comment oozes with hindsight bias. Any tragedy is preventable if you know everything about it and have read exactly how it plays out, but in the present, things don't work that way. People can only make their best judgement in the now, with what information they have, and sometimes that will not be enough. So yes, technically every bad thing is preventable, but some bad things will still happen. Such is life.
Yeah, that's what I'm saying! None of them had the right information, and none of them understood what Maeglin was really going through and there were no psychologists around! And yes, bad things happen and hindsight is 20/20, but especially in real life, we know a lot of things that will help prevent tragedy - we know that, say, having enough food to eat increases the likelihood that you will do well in school which decreases the likelihood that you will be poor as an adult, or that having strong support systems decreases the likelihood that you will hurt yourself or others due to emotional distress. Sure, individuals might fail to help themselves or other people around them, but as a society we have a lot of knowledge and we can do a hell of a lot better.@@husky0098
Our official channel: th-cam.com/channels/YQNda-j0hX1igt_OlJhxWA.html
In my mind this is the perfect end song for a Fall of Gondolin movie! Truly amazing! But then again I hope there never is a Fall of Gondolin movie made, that way hollywood won't butcher it
This is crazy, I'm listening to a random playlist while reading the Silmarillion and this video started exactly when I got to the sentence of the excerpt the voice was reading 😭😭
thats a beautiful experience, kinda jealous not gonna lie
"Oh, it's but a dream" gave me genuine chills
This is a masterpiece and absolutely beautiful, I'm in awe
This is so good I want to play it over and over, but it would lose its specialness that way. The Silmarillion quotes, and Maeglin and Idril's singing battle, especially give me chills.
Best thing I have seen in a while. I really needed this. Idril is truly one of my favorite characters from the silmarillion.
This is so amazing, that's what I always imagined elves sound like. I imagine you'd be able to do Luthien's song justice as well
Wow this is stunning! I am definitely subscribing. You all do a fantastic job humanizing Maeglin here. I feel bad for both him and Idril, honestly. Maeglin deserved better than Eol as a dad and Idril deserved to love Tuor and raise Earendil in peace!
Also HOW DID EOL SNEAK IN A FUCKING JAVELIN WITHOUT THE GUARDS NOTICING IF AREDHEL HAD LIVED MAEGLIN MIGHT HAVE HAD A CHANCE BECAUSE SHE UNDERSTOOD WHAT HE WENT THROUGH BECAUSE SHE WAS THERE
@@NiennaFan1 I'd never thought of this before. If it was snuck in, maybe the javelin was hidden in his cloak, like in a pocket or fold. Akin to General Grievous, if you'll excuse a Star Wars reference, and where he pockets lightsabers.
This is gold, mithril and silmaril
Silmaril you say.... I'd be careful throwing such words around... The sons of feanor might be around
underrated comment
@@SimplifieedgamingAre you truly Maedhros?
@@vineetamendiratta5121 yes
@@Simplifieedgaming You were released from Mandos, or is there internet there?
ok i'm back to say I genuinely feel like I'm listening to a Silmarillion / Gondolin musical whenever I hear your songs -- they're absolutely stunning (I listen to Aredhel's lament like, daily) and this one I've been repeating over and over
you're incredibly talented!! thank you for sharing your hard work with us, it's amazing
Wow! I'm at a lost of words! This is just amazing!
oh this is beautiful beyond words. I’m obsessed with Idril’s voice, so lovely ❤
Damn this gave me chills. Please put this on Spotify I love it❤
This is magnificent! I don't even have words... The part where their voices overlapped sounded like a song battle, like Finrod and Sauron. The readings from the Doom of Mandos... Gorgeous. I need to listen to the rest of your music now. It's so cool that you're making this! Silm vids are rare but I adore them.
You deserve infinitely more subscribers but never let those numbers influence your self of worth (bc i know it sometimes can, not saying that's necessarily the case), you've touched more people than you could even fathom. Thank you (:
An anime Silmarillion would be the best way to interpret it visually.
This is beautiful beyond words! I was crying to whole time and can't wait to listen to it again and again.
Wonderful!! Thank you for the music:)
I love your silm soundtrack as well😭
Beautiful work !!!! Please do more !!!😍🥰
Love this!!
I really really like it, I’m very glad that I came across this video and I listen to it almost every day. 😭❤ Can I make subtitles for your video?
Ai! This. Is. AMAZING! Seriously, you guys! I'll definitely be sharing, and Lyra, tell the others how much everyone loves this!! You guys have some serious talent and I hope that you continue to put it to good use!
Just so beautiful!
Dammit. Who's cutting onions?
For real though, this song is awesome.
Brilliant work!
Another masterpiece! Damn it gave me chills and for some reason made me think of Hellfire, Frolo's song from Notre Dame
Omg...its soo good! I just recently red the chapter of Of Maeglin. Gosh that song gives me chills...
This is so lovely
Whoever the first singer is gives me massive Mercedes Lackey vibes. Both of the singers in this video have amazing voices.
My favorite song by Misty is The Face Within
THIS IS AMAZINGGGGGGG
AMAZING
Wow!
Tuor will save her!
yeah u just miss the entire point of the song
@@lyraofbeleriandHow?
❤️
You can fight it - you just don't know how because none of you understand the psychology of trauma the way we do in the modern age having studied stuff and you were alone and had no one wiser to call on for help! None of you understand, and I doubt any of you know how to really listen either! (That goes for the Valar doubly.) All of this was preventable! Feanor was preventable, Turin was preventable, Maeglin was preventable, all of it!
But the worst part is that we're still making these same mistakes, and real world evil is preventable, too.
This comment oozes with hindsight bias. Any tragedy is preventable if you know everything about it and have read exactly how it plays out, but in the present, things don't work that way. People can only make their best judgement in the now, with what information they have, and sometimes that will not be enough. So yes, technically every bad thing is preventable, but some bad things will still happen. Such is life.
Yeah, that's what I'm saying! None of them had the right information, and none of them understood what Maeglin was really going through and there were no psychologists around! And yes, bad things happen and hindsight is 20/20, but especially in real life, we know a lot of things that will help prevent tragedy - we know that, say, having enough food to eat increases the likelihood that you will do well in school which decreases the likelihood that you will be poor as an adult, or that having strong support systems decreases the likelihood that you will hurt yourself or others due to emotional distress. Sure, individuals might fail to help themselves or other people around them, but as a society we have a lot of knowledge and we can do a hell of a lot better.@@husky0098
👍
I wish I can download this song to my list of music where can I find it
Try a TH-cam music downloader?
@@lyraofbeleriand thanks so much
Is that idril Celebrindal
Yep
this is incredible!!! would it be okay if I did an animatic of it? obviously with proper credit to you guys ^^
We'll be honored!
Just @me when u post
@@lyraofbeleriand oh absolutely!! Your work is really inspiring :D
Next up: I'm just a ma'am🎶
This is truly incredible!!!! 🩵🩵🩵🩵🩵🩵
I have an retired crew who is in danger after their lives were taken in their time
0:33
I just thought this a galadriel and i read about idril and maeglin 😮😢
she is 😟😢 Galadriel
That's not galadriel
@@lyraofbeleriand oooh who is this do you know 🤔
@@AnastasiaBlack-999 it's literally in the description
@@AnastasiaBlack-999 and in the lyrics